Frigates vs a Ship of the Line - An Indefatigable Contest
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024
- Today in something of an 'emergency' video, we recount one of the most interesting contests of the Age of Sail, when the frigates HMS Indefatigable and HMS Amazon took on the 3rd rate ship of the line Droits de L'Homme in the middle of a raging storm.
The book in question - www.amazon.co.uk/Against-Odds-Battles-Sea-1591-1949/dp/1557500258
Free naval photos and more - www.drachinifel.co.uk
Want to support the channel? - / drachinifel
Model ships of many periods - store.warlordga...?aff=21
Want a shirt/mug/hoodie - shop.spreadshi...
Want a poster? - www.etsy.com/u...
Want to talk about ships? / discord
Want to get some books? www.amazon.co.uk/shop/drachinifelDrydock
Music - / ncmepicmusic
Pinned post for Q&A :)
Had the Tirpitz battleship survived the war, what would the allies due to the ship?
How accurate historically is the Hornblower series of books?
Have you done a video on the USS Constitution? She is a most excellent frigate. If so, the USS Essex is another frigate story that needs to be told.
Ah, just found your video on the Constitution
Aside from HMS Tiger what where in your opinion some warships that were well designed but ended up not performing as well as they could or should have due to various reasons?
When is the next Guadalcanal campaign episode coming out
Note on the British prisoners: The prisoners on the Droits de l'Homme were returned to Britain in recognition of their attempts to save lives during the wreck. The crew of the Amazon soon returned home, having been exchanged for French prisoners held in England.
The monument to those lost in the wrecks, currently broken due to storm damage, was erected after the Napoleonic Wars by a Major Pipon, formerly one of the British prisoners aboard the Droits de l'Homme.
Always very nice to hear about mutual respect between combatants. Somewhat ironic that the monument broke due to storm.
Didn't an episode of Hornblower use this for inspiration?
@@Jon.A.Scholt i think they replaced the French ship of the line with the Indy and the two british ships were replaced with two french Corvettes, kinda switcherooed it round. Then Horatio arrives in the Papillon to save Pellew and the Indy and blows the french out of the water. Think one of them explodes and the other surrenders.
That’s the episode devil and the duchess if I remember correctly
WoW, thank you . Fly safe.
It's ok to want/need a day off every now and then.
Especially if you/loved ones have legit medical/personal reasons.
We appreciate your high quality content, more so given current circumstances.
Please don't feel that you owe us anything, we are happy for the free entertainment.
Well said
Agreed.
I think you nailed it there.
Unfortunately, can't 'like' comments more than once!
Well said Fatmanbravo6! May I add we all wish a long and healthy life to Drach and Ms. Drach! Take everyone take care!
You know it's a top-tier channel when the "Emergency fill-in" video is still absolutely fascinating and interesting.
Honestly I like these fill-in videos better than the dry docks
@@heisenberg1817 well you can't compare the Wednesday video to the 5-minute guide or the dry dock or whatever because they're all very different types of video. Personally I like the dry dock but that's possibly because I have many MANY hours where I would like some kind of content playing so that it's not just dead silence in my house and there's only so many times you can listen to the same songs.
@@the_undead 100% with you there dude
Those words are synonymous... Why do people keep doing this?
Only the post revolutionary French would name a warship Rights of Man
The name of the ship that Billy Budd was pressed from
Sure, right of men and citizen were unknown to the citizen of England poor and dominated by noblemen and rich aristocracy, a bit like today too.
lol
@Zippy Dastrange More so because the entire worlds economy has been carefully crafted and manipulated to keep the American elite class in there positions of ridiculous fortune and anyone who tries to change it ends up dead.
like the USSR named a battleship October Revolution.
Impressed. No small number of content creators would just take a day and rest instead. Don't work yourself to death and take care of your health!
@Yannick 73 He could get a gig as an audiobook reader. I like his After Action Reports readings in the Guadalcanal series as well.
Actually it makes for an interesting juxtaposition:
- Drach's reading skills
- Drach's speaking skills when not reading
They are very closely matched. Neither is obviously discernable from the other, which is to his great credit.
Reading books is a time honored way to beat sickness, though typically one has their grandfather do it so he can skip the kissing parts.
French: We’re invading England!
Poseidon: No
Or the Royal Navy in general to anyone thinking to have unauthorized vacations:
No.
Non.
@@YOUPIMatin123 unless that someone is a former Scot turned Continental pirate captain and damnable scoundrel.
Let's try Wales then.
@@davidtuttle7556 - And later on Russian Rear Admiral, then bass guitar player for a rock band. 😉
Makes me think hornblower every time!
It does
I have read that Patrick Stewart based his take on Captain Piccard on Hornblower.
Oh yes, it does! After all, C. S. Forester based His main character on all sorts of known, famous captains: Cochrane, Pellew, Nelson... Damn, I think it's time to reread the series 😁
@@shaider1982 I would have thought Pellew more than Hornblower? Or did you (and he) simply mean the books?
@@shaider1982 - Was Captain Picard tone deaf like Hornblower, and did he get motion sick at the start of each voyage?
"A Reef of Dire Repute" sounds like a good name for a 70s prog rock album
Or a seriously gnarly variety of cannabis
Whenever any nation plans a attack during winter. The COLDEST winter in recent/living memory happens.
Mate you did a 5+ hour drydock, still got an interesting video up and are looking after yourself and your partner, double up your rum and tea ration and take it easy!
“Partner”.
It’s his wife, dude. Get that PC shit out of here.
Wife is no longer PC,
suggests servitude.
@@billrich9722 ???? How the fuck is partner PC?????
@@billrich9722 are you triggered, snowflake?
@@fredgervinm.p.3315 Lmao no one thinks that. What?
Love these ships under sail segments. I can’t imagine the sheer strength of will and discipline it took to fight a battle as described.
wooden ships, steel men
@@davidbocquelet-dbodesign - Used to be a board game called "Wooden Ships and Iron Men".
Damn fine of the French crew to remember the prisoners and do the best to get 'em loose. We may poke fun at the French, but they wouldn't have been able to keep England on their toes if they weren't badass in their own right.
This puts you right up there with Mark Felton in narrating a story.
If you need a break, for whatever reason, you should take it. Your fans will understand.
This was a great explanation of the fight and contained many small "nuggets of knowledge" within it. Kudos on a fine presentation.
its amazing that in such horrendous weather they still decided its a perfectly good time for a naval battle
To a British frigate captain, anything but the gates of hell is still a good time for a battle... seriously, that's why they had the warning about getting a court martial.
"Pour le encourage less autres" Read AT TWELVE MR BYNG WAS SHOT for the story behind Voltaire's famous aphorism
Well, the powder was going to get wet anyway,
French Planners: "The worst thing that could happen is if we all get scattered!"
What Happens: The French get scattered
On board the Indefatigable that night was Midshipman Horatio Hornblower, according to C. S. Forester..
"I'm going to make my main character a kick-ass Frigate captain. What better way to start out his career than serving under one of the most brilliant real captains of the age!"
I still name my hero ship Indefatigable in any game that lets me.
Ah yes, we'll make the signals for "It's safe, follow me" and "Oh God the ship is on rocks" the same thing. What could go wrong?
Hennimore!
"That Mitchell and Webb Look" for you non-British.
Thank God, Drach. And kudos to your other half too. (Your lady, I mean.) Your naval content is second only to my late Dad's. I still have his Armada, pun not intended, of naval history books.
Excellent job.
Just when I needed something to listen to when I was putting together some warhammer minis
I just can't any more.
Really wish I could but can't support them any more.
Drak is good to listen to while playing warthunder though.
Hopefully its not anything Xenos or else the inquistion might get called
The aether wars box I’m afraid. Kharodon overlords and Tzeentch. But if it helps I just got the box to sell on eBay
The Patreon Drydock marathons work best for me.
I can bang out an entire Panzer unit.
@@Gunninator - I wasn't expecting a kind of Spanish Inquisition.
Could you do the History of the entire Russian Navy, just a request if you would like to do it?
If you have a few minutes spare, you know?
I can add it to the list, albeit even at around an hour it would be a whistlestop tour, the Russian Navy goes back a surprisingly long way. :)
@@Drachinifel Then perhaps make it as long as it need to be...😋😉👍
Oh yes please
@@Drachinifel yes I am ready for a 12+ hour video!!! Note I am still there at the end when you ask if we made it that far. Also I would pay you for a I survived the drydock medal. You are my favorite channel of all time! Started watching you back in Drydock 7
RN: *Indefatigable*
Frenchies: _Hon! Hon! Hon! Et tu petit, Inzefattygayballs?_
“Ya did what in his balls?”
😂😂😂
Captain Pellew: "Mr. Hornblower, hold my port. I'm about destroy this man's whole career."
😂
@@creanero I think Hornblower had left _Indefatigable_ for _Renown_ and the West Indies before this battle.
That was fantastic, thank you.
Can’t tell if I prefer the dreadnought era videos or the age of sail videos
Fortunately, we don't have to choose!
Just sail away just sail away
I found the channel through the USS Monitor vs. CSS Virginia video.
Surely you jest. Maneuvering under sail requires real seamanship.
Just a week ago i rewatched The Hornblower series, so seeing something on the "Indi" is nice.
In the USA the second shot is the one to watch out for. Get well, take care of Mrs. Drach and come back stronger. I love your material.
Glad you and Mrs. Drach are safe and recouping. Thanks for the great informative content!
First of all: all the best and good health to Drac-Family; Secondly: I kinda like that "Fairy Tales with Uncle Drac" format.... and the stories about fights against all odds... it just catches me. :-) Keep it up, please!
If Drach is telling Ferry Tales, I would like a 5-Minute Guide (more or less) about the roll-on/roll-off ship F/S Theodor Heuss, which sailed between Rødbyhavn in Sjælland and Puttgarden in Schleswig-Holstein.
Wednesday afternoons never looked so sweet! Always an interesting topic
Living far from there I looked up Penmarch Reefs. That is a crazy gauntlet to get a damaged ship in a storm out of, legendary captain and crew in real life. I imagine the reefs have claimed many ships over the years.
Fun Fact: At flank narration speed, HMS Drachinifel consumes 1.2-L of Irn-Bru per hour. 😉
I've been finding myself checking RUclips WAY too often for new Drach videos lately, and most the old ones have that red line along the bottom that tells me I've watched them :( . Glad you've recovered from the covid-poke.
An excellent view of these ships of the line in battle of which held morals in battle with honor and dignity, different times.
Oh my. Yes, when I got mine I was out for the afternoon, and I know people who were feeling like you for the better part of a week. But that means it's working: the thing that makes you dead tired is your body's immune system firing up.
I truly enjoy your age of sail videos
Congratulations on getting your vaccines both, and thank you for taking them. :-)
Waiting patiently for mine, since I'm in the very last group.
We love any video you put out. Thank you for your time and effort.
Especially age of sail stuff
Of course, Captain Pellew was also blessed with having a great crew and midshipmen like one Mr. Hornblower :-)
I just looked up his bio on Wiki.
Pellew was no less than a superman. In heavy seas, on another occasion, with a stranded East Indiaman, he swam over to the wrecked ship, installed a lifeline and saved almost all onboard.
Err...French lower-deck guns were 36 (French) pounders which equates to 39 English pounds.
Damn. What happened to that French man-o-war makes me shudder.
Kinda sounds like Sir Edward may have been a bit of an inspiration for Hornblower. A bit of a badass he seems to be.
Congrats on getting your jab and get well soon, Drach
As I am sure you all know "Droits de L’Homme" means "Human Rights". Pretty cool name for a ship.
Well done, and best wishes for your recovery and that of your lady wife! As a yachtsman and as a devoted reader of Patric O'Brien and Alexander Kent novels, I got a great deal out of your description of the maneuvering and efforts to survive the lee shore. I was heartened to hear of the honor and gallantry of the French in their efforts to rescue their prisoners. I am not French, but given the moral squalor of so many in the world, courage combined with decency is heartening for me as a human being.
Get well soon Drach. I have had two shots here in Texas and never had even the slightest reaction. Echoing others, you and spouse health first. We the crew can wait.
Imagine a Drachinifel/Felton coproduction of a key sea/land episode in history.
How is it that basically any time someone wants to wage war during winter, it’s always “the coldest in living memory”?
Or is that just me?
Murphy's Law is apparently a real thing.
When its in summer its also always the hottest in living memory
tbf the period in question actually was one of the coldest in recorded history because of a freek global cooling event that they're still working out what caused it
They should really aim for those mild winters.
Desert Storm vet here. True fact: it rains in eastern Saudi where we were it rains once about every 10 years. Yup, we got rained on. Went to the desert and had to deal with heat, cold (it was winter) sand dust and mud!
I like how "knocked for 6" had a seamless alternative analogy for the benifit of non-cricket types...
Just a suggestion. I started reading Patrick O'Brien's Master and Commander series a few years back. It's a wonderfully entertaining introduction to the Age of Sail, but one which also opens one's eyes to just how technical a sailing ship is. There's a ton of jargon and concepts that are discussed quite casually but which do require some explanation to fully understand. This description of the battle with the Droits de L'Homme suffers from some of the same. What I would suggest is a short overlay when you use technical terms the first time to show what they are. For example, what's a mizzen mast? A yard arm? A top sail, etc? Overlay a small graphic showing the part of the ship, or a short text definition. It doesn't need to be long. The interested user can pause to read it. This way you still maintain the pace of your story telling and the visual focus on the artwork, but it does allow the non-sailor to approach the topic a little easier. Another option would be to link to a good source for that sort of thing in the description.
Excellent story-telling! Sometimes it's very difficult for the modern listener to really comprehend what fighting such a battle would have been like, and why this action was both heroic and lucky for the two British ships.
I felt like I was listening to a Hornblower adventure.
Thank you and hope you are feeling better!
JEEZ!! What an Unmitigated Cluster Fudge - Thanks for the harrowing tale
I am sorry that you had such a difficult time with the Covid inoculations but bodily responses vary widely. My wife and I went through both inoculations symptom-free except for the ache common to all intermuscular injections.
Seaward though, my maternal grandfather was amongst the last of those who went to sea in commercial sailing ships. ( i am 76). He was shipwrecked twice. The first time on a coral reef offshore from Java- neither man nor cargo lost.
The second was of an entirely different sort. The ship was caught in a brutal storm, perhaps a hurricane, my grandfather, third mate and ship's carpenter, was at his station distributing tools and giving instructions. Above deck, lines were breaking and the topsail of the mainmast was unfurled and its lines snapped somewhere above the deck. A young man was ordered to ascend the mast and free the sail to reduce the pressure on the mast. He never got there having been lashed to the mast by other free lines.
Shortly, my grandfather heard the ship groan and placed his finger in some of the holes provided for the tools. Then the ship parted from the mainmast on both sides, leaving the young man and my grandfather alone at opposite ends of the mainmast.
They came ashore, exhausted, on a beach and were found by some children and soon the whole village came and freed them from the mast. Like those British sailors in the above story, they had no idea as to where they were. They had no ability to understand the language they were speaking and my grandfather who knew almost every port from the Levant to the arctic Norway of his birth and had never heard anything closely like the language they spoke.
After a day or so, the young man remembered that my grandfather spoke English and he thought that some words in English might help if one of the people in the village recognized it. After a few sentences in English, the man who seemed to be the one in authority sent off a boy who did not return until two days later, coming with a representative of the government in Tipperary. The British government got them back to Norway where they found out that they were the only survivors, saved by poor Gaelic speakers from southwest Ireland.
We appreciate you take a day off now and then so you last longer (and give us more content over all).
"L'attaque", not "l'attaqué". Pronounced more or less the same as in English, with two syllables. Still a very entertaining video, of course. :)
I blame my Spanish for thinking o can read French :D
@@Drachinifel You may also have heard "Attaquez!" (let us attack!), which _is_ pronounced with three syllables. :)
merci! ;)
@@Drachinifel You can use the speaker icon in google translate to know what a word sounds like in another language.
@@adrien5834 true, although I've noticed it does get it wrong a fair bit in the foreign languages I can speak :)
Greetings Sir! Been listening to you for a time now.. Am so fascinated by the amt. Of your information on the many many subjects. i believe you made it your life's work from an early age. From the very first coming across your Site , i've been Hooked ever since.. Thank-you and Most Respectfully !! RDK.
I know I'm almost a year late with this, but please, for the love of God, take breaks whenever you damn well please! You do not owe us ANYTHING. Neither an apology nor an explanation. You make these amazing videos for us to enjoy and we should all just be grateful you do this at all.
Good luck and God bless both you and Mrs. Drach.
Well, that was a stirring account! Listened to at midnight, from Riverside, California March 2021. Well done, sir! Now, to get a cup of tea.
“Give me a tall ship …” *and* a crew of jolly, Jack Tars!
You are entitled to time out and thanks for posting - you are part of my binge viewing during lockdown. Stay safe and well.
Congratiulantis hope you and miss Drach are well and are staying save.
To deliberately misquote Patrick O'Brian, (and to quote his source William Falconer),
Then, too severely taught by cruel fate,
To share in all the perils I relate,
Then might I, with unrivall'd strains, deplore
The impervious horrors of a leeward shore.
One of the hardest things about being a RUclipsr is being able to be comfortable taking a break. But just like a regular job you deserve vacations.
Whether for you that means trying to get several shorter videos in a hopper so you don’t miss posting, or you just miss posting some. Please take some time for yourself.
As an avid body-surfer, I can attest to the power of NON-storm-driven waves.
Hi. I'd love a Rum Ration on the newsreel footage that makes up your intro. Would love to see more of this footage, and I'm sure you'll have something interesting to say on the political reasons the First Sea Lords put newsreel camera crews on their ships, etc. Were there subtleties behind which ships got coverage, and when?
The aerial footage is of the High Seas Fleet as they sailed to internment. One of my favourite bits of footage ever - filmed from a British airship I believe.
Outstanding as usual
Congats on getting the Vac! I was down for a couple of days after the first one myself. The second went much smoother.
Sounds yummy
Glad to hear that Drach got his COVID-19 vaccine ... sorry to hear it laid you low for the weekend
Monument overlooking the shore is appropriate and thought provoking. Interesting design.
Glad you and the Mrs. got your needles. Good health and best wishes.
A day spent in a good cause is not lost. Stay healthy and keep your family safe!
YAAAAYYYY story time with Uncle Drach is always the best kind of episode!
Very good, I enjoyed this as much as a regular Video of the Line. Thank you working this up.
As a French speaking a decent English, the hardest is in fact hearing an English saying a French word. When you said "Les droits de l'homme" it took me several minutes to figure it out. But if you had said "the rights of man" I would've understood on the fly. It's not just you though.
Just wanted to share that thought. Great video as usual 👍
Can't understand a word of that. Speak English
fantastic audio. just lovely. so often overlooked.
Thanks for your efforts.
Good health to you and Mrs Drach
the Lanchester equations, although not known by that name at the time, show why frigates would not engage ships of the line.
The second one hit me hard. Hopefully it goes smoother for you.
Interesting story; sounds like the weather was as much an adversary as the actual adversaries. Also, I'm glad to hear I wasn't unusual in getting walloped by a Covid-19 shot (though the second shot wasn't so bad ~ after I knew from experience to get plenty of rest, drink water and avoid eating anything too heavy).
Dude, you do 5 hour(!) live streams, no need to ever apologize for taking a break.
Indefatigable, adj. Persisting tirelessly.
New word.
Good to have you back from “leave”.😀
I came accross an account of this engagement and the following disaster in admiralty records at a university library, tomes and tomes of contemporary accounts of engagements at sea!
That was really exceptional. That book is on my wishlist now. Thanks for sharing. :)
Thank you, Drachinifel.
I can’t think of a more lunatic idea than to plan a landing on the Wild West coast of Ireland facing Atlantic fowl winter weather.
Am I a bad guy for imagining Ioan Gruffudd as Hornblower tumbling and rolling over the deck until he hits the railings. Then struggling to get up again, only to fall over again and tumble to the other end of the deck, throughout the entire engagement?
And every time he hits one side, a fellow crewman hands him a loaded gun, which he fires at the enemy before handing it back and rolling off again.
I had the Pfizer on Thursday - zero side effects. Mum (91yo) had the AZ with similar result.
Sister had the AZ yesterday & can't stay awake!
So much for genetics. 😁
Anyway, thanks for making the effort to get this latest vid uploaded.
Nice, HMS Amazon on the right in the thumbnail
no need to explain.....hope you and Mrs Drach stay safe and healthy
Ok...maybe one of your best. Just finished your Solomon Island series. The contrast is ... perfect.
Again another enjoyable Drachinfel, thanks!
good for you! Better than the hospital!
Hope Mrs Drachinfel is feeling well!
Get well soon, thanks for the history, l like hearing about these old fighting ships.
Epic story telling, Drach, great work.
Never has the phrase "Wooden ships and Iron men" been better illustrated, on both sides of a conflict.
Next week, Drach announces Microsoft as his new sponsor! /s
Glad to hear you and Mrs. Drach got the shot!