The defense has pretty much said law enforcement, MUSC, SLED, coroner and all others who were witnesses for the prosecution are INCOMPETENT. All of the defense witnesses, according to defense lawyers , have more education, experience, better work facilities with state of the art equipment to conduct test and various analyses that SC can only dream about. So where are the clothes he had on? A shower was taken according to his own brother. Paw Paw left the most compelling evidence….. AM was at the kennel, the dogs were not barking or agitated because they knew the three persons there :Alec, Paw Paw, and Mags two are dead and the killer remains.
The richer and more prominent you are, the longer your "trial" goes on. Have you noticed that? I think Alex should be found guilty. But I will not be surprised when they find him not guilty.... like they did with OJ. The richer and more famous you are, the less likely that you will ever be held to account for your actions.
If the Forensic Pathologist gets paid $600/hour or $5500/day for testimony for that amount he shouldn’t be consecutively labeling/confusing the ‘Angle of the Mandible’ with the ‘Chin’.
Well, Paul didn’t murder Mallory. DUI with fatality is not charged as a murder. That happens a lot with drinking young people. Most of them understand but they never think it will happen to them. He still had a life to lead. One would hope to inform the community about drinking and boating being the same as driving a vehicle. I’m not convinced Maggie went berserk and pushed the housekeeper. Sure it’s highly suspicious but what reason would she have to do that. As far as the hit and run paint flecks we’re found on the young man. Consistent with hit and run. They’ve reopened it yes. Will they have anything other than town gossip…doubt. I am not saying Buster wasn’t involved but ya have yo have something. At some point all the money grab lawsuits make me NOT believe the cases.
What is confusing me in this case is why Alex needed to steal hundreds of thousands/millions of dollars. I hear his drug habit as the reason but I don't buy that he could spend that much on pills, nowhere close. He has a good enough income to afford a robust pill habit unless opiates cost way more than where I am. He comes from generations of upper class wealth and power. I doubt he even had a big mortgage to worry about. Where was all this money going?
The thing that is difficult for us normal people to understand is that people who get drunk on power don't need any other reason to pursue power than power itself. Aside from power being a means to an end that is more power, they're not thinking functionally. The money was probably "invested" in corruption, besides quality of life of a hedonistic lifestyle. The whole pill-snagging thing is a red herring. He seems like an intelligent guy, but the Achilles' Heel of the pathological narcissist is that in their egocentricity and arrogance they constantly underestimate people, as if they didn't even deserve a realistic assessment from their supreme intellect. I can't believe he thought the pill addiction story would fly as an excuse for embezzling, as if people were incapable of doing basic math. That's how arrogant he is. It's also hilarious observing these crooks (Alex and John) put in their best effort in trying to display human emotions while feeling around in the dark trying to guess what an adequate emotional response is expected to look like in this situation. I'm not saying they're not skilled, but Alex has been under the spotlight for such an extended period of time that all the cracks in his facade are apparent. I assure you they have no idea how inauthentic their gig is, and were you to confront them about it with comprehensive explanation as to why, they would be enraged that you dare cast doubt on their sophisticated artificial expression of emotion from your inferior position with your socially conforming expression of your insignificant and unremarkable human emotion. "Such impudence, who do these people think they are, that our elaborate and complex lies are not as good as truth to them?" That's the gist of it.
I went into this trial believing he did it, but I'm not sure anymore. If he didn't do it, there's a killer still out there, and apparently no one is looking...
And why have you changed your mind? Is it sympathy for his constant rocking and crying? Or Facts? I do believe he had something to do with it, he may not have been the shooter though.
It would have been physically impossible for someone to arrive on the scene, knowing Paul and Maggie would be in that precise spot, without weapons, and commit the crime after Alex was at the kennels. He already said the dogs didn't bark. And he lied to the very first cop on the scene. Guilty. That said, I think the prosecution needs to put forth something about a motive in the closing arguments (although not required to) because many people would have a problem convicting someone of murdering their family with only circumstantial evidence and no clear motive. I'm calling "hung jury" unless the closing argument is solid.
How would you justify an 'unknown assailant' running off from his Property completed undetected? All within 10 mins of having his Wife's guts sprayed all over his shirt?
Hurts me as well, incomplete, I still think the state had very little evidence, I think the Judge was favoring the state case sloppy evidence collection
Never had a chance for a fair trial,,,should have been far away....The two shooter indication makes more sense, I think his wife an$ Son were shot but the shooters were after Alec
@Angela Barsekian Agreed! The defense forgot to show up for closing arguments... which leads me to believe that Alex was chosen to fall on his sword to cover up an even bigger conspiracy... but what...any ideas? South Carolina is a scary kinda place.
there's also a theory that Paul & the Wife were on him about his addiction, and like any all-in addict, he shot them out of anger. He's so used to getting away with hiding crimes, I bet it didn't even dawn on him, he'd be charged for this.
This female thinks that sarcasm gives her professional credibility. She is terrible. These questions make the prosecution look weak. They no longer look very confident. JMO
Who else sees through this fake smoke and mirrors crap. I've never saw a trial with so much evedance being purposely evaded. The prosecutor is throwing the case, horrible job. He is going to walk. Shame on this show, they the good ole boys club and all eat dinner together. Wonder what the pay off was.
Ok, I'm so glad someone else has issues with the prosecution. I thought, stop asking him to repeat the same thing over and over. Eventually, some of its gonna stick, and the prosecution is the reason. Move on.
Exactly... Why didn't the lady in black press more about the probable height of the killer.... that he was hugely tall .. just like good ole boy Alec 🧐
The fact that John Marvin is so much more emotional than AM it is obvious that he was much more closer to Paul!! And so much more tore up about his father than AM by far 😢
He's a Murdaugh..they all will stick together..they 4th generation..if Alex goes down the dynasty, power and priveledge ends..John Marvin (doing quick search admittingly) apparently has BA in criminal justice...hmmm!
9 out of 10 negative comments come from accounts created NO MORE than exactly 2 years ago. I wonder why. But if you haven’t seen AM being emotional, you haven’t watched. Not just sitting at the defense table.
@@HD_Diesel_Mechanic 8:44pm AM is with them at the kennels - by voice in video-, 8:49 PM and MM phones are locked forever -not using by they owner besides they tend to answer everything fast- who you think kills them? 5 minutes…so many lies he has said making he suspicious….and yes ! he has to be emotional it is a trial by jury
@@HD_Diesel_Mechanic what in the world are you talking about fake Accounts ? I think he did it! I also have not seen him get anywhere as emotional as JMM
1700 acres and the shooter knew the in's and out's of that property and how to get to both Paul and Maggie via atv, golf cart, or just happened to be camping out without being seen or heard by dogs? Not to mention the fact of a botch search of the house when they had a warrant due to Alex was calling everyone to come over and stay.🤔 That placed should have been sealed off completely as well as the house, so nobody would interfere until the investigation was over. How the hell does this happen?
The dogs 100% would have alerted at any stranger walking up. Those are hunting dogs-they aren’t quiet city pets. It’s actual proof that Alec did it in my opinion. The timing is too short. 5 minutes. He shot them literally right after that video! He probably freaked out when Paul’s phone rang when Rogan called and kept calling. Thank goodness that Cash had that little issue with his tail/back end and Paul was videoing and trying to get thru to Rogan. Paul needs a ghost so he can point at his father but this video and tech timed records are doing it.
It's called Google Earth. Look at the property. They've told the address and showed the Google Maps multiple times. It was completely straight forward and didn't need to be scouted for more than a few minutes. Three buildings, two dirt driveways, nothing but grass and dirt in between, no trees except on property boundary then there is a tree barrier. Easy to access via main road.
John M M sounds just like Alec M, his brother. Every time I turned around I had to see who really was answering the cherry picked out questions of the pro-accusers and pro-defenders.
something fishy about his car story he cleaned the crime scene up and led police to the phone alex put maggies phone there before he went to the house to start calling it and his brother is involved
It’s insane to see the physical transformation in Alex. He seems to have really aged. N is it frickin Alec or Alex? I feel like everyone calls him something different lol
@@ILUVXO yep! 🙃🤪 they probably changed the way they say it because saying MURDAUGH comes out “murdaw” which sounds like the country version of saying MURDER which comes out “murda” LOL!😂
I agree. I wanna throw-up when I see him shaking his head and smacking his lips together when who ever is talking about Maggie and Paul and brain matter!!!!!
@@shadymistkennel lmao you're clueless if you think this. Hint: the goal is to be objective and look at the evidence in a case not use your subjective pre determined opinion and ignore everything else. Reasonable doubt still exists
@@Zeta-vb2xh absolutely 💯 agreed. The prosecution has nothing to say or they would be all over the expert testimony. The female was just nasty. Her questions were weak at best.
It’s actually scary imo because I do think the defense has created reasonable doubt. It’s really going to be sad if they are unable to convict him of these murders. I don’t think the investigation was handled properly, and because of that they don’t have a strong case in the court of law. In the court of opinion I think we all know what really happened.
What was the relationship, if any between Alec, Paul and Paul's mother, of Michael Satterdileld and family, before and after the law suit? How long was Michael S and his family seeking revenge against the Murdaugh family, because he didn't get the millions and sued Alec again after the double murders, to get their millions and did they get their 4.3 mil?
I am not sure why the defense is belaboring Paul's fatal shot to the head, insisting it was a contact wound from the top rather than an exit wound from the left and below/horizontal? The fact is, Paul had his brain blown out of his head by a brutal murder. Whether a contact shot entrance or a horizontal shot exit, neither exonerates AM. I still believe AM is guilty of these murders.
I’m also curious why they are basically solely focusing on Paul’s shot to the head. Did we miss something as to why this shot is so important? Is it a determining factor who shot him? I just don’t understand.
I think prosecution doing good job. Paul taking John's white F150 (just like his own) and John Marvin taking F250 to house (couldn't take wife's car as she had to take kids to school in morning! Seriously questionable). Read lawsuit on Paul dropped when he was murdered if true there's motive Murdaugh money stays in family.. so far I think Judge Newman fair..
How can he narrate Alex’s dream as being dreaming about what he found of Paul and Maggie, is he Joseph/Daniel. Could it have been he was dreaming of what he did to Maggie and Paul.
8:33:39 and do we really need to hear that BS from the old defense lawyer ? He blames the time spent on witnesses on the State alone!! However if anyone would measure time spent with each witness I’m pretty certain that he has always taken the longest!! Just for example he bites down on a specific detail and then argues with the witness back and forth like a puppy playing with a toy- for hours!!! So WHO is wasting the courts time???? HE IS!!! Why blame another person?? Obnoxious!! 🤮🤢
It took me about an hour and a half to walk 283 steps just moving around my living room, kitchen, bathroom, etc. this am. How Alex could have walked that many steps in such close quarters, and lying down on the couch as well in such a short amount of time ??? I find that impossible!
How many steps is a 5 minute walk? 624 steps Steps in 5 minutes (based on speed and height) 3.5 mph - 624 steps. 4 mph - 668 steps. 250 steps is roughly 2 to 3 minutes of walking.
How the heck in a number of hours is that crime seen released? Why was a uncle left to clean away the remainder of his nephew (how was that released) Why were people allowed to congregate in the house Why was John marvin allowed to drive his truck away from the scene? Considering his nephew was the last person to drive it So many things seem outrageous to me and I know diddley squat about crime scene protocol. But this whole thing seems a complete shambles.
My theory......he was involved with the murder....maybe had another person there to help him. He clearly was at the kennels within minutes of the murders....maybe he shot maggie and someone else shot his son.....They did him so bad.....he said (or something like that). Shoddy work by SLED. Though the original lead of the investigation was his buddy...so there is so much complicity......
The only clue I see to an additional killer was AM saying “here” on the 911call…like he was handing something to someone-BUT he is still guilty in that case…and it would be someone the dogs already knew well since they weren’t agitated… Maybe the Kennel washing guy(?) But it could be anyone that hunted with them. However he may have mumbled “here” to himself or to one of the dogs.
yep! “might, probably, could have, I think, I believe, I remember, I assume, maybe, should have, It’s possible”, etcetc. There should be a language monitoring system that beeps every time a qualifier is used. People don’t like to lie and the qualifier allows them to say the lie in a way that’s not “quite” a lie. Like OJ’s. “if I killed them.” That tiny “if” lets him off from a true confession!
@@beastshawnee exactly what I meant to say!! He even said something like this: “Was your father ill? he answers “No he wasn’t ill”, the prosecutor replies “Okay? Wasn’t that what you just said?” and he replies “My dad was VERY SICK, that’s what I said!!!” Twisting his words, being this way, really makes questioning him very challenging!!! He uses Qualifiers Too Much!!! Makes me sick listening to him….. 🤢🤮
Why doesn't Alex just say someone handed him a gun that wasn't loaded. It worked for Baldwin. No one can figure out HE put the live round in the gun. Reasonable doubt.
So I find him GUILTY. But my brother reminded me it's better to let ten guilty people be free than to put one not guilty person in prison. I want the laws to be but I know he murdered them.
No. That dumb mantra doesn’t cut real life mustard. Want me to explain? Well I’ll say this…if your family member was a victim of a heinous crime will you be the first to say….let him go because 10 guilty going free is better? You think on that. It’s a garbage statement used by pro criminal folks. UNLESS it happens to them, THEN it’s a different attitude all of a sudden.
State says time of death. To make shory fit. I think drug dealers are involved. No way Alec Could kill Paul. Alec said more than once they did them bad. State kept saying 8:45. Med examiner did not say that. State did to make story fit. To go from happy with the dogs to two brutal murders, why?
Does the main Judge ever talk with the Judge Juries looking over any evidence or 2 or more eye witnesses? Do these Judges, picked by man know God's statue and judgments are for judges to follow, being "one nation under God" and his are above all.
what has the family actually done to , as Alecs bro promissed " find out who did this to you", ie Paw paw... have they offered a reward? god knows they all seem rich enough.... have they pettitioned the public for info on any platforms at all?
@6:58:45 - Well Golly Gee Hornswogglers ah jist hed to go an clean upp all dat forensic evdience from yon crime scene, like any good ole country boy wood do for a bruddah who murdered he wife & son. Heavens to Betsy, ah do declarah, where *is* mah pearels?
@@jmortonburden6164 Lawd's a'mercy, we dun got us anudder guid ole boy moseyin' on over in up in 'ere. It be like Alec dun sayed, y'awl gots to shoot dem hawgs runnin wile on muh prappety, whin he seed MawMaw (that's Mags) down on all fours rooting aroun among dem pine saplings he'd a planted in de spring for dem doves to roost on it were pure primal reflex to grab dat Blackout 300 outta he truck an let her have it repeatedly until the squealin stopped. PawPaw's brain jist happen git in da way when he be checkin he phone like any dumb millenial do be doing all day evriy day. An thassa troof, so halp me Gawd!
The defense has pretty much said law enforcement, MUSC, SLED, coroner and all others who were witnesses for the prosecution are INCOMPETENT. All of the defense witnesses, according to defense lawyers , have more education, experience, better work facilities with state of the art equipment to conduct test and various analyses that SC can only dream about. So where are the clothes he had on? A shower was taken according to his own brother. Paw Paw left the most compelling evidence….. AM was at the kennel, the dogs were not barking or agitated because they knew the three persons there :Alec, Paw Paw, and Mags two are dead and the killer remains.
![Chris Langan - The Interview THEY Didn't Want You To See - CTMU [Full Version; Timestamps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9miVG2xT5jY/mqdefault.jpg)
The woman coughing every two seconds should have left the courtroom. Some people have no common sense.
The defense has pretty much said law enforcement, MUSC, SLED, coroner and all others who were witnesses for the prosecution are INCOMPETENT. All of the defense witnesses, according to defense lawyers , have more education, experience, better work facilities with state of the art equipment to conduct test and various analyses that SC can only dream about. So where are the clothes he had on? A shower was taken according to his own brother. Paw Paw left the most compelling evidence….. AM was at the kennel, the dogs were not barking or agitated because they knew the three persons there :Alec, Paw Paw, and Mags two are dead and the killer remains.
The richer and more prominent you are, the longer your "trial" goes on. Have you noticed that? I think Alex should be found guilty. But I will not be surprised when they find him not guilty.... like they did with OJ. The richer and more famous you are, the less likely that you will ever be held to account for your actions.
Are you still considered rich if the money you have was all stolen?
@@kimberlysnow1465 His family is very rich, that's who is paying for his attorneys.
@@kimberlysnow1465 have you heard of donald trump?
Yes, I thought all this too! I also think it's going on longer than it should to make an actual show of it.
@@sabinekatsavrias4422 🙄
I sure wish dogs could talk
Lol. Don't we all?
They do in movies.
If the Forensic Pathologist gets paid $600/hour or $5500/day for testimony for that amount he shouldn’t be consecutively labeling/confusing the ‘Angle of the Mandible’ with the ‘Chin’.
Don't think this is the first murder from this family
Not even from precious generations-the talk was already that the Murdaughs could make you disappear in his grandfather’s generation!
Well, Paul didn’t murder Mallory. DUI with fatality is not charged as a murder. That happens a lot with drinking young people. Most of them understand but they never think it will happen to them. He still had a life to lead. One would hope to inform the community about drinking and boating being the same as driving a vehicle. I’m not convinced Maggie went berserk and pushed the housekeeper. Sure it’s highly suspicious but what reason would she have to do that. As far as the hit and run paint flecks we’re found on the young man. Consistent with hit and run. They’ve reopened it yes. Will they have anything other than town gossip…doubt. I am not saying Buster wasn’t involved but ya have yo have something. At some point all the money grab lawsuits make me NOT believe the cases.
What is confusing me in this case is why Alex needed to steal hundreds of thousands/millions of dollars.
I hear his drug habit as the reason but I don't buy that he could spend that much on pills, nowhere close. He has a good enough income to afford a robust pill habit unless opiates cost way more than where I am.
He comes from generations of upper class wealth and power. I doubt he even had a big mortgage to worry about.
Where was all this money going?
The thing that is difficult for us normal people to understand is that people who get drunk on power don't need any other reason to pursue power than power itself. Aside from power being a means to an end that is more power, they're not thinking functionally. The money was probably "invested" in corruption, besides quality of life of a hedonistic lifestyle. The whole pill-snagging thing is a red herring. He seems like an intelligent guy, but the Achilles' Heel of the pathological narcissist is that in their egocentricity and arrogance they constantly underestimate people, as if they didn't even deserve a realistic assessment from their supreme intellect. I can't believe he thought the pill addiction story would fly as an excuse for embezzling, as if people were incapable of doing basic math. That's how arrogant he is. It's also hilarious observing these crooks (Alex and John) put in their best effort in trying to display human emotions while feeling around in the dark trying to guess what an adequate emotional response is expected to look like in this situation. I'm not saying they're not skilled, but Alex has been under the spotlight for such an extended period of time that all the cracks in his facade are apparent. I assure you they have no idea how inauthentic their gig is, and were you to confront them about it with comprehensive explanation as to why, they would be enraged that you dare cast doubt on their sophisticated artificial expression of emotion from your inferior position with your socially conforming expression of your insignificant and unremarkable human emotion. "Such impudence, who do these people think they are, that our elaborate and complex lies are not as good as truth to them?" That's the gist of it.
This is insane
I went into this trial believing he did it, but I'm not sure anymore. If he didn't do it, there's a killer still out there, and apparently no one is looking...
Absolutely 💯 agree
And why have you changed your mind? Is it sympathy for his constant rocking and crying? Or Facts?
I do believe he had something to do with it, he may not have been the shooter though.
Like OJ. The real killer is on a golf course somewhere.
It would have been physically impossible for someone to arrive on the scene, knowing Paul and Maggie would be in that precise spot, without weapons, and commit the crime after Alex was at the kennels. He already said the dogs didn't bark. And he lied to the very first cop on the scene. Guilty. That said, I think the prosecution needs to put forth something about a motive in the closing arguments (although not required to) because many people would have a problem convicting someone of murdering their family with only circumstantial evidence and no clear motive. I'm calling "hung jury" unless the closing argument is solid.
How would you justify an 'unknown assailant' running off from his Property completed undetected? All within 10 mins of having his Wife's guts sprayed all over his shirt?
play the kennel video and ask him if hes shocked that alex was there
This trial hurts me.
Hurts me as well, incomplete, I still think the state had very little evidence, I think the Judge was favoring the state case sloppy evidence collection
Never had a chance for a fair trial,,,should have been far away....The two shooter indication makes more sense, I think his wife an$ Son were shot but the shooters were after Alec
@Angela Barsekian Agreed!
The defense forgot to show up for closing arguments... which leads me to believe that Alex was chosen to fall on his sword to cover up an even bigger conspiracy... but what...any ideas?
South Carolina is a scary kinda place.
I think Buster did paw paw in for the money 💵 💵
there's also a theory that Paul & the Wife were on him about his addiction, and like any all-in addict, he shot them out of anger. He's so used to getting away with hiding crimes, I bet it didn't even dawn on him, he'd be charged for this.
@@SINJONES Look at the way he was drinking that water ohh boy ...Once they announced photos his heart started palpitating
He’s rocking. Self soothing.
This female thinks that sarcasm gives her professional credibility. She is terrible. These questions make the prosecution look weak. They no longer look very confident. JMO
I agree 😂
Who else sees through this fake smoke and mirrors crap. I've never saw a trial with so much evedance being purposely evaded. The prosecutor is throwing the case, horrible job. He is going to walk. Shame on this show, they the good ole boys club and all eat dinner together. Wonder what the pay off was.
Ok, I'm so glad someone else has issues with the prosecution. I thought, stop asking him to repeat the same thing over and over. Eventually, some of its gonna stick, and the prosecution is the reason. Move on.
I couldn’t watch her anymore
Exactly... Why didn't the lady in black press more about the probable height of the killer.... that he was hugely tall .. just like good ole boy Alec 🧐
evedance
@@hoss-lk4bg evidence
The lady prosecutor wearing all black is an absolute embarrassment.. she isn’t doing the prosecution team any favors acting so incompetent
I disagree. I like her.
She’ll be under the guidance of Mr Waters
Agreed! Her body language was so awkward what with folding her arms as if she didn't know what to do with them.
She reminded me of Cruella. I didn't get a good vibe from her.
@@rswfire is the jury all Caucasian?
The fact that John Marvin is so much more emotional than AM it is obvious that he was much more closer to Paul!! And so much more tore up about his father than AM by far 😢
He's a Murdaugh..they all will stick together..they 4th generation..if Alex goes down the dynasty, power and priveledge ends..John Marvin (doing quick search admittingly) apparently has BA in criminal justice...hmmm!
9 out of 10 negative comments come from accounts created NO MORE than exactly 2 years ago. I wonder why. But if you haven’t seen AM being emotional, you haven’t watched. Not just sitting at the defense table.
@@HD_Diesel_Mechanic 8:44pm AM is with them at the kennels - by voice in video-, 8:49 PM and MM phones are locked forever -not using by they owner besides they tend to answer everything fast- who you think kills them? 5 minutes…so many lies he has said making he suspicious….and yes ! he has to be emotional it is a trial by jury
@@HD_Diesel_Mechanic what in the world are you talking about fake Accounts ? I think he did it! I also have not seen him get anywhere as emotional as JMM
yeah but he is still covering for his bro
1700 acres and the shooter knew the in's and out's of that property and how to get to both Paul and Maggie via atv, golf cart, or just happened to be camping out without being seen or heard by dogs? Not to mention the fact of a botch search of the house when they had a warrant due to Alex was calling everyone to come over and stay.🤔 That placed should have been sealed off completely as well as the house, so nobody would interfere until the investigation was over. How the hell does this happen?
The dogs 100% would have alerted at any stranger walking up. Those are hunting dogs-they aren’t quiet city pets. It’s actual proof that Alec did it in my opinion. The timing is too short. 5 minutes. He shot them literally right after that video! He probably freaked out when Paul’s phone rang when Rogan called and kept calling. Thank goodness that Cash had that little issue with his tail/back end and Paul was videoing and trying to get thru to Rogan. Paul needs a ghost so he can point at his father but this video and tech timed records are doing it.
It's called Google Earth. Look at the property. They've told the address and showed the Google Maps multiple times. It was completely straight forward and didn't need to be scouted for more than a few minutes. Three buildings, two dirt driveways, nothing but grass and dirt in between, no trees except on property boundary then there is a tree barrier. Easy to access via main road.
@@beastshawnee They weren't at the kennel when they were shot. They were walking back to the house.
I hope Alex has nightmare s of what he did to wife and son and all the people he stole from .
He doesn't. He's a psychopath. Bet he sleeps no problem
Alecs bro looked like he was lying the whole time he was up there with his red face and body language.
Do not feel the same Honesr
John M M sounds just like Alec M, his brother. Every time I turned around I had to see who really was answering the cherry picked out questions of the pro-accusers and pro-defenders.
something fishy about his car story he cleaned the crime scene up and led police to the phone alex put maggies phone there before he went to the house to start calling it and his brother is involved
He did seem to be involved heavily
EVEN O.J. was smart enough not to take the stand!!!
Where'd they get the first defense witness from? Temp Services?
It’s insane to see the physical transformation in Alex. He seems to have really aged. N is it frickin Alec or Alex? I feel like everyone calls him something different lol
Spelled Alex pronounced Alec
Just like the last name - Murdaugh but they all say Murdock??
@@ILUVXO yep! 🙃🤪 they probably changed the way they say it because saying MURDAUGH comes out “murdaw” which sounds like the country version of saying MURDER which comes out “murda” LOL!😂
He probably thinks Alec sounds way cooler so he just changed the pronunciation himself. 😂
all I keep hearing in my head is paw paw this and paw paw that
AM was caught by the prosecutor about using these family names. They are well aware that AM is playing a sympathy game
@@bartoknight Exactly
What a creep. Shaking his head yes whole time while saying he never shot his wife and son...not anytime, ever.... uhmmmm....psychology 101.
I agree. I wanna throw-up when I see him shaking his head and smacking his lips together when who ever is talking about Maggie and Paul and brain matter!!!!!
It would be *nodding* his head yes. I’m surprised how many people say this lol
Was the airstrip ever looked at as way to estate and exit the estate on day of murders.
It seems like the prosecutors aren't even trying 😕
I don't think they need to. I think the case is over except for the jury vote...slam dunk. You'd have to blind to not see how guilty this creep is.
@@shadymistkennel lmao you're clueless if you think this. Hint: the goal is to be objective and look at the evidence in a case not use your subjective pre determined opinion and ignore everything else. Reasonable doubt still exists
@@Zeta-vb2xh absolutely 💯 agreed. The prosecution has nothing to say or they would be all over the expert testimony. The female was just nasty. Her questions were weak at best.
It’s actually scary imo because I do think the defense has created reasonable doubt. It’s really going to be sad if they are unable to convict him of these murders. I don’t think the investigation was handled properly, and because of that they don’t have a strong case in the court of law. In the court of opinion I think we all know what really happened.
@0Zeta I don't feel do clueless right now.
What was the relationship, if any between Alec, Paul and Paul's mother, of Michael Satterdileld and family, before and after the law suit?
How long was Michael S and his family seeking revenge against the Murdaugh family, because he didn't get the millions and sued Alec again after the double murders, to get their millions and did they get their 4.3 mil?
I've heard a few times that Harpootlian is such a great attorney. I suggest they're fishing in a very small pond. Puddle.
his , and the other lawyer's, stammering is driving me nuts (that IS maybe their tactic ). I am listening at the 1.5 speed and they are still slow.
@@citizenoftheearth6 Me, too! I keep yelling "move on!".
Harpootlian saying something is the “most distasteful thing” he’s ever seen is like Dahmer calling something “gross”.
I am not sure why the defense is belaboring Paul's fatal shot to the head, insisting it was a contact wound from the top rather than an exit wound from the left and below/horizontal? The fact is, Paul had his brain blown out of his head by a brutal murder. Whether a contact shot entrance or a horizontal shot exit, neither exonerates AM. I still believe AM is guilty of these murders.
I’m also curious why they are basically solely focusing on Paul’s shot to the head. Did we miss something as to why this shot is so important? Is it a determining factor who shot him? I just don’t understand.
And I also agree that AM is guilty but there’s also not enough hard evidence to prove he did it 😡
I think prosecution doing good job. Paul taking John's white F150 (just like his own) and John Marvin taking F250 to house (couldn't take wife's car as she had to take kids to school in morning! Seriously questionable). Read lawsuit on Paul dropped when he was murdered if true there's motive Murdaugh money stays in family.. so far I think Judge Newman fair..
Where's the orange jumpsuit and handcuffs?
They don't usually wear orange in court
😂 I think they should’ve made him wear Orange & Cuffs
that's netflix
@@hoss-lk4bg Chris Watts murderer sat in court in an orange jumpsuit & cuffs
How can he narrate Alex’s dream as being dreaming about what he found of Paul and Maggie, is he Joseph/Daniel. Could it have been he was dreaming of what he did to Maggie and Paul.
this is the most split i’ve been abt a trial
8:33:39 and do we really need to hear that BS from the old defense lawyer ? He blames the time spent on witnesses on the State alone!! However if anyone would measure time spent with each witness I’m pretty certain that he has always taken the longest!! Just for example he bites down on a specific detail and then argues with the witness back and forth like a puppy playing with a toy- for hours!!! So WHO is wasting the courts time???? HE IS!!! Why blame another person?? Obnoxious!! 🤮🤢
Mr. MaGoo asked alot of NOTHING Questions .
It took me about an hour and a half to walk 283 steps just moving around my living room, kitchen, bathroom, etc. this am. How Alex could have walked that many steps in such close quarters, and lying down on the couch as well in such a short amount of time ??? I find that impossible!
I do 10k steps in 8 hours everyday so that seems a bit off
How many steps is a 5 minute walk?
624 steps
Steps in 5 minutes (based on speed and height)
3.5 mph - 624 steps. 4 mph - 668 steps.
250 steps is roughly 2 to 3 minutes of walking.
How many hogs were shot in the head???‽
Good question
Money cannot make you happy
Preach!
How the heck in a number of hours is that crime seen released?
Why was a uncle left to clean away the remainder of his nephew (how was that released)
Why were people allowed to congregate in the house
Why was John marvin allowed to drive his truck away from the scene? Considering his nephew was the last person to drive it
So many things seem outrageous to me and I know diddley squat about crime scene protocol. But this whole thing seems a complete shambles.
John Marvin’s testimony broke me
anyone know the name of the girl that did cross?? such a great job
That court room was a joke,,from the microphone ,,cords running everywhere, no room for decent tv ,s so crowded
My theory......he was involved with the murder....maybe had another person there to help him. He clearly was at the kennels within minutes of the murders....maybe he shot maggie and someone else shot his son.....They did him so bad.....he said (or something like that). Shoddy work by SLED. Though the original lead of the investigation was his buddy...so there is so much complicity......
The only clue I see to an additional killer was AM saying “here” on the 911call…like he was handing something to someone-BUT he is still guilty in that case…and it would be someone the dogs already knew well since they weren’t agitated… Maybe the Kennel washing guy(?) But it could be anyone that hunted with them. However he may have mumbled “here” to himself or to one of the dogs.
Shooting a person in the HEAD ? Means you HATE “?
99.99% of people would be screaming I didn't do I'm inosent
People that answer any question with qualifying factors makes my skin crawl… they are hiding something for sure!!!
yep!
“might, probably, could have, I think, I believe, I remember, I assume, maybe, should have, It’s possible”, etcetc.
There should be a language monitoring system that beeps every time a qualifier is used. People don’t like to lie and the qualifier allows them to say the lie in a way that’s not “quite” a lie.
Like OJ’s. “if I killed them.” That tiny “if” lets him off from a true confession!
@@beastshawnee exactly what I meant to say!! He even said something like this: “Was your father ill? he answers “No he wasn’t ill”, the prosecutor replies “Okay? Wasn’t that what you just said?” and he replies “My dad was VERY SICK, that’s what I said!!!”
Twisting his words, being this way, really makes questioning him very challenging!!! He uses Qualifiers Too Much!!! Makes me sick listening to him….. 🤢🤮
Why doesn't Alex just say someone handed him a gun that wasn't loaded. It worked for Baldwin. No one can figure out HE put the live round in the gun. Reasonable doubt.
More than one gun was used. More than one shot on each person…
So I find him GUILTY. But my brother reminded me it's better to let ten guilty people be free than to put one not guilty person in prison. I want the laws to be but I know he murdered them.
No. That dumb mantra doesn’t cut real life mustard. Want me to explain? Well I’ll say this…if your family member was a victim of a heinous crime will you be the first to say….let him go because 10 guilty going free is better? You think on that. It’s a garbage statement used by pro criminal folks. UNLESS it happens to them, THEN it’s a different attitude all of a sudden.
This family doesn’t know how to answer questions, what’s with you know, no I don’t.
Does anyone know who the guy in the yellow suit is?
He has been there every day behind Alex
All the Murdaugh's , when on the stand, like to fiddle with that microphone, don't they?
Every witness is specifically instructed to adjust the mic as they need to
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Prosecution looks very concerned.
State says time of death. To make shory fit. I think drug dealers are involved. No way Alec
Could kill Paul. Alec said more than once they did them bad. State kept saying 8:45. Med examiner did not say that. State did to make story fit. To go from happy with the dogs to two brutal murders, why?
Are they taking cameras to Moselle tomorrow?
Alec did not kill anyone
Neither did Alex!
Ellick sure did tho.
@@beastshawnee It's Alex :-(
Dog collar camers i need a loan someone please .
Does the main Judge ever talk with the Judge Juries looking over any evidence or 2 or more eye witnesses? Do these Judges, picked by man know God's statue and judgments are for judges to follow, being "one nation under God" and his are above all.
what has the family actually done to , as Alecs bro promissed " find out who did this to you", ie Paw paw... have they offered a reward? god knows they all seem rich enough.... have they pettitioned the public for info on any platforms at all?
Yes they did. Pay attention!
@@jmortonburden6164 obviously i have a life and missed something... which is why i asked ....pay attention.
@@sabinekatsavrias4422 obviously you are stupid.
@@jmortonburden6164 Not as stupid or rude as you apparently...
Good family
@6:58:45 - Well Golly Gee Hornswogglers ah jist hed to go an clean upp all dat forensic evdience from yon crime scene, like any good ole country boy wood do for a bruddah who murdered he wife & son. Heavens to Betsy, ah do declarah, where *is* mah pearels?
Thanks for showing your ignorance
@@jmortonburden6164 Lawd's a'mercy, we dun got us anudder guid ole boy moseyin' on over in up in 'ere. It be like Alec dun sayed, y'awl gots to shoot dem hawgs runnin wile on muh prappety, whin he seed MawMaw (that's Mags) down on all fours rooting aroun among dem pine saplings he'd a planted in de spring for dem doves to roost on it were pure primal reflex to grab dat Blackout 300 outta he truck an let her have it repeatedly until the squealin stopped. PawPaw's brain jist happen git in da way when he be checkin he phone like any dumb millenial do be doing all day evriy day. An thassa troof, so halp me Gawd!
@@foobarrel9046 Your stupidity is astounding!
@@jmortonburden6164 Yaw'l bess be movin long, pardner, fore ah haz te git bizzy upside yore brainbox wiff mah fisticuffs.
@@foobarrel9046 Bring it on ASSHOLE!
I Googled and it is true the CORONOR usually does RECTAL or internal abdominal Temps
Duh
The defense has pretty much said law enforcement, MUSC, SLED, coroner and all others who were witnesses for the prosecution are INCOMPETENT. All of the defense witnesses, according to defense lawyers , have more education, experience, better work facilities with state of the art equipment to conduct test and various analyses that SC can only dream about. So where are the clothes he had on? A shower was taken according to his own brother. Paw Paw left the most compelling evidence….. AM was at the kennel, the dogs were not barking or agitated because they knew the three persons there :Alec, Paw Paw, and Mags two are dead and the killer remains.