Two things I wasn't expecting to learn when I clicked on this extremely enjoyable video: 1. I know the drum part from Taxman better than either of you (but would have lost on everything else) 2. Why no-one makes banana marmalade Looking forward to the rematch: Radiohead + eating an entire lemon
Jay Foreman has an eerie talent of singing a song off one note. Hearing a song backwards should be no challenge for him at all. His brain scares me a little.
My mum and I met David Bennet Piano in line for the toilet after a jay foreman gig on the night this was recorded. Despite my attempts to maintain the mystery, he was all too willing to divulge all information about the video, including that Jay won. My mum would like to see a rematch with lots of different rounds
@@Iain1962 I was hoping that if I clicked "translate" it would reveal the meaning of "ob-la-di" (if not "ob-la-da"), but I was disappointed. Oh well, life goes on.
I like how at the beginning of the end, they were like, have we just been wasting banana skins? and gradually, they start to realize why we've been tossing them
That’s precisely when the strange (for rock) instruments were being introduced. I don’t think either of them would’ve had a problem identifying She’s Leaving Home backwards. In 1966 there was a lot of strange sounds on Revolver too
I only missed 3 of them. I'd love to see more guest spots like this. I bet Elliot Roberts, Andrew from Parlogram Auctions, Rick Beato, and Jack White could score well on an Ultimate Beatles Quiz.
I didn't identify many songs in the first two rounds, but then I got Tax Man, which neither Jay nor David got and hence I can already unilaterally declare myself the winner! Thank you, thank you everyone! 🙏🏾🎉😘
For the isolated drums at 7:45 [Spoiler space] .. ... .. I thought those cymbal splashes at the end were from The Word (on the line: "It's so fine, it's sunshine."). It never occurred to me until now how similar that bit is to the bit where the title gets sung in You Won't See Me!
Fantastic video. I love Jay and David and seeing them both together was a treat. Its worth acknowledging in this video that Jay has perfect pitch, which makes most of the questions significantly easier for him, so it’s really no surprise that he won against David who doesn’t have PP, it simply isn’t a fair fight. It does seem David was aware of this as he alludes to Jay having PP at 14:05. Still, I’d love to see more collabs with both creators in future!
I can't believe I beat you both! Thought the drums were going to be the hardest but managed to get the majority of them! Excellent video as always - love a crossover between two of my faves
Just underscores how inventive each of Ringo's drum parts were. If I hadn't listened to the isolated drum parts of 'You Won't See Me" 10 bazillion times I'd never have guessed.
I recognised the drum part for We Can Work It Out immediately and was very nearly shouting at my monitor "THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST DRUM-FORWARD SONGS IN THEIR CATALOGUE. YOU TALKED ABOUT THAT TIME SIGNATURE CHANGE IN ONE OF YOUR VIDEOS. HOW DARE YOU GET THIS WRONG, YOU HACK, YOU FRAUD!" then promptly went back to "Oh wow, good job that one was tough". Thank you for teaching me that I would be intolerable to watch sports with.
I thought it was ticket to ride at first… but quickly remembered that it was more Tom-heavy lmao. As soon as they said in my life I was like “d’oh!” I got a few of the drum ones that David missed, I think the songs they chose for that are more well known and that’s probably why I feel that way
So much fun!! I once did a Beatles quiz with a friend where we alternating had to say each song from an beatles album in the right order. Was also a lot of fun!
What an awesome crossover, and good to finally see Jay after all his gloating! He does just have an ear for strange renditions of music, it seems. The drum only round was still the hardest one for sure.
Great Fun! Among other things, the percussion only demonstrates one again Ringo's rich contribution to the songs (no pun intended) - what an artist! Of course it was Paul playing the kit on "USSR," and I think that someone listening to that for the first time would be able to guess it wasn't Ringo. Thanks so much, and "yes, you have no bananas, today."
The best part of this video for me was the two guys shaking their heads to the beats like boble heads. :D I would have got around 30% of the questions, but I did get a couple that both didn't so I'm super psyched.
Absolutely wonderful video. So great to see you both! And I’m wincing because I’m watching you guys eat the banana, and I did that once when I had no lunch money at work at a grocery store. And I think somebody gave me five dollars if I ate a banana skin. So I remember that to this day.
Jay is one of my favourite RUclipsrs and one of my favourite things he does is randomly show up in some of my other favourite RUclipsrs videos in a collab from out of the blue
Map Man and Piano Man
Map man, piano man, map, piano, man, man, man, man ...
Billy Joel?
@@chobies5383 Only if they'd uploaded this at nine o'clock on a Saturday.
@@ongoingmartin You son of a gun
Mapiano Man!
It's always such a joy to see Jay Foreman absolutely anywhere lol
Creepy.
couldn't agree more. jay foreman for the prime minister!
here, there and everywhere
Er, YES! Replace the news channels with a selfie camera on him
BEHIND YOU
I love how Jay would say "by the Beatles" on the beatles quiz show 🤣
They didn’t write every single song they sang…
@@Captain_Sir_Lord_Chimcharno but they performed all the songs they performed
🎶 “Tax man, tax man, tax tax tax man man man.”
... man.
That's actually what I think when I read the title for the song
This deserves more likes.
@@blindleader42 mark is the taxed.
I'm the man - and here's the tax
Round 3 was straight up insane. It's beyond Beatles knowledge at this point; Jay Foreman is just a wizard.
He has a video where he can play any Beatles song 1 lyric off the beat. I think he just has a good mental ability to think with music/time.
The backwards round was easy.
I picked Hey Bulldog straight away because the grove barely changes, but the rest of them I had no idea. Jay is definitely a wizard though.
@@collisw8302 I had him beat rather handily.
I am not even musically trained but would have guessed nearly all
Two things I wasn't expecting to learn when I clicked on this extremely enjoyable video:
1. I know the drum part from Taxman better than either of you (but would have lost on everything else)
2. Why no-one makes banana marmalade
Looking forward to the rematch: Radiohead + eating an entire lemon
I could get a massive score in a radiohead version of this
Radiohead, Ladytron, Portishead I feel I would have good chances on each time. I'd be rather screwed against Dave on the Beatles for sure though
That was the only one I got for the drum round too, oddly enough
Like Spinning Plates in the reverse round...."That's just a normal song!"
Even gorillas don’t eat the skin
They should combine all three to be 1 second of reversed drums
And with a final score of nil-nil, they split the banana.
The ultimate featuring I didn't even know I wanted
Jay Foreman has an eerie talent of singing a song off one note. Hearing a song backwards should be no challenge for him at all. His brain scares me a little.
Jay looks like a cross between John and George, whereas David looks like a cross between John and Paul.
Underrated comment
Best comment
British People
David kinda looks a tad like Pete Best lol
And Ringo looks like your mom. Ooohhhhh
My mum and I met David Bennet Piano in line for the toilet after a jay foreman gig on the night this was recorded. Despite my attempts to maintain the mystery, he was all too willing to divulge all information about the video, including that Jay won. My mum would like to see a rematch with lots of different rounds
I remember our meeting. Sorry that I spoiled the outcome of the video!
😆 no worries. And no shame in being beaten by the better man. Jay foreman is on another level 🫡
@@saulmcgowan1654True, we're talking about the man who can sing any Beatles song one syllable delayed
TBH, eating an unpeeled banana seems like the sort of thing Jay would just do in passing. He’s surely eaten worse for a Map Men gag.
Yeah, like that English language soup.
Too true.
16:00 I was expecting him to suggest for himself to eat the inside of the banana and leave the peel for David.
David Peel. I get it
Jay could totally host a gameshow. He has the charm, plus he can do a rules spiel from memory.
Yeah, those isolated drums were damn near impossible.
I only got one of them.
I actually got them all. But I'm a drummer and was in a Beatles tribute band for a few years so.. 😂
I somehow got Taxman right off a complete guess but that was the only one, it's really hard
David's were way more difficult than jays
Really? I got 8/10
The loser has to partake in Ob-La-Di, Ba- Na-Na
I laughed harder at this than I should probably admit.
What's funny is google offer to translate your comment into English.
@@Iain1962 I was hoping that if I clicked "translate" it would reveal the meaning of "ob-la-di" (if not "ob-la-da"), but I was disappointed. Oh well, life goes on.
Ob-li-terate, Ba-na-na
*one syllable off version*
I like how at the beginning of the end, they were like, have we just been wasting banana skins? and gradually, they start to realize why we've been tossing them
the taskmaster sound at the end!
Does this mean Jay will be on series 18? 👀
I hope so
@@M00NF1SHXD I would eat a whole banana with skin to make that happen!
The 67 era Beatles songs are surprisingly recognisable backwards, as the music from that era is so distinctive.
That’s precisely when the strange (for rock) instruments were being introduced. I don’t think either of them would’ve had a problem identifying She’s Leaving Home backwards. In 1966 there was a lot of strange sounds on Revolver too
Yeah that's true.
She Said She Said is one of my favorites too. And that is saying a lot regarding a band that has virtually countless songs worthy of being favorites.
👍👍👍 for that Taskmaster sting before the final scores.
😁😁
I only missed 3 of them. I'd love to see more guest spots like this. I bet Elliot Roberts, Andrew from Parlogram Auctions, Rick Beato, and Jack White could score well on an Ultimate Beatles Quiz.
This is so British, Jay is literally profusely apologising for getting the right answers and ashamed of winning
Next round. General questions about London and maps.
Who cares?
@@daveidmarx8296It's a reference to the sort of content on Jay's channel, that's all
That’s just cruel.
2-0 😂
TAKE THAT, BANANA
Ringo added a dynamic to the Beatles that is easily overlooked.
His isolated drums sound great.
I'm ashamed to say I realise until my friend pointed it out
and I used to think that Tom Ska vs Tom Scott was the most insane crossover ever...
You should do more of these! i love them!
I didn't identify many songs in the first two rounds, but then I got Tax Man, which neither Jay nor David got and hence I can already unilaterally declare myself the winner!
Thank you, thank you everyone! 🙏🏾🎉😘
Paul played the drums on Back in the USSR actually.
I absolutely loved this video. You both worked so well together.
Thank you so much!
"Excuse me for thinking a banana eating contest would be about eating a banana!" - Paris Geller
This popping up on the front page of RUclips made me so happy.
For the isolated drums at 7:45
[Spoiler space]
..
...
..
I thought those cymbal splashes at the end were from The Word (on the line: "It's so fine, it's sunshine."). It never occurred to me until now how similar that bit is to the bit where the title gets sung in You Won't See Me!
Such a fun vid/crossover. Not seen Jay before - will subscribe now.
Congratulations on a million David!
I bet 14:48 is a hidden hint that Jay is going to be on Taskmaster and I for one would absolutely love that
"You might as well say something" - Don't give it away, what if it was "Something" :D :D
as someone who watches both channels and is a beatlemaniac this is a dream come true - loved playing along :)
neM neM paM paM paM neM paM neM paM
neM
@@DaedalusYoung 😄
Fantastic video. I love Jay and David and seeing them both together was a treat.
Its worth acknowledging in this video that Jay has perfect pitch, which makes most of the questions significantly easier for him, so it’s really no surprise that he won against David who doesn’t have PP, it simply isn’t a fair fight. It does seem David was aware of this as he alludes to Jay having PP at 14:05.
Still, I’d love to see more collabs with both creators in future!
Glad I watched to the end - I have now learned definitively what the internet is for. You have saved me a lifetime of wondering, banana skins and all.
So proud I got the first three drum questions of Jay's round
You guys are like my two favorite people on youtube. I was literally watching through all of unfinished London the other day!
Loved the taskmaster references!
Wow didn't see this cross-over coming two of my favorite youtubers talking about one of my favorite bands, it's a good day!
Awesome Video. Its so surreal seeing my face at the end of a video!! 17:20 Proud to support!!!
I can't believe I beat you both! Thought the drums were going to be the hardest but managed to get the majority of them!
Excellent video as always - love a crossover between two of my faves
Love you guys together, and this was very impressive!!
😍
Just underscores how inventive each of Ringo's drum parts were. If I hadn't listened to the isolated drum parts of 'You Won't See Me" 10 bazillion times I'd never have guessed.
I noticed The Taskmaster transition music!
I recognised the drum part for We Can Work It Out immediately and was very nearly shouting at my monitor "THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST DRUM-FORWARD SONGS IN THEIR CATALOGUE. YOU TALKED ABOUT THAT TIME SIGNATURE CHANGE IN ONE OF YOUR VIDEOS. HOW DARE YOU GET THIS WRONG, YOU HACK, YOU FRAUD!" then promptly went back to "Oh wow, good job that one was tough". Thank you for teaching me that I would be intolerable to watch sports with.
KEEP THIS COLLAB GOING!!! Loved you two together!!
I'm only disappointed about missing "In My Life." I knew that drum part inside and out but just could not come up with the song until it was revealed.
The bell of the ride cymbal is what gave it away to me, that kind of response to the call of the verse
I thought it was ticket to ride at first… but quickly remembered that it was more Tom-heavy lmao. As soon as they said in my life I was like “d’oh!”
I got a few of the drum ones that David missed, I think the songs they chose for that are more well known and that’s probably why I feel that way
17:08 that's THE Foreman's sound!!!
Uugghhh
This was fantastic !!!👏👏
Glad you liked it!!
So much fun!!
I once did a Beatles quiz with a friend where we alternating had to say each song from an beatles album in the right order. Was also a lot of fun!
Me in round one: 10/10. Me in round two: 0/10.
7/10 for me in the isolated drum round.
Same. That was so hard; I also only got two in the final round
3rd round
@@daveidmarx8296 lies
@@CheeseMiser What would I possibly have to gain by lying. I'm pissed off that I missed three tbh
me, confidently after drums #4: “take me to the river!!!” lol that round was so impossible!
As a HUGE Beatles fan who ALSO was laughing at the misses in your previous videos, Jay bested us all!
Great stuff - Jay has magical powers.
Pleasure to watch you both -lovely, thank you.
Two of my favourites talking about The Beatles. Today is a good day.
This is something I have always needed. Two of my favourite entertaining educational channels collide.
fire vid David. loved the production value
Jay Foreman's singing one syllable out-of-sync is still one of my favorite RUclips videos ever
What an awesome crossover, and good to finally see Jay after all his gloating! He does just have an ear for strange renditions of music, it seems. The drum only round was still the hardest one for sure.
Great Fun! Among other things, the percussion only demonstrates one again Ringo's rich contribution to the songs (no pun intended) - what an artist! Of course it was Paul playing the kit on "USSR," and I think that someone listening to that for the first time would be able to guess it wasn't Ringo. Thanks so much, and "yes, you have no bananas, today."
The best part of this video for me was the two guys shaking their heads to the beats like boble heads. :D I would have got around 30% of the questions, but I did get a couple that both didn't so I'm super psyched.
I mean, Taxman has a *really* distinctive drumbeat.
woooah was not expecting Mr Beat to be referred lol I love this video!
😊😊
had a very good time watching this video. thanks David and guest for the entertainment!
She said she said, I agree, one of my favourites!
this was a dang ol treasure to watch, thanks fellas!
This is incredible.
Thank you!
9:57 / 9:17 - The Jam - Start
I watched this when it came out, a month later I did a discog dive and listened to all of their albums, definitley made the quiz easier
What kind of crazy world is this!? Two of my favourite channels come together ❤
A banana? Not an Apple?
Also, I appreciate the Taskmaster cue, but more the House Of Games reverse order answer!
Yeah btw ta not tha hard to eat a whole apple.
I don't know who this Jay Foreman is, but he's great. You guys pretty much have to do more shows together. This is gold.
Thanks! Check his channel out 😊😊
Loved it. Thanks for the video.
Thanks 😊
Damm! Jay is pretty solid! I would love to challenge him.. and you at one of these ultimate Beatles showdown’s
This was wonderfully fun. Thank you both.
very entertaining - you will have to have him back again.
Thank you for the bunch of laughs 🎼👍😀🎵
Two of the best RUclipsrs, together at last
So glad this happened, thank you.
Whoever put the quiz together should have trolled you with a backwards playing of Come Together.
Absolutely wonderful video. So great to see you both! And I’m wincing because I’m watching you guys eat the banana, and I did that once when I had no lunch money at work at a grocery store. And I think somebody gave me five dollars if I ate a banana skin. So I remember that to this day.
Jay is one of my favourite RUclipsrs and one of my favourite things he does is randomly show up in some of my other favourite RUclipsrs videos in a collab from out of the blue
Brilliant video!! Great job guys!
The optical presentation of this video is epic! 🤩👍
Wow the drum part was MUCH harder than I expected.
Please do more videos with Jay.
Absolutely lovely. These dudes are so animated, god. Even hard to believe they are real and so sophisticated
An unexpected but wonderful surprise of a collaboration :)
Jay! The out of syllable man! I love ye mate
This was fantastic! Keep these up always
Jay is incredible!
Jay Foreman = instant click! My favorite perfect pitch comedian