It would be worse if she wasn't a psycho that's entire existence it's only about protecting Sally from more emotional damage by very twisted ways. Like seriously. She isn't a "sane" Split personality, she's a defensive mechanism. But yeah, that's funny
@@TheShadow7771 And it did admittedly do a good job of that. There was no way to prevent us from knowing it was either a possession or DID past a certain point, so they did the best they could by convincing us it was one, and then surprising us with the other. The idea didn't surprise us, the execution did. And that was pretty fulfilling. I also quite liked the extra end. The complete flip was a nice extra treat.
I was going to be like "Well, I did guess it before him and I don't play that much" and then I remembered I watch horror gameplays and movies almost daily for decades now...
I loved that twist with Marty losing his mind and becoming overly obsessed with Sally, this is fresh and not unlike normal "yandere" trope. Very good job on devs' and writers' part
I mean, Marty was in so many time loops to the point where I’d honestly go insane as well. Plus, the game did mention some trauma that he had, so maybe the next game will give us more into :)
This is one of those comments where you laugh and go "huh, so I must be a bit insane too..." and then you move on with your day like you didn't just laugh at a new-age Frankenstein being mistaken for a rotisserie chicken.
Matry: "Man. My new girlfriend was allergic to this pendant that killed an evil spirit, has psychiatric medications in her cabinet, has this scary photo of herself that gave me the hibigibies, and looked very strange holding a knife... I wonder what's in her room she told me not to peek in." *option not available* Matry: "Huh. Why can't I open this doo-" Conscious: "I'M NOT DYING TO NATURAL SELECTION, YOU NITWIT!"
@@johndelmo1213 Bruce is in Cannibal boy and Physical exorcism, they’re part of the main series whereas this is a side case set in the same universe. Plus I think there’s some other games in the series manly hasn’t played yet.
Ok, so here are the timestamps for each loop since no one has posted it yet. 00:13 - 17:15 Ending 1: Marty didn't open the door, left the house without knowing anything. The relationship fell apart. 17:15 - 24:12 Ending 2: Marty opened the door, saw 1 picture of her dead ex, heard about Sally's tragic part, comforted her, happy ever after? 24:12 - 30:18 Ending 3: Marty saw all of her dead exes. Marty broke up with Sally, convinced by her that she might be cursed. 30:18 - 34:32 Ending 4: Marty discovered the secret stair after looking at the pictures, got stabbed before he could get down. 34:32 - 38:08 Ending 5: Marty went to the basement without looking at pictures, saw the corpse, tried to flee, got stabbed, licked, and beheaded. 38:08 - 45:30 Ending 6: Marty successfully fled after thinking Sally and Seira are different beings, went to the police to report letting Seira escape, lived in fear, and was last seen seeing Seira in front of his house. 45:30 - 54:25 Ending 7: Marty confronted Seira to protect Sally, beat her to death, couldn't find Sally, went insane after being caught by the police. 54:25 - 1:06:42 Ending 8: Marty learned of Sally's split personality that was Seira. She stabbed herself to save him. Marty survived but went insane. 1:06:42 - 1:22:33 Ending 9: Marty reconciled with Sally. Sally wanted to confess and went to jail. 1:23:03 - 1:29:14 Ending 10: Marty remembered all the previous loops, went absolutely yandere for Sally. Happy forever after?
Hey dude, who's Seira? You mean that Sally has twin sister that yandere girl tried to kill Marty because she can recreate her ex-boyfriend, John when she was after Marty's head for re-create him? Whoa, I didn't see coming that.😮
Ok, this developer is just great at going from suspense to comedy at the drop of a hat. The fact the game specifically called out that Sally stabbed Marty "a little bit" after that comment in ending 9 instead of Siera was just pure comic gold.
They did a pretty good job with the random bits of comedy not ruining the story. I guess some silly shit would inevitably happen in tense situations if they stretch on long enough.
Nope. in RESIDENT EVIL video game you cannot leave the way you came in. ALONE IN THE DARK video game is even worse, the game punishes you with a Game Over for leaving before "cleaning the house" (The MC will be killed by some Outerworld creatures)
He also then tries to go as deep as possible in the "secrets" even though he knows the deeper he goes the worse it gets. So it's more of a 50/50 chance.
It's refreshing to see Yandere girlfriend is actually afraid of her boyfriend... It would be even more interesting to see not only Sally, but Seira is afraid of him.
This talisman protects you from evil, I GUARANTEE you it works. Girlfriend touches the talisman, feels sick Oooook... that is... not a good sign, isn't it?
I like how the plot twist was just us going a full circle and passing the player POV now to Sally lmao. Marty took acting crazier quite too literally to the point that he had helped Sally moved forward in exchange for his own sanity. These two are literally two peas in a pod for sure lol, but hey looks like in Case 03, Marty will be part of the story.
I love the break of form with the twist of Marty going crazy instead of ether dying or being a idiot throughout, it’s way more fun seeing him go off the deep end WITH Sally rather then a binary good or bad end it felt fresh and I hope you play case three because man I want more of our favorite crazy ass yandere couple
Hi, I'm Sounding Stone, the developer of Extra Case: My Girlfriend's Secrets. Thank Manly so much for playing it and reviewing the Physical Exorcism Series. After reading some comments, I realized that this game should have been better. I will be more careful about sensitive issues in the next game. 29 Sep, 2022: Ｗe took the players' feedback seriously and have removed or replaced sensitive terms and modified some lines to avoid exacerbating the stigmatization of specific groups.
This is the first time I've seen one of your games, and I have to say that I'm amazed by how well-polished and written it is. Keep up the good work! I wasn't put off by any your portrayals of sensitive issues here myself, but best of luck to you in your use of them in future games!
i really appreciate you seriously listening to the feedback about how mental illness was portrayed. i know mental illness has been used as a horror trope often in the past, though i think you have done more research than most have in the past. i am excited to see what you will do in the future!
What an absolutely amazing game dude. The build, storyline, and the way you connected the split personality of Sally was so crisp. And the ending, the title drop in reverse; my Boyfriends Secrets. Just amazing. Again, amazing game, cant wait for case 03 :)
When Manly referenced how it is within the same universe as Cannibal Boy, I knew that the world poor Marty is in is full of abnormal crazy people. Please everyone, stay safe and make sure to carry a weapon with you outside of your house to give you a fighting chance against your attackers.
When Bruce told Marty to 'act even crazier' I honestly thought that he was going to pretend to be John with the alter's talk of John hiding in Marty's body and all
Tho the risk of that is that the kind of temporary persona you gotta build to do that, will eventually corrupt you, the 10th ending is pretty much what happens when a higher value person has to lower his standards for a low value Yandere, in terms of violence and crimes, Daredevil did this outrageously well with Kingpin´s love interest and how she became more and more detached from good and wanted to involve herself more with Kingpin´s evil stuff on the later seasons, much to his disconfort as he didnt want (just like Sally here) to let his line of corrupted crimes take away from his wife´s innocence
@@sebas8225 I disagree, its not corrupting if you dont let it be. Remember that you are always in control and make the lines you will never cross clear and all will be good.
"Here is a real talisman that wards off evil" "Oh I can't take that it makes me sick. Also bee tee dubs, never go in my room ever, ok!" Red Flag: The Game.
Man Why can't these people have a happy ending? Although Marty's slow descent into madness was done really well, it makes total sense that the time loops would inevitably make him snap and become a yandere. But I do still hope that he snaps the fuck out of it and they get an actual actual happily ever after. Knowing this dev though, the best we can get is 2 minutes of resolution before getting thrown into more yandere fun times. Oh well lmao.
Marty would have remained in the Normal Ending and lived as a relatively normal person, had not Nya entertained his whimsical wishes. Will Marty be able to keep his "happily ever after" with Sally? Only the next game(s) can tell.
So I just googled the suspension bridge effect, and (about 5 minutes into the game, admittedly), I think that's really telling. It's proper name is "the misattribution of arousal" and it's our brain's tendency to confuse the physiological sensations of fear with those of romantic or sexual attraction.
makes sense. I remember watching a cinema therapy episode and the therapist said that extreme anger and terror are also states of arousal and that the critical thinking center gets shut off basically
Oh, interesting! I assumed it was based on those experiments where any adrenaline-inducing activity would cause people to rate the attractiveness of their potential romantic partners higher than non-adrenaline-inducing activities -- people would unconsciously attribute part of their excitement to their potential romantic partner rather than to the activity. I'm sure that similar experiments and the suspension bridge effect are related, but the fact that the suspension bridge effect is based on FEAR specifically does a great job underlining themes in the game. Thanks for taking the time to share your comment!
BTW, it seems that Sally & Seira are *mirror twins.* It's a type of identical twin where instead of being exact duplicates, it's like they're mirror-images of each other. So one is left-handed, the other is right-handed, and if one had a mole by her left eye, the other would have that same mole by her _right_ eye, and so on.
I can't stress enough how I absolutely, *ABSOLUTELY LOVE* the extra ending. The idea of a psycho and a yandere being in love with each other has always been a dynamic I could ever only dreamt of. It just sounds like it'd be so damn chaotic and one hell of an emotional roller coaster compared to the typical normal - yandere dynamic, and it saddens me that not a lot of people really ever tried to write a story with this dynamic. I just wanna see both sides suffer and got wrecked to pieces by both their partner and themselves. The crazier it gets the better
The "Cannibal Boy" universe is slowly starting to become one of my favorite indie horror series. That dev knows what he's doing! Hope more cases get released.
Ayyy more yandere stuff! Btw, Manly, you could totally make a playlist of some of the yandere games you played so we could binge. Been trying to find all of them, but it's definitely hard finding them
For people confused about the context and backstory of this, this game is the latest in the Physical Exorcism series of RPG Maker games - Physical Exorcism: Case 01, Loser Reborn, Case 00: The Cannibal Boy, Case 02: Paranormal Evil, and finally this game Extra Case: My Girlfriend's Secrets. As Manly says, they all share the same universe. Bruce is the main character of Case 00 and 01, and a side character of Case 02. Marty is the main character of Loser Reborn, Case 02 and this one. Nya is from Loser Reborn, while Marty first met Sally in Case 02.
Wait, so basically Sally developed a split personality from trauma, connected to her family and now one of the personalities is a loveable goofball, behind which the second personality, a murderous psychopath, hides.... That's no horror game, that's just Diavolo Plot twist: the entire game is a JoJo reference
@@geneticion9158 It's the titular character of an RPG-maker game series Manly played awhile back. The playthrough is somewhere on his "recommended playlist" if you're curious. Fair warning though; if you're squemish with (cartoon) blood, creepy eyes, and "implied" SA.
@@cilcipher tbh i never finished manly's wadanohara playthroughs. i intended to, but at the time i just didn't have it in me. maybe sometime in the future i'll go back and actually watch it all again.
This dude has officially become my favorite comfort RUclipsr. I love horror games I love watching play through a an on top of that he’s not loud and obnoxious is voice is rather southing
DUDE I LOVE THIS! The psychology is compelling. The way Marty stew, which is literally the name of a boy mary sue, slowly goes insane due to the plot and the repeated loops and becomes the villain is super cool. They took the stupid trope and then used it for such an ending is beautiful.
This was quite the rollercoaster from start to finish. After some of those bad endings, I was certain I had the full story but it just kept adding twists and thankfully didn't squander what was enjoyable in the process. This world the developer has made is real weird but I do like it.
@@maxwell8540 damn, after this video i think im gonna watch the other games of this dev and understand better this world, it will be pretty interesting to see
It´s kinda funny the reaction reminds me of Kingpin in Daredevil´s reaction to having his wife asking and acting with no regard to his crimes, he didnt like it very much case it took away from her innocence when they were starting out their relationship, guess Sally too, will have to live with the fact she corrupted her boyfriend
Another thing that I love about this is that the boy, Marty was actually able to kill the Yandere, Seira (actually Sally's alter) on a melee physical combat, it was very satisfying in my opinion. 51:03 just because the girl is a yandere and smiles creepily with a kitchen knife, doesn't mean she is overpowered and always overpowers her victims. I love seeing the victim actual won for once. Many anime writers made yanderes too strong, it is getting bland.
Agreed, unless the Yandere character is some kind of powerful being in the universe they inhabit in, many of them are just *ordinary* human girls with a few screws loosen, dunno why anime tends to make them so goddamn OP. Being a nutcase doesn't correlate with excellent fighting capabilities. Am I really supposed to believe Yandere GIRLS can easily physically overpower their MALE victims most of the time? lol Such Mary Sue wish fulfillments for females who are prone to jealousy in relationships.
Eh...it's not a special thing since the victim usually overpowers the killer at the end of the story all the time, and yanderes in a bunch of horror games just get killed by the protag a lot at the end or in one of the endings at least so a don't think this rare or something
@@loremipsum980 most people who write female yanderes are men. Them being op isn't for female empowerment, it's for the kink and horror aspect. What are you even going on about?
Yes!!! Usually those games at least imply that humans are the real monsters but weren't the victims that almost all the time can't even put a fight also humans? Why are they killed so easily by someone that have no training in fighting, isn't even fit and most often have the biological disadvantage? I get that even a person like that will be dangerous with an adrenaline boost but this is just ridiculous. And, in the cases where they know is coming, what about the adrenaline response of the victims?
@@user-uq9oe7sc5m i'am not talking about any specific horror game it just comes to mind since it happens a lot in the end of a movie when the protag wins like Alien, some movies of the Friday 13th, Halloween, and some others games that Manly has played usually has some ending where you kill the murderer
As a left-handed person, that random question about Sally being left-handed amused me. It took 5 years for my friend to realize I'm left-handed. It's a big shocker to a lot of righties. 🤷♀️
29:06 "If something happened to me, you'd blame yourself to death. Even if that chance is less than 1%..." Marty is the living embodiment of the 'The risk I took was calculated, but man, am I bad at math' meme. 😂
I really like these kind of games Manly plays. They start like "oh it's so predictable", but then when you indulge deeper you can see a different story, actually well-built. I can see the best games of these kind just follow the same formula, they all have a really predictable start, multiple knots getting complex as they pass and then a finale that actually makes you understand the story completely. I have seen many of the novels I have read start or end in ambiguity, actually leaving everything in your hands so you can say "oh so this is what it meant". I think the best of these are the ones that both start and end in ambiguity, leaving everything in your hands and literally pulling you into the story. Congratulations to the devs, I am happy you knew how to blow the mind of a dumb man like me, despite how cringe this would sound.
So you’re finally awake *You were trying to open your girlfriend’s secrets weren’t you?* Don’t even bother trying to get up dude *she has us both locked in the basement or quite possibly a sex dungeon*
I could imagen the boyfriend seeing horror movies and is just mentally pleading in his mind please let it be a sex dungeon and not what I think it's going to be. So he just sees the gf lock the door with only them 2 in the basement he just tells her please tell me you locked us in a sex dungeon. While she's just genuinely laughing from the unexpectedness and says "haha, you wish". So he says "damn well i seen too many horror movies so I thought I'd just give it a shot." When she hears that answer you can hear her going hmm like she's honestly debating on it. So you just imagen the guy mimicking quagmire's thumbs up.
i think it was just because the title of the ending completed the phrase ("Sally and I would live- Happily ever after?"), as it happened with other ending. I found it funny that manly noticed this in the other ending but not in ending 2.
I wonder if those sleeping pills are actually anti-psychotics? I'm on anti-psychotics and they have the side effect of making you super drowsy, they're actually sometimes prescribed for that very side effect since it's very common. Still only 6 minutes into the video though so I'll wait and see Edit: Well I certainly hope those are anti-psychotics
@@adamsalik7389 i may not know what anti-psychotics are for, but i (think i) know they're for helping certain group of people. like those antidepressants and melatonin candies my sister usually takes edit: said anti-depression instead of antidepressants
The whole 'cursed to have their husbands die' reminds me of a movie I saw as a kid, where this family of witches I think were cursed with the exact same thing, it was a good movie overall, can't remember the title tho But damn. All those red flags that you could build a bridge between the earth and pluto, and Marty sees almost none of em until a few replays lol...
90% of this game is also the movie 'So I Married an Axe-Murderer.' except M. Night Shallamallamadingdong shows up after that 90% part to blame it all on a vulnerable demographic.
That curse when I first heard that in this game completely reminded me of ayumi shinozaki from corpse party tortured souls game because that sounds like a dead ringer for her curse.
Game: mostly normal, no sign of horror so far Manly: I thought this was gonna be about organ harvesting or whatever but I guess I was wrong Game: yeah, about that
21:33 "Even now, I have dreams where I'm trying to find his missing arms and legs." Ah. I see where this is going... Makes dolls, has dreams about stitching her dead ex back together, dead ex looks an awful lot like the MC. Really it's just a question of whether or not she's going the full necromancy route. Really glad this wasn't another cannibalism game. Or at least doesn't seem to be one *yet.* Not-cannibalism is almost a twist itself, given the trend.
Debating whether I am disappointed that there is no 'good ending' where the necromancy is successful and he actually comes back to life. Same for a 'good ending' where she gets him transhumanist enhancements for the rest of his body parts and he becomes the most beautiful and powerful boy in the world.
@Grima the Fell Dragon Never watched the second one, but FMA did not have the benefit of being able to locate and identify the spirit of the deceased in order to bind it to the flesh golem directly. FMA had the benefit of quick manufacturing, but no direct, clear line, to the spirit world, making it a worse place to try to bring back the dead. The paranormal cosmology of those worlds were very very different from this one. Those examples, while much higher quality, are about as relevant as pet cemetery.
"OH MY GOD YOU OPENED YOUR EYES!" thank you for that good laugh. i feel that can be said used many times for some characters. love your vids manly. il be trying to catch up on alot of stuff i missed cause i always forget i love watching your vids somehow... plus always loved your reaction to bunnies. "bun"
SPOILER BELOW: I love that they actually (on purpose or not) have the left side of her face associated with her right-hand and vice-versa. Not many people think of that little detail.
I actually prefer the extra ending storytelling wise and I kinda wish that was the Canan ending. From my perspective it just seems a lot for interesting it feels like how it would naturally end. Especially with him gaining the memories from all the time loops for that ending in a satisfying way. Is that just me?
SPOILERS . .. … …. ….. …… ……. I love how the extra ending turns the whole game upside down where it’s no longer “my girlfriend’s secrets” but “my boyfriend’s secrets”! Also, I really believe that Marty *IS* John. There are a lot of signs pointing to it, especially the fact that he is nearly identical to John to the point both himself and Sally mistake him for John at times. He also seems to act a lot like John. Sally is without many of her memories from the accident and Marty also is suffering from amnesia (which is a point not often touched upon other than to explain Marty’s obsessive attachment to Sally). The fact that Marty also mentions he feels he’s known Sally longer than Sally has known him is a point to be made about Nya’s time rewinding powers, which has come in handy with every event Marty regretted. It’s entirely possible that the first time Nya rewound time for Marty was not after ending 1, but rather at the beginning of the game.
I thought that too when I read the line about how he feels like he's known her for longer than he did, but then you have to connect the dots about the people in the car. Marty was John, His friend was either Sally or Seira (could've thought she died but she made it and they both forgot) but what about the rest of his family? And the sister? Also John is officially dead so he can't be John with amnesia. Maybe he haunts Marty? How would they know each other? And it couldn't impact Marty's appearance... Plus, then John would need to be another person in the car and there was only one friend... Or John was Marty's brother? That'd explain their ressemblance, but wouldn't prove they were in the same car crash. And if Sally dated John for 5 years, she'd know if he had a brother... I think that's just a coincidence. Feels like everything is a dead end here.
there's actually 2 sets of main characters for the series: you have the cases (cannibal boy, etc.) then there's Loser reborn where Marty comes from that leads directly to Case 02 where you meet Sally, which then leads to this one.
Im back after 1 year. I forgot about this channel and i recalled last week whats this channel's name, my guesses were "Oddlyhandsomeman" "Handsomeoddman" i searched "horror games" and kept on scrolling 'til i find a familiar channel. It was manlybadasshero! Glad to be back, your videos are my past of time. Glad you doing well too!!!
This actually happened to me too except i typed 'batmanhandsomehero' . I couldn't find it though but a video of manly suddenly popped up on my fb so yeah glad to found it back. (Sorry for bad english)
I really like the meta way the protagonist rejected the "good" ending and went for something completely different. A linear multi-ending game where you still have the choice to stop after getting the "good" ending or go beyond and see the true extent of what the protagonist is capable of. It's a genuinely interesting take.
the frankenstein'ed boyfriend part of the story would've been so interesting without the "she's mentally ill with a crazy murderous alter" tacked onto it 😮💨
I agree, the game is good and Manly's playthrough is great as always, but the game's take on dissociative annesia and split personality disorder feels sadly like unjustified bad rep for mentally ill people.
That's exactly what I thought as well. Even aside from the stereotypes on display here, it's just completely unnecessary and undermines the rest of the story.
@@opinionatortv6457 No, the game clearly establishes it's DID and not spirit possession, and as much as I generally like the story the criticisms levied at using that trope are valid.
@@opinionatortv6457 It's not. Watch the Extra Ending again. It explains that the talisman didn't work because Seira isn't an evil spirit. She's an alter Sally made based off of Seira and her supposed hatred of Sally and love of John.
Marty: Look, I don't even mind that Sally killed a couple of guys. Why would I care about her virginity? Me: Only a true *sigma* would say such wise words.
Fun fact: Nazar beads are effectively Super Mushrooms from Mario. They will shatter after warding off evil successfully, after which they will be _useeeeelesssss_ and you will need another. Like how you can withstand one killing blow when Mario is big. :D
_"OoooOoooOoo I'm not gonna let you gOoooOoooOoo"_ _Spoilers_ Ending #3 Pretend happiness was my favorite ending. I always like the bittersweet ones. Besides, it featured MBH's ghostly wail lol. I liked that movie Ghost... so romantic and sad. As for the others, I'd be creeped out to find a photo of me in a guy's room that I didn't remember posing for. The idea of a stalker is all too real and frightening for many people irl. Honestly MBH has watched so many anime, he can guess these plots a mile away lol! This was a bit more twisty than I expected, more sad. I liked the escalation of the plot endings to ghost, to the alter. Best ever movie that immediately came to mind with ghost/question about what happened was A Tale of Two Sisters. I saw it and never forgot it, but I won't spoil it here. The moral of the story: If you have precognitive dreams, don't go down to anyone's basement and forget a night-time reward including cookies. Just leave.
To be fair, he has total amnesia, and she was immediately nice to him, it would have been very reasonable for them to have been friends before he remembers them meeting for the first time. Should I watch that movie?
@@eloujtimereaver4504 I didn't see your reply in my notifications, so apologies for not responding sooner! Yes, it is a great Korean horror movie. It theoretically is a ghost story, but it is much more complicated. Definite must see. :)
Bro this game was amazing it helped me get through many of the inner conflicts i had and answered many questions i never though about but should have now because of you and this game i got a realisation that i should explore this domain of phycological horror stuff and thanks you earned a subscriber
This games portrayal if systems and DID is at least a *little* better than most, with using the right terms and explaining things mostly correctly. But the bar is still on the floor and they still fall into a lot of pitfalls, like only 1 alter and said alter being a murderous yandere. There's a lot more but god don't have the energy to. I still enjoyed watching the game in the background tho like any Manly vid lol.
I love that it closes out with the roles totally reversed. I really enjoyed this! Love loop stories, creepy yandere (but not really) stories, etc, etc.
What I like about this game it that the plot leads you to 1 conclusion, but then in the next “run” it shows something completely different making you come up with a whole new theory, who found most of the plot on 2 minutes lol
Cool story but I really wish that there had been actual choices to lead to the different endings instead of everything being on rails. At this point it isn't even a VN, much less a game. This is effectively just a cartoon narrated by Manly. Instead of having the endings be sequential, just have them be whatever is interacted with in her room first. It wouldn't be that hard.
I call this game: God You Two Need Couples' Therapy: Red flags and unhealthy dynamics! Lmao Great game! I really liked it. Feel like the guy became a little too crazy at the end. I mean I get that they're both meant to be crazy but the ending just felt kinda exaggerated or something. Idk how to describe it but other than that it was really good. I actually really liked all the twists and turns. Really good game!
I'm so glad that I found this channel because I enjoy watching horror games gameplay but the streamers/youtubers I watch doesn't mainly make horror games videos 😊
Marty: These photos, why are they of the same old business man. But when I pick them up, they look like a boyband? Sally: ... *Door breaks open* Marty: DOC? Doc Brown: It's time to go Marty! Back to the Future >>>>>>> *queue theme music* Abnormal Ending 1
Welcome to the What Are You Hiding? Club, how What Are You Hiding? are ya?
I ain't hiding anything.....
Also I'm fine ty
I’m hiding everything :)
My emotions
I’m hiding my toes
*I'm hiding your Soul Manly Kun.*
Imagine telling your girlfriends split personality to stop being a third wheel.
It would be worse if she wasn't a psycho that's entire existence it's only about protecting Sally from more emotional damage by very twisted ways.
Like seriously. She isn't a "sane" Split personality, she's a defensive mechanism.
But yeah, that's funny
That is honestly the hottest thing I have ever heard. Next level NTR.
@@MYCUNNYsob why...?
@@MYCUNNYsob no...
@@MYCUNNYsob honestly the split personality would be more terrified of you then you are of it.
Man I swear Manly has played so many horror games at this point he knows the entire plot after playing for 2 minutes lol
That’s just a fancy way of saying “All horror games are the same”
agreed
Well this one tried its level best to prevent that
@@TheShadow7771 And it did admittedly do a good job of that. There was no way to prevent us from knowing it was either a possession or DID past a certain point, so they did the best they could by convincing us it was one, and then surprising us with the other. The idea didn't surprise us, the execution did. And that was pretty fulfilling.
I also quite liked the extra end. The complete flip was a nice extra treat.
I was going to be like "Well, I did guess it before him and I don't play that much" and then I remembered I watch horror gameplays and movies almost daily for decades now...
Marty: My girlfriend is hiding some terrifying secret from me!
Also Marty: I'm gonna do what's called a pro-gamer move.
*proceeds to make himself killed several times.
Save scumming is a pro gamer move
ManlyBadassHero activates Bites the Dust.
Killer hero switch to third bomb bites the badass
Saves game*
I loved that twist with Marty losing his mind and becoming overly obsessed with Sally, this is fresh and not unlike normal "yandere" trope. Very good job on devs' and writers' part
Marty is cultured.
She turned him into Yandere
Yeh
A yandere plot twist where two people who do not realize they are yandere fall in love and one ends up out yandere-ing the other yandere
I mean, Marty was in so many time loops to the point where I’d honestly go insane as well. Plus, the game did mention some trauma that he had, so maybe the next game will give us more into :)
The corpse in the basement being so fucking tiny sent me into hysterical laughter. I thought it was a rotisserie chicken lmfao
This comment out of context gives me emotional whiplash
@@hyperion3145fr I snorted way too hard after reading this
This is one of those comments where you laugh and go "huh, so I must be a bit insane too..." and then you move on with your day like you didn't just laugh at a new-age Frankenstein being mistaken for a rotisserie chicken.
But after considering the characters size it seems normal
This comment made me laugh
Matry: "Man. My new girlfriend was allergic to this pendant that killed an evil spirit, has psychiatric medications in her cabinet, has this scary photo of herself that gave me the hibigibies, and looked very strange holding a knife... I wonder what's in her room she told me not to peek in."
*option not available*
Matry: "Huh. Why can't I open this doo-"
Conscious: "I'M NOT DYING TO NATURAL SELECTION, YOU NITWIT!"
*Funny liked*
When you're so dumb that the brain would rebel against itself.
This games gone off the rails in the finale.
You don't know how happy it makes me to know that someone else still uses nitwit other than me!
Asian parent's be like: " You allergic to pendant I allergic to allergic people "
Game: *ending 1 out of 10*
Manly: *sits up in his chair*
Me: *clearing my schedule for the next 2 hours*
yea I can imagine him went "oh boy, here we go" :D
unfortunately the game is just on rails, so kinda boring unless you like that sorta un-engaging thing.
@@JoanLamrack You can hear it in his voice lol
Oh shit, didn't even check how long the video was. Jesus Christ, time to get cozy I guess...
@@RottenHeretic i really loved it tho maybe because i was watching at 3am and it helped me a lot with some inner struggles of my ideology
Bruce: "you just have to act crazier than them"
Marty: ...yeaahhhh "aaact" gooootcha
_"I'm about to do what's called a 'pro gamer move.'"_
@@aegisScale Dude acrobatic fucking periutes into a murder accomplice
Can I ask if bruce was in another game? I wish to watch it. If not, what was the title of what manly is saying about game in similar verse. Tnx
@@johndelmo1213 Bruce is in Cannibal boy and Physical exorcism, they’re part of the main series whereas this is a side case set in the same universe. Plus I think there’s some other games in the series manly hasn’t played yet.
BRO U MISPRONOUNCED "Bruce wayne" ☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️
Ok, so here are the timestamps for each loop since no one has posted it yet.
00:13 - 17:15 Ending 1: Marty didn't open the door, left the house without knowing anything. The relationship fell apart.
17:15 - 24:12 Ending 2: Marty opened the door, saw 1 picture of her dead ex, heard about Sally's tragic part, comforted her, happy ever after?
24:12 - 30:18 Ending 3: Marty saw all of her dead exes. Marty broke up with Sally, convinced by her that she might be cursed.
30:18 - 34:32 Ending 4: Marty discovered the secret stair after looking at the pictures, got stabbed before he could get down.
34:32 - 38:08 Ending 5: Marty went to the basement without looking at pictures, saw the corpse, tried to flee, got stabbed, licked, and beheaded.
38:08 - 45:30 Ending 6: Marty successfully fled after thinking Sally and Seira are different beings, went to the police to report letting Seira escape, lived in fear, and was last seen seeing Seira in front of his house.
45:30 - 54:25 Ending 7: Marty confronted Seira to protect Sally, beat her to death, couldn't find Sally, went insane after being caught by the police.
54:25 - 1:06:42 Ending 8: Marty learned of Sally's split personality that was Seira. She stabbed herself to save him. Marty survived but went insane.
1:06:42 - 1:22:33 Ending 9: Marty reconciled with Sally. Sally wanted to confess and went to jail.
1:23:03 - 1:29:14 Ending 10: Marty remembered all the previous loops, went absolutely yandere for Sally. Happy forever after?
Thanks
Hey dude, who's Seira? You mean that Sally has twin sister that yandere girl tried to kill Marty because she can recreate her ex-boyfriend, John when she was after Marty's head for re-create him? Whoa, I didn't see coming that.😮
Thank u so much for this
With all the endings u kinda get lost in them
Ok, this developer is just great at going from suspense to comedy at the drop of a hat. The fact the game specifically called out that Sally stabbed Marty "a little bit" after that comment in ending 9 instead of Siera was just pure comic gold.
They did a pretty good job with the random bits of comedy not ruining the story. I guess some silly shit would inevitably happen in tense situations if they stretch on long enough.
I love how when ever there is a chance to immediately leave when the game starts manly goes right to the door hes a man who'd survive a horror game
Absolutely, *but would you really dare to ditch* **Sally and Seira** ?
@@dr.skillz77mgpl92 Yeah, how could Marty protect Sally's smile if he runs away?
To me, thats the point of the channel. Nothing phases that guy, he's a manly baddass hero
Nope. in RESIDENT EVIL video game you cannot leave the way you came in.
ALONE IN THE DARK video game is even worse, the game punishes you with a Game Over for leaving before "cleaning the house" (The MC will be killed by some Outerworld creatures)
He also then tries to go as deep as possible in the "secrets" even though he knows the deeper he goes the worse it gets. So it's more of a 50/50 chance.
It's refreshing to see Yandere girlfriend is actually afraid of her boyfriend... It would be even more interesting to see not only Sally, but Seira is afraid of him.
nah
Not really
@@Uwhwvwgwh Ah yes. _The Negotiater_
@@TabbyCatq I mean no
@@Uwhwvwgwh "Ah no, the negotiater"?
This talisman protects you from evil, I GUARANTEE you it works.
Girlfriend touches the talisman, feels sick
Oooook... that is... not a good sign, isn't it?
It's fiiiine
nothing to worry about
*Something's Wrong . . .*
@@aegisScale nahhhh fam nothing strange here
I still don't understand why she got sick having watched the whole thing
I like how the plot twist was just us going a full circle and passing the player POV now to Sally lmao. Marty took acting crazier quite too literally to the point that he had helped Sally moved forward in exchange for his own sanity. These two are literally two peas in a pod for sure lol, but hey looks like in Case 03, Marty will be part of the story.
The fact that manly predicted the Frankenstein thing was actually insane omg
Kek
The funny part was how quickly he got proven right after dismissing it. XD
I was listening going "manly usually has a good sixth sense about this sort of thing -he has to be way off this time"
@@angelacurtis6938his spider sense
@JN-so6wt didnt he predict that before fully reading the labels though?
I love the break of form with the twist of Marty going crazy instead of ether dying or being a idiot throughout, it’s way more fun seeing him go off the deep end WITH Sally rather then a binary good or bad end it felt fresh and I hope you play case three because man I want more of our favorite crazy ass yandere couple
I mean he stopped caring about Sally's privacy the moment he is done exploring the house, I don't think he's a generic anime protagonist.
realistically the first time he died would be enough the god just kept rewinding him till he lost his crap .
Hi, I'm Sounding Stone, the developer of Extra Case: My Girlfriend's Secrets. Thank Manly so much for playing it and reviewing the Physical Exorcism Series. After reading some comments, I realized that this game should have been better. I will be more careful about sensitive issues in the next game.
29 Sep, 2022: Ｗe took the players' feedback seriously and have removed or replaced sensitive terms and modified some lines to avoid exacerbating the stigmatization of specific groups.
I personally really liked it, the build up with the endings was great, can't wait to see more from you
This is the first time I've seen one of your games, and I have to say that I'm amazed by how well-polished and written it is. Keep up the good work! I wasn't put off by any your portrayals of sensitive issues here myself, but best of luck to you in your use of them in future games!
Love this series, can't wait for case 3. Thank you for the hard work!
i really appreciate you seriously listening to the feedback about how mental illness was portrayed. i know mental illness has been used as a horror trope often in the past, though i think you have done more research than most have in the past. i am excited to see what you will do in the future!
What an absolutely amazing game dude. The build, storyline, and the way you connected the split personality of Sally was so crisp. And the ending, the title drop in reverse; my Boyfriends Secrets. Just amazing. Again, amazing game, cant wait for case 03 :)
When Manly referenced how it is within the same universe as Cannibal Boy, I knew that the world poor Marty is in is full of abnormal crazy people. Please everyone, stay safe and make sure to carry a weapon with you outside of your house to give you a fighting chance against your attackers.
always carry pepper spray
_United States_ loves your post
@@coultersheppard2052 that's kinda like a universal code. People are just crazy
If your American don't be afraid to at least buy a gun for your home
I Like the attackers
At least someone wants to confront me
When Bruce told Marty to 'act even crazier' I honestly thought that he was going to pretend to be John with the alter's talk of John hiding in Marty's body and all
I didn’t even think of that but that’s so good now I wish they had done one ending like that.
That would have ruled!
this is one of the calmest and cutest horror game ive seen.
The "act crazier than them" thing is literally true cause ive done that to get some of the most annoying people away from me
Tho the risk of that is that the kind of temporary persona you gotta build to do that, will eventually corrupt you, the 10th ending is pretty much what happens when a higher value person has to lower his standards for a low value Yandere, in terms of violence and crimes, Daredevil did this outrageously well with Kingpin´s love interest and how she became more and more detached from good and wanted to involve herself more with Kingpin´s evil stuff on the later seasons, much to his disconfort as he didnt want (just like Sally here) to let his line of corrupted crimes take away from his wife´s innocence
Just need to focus on the Acting part, it can get to your head
@@sebas8225 I disagree, its not corrupting if you dont let it be. Remember that you are always in control and make the lines you will never cross clear and all will be good.
Marty: Time to do what i call _a pro gamer move_
@@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 sort of like addiction. Some people can just stop, without issue.
"Here is a real talisman that wards off evil"
"Oh I can't take that it makes me sick. Also bee tee dubs, never go in my room ever, ok!"
Red Flag: The Game.
Hey, hey, hey…
Perhaps ending 1 was for the best.
@@aegisScale Yes, she clearlly not fully evil since she couldnt kill him once she realized how good he was.
@@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 What do you mean?
@@jaideepshekhar4621 Im mean couldnt.
Man
Why can't these people have a happy ending?
Although Marty's slow descent into madness was done really well, it makes total sense that the time loops would inevitably make him snap and become a yandere. But I do still hope that he snaps the fuck out of it and they get an actual actual happily ever after. Knowing this dev though, the best we can get is 2 minutes of resolution before getting thrown into more yandere fun times. Oh well lmao.
Marty would have remained in the Normal Ending and lived as a relatively normal person, had not Nya entertained his whimsical wishes.
Will Marty be able to keep his "happily ever after" with Sally? Only the next game(s) can tell.
Seeing from the character description in Case 03, most probably the couple will die in the hands of the "Cannibal Boy"
And that's the fun part. :)
Good
I mean what
Happily ever after in the 1st ending .... you order in the wrong neighborhood
I love how even Sally of all people was scared or at least surprised of Marty going crazy
Kekw
“That‘s not mantal illness.That’s just a woman being a woman.“
Man this game is so realistic
my praying mantis has a mantal illness
@@NIGHTBLOODUSAGI I am a sucker for terrible jokes. So best believe I laughed at that
Not wrong
Nothing but facts.
So I just googled the suspension bridge effect, and (about 5 minutes into the game, admittedly), I think that's really telling. It's proper name is "the misattribution of arousal" and it's our brain's tendency to confuse the physiological sensations of fear with those of romantic or sexual attraction.
makes sense. I remember watching a cinema therapy episode and the therapist said that extreme anger and terror are also states of arousal and that the critical thinking center gets shut off basically
I know, I've seen Saiki K and School Rumble
Could that play into Stockholm Syndrome?
That explains a lot of things for me
Oh, interesting! I assumed it was based on those experiments where any adrenaline-inducing activity would cause people to rate the attractiveness of their potential romantic partners higher than non-adrenaline-inducing activities -- people would unconsciously attribute part of their excitement to their potential romantic partner rather than to the activity.
I'm sure that similar experiments and the suspension bridge effect are related, but the fact that the suspension bridge effect is based on FEAR specifically does a great job underlining themes in the game.
Thanks for taking the time to share your comment!
BTW, it seems that Sally & Seira are *mirror twins.* It's a type of identical twin where instead of being exact duplicates, it's like they're mirror-images of each other. So one is left-handed, the other is right-handed, and if one had a mole by her left eye, the other would have that same mole by her _right_ eye, and so on.
Well the handed-ness is not necessarily genetic, but I like this assumption. Mirror Twins are cool.
Oh that's cool!
aren't their organs also swapped in their bodies?
Wow, that's fascinating that it's a real thing.
@@Tamsi-Akisno. the chance of that is so minimal that there would never be such a person in a million years
Sally: Good boys get "rewarded" at night.
Manly: NO NO NO!
Sally: With cookies of course!
Manly: YES YES YES!
I can hear YT policy checker lurking rofl
“Reward” can mean two things-.
“With cookies of course!”
“Reward” can mean three things.
RUclips demonetization team: "Ok, false alarm"
@@Zack_Zander
1. Anime
2. Manga
3. Light novel
@@gitgud4737 4 things then
Dude, Marty just perfectly described the feeling of finding out you're a side-character.
I can't stress enough how I absolutely, *ABSOLUTELY LOVE* the extra ending. The idea of a psycho and a yandere being in love with each other has always been a dynamic I could ever only dreamt of. It just sounds like it'd be so damn chaotic and one hell of an emotional roller coaster compared to the typical normal - yandere dynamic, and it saddens me that not a lot of people really ever tried to write a story with this dynamic. I just wanna see both sides suffer and got wrecked to pieces by both their partner and themselves. The crazier it gets the better
The "Cannibal Boy" universe is slowly starting to become one of my favorite indie horror series. That dev knows what he's doing! Hope more cases get released.
Ayyy more yandere stuff! Btw, Manly, you could totally make a playlist of some of the yandere games you played so we could binge. Been trying to find all of them, but it's definitely hard finding them
I second this, I love me some yanderes.
Yandere is perfection
He has a Charon's yandere Playlist somewhere
Found the Playlist
ruclips.net/p/PLq7Wze90TsOoJzbGS_KbxmzykoavHk8pF
Chillpietoo manly
Imagine buying a talisman against evil, finding that it actually works, and proceeding to throw all of that out the window
For people confused about the context and backstory of this, this game is the latest in the Physical Exorcism series of RPG Maker games - Physical Exorcism: Case 01, Loser Reborn, Case 00: The Cannibal Boy, Case 02: Paranormal Evil, and finally this game Extra Case: My Girlfriend's Secrets. As Manly says, they all share the same universe.
Bruce is the main character of Case 00 and 01, and a side character of Case 02. Marty is the main character of Loser Reborn, Case 02 and this one. Nya is from Loser Reborn, while Marty first met Sally in Case 02.
Wait, so basically Sally developed a split personality from trauma, connected to her family and now one of the personalities is a loveable goofball, behind which the second personality, a murderous psychopath, hides....
That's no horror game, that's just Diavolo
Plot twist: the entire game is a JoJo reference
game: "shes like a little bunny"
manly: bun
I cried, i miss wadanohara
@@geneticion9158 It's the titular character of an RPG-maker game series Manly played awhile back. The playthrough is somewhere on his "recommended playlist" if you're curious. Fair warning though; if you're squemish with (cartoon) blood, creepy eyes, and "implied" SA.
@@Totallyarealhuman2210 what is the name of the game?
@@jood.q Wadanohara and The Great Blue Sea
@@geneticion9158 manly played wadanohara and the great blue sea a while ago, the bun phrase comes from that
@@cilcipher tbh i never finished manly's wadanohara playthroughs. i intended to, but at the time i just didn't have it in me. maybe sometime in the future i'll go back and actually watch it all again.
The way Manly pronounces “knife” never fails to send my sides into orbit
noiyfe
Unmanned Drowns, Fookin layzer soights
@@History_Nurd whats in the canister? Or is it best I don't ask?
@@History_Nurd🇬🇧☕️🇬🇧
@@History_Nurd what is this from??
At normal ending 2, when manly says "why did it cut off at the end?" you can hear a faint slashing sound.
That answer that question. :)
Oh, no... Oh, no no no... OH, HELL NO!!! SOMEONE GET THE COPS, THERE'S A SERIAL KILLER ON A LOOSE!!!
@@NX_K Not anymore.
It's a psycho killer and John, her dead boyfriend Frankenstein
And they're on the loose.
This dude has officially become my favorite comfort RUclipsr. I love horror games I love watching play through a an on top of that he’s not loud and obnoxious is voice is rather southing
DUDE I LOVE THIS! The psychology is compelling. The way Marty stew, which is literally the name of a boy mary sue, slowly goes insane due to the plot and the repeated loops and becomes the villain is super cool. They took the stupid trope and then used it for such an ending is beautiful.
Also his name really fits considering the setting of Loser Reborn, which is where his character first came from.
Villain? Wdym? He's a naive boy who becomes the sweetest bf ever... Anyone willing to dispose of a body for you is Def a true homie
@@Dreamstrafe Ikr? Ppl just say that for no reason at all
This was quite the rollercoaster from start to finish. After some of those bad endings, I was certain I had the full story but it just kept adding twists and thankfully didn't squander what was enjoyable in the process. This world the developer has made is real weird but I do like it.
@@maxwell8540 damn, after this video i think im gonna watch the other games of this dev and understand better this world, it will be pretty interesting to see
@@maxwell8540 He became a sociopath for her and she´s like: "I didnt knew"
After watching Marty in the extra ending.
Sally: "Um you wanna tag in for a bit?"
Alter: "Hell no you made this bed, now you lie in it!"
Just going to take that as the canon dialogue for the wedding night.
It´s kinda funny the reaction reminds me of Kingpin in Daredevil´s reaction to having his wife asking and acting with no regard to his crimes, he didnt like it very much case it took away from her innocence when they were starting out their relationship, guess Sally too, will have to live with the fact she corrupted her boyfriend
Another thing that I love about this is that the boy, Marty was actually able to kill the Yandere, Seira (actually Sally's alter) on a melee physical combat, it was very satisfying in my opinion.
51:03 just because the girl is a yandere and smiles creepily with a kitchen knife, doesn't mean she is overpowered and always overpowers her victims. I love seeing the victim actual won for once. Many anime writers made yanderes too strong, it is getting bland.
Agreed, unless the Yandere character is some kind of powerful being in the universe they inhabit in, many of them are just *ordinary* human girls with a few screws loosen, dunno why anime tends to make them so goddamn OP.
Being a nutcase doesn't correlate with excellent fighting capabilities. Am I really supposed to believe Yandere GIRLS can easily physically overpower their MALE victims most of the time? lol Such Mary Sue wish fulfillments for females who are prone to jealousy in relationships.
Eh...it's not a special thing since the victim usually overpowers the killer at the end of the story all the time, and yanderes in a bunch of horror games just get killed by the protag a lot at the end or in one of the endings at least so a don't think this rare or something
@@loremipsum980 most people who write female yanderes are men. Them being op isn't for female empowerment, it's for the kink and horror aspect. What are you even going on about?
Yes!!! Usually those games at least imply that humans are the real monsters but weren't the victims that almost all the time can't even put a fight also humans? Why are they killed so easily by someone that have no training in fighting, isn't even fit and most often have the biological disadvantage? I get that even a person like that will be dangerous with an adrenaline boost but this is just ridiculous.
And, in the cases where they know is coming, what about the adrenaline response of the victims?
@@user-uq9oe7sc5m i'am not talking about any specific horror game it just comes to mind since it happens a lot in the end of a movie when the protag wins like Alien, some movies of the Friday 13th, Halloween, and some others games that Manly has played usually has some ending where you kill the murderer
As a left-handed person, that random question about Sally being left-handed amused me. It took 5 years for my friend to realize I'm left-handed. It's a big shocker to a lot of righties. 🤷♀️
29:06 "If something happened to me, you'd blame yourself to death. Even if that chance is less than 1%..." Marty is the living embodiment of the 'The risk I took was calculated, but man, am I bad at math' meme. 😂
1:13:21 Sally: “No…no! You’re…”
Marty: “Don’t say it!”
Sally: “You’re not me!”
Alter: “MWAHAHAHAHA!”
*Battle starts and “I’ll Face Myself” plays*
"It's symboooooolic!~"
Yaeeeeeees!!! PERSONAaaaa
Best comment ever lmao
"I am a shadow... the true self..."
Hahaha you made my day with that comment kind sir.
I love how there was no voice acting until the face licking
nice name
long lost twins!?!?!??!
Listening to Manly read corny dialogue with his uniquely monotone voice is surreal... I love it.
I really like these kind of games Manly plays. They start like "oh it's so predictable", but then when you indulge deeper you can see a different story, actually well-built. I can see the best games of these kind just follow the same formula, they all have a really predictable start, multiple knots getting complex as they pass and then a finale that actually makes you understand the story completely. I have seen many of the novels I have read start or end in ambiguity, actually leaving everything in your hands so you can say "oh so this is what it meant". I think the best of these are the ones that both start and end in ambiguity, leaving everything in your hands and literally pulling you into the story.
Congratulations to the devs, I am happy you knew how to blow the mind of a dumb man like me, despite how cringe this would sound.
What to say when a loved one opens up about them being neglected as a child :
*”You’re left handed?”*
So you’re finally awake
*You were trying to open your girlfriend’s secrets weren’t you?*
Don’t even bother trying to get up dude
*she has us both locked in the basement or quite possibly a sex dungeon*
Aw, I was hoping the closet.
Is a Charon reference to a game Manly played
For second I thought you would woke in a giant jar
Shut up down there.
I could imagen the boyfriend seeing horror movies and is just mentally pleading in his mind please let it be a sex dungeon and not what I think it's going to be. So he just sees the gf lock the door with only them 2 in the basement he just tells her please tell me you locked us in a sex dungeon. While she's just genuinely laughing from the unexpectedness and says "haha, you wish". So he says "damn well i seen too many horror movies so I thought I'd just give it a shot." When she hears that answer you can hear her going hmm like she's honestly debating on it. So you just imagen the guy mimicking quagmire's thumbs up.
Fun fact: There is an RPG Isekai game related to Physical Exorcism Series that involves Marty and Goddess Nya.
This game is literally just Twist Endings: The Game. I like the added humor. Vaguely remember the cannibal boy one; might have to rewatch that.
-You're handsome!
-Really? Nobody never says that to me...
-Well... Love is blind after all.
OUCH!
She really told my homie he ugly 😭
On ending 2, I think the cutoff was a way to imply the very moment of death
i think it was just because the title of the ending completed the phrase ("Sally and I would live- Happily ever after?"), as it happened with other ending. I found it funny that manly noticed this in the other ending but not in ending 2.
I wonder if those sleeping pills are actually anti-psychotics? I'm on anti-psychotics and they have the side effect of making you super drowsy, they're actually sometimes prescribed for that very side effect since it's very common. Still only 6 minutes into the video though so I'll wait and see
Edit: Well I certainly hope those are anti-psychotics
I dont know why, but im concerned on the part on why you needed those "anti-psychotics" for
@@adamsalik7389 people can be mentally ill Adam
@@adamsalik7389 i may not know what anti-psychotics are for, but i (think i) know they're for helping certain group of people. like those antidepressants and melatonin candies my sister usually takes
edit: said anti-depression instead of antidepressants
@@ni99ashells same diff lol
@@adamsalik7389 for psychotic disorders, they lower dopamine
The whole 'cursed to have their husbands die' reminds me of a movie I saw as a kid, where this family of witches I think were cursed with the exact same thing, it was a good movie overall, can't remember the title tho
But damn. All those red flags that you could build a bridge between the earth and pluto, and Marty sees almost none of em until a few replays lol...
Practical magic is the movie 💕
90% of this game is also the movie 'So I Married an Axe-Murderer.' except M. Night Shallamallamadingdong shows up after that 90% part to blame it all on a vulnerable demographic.
That curse when I first heard that in this game completely reminded me of ayumi shinozaki from corpse party tortured souls game because that sounds like a dead ringer for her curse.
Reverse Jojo curse
Am I the only one that kinda wanted the twist to be that Marty was actually possessed by John and that's why he was so obsessed with her? XD
Game: mostly normal, no sign of horror so far
Manly: I thought this was gonna be about organ harvesting or whatever but I guess I was wrong
Game: yeah, about that
3:19 - 3:24
That damned sprite change with the context made it for me.
MBH: I like that little segue (regarding the last line and the ending title)
Also MBH, with genuine concer : Why did he get cut off!?
Tbf it was the second ending and Manly was anticipating something to make the ending unhappy
21:33 "Even now, I have dreams where I'm trying to find his missing arms and legs."
Ah. I see where this is going... Makes dolls, has dreams about stitching her dead ex back together, dead ex looks an awful lot like the MC. Really it's just a question of whether or not she's going the full necromancy route.
Really glad this wasn't another cannibalism game. Or at least doesn't seem to be one *yet.* Not-cannibalism is almost a twist itself, given the trend.
Debating whether I am disappointed that there is no 'good ending' where the necromancy is successful and he actually comes back to life.
Same for a 'good ending' where she gets him transhumanist enhancements for the rest of his body parts and he becomes the most beautiful and powerful boy in the world.
@Grima the Fell Dragon Never watched the second one, but FMA did not have the benefit of being able to locate and identify the spirit of the deceased in order to bind it to the flesh golem directly.
FMA had the benefit of quick manufacturing, but no direct, clear line, to the spirit world, making it a worse place to try to bring back the dead.
The paranormal cosmology of those worlds were very very different from this one.
Those examples, while much higher quality, are about as relevant as pet cemetery.
"OH MY GOD YOU OPENED YOUR EYES!" thank you for that good laugh.
i feel that can be said used many times for some characters.
love your vids manly. il be trying to catch up on alot of stuff i missed cause i always forget i love watching your vids somehow...
plus always loved your reaction to bunnies. "bun"
His genuine excitement got me laughing out loud too. Good stuff.
Despite how walking-simulator-like these rpg maker horror games can be, I always find them utterly fascinating.
They’re basically visual novels with greater movement.
SPOILER BELOW:
I love that they actually (on purpose or not) have the left side of her face associated with her right-hand and vice-versa. Not many people think of that little detail.
"she's like a little bunny"
Me: thinks of the monty python bunny
Yeah, I can see it.
I actually prefer the extra ending storytelling wise and I kinda wish that was the Canan ending.
From my perspective it just seems a lot for interesting it feels like how it would naturally end. Especially with him gaining the memories from all the time loops for that ending in a satisfying way.
Is that just me?
That is the canon ending.
@@ManlyBadassHero Oh, since it was called the “Extra Ending” I just assumed it was an afterthought.
@@ManlyBadassHero hmm don't you mean the canan ending
@@ViTeofilothey misspelled the "canon" to "canan"
Can't believe Sally took the term "sucking some face" literally in one of the endings
“She’s entitled to her privacy” goes into her bathroom
SPOILERS
.
..
…
….
…..
……
…….
I love how the extra ending turns the whole game upside down where it’s no longer “my girlfriend’s secrets” but “my boyfriend’s secrets”!
Also, I really believe that Marty *IS* John. There are a lot of signs pointing to it, especially the fact that he is nearly identical to John to the point both himself and Sally mistake him for John at times. He also seems to act a lot like John.
Sally is without many of her memories from the accident and Marty also is suffering from amnesia (which is a point not often touched upon other than to explain Marty’s obsessive attachment to Sally). The fact that Marty also mentions he feels he’s known Sally longer than Sally has known him is a point to be made about Nya’s time rewinding powers, which has come in handy with every event Marty regretted. It’s entirely possible that the first time Nya rewound time for Marty was not after ending 1, but rather at the beginning of the game.
This is the best comment I have read in this comment section
I agree
I thought that too when I read the line about how he feels like he's known her for longer than he did, but then you have to connect the dots about the people in the car. Marty was John, His friend was either Sally or Seira (could've thought she died but she made it and they both forgot) but what about the rest of his family? And the sister? Also John is officially dead so he can't be John with amnesia. Maybe he haunts Marty? How would they know each other? And it couldn't impact Marty's appearance... Plus, then John would need to be another person in the car and there was only one friend... Or John was Marty's brother? That'd explain their ressemblance, but wouldn't prove they were in the same car crash. And if Sally dated John for 5 years, she'd know if he had a brother...
I think that's just a coincidence. Feels like everything is a dead end here.
Sally: “Don’t ever, EVER open the door to my room. Okay?”
Me: Okay, Bluebeard.
there's actually 2 sets of main characters for the series: you have the cases (cannibal boy, etc.) then there's Loser reborn where Marty comes from that leads directly to Case 02 where you meet Sally, which then leads to this one.
Im back after 1 year. I forgot about this channel and i recalled last week whats this channel's name, my guesses were "Oddlyhandsomeman" "Handsomeoddman" i searched "horror games" and kept on scrolling 'til i find a familiar channel. It was manlybadasshero! Glad to be back, your videos are my past of time. Glad you doing well too!!!
Oddly handome man I am dead
oddlyhandsomeman 😭 that cracks me up, glad you were able to find manly tho!
fancymandad is what i typed
@@blatantslander we do got some weird ass names on our heads 🤣
This actually happened to me too except i typed 'batmanhandsomehero' . I couldn't find it though but a video of manly suddenly popped up on my fb so yeah glad to found it back. (Sorry for bad english)
The time where Manly says "Nothing personal kids" that's where my humor broke 😂😂😂
I really like the meta way the protagonist rejected the "good" ending and went for something completely different. A linear multi-ending game where you still have the choice to stop after getting the "good" ending or go beyond and see the true extent of what the protagonist is capable of. It's a genuinely interesting take.
34:17
Manly reciting the "Nothing personnel" meme is something I didn't know I needed in life.
That final ending was quite an interesting turn of events to say the least.
Can't wait to see you play the next game from this developer.
the frankenstein'ed boyfriend part of the story would've been so interesting without the "she's mentally ill with a crazy murderous alter" tacked onto it 😮💨
I agree, the game is good and Manly's playthrough is great as always, but the game's take on dissociative annesia and split personality disorder feels sadly like unjustified bad rep for mentally ill people.
That's exactly what I thought as well. Even aside from the stereotypes on display here, it's just completely unnecessary and undermines the rest of the story.
@@loucantnot It's not DID it's literally spiritual possession. These aren't two personalities, these are two different entities in one body
@@opinionatortv6457 No, the game clearly establishes it's DID and not spirit possession, and as much as I generally like the story the criticisms levied at using that trope are valid.
@@opinionatortv6457 It's not. Watch the Extra Ending again. It explains that the talisman didn't work because Seira isn't an evil spirit. She's an alter Sally made based off of Seira and her supposed hatred of Sally and love of John.
I loved this. Truly a pair made for each other
Marty: Look, I don't even mind that Sally killed a couple of guys. Why would I care about her virginity?
Me: Only a true *sigma* would say such wise words.
Fun fact: Nazar beads are effectively Super Mushrooms from Mario. They will shatter after warding off evil successfully, after which they will be _useeeeelesssss_ and you will need another. Like how you can withstand one killing blow when Mario is big. :D
cute premise; i just wish it wasn't another "mental health issues equals psycho killer" story.
I agree
You can't deny though, it was a good story.
@@kylestanley7843 You can't deny though, that they kinda fucked up at the end.
@@Willowisp927 In what way? I found the story enjoyable, you'd need to be more clear.
@@kylestanley7843 by confirming to the "people with DID are evil murder's" trope
_"OoooOoooOoo I'm not gonna let you gOoooOoooOoo"_
_Spoilers_
Ending #3 Pretend happiness was my favorite ending. I always like the bittersweet ones. Besides, it featured MBH's ghostly wail lol.
I liked that movie Ghost... so romantic and sad.
As for the others, I'd be creeped out to find a photo of me in a guy's room that I didn't remember posing for. The idea of a stalker is all too real and frightening for many people irl. Honestly MBH has watched so many anime, he can guess these plots a mile away lol!
This was a bit more twisty than I expected, more sad. I liked the escalation of the plot endings to ghost, to the alter. Best ever movie that immediately came to mind with ghost/question about what happened was A Tale of Two Sisters. I saw it and never forgot it, but I won't spoil it here.
The moral of the story: If you have precognitive dreams, don't go down to anyone's basement and forget a night-time reward including cookies. Just leave.
To be fair, he has total amnesia, and she was immediately nice to him, it would have been very reasonable for them to have been friends before he remembers them meeting for the first time.
Should I watch that movie?
@@eloujtimereaver4504 I didn't see your reply in my notifications, so apologies for not responding sooner! Yes, it is a great Korean horror movie. It theoretically is a ghost story, but it is much more complicated. Definite must see. :)
Bro this game was amazing it helped me get through many of the inner conflicts i had and answered many questions i never though about but should have now because of you and this game i got a realisation that i should explore this domain of phycological horror stuff and thanks you earned a subscriber
I think he took the saying "if you can't beat them join them" too literally...
This games portrayal if systems and DID is at least a *little* better than most, with using the right terms and explaining things mostly correctly. But the bar is still on the floor and they still fall into a lot of pitfalls, like only 1 alter and said alter being a murderous yandere. There's a lot more but god don't have the energy to. I still enjoyed watching the game in the background tho like any Manly vid lol.
I love that it closes out with the roles totally reversed. I really enjoyed this! Love loop stories, creepy yandere (but not really) stories, etc, etc.
more than an hour long of manly’s gameplay, I can’t wait to watch this at night. Youre the best, Manlybadasshero!
Marty: Awh Jeez Manly, I don't think we should open this door
Manly: Open the door, 9 more endings, Manly and Morty FOREVERRRRRR
What I like about this game it that the plot leads you to 1 conclusion, but then in the next “run” it shows something completely different making you come up with a whole new theory, who found most of the plot on 2 minutes lol
It’s funny when the protagonist keeps bringing up how Siera died on Sarah’s birthday like they’re not twins…
He says that when he doesn't remember the loops which means he doesn't remember they're twins
Arent you more likely to die on your birthday though?
Cool story but I really wish that there had been actual choices to lead to the different endings instead of everything being on rails. At this point it isn't even a VN, much less a game. This is effectively just a cartoon narrated by Manly. Instead of having the endings be sequential, just have them be whatever is interacted with in her room first. It wouldn't be that hard.
I love love love manlys reaction to the hospital scene
...
...
...
"*JADE.*"
I call this game: God You Two Need Couples' Therapy: Red flags and unhealthy dynamics! Lmao
Great game! I really liked it.
Feel like the guy became a little too crazy at the end. I mean I get that they're both meant to be crazy but the ending just felt kinda exaggerated or something. Idk how to describe it but other than that it was really good. I actually really liked all the twists and turns. Really good game!
I'm so glad that I found this channel because I enjoy watching horror games gameplay but the streamers/youtubers I watch doesn't mainly make horror games videos 😊
This game made me quite interested in the dev's other games. I hope you play them Manly.
Marty got isekai'd!?!? I mean, ive seen his name thrown around before. But Cannibal Boy seems like there WAS a real culprit there. In the OG CB.
"Look, I don't even mind that Sally killed a couple of guys. Why would i care about her virginity?"
King shit.
51:40 I love how he just casually stands with an open mouth holding hand in his pocket.
Marty: These photos, why are they of the same old business man. But when I pick them up, they look like a boyband?
Sally: ...
*Door breaks open*
Marty: DOC?
Doc Brown: It's time to go Marty! Back to the Future >>>>>>>
*queue theme music*
Abnormal Ending 1