Whoever is sharing any incidents regarding Netaji, they all are seemed to be very honest, genuine and men with great integrity and pride. It is seen in their eyes. It is very satisfying to see so many of my country men are so loving & caring and respectful to our true heroes.
Projected as if only Ghandhi, Nehru, Jinna, fought for independence. Netaji, sukdev, bhagat singh, Savarkar, Mangal Pandey, Savitribai Phule,Rani Laxmibai, Rani Chennamma.... to name few, were born after we got independence. Respect the unsung heroes. They fought till their last breath for Maa Bharati.
India is indebted to Chandrachud Jim , Anuj Jim , Tandon Ji and your whole team for bringing out the truth of my real life hero . No words can suffice my gratitude to you .
शत-शत नमन नेताजी सुभाष चन्द्र बोस को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम और धिक्कार है ऐसे लोगों पर जिन्होने नेताजी को गुमनाम बाबा बनाया नेता बनने के लिए धिक्कार है कांग्रेस पार्टी के नेताओं पर
I think this is the spiritual power of Neta ji that was prevalent upon everyone who used to visit him and this power made every one honest , sincere and bonafide to Neta ji as everyone accepted everything honestly and there is not even a pin point difference in their evidence . They are fortunate enough to come closure to Neta ji and still they have devotion for that great soul 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Unstructured interview formats are the best in Qualitative research. Tandon ji brought up several valuable inputs of the time in which he had written extensively on the matter after Bhagwan ji had passed away. The recount of Capt. Sehgal's blatant but illogical denial from a distance was particularly uncanny as it points out to the fact that there were so many people who did not wish to address the existence of Netaji Bose at all despite the presence of ample evidence to the contrary. Wonderful interview 👌😊
Maine gumnami movie dekh k apke bare m search kiya sir great work done buy u this country doesnt deserve person like netaji for me he is father of our nation bt jane kb yaha k logo ka khoon kholega or neta ji ko insaaf milega same on indian poltics
Trimurti's of Indian independence might have been involved to suppress the glory of Bhagwanji. 😭 Truth Prevails. 🔥🔥 Feels sorry for a Great National Hero, had to live like Gumnaam. Evil forces had tried to hide rays of Sun ☀️, they could only till Eclipse lasts. Glory has to light up Maa Bharthi, Love INA. Jai Hind
Everybody talked about who was Gumnami Baba but no body even Ashok Tandon_he being my elder brother_told about the existence of swami Sachidanand alias Sri Bengali Baba , who was the mostsscilined famous saint of Ayodhya living in Birla Dharmashala_ I being his initiated disciple _ but I being spiritual di
As a follower my heartiest compliment to you and Anuj Dharji for documenting and recording this priceless conversation. All your interviews uploaded, establishes that Bhagwanji was indeed Netaji. It definitely points out to a cover-up sanctioned from the highest level with the off-course full approval of Netaji himself. The overwhelming motivation probably was to cover the track and avoid the consequence of collaborating with an internationally designated War Criminal. Netaji had no personal ambitions and having renounced worldly life upon taking sannyasa, suited the then dispensation. The idea was to lead a peaceful life in the end. But for his legacy and accuracy of history, it's important to establish truth correctly, now that he is no more. A big salute for your effort!! let us hope a parliamentary committee or commission tries to relook at all the facts again to validate the true sequence of his life.
I doubt that Indian government has any intention or desire to acknowledge the fact that Bhagwan Ji was actually Neta Ji. I also don’t have any hopes from Indian judicial system. But I believe a series should made in Netflix that could raise awareness to new level so that the government could be pressurized to finally act.
agar sarkar ek small action ya reaction leti iss case per, wo apne aap me prove kr deta ki sarkar sach chhupa rhi h...bus BJP isko official declare krde toh mjaa aa jaye..feel sad for our national hero
@AnujDhar ji, I suggest you to try and persuade once again Mr. Ajay Pal Sharma, the former Delhi CP who was said to have close contact with #Bhagwanji when the former was DIG there!..may be by sheer Destiny, he can give new direction to this saga.. Truth of India's liberator must come out!.. One push and revered Netaji will get his due
सरस्वती माता को तत्कालीन उत्तर प्रदेश के मुख्यमंत्री जो नेता जी के नेपाल से भारत में प्रवेश करने पर सम्पर्क में आए और सर्व प्रथम वे ही नेता जी को गोपनीय ढंग से मदद करते थे वे मुख्यमंत्री ने सरस्वती देवी जो विधवा थी और उसे एक छोटा सा लड़का था और बहुत ही गरीब थी को नेता जी को सेबा करने के लिए रख दिया था और उसकाऔर उसके लड़के का भरण पोषण नेता जी करते थे।
Thanks Chandrachurji for uploading this interview. From what Ashok Tandon ji says at 22:01 - 23:18, DR. Pabitra Mohan Roy not only knew that the plane crash death story was a faked one, but also knew where all Netaji could have gone while hiding. It seems Dr. Pabitra Roy was actively searching for Netaji at all possible places. So his meeting Netaji was not a chance one as some people believe.
Chandrachur Sir, you and Anuj Sir's works are brilliant. It would be helpful for us to understand the words properly if you give bengali and english subtitles.
Very poor quality sound recording. A persistent background noise all tbrough. Plse take care of recording while taking such invaluable interview from such a legend.
38.07 min. later video is blank. Complete episode shows if any incident is ignored, how it dies itself. Any many scrap things are super elevated. जैसे कि काफी-कुछ बोने लोगों को इस देश में महान देशभक्त चित्रित कर दिया गया है। और बहुत सारे लोग बिना जाने बिना सोचे समझे उसी को फॉलो करते रहते हैं।
Sir I have seen your all videoes And i have observed you are some what unable to trace Netaji when he has return to India from Russia, For your convenance I only say bthat some video are already on you tube In which it is stated that Neta ji were in Punjab and Haryana border in Patiyala Distt, a village named Panjola from 1953 to 1956. But he was shifting his residence frequently. in nearby villages. From Haryana Subhash ji has shifted to Barreli and then to Lucknow and so as stated by you. They have shown a gold Mala cum Haar to a lady who used to cook food for Netaji. Her son who was just 8-9 year at that time and is still alive and he has posted video on you tube. Hope it may work for you.
Sir, I have been following your updates about this matter. Also following Anuj Dhar's channel.Now I have one observation. Now a days during this lockdown period we are locked inside our home and under mental stress of some kind. If this type of lock down continues for one more month I shall not be surprised to see someone at some corner of India shows some kind of abnormal or stressed out behaviour. Now take the case of Gumnami baba who locked himself under similar quaratine for 30-35 years. How a person can be completely normal under such circumstances? So if Gumnami baba showed such behaviour then it was quite possible. This need not have a connection with some kind of physical torture happened in the past.
Did he say that Captain Sehgal, Dr Lakshmi Sehgal the head of Women wing of INA disowned gumnami baba as Netaji. Shocking to believe that she didn't know. She would have definitely known. At least before she died she should have confirmed. Why such secret all these years i can't understand.
Maybe it is here a reason where an apparent betrayal might have happened on the basis of idealism. May be Dr Lakshmi Sehgal didnot want to officially in anyway confirm it. If caught dead or alive Netaji would be transferred to Britain. Dr RP Mishra also said to homeopathy Dr on last rite funeral time that if he see the face then body might be send to London. So you can get the clue there was strict restriction. And Netaji is not selfish if it was only for him he would have faced British boldly but there is something very important which Netaji was trying to save all Indian and India from. The Indian govt was not completely wrong. Indian govt was had all knowledge of Netaji without Indian govt post 1947 independence Netaji I think arrived from russia to punjab region through govt aide but in complete disguise. Somewhere all politicians wanted to save Netaji for some years after Independence but gradually netaji willingly left mainstream politics and turned inward to spirituality but it was not completely his will maybe he saw India's political corruption too high and moral of people too low. And Netaji's idealism was suppressed and he felt suffocated watching those days political figure so Netaji did not feel that India needs him anymore. He understood people are happily convinced by narratives of Gandhi and Nehru and India had actually forgotten Netaji which Netaji understood very well while living in disguise and he saw there is no need for him in India. He had that disappointment. Anyhow he flourished in his spiritual journey. I feel Netaji had not married. His spiritual life from beginning and his idealism from early age make him complete revolutionary who could leave his family members for love of his country.
i am a great admirer of your work.... could you do video on the way forward to deal with the entire issue..... and discuss other salient aspects of the book"conundrum" Are there any sources and materials which came up while research which were not divulged in the book conundrum due to lack of corroboration like the Hitler & Himler angle , if it has any substantial proof regarding this aspect? or some nazi war criminal came along with him and he provided any safe heaven for them in india.? Dr. Kurt Waldemar Tank was a German aeronautical engineer who ws the designer of legendary focke wulf 190, who was in hiding in Argentina after WW2, Nehru got him& his associates in here India and made Director of the Madras Institute of Technology and later joined Hindustan Aeronautics, where he designed the HF 24 Marut India's 1fst supersonic fighter.
Sir ami somoy palei apnar kora interview dekhi .apnar kaj amar dida dadu k boli onader boyos hoeche onara khub proud apnar kotha sune. Apnar lekha boi Kolkata pabo janale valo hoi ba publisher nam janleo hobe.
Dada, u r a gem...tomar obodan keu knodin bhulbena. . Pranab Mukherjee jokhn ato kichu janten , uni Kno atodin Congress e chilen? Left liberal lobby k shobai bhoy pae dekhchi😖... All the best of ur future works..love u lots dada 💗😊
Sir till now we haven’t got the subtitles of your interview with the son of Dr. Pavitra Mohan Roy. Kindly update it. I don’t understand Bengali. Please help @chandrachur Ghose
@@chandrachurg গুমনামি বাবার মৃত্যু নিয়ে পবিত্র মোহন রায়ের ছেলে কী বলতে চেয়েছেন?উনি কি আবার সবার চোখে ধুলো দিয়ে অন্য কোথাও চলে গিয়েছিলেন?এই বিষয়টি নিয়ে কিন্তু আলোচনা প্রয়োজন আছে।
পুরো interview শুনতে পারলে ভীষন ভাল লাগতো, কপাল খারাপ তাই যতটুকু পেলাম আভিভূত হলাম,conundrum বইটা পড়ছি, বাংলা হলে ২/৩ বার পড়ে ফেলতাম, আমার ঔষধের দোকান, এর মাঝখানে যতটা পাড়ছি দেখা,ও পড়া চালিয়ে যাচ্ছি, 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for pointing out. The actual video length is about 38 minutes, but is being displayed as 56 minutes for some reason that I am not able to understand. Kindly ignore the glitch.
Netaji secret service bole ekta boi likhechilen seta pradipta mohan Roy er lekha seii boi ta internet a pelam nahh seii boi kothay pete pari ektu bolle khub help hoto
Is the duration of this video 56minutes? But the video is available for 38minues. Thanks to Mr. Tandon without knowing much about Netaji before hand he took up the issue and started writing about Bhagwanji.
@@saurab02 Death kahin bhi ho (ghar pe or hospital mein), death certificate to banegai aur unki death hui hai 80s mein. Tab to death registration chalu ho giya tha.
Sir, the video stopped after playing for 38 mnts. There is no audio or visual. Is it 38 mnt video if so why the length of the video shows of 56 mnt? Please, let me know, sir
Why no one contacted col.sehgal. ,mrs sehgal or thier daughter whi was Marxist they were living in kanpur Col sehgal s brother was IAS officer and had bunglow in friends colony
Bhagavan jee was our liberator Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose undoubtedly. Revolutionary freedom fighters from Anushilan Samiti, Bengal volunteer and Shreesangha Lila Nag, Dr Pabitra Mohan Roy etc can't connect with a normal saint from Kolkata decades after decades devoutedly. . Justice MK clearly mentioned that He was Netaji. As of now I want to request you to make interviews with Pranab Mukherjee, director of Kolkata lab Santosh Kumar Mondal and lastly try best for Dalay Lama to know about Netaji Subhas' role in Tibet and China. As of now nation and nationals facing LOCKDOWN fighting against Corona virus 21 days and we are becoming very tensed mentally. Then trying to understand about great LOCKDOWN of the great revolutionary freedom fighter Netaji who was first prime minister of United India and fought War against the British Raj, passed decades after decades on this soil of nation fighting against Corona virus type dirty politics upto 1985 ?? How can we remain Silent about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose ? We have to Vocal. Many many thanks to you all Dada. Jay hind! Jayatu Netaji!
Sir Agar Netaji ko isi tarah se gujar jana tha, to aisa kahin aur bhi jagah ho sakta tha... Is tarah se amartva ko praapt karne aadi any paristhitiyan jo Raj Kumar ne bataayi hai, We sabhi baate Netaji ke kad se bilkul bhi mail nhi rakhti... Aisee meri opinion... Something is hidden Must be investigated
Gajendra Bhai app writter Anuj Dhar ki book padha.sab sawalo ki answer app ko mill jayanga.Britisher na unha war criminal ghoshit Kiya tha.nahru ka britisher ka sath Aggrement huaa tha.
Khud subhash babu khte the koi b gov. Esh raj ko nhi ujagar kr payegi qki vo khte the jaise yehi ujagar hoga desh m kranti aa jayegi girahyudh chhid jayega dnge ho jainge
He was a true soldier who gave up himself for the independence struggle,for mother India ,for his fellow countrymen,did not want anything in return.he was a true saint who believed in “Nishkama Karma.”
1985 ke bad laldari mutya maraj bhi bahr nikle vo bhi kisi ke gar pr rahte the 1985 ke bad isliye bahar nikle kuki ye dono ina me sath kam kr chuke hoge koi
Whoever is sharing any incidents regarding Netaji, they all are seemed to be very honest, genuine and men with great integrity and pride. It is seen in their eyes. It is very satisfying to see so many of my country men are so loving & caring and respectful to our true heroes.
Remember Arindam only good people can do such work.
True credit, nice observation
Yes very true
Projected as if only Ghandhi, Nehru, Jinna, fought for independence. Netaji, sukdev, bhagat singh, Savarkar, Mangal Pandey, Savitribai Phule,Rani Laxmibai, Rani Chennamma.... to name few, were born after we got independence. Respect the unsung heroes. They fought till their last breath for Maa Bharati.
@@salian_mj please take savarkar out of that list.
India is indebted to Chandrachud Jim , Anuj Jim , Tandon Ji and your whole team for bringing out the truth of my real life hero . No words can suffice my gratitude to you .
शत-शत नमन नेताजी सुभाष चन्द्र बोस को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम और धिक्कार है ऐसे लोगों पर जिन्होने नेताजी को गुमनाम बाबा बनाया नेता बनने के लिए धिक्कार है कांग्रेस पार्टी के नेताओं पर
I think this is the spiritual power of Neta ji that was prevalent upon everyone who used to visit him and this power made every one honest , sincere and bonafide to Neta ji as everyone accepted everything honestly and there is not even a pin point difference in their evidence . They are fortunate enough to come closure to Neta ji and still they have devotion for that great soul 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Unstructured interview formats are the best in Qualitative research. Tandon ji brought up several valuable inputs of the time in which he had written extensively on the matter after Bhagwan ji had passed away.
The recount of Capt. Sehgal's blatant but illogical denial from a distance was particularly uncanny as it points out to the fact that there were so many people who did not wish to address the existence of Netaji Bose at all despite the presence of ample evidence to the contrary.
Wonderful interview 👌😊
Neta ji hum sharminda hain 🙏 😔
रोना आता है सुभाष बाबू की कहानी सुन कर
क्या कुछ त्याग नहीं किया इस व्यक्ति ने देश के लिए 🙏🙏
Thank you Ashok ji for keeping this issue alive in whatever way you can. Unfortunate that Netaji's family is not taking enough interest
Maine gumnami movie dekh k apke bare m search kiya sir great work done buy u this country doesnt deserve person like netaji for me he is father of our nation bt jane kb yaha k logo ka khoon kholega or neta ji ko insaaf milega same on indian poltics
Trimurti's of Indian independence might have been involved to suppress the glory of Bhagwanji. 😭 Truth Prevails. 🔥🔥 Feels sorry for a Great National Hero, had to live like Gumnaam. Evil forces had tried to hide rays of Sun ☀️, they could only till Eclipse lasts. Glory has to light up Maa Bharthi, Love INA. Jai Hind
Everybody talked about who was Gumnami Baba but no body even Ashok Tandon_he being my elder brother_told about the existence of swami Sachidanand alias Sri Bengali Baba , who was the mostsscilined famous saint of Ayodhya living in Birla Dharmashala_ I being his initiated disciple _ but I being spiritual di
As a follower my heartiest compliment to you and Anuj Dharji for documenting and recording this priceless conversation. All your interviews uploaded, establishes that Bhagwanji was indeed Netaji. It definitely points out to a cover-up sanctioned from the highest level with the off-course full approval of Netaji himself. The overwhelming motivation probably was to cover the track and avoid the consequence of collaborating with an internationally designated War Criminal. Netaji had no personal ambitions and having renounced worldly life upon taking sannyasa, suited the then dispensation. The idea was to lead a peaceful life in the end. But for his legacy and accuracy of history, it's important to establish truth correctly, now that he is no more. A big salute for your effort!! let us hope a parliamentary committee or commission tries to relook at all the facts again to validate the true sequence of his life.
I totally agree with yr comments.
Dhansu evidence ,footage revolutionary sir Chandrachur Ghosh....jai Hind
u both r doing such a great work......hindustan hmesha aabhari rahega aap logo ka..
Amazing.. Great work.. Keep the light burning... So proud of your team...
Our country will be grateful to all of them 🙏🙏 🙏
I doubt that Indian government has any intention or desire to acknowledge the fact that Bhagwan Ji was actually Neta Ji. I also don’t have any hopes from Indian judicial system. But I believe a series should made in Netflix that could raise awareness to new level so that the government could be pressurized to finally act.
agar sarkar ek small action ya reaction leti iss case per, wo apne aap me prove kr deta ki sarkar sach chhupa rhi h...bus BJP isko official declare krde toh mjaa aa jaye..feel sad for our national hero
These are nice series of videos but i would be nice if u can add english captions atleast so even south indians can understand properly
@AnujDhar ji, I suggest you to try and persuade once again Mr. Ajay Pal Sharma, the former Delhi CP who was said to have close contact with #Bhagwanji when the former was DIG there!..may be by sheer Destiny, he can give new direction to this saga..
Truth of India's liberator must come out!..
One push and revered Netaji will get his due
गुमनामी फिल्म अपलोड कीजिए।
There is no video after 38 mins and 8 seconds.
Wow. This is mind blowing. Why this is not becoming mainstream.
सरस्वती माता के बारे में चर्चा होनी चाहिए कि वो भगवन जी की सेवा में कब से आयी उसे किसने भगवन जी से मिलवाया इत्यादि इत्यादी
सरस्वती माता को तत्कालीन उत्तर प्रदेश के मुख्यमंत्री जो नेता जी के नेपाल से भारत में प्रवेश करने पर सम्पर्क में आए और सर्व प्रथम वे ही नेता जी को गोपनीय ढंग से मदद करते थे वे मुख्यमंत्री ने सरस्वती देवी जो विधवा थी और उसे एक छोटा सा लड़का था और बहुत ही गरीब थी को नेता जी को सेबा करने के लिए रख दिया था और उसकाऔर उसके लड़के का भरण पोषण नेता जी करते थे।
तत्कालीन उत्तर प्रदेश के मुख्यमंत्री ने सरस्वती देवी को भगवन जी के साथ रखवा दिया था
Thanks Chandrachurji for uploading this interview. From what Ashok Tandon ji says at 22:01 - 23:18, DR. Pabitra Mohan Roy not only knew that the plane crash death story was a faked one, but also knew where all Netaji could have gone while hiding. It seems Dr. Pabitra Roy was actively searching for Netaji at all possible places. So his meeting Netaji was not a chance one as some people believe.
bilkul sahi... you have a good catch.
Chandrachur Sir, you and Anuj Sir's works are brilliant. It would be helpful for us to understand the words properly if you give bengali and english subtitles.
Thanks, but we do not have enough resources. These are extremely time consuming work.
His book name and link plz
@@chandrachurg v
Thanks for the clarification
Humesha yeh bharosa raha hai ki Netaji ne azaadi dilayi thank you for this final reiteration
Netajir upojukta Aashon e oti sottar Pratistha korai hobe prakrita Shroddha o Sanman nibedan.
NETAJI JINDABAD !!
JAI HIND !!
सरस्वती देवी का बयान भी शामिल होना चाहिए
Thank you sir ☺. Jai Hind
Only 36k view shame on us
पुराने लोग कितने स्पष्टवादी और सत्यवादी होते थे ।।।
jai hind!!!
ठीक ठीक समझ नहीं आ रहा क्या है पर टन्डन जी की एक आभा है, एक कोई गुण है उनका जो आवाज़ मे खनक बनकर निकल रहा है।
Very poor quality sound recording. A persistent background noise all tbrough. Plse take care of recording while taking such invaluable interview from such a legend.
38.07 min. later video is blank. Complete episode shows if any incident is ignored, how it dies itself. Any many scrap things are super elevated. जैसे कि काफी-कुछ बोने लोगों को इस देश में महान देशभक्त चित्रित कर दिया गया है। और बहुत सारे लोग बिना जाने बिना सोचे समझे उसी को फॉलो करते रहते हैं।
Yes, after 38.7min. video is blank. pls. check. Eager to watch further.
Sahid bhagat singh ko fansi ke gawah aaj Sugarmil owner or punjipati bane hue hai.british gift kargaye the.
Dada, tumar 2nd part interview ta deklam kunar da sathe meeting te.
I request you to post your contents in Bengali also to penetrate deep into Bengali speeking regions and Bengali minds.
Bengalis are gone cases, don't expect anything from them.
Jai Hind🇮🇳🙏
Very Good
Background main bahut disturbance aa rahi hai video main.
Great job..........thanks for the upload........
Sir I have seen your all videoes And i have observed you are some what unable to trace Netaji when he has return to India from Russia, For your convenance I only say bthat some video are already on you tube In which it is stated that Neta ji were in Punjab and Haryana border in Patiyala Distt, a village named Panjola from 1953 to 1956. But he was shifting his residence frequently. in nearby villages. From Haryana Subhash ji has shifted to Barreli and then to Lucknow and so as stated by you. They have shown a gold Mala cum Haar to a lady who used to cook food for Netaji. Her son who was just 8-9 year at that time and is still alive and he has posted video on you tube.
Hope it may work for you.
Can you share the link of the video ?
Bhai video ka link to de de
link ?
অনুজ
জী আপনাকে অনেক ধন্যবাদ জানাই
Neta ji Subhas Chandra bose Amar rahe
Sir, I have been following your updates about this matter. Also following Anuj Dhar's channel.Now I have one observation. Now a days during this lockdown period we are locked inside our home and under mental stress of some kind. If this type of lock down continues for one more month I shall not be surprised to see someone at some corner of India shows some kind of abnormal or stressed out behaviour. Now take the case of Gumnami baba who locked himself under similar quaratine for 30-35 years. How a person can be completely normal under such circumstances? So if Gumnami baba showed such behaviour then it was quite possible. This need not have a connection with some kind of physical torture happened in the past.
🙏🙏 neta ji
Did he say that Captain Sehgal, Dr Lakshmi Sehgal the head of Women wing of INA disowned gumnami baba as Netaji. Shocking to believe that she didn't know. She would have definitely known. At least before she died she should have confirmed. Why such secret all these years i can't understand.
Because she had sold herself to the Indian establishment of her times!
True.I too have the same doubt.
Maybe it is here a reason where an apparent betrayal might have happened on the basis of idealism. May be Dr Lakshmi Sehgal didnot want to officially in anyway confirm it. If caught dead or alive Netaji would be transferred to Britain. Dr RP Mishra also said to homeopathy Dr on last rite funeral time that if he see the face then body might be send to London. So you can get the clue there was strict restriction. And Netaji is not selfish if it was only for him he would have faced British boldly but there is something very important which Netaji was trying to save all Indian and India from. The Indian govt was not completely wrong. Indian govt was had all knowledge of Netaji without Indian govt post 1947 independence Netaji I think arrived from russia to punjab region through govt aide but in complete disguise. Somewhere all politicians wanted to save Netaji for some years after Independence but gradually netaji willingly left mainstream politics and turned inward to spirituality but it was not completely his will maybe he saw India's political corruption too high and moral of people too low. And Netaji's idealism was suppressed and he felt suffocated watching those days political figure so Netaji did not feel that India needs him anymore. He understood people are happily convinced by narratives of Gandhi and Nehru and India had actually forgotten Netaji which Netaji understood very well while living in disguise and he saw there is no need for him in India. He had that disappointment. Anyhow he flourished in his spiritual journey. I feel Netaji had not married. His spiritual life from beginning and his idealism from early age make him complete revolutionary who could leave his family members for love of his country.
Jai hind
the video is showing blank for me after 38.06Min
Thank you 🙏🙏👍👍
नेताजी के विरोधियों का सर्वनाश होगा
i am a great admirer of your work.... could you do video on the way forward to deal with the entire issue..... and discuss other salient aspects of the book"conundrum" Are there any sources and materials which came up while research which were not divulged in the book conundrum due to lack of corroboration
like the Hitler & Himler angle , if it has any substantial proof regarding this aspect? or some nazi war criminal came along with him and he provided any safe heaven for them in india.?
Dr. Kurt Waldemar Tank was a German aeronautical engineer who ws the designer of legendary focke wulf 190, who was in hiding in Argentina after WW2, Nehru got him& his associates in here India and made Director of the Madras Institute of Technology and later joined Hindustan Aeronautics, where he designed the HF 24 Marut India's 1fst supersonic fighter.
Rone ka man kar raha hai neta ji ki paristhiti sunkar aur vartman rajniti par khij ho raha hai
Sir ami somoy palei apnar kora interview dekhi .apnar kaj amar dida dadu k boli onader boyos hoeche onara khub proud apnar kotha sune. Apnar lekha boi Kolkata pabo janale valo hoi ba publisher nam janleo hobe.
College street e peye jaben. International Book Trust e.
Dada, u r a gem...tomar obodan keu knodin bhulbena. . Pranab Mukherjee jokhn ato kichu janten , uni Kno atodin Congress e chilen? Left liberal lobby k shobai bhoy pae dekhchi😖...
All the best of ur future works..love u lots dada 💗😊
Sir till now we haven’t got the subtitles of your interview with the son of Dr. Pavitra Mohan Roy. Kindly update it. I don’t understand Bengali. Please help @chandrachur Ghose
That will take some time. Translating the interview and then uploading subtitles is extremely time consuming. Will take at least a few weeks
Chandrachur Ghose thanks
@@chandrachurg গুমনামি বাবার মৃত্যু নিয়ে পবিত্র মোহন রায়ের ছেলে কী বলতে চেয়েছেন?উনি কি আবার সবার চোখে ধুলো দিয়ে অন্য কোথাও চলে গিয়েছিলেন?এই বিষয়টি নিয়ে কিন্তু আলোচনা প্রয়োজন আছে।
Romit Singh pavitra mohon Roy’s son confirms that gumnami baba was Chandra Bose
পুরো interview শুনতে পারলে ভীষন ভাল লাগতো, কপাল খারাপ তাই যতটুকু পেলাম আভিভূত হলাম,conundrum বইটা পড়ছি, বাংলা হলে ২/৩ বার পড়ে ফেলতাম, আমার ঔষধের দোকান, এর মাঝখানে যতটা পাড়ছি দেখা,ও পড়া চালিয়ে যাচ্ছি, 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you!
Hi ....from @38 mins the screen becomes blank with no audio or video. Can you please check the upload?
Thanks for pointing out. The actual video length is about 38 minutes, but is being displayed as 56 minutes for some reason that I am not able to understand. Kindly ignore the glitch.
@@chandrachurg maanniyaa mohoday aapko kis baat yaa cheez ne preritt kiyaa jo aapnee poojniya SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE ji ke liyee yeh moohimm shuru kiyaa plzzzzzz zaroor batayein dhanyawad aapko saadhoowaad aapko jaihind jai akhand Bharat Raashtra Jai Aryawarat Jai satya sanatan dharm darshan gyaan vigyaan sanskar sanskriti sabhyta jai Shri Rammmmmmmmmmmmmm
@chandrachur ghosh Please provide a link to buy ashok tandans book or name of the book
The book is called Gumnami Subhas. It’s probably out of print. Read Conundrum. It contains much more information and is updated. Get it from Amazon
@@chandrachurg conundrum already done
Sir kya yh book hindi me h
Netaji secret service bole ekta boi likhechilen seta pradipta mohan Roy er lekha seii boi ta internet a pelam nahh seii boi kothay pete pari ektu bolle khub help hoto
Amazing No words
Good job sir jai hind❤
Sir it would have been more audible with a mic and cancel out ambient noise. Only your voice is close to camera! 😣
What happened after 38.08 mnt of this video???
Then video is ended .
Is the duration of this video 56minutes? But the video is available for 38minues.
Thanks to Mr. Tandon without knowing much about Netaji before hand he took up the issue and started writing about Bhagwanji.
Who has given death certificate of Gumnami Baba and what was written in the death certificate?
Bhai normal ensaan ki tarah rhte the or nahi unki hospital m hui jo death certificate bnta
@@saurab02 Death kahin bhi ho (ghar pe or hospital mein), death certificate to banegai aur unki death hui hai 80s mein. Tab to death registration chalu ho giya tha.
@@971381744 jaldi me kriya ki gayi thi.unke Adewale sharir ko nadi me bhadiya tha.aisa v.n Arora kehte hain.
Sir, the video stopped after playing for 38 mnts. There is no audio or visual. Is it 38 mnt video if so why the length of the video shows of 56 mnt? Please, let me know, sir
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Backgound sound ko hata ke video Dale🙏
चंदन साहब की जय हो
Sir why there is no video after 38.00
Plzz it comes in account
Why no one contacted col.sehgal. ,mrs sehgal or thier daughter whi was Marxist they were living in kanpur Col sehgal s brother was IAS officer and had bunglow in friends colony
Gumnamibaba hi netaji the unke room me jo saman tha vi netaji se hi realative tha
Bhagavan jee was our liberator Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose undoubtedly. Revolutionary freedom fighters from Anushilan Samiti, Bengal volunteer and Shreesangha Lila Nag, Dr Pabitra Mohan Roy etc can't connect with a normal saint from Kolkata decades after decades devoutedly. . Justice MK clearly mentioned that He was Netaji. As of now I want to request you to make interviews with Pranab Mukherjee, director of Kolkata lab Santosh Kumar Mondal and lastly try best for Dalay Lama to know about Netaji Subhas' role in Tibet and China.
As of now nation and nationals facing LOCKDOWN fighting against Corona virus 21 days and we are becoming very tensed mentally. Then trying to understand about great LOCKDOWN of the great revolutionary freedom fighter Netaji who was first prime minister of United India and fought War against the British Raj, passed decades after decades on this soil of nation fighting against Corona virus type dirty politics upto 1985 ?? How can we remain Silent about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose ? We have to Vocal. Many many thanks to you all Dada. Jay hind! Jayatu Netaji!
Very strange mrs sehgal.dint meet neta. Je who was so close to him
🙏🙏🙏
good job
इनके लेखन की सीरीज बनाइये
Jai Hind INA
नमस्कार
Done
Sir
Agar Netaji ko isi tarah se gujar jana tha, to aisa kahin aur bhi jagah ho sakta tha...
Is tarah se amartva ko praapt karne aadi any paristhitiyan jo Raj Kumar ne bataayi hai, We sabhi baate Netaji ke kad se bilkul bhi mail nhi rakhti...
Aisee meri opinion...
Something is hidden
Must be investigated
Gajendra Bhai app writter Anuj Dhar ki book padha.sab sawalo ki answer app ko mill jayanga.Britisher na unha war criminal ghoshit Kiya tha.nahru ka britisher ka sath Aggrement huaa tha.
Gumnami film bhi dakha.
Sir, Where can I get his book, and the Ganga magazine series he authored?
Prashant Kumar unfortunately both are currently unavailable. But if he permits I might be able to upload both someday
Is Mr Tandon still alive ?
You should upload the scanned pdf of the book as well as Ganga Magazine.
@Hritik Sachan can u email? Do u have pdf of all relevant editions?
@Hritik Sachan Can you Email it ?
bhanunarayan20@gmail.com
@Hritik Sachan can u send pdf of ganga magazine and Gumnami Subhash books..?
Nonviolent se too Kutta bhi raste se nahi hatta or Aungrej bhag jaynge
Actual reason kya tha jo netaji subhash ch.bose ne khud ko duniya se chupkar ek sadhu banke jivan byatit kya ?
Khud subhash babu khte the koi b gov. Esh raj ko nhi ujagar kr payegi qki vo khte the jaise yehi ujagar hoga desh m kranti aa jayegi girahyudh chhid jayega dnge ho jainge
He was a true soldier who gave up himself for the independence struggle,for mother India ,for his fellow countrymen,did not want anything in return.he was a true saint who believed in “Nishkama Karma.”
Chandrachur sr plz translate your book (which is written by you and anuj sr) in hindi so that we can also read. Thanks a lot
Gumnami baba hi netaji the isliye to parde ke piche rahte the koi badi vajah hogi ye sab britan or nehruji ki chal thi taki vo bahar nahi aa sake
Hey media
Neta ji ne desh ko Indipend kia Congress gaddar hai hame jhoot bola
There should be DNA testing of gum nami baba
Ye jiva ka add dekh ke gussa aata hai
Laldari mutya maraj or netajii dono ina me ssth kam kr chuke hoge isliye unhone bhi apni pahchan chupai a
Ab sabase jaroori hai unako samano ko sanrakshit kiya jaye
Blank after 40 mins
1985 ke bad laldari mutya maraj bhi bahr nikle vo bhi kisi ke gar pr rahte the 1985 ke bad isliye bahar nikle kuki ye dono ina me sath kam kr chuke hoge koi
Heyyyyy bhagwaaan..
Sabse bada gaddar Congress nikla
Modi govt se sach kyu nhi nikalbate dharna do