I really respect the effort Nana has put into improving her vocals. She was a model/dancer and with that face she don't really need good singing skills to be famous and earn quite alot. She went from no lines, to a few low pitch lines, then mediocre singing to getting a song of her own, and started to singing higher tones, and now she just a goddess.
she's not rich and only hold a small fandom in korea. Before they debut as OC, she's not even among the top 3 members of AS. People in korea don't quite value appearance. Only those idols who can act well in drama and movies are popular and rich. NANA is filming in 'roommates'. Since she's a rookie actress, they only gave her a discount of the rental as the payment for her acting in their show. People outside korea may hard to believe five members of AS are still have no money to rent an apartment and have to live together. This rental discount makes NANA willing to film the second season... I think this is why korean groups willing to accept any offer in japan and china. It's hard to make a life in korea as idol....
Orange Caramel was such a rare beautiful thing. Orange Caramel was a beautiful flower that bloomed one day and was gone the next. I am grateful that they took pictures so I can see it bloom whenever I want. Orange Caramel still as captivating. You were perfection.
This is epic of Orange Caramel's Singing Chrnology. because Many people know that they has visual, concept and ablity of Good singer. I trust they soon will be 1st grade in K-pop Chart. Thank you O.C
La musica "indi" o concepto "indi" tiene un matiz diferente y unico que le dan sus artistas y puede transformar una cancion comica o divertida como lo hizo esta chica que canto LS !!! Wow!!! me encanto!!!!
Nana can sing since the beginning, of course there are improvements.. Pledis just wasn't giving her many chances/lines when she first debuted in Afterschool, but then you still can hear her sung live in earlier OC songs. Raina & Lizzy are good singer & performer too (of course)
![[ETC] Lizzy Ice bucket challenge (리지-얼음물 샤워)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Cl9xe_2CQcU/mqdefault.jpg)
와 다들 라이브 미쳤다 특히 나나 왜이렇게 쫀득하게 잘부르지
음색이 독특해서 더 귀에 잘박히는듯요 ㅎㅎ
I really respect the effort Nana has put into improving her vocals. She was a model/dancer and with that face she don't really need good singing skills to be famous and earn quite alot. She went from no lines, to a few low pitch lines, then mediocre singing to getting a song of her own, and started to singing higher tones, and now she just a goddess.
i agree 10000% she is a pure talent
she's not rich and only hold a small fandom in korea. Before they debut as OC, she's not even among the top 3 members of AS. People in korea don't quite value appearance. Only those idols who can act well in drama and movies are popular and rich. NANA is filming in 'roommates'. Since she's a rookie actress, they only gave her a discount of the rental as the payment for her acting in their show. People outside korea may hard to believe five members of AS are still have no money to rent an apartment and have to live together. This rental discount makes NANA willing to film the second season... I think this is why korean groups willing to accept any offer in japan and china. It's hard to make a life in korea as idol....
김다예 Yeah, Korea doesn't value appearance at all, that's why so many get plastic surgery.
***** Well, it's because so many get PS, ppl don't care about their appearance anymore.
김다예 Makes sense, I'm sure they're just getting plastic surgery to change their personality. Or for shits 'n' giggles; whichever.
다른 두분은 잘하는거 알았는데 나나씨도 장난 없네 ㅡ..ㅡ 나나씨 목소리 애간장 녹이네....
Orange Caramel was such a rare beautiful thing. Orange Caramel was a beautiful flower that bloomed one day and was gone the next. I am grateful that they took pictures so I can see it bloom whenever I want. Orange Caramel still as captivating. You were perfection.
리지, 레이나, 나나~~
세 명 다 예쁘고, 날씬하고, 귀엽고~~💕💕💕
게다가 노래까지 잘 불러~~🖒🖒🖒
아직도 오캬의 재결합을
격하게 바라는 팬~~🤗
Nana sings so much better now
저 당시에 나나는 의외로 노래를 잘 한다고 생각했었는데..
지금 다시 보니 너무 대놓고 잘하는거 같다
오토튠 살짝 들어가긴 한듯
셋 다 너무잘부른다 ㄷㄷㄷ 특히 나나목소리 너무좋아
Well nana just gave me an eargasm! Shes a goddess
최고의 조합이다 레이나가 저음이랑 안정적으로 중심잡아주고 톡톡튀는 하이톤 나나음색 쫀득한 리지음색이 조화롭다ㅜㅜ
They sing so much better now so proud
Raina already did picninc live together with Yoo Ara (Hellovenus) and some other band which was truly terrific. gonna enjoy watching this too.
Nana's voice is so sweet and i love her
고3때보고 대학교4학년되서 오렌지카라멜 라이브 보고싶어서 다시 왔습니다
취업 잘되게 해주세요~
셋다 존예면서 노래까지 맛깔나게 잘 부름
i love how raina always looks both side hyping her members, that's really sweet
와 진짜 나나 콧소리 쩐다....홀려들어간다 구미호같은 느낌,,, 짱
nana's voice is so clean... orange caramel fighting!!!
jesus i wanna a buy an acoustic orange caramel record
This is epic of Orange Caramel's Singing Chrnology. because Many people know
that they has visual, concept and ablity of Good singer. I trust they soon will be 1st grade in K-pop Chart. Thank you O.C
2/7/2018 I'm here. I love Orange Caramel and I Love NaNa
와 노래진짜 잘부른다 ㄷㄷ
How I wish I could get this versions somewhere... I think they're awesome, vocally and musically.
나나 음색 너무 좋은데🥰
La musica "indi" o concepto "indi" tiene un matiz diferente y unico que le dan sus artistas y puede transformar una cancion comica o divertida como lo hizo esta chica que canto LS !!! Wow!!! me encanto!!!!
나나 진짜 얼굴에 노래라고는 없을 것 같이 생겨서는 잘 부르네ㅋㅋㅋ
아니 오캬 원래 찐 라이브 그룹이었네.. 그냥 뭐.. AR수준인데??.. 상당히 깔끔하게 부른다 셋다
wow they really should release an album in this jazzy lounge-style sound! thats awesome!
Oh man, here i am again! Orange Caramel Forever!
they sing beautifully. damn. i love their voices & surprisingly i actually love nana's voice the most! they are really good :)
So underrated ! They need more fans :D
Nana's voice
nana eonni's voice improved~ who said she cant sing? just shut up your mouth! she can sing!
I don't understand but I like this song! Raina is so cute and a good singer.
Orange Caramel miss you😭😭❤
Their voices are amazing!!! so good
nana has the sweetest voice, but Raina is soooooo cute!!!
I miss Orange Caramel🥺🥺🥺🥺💓
Increíble el nivel de los idols de hace 10-15 años atras. Hoy en día ningun grupo debutado podria hacer un acústico como éste
who was that girl singing at 9:40 ? she's really good, i know she's a fan and she sang in one of the videos.
wow!! they really have such a beautiful voice. ♥♥
Nana can sing since the beginning, of course there are improvements.. Pledis just wasn't giving her many chances/lines when she first debuted in Afterschool, but then you still can hear her sung live in earlier OC songs. Raina & Lizzy are good singer & performer too (of course)
리지 무대서 빵긋빵긋 하는거 넘 이쁨 최고~
나나 콧소리가 아니라 진짜 진성 같에 목소리 이쁘다 ㅎㅎㅎ
oooowww simplemente Lizzy es taaan linda me encanta cuando hace su acentooo :D
Raina is my favourite but Lizzy looks beautiful
honiton41967 Raina is my favorite too! She is also the best singer in OC and After School.
Awesome !
나나 계속 가수하지 가창력 너무 좋다
How Beautiful!
Raina's beautiful hair.
재결합하자 세계적 그룹으로 도약할 기회다
와 나나 노래 잘하는건 진짜 처음 알았네 ㄷㄷ
근데 왜 소속사는 저 원석을 썩혀둔거지? 이해가 안가네 ㄷㄷ
나나 복면가왕 나오면 진짜 확 뜨겠다
지금 셋중에 젤잘나가는데요... 배우하고있어요.
Who is the woman that starts singing at 9:20? She sounds amazing. Also, Orange Caramel sounds so good acoustic omg..
나나 목소리 쩐다... 녹네녹아... nana holic
Orange caramel
Junto con
Crayón pop
Lo mejor del k pop
나나 라이브 최고다
Why are their voices auto tuned argh
Nana's voice is cute
Acaso no son las mas hermosas, son las rolling stones de corea además hicieron su propio unplug
nana slayss fudge so love her
Cantan genial en vivo :O
Рейна - самая сладкая карамелька в этой пачке.
Raina - it is most sweet caramel.
Love Nana more and more after watching this!!!!
I like this version of Magic Girl.. +pledisartist studio version of this perf please
OMG! I love this version of Lipstick!
I really miss them. 😭
I CANT BELIEVE AT 2:58 THE GUY SCREAMED MULA WITH RAINA IM CHOKING IT WAS SO FUCKING LOUD
Still watching in January 2019
I didn't know they are so good at singing
did somebody upload this with eng subtitles?
yes its subtitled on Dailymotion.
www.dailymotion.com/video/x1oiab6_orange-caramel-picnic-live-part-1-engsubs-140410_shortfilms
Orange Caramel
Loving this girls so much
뭐지?? 리지 나나가 노래를 저 정도로 잘했었던거?? 왜 활동할때는 몰랐던건지;;
음원이랑 라이브가 똑같아서 티가 잘 안 났던 거 같아요...
모밋쒸.....아이시떼루우~~~~~~
나나 콧소리섞인 목소리 매력적이야
love Raina
Волшебные девушки - навсегда!
lizzy is great
what did they get that cake for? 4 years of what? since orange caramel was made maybe
+Tayshwn Jackson yep i believe they debuted in 2010 during bang
라이브 찰진거 보소 ㅋㅋ
오캬 노래 너무 잘 들었어용
레전드 오렌지캬라멜
다 왜래 잘해...아깝다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
i love that so much ;D
I wanted someone to make Lizzy laugh.
Catallena pls.
0:23 what's name of song? i really really love it
Bangkok city orange caramel
Thanks
What is the name of the song in 10:00? Please
Jaxmany lipstick !
Great! : )
u guys are talented as hell.
lizzy is the best
the girl cover at 9:26 sounds better than orange caramel tbh
raina
Orange Caramel for ever!
0:46 Omg Orange Caramel version Joan of Arc ???? I'm laughing so hard lmao
me tooo HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA!!! XD
Worldclass!!! 재결성하고 컴백하여 세계평정하러가자!
라이브
0:58 마법소녀
11:03 립스틱
THIS IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!
0:45 Orange Caramel of Arc?
노래는 레이나지..
What's the name of the song they're singing at 1:11?
Magic Girl, their first promoted song.