पहली बार कैमरे पर: गुमनामी बाबा के साथ दो दशक तक रहे शख्स ने बताई अपनी कहानी
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 май 2020
- Raj Kumar Shukla walked into Bhagwanji's rented house in Singar Nagar, Lucknow, holding the hands of his mother Saraswati Devi and grandfather Mahadev Prasad Mishra. The year was 1955/56, and he was just about five or six. When he spoke to us, he was 64. Shukla took us down memory lane and helped us see through his eyes what life was like for them from the mid-1950s. The first part of the interview covers the period from 1955 to 1964. As I have written earlier, the interview was recorded for research purpose and we didn't think that one day we would release the recording. The camera wasn't the best, and the surroundings were not best for the sound. But thankfully, we have him on record.
#Bhagwanji, #Netaji, #Rajkumar Sukhla, #Gumnami Baba
![[Q/A] Conundrum: Netaji's Life After Death | Anuj Dhar | Chandrachur Ghose | KGB Archives](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eoQ79l2g4Gw/mqdefault.jpg)
![EST Gee - NEVER NEED (Feat. Selfpaid Savage) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f2cRtr52HXI/mqdefault.jpg)
My family is victim of partition brutality.
Mine and Netaji's enemies are same. Gandhi and Nehru. Hate is a small word. Respect and love for great Neta ji 🙏🙏 .Thanks for this interview.
Gandhi and Nehru destroyed India my family suffered in partition too
Small minds filled with such hate.
Guruji would never tolerate this sankeerna idea!
Whenever I learn, that a man of his stature lived life in such a poor condition, I shiver. I feel shame. Actually it’s a collective shame for this nation.
U see the pain and suffering he went through when ppl who were his ex-party teammates (gandhi & nehru) joined hands with the British and made them their allied powers...the independence for which he and his men(INA) fought so bravely was shattered by Gandhi n Nehru by agreeing to the partion of his beloved hometown Bengal...and he was declared as a war criminal to which the Indian Govt agreed and there was a secret protocol which was to handover him to the British so there was no chance of him going out and do anything, maybe he was convinced that for ages "MIRZAFFERS" are born here in India who always join hands with the foreign criminals for their own personal gain and betray people from their own motherland ...for nehru and gandhi British became friends which was never possible for Netagi coz he's not an ass kisser like the other two, he saw the misery of Indian people especially the poor who were tortured by the British...unlike nehru who was a rich spoilt brat and then we have his incest relationship talks with lady mount batten all around the internet...it feels so sick in my stomach to say all this
Agree bro. Netaji was greatest son of mother india.
Why do u believe he lived in isolation. Do you think a leader and person like netaji would live in isolation ? Why would he ?
@@jwalantjoshi6517 My belief us based on facts & not mere speculation. Facts presented by the extensive research work done by Anuj Dhar & Chandrachur Ghose in their book(s). I have myself visited the places where this great man lived in his last days. Pre conceived notion will not help anyone to understand this complex issue. I would like to suggest u, please take out some time & read the book Conundrum, authored by the above mention people. Many doubts will be cleared. Regards.
You are absolutely right banerjee bhai
Very useful. This kind of interview is needed. Mr. Anuj Dhar& Mr. Chandrachur Bose, your efforts will not go in vain. We are with you.
नेता जी को, सत सत नमन..🙏🙏.. मेरी तो आंखे ही छलक उठीं, उनकी बातें सुनकर..
राजकुमार जी बीच बीच मे घटनाएं बताते बताते हुए रोने लगते हैं "कितना सरल है मेरे देश का आम आदमी " "कितना लगाव व इज़्ज़त है इनके दिल मे देश भक्त के लिए"
AISA HI HAI mere bHarat
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@$^
It broke my heart knowing the man who gave us independence, we couldn't do anything for him when he was alive ..at least now we can do is to declassify his truth and give him respect that he deserves
He is "most respected national hero" in all Indian hearts n mind. True national heroes n true sons of motherland always do suffer in hands of traitors be it Bhagat Singh or Netaji Bose, unlike fake leaders like Nehru n Gandhu who were hands in hands with Britishers n traitors n enjoyed luxury life n privileges. They were never subjected to any discomfort or torture.
India was awarded Independence due to INA n World War II compulsions. I read it somewhere that it was precondition written in Independence Treaty that India would handover Netaji Bose to Britishers "Dead or Alive".....to an extent that his even dead body had to be given to Britishers .....for them to insult n disrespect his body n soul.
Yes, he was into hiding n was meditating at highest levels, but he was alive n living in his dear motherland for which he fought throughout his life. He was Britishers's "Most Wanted Enemy" otherwise he had been brutally brutally tortured n they would not let him breath or die", like they did with Sawarkar n others!!
Indian government too wanted him to live in hiding. That was the only solution. Condition in 1960s n 1970s were different. Britain used to exert enormous pressure on India n India was poor n helpless. India had been given Independence due to complexities of INA n World War II. History is fully of distorted facts n wrong notions which were forcefully taught to us all these decades by Nehru who was "chamcha" of Britishers n Gandhi.
Bhagvan ji was an appropriate name for Netaji.....watched the whole video with tears in eyes ......
Itna dukh... Itna kasht.. आँसू नहीं रुक रहे मेरे... आत्मा में मानो गहरी चोट लगी जो इस जनम न भरेगी
I am from Basti near to Ayodhya. I was 14 years old in 1985. Heard ot of stories about Netaji. My father knows Saraswati Devi ji.
Rajkumar Ji has come to my home many times. My father said it was sure that Gumnami Baba was actual Neta ji. but common ppl have their own problems to deal with and they have very limited options to do something about it.
@@ArjunSingh-wl9dcyou are absolutely right Arjun I am watching this video after 4 year from upload time , I am grandson of Rajkumar ji.
@@shggkp263 WoW.. Nice to hear about you. Can we talk ?
प्रणाम इनको जो भगवान जी के सानिध्य में रहे और इनकी अम्मा मां जगदम्बा को शत शत नमन ।धन्य है।भाव विभोर कर दिया।चंद्रचूड़ और अनुज जी आपको सादर प्रणाम।आपके प्रयास से कड़ी से कड़ी जुड़ी।
अंकल को मेरा प्रणाम, पर दुख होता नेता जी की सेवा करने वाले आज भी इतने गरीब में जी रहे है, सच मे हमारा देश सच्चे लोगों का नहीं है,😭😭😭।
Great work Anuj ji or chandrachur ji.👍👍Your effort s will not get waste. Netaji ji ne desh ko ajadi dilai unhe apni life ke antim samay itne kasto se bitani pari.😭😭😭😭😭 Netaji ko sat sat naman🙏🙏
On one side Nehru who didn't lift a finger against British n who was their stooge enjoyed all amenities in life n the real hero of our freedom struggle had lived such hard life n that too as Gumnami!!! My blood boils at the very mention of names of Gandhi n Nehru n Congress.
He has also experienced the ups and downs of Gumnami baba's life... He was a part of it.... Thanks for the interview...
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@#$
Thanks sir i hv no words for ur respect both of u r just unbelievable researchers 😔mere netaji 😔😔... Jai hind jai subhash ji
Salute to him who came in contact with that great hero of india,who is Netaji in disguise.
Heartbreaking story of our greatest leader Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Excellent work, I was searching for his interviews
I was so awaited for this interview , thanks sir , great job ! , Jai Hind!
Such a great soul who was responsible for our freedom was facing so many hardships, while the people who were running the Government did not even care a damn about him....Shame on these selfish politicians. Our hearts are breaking into pieces listening to all these things and could not continue to listen it any further. Tears rolling down the eyes...😭😭😭 Sorry Netaji,, ..we did not know anything about you when you were alive 😭😭 Selfish politicians..😡😡
I cried, 😭 he was real father of nation.
Japanese puppet boy.
सुभाष चंद्र बोस जी के बारे में पूरी दुनिया को पता चलना चाहिए
Excellent Job Anuj ji and चंद्रचूड़ जी
Tears came to my eyes, Netaji gave the ultimate sacrifice for his country, shame on politicians .
अच्छी आत्माओं के हिस्से में बलिदान दुख और तिरस्कार ही आता है ❣️🙏😭
Man of his stature lived in India for 30 years and didn't come out in public. That means it was a very big reason for him not to come out in public. The greatest son of monther India.
Tears well up when the old gentleman talks about not having food on some days in the makwshift tent in Lucknow... Even if BhagwanJi was not SC Bose this is common but terrible. BUT if BhagwanJi WAS SC Bose, then the emotion of sheer anger is indescribable.
😭😭😭😭😭 asssu ruk nhi Raha ... Suchi itne bade deshbhakt ki kya durdasha kar di isss desh ... really sorry to neta ji...🙏🙏unke charno me sat sat naman
धन्यवाद आदरणीय श्री सेवको की जिसने नेताजीसुभाष चन्द्र बोस की सेवा और मदद की ((गुमनामी बाबा की)) क्योकी अब एयाश नैताओकी पोल खुल गई हौसला
अनुजजी & चंद्रचूड जी you have done very great job for all Indians who were really want to know What happened with Netaji ....
I m crying,he didn't deserve this kind of miserable life, India's real hero should not have lived like this,
You are such a idiot
While Congress lived like britishers...
न जाने कितनी बार इनका इंटरव्यू सुन चुका हु । दोनों भाग कितनी भी बार सुनो तो भी मन नही भरता ।
😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏we are very sorry netajii aapne desh k liye kya khuch nahi saha 😭😭😢😢aap ko koti koti naman netaji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💐💐💐💐💐
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
#$
It's shame on us how we Indians treat our hero's one of our biggest heroes First PM of Undivided India is treated such as this ... shame on us Sorry Netaji please forgive the Nation
Brilliant job sir.
Good job!!
i cnt stop crying ..feeling angry..very angry...I wish they make movie on this..
There is a Bengali movie on gumnami baba...really loved it
Chandrachur bose and Anuj ji you both are also great man
you are also so fortunate rajkumar ji that you have served for the man who served only of the country.
He & his whole family is so blessed as they could serve & be with this great soul always & especially during the painful periods.
This video brings tears. Dhanya hai Shuklaji 🙏🙏🙏
Great men of India 🙏🙏🙏
history of bharat needs to b corrected.
Please add an English subtitles due I am deaf. It's very frustrated because most of video don't have it... 🙏🏼🙏🏼 Please add it. I kept checking all those videos. Very disappointed ☹️☹️.
Disappointing indeed.
My heart cries out. How ungrateful we r!,We forgot our real heroes n made pigmies our leaders.
भगवन जी की देख भाल करने वाले को मेरा लाखो सलाम 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
So much to learn from Pujya Nataji's immortal Words of conversation - most precious lesson for us. Prayers to Netaji to bless us from his eternal abode of Bliss.🕉👍🕉🙏🙏🙏🙏🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
Sir, you should record him more carefully, so that we could listen him more clearly. His revelation & experience are very important in this case. He is the most vital eye-witness of the entire Gumnami Baba chapter.
Yes.. very true
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@#$
महापुरुषों की सादगी की अमरगाथा ।जय नेता जी ।जय हिंद ।
The Person Who had to become PM of India... live such kind of life. This mystery should be resolve by the government...
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@$^
Jo Insaan ush time ias ban sakta hai jo Insaan khud se army bana sakta hai jo Insaan apni death ki news faila sakta hai wo Insaan ko ye desh na kuch de saka ye desh tha nehru ke layak ishliye nehru mile shayad agar bose mil jaate to aaj bharat vishwaguru hota
100 % sahi bola mera bhai
To be in hideout though being a open secret while a group of opportunist vultures awaiting for his blood, itself was a great symbol of his strong revolutionary and intelligent will power. Even if he left his body he made it to be in his motherland.
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@$%
देश के सच्चे भगवान को देश रहने के लिए जगह भी न दे सका ,,,,शर्मनाक,,,,
😢
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
#$^
I was waiting for this interview.
Thank you so much Sir. 🙏
Jai Hind
Sr..Aap meri inspiration hai.aap jo kr rhe..Uske liye mere paas shabd nahi hai...🙏
It was a very expected video from you Sir.
He became emotional its very sad what we did to our greatest hero
Greatest job sir
The most awaited video.
पता नहीं उस आत्मा की याद में और कितने दिन अकेले में अश्रु धार निकलती रहैगी। शर्म आती है कि इस देश ने कपटी ,नीचे मोहनदास को राष्ट्रपिता व अय्याश जवाहर लाल को चाचा बना दिया।
Dr. Anil Kumar Shandilya....salute n hats off to your statement
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@#$
Netaji😭
Long year's waiting over Chandrachur Da...Hats off to u.. please do interview with Ajay Raj Sharma IPS, Faizabad.. regular visitor of Bhagwanji...
Waiting 4 part 2 of this video...
Sir I can't eat, can't sleep to hear how NETAJI passed his days so painfully!!! WHAT LIFE HE DESERVES AND WHAT LIFE HE GETS FROM THIS COUNTRY, INDIA FR WHOM HE GIVES HIS EVERYTHING TO FREE OUR COUNTRY!!! AS A FREE INDIAN I AM SHAMED FR THIS!!!!!
THOUGH IT IS CLEARED THAT BHAGBANJI IS NETAJI.
I feel the same way. Couldn't hold back my tears. I cried like a baby. There's one consoling thought however. He could ultimately fulfill his childhood ambition...to live the life of a saint. He attained that, having attained which, nothing more remains to be desired for. Jai Hind🙏
PT.Jawaharlal Nehru wanted Netaji to be described as a war criminal, he confided with British and wanted all INA person including Netaji to be detained as per UN resolution, Utter Shame to PT.Nehru
Kahan ka pandit! British stooge!
@@alex_2020 Jawaharlal ko Prime minister banne ki itni padi thi ki usne Desh ke tukde kar Pakistan banvaya, aur partition kai lakh hindu marvaye
He is not Pandit but great Bandit
I think people in authorities did know Gumnami baba was...
The reason he did not get luxuries is bcoz of the declaration that SC Bose is a war criminal..and since India got its dominion status transfered from the British ...
Our govt(congress) and our PM were obliged to handover the war criminals to the British authorities even after the Independence...
This Netaji did know ..thats why he could not have dine anything beside living as Gumnaami Baba....
And authorities despite knowing him he is netaji could not provide him services and could not recognise him as Netaji publically...
For the reason if they do that then Britishers would have taken action against him..and may be do whatever they could...
Thats why the govt needed to hide this fact ..not from the people of India but from the Britishers...
Not only till his natural death in 1985 but even after that...otherwise how would they show loyalty to Britishers...that would be a clear betrayal if they had revealed his identity...!
Plz keep it up.. your research on Subhash ji.. truth should come out one day.. Truth will shine like Sun on india..
Desh Sewa ka ye phal bhagwan kisi aur Rashtrabhakt ko na de .. 😭😭😭😭
He sacrificed for the nation.i am crying .
Speechless...Just no words.😪
Waiting for next part.
Jai Jai ho RASHTRA AMAR VEER HIND PUTTRA NETA JI SUBHASH CHANDAR BOSE JI... AAP KO NGANYABAR PRANAM 🙏🙏🙏
Very heart rendering
उनकी तुरबत पर नहीं है एक भी दीया, जिनके खूं से जलते हैं ये चिरागे वतन। जगमगा रहे हैं मकबरे उनके, बेचा करते थे जो शहीदों के कफन।
@#$%
Thanks to Ghosh & Dhar, kindly give us any chances to help to you. By monetary and other help to fulfill your job smoothly.
बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
When was he interviewed? I was like anyone else waiting to hear him out for long time. Also to Dr R P Mishra’s family.
His description of the events around the time of Bhagwanji’s death would definitely remove the unnecessary cloud being spread.
Some thoughts on how this current situation can be solved and India can officially establish the identity of this great Man.
Why not approaching the court again ? If Mukherjee commission was initiated by the Honourable Allahabad High Court’s order - what was the need for the report to be submitted to the parliament but not to the court?
Can we not appeal to the court to accept the commission’s report? Politicians have their own vested interest. Court’s acceptance would possibly be the only option available to establish the identity of Bhagwanji as Netaji officially!
নেতাজি সুভাষচন্দ্র বসুর জিবনের বিষয়ে যে কথপকথন আমাদের সামনে এত পরিশ্রম করে তুলে ধরেছেন এই অমূল্য সম্পদ তার জন্য কোটি কোটি ধন্যবাদ এবং এটি আগামী জন্মের ভারতবর্ষের জন্য এটা উপলব্ধির কারণ হয়ে দাঁড়াবে আমার বিশ্বাস
But very sad to know that majority of Bengali voted for congress at that time
Dislikes krne wale shayad British k bachhe hai 😠😠😠
Congees, communists, naxalities ...
I sadly say that it is shameful happening that the true Hero of freedom struggle living is such pitiful conditions.This truly shows the greatness of the legend Netaji who selflessly loved his country and sacrificed his life as an unknown identyless brave soul 🙏🏼🪔😭🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼 Om Shanti 🙏🏼
सुभाषचन्द्र बोस जी अमर रहे।
जय हो🙏
Wah!!! isko bolte h real neta hona, jisko mna kr dia toh mna kr dia!!! How respectfully people followed him!!!
request you to put subtitles . then it becomes very clear . thank you both of you great warriors of truth.
How unfortunate this country is 😢
The true Father of the Nation was here with us all the time and we were chewing on the concocted history and worshipping the scamsters.
Shame on us 😞
Excellent work by u two.Awaitng anxiously for part 2.
Netaji subhash chandra boss jindabad ✌🙏
Subhash Chandra Bose living as Gumnami Baba because As he is declared war Criminal by Britishers at Independence time, so if he reveals his identity as Subhash then Indian Government certainly extradited him to England for War Punishment. After meeting with Shastri Ji in 1966 in Tashkent, Shastriji also told nation to bring an assest wìth him but neither Sashtriji returns from Tashkent as he is died and due to this incident, Bose is again failed to return as a Independence Warrior so this might be a reason he changes his whole look into Gumnami Baba and returns into India. Some People says that Subhash Ji died due to Stalin in Russia but if that is true then his belongings didn't come with Gumnami Baba as peoples who met with Gumnami Baba says he has a similar voice as Netaji, talked National politics and International venues. So, If he is a mere Sadhu, then how he knows these International venues. Thirdly, In a news Channel, reports given that Nehruji is written a letter to Britishers that war criminal Subashji has been given shelter by Russian PM Stalin. If he gets a shelter in Russia, then this theory that Boseji is killed by Stalin is useless and he can fled away from Russia with a getup of Gumnami Baba and returns to India without the Knowledge of Then Indian Government around 1970 with the support of Russian Government. Gumnami Baba living in Faizabad is not born in 1985 after some reporters tell about him but he living there around for 10 to 15 years as locals who met him tell so. Now, Bose Ji family didn't recognise him as Gumnami Baba because as Anuj Dhar Sir tells that there is a evidence of contacting family after becoming Gumnami Baba is that if family members of Subhash Ji tells to Nation that Netaji had live in hiding due to that time Indian Government, then public can also put blame on Netaji that He is a brave hero so what is the reason of hiding himself? Then Family members of Bose Family has to answer these tough questions.
Miss you netaji
Ashadharan interview, thanks so much, very good research.
आपकी खोजी जानकारी को सलाम
I always watch your every video on Bhagwanji..... So glad to feel that you try to expose every hidden fact about Netaji. Upload part 2 sir.... We are eagerly waiting
Thank you so much for this much awaited video with Rajkumarji
Jai hind 🙏💕💯🌺
Jai netaji subhas 🙏💕💯🌺
Great interview Chandrachur da and Anujda, waiting for your 2nd part of interview.
Chandrachur,is there any audio/video interview of Rajkumar' mother, Saraswati Devi,whom Bhagwanji used to call mother?
I decided not to comment on this video to describe my heavy heart. I just wonder it must be some dumb and blind who do not see thi respectable simple old man's pain while recalling those miserable days and reject Netaji-Bhagwanji theory.
I am ashamed, our Netaji had to live like this also because of Nehru and Gandhi
Very great efforts Aapka
😭😭😭😭vogban ji up har bharat basi ko antorme homasa rehage 🙏🙏🙏❤️
Chandrachur ji maine aapke bahut sare vedeo dekha ye to clear lg rha hai ki wo netaji hi the lekin .....wo kya chij thi jisne unko apni khud ki pahchan chhupane pr majboor kr diya...... agar wo logo ke samne aate to pura desh unko Gandhi se bhi jyada respect deta ...😞😞
15:41 to 16:00 (epitome of video)
He Man speaks only truth... 🙏🙏
अब तो पिट्ठुओं की सरकार नहीं है फिर सरकार तथ्य क्यो नही बताति।