Soviet Moon Dust - Objectivity 209
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Keith pulls out all the stops and brings us dust from the Moon (via Russia) - ... More links below ↓↓↓
Featuring Keith Moore from The Royal Society speaking with Brady.
Some news about the future of Objectivity: www.bradyharanb...
Objectivity on Patreon: / objectivity
Subscribe to Objectivity: bit.ly/Objectiv...
Films by James Hennessy and Brady Haran
Royal Society website: bit.ly/Royal_So...
The Royal Society's own RUclips channel: / royalsociety
Facebook: / objectivityvideos
Twitter: / objectivity_vid
Patron thank you page: www.bradyharanb...
Objectivity T-Shirts: teespring.com/...
On the future of Objectivity: www.bradyharanblog.com/blog/the-future-of-objectivity
Done. Hope you get a lot more supporters, thanks for this incredible channel. :-)
Thanks for letting us know! I can't donate much, but I'll do what I can, this might be my favorite series on RUclips.
Thanks!
That’s very kind. Thanks for watching.
Keith is a Firefly fan!
Two by two...
Royal Browncoat Society!
Did not expect that, yet at the same time not surprising.
It's a Big Damn Royal Society
Buffy originally then followed Whedon to Firefly
"I've no idea what that was about."
"Alright, you'll find out."
Keith is not only a browncoat; he knows the commenters are too!
Keith about to go get the chain of command!
*Cheering* glad to hear Keith gets it, and that I'm not alone with commenting that quote
I'll be in my bunk.
Keith you just made my day! You can't stop the signal!
Its weird but I never pictured Keith as caring about pop culture at all lol. I dunno why.
"From here to the eyes and the ears of the 'verse"
Kinda losing my mind right now at Keith's reference.
Soviet moon dust... this reeks of conspiracy
"Two by two..."
Keith is a man who knows his audience.
Bravo
2 by 2 hands of blue. Classic.
Said it in my head about 0.5s before he did. Choke, snort, LOL.
Just when you think you can't love Keith any more he casually throws out the "two by two hands of blue" quote.
Brandy's not a Firefly fan... tsk tsk.
But I think I speak for most everyone when I say that Keith, my man, you are the bee's knees! 😊💙💙
I think Bradley and Grey need to do a Firefly review on HI
Is there a running joke about misspelling Brady's name?
As someone who was born in Communist Poland, I always thought that the Luna programme was every bit as cool as Apollo.
When I was a kid I saw a much bigger heap of Soviet moon dust when the Soviet Cosmos space exhibition came to Melbourne. It was a long time ago but I still remember the fortified glass display case it was in.
FIREFLY! Good on ya, Keith! ...Brady, I am disappoint...
Holy crap. Keith just made my day
One small object for Objectivity, one giant thrill for the viewers.
Keith rocks the Firefly reference!
2:10 That container is a beautiful object on its own
Keith is correct. Firefly references are EXACTLY what we want.
2 by 2 hands of blue! Love me a Firefly reference!
Keith quoting _Firefly_ is my new favorite thing in the 'verse!
So cool that Keith is a Firefly fan.
Shiny.
I'm a little sad there wasn't any pictures of Soviet letterhead in this episode.
Bonus points to Keith for the Firefly reference :)
Firefly reference for the win!
I have been waiting for that two by two hands of blue reference, thank you Keith
Keith! *Squeee!* Loved that!
Also, those are pretty grains of moon dust.
You can't take the sky from me!
2:30 love it. Don’t hear that reference very often
I just marathon every single episode of objectivity ever uploaded this is one of the best channels I've stumbled upon keep up the great work Brady and Keith
“Two by two, hands of blue.” Browncoats unite!
Oky I'm even more impressed with Keith Moore. :)
Keith just became 1000x cooler.
Honestly, I can't say that the moon dust sample beats the Genesis Rock and Storage lab. They're pretty cool, but I didn't think Keith had quite pulled it off... *until I saw that presentation box!* Now that is lovely! Also, Keith referencing Firefly! OK, OK, this was as good as the last episode!
Nice to see this kind of exchange between the academies!
Reminds me that Moscow museum of cosmonautics has a sample on display of a few specs of dust from both Apollo 11 and from Luna 16.
(One little thing regarding mentions of Russia, it's always good to remember that Soviet Union consisted of a lot of nations, not only Russia).
You know, scientist (and engineers, BTW) usually doesn't give a serious sh*t about country of origin of the theory/idea/whatever. There are so many things to try and consider - no need to waste your life trying to defend that you belong to the nation that made something 'first' before you were even born. If you want to succeed - make something new in your lifetime.
Artyom Ivankovich Of course, the validity of a scientific theory does not depend on something like nationality. But it is different if you talk about history and not the theory itself. Not because it makes anyone a better person today but it has something to do with acknowledging the history. You know what I mean?
lol yeah, each time I heard "Russia" I kept shouting to my computer "SOVIET!" I mean, the Soviets spoke Russian, and the modern Russian state inherited all the Soviet space program materials... but to call the Soviets "Russian" would be like calling the Americans "English" because Americans speak English and have English history.
@@artyomiv Yeah but when it comes to history it's best to give credit where credit is due. That would be like NOT making a fuss if someone called the Apollo program "English" or "British" because once-upon-a-time the United States of America was once an English/British colony.
A: "But Apollo was an American space program..."
B: "lol no one gives a sh*t about country of origin"
@@pokemonaaah So, let's give credits to Germans :-)
4:13 I REMEMBER THAT GUY! He appeared in Top gear in the challenge to see which professor could do the best burnout (and he won)!
Scientists shuffling about nervously "Oye, you got any moon dust I can have? *sniff* Come on man, just a few grains, I need it!"
I always knew Keith is cooler than he let’s on and now it’s certain! “Two by two....” Outstanding! Like a leaf on the wind!
"largely non-destrictive" had a prof that would laugh whenever he saw this.
INAA analysis doesn't change the mass of the sample, so its called non-destructive, but the isotope signature gets completely destroyed.
Great episode. Love the letters at the end. Interesting how this process goes as people want things and what tests they wanted to do.
Keith attains legend status!
Dude you make the best videos on YT, I just watched a 10 year old Periodic Video... please keep it up!
Thanks. Keep watching and we’ll keep making them.
THe one thing I didn't think I'd hear, a Firefly reference. Shame on Brady for not being a fan!
Soviet Moon Dust will now be the name of a drug in my sci-fi screenplay.
I really just want the Brady and Keith aftershow, where you chat over a pint after recording
YES! THIS!
Knowing what the late great Professor Pillinger FRS went through to get Beagle 2 successfully to Mars, makes this paper trail look like an application for a library card! Credit to the man, his dreams and his perseverance were truly out of this world.
2×2...way to go Mr Moore
I just really love how much solemn reverence the respective governments have for the samples. These little specs of the moon are so awesome that even the governments are geeking out about them.
Keith is a browncoat! ^^
We got a gorram Browncoat in The Royal Society! I have a faint hope for the future rekindling!
You can't stop the signal.
Hi sir
Another interesting topic...
These moon dust/grains are so small...
Nice to watch..
Thanks for the video..🙏👍😊
The label on top of the transport container says "Academy Of Sciences USSR".
The Chang'e 5 mission returned rock and dust from the Moon back in December of 2020.
I am from Slovakia. Does anyone know what happend to Czechoslovakia samples? 5:26
Awesome!!!
1:23 Oh yeah, I remember that mission in Kerbal Space Program!
9:03 I think that is the exact face Brady has made every time he has thought of a new great idea for something like the Hello Internet wax cylinder episode or the HI sneakers.
Look at those, James!
Plllleeeeasssse Brady, can we see Keith's personal fossil collection, the one he mentioned years ago???
How is it possible you have never watched Firefly? This must be fixed!
Are there any grains from earth on the moon?
2:29 Nerdgasm.
definitely a suitable follow-up to the previous film! But was this one also held for four years?
9:02 Brady affirms with James his plans with the moon rocks.
In Austria in Graz 15 years ago i saw a watch with moonrocks
4:12 Jack Nicholson in the Colin Pillinger biopic.
If I had a sample of Moon rock I'd buy the biggest shadow box I could find, put the sample right at the bottom where people can see it and in the biggest font that would fit write "THIS IS A PIECE OF THE MOON!" with a little arrow pointed to the sample.
It's extraordinary, if you actually think about the journey that these grains of moon dust have been on, that humans conveyed pieces of the moon to earth. It's a little like something from a fairytale.
I see freakin' SOVIET MOON DUST, I immediately click
What a lovely object. It does indeed seem more special that NASA's chunks (which are still immensely impressive and interesting) :)
3:05 - "hmm, no hiss..."
Let’s get this out on a tray
Nice idea to set a piece of the moon in a watch but it would have to be an Omega speedmaster for obvious reasons.
Is very interesting that the samples where taken even at a depth of 2 meters at 5:06 time. Now on Mars we can not get to more than 30cm . Why they do not use the same tech to drill to mars???
I think that if I had a grain of moon sand/dirt from one of the missions then I would put in a 1 meter squared frame with an attached magnifying glass on a chain and I would put it on a wall without any obstacle below it so peoples can get near to it.[/long sentence]
It cracks me up how excited you are about grains of sand. Meanwhile, back here in the US we have boxes and boxes of big rocks. How can that possibly top what the US has?
India is going to the moon tomorrow (22 July 2019). Hope they bring back some more samples from moon.
i think they were gold gloves !
It'd be funny if Soviets decided to mess with them and just scooped it all up from some kid's sandbox or something.
Blue Gloves, Brady.... They are blue....
LOL @ Watch!
Honest question: who was more efficient at obtaining lunar samples on a $/kg basis, the Americans or the Soviets? I doubt we can never know for certain because I can't imagine the Soviets kept accurate cost records that would go public (no Senate oversight committee to bother them). If you take just the cost of the actual equipment used on the missions, I'd guess the Americans were more efficient. But if you take the total cost (including all the R&D and training time) it has to be the Soviet method. (I'm discounting all the time/money the Soviets invested in their own manned mission program that ultimately failed).
Unmanned Robots are cheaper
Purple!
So, could you use the Luna samples and compare the chemistry to NASA?
Yes. I believe they have been compared.
Keith saw the moon landing? He doesn't look old enough 😳
Hope i can walk on moon in the future so that i can do an actual moonwalk
USSR ACADEMY OF SCIENCE 🧪 says on the 📦 box
I recently discovered at my local planetarium that they sell actual samples from the moon. They are very thin but "quite" large. And "quite" cheap (35€ each). But that's a moon rock ! I'll buy me one for my birthday.
Whatever those are, they're not samples from manned or unmanned expeditions. They might be moon meteorites.
I have touched large piece of moonrock a few weeks ago.
Bruh. Keith watches firefly.
Haaand Saaand Australiaaaaan
anyone else thinking they'd eat their 1mm moon grain?
BLURPLE gloves
Какой контейнер! ААааах!
I wonder what the soviets thought about the moon landings. Were they a little salty that all they had was some moon dust while the Americans had so much rock? Not to mention a flag there!
Before the moon landings both nations had impacted probes. They would transmit video of them falling and crashing into the surface. A few of the soviet ones were full of hundreds of plaques with the soviet equivalent of USSR on it, as well as the year. They covered the moon in their name before the Americans put up 6 flags
@@benocq That's exactly the worst part. They were pioneering space explorations but they never made it to the moon. The Americans basically snatched the victory.
You can touch a moon rock at NASM in Washington DC.
I touched one at KSC, it was very smooth, from all the touching. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
soviets was cool but they didnt find petrified wood so the americans was much cooler.
I only counted 25, I'm calling the police!
Conspiracy theorist: We have no physical evidence that man landed on the Moon. The Soviets did it all with unmanned probes!
fun fact #1: Apollo returned 1000x more rock/soil samples than the Russians 1/3 kg. They geo-chemically match the Soviet samples and independently collected lunar meteorites.
fun fact #2: The very latest technologically advanced plans on the drawing board for lunar sample return robots would require over 1,500 flights to match the haul collected by the Apollo astronauts!
More proof Americans’s never landed on the moon. I was the Russians.
but the secretive, authoritarian Soviets faked their space program as well!
Checkmate :)