Rameau - Suite A-minor 1728

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 июл 2024
  • 1:Allemande 0:00~
    2:Courante 7:51~
    3:Sarabande 12:05~
    4:Les trois Mains 15:36~
    5:Fanfarinette 20:15~
    6:La Triomphante 23:02~
    7:Gavotte et Doubles 24:40~
    Frederick Hass ( cem )
    clavecin is Henri Hemsh 1751
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 159

  • @livliv2958
    @livliv2958 2 года назад +28

    Rameau's music is beautiful beyond any human words...

  • @lehrmandavid10
    @lehrmandavid10 9 месяцев назад +11

    What magnificent playing. I particularly admired the majesty and surprising tempo at the end of the gavotte and doubles. How he brought this magnificent passacaglia (essentially) home for a splendid and rousing finale. M. Haas is a great maestro, and the authority of his interpretation will be a source of delight for years to come, I am sure.

  • @user-gm1cj1mx3y
    @user-gm1cj1mx3y Год назад +5

    フェルメールのこの絵を洗浄した状態で観たが、世界最高の絵画だと思った。観るだけで心と知能が開発されていく、知恵の絵だ。

  • @yuritomassen6305
    @yuritomassen6305 5 лет назад +32

    "Have another glass, my dear. You'll see what I mean."

    • @rupertkemsley7166
      @rupertkemsley7166 Год назад +2

      She’ll finally be able to see that the room they are sitting in warps reality and space time. The painting is right next to the table, however, if you look at the tiles directly behind her, they go off into the distance and make the back wall look really far away.

  • @robfox5670
    @robfox5670 4 года назад +21

    The best harpsichord suite ever

  • @user-zy2mz6sj6h
    @user-zy2mz6sj6h 2 года назад +8

    Рамо это совершенство гармонии , Свет и материя! Это душа гения! Спасибо за музыку !

  • @baroque6hiro
    @baroque6hiro  11 лет назад +32

    The glass of wine - Johannes Vermeer

    • @yuritomassen6305
      @yuritomassen6305 5 лет назад +2

      Hand-made stained glass panels just like that one are popular again.

  • @user-zy2mz6sj6h
    @user-zy2mz6sj6h 2 года назад +21

    Спасибо за музыку ! Барокко это
    тихая страсть и победа Света над материей, мука и радость! Рамо это совершенство космоса и торжество гармонии!

    • @sergelachantee767
      @sergelachantee767 Год назад +2

      ЭТО МУЗЫКА РОКОКО!!!⚜😌

    • @t_mm_r
      @t_mm_r Год назад +5

      @@sergelachantee767 почему Рамо это рококо? В музыке в принципе не принято выделять отдельный стиль рококо. Если уже это и делать, то скорее рококо соответствует "галантный" стиль, в котором писал например Иоганн Кристиан Бах, Галуппи, Чимароза и т.д.

    • @sergelachantee767
      @sergelachantee767 Год назад +1

      @@t_mm_r А Я ВЫДЕЛЯЮ!!! ТЫ ЧТО НА МЕНЯ КАТИШЬ?🥊

    • @MrVonLeipzig
      @MrVonLeipzig 11 месяцев назад +1

      Roccocco is one of Rameaus influences, like the pre-clacissicism before Stamitz and Bocherini.

  • @_PROCLUS
    @_PROCLUS 6 лет назад +22

    The Belgian harpsichordist, Frédérick Haas born 1969 .. studied the harpsichord with a number of teachers, and was awarded solo diplomas at both the Sweelinck Conservatorium of Amsterdam and the Conservatoire Royal de Bruxelles, in addition to a Musicology degree from the Sorbonne. ... Frédérick Haas is professor of harpsichord at the Royal Conservatorium of Brussels.

  • @danawinsor1380
    @danawinsor1380 2 года назад +27

    This music is glorious. The "Gavotte et Doubles" is so beautiful it almost hurts.

    • @erikvictor
      @erikvictor 2 года назад +3

      I agree with you. Check out the version and interpretation of Natacha Kudritskaya here on RUclips. ''Rameau - Suite en la Gavotte et six Doubles / Natacha Kudritskaya'' Prepare for pain.

    • @valerytaubin8728
      @valerytaubin8728 Год назад

      I feel the same listening to Favorite in six doubles

    • @johnrickert5572
      @johnrickert5572 Год назад

      @@erikvictor Her performance is simply incredible.

    • @kmidst_mz5094
      @kmidst_mz5094 Год назад

      Olena Zhukova has a great rendition of this song ruclips.net/video/K-wK-rmFoZY/видео.html&ab_channel=OlenaZhukova-Topic

  • @ninodaney
    @ninodaney 5 лет назад +4

    Absolument splendide. D’une très grande beauté.

  • @olegkurkov9689
    @olegkurkov9689 4 года назад +8

    Рамо---это изумруд эпохи,а исполнение,как алмаз,сияющий разными цветами.Слушаешь и понимаешь,что музыка(настоящая!)вечна....

  • @vhsjpdfg
    @vhsjpdfg 10 лет назад +40

    Rameau was the trill-master.

    • @peteacher52
      @peteacher52 4 года назад +11

      Couperin le Grande and the French keyboard school of the era generally. Bach is recorded as not being particularly fond of the fact that hardly a note of French music is free of ornamentation.

  • @mereyeslacalle
    @mereyeslacalle 2 года назад +4

    24:40 muero con la Gavotte et six doubles ; la entrada al cielo , maravilla❤ . Rameau es fascinante !! Y la pintura "La copa de vino " , magnífica obra de arte de Johannes Vermeer van Delft . Gracias por compartir tanta hermosura @baroque6hiro . Saludos desde Chile ❤🌺

  • @gerardbegni2806
    @gerardbegni2806 6 лет назад +14

    A very beautiful registering which uses the "notes inégales" of the French harpsichord tradition. This gives a perfume of authenticity without drawing Rameau backwards.

  • @suremate
    @suremate 10 лет назад +35

    The gavotte et doubles was so good I had to listen to it twice!

    • @violinhunter2
      @violinhunter2 10 лет назад +7

      Agreed!!! And I listened to it 3 times. So imaginative!!!!

    • @Omoraru
      @Omoraru 9 лет назад +7

      I listened to it a lot too, thought it only had that effect to me, The last couple of doubles is especially addicting !

    • @marcellofildoz2841
      @marcellofildoz2841 8 лет назад +3

      +suremate Wonderful interpretation

    • @teruoimai668
      @teruoimai668 6 лет назад +2

      suremate ほほほ

  • @marcustorquatus
    @marcustorquatus 11 лет назад +6

    Tout simplement magnifique ! Merci.

  • @danieltamminga1748
    @danieltamminga1748 5 лет назад +1

    Die Musik ist Gold. Und so ein tolles Bild aus längst vergangenen Zeiten...

  •  8 лет назад +16

    Such great music, praise Rameau

  • @gonzalotobellamatas7388
    @gonzalotobellamatas7388 5 лет назад +5

    Excelente.Rameau es un compositor extraordinario.

  • @jorgeaguirre7260
    @jorgeaguirre7260 5 лет назад +3

    I´ve heard incredible interpretations on the Piano....but this interpretation on the hapsichord is superb, so beautiful you just don´t get tired of hearing again and again and again...

  • @maximillianrodriguez164
    @maximillianrodriguez164 6 лет назад +3

    he plays it with a lot of feeling, it's really good.

  • @violinhunter2
    @violinhunter2 10 лет назад +36

    Just as I was thinking that Frederick Hass' playing could not get any more brilliant, I got to 31:00 !!! Amazing virtuosity.

    • @philipbay1548
      @philipbay1548 3 года назад

      Waaaaaay too rushed. He blew it

    • @rodthom86
      @rodthom86 Год назад

      @@philipbay1548 Do better and put it online.

    • @philipbay1548
      @philipbay1548 Год назад

      @@rodthom86 put what online?

  • @TristanDeCunha
    @TristanDeCunha 10 лет назад +11

    I'm reading I. Berlin's 'Roots of Romanticism' and hearing Rameau in that context (17th c. Germany v France, Rameau v Bach, worldly music v pious music) is fascinating.

    • @andrewsappel
      @andrewsappel 5 лет назад +2

      I always think that Rameau is akin to Boucher. Diderot said that Boucher was the greatest living painter but so dishonest. It was the entitlement to sensual delight, to color and taste and texture without moral purpose that offended...and Rameau in his music is as voluptuous and indulgent. I call it a generosity. Keep your high flown Greuze moralities...give me Venus ini pearls!

  • @user-oj9fz4pi9j
    @user-oj9fz4pi9j 11 месяцев назад +3

    What a masterpiece!

  • @peteacher52
    @peteacher52 4 года назад +8

    All areas as good as it gets - a special tip of the cap to the recording engineers as the harpsichord is not an easy instrument to record well. Wanda Landowska was particular about which carpets rolled up, which curtains pulled and specific furniture placement and above all, where will the microphone go? In 1952!

  • @solcarzemog5232
    @solcarzemog5232 4 года назад +2

    What a SPLENDID performance

  • @Blake4625kHz
    @Blake4625kHz 4 года назад +2

    Excellent recording!

  • @jeffersonsantos6379
    @jeffersonsantos6379 9 лет назад +2

    Obra magnífica!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! é de uma beleza tamanha !!!!!!!!! Bravo!!!.

  • @comtaar2245
    @comtaar2245 2 года назад

    Omg, Fanfarinette, the opening tune to a CBC radio show for so many years!

  • @rosanacianciosi1226
    @rosanacianciosi1226 Год назад

    Hermosas piezas del Barroco,me encanta el sonido del clave,gracias por compartirlas saludos

  • @ENIGMAXII2112
    @ENIGMAXII2112 Год назад

    Magnificent, truly MAGNIFICENT..!!

  • @XavFranz
    @XavFranz 6 лет назад +1

    Courante & Trois Mains - unreal beautiful!!!!!!!

  • @louisegray4686
    @louisegray4686 5 лет назад +1

    Very lovely and sensuous. I have played this piece and never tire of it.

  • @tepmich
    @tepmich 3 года назад

    BRILLIANT !!! Tepper Michael.

  • @oltynn
    @oltynn 5 лет назад +2

    BRILLIANT

  • @csabasc
    @csabasc 4 года назад +1

    An ultimate performance. No more needs.

  • @christianlagadec7296
    @christianlagadec7296 2 года назад +1

    Et merci pour vos repères qui facilitent la réécoute.

  • @alvarodevita8177
    @alvarodevita8177 Год назад

    My favorite collection about Rameau,,,,,there is not same...

  • @agonludmilla
    @agonludmilla 11 лет назад +1

    EXTRAORDINARY BEATIFUL .

  • @violinhunter2
    @violinhunter2 10 лет назад +17

    I hope the aristocracy Rameau wrote his music for enjoyed it as much as I do. It is fantastic.

    • @psalc1
      @psalc1 6 лет назад +1

      he also co-authored an opera with Voltaire. apparently they were friends and would attend the same salons. ;-)

    • @comtaar2245
      @comtaar2245 2 года назад +1

      @@psalc1 friends with Voltaire? Then they were just poking fun at everything.

  • @cassianomoura1165
    @cassianomoura1165 10 лет назад +4

    É excelente e espetacular

  • @CRAEager
    @CRAEager 11 лет назад

    Thank you!

  • @alistairkewish651
    @alistairkewish651 2 года назад

    A beautiful and sonorous harpsichord.

  • @alcyonecrucis
    @alcyonecrucis 2 года назад +1

    Rameau is so original

  • @_PROCLUS
    @_PROCLUS Месяц назад

    Capriccio in B-flat major, BWV 992 written ca 1705 -- Gavotte et Doubles 1728

  • @vraellar
    @vraellar 5 лет назад +7

    The end is so cool - hard rock of the Baroque age

  • @pianofan1000
    @pianofan1000 2 года назад

    how lovely

  • @Omoraru
    @Omoraru 9 лет назад +15

    Very good, surprisingly easy on the hear for the harpsichord imo; and excellent melodic lines. the trills overabundance is weird at first, but strangely pleasant when you're accustomed to it. Very refreshing and not what I thought I would hear !

    • @giuseppelogiurato5718
      @giuseppelogiurato5718 7 лет назад +8

      lol, for sure, the first few minutes strike our modern ears as gaudy and flamboyant, but one becomes accustomed to it quite easily... how many appoggiatura can you can fit into a piece? Exactly this many... it literally "sparkles"; musical "bling" no?

    • @alejandrom.4680
      @alejandrom.4680 5 лет назад +5

      I hear Rameau music since I was 10 and I love it as much as love the music itself. Those trills are the best part of Rameau pieces, they have something special, and i dont know what specifically is. I want to be a hapsichordist, but in my country there are no hapsichordists so, maybe when i grow and go to other place of the world for study it. Anyways, I'm glad you liked this piece and the style of Rameau, is one of the beauties things of Baroque era.

    • @Blake4625kHz
      @Blake4625kHz 4 года назад +1

      The trills here are what my eyes do to the road at night when I'm driving tired 😄

  • @peteacher52
    @peteacher52 4 года назад +30

    To all of the folk who have been commenting on and even bellyaching about the number of "trills" as they put it ... do some homework and educate yourself about trills, turns, mordents, acciacctura, appoggiatura in relation to French baroque practice. The player is expected to extemporise as the performance is much more complex than the written score suggests. An expert like Mr Hass makes it sound easy ... it's not!

    • @rickack8176
      @rickack8176 4 часа назад

      Nicely put. I’m no musician of any kind but I love to listen, all kinds. I used to express ‘preferences’ but I now understand that Art Music evolved over the centuries from the genius of each Composer.
      Each piece is wonderful in its own rite. 💙

  • @allegriniedmond9885
    @allegriniedmond9885 Год назад

    et oui composer de telle musique a cette époque est manifique..

  • @ichbifeuertrunk
    @ichbifeuertrunk 8 лет назад +14

    30:13

  • @flyingdutchman773
    @flyingdutchman773 3 года назад +2

    painting caption: "Ok ok dear, I will buy you a harpsichord for your birthday"

  • @blackletter2591
    @blackletter2591 Год назад +2

    I have never heard the harpsichord sound so good.

  • @zarathustra8789
    @zarathustra8789 8 лет назад +32

    Vermeer and Rameau... Could there be a better combination between image and sound? Probably not.

    • @ninodaney
      @ninodaney 5 лет назад +5

      Pedro Silva We might add your Tarkovsky and it’d be even more wonderful :)

    • @antoinemozart243
      @antoinemozart243 3 года назад +1

      They didn't live in the same Century.

    • @zarathustra8789
      @zarathustra8789 3 года назад

      @@antoinemozart243 You don't say. I thought they were contemporary with Plato and Giotto.

    • @antoinemozart243
      @antoinemozart243 3 года назад

      @@zarathustra8789 to associate Wermeer and Rameau is irrelevant as I personally don't see any link whatsoever.

    • @zarathustra8789
      @zarathustra8789 3 года назад

      @@antoinemozart243 It's absolutely insignificant that you find the association irrelevant, as I merely expressed my fondness for both's art and joy with the surprisingly pleasant merging.

  • @DocToombs
    @DocToombs 10 лет назад +1

    Who is playing this wonderfull piece? Is it you,if so it is superb ;-)

  • @debsiwebs
    @debsiwebs 5 лет назад +2

    Fanflippintastic

  • @afbf6522
    @afbf6522 Год назад +1

    L'allemanda em transmet una pau i una tranquil·litat íntimes, com poques altres peces ho aconsegueixen.

  • @gillestillieux5165
    @gillestillieux5165 4 года назад

    Les trillrs et autres ornements sont écrits chez Rameau ?

  • @penjamfilms
    @penjamfilms 3 года назад +3

    Good music, connects you to the unknown.

  • @llVincentRockll
    @llVincentRockll 5 лет назад +1

    Thanks for the upload. Very nice to hear this recording.
    By the way, a kind correction, the name of the harpsichord performer is Frederick HAAS.
    Best.

  • @asinusvonachalm5164
    @asinusvonachalm5164 7 лет назад +1

    Gavotte et Doubles : aussi beau que Händel mais mode royal !

  • @XavFranz
    @XavFranz 6 лет назад

    Courante is unusual!

  • @filsuf
    @filsuf 5 лет назад +2

    listening to this makes me feel Bach French Suites really "make sense" .. I dont know how to say it, they are "corresponding" to the whole ambiance and mood in this Rameau's . thanks!!

    • @erika6651
      @erika6651 Год назад +1

      Bach was quite limited emotionally considering how much he composed.

  • @polettepetite7950
    @polettepetite7950 3 года назад +1

    Viaggio all indietro

  • @sandygrungerson1177
    @sandygrungerson1177 10 лет назад +44

    needs more trills

    • @sandygrungerson1177
      @sandygrungerson1177 10 лет назад +1

      C. Arthur Eager
      lol....i was being facetious, but OK, i'll give it a try anyway on some other pieces.....dadadadadadad d dum....

    • @sandygrungerson1177
      @sandygrungerson1177 10 лет назад

      C. Arthur Eager
      did anyone 'check-de-expiration-date' on this rameau?

    • @danielhornby5581
      @danielhornby5581 4 года назад

      I agree, hardly heard any in this recording.

  • @egidioloi7335
    @egidioloi7335 9 лет назад +11

    Who is the performer? He is absolutely fantastic!!

    • @nebbit1
      @nebbit1 9 лет назад

      Egidio Loi If you are still wondering, this is Frederick Hass performing.

    • @thelookingglassss
      @thelookingglassss 8 лет назад +2

      His name is Frédérick Haas (not Hass). He's really fine harpsichordist, special musician!

    • @nebbit1
      @nebbit1 8 лет назад +1

      +felipetavares79 Thank you very much for the information!

    • @zarathustra8789
      @zarathustra8789 7 лет назад +4

      Indeed, I have heard many versions of the Gavotte and this might be my favourite, the most virtuous and closest to being flawless, both in terms of speed and expression. I love it!

    • @egidioloi7335
      @egidioloi7335 7 лет назад

      thanks guys☺

  • @user-pz9ib8xf8o
    @user-pz9ib8xf8o 8 месяцев назад

    画面構成が変わって、すごく見難くなった。希望のタイトルを探しにくくなった。RUclipsさんへ

  • @elfpix
    @elfpix 6 лет назад +1

    Frédérick is a devotee of Ross and so the Allemande is slower than I prefer. The trills are all wonderful but he does have a habit of thinking outside the box and I'm not inclined to the Gavotte.

  • @bachianm2375
    @bachianm2375 Год назад

    Thank you for publishing this beautiful work and rendition. But it is Frédérick Haas, not "Hass".

  • @TomKotarba
    @TomKotarba 11 лет назад

    what is anachronistic?

  • @follonica1
    @follonica1 5 лет назад

    Troppo trippo...glggllgglgl!!

  • @kristianapacheva
    @kristianapacheva 8 месяцев назад

    It's like listening to Bulgarian chalga but classical

  • @marcobagut
    @marcobagut 5 лет назад

    who's is the painting, please?

    • @franciscomalonzo98
      @franciscomalonzo98 6 месяцев назад

      Johannes Vermeer, Glass of Wine (1658-61), Gemäldegalerie, Berlin..

  • @sanpehla
    @sanpehla Год назад +1

    27:20

  • @gillestillieux5165
    @gillestillieux5165 4 года назад +1

    Trilles xcuses

  • @bootman26
    @bootman26 11 месяцев назад

    I'm an ignoramus when it comes to harpsichord performance, but I'm assuming that this is mostly performed notes inegales?

  • @gtuneit
    @gtuneit 3 года назад

    Not as stringy as some recordings. It is hard to tell if I am listening to a piano or a harpsichord.

  • @CRAEager
    @CRAEager 11 лет назад

    What is the painting?

  • @AureliaVisovan
    @AureliaVisovan 11 лет назад

    they're both Baroque, that's the explanation - it's just that in music every Era came later than in the other fields :)

  • @norbertnagy3123
    @norbertnagy3123 4 года назад

    Not 480p, only 360p.

  • @proulxmontpellier
    @proulxmontpellier 10 лет назад

    About anachronism, just imagine illustrating some music of, let's say David Bowie with some 19th C illustrations... :)

    • @giuseppelogiurato5718
      @giuseppelogiurato5718 7 лет назад +3

      True, but the Baroque style was never about chronological accuracy... the painting nicely fits the "Affekt" of the suite; I don't think Rameau would even care which paintings people looked at while listening to his work.

    • @asinusvonachalm5164
      @asinusvonachalm5164 6 лет назад +1

      WHO IS THAT IDIOT DAVE BOWIE ?

    • @baretous
      @baretous 5 лет назад

      Asinus von Achalm Don't mind. David Bowie is a genius only for geniuses ..

  • @mantictac
    @mantictac 3 года назад

    The Courante is too fast. Part of the reason there are so many ornaments is because the Courante is a slow and stately dance, and the notes can be sustained with them. This tempo isn't nearly as extreme as you can get with other modern performances, but the ornaments still sound cluttered.

    • @antoinemozart243
      @antoinemozart243 3 года назад +1

      Courante means running in French.

    • @mantictac
      @mantictac 3 года назад +3

      @@antoinemozart243 Yes, it does. It also means "a current". But this isn't French language class. The French dance, the Courante, was described throughout the baroque era as a grave dance, sometimes even the slowest of the suite (including the Passacaille, AND the Sarabande). The fast dance is the Italian "Corrente".
      The word "Gigue" comes from a Germanic root word meaning "to wish, to desire". Is that what comes to mind when you hear the Gigue?

    • @antoinemozart243
      @antoinemozart243 3 года назад

      @@mantictac hahahaha ! Go back to a nurse school ! Courante, a grave dance !!!! Courante Comes from the verb courir meaning ...to run !!!! Hahahaha !

    • @zarathustra8789
      @zarathustra8789 5 месяцев назад

      ​​@@mantictacThank you for sharing your knowledge with us. This juvenile fellow hassling you has posted other ridiculous comments over this video, pay no mind to him.

  • @bernardosepulveda2276
    @bernardosepulveda2276 8 лет назад

    All this beautiful hapischord music by Rameu thath we have is because of Balbastre work

    • @TinyFloyd
      @TinyFloyd 8 лет назад

      +bernardo sepulveda
      yea...sure....thanks Claude Rameau

    • @bernardosepulveda2276
      @bernardosepulveda2276 7 лет назад

      Balbastre not invent the harpsichord but took the work of Rameau and transcribed for the harpsichord
      Rameau never wrote for the harpsichord

    • @bernardosepulveda2276
      @bernardosepulveda2276 7 лет назад +3

      Apology accepted. The truth is not much is known about the life of Rameau, because much of their work was lost ( as was the custom at that time ) have only been preserved operas and other works but nothing for the harpsichord all this is in the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris , so all the pieces for harpsichord of Rameau we know are transcripts made ​​by his pupil Claude Balbastre .

    • @inesdesatrustegui3903
      @inesdesatrustegui3903 7 лет назад +7

      I believed Rameau wrote and published himself the Premier livre de pièces de clavecin (harpsichord) in 1706, the Deuxième (second) livre de pièces de clavecin in 1724, and the third, called Nouvelles suites de pièces de clavecin, in 1728, and the Pièces de clavecin en concert, and… Here, in France, we consider him as our most important composer for harpsichord with François Couperin.
      Barbastre made the transcriptions for harpsichord of his operas, but that's all…
      (Sorry for my awful english.)

    • @asinusvonachalm5164
      @asinusvonachalm5164 6 лет назад +2

      Yoor hinglish isch mootsch mor better than most of what we bikome to read in this annoious columns

  • @xlrv1
    @xlrv1 11 лет назад

    What is anachronistic - the use of a painting by Vermeer (died 1675) to illustrate music from the 18th century.

    • @MultiShinypants
      @MultiShinypants 5 лет назад +2

      On this particular occasion it's definitely an expression of good taste.

  • @pharanaiton6851
    @pharanaiton6851 5 лет назад +1

    yes my love, it's that small... sit down and drink some water my love, you'll feel better... i will make this up to you, i swear!

  • @asinusvonachalm5164
    @asinusvonachalm5164 7 лет назад

    Cette interprétation -comparée à celle angélique , subtile, tendre et raffinée mais non dépourvue de brillance et d'émotion de Nathalia Kudritzkaja n' est autre chose qu'une charge de chars lourds destinée aux oreille modernes, rendues insensibles par 60 ans de tamtams, batteries assourdantes, grosses caisses, cymbales, et autres intruments producteurs de bruits dévastateurs pour le tympan et la sensibilité musicale. Il est compréhensible que celà plaise aux belous de tout poils issus de cette subculture du tintamarre ! Ezzo Eberhard II Asinus von Achalm

    • @lassalbet
      @lassalbet 6 лет назад +1

      Vous avez peut-être raison. Mais,pour en juger, il faudrait entendre une interprétation de Nathalia Kudritzkaja au clavecin, si elle existe. Je suis allé écouter sur youtube son interprétation au piano que je trouve certes beaucoup plus riche en nuances. Mais il importe quand même de jouer les musiques sur les instruments pour lesquels elles ont été écrites. Et j'avoue que j'aimerais bien entendre une autre version de cette suite jouée sur clavecin.

    • @melodyhappywish
      @melodyhappywish 2 года назад

      Insensé.. l’ornementation est partie intégrante de la musique pour claviers de cette époque là, et la liberté en est laissée à chaque interprète. Je vous en prie, renseignez-vous sur les pratiques d’interprétation fort intéressantes de la musique baroque.

  • @xlrv1
    @xlrv1 11 лет назад

    A bit anachronistic.

  • @CarlBowlby
    @CarlBowlby 5 лет назад +2

    Ok, modern ears here so I cannot listen to more than 3 movements of this wonderful suite. The harpsichord, especially when it goes very fast on “Les Trois Mains”, is almost unbearable to my ears. But this is just me, of course. The other “issue” I have with this interpretation is that there are many embellishments improvised into a score which already has plenty, imo, of them. So why “tax” the listener’s ears with constant ornamentations? Makes little sense to me not only as a performer but a listener. However, the playing is flawless and expert so that I cannot argue with.

    • @phebus2005
      @phebus2005 5 лет назад +3

      Carl Bowlby ... About those "embellishments", Huguette Dreyfus, whom I studied with, would tell you to carefully read introductions and treatises, which we extensively did at her class. Early French music was formerly, so Couperin himself says, meant not to be played as it's written. Great freedom of expression is expected from the performer playing Rameau who didn't always filled in what could be imagined by his player. That's the idea of live music : do not play it twice the same way. A harpsichordist, and an organist, must know what to do with what's not specified. In a way Chopin continued the tradition, but then his text had become unbearably impossible to adapt to the spur of the moment.

    • @CarlBowlby
      @CarlBowlby 5 лет назад +1

      thierry guffroy hello, and thank you for not “shouting me down” if you know what I mean. Of course I understand the concept of embellishments and do so myself on the organ and piano, but I guess my exception to this interpretation was that they were too much to my ears. Simply a subjective response. I also love Couperin and Rameau’s clavecin music as they wrote it. But if historically they expected more ornamentation than what was written then that’s an issue concerning my own tastes. However, all that said, the music played is beautifully rendered. And yes, yes I have read countless introductions and early books on ornamentation which was never truly agreed upon by all those considered, so there was no one set standard of executing trills, mordents, etc. It’s new to me when you say that Chopin expected embellishments in his music. Is this true?

    • @phebus2005
      @phebus2005 5 лет назад +1

      Carl Bowlby 😊 Trying to say things in just a few words without sounding rude is something I know little about, especially when I am not using my mother tongue, and I certainly did not mean to teach anyone a lesson. Thank you for acknowledging that. Here may not be the ideal place to debate and discuss. I'd be awfully sorry to realize that people would think of me as not interested in everyone's remarks. I am no specialist of Chopin. But the way his music is conceived seems to lead to much more liberty than it looks, perhaps with other means. Then again, the comparison only came from pianists. Let's stick to one style and one instrument for now. Nice talking to you ! (And forgive my English. Hard to be clear when you think in a language and write in another one !)

    • @CarlBowlby
      @CarlBowlby 5 лет назад

      thierry guffroy yes thank you, it is hard to discuss ornamentation in a format such as RUclips comments! And may I ask, what is your original language?

    • @phebus2005
      @phebus2005 5 лет назад +1

      Carl Bowlby ... If of any interest, speaking of embellishments, let me give you two examples :
      We know that Bach published very little of his complete organ work. Many copies were made by pupils, family and friends, which says a lot on the popularity (or not) of a piece. Take the "Pièce d'orgue" in G Major. The Bach Gesellschaft Edition (I hardly know of a better one) published what seems to be a fair copy in which the counterpoint is left rather "clean". The Neue Bach Ausgabe though later reveled and released a copy with an ornament on each note !!! See !
      In his organ chorales, Bach sometimes produced two versions of the exact same one (which he called "Alio modo", another way to play the same thing). It occurs in the Orgelbüchlein and in the Leipzig collection ...
      I like to suppose that the idioms Chopin used were just examples, his technique being new, as did Haendel, Bach and ... Rameau ... What do you think ?