V-Cast: Talking Michigan State finale against Penn State, latest on coaching search.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- SpartanMag staffers Jim Comparoni and Paul Konyndyk check in from Ford Field after Michigan State lost 42-0 to Penn State. We talk state of the program and the latest on the coaching search with wide spread speculation about Oregon State coach Jonathan Smith as the top candidate to take over the Spartan program.
The players may have played their butt off tonight. But I felt like the coordinators quit on this team. So happy that Hazelton and Johnson are finally done!!
I was originally upset about the Jonathan Smith news. But the more I’ve looked into him, but more I’m ok with it.
Penn State fan here. I didn’t see an ounce of quit in the MSU players last night. They didn’t give Penn State an inch in the first half and the score showed it. They got worn out without a ton of subs in the second half. Anyway, having been through our own coaching crisis, I give the young men who stayed with their team and played hard all season a tip of the cap. That’s heart and dedication to teammates and team. See you next year!
Why is your Dick DC blitzing a walk on QB in the last drive? That was BS
@@ryan2985kManny Diaz lost his job at Miami in part because MSU kicked his butt on the road in 2021. I don’t think Penn State finished that game in classy fashion, from blitzing a walk-on to running the ball when they could take a knee, but at the same time if you don’t like it then don’t get beat. They play between those lines until the clock hits zero.
@@ryan2985ku want him to feel bad for the guy and let him score an easy td. Gtfo 😹😹😹
Thank you for enduring the season. We don’t have access to the press conference videos without you guys, and your analysis is appreciated. Here’s to Jonathan Smith and we need Barnett and coaches like him to retain the spirit of MSU with a young guy from the west coast becoming our head coach. Go Green!
I know I’m bias, because I love Spartan Stadium, but if they’d move the last game of the year to Detroit every year would be a bad look for the program. Basically saying “we know our fans won’t come out in the cold”. Ohio State and Michigan don’t have that issue. And to not make a west coast team play in the cold? That’d be a miss.
The Friday after thanksgiving most students are not on campus. It’s always going to be a lower turnout game in spartan stadium.
@@markwebster4996First of all, most people that watch games at Spartan Stadium are not current students.
Second, Spartan stadium has hosted games after Thanksgiving before. People showed up.
Third, cold weather games are part of college football tradition.
Great Coverage this year Jim and @SpartanMag staff.
Recover, Restructure, Rebuild... Reach Higher!... as we shall rise again.
My Heart of Hearts go to all the Players this year, rough year is an understatement, but for the players who illustrated what LOYALTY genuinely means.... thank you!!
💚SD4L💚 Go Green!!!
Michigan fan here: I’ve been through the rough years of late Lloyd Carr / rich Rodriquez / the ups and mostly downs of Brady Hoke and now Jim Harbaugh. The one thing I always take away, is no matter how much you lose or win by, these kids chose to come to your school. Whether that is Michigan or MSU, or whatever school. As fans, we shouldn’t question the heart or determination of the players, just competency of the coaching. These are the young men that will shape our future as a nation, placed on public stage. Win or lose, support them and watch them grow.
I hated the idea of playing FF initially, then I realized 99% of the students are at home in Detroit on Thanksgiving anyway. So maybe not a bad deal. I'm sure you had more fans that stayed in FF than would have at SS. You could do a double play with MSU hockey at LCA.
Saying the players gave their all makes it even sadder by emphasizing the talent gap.
If we want positives from this season, I'd say Eckley is about as good of a replacement for Barringer as we could realistically hope for, Jonathan Kim is a good college kicker, we have established Leavitt as by far the best quarterback remaining on our roster, Carter is good, the defensive line has been intermittently sturdy against the run despite the injuries and attrition (at the start of the game Penn State gave up on running it after being stopped on first and 1 and ran back to back passing plays), and it looks like we are finally going to have a competent coaching staff. A lot of other pieces need to be fixed. And we could easily lose some of those good points to the transfer portal.
Not sure who this tall guy is but don’t agree with him at all on recruiting. Of course we need the local kids but these days the best players are from the south these days are Texas, Florida and Georgia. That’s why the best teams are Georgia, Alabama, Texas and Florida State. Michigan State needs to be a national brand not a regional brand. We want to compete with Ohio State, Michigan and the rest of the top 10. Technically in the future we want to be competing every year for a playoff spot that should be the goal. Of course I want Urban Meyer as the next coach and make him the highest paid coach in the country. If he passes then he passes. Michigan State needs to go big or go home that’s it!!! Johnathon Smith I think would be ok along with Elko from Duke or Lance Leipold. Regarding playing in Detroit I’ve been saying for years Sparty should have 1 home game every year at Ford Field. It can help in recruiting and improves the image of the program to play on the bigger stages and in the best stadiums.
That's the typical msu mentality. What this guy doesn't know would fill a book. Milk toast
Facts 💯 it's like dudes feel comfortable when we're mediocre, or win every ten years or so. Mel Tucker made a huge personal decision that affected the team, but I see what he was trying to do recruiting wise. So we'll see how Jonathan Smith does. Go Green Go White!💯💪🔥
We have to recruit nationally, or we're never going to compete! You dudes sound crazy! Go Green Go White!🔥💪💯
"We need to get back to that 5-hour radius....now lets go get a guy from Oregon who's never been to the Midwest" - SMH. "We need a coach who doesn't need a map to drive to Flint" -Drew Stanton on John L Smith
I’ve been to about 15 MSU football games and this was the first one I Left early. My family and my brother-in-law‘s family left in the third quarter. That game was unwatchable.
As a Penn State fan I do respect you guys for calling it how it is.
Can you please post Tom Izzo's post press conference after Arizona game
Random thoughts from a PSU fan. PSU was where Sparty is, different circumstances, so we feel your pain. Sparty played their guts out until depth took over. I am surprised to see the darts being thrown at a coaching staff that ran out of bullets. Great idea to put this game at Ford Field. But, please don't do this in the future for the new Pac 12 members. Kenneth Walker got Mel Tucker a contract he never deserved. Tucker, was fools gold and was the cancer that sucked the life out of Sparty. Put the blame where is should be. Tucker's deal is also what got James Franklin his ten-year deal. Sparty fans were all class and showed PSU fans a fun time. Good luck, get the next hire right, and let us show our new members what BIG TEN football is all about.
J Smith and Comp could pass for brothers...
Step brothers. “DID WE JUST BECOME BEST FRIENDS?!”
Penn State fan here, ya’ll got beat down.
We have a positions coach calm down little cat.
@@spartandogs3126 Penn State doesn’t have an OC, we went 10-2 with a mid at best offense and still had 3 shutouts. I have to say this because as much as I respect MSU, anyone that is in the BIG is in our way. It’s just business, nothing personal.
"It's hard to get a winning power 5 coach from another team" - Yeah, now continue with that logic. Why is it hard? Because if they're winning , they're going to get paid. And they aren't going to leave a good situation. If you can get a winning power-5 coach, what are the chances they aren't really that good??
I prefer a coach who has proven they are elite on some level with a varied resume. Not 6 years at the same place with an overall losing record and essentially ONE marquee win in their career. I mean if we want to hire Jon Smith for his win against Oregon last year, why not get the coach from App State for beating A&M?
Those players that remain for next year will be rewarded by having better coaches and a bowl game.
Haha bowl game.
I doubt anyone is questioning the players. And you can never hate Harlan Barnett, he smiles too much. I don't even blame Mel Tucker, I blame the idiots who hired Mel Tucker.
And if those same idiots hire Jon Smith, I will blame them when the program starts to resemble Nebraska.
I know some fans, like Jim, like Smith, but he will absolutely be a dismal failure at MSU. I'm hoping Haller proves me wrong and surprises me with someone else.
Best sign right now is Jon Smith wasn't hired yet, meaning there's a good chance he won't be.
I hope they told both coordinators to start packing unless they’re willing to accept a demotion to the janitorial department.
if you listen close and read between the lines you can understand what Paul thinks of Tucker.
53 total yards and -35 rushing yards.
Imagine if this team had quit. Is negative total yards ever been done in the history of college football?
Players didn’t want to quit but they also know that football is a very physical game. Major injury is only a play away. Why would anyone risk injury for a non-consequential game?
Of course, they pulled back some. I don’t blame them either.
What is Paul talking about?? No one is questioning effort, they were obliterated on the field!!!
Moving the last game to Detroit would be terrible and isn't needed at all. Imagine having an advantage vs USC then moving the game away for them lol
I agree, footballs an outdoor game. All my favorite games I’ve been to were played in bad weather.
The players are great the coaching staff quit on us
How is Paul doing this video with Jonathan Smith? 😂
It's the magic of SpartanMag television.
Excited for the J Smith era if he ends up the guy! A solid football coach, no BS just a solid players coach.
The guy is a loser. I want to vomit that people are cheering on this horrible, horrible potential hire. Haller needs to be fired if he hires Jon Loser Smith.
Anyone who would talk down on the players is awful. The coaching staff is/are/were terrible.
68 total yards of offense. They played their tails off. Come on now.
When you are completely demoralized on the field in multiple games, the best you can hope for is a complete overhaul of the coaching staff, and that’s the only positive you can take from this-there will be a new staff in the next 5 days.
Otherwise, this season was a COMPLETE disaster.
This season will set MSU back 5-10 years. Talent level is sub par and recruits are decomitting and players leaving for portal. No other way to say it, this year was a dumpster fire. With the BIG expanding MSU will never win BIG tittle again.
This is why teams stay bad, sympathy. If you get your ass kicked. Own it
Msu doesn't have the ability to abandon hiring mediocrity. They can't abandon it because that's all they can get as head coach. I also find it hilarious that this was tuckers year, he had his recruits and tucks coming. This was every sparty fans mentality. Well when this unfolded it was " were were only supposed to win 5 or six games at best😂😂😂 " tucker was never vetted before the hire and the rest is history. Spartan football is cooked for over a decade.
This is a stupid comment
Agree!
@@stevenculver6416pedophile Wolverine fan
@@johnpizanis591Wolverine bot
Was at ford field. Absolutely the worst coaching ever….. This program needs a total PURGE of the coaches….. And then the AD needs to be fired….. He’s going to hire a coach that at best brings a 50/50 record… REALLY🤔🤔👀 So why would ANY recruit sign. People were walking out early in the 3rd quarter.. Who’s going to pay for advertising when nobody wants to watch….. ??????
You have to face some reality with MSU football. They don't have enough talent and were led by lame duck coaches, the lone exception being Harlon Barnett. The "what if" game doesn't help at all. The Spartans are a bad team, especially on offense.
Jon Smith: Best scenario for him to succeed is at his alma mater. He has an overall losing record, went 6-3 and 5-4 in conference the last two years. That's in the best scenario for this guy to win. Put him in EL, and what? 5-7 every year??? I just want to vomit at the thought of this clown coming to MSU.
✌️ then 🤡
@JustinHudson-cx5ym I wanted MSU to replicate Dantonio's success. Elko was my favorite. But get a Midwest guy not some clown from Oregon with one #17 ranking under his belt and a losing record.
@JustinHudson-cx5ym I see time as a problem. You don't build a program in one year. Especially at MSU. If this guy recruits like he did at OSU, mostly weak 3-star guys. And wins 5-6 games per year for 3-5 years. It will take the next coach 3-5 years to restock. People will always say "you have to give him 4 years to get his own players". That's why you don't mindlessly pick a HC. At least get someone who recruits well. I doubt that's Smith.
Cry me a River, I know it was Harbaugh's fault
What?
Don’t talk about what ifs. Total waste of time.
USC at Spartan Stadium. No f ing way. Let em play in the cold.
When the west coast teams come to MI, we can only hope it’ll be a blizzard. Big home field advantage