SPECIAL EDITION: Macron vs Le Pen: follow the Debate LIVE - French presidential election 🇫🇷
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- The 2nd round of the french presidential election will take place on April 24, 2022. President Emmanuel Macron and far-right challenger Marine Le Pen pacing themselves until Wednesday's face-off, which could turn out to be the key to the campaign. Follow LIVE the Debate on FRANCE 24
#Macron #LePen #2022FrenchElection
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.c...
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on Twitter: f24.my/TWen
Discover the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
(off-topic) Just to mention that the translators put so much passion! They did a good job!
Sarcasm?
@@Qatari2007 Absolutely not. To me, they did a great job. At 56:28 for example, I find the fact that they put so much efforts and passion into it, it's really good.
@@NetTubeUser ohh, I see now. I only had a chance to watch the first 15 or so minutes, and that was really monotone
I was wondering, as a non-French speaking person
The guy said uhm about 3 times every sentence. It was very jarring.
How on earth can these Interpreters listen, translate and speak at the same time? I hope they are paid well
Being a simultaneous translator is not an easy job.
it happens all the time mainly in countries where English isn't first language..
There’s usually a built in delay in the broadcast. Usually it’s about 7 seconds. Not a ton of time, but probably enough for skilled translators to do their job.
it makes you appreciate how incredible the translators are, doesn't it
Yes, definitely!
interpreters*
Joi😅ij😅opjojojjojojoojojoojoojojojjojojjojojojojjoi😅ojoi😅ojoik
Tst
True . 😜
Debate starts at 14:52
Thanks!
Real hero
Thanks bro!
Thanks 🥰🥰
Thanks
French candidates should only talk about one issue: what are they going to do to get Daft Punk back together.
Finally addressing the real issues
YES
The crisis of their generation is being IGNORED. Smh…
LOL exactly t
Around the world around the world….
the guy dubbing for Macron is brilliant, this wouldn't be half as entertaining if not for the attitude he injects 🤣
Yes and Macron is unfortunately a man without balls....
Yes, but I thought he made Macron sound like a whingeing moaner.
@@garystevens4303 that’s what he is
I’m very embarrassed that we in Australia don’t have televised “debates” like this, vive la France, I really appreciate this discourse.
Is that true? I didn't know you were so backward over there!
@@garystevens4303 very backward ! Over sensitive left wing dumb dumbs as well 🤮
Wow really? It's a pretty big part of European politics at least the countries I know of, UK, France, Germany, and the US of course too. I'm surprised it isn't there in Australia. Scomo would get battered in a debate
@@chilldude30 Australians overall are hopeless at debates .scared they might say something the left wings will cry over and get "cancelled "
You have parliamentary system in Australia. It doesn't make sense to have debates when it's the elected members choosing a prime minister, i have to say American system is actually incredibly better
Watching this from the US and ashamed and frustrated we don't have a single politician who could sit and debate in this manner.
You get what the public wants in the US unfortunately
Oh yes, Bernie Sanders had hour-long debates and he was excellent in them!
Obama could
Ron DeSantis
@@privateyoutuber3640 he'd call you a commie and put his hands on his ears
thanks for putting this up in english
Yes im interested as a german to See the outcome of this election
Man, you guys are lucky your debates are like this. In the US, it's just two people personally attacking each other and literally yelling over both each other and the moderators. The moderators have no power. They also only give candidates 90 seconds to answer, bc they're just trying to get a sound bite. Both candidates were allowed to talk back and forth without moderation, and each candidate had a few minutes per topic uninterrupted to lay out a platform. A million times better than our system in the US
The trick is in the chairs.
They both still said nothing and the French will be left hanging.
I agree. It was a discussion about the issues without personal attacks. It reminded me of the civility in public discourse we used to enjoy here in the U.S. -
Because there is still some level of civility in French society
No, you are just unlucky
Thank You FRANCE 24 !!!
Surprised to find she is only 53. She looks mid 60's.
Smoking
Why is Marine translator so slow and monotone with such a depressing tone when Le Pen’s tone is alive. Is like it doesn’t want to do its job
Interpreters are supposed to translate in a neutral tone, not to match their attitude, behaviour, or body movements (eg slamming fists).
Just further bias against Le Pen
In my opinion the translator was absolutely brilliant and di her job very well.
He's actually more expressive than Macron himself, Macron isn't exactly some bright happy man
3:29:20 Send Former French President Sarkozy to the tribunal as well for spearheading the destruction of Libya.
Sarkosleazy
Quadafi bombed Pan Am 103 , Lockerbie. Killing 270. Funder of terorisim in the 1970,s. Finally paid with a hole in his head. 23 yrs late.
Can we get this debate with subtitles, not with dubbing?
Of course, there is no difference between the two of them, and one and the other are poodles, one was the other stayed. There is nothing more difficult for a mother than for her male child to be a nod !
No
So fascinating watching two French people talk in deep discussion. It's amazing how similar it feels to watching two Africans debate, especially the African phrases that come up or they use, like 'I'm not like you.' I never knew this about France :)))
I don’t care who wins, it’s up to French people(love you guys) . I really love this type of debate and I hope in every country will be the same … for more details about the candidates!
Amen to that
The translators are so much better than politicians (especially the Macron translator around the 1:00:00 mark) that it feels like it's better to watch the debate in english than in french.
I cannot compare since I can't speak French, but the translators did great job indeed! It was like candidates are actually debating using English.
The debate is far more interresting in the native language, because 1) french is a beautiful language more beautiful than English 2) with the native language you have the exact tone, the exact way of speaking of both.
Is there a version with English subtitles instead of dubbing?
Sadly no
the problem is that you cannot dub in writing something that goes live, maybe after the fact, but yes, would be much nicer in subs.
Don't worry. RUclips always translates and adds subtitles with their new AI and algorythm. They will be available in a few hours.
@@NetTubeUser not sure
looking for this comment
as a german i was geniunly interested in the debate of our friends in the west.
Why you don’t have presidential system in germany ?
@Paul Bilange Germany does have a President. The position is mostly ceremonial, however, possessing little power.
Liberté. Égalité. Fraternité.
Amitié. Solidarité. Laïcité.
Dans toutes les Démocraties et Républiques.
…
Je suis d'accord
@@henrykjohn78 Merci 🙏 😉😎
Blood. Soil. Nationalism.
@@yakovendelman7659 Free Trade, Open Borders, Taco Trucks on Every corner!
@@jamiearan Oy vey you read my mind
You have to give Madame Le Penn credit, she keeps on fighting, the media are against her the banks and governments.
Viva la France
Rightfully so
Omg, I am utterly disappointed in people who support Le Len. I grew up and lived in Moldova until 18 years old. A country led by Putin’s loonies which also were financed by him. Divided our country, gave birth to hatred and aggression in our society, tolerated that part of our country is occupied by Russian army for 30 years, disrespected our culture and native language. And you guys support another Putin’s lover? Putin is about totalitarianism and aggressive nationalism. If the free France chooses it, you are no longer supporting your democratic values. Good luck. Don’t be fooled, they promised us low prices and high wages as well, but never kept their promises.
Le Pen is supported because she neglects globalization of France and the EU.
Ты болен, причём серьёзно. Когда молдоване напали на Приднестровье то Россией руководил друг Запада Ельцин, он остановил гражданскую войну и там прекратились смерти и их нет и по сей день. Вы националисты, поэтому убивать для вас норма.
So a gay loving corporations and lobby controlled and warmongering liberal democracy is a better choice?
well said!
@@Станислав-о7ь убивать норма только для русских, и этот ваш имперских угар ставит весь мир под угрозу ядерной войны. Тебе вспомнить Чечню и Грузию?
I don’t think le pen is far right, people say that because of her father and her party‘a past. She is ok with abortion, gays, lowering the retirement age, higher wages. Doesn’t sound far right to me
That’s not her only positions.
@@AtlasKebabfile please elaborate then no slogans or overheard chants. Want evidence
Wanting to kick out non citizens from public housing and firing them from their jobs doesn't sound far right to you ?
The two issues of abortion and homosexuality are related to religion, and religion in France isn’t really their thing from left to right , so she can’t be “anti” any of the two.
The far right never does until they get in
Why is there always a “far Right” but never a “ far Left? “ …And what does that tell us about “moderators” and “journalists?”
@Russophobia Ironic. And who informs you? CNN? MSNBC? CBS? Not a surprise.
@Russophobia Your channel name tells people everything they need to know about your pathetic comment.
There is a far left, but their ideas are much less prevalent in modern society. The far right ideas of xenophobia, isolationism, and authoritarianism are more popular with the masses and have a larger footprint in our society. When a far left person says we must not eat meat because of the animals, everyone else says "that guy is crazy". When a far right person says, "we have problems in this country and it's because of [insert other race/religion/ideology here]" a decent percentage of any population agrees. Far right ideas are much more acceptable to the masses. Far left ideas are often laughed off as impractical and unable to succeed.
Melenchon (finished third in first round) is usually labelled as far left. The only reason you did not see a far left label in this paticular debate is because he lost the first round.
far left exist they just are less in the spotlight because they are less dangerous and therefore less popular duh 🧠
The French version is so interesting 😊
globalisation is brutal , very true, but the world is highly interwoven.
Globalism will destroy our identities and our way of lives. Realise that ! We, as Europeans, NOT EU, will be signing our own demise if these people continue to rule us.
I am watching from Mexiko, as a German. I hope Le Pen will win and reform the EU and stop the EUs undemocratic actions.
I support Le Pen because she priorities the French people and their culture. Macron is for the rich and is a globalist
She thinks Putler and Trumpachenko are great leaders.
@@worldtopgun-3525 and they are . They defending their country against USA that wants to control everyone
U are big fool
Moin
You wouldn't think these two needed to take loans. Surely they earn enough?
I had no idea you could get loans outside your own country on the continent. We in the UK are bound by the UK banking system for loans/mortgages.
We support Le Pen against the globalists Vive Le France!!
DA da towarish.
@Russophobia L
@Russophobia as usual 😂😂😂 ww1 and ww2 we was be on right side and we are on right side today
@Russophobia Serbia is Russia's doggy
LMFAO, DEFEATED AGAIN!
thank you to the translator's. excellent work!!
I thought it was very good. Macron's body language does not help him.
Why didn't Macron implement all the goals he refers to and talks about in his first presidency, he is full of words but didn't do much. For me: Marine Le Pen.
I think Le Pen won this debate. She looked calm compared to Macron pointing his fingers constantly and looking angry though the debate.
Do you think she will get elected?
@@gw1265 I think she will have more support than she did in 2017. Rather it will be enough to win, remains to be seen. I hope so.
Le Pen looked like an incompetent fool who didnt know what she was talking about.
@@aaronmurphy6554 i hate Macron but i think Macron win
You didn't watched it in french. Macron had the voice, while she was stuttering 50% of the time.
I'm no pro Macron nor pro Lepen, just telling you that the french version (if you understand it) gives a way different view of this debate.
Marine isn’t far right, just a common senser
This is exactly how American debate's should be done.
would be nice to only have a version with english subtitles and original audio
BS. France24 too often is too lazy to use a translator, so I thumbs down those videos when subtitles appear instead.
How can one value truth when you support people who doesn't allow people to speak it?
Omg just use subtitles, I want to hear their voice. I can read....
As an independent observer from Croatia, I can say that Le Pen was better, more convincing, and it seems that Macron is playing a bit insolently on the card of electorate's oblivion, and that could easily get in his head like a boomerang.
“indipendent” suuuuure buddy 😂😂
Independent, my foot!
@@templecreations2351 macron is neolib-fash
That’s hijab law alone will make her lose that alone will make her lose 5 million voters
@@max_skim-pontoon-cough you clearly have no clue what fash is if you say that 😂
Can anyone show me where I can watch this with French subtitles and normal voice? My French is good enough to understand with subtitles
I am also trying to find the subtitled version, did you find it anywhere?
I like seeing a strong woman in this world. But I don't understand for the love of god, How can Le Pen find Mr. Putin, a friend and inspirational?
She's evil
From the US with love. It seems your circumstances relate to ours, however i commend your candidate's fpr conducting themselves professionally. Truly setting an example, specifically for us as our embarrassment of a governmental institution churns ludicrously into oblivion. Keep your chins up.
Le Pen!
🤮
DEFEATED AGAIN!
In France there are so many foreigners and Arabs, Africaines, so it is not easy to win as to French opinions.
Even it get to the election of Algeria national president in Paris because they are some million peoples from there!
Also they have babies a lot than French ! They are more than 15millions foreigner in France !
Frankly that is pity things!
.
I believe mr Macron has learned something from this smart and frank women
LE PEN !!!
Obviously, the history of WWII escapes the younger generation in France. Quelle tristesse
@@joannetomarchio4568 🤣🤣🤣
@@joannetomarchio4568 Don’t worry they will remember soon. She’ll spice up the next WW3
debate starts 0:15:01
thanks
Oh people... Just admit you are for Macron instead of pretending to be impartial and objective! It would be easier to take you seriously.
How's your Russian loan LePen😂
Why is the statement on purchasing power by Marie Le Pen edited out? Why are you censoring this. Please restore it. thank you
This panel is a joke. From the outset the bias was clear. Good debate between the two sides but the panel analysis was a bit of a let down.
France24 are racists. They hate Muslims just like Emmanuel Macaroni and cheese does.
at least you get debates lol.
Le Pen for President! God save France!
If you want covid agenda and digital passport sanitare for travelling and again for using public places in next winter then vote for Macron..
If you want covid vaccines blackmailing and PCR tests for life , then vote for Macron.
If you no jobs and more poverty more high cost of living.,then vote for Macron.
Be brave France. Vote for change.
so that's what a debate with two living contestants looks like
They switched the translators because the first translator for Macron was so slow hahaha
He can voice act do.
thanks for translation 🖤
Le Pen isn't far right, she's not far wrong though.
She supports banning Muslims from wearing head scarves, that’s totally far right
Every country has racked up debt , systems cannot sustain them selves anymore , financially what worked before , years ago , will no longer work
Why can't US candidates have debates like this? Insteed of those game show type debates.
This is boring, the 2020 debate was a comedy show that had me laughing. It was entertaining.
@@ghostofantarctica8216 the Alzheimer's patient is definitely laughable, continues to melt more each day
+@@stopdeforestation Whose that?
@@worldtopgun-3525 exactly. both 2020 candidates were laughable. usa has talented, non-despotic leaders but does a poor job of funneling them into political leadership positions
+@@stopdeforestation Oh! You mean the Ruskin Pickle sucker.
Le Pen
What's wrong with you guys. Here in Germany the retirement age is 67.
What's wrong with YOU? By 65 years old, 25% of the poorest workers are already dead and we do not live to work anyway and never will.
66.5 in Australia.
@@Kris-fd4vz not so far away. I'll take it with a bit of black Humor. You can say, if you work longer you are not staying long in an elderly care center. 😁
@@AuxaneST secondly only 2% of the German population have no training.
As a Frenchman i would like to ask you the same thing
Le Pen👍
Le pen has no logic and she is also anti nato and European union this would not age well tbh
@@randommobilegames9538 If that was true, there would have been no run off election. Right?😁
LOST!
President Macron seems to care about his country . He really tries hard to be a good President. Im not French but I like this man and I hope he wins.
He hates his people. He doesn't even respect them. Macron is the end of France.
That tweet from LePen is such a joke tell me you are desperate without telling me you are desperate.
it's actually real. she is an authentic souverainist
@The Stormblooper a racist
@The Stormblooper 9? Surely not
Obviously and definitely Marie Le Pen has won this Frank debate outright. Time for THE FIRST WOMAN PRESIDENT OF FRANCE 🇫🇷. MARIE LE PEN.
800 comments on this channel alone, damn
@@Marco-es5wz either a bot or copium
Glory to Marie, I hope she wins and stands for the People of France, just Orban of Hungry, and not in the pockets of the un elected dictators in Brussels .I hope she sticks it to Europe, and make France a great country again with its own Independent policies.
what is funny is that her name is not even Marie. 😂😂😂
Dream on and on and on.....LOL
A smiling happy demeanor does not equate to having a sensible immigration policy stance... the French have LOST it
As an outsider from 🇬🇧
I would say Le Pen won this quite solidly
Macron seemed quite snobbish, and almost passive aggressive. Le pen made some great points and Macron was blaming all his issues on other and events.
This panel was obviously biased by the way
Not a chance her facts were terrible
Precisely why Macron will win
For any even slightly patriotic Frenchman and Frenchwoman Le Pen is the ONLY choice.
And if you're just a little over slightly patriotic you know there is no political solution. Le Pen is controlled opposition who won't change much, only delay the inevitable.
There’s no French empire coming back I’m afraid, we’re well past those times 😂😂
@@bornealucian4717 has nothing to do with it
You can be patriotic and still dont want an „empire“
Patriotic means you love your country and your proud of it and its culture
How so ?
She is a racist.
No subtitles?
This woman had no clue how to deal with problems of France, total non sense & contradicting herself!
Your hate for her is showing. Nothing she says will make sense to you. She may not have the proper grab over a lot of issues but from what I heard from both candidates she is way better than Macron
@@moforndong3629 no she's not
@@moforndong3629 understanding the issues is literally what politics is …. She doesn’t know what shes doing , just trying to get elected . You won’t have a country if you elect her , watch
She "supports" everything she voted against, what an insincere clown
@@moforndong3629 well done! The racist National Front have 8 attempts from the Pirate-wannabe Father to the old women daughter. It’s about time to look for a proper job! The decent society have no room and no time for extremist!
France get out of the EU before it is too late.
Le Pen is not far-right, but Macron is far left. Understand?
Le Pen is not far right just right. Simple as that.
Macron is a centrist at best . He leans right sarkozy was a leftist
@@JohnJohnson-oe3ot Nah, Macron promotes refugee immigration for more votes, which indicates not only left, but far left.
Macron have lots of meme moment
in the french twitter lots of his arrogants poses and smiles have been turned into memes actually
So does Le Pen 😂
His body language is condescending and awesome 😅😅
The debt is 113% of GDP; compare that to less than 15% of GDP sovereign debt of Russia. Frexit is urgently needed and boosting the trade turnover with Russia which is a huge market for French goods. Surely Franc should return to replace EURO.
My eyes don't do the knees
Le pen all the way. Power back to the people of france.
She’s clearly unprepared. And this debate proved it. She’ll lose.
I am with the people who are prepared with actions not with words.She deserves a chance.
@@dragon1976pz most idiotic comment I’ve ever seen, how do you expect someone like that to run the government.
@@dragon1976pz A chance? She’ll make another autocracy. You want France to become the 2nd Belarus?
@@dragon1976pz hell yea autocracy!!
2:00: When the only opposition is Le Pen, an empty toolbox could win without campaigning.
That's what the U.S. said about Trump, now he's taken over one of two parties. Does make voting easier, agreed.
So why is the poll only 56-44%? Le Pen is only 6 points away from a tie!
@@josephshields2922 That's the poll for Macron vs Le Pen. The gap would be bigger for empty tool box vs Le Pen.
85% of french people are represented as lon g as their reach ( their party reach ) 5% they are represented in the French parliament ...remind me of how many people are represented in the congress 54% ( sum up of the voters in usa)
Minority Rule is Electoral college for Senate, about 40%🔻
it seems fiercely verbal battle arena~` yes, I like it. Even mediators are not able to timely handle, Good! Two speakers are so much concentrate with on each to promote! So much professionalism elate with every last bottom of each speaker! winning spirit relentlessly showing to the world, I like it! debate should be ~ like this~
And I am sorry not saying about which candidate is better or in favor of French people, honestly I do not know about that.
thumbs up~
Le pen is a brave lady.
The reason the uk left was through the eu unfortunately it got ridiculous when you’re country are not allowed their own laws and have to follow everything the eu does and now we are being moaned about over migrants but when is enough? How long do you keep allowing people in and yet you’re own country has its own problems to deal with every country has its own problems but the eu don’t respect this they made it difficult for us but it wasn’t difficult when they were taking our money each week
I hope we french will follow your example. Unfortunately, i don't see how it could happen in the next 20 years.
No to far right governments.
She is patriotic centre left and her socialist policies should appeal to the far left candidate's voters more than the globalist's.
No to elites that hate us.
No to Macron's neoliberal dictatorship...
Come on Le pen
Wow, the panel aren't very neutral!
She went on and on about the loan ... they should focus on the people of France and EU ... the question was about international relations.
Thought he kept bringing up the loan.
@@shelob12347 she shouldn’t have taken it out then
God, there must be something wrong with her
I really very happy that le pen did not win the french presidential election in 2022 , congratulation Mr macron, you are really welcome french president, may hod bless you,
Where can I find real-time current stats?!
Marine Le Pen just faced down the most narcissistic mysogisnist who let's face it: has always just lived with a mother figure... in one way shape or form that have led him to believe he will always be the best in fayre!..and might have met the first woman who is telling him starkly "you ain't all that Monsieur!"
That’s why we love him 🥰 WHAT A KING 👑
She is a far left lunatic and a far right lunatic at the same time. Amazing to be wrong about 100% of issues...
@@dabi2k I think it's Vive La République...not Vive le Roi
please make a subbed version with original voices :(
I don't think the polls are close as the media puts it. I think Macron will win reelection with 62% to Le Pen's 38%.
You're not even close
@@marasovac you think the gap is even wider?
The fact that the media is claim8ng it’s close could possibly mean it’s tied or Le pen is possibly above macron
@@Marco-es5wz the polls underestimated Macron in the first round. It's possible that's happening again.
Yea, Macron already won this, it is impossible for Le Pen to win, you can check that by analyzing the first round, Macron didn't put too much effort going to debates and got much more voters than Le Pen and the other, so it's easy to predict the result, sadly Le Pen will lose again :'c
Le Pen won this debate
Amazing translators
As an English person I'd always thought of Macron as similar to Blair, but his manner is much smarmier and more patronising than Blair with a dyed bouffant hairdo. I didn't understand the French hatred for him before, but now I understand why he could get quite annoying. Having said that, in elections it's usually the lesser of two evils, and clearly that's him unless you're a fascist.
Fascism is: lowering the age of old age pensions to 62. Big money is happy with a vote for Macron. Fight fascism, expand capitalism!
Le pen isn’t a fascist
Absolutely ridiculous you're just a woman hater evidently.
buzzword on buzzwords
@@zowaeh1829 most people don’t, sadly
8:33 Wish the UK would take a page out of that book on policies.
LE PEN FOR THE WIN!!!!
Not a chance!!!
Macron all the way
@@JamesBond-dq2dz Rothschild time is up🇷🇺
MACRON FOR THE WIN!
DEFEATED AGAIN!
Governments should not be deciding minimum wages or bonuses for employees. Governments should not be paying people for not working.
Definitely. Companies should be able to pay wages far below a living wage, should be able to pay almost zero. Unemployment is also terrible, no one should receive help at the most difficult time of their lives.
🇫🇷🇩🇪💪
🇷🇺🇨🇵🇩🇪
Hahaha
poderiam colocar uma tradução para nós acompanhar aqui também do Brasil
No lmao