@@FelixS. i get the generational gap, but even then (i played it when it came out), it's not graphically impressive compared to other games released at the time, say, Horizon Zero Dawn for example. But tbf, graphics wasn't really NieR Automata's strength, it was the story and its impact, that's what made it one of my fave games ever.
@@soulscyther666 That’s not necessarily defining for the budget though and tripleA games have an above „decent“ budget. I said Nier automata had at least a decent budget, it certainly wasn’t low budget. Platinum games doesn’t accept low budget projects and the project was funded by SE which is one of the industry’s big players.
One of the things I like about stellar blades combat is it really feels like Eve is growing, at the start of the game Eve is panicking during the drop when she is seeing the casualties of the 7th airborne, she gets stuck in the pod and needs Tachy to save her, she gets wounded and Tachy has to sacrifice herself to save eve and Adam spirits her away from the combat, her fighting is very slow and methodical making the game initially feel almost like a souls like game, however as the game progresses eve gets stronger and stronger gaining more abilities and mobility her hits are stronger, she starts getting special attacks and the game starts shifting from a souls like to almost a DMC game up to and including her getting what amounts to a devil trigger and she basically becomes a whirlwind of death and destruction
100% agree. And there is just something about the movement and combat in Nier, I cant explain why I never get bored of it. Stellar Blade is absolutely amazing and I'll probably play it for years to come, but I'll also play Nier automata forever
" Obviously one influenced the other " bro wanted to sound smart, bro nier came out in 2019, possibly even 2018 and stellar blade mid 2024, stellar blade wasn't even in development when nier was around heck even developers weren't even thinking of making stellar blade game 🙄
@@verde5738 I agree that Nier is a masterpiece but Stellar Blade is a solid 8.5 for me. Combat is fun and gratifying. Graphics are great. Character design is awesome. Enemy and level design is great too. where it falls flat is the story. but lets be honest, in both games, we're just staring at MC's magnificent ass anyways.
@@godssalvation87yup. Original Nier had a 67 on Metacritic and Stellar Blade is much better at an 82. The 2nd one has the potential to be on the level of Nier Automata
my heart is on NieR: Automata because its just its own different game. you see all the artistic direction starting from character design/fashion, color pallete and color grading, UI, music, world's ambient etc its all directed perfectly. I remember when I play the game the first time it didn't remind me of any other games (apart of previous Nier game) but I just full dive into it.
Automata is perfection and still grossly underrated. it's up there with gta5 and rdr2 who make top 5 constantly in ps and xbox store popular sales. i don't know why the creators abandoned it to make inferior crap.
RDR2??? You're kidding friend, Nier Automata is a good game, but it's not at the level of RDR2, I don't like GTAV, maybe it's close to that story mode.
yeah, NieR had no money for graphics, and also 2017 game, the story is way better than Stellar Blade imo but stellar blade has everything NieR lacked into the gameplay and graphics
@@KiddoBestBoi check donguri youtube nier automata gameplay. nier automata mechanic is simple to learn but hard to master. but again, its similiar to DMC series, one no need to understand that sophisticated combo at all to finish the game. just button mashing gameplay is enough
@@KiddoBestBoi And also the studio want to bring the 60fps on the PS4, the console is not powerfull enough if they want good graphic and 60fps on the game, so for the studio is Gameplay > graphics
@@kilikilio5321 i know what u guys are talking about, i 100 percent NieR a long time ago and also have been playing since the release, it's even my favorite game of all time, but still, like i said Stellar is better than NieR in terms of gameplay and graphics, that doesnt mean NieR gameplay is bad tho, cant say the same about graphics sadly.
Smaller budget basically, so Nier devs focused on what's important first, since they already know the game's true weakness from the first Nier game is the gameplay. Yoko already got the music and concept down. Graphics is secondary because Square Enix splurges on FF titles, not a sequel title for a cult classic.
Nier Automata animation still look more fluid. There still some sense "stiffness" in some Stellar Blade animation. Also voice over and story of Nier is better. Edit: Lot of people doesn't get it. When I said animation, I mean animation, how the character moving, attack etc. I'm not talking about combat or mechanic.
The games were just going for 2 completely different types of gameplay & combat. In Automata you could cancel out of any animation and perfect dodge any attack while Stellar Blade is more strategic and focused on attack timing like souls games. The main comparison between these games is the art direction, the world, characters & music.. not so much the gameplay & combat
It is. The visual difference in Performance and Resolution mode is like night and day. Resolution mode is unplayable though. That's why the gameplay has be slowed down. Stellar should have been a hack n slash.
@@BatMane95 which begs the question as to why so may youtubers said Stellar Blade was the "second coming?" It was a baffling phenomena. They said it would put an end to modern gaming as we know and would change everything. Anyone whose been around gaming long enough knew it would end up this way. They set SB up for a massive failure comparing it to games like Nier and Horizon 0 Dawn. It's a great game just not on par with the games it was being compared to two months ago.
@@bw8685 People tend to compare things they're interested in or like to other things they're interested in or like. There was also the fleeting hope that this one little game would spark other games to follow in its footsteps, in turn setting things back to the way they were.
@maulanaadrian9383: Meanwhile in Elden Ring and Sekiro: DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN
Reincarnation exists (existed) it's literally the sequel of both NieRs and it really expanded the lore even more. Sadly the game service ended yesterday so it's not playable anymore.
@@vergilschair4040 but an actual game that plays like a Nier instead of a auto gacha, (not that the game is bad, its as good as the rest, minus the gameplay)
@@AkiyamaKatsuko Get the team that did Replicant on the Drakengard trilogy. That was an almost perfect remake, and I'd love to see Drakengard 1-3 get the same treatment. Especially 3.
Eve from stellar blade is that girl that you think she doesn't know that you're checking her out and she's nice enough to let you look at her without creating a fuss
I fckn love Nier: Automata, the music is one of the best i have ever listened to, how 2B animations are so fluidly, each animation has a beginning and an end and each one of them has different transitions to return to the idle position, if u continue or not the next animation, the lore of the aliens, the fuckin humans crap corporation, completing all the endings was so amazing discovering more about the world and the robots, A2 and 9S gameplay and background...bro i cant explain, its just amazing.... OBS: Listen to Emir Soundtrack guys, its the best track in the game imop
니어 오토마타는 저의 인생게임중 하나 입니다. 스텔라 블레이드도 마찬가지입니다. 니어 오토마타는 스토리와 음악 엉덩이가 기억에 남습니다. 전투는 아무런 전략도 긴장감도 없으며, 그냥 버튼만 누르면 될정도로 형편없고 그래픽은 평범했습니다. 유리했던점은 이전작품들과 연결점 스토리텔링의 유리함을 가지고 있습니다. 스토리와 음악때문에 계속 플레이 했지만 플레이는 엔딩을 볼때까지 너무나도 지루했습니다. 제 주위 친구들은 니어 오토마타를 이야기하면 오타쿠 엉덩이 게임이라 생각하고 스토리도 호불호가 너무 갈리는등 찬반양론이 많습니다. 오글거리는 중2병 감성이라 얘기하기도 합니다. 나에겐 인생 게임이지만 그건 스토리와 음악에 관해서이고 니어는 한번 클리어하고 다시는 손대지 않습니다. 스토리의 감동은 있으나 플레이의 감동은 없습니다. 전투가 밋밋하고 재미없기 때문입니다. 그러나 스텔라 블레이드는 벌써 5회차 진행중이며 플레이타임은 100시간을 넘겼습니다. 스토리는 니어의 압승입니다. 스텔라의 스토리는 일반적인 액션게임 정도로 평범합니다. 하지만 게임 자체가 너무나 재밌습니다. 계속 플레이를 하게 만듭니다. 전투의 메커니즘은 충격적입니다. 새로운 액션을 개척했다고 봐도 무방합니다. 기존에는 소울라이크처럼 아주 어렵거나, 베요네타와 니어, 데빌메이크라이 처럼 너무 쉬운 2가지 측면만 있었는데 스텔라블레이드는 그 중간을 절묘하게 갖추었습니다. 그러면서도 굉장히 화려하고 도전욕구를 불러일으킵니다. 스텔라 블레이드는 시프트업의 첫 작품입니다. 다들 이점을 너무 간과하는군요~ 니어 오토마타는 그전 작품들의 업그레이드 버전입니다. 앞으로 스텔라블레이드는 더욱 발전할것이고 탄탄해질 것입니다. 스토리는 점점 굵어져 갈것이고 연기는 자연스러워 질 것이며 그래픽은 더욱 다듬어질것이고 액션은 더욱 발전할것입니다. 몇몇 사람들은 스텔라블레이드에 너무 냉정합니다. 관대한 시선으로 봐주길 바랍니다. 둘다 좋은작품입니다. 그리고 댓글을 보니까 플레이도 안해보고 추억에만 잠겨있는 사람들이 너무 많습니다. 멍청한~
There actually is an achievement/trophy for looking up 2B's skirt a few times. I found that out by just looking through Nier Automata stuff on RUclips and curiousity got the best of me (I don't actually own the game right now). So yes, they really did know since they probably did themselves
Suddenly all the people here that never played stellar blade(probably just watch a trailer and reviewer) act like they already play and finish it and make a comparison😂😂😂
Story - Automata Combat - Stellar blade Soundtrack - Automata Characters - Automata Boss fights - Stellar blade Exploration - Stellar blade Depth - Automata Dialogue - Automata Character development - Automata Character design - Automata Graphics - Stellar Blade Replayability - Stellar blade And most importanlty, fishing - Stellar blade Stellar blade is a seriously impressive game for Shift Ups very first AAA game, from a studio that mostly pnly ever made mobile games like Nikke its mind blowing that they made something better than most of the other garbage coming out in recent memory. For me personally I think the game is an 8 but i can understand some 7s. Only thing holding it back was unfortunately the story and overall writing, which imo is the most important part of a STORY driven game. Having good gameplay without an equally good story is like having a good side dish with a 1 dollar walmart steak. The steak isnt terrible, its just there.
@deadpool3302 "The game has 27 endings" 22 of them are joke endings that you get for eating a fish, killing pascal early, or going the wrong directions in certain places, uninstalling your OS etc. These can all be achieved in a singular playthrough. Calling route A and B endings is like calling the end of the chapter for a story the end of the game, route A and B are better described as chapters from different character perspectives, while route C covers the final half of the story and is completely different. After getting ending C you can just use chapter select to go back to the final boss fight and then get ending D and E. And before you argue "Well the credits roll at the end of each ending" You can do all of this without ever starting a new game as you just hit continue. So it all occurs on the same file, therefore it isn't starting a new playthrough. Stellar Blade has more enjoyable combat, which inherently contributes to replay value as well as a ng+ mode that unlocks a new difficulty as well as 30 additional costumes, in addition to the 2 endings you didn't get from the first playthrough. So at minimum that's at least 3 playthroughs for all endings where as with Automata you only need 1 complete playthrough and chapter select to 100% the game.
@@gibbygibbstein7858 you're rating replayability based on combat it seems. As someone who prefers story, characters and music, automata is more replayable for me. Stellar blades story and characters are it's worst part and having to go through that again and again when I'm just not invested enough is just kind of draining. Automata has such an excessively well written story, narrative, characters, etc that you can constantly and consistently find new appreciation and value in what it does and conveys in replays. Also consider this; automata was designed as a story to be replayed to get the full story. Have you considered how different replaying that completed story is? Have you considered the insane amount of side materials that are out there for automata that contain Canon lore with very important details on the characters and world? Playing Automata knowing all the details from the side materials actually elevates the emotional impact of the game to insane heights even beyond the crazy amount of depressing, sadness filled suffering the games story is as a first time experience. I would go as far as saying that automata can genuinely be played for the 1st time twice. It's really a whole different experience replaying it with a whole and complete understanding. Especially if you have a complete or at least robust understanding of the entirety of the DrakenNieR verse/series. The quality of writing is absurd in Automata.
@trevorveillette8415 I get that not everyone values story and gameplay the same, but where NieR excels in story Stellar blade excels in combat. You can't really play through Automata multiple times for all the endings, since you have to complete all 4 main routes on the same file to complete the story anyways, if you dont have A, B, C, D, and E then you haven't actually completed the story, you've completed a chapter of the game. Now, if you're going for 100% completion and platinum Personally I don't consider endings A, C, D, and E to be different playthroughs because they all occur on the same file and tell different halves of the overall story and are needed to get the game's ending, the "playthroughs" are better described as completing chapters and not the game. If someone only did route A, you would tell them they didn't actually beat the game. So it can't be considered a full playthrough, because it isn't. I only consider B to be a playthrough because it's just route A from 9's perspective. With Stellar blade, you're looking at one playthrough of being close to 100% and 2 additional playthroughs. The game also added ng+, which added to the game, and they're also adding boss rush. This and the game being more enjoyable combat wise gives it more overall replay value to me than NieR did even if NieR has a better story. When it comes to single-player games, I generally value story over gameplay, but once I've experienced a story, I've experienced it. I have no reason to play a game again solely for the story, which is when the gameplay actually starts to matter more to me, because if I revisit a game I usually do it for the gameplay. I think completionists and gameplay freaks get more value out of SB than NieR because SB seems to incentivize you to actually play multiple new playthroughs for things like the platinum trophy, new costumes, and new skills.
@@deadpool3302Most of Nier's endings are joke endings and most of them are just sequels of the story and the actual ending except for the Emil one, B and the alternative ending if you choose to use A2 against 9s in the ending.
I love Both Games, i stayed for Nier Replicant and Automata cause of its story and Characters , and stayed for Stellar Blade for its addictive Combat, gameplay loop and bosses, while the story isn't bad and is engaging enough, it just doesn't come close to niers storytelling, but both games are amazing on their own way, i can't wait for Stellar Blade 2
Nier automata is slightly better overall, storylinewise and also Nier has easier fishing gameplay, Stellar blade just has better physics, water exploration and graphics, but think if Nier was made these days like a brand new updated game it would still be king. Stellar blade took inspiration from Nier so it's not entirely unique or original but it is a great game that's almost as good as Nier automata as a whole.
The only thing Stellar Blade needs is more depth in the writing. For example if you guys remember the map you can find in Eidos 7 eve comments “what is this?” And Adam responds telling Eve it’s a map. Then Eve says “how do you triangulate your position?” And Adam just groans or makes some noise without answering the question. What would have been better is if Adam said something like : “well, it would be hard to explain through the drone but how about you pick it up and I’ll show you later.” Then Eve could’ve picked up the map and they could have had a short cutscene on their way to Xion or later in the game where Adam brings it up and shows Eve how to use a map the old fashioned way. They could’ve tied it into the map we use in game and it would have helped build an emotional connection to our friends. This is only one example, there are plenty of other examples throughout the game where they could’ve added more depth to the writing that would have made this game that much better.
Both are incredible titles. While SB boasts it's gorgeously detailed Eve, NieR has iconic 2B. The combat in both games are exciting to say the least. In Automata you can do some seriously cinematic sequence given that you have mastered the game. While SB has a more brutal and raw combat with QTEs. One thing that matters most is the deeper impact of the plot. And NieR wins clearly there. I'd buy SB in a heartbeat if it came in PC.
На год выхода даже у Nier была посредственная графика и геймплей, а в этом году Stellar Blade лучшая игра по графике и геймплею. Не спорю что Nier произведение искусства, просто не надо искажать факты если фанаты Nier, Stellar Blade тоже прекрасная игра. Просто Nier больше про рассказ, а SB про геймплей
@@Vengeance_I_m нет, даже геймплей в Nier, имхо, лучше. Фича с переходом из 3д в 2д, внезапный переход в shmup и всё такое. Это очень хорошо разбавляет геймплей. В Stellar Blade же только унылая суходрочка мобов с посредственной боевкой и с отвратительными анимациями. Соглашусь только с графикой, Stellar Blade в этом плане превосходит оба Nier'а.
Nice video idea As to which is "better" I think the interview between Kim and Yoko Taro says all that needs to be said There but great games, with some similarities...just have fun
Nier me parece superior, solo que stellar blade es mas moderno y tiene mejores graficos, en algunas jugabilidades es mejor que Nier pero nivel historia Nier le hace trizas
@@drunksquirrel2051 No, it’s definitely not necessary. It does help with understanding some references about the history of the world though. Then again, if you want the full picture about the game’s world and lore, you’d also need to play the Drakengard games. I didn’t play those other games before though and I’m pretty sure a lot of other people that loved Automata didn’t either
@@OMEKS_1The only game that really links to Automata is Drakengard 1 through Nier. Personally I like the whole series including the Drakengard games but it's only worth it to play Drakengard 1 if you really want to know the origin of what caused Nier's world to be the way that it is.
Man. Nier muaic> Nier story> Characterization of nier> Play style> Anyone who likes this new game just likes an attractive girl And if you are comparing because of the quality, it is better to know that nier was made in 2017. The only thing that is very focused in this game is the physics of the main character's breasts 👁👄👁
Nier Automata does better considering the technical limitations of the release platform. uses the environment in a complex way and is more inventive. You believe in this world, because the functionality of invented things is visible not only in battles. Stellar blade has a place to be, but it is rather contemplative and no more. it is better not to think about the meaning of what is happening. Content for the sake of content. Waiting for release SB on pc btw
the character design of Nier Automata is just unmatched. Stellar Blade has that weird style found in many korean games... like a style checklist. I see why they went with it tho, many like it.
@@MiguelRodriguez-lp9et Thats what he said, Graphics and battle combos. Nier didn't had the same budget as Stellar Blade had. It's not about the console generation.
I love Nier A and it's so obvious you're clouded by the story that you're blatantly ignoring a lot of Nier A's flaws Just as an example in Nier A you're literally forced some really stupid camera angles in some of sections and battles
I feel like you cannot really compare these 2 games I say nier is more relatable, to like a devil may cry fight system and stellar blade like god of war 4 mixed with sekiro
well you can see what they put the budget into in stellar blade. i think her interacting with the water causes less distortion then cyberpunk originally did 😅😅 plus for some reason eve doesnt get wet at all.
Nier had very low budget but the art and physique is so F beautiful. I enjoy watching Nier to play with her big sword! Stellar is not even close. If Nier has a lot higher budget, I bet it can make as pretty graphics as Stella. I am very impressed on Nier and Japanese to make such game only by such low budget!
Graphical quality obviously goes to stellar blade but Nier Automata owns it in the departments: art direction, soundtrack, combat fluidity, story and writing.
Stellar Blade True Ending here: ruclips.net/video/kspcOOL0vSw/видео.htmlsi=PkDmPput9gnbgnZt
Nier Automata obviously didn't had the same budget, but damn Platinum did miracles with this game. Easily one of my favorite games ever.
It is on the previous console generation, that’s not even a matter of budget plus I am pretty confident Nier Automata had a decent budget.
@@FelixS. Nier was a AA and platinum had problems during development because they tried to use another engine
@@paulogustavobatistasantosl1491 AA is a decent budget.
@@FelixS. i get the generational gap, but even then (i played it when it came out), it's not graphically impressive compared to other games released at the time, say, Horizon Zero Dawn for example. But tbf, graphics wasn't really NieR Automata's strength, it was the story and its impact, that's what made it one of my fave games ever.
@@soulscyther666 That’s not necessarily defining for the budget though and tripleA games have an above „decent“ budget. I said Nier automata had at least a decent budget, it certainly wasn’t low budget. Platinum games doesn’t accept low budget projects and the project was funded by SE which is one of the industry’s big players.
Now this is REAL gaming journalism
Fuck yeah
Facts bro 💯
FUCK THE JOURNOS!
Absolutely
😂
One of the things I like about stellar blades combat is it really feels like Eve is growing, at the start of the game Eve is panicking during the drop when she is seeing the casualties of the 7th airborne, she gets stuck in the pod and needs Tachy to save her, she gets wounded and Tachy has to sacrifice herself to save eve and Adam spirits her away from the combat, her fighting is very slow and methodical making the game initially feel almost like a souls like game, however as the game progresses eve gets stronger and stronger gaining more abilities and mobility her hits are stronger, she starts getting special attacks and the game starts shifting from a souls like to almost a DMC game up to and including her getting what amounts to a devil trigger and she basically becomes a whirlwind of death and destruction
I think NieR Automata is more beautiful with its art direction and Stellar Blade is more technically impressive with its graphics. I like both a lot
Yupp this is what I was thinking, Nier wins in terms of art direction which is the reason it will still look good for generations.
100% agree!!!
100% agree. And there is just something about the movement and combat in Nier, I cant explain why I never get bored of it. Stellar Blade is absolutely amazing and I'll probably play it for years to come, but I'll also play Nier automata forever
The music is very similar i will say that - it hit me immediately
Yeah nier is art
Nier Automata soundtrack is so good!
So is Stellar blade soundtrack. It’s really fascinating!
It's literally the best ever
It's the same music team from Japan :)
@@superduper6419stellar blade soundtrack sounds like Heavily rely on auto tuned 😂
차피 부모가 같아서 의미가 없음
Obviously one influenced the other. And the devs for both games are admirers of each other's work.
Copied*
Copied*
" Obviously one influenced the other " bro wanted to sound smart, bro nier came out in 2019, possibly even 2018 and stellar blade mid 2024, stellar blade wasn't even in development when nier was around heck even developers weren't even thinking of making stellar blade game 🙄
@@NightSide22comment flew over your head
@@NightSide22NieR Automata came out in 2017 as an exclusive for PS and 2018 on Xbox to be exact.
Stellar blade is a worthy spiritual successor, approved by even the creator of nier automata
Nope. Nier automata is a masterpiece, Stelar Blade is a generic, forgettable Korean game.
@@verde5738 I agree that Nier is a masterpiece but Stellar Blade is a solid 8.5 for me. Combat is fun and gratifying. Graphics are great. Character design is awesome. Enemy and level design is great too. where it falls flat is the story. but lets be honest, in both games, we're just staring at MC's magnificent ass anyways.
They should do a Stellar Blade x NieR: Automata cross over
We have a good chance to at least get a 2B outfit, just like they did in gravity rush.
Possible
NIKKE (same developers of stellar blade) made a collab with nier
Как максимум - добавят в SB костюм 2B.
it might as well be lol with the way the story turns out
this is actually a good idea
Graphics - Stellar Blade
Combat Mechanics - Stellar Blade
Story/plot - Nier automata
Character design - Nier Automata
Depth - Nier automata
Bosses - Stellar Blade.
MC - Nier automata
Imo.
Orignal nier wasn't all that great but automata is what gave nier a name but stella blade is the first game an still has room to grow.
@@godssalvation87yup. Original Nier had a 67 on Metacritic and Stellar Blade is much better at an 82. The 2nd one has the potential to be on the level of Nier Automata
for me
Graphics - Stellar Blade
Combat Mechanics - Stellar Blade
Story/plot - Stellar Blade
Character design - Stellar Blade
Depth - Stellar Blade
Bosses - Stellar Blade.
MC - Stellar Blade
@@godssalvation87 yeah I agree with you, stellar blade has potential.
dont forget soundtrack is a crucial part aswell.
and the point goes to nier
Nier Automata is one of the best games ever. A masterpiece. And we need a 2B outfit in Stellar Blade asap 😂
Giving 2b alot of outfits like stellar blade will revive the game again 😂😂😂
my heart is on NieR: Automata because its just its own different game. you see all the artistic direction starting from character design/fashion, color pallete and color grading, UI, music, world's ambient etc its all directed perfectly. I remember when I play the game the first time it didn't remind me of any other games (apart of previous Nier game) but I just full dive into it.
5:23 Eve actually does 2Bs stretching animation as a cameo! Ive seen it in game a few times.
Nier music is beautiful ❤
You can clearly see how polished Stellar Blade is, such a gem of a game. It has it all!
Yoko Taro is definitely an influence here. I can’t wait for the collab lol
@gamesstarthere didn’t know Platinum was still around. They still owe us a Vanquish sequel.
@@2URLexhell I thought platinum games stopped awhile back to but I was wrong their still going strong
Now I wanna play Nier Automata again. Until Stellar blade release on pc
That's what I'm prolly doing
Why on pc? WHY? Naked mods haaah 🥸
@vilvethope Or you know... not owning a ps5 and not buying one just to play one game 🤣
@@vilvethope I don't have PS5😒
@@arunmax8319
Yeah!!!!!
The graphics on pc have better graphics quality than ps5 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
Automata is perfection and still grossly underrated. it's up there with gta5 and rdr2 who make top 5 constantly in ps and xbox store popular sales. i don't know why the creators abandoned it to make inferior crap.
what is the inferior crap? i guess u mean the mobile game?
@@KiddoBestBoi every game they have made after automata has been inferior. not sure what you are arguing?
@@somfplease i'm not arguing anything? Cause Yoko Taro have not made any game after automata besides Reincarnation on mobile???
RDR2??? You're kidding friend, Nier Automata is a good game, but it's not at the level of RDR2, I don't like GTAV, maybe it's close to that story mode.
과대평가겠지.
그리고 니어는 액션게임이 아니라 슈팅게임 이다
The difference in graphics is huge...
Stella Blade is so fancy.
yeah, NieR had no money for graphics, and also 2017 game, the story is way better than Stellar Blade imo but stellar blade has everything NieR lacked into the gameplay and graphics
@@KiddoBestBoi check donguri youtube nier automata gameplay. nier automata mechanic is simple to learn but hard to master. but again, its similiar to DMC series, one no need to understand that sophisticated combo at all to finish the game. just button mashing gameplay is enough
@@KiddoBestBoi And also the studio want to bring the 60fps on the PS4, the console is not powerfull enough if they want good graphic and 60fps on the game, so for the studio is Gameplay > graphics
@@kilikilio5321 i know what u guys are talking about, i 100 percent NieR a long time ago and also have been playing since the release, it's even my favorite game of all time, but still, like i said Stellar is better than NieR in terms of gameplay and graphics, that doesnt mean NieR gameplay is bad tho, cant say the same about graphics sadly.
Smaller budget basically, so Nier devs focused on what's important first, since they already know the game's true weakness from the first Nier game is the gameplay. Yoko already got the music and concept down. Graphics is secondary because Square Enix splurges on FF titles, not a sequel title for a cult classic.
Nier Automata animation still look more fluid. There still some sense "stiffness" in some Stellar Blade animation. Also voice over and story of Nier is better.
Edit: Lot of people doesn't get it. When I said animation, I mean animation, how the character moving, attack etc. I'm not talking about combat or mechanic.
That's the difference between a mobile game studio who just made their first console game and a studio who's been doing it since around 2008
The games were just going for 2 completely different types of gameplay & combat. In Automata you could cancel out of any animation and perfect dodge any attack while Stellar Blade is more strategic and focused on attack timing like souls games. The main comparison between these games is the art direction, the world, characters & music.. not so much the gameplay & combat
It is. The visual difference in Performance and Resolution mode is like night and day. Resolution mode is unplayable though. That's why the gameplay has be slowed down. Stellar should have been a hack n slash.
@@BatMane95 which begs the question as to why so may youtubers said Stellar Blade was the "second coming?" It was a baffling phenomena. They said it would put an end to modern gaming as we know and would change everything. Anyone whose been around gaming long enough knew it would end up this way. They set SB up for a massive failure comparing it to games like Nier and Horizon 0 Dawn. It's a great game just not on par with the games it was being compared to two months ago.
@@bw8685 People tend to compare things they're interested in or like to other things they're interested in or like.
There was also the fleeting hope that this one little game would spark other games to follow in its footsteps, in turn setting things back to the way they were.
2:37 The cameraman never desappoint us. God job Dan Allen Gaming, your a real professional 😊
I like automata’s art style more
Meanwhile in Bloodborne: *DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG DONG*
@maulanaadrian9383: Meanwhile in Elden Ring and Sekiro: DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN
Imagine bloodborne in pc with 60fps 4k
Sony: we don’t do that here
i knew that Stellar Blade reminded me of NieR, thats why i love Stellar Blade
Stellar blade is more Like 3rd birthday where you collect Costume
Dats da whole reason I’m getting it I love nier
@@Morbius-Tension thats also my only reason i got it lmao, NieR is peak and Stellar Blade is such a good game
Nier atmosphere so good
I can just walk in city ruin and feel peacefulness and sadness at the same time
Nier Automata needs a spinoff or remastered.
Reincarnation exists (existed) it's literally the sequel of both NieRs and it really expanded the lore even more. Sadly the game service ended yesterday so it's not playable anymore.
@@vergilschair4040 but an actual game that plays like a Nier instead of a auto gacha, (not that the game is bad, its as good as the rest, minus the gameplay)
What we really need is a Drakengard remaster.
@@AkiyamaKatsuko Get the team that did Replicant on the Drakengard trilogy. That was an almost perfect remake, and I'd love to see Drakengard 1-3 get the same treatment. Especially 3.
Eve from stellar blade is that girl that you think she doesn't know that you're checking her out and she's nice enough to let you look at her without creating a fuss
I want a 2024 version of NieR: Automata.
How I wish PlatinumGames would get the funding to make a AAA game with a sexy female protagonist like Nier Automata.
I fckn love Nier: Automata, the music is one of the best i have ever listened to, how 2B animations are so fluidly, each animation has a beginning and an end and each one of them has different transitions to return to the idle position, if u continue or not the next animation, the lore of the aliens, the fuckin humans crap corporation, completing all the endings was so amazing discovering more about the world and the robots, A2 and 9S gameplay and background...bro i cant explain, its just amazing....
OBS: Listen to Emir Soundtrack guys, its the best track in the game imop
니어 오토마타는 저의 인생게임중 하나 입니다. 스텔라 블레이드도 마찬가지입니다. 니어 오토마타는 스토리와 음악 엉덩이가 기억에 남습니다. 전투는 아무런 전략도 긴장감도 없으며, 그냥 버튼만 누르면 될정도로 형편없고 그래픽은 평범했습니다. 유리했던점은 이전작품들과 연결점 스토리텔링의 유리함을 가지고 있습니다. 스토리와 음악때문에 계속 플레이 했지만 플레이는 엔딩을 볼때까지 너무나도 지루했습니다. 제 주위 친구들은 니어 오토마타를 이야기하면 오타쿠 엉덩이 게임이라 생각하고 스토리도 호불호가 너무 갈리는등 찬반양론이 많습니다. 오글거리는 중2병 감성이라 얘기하기도 합니다. 나에겐 인생 게임이지만 그건 스토리와 음악에 관해서이고 니어는 한번 클리어하고 다시는 손대지 않습니다. 스토리의 감동은 있으나 플레이의 감동은 없습니다. 전투가 밋밋하고 재미없기 때문입니다. 그러나 스텔라 블레이드는 벌써 5회차 진행중이며 플레이타임은 100시간을 넘겼습니다. 스토리는 니어의 압승입니다. 스텔라의 스토리는 일반적인 액션게임 정도로 평범합니다. 하지만 게임 자체가 너무나 재밌습니다. 계속 플레이를 하게 만듭니다. 전투의 메커니즘은 충격적입니다. 새로운 액션을 개척했다고 봐도 무방합니다. 기존에는 소울라이크처럼 아주 어렵거나, 베요네타와 니어, 데빌메이크라이 처럼 너무 쉬운 2가지 측면만 있었는데 스텔라블레이드는 그 중간을 절묘하게 갖추었습니다. 그러면서도 굉장히 화려하고 도전욕구를 불러일으킵니다. 스텔라 블레이드는 시프트업의 첫 작품입니다. 다들 이점을 너무 간과하는군요~ 니어 오토마타는 그전 작품들의 업그레이드 버전입니다. 앞으로 스텔라블레이드는 더욱 발전할것이고 탄탄해질 것입니다. 스토리는 점점 굵어져 갈것이고 연기는 자연스러워 질 것이며 그래픽은 더욱 다듬어질것이고 액션은 더욱 발전할것입니다. 몇몇 사람들은 스텔라블레이드에 너무 냉정합니다. 관대한 시선으로 봐주길 바랍니다. 둘다 좋은작품입니다. 그리고 댓글을 보니까 플레이도 안해보고 추억에만 잠겨있는 사람들이 너무 많습니다. 멍청한~
전 한국인 아니어도 읽기 속시원한 댓글입니다.
2B swatting the camera away when you look up her skirt is proof that Yoko Taro knows his audience very well.
Главное, что мы узнали из этого видео: 2B - скромняшка, а вот Ева - не против 😜
Starting strong opening with the ladder animations... 😅
i love everything about eve's assets 👀
2:10 devs knows what guys do that so they thought let her also look down 😂
There actually is an achievement/trophy for looking up 2B's skirt a few times.
I found that out by just looking through Nier Automata stuff on RUclips and curiousity got the best of me (I don't actually own the game right now).
So yes, they really did know since they probably did themselves
Fast Travel and jiggle physics on Stellar Blade look like from Mobile Game 😂
To start, simply comparing a game from 2016 to one from 2024 only makes Nier totally superior.
They cannot be compared.
I don't think one game is better than the other. They compliment each other well, without going into the pointless debate about which one is superior.
Dan Allen is a man of culture🗿🍷👍🏼👍🏼
The combat style of nier is legendary.
Nier is way ahead of its time❤️
Suddenly all the people here that never played stellar blade(probably just watch a trailer and reviewer) act like they already play and finish it and make a comparison😂😂😂
I will definitely play SB when it comes out for PC
3:32 2B can survive a 500 meter drop meanwhile Eve can't even survive a 50 meter drop.
Story - Automata
Combat - Stellar blade
Soundtrack - Automata
Characters - Automata
Boss fights - Stellar blade
Exploration - Stellar blade
Depth - Automata
Dialogue - Automata
Character development - Automata
Character design - Automata
Graphics - Stellar Blade
Replayability - Stellar blade
And most importanlty, fishing - Stellar blade
Stellar blade is a seriously impressive game for Shift Ups very first AAA game, from a studio that mostly pnly ever made mobile games like Nikke its mind blowing that they made something better than most of the other garbage coming out in recent memory. For me personally I think the game is an 8 but i can understand some 7s. Only thing holding it back was unfortunately the story and overall writing, which imo is the most important part of a STORY driven game. Having good gameplay without an equally good story is like having a good side dish with a 1 dollar walmart steak. The steak isnt terrible, its just there.
bruh you really gave replayability to stellar blade? nier has 27 endings and you at least need to play the game 4 times to get the true ending
@deadpool3302 "The game has 27 endings"
22 of them are joke endings that you get for eating a fish, killing pascal early, or going the wrong directions in certain places, uninstalling your OS etc. These can all be achieved in a singular playthrough.
Calling route A and B endings is like calling the end of the chapter for a story the end of the game, route A and B are better described as chapters from different character perspectives, while route C covers the final half of the story and is completely different.
After getting ending C you can just use chapter select to go back to the final boss fight and then get ending D and E.
And before you argue "Well the credits roll at the end of each ending" You can do all of this without ever starting a new game as you just hit continue. So it all occurs on the same file, therefore it isn't starting a new playthrough.
Stellar Blade has more enjoyable combat, which inherently contributes to replay value as well as a ng+ mode that unlocks a new difficulty as well as 30 additional costumes, in addition to the 2 endings you didn't get from the first playthrough. So at minimum that's at least 3 playthroughs for all endings where as with Automata you only need 1 complete playthrough and chapter select to 100% the game.
@@gibbygibbstein7858 you're rating replayability based on combat it seems. As someone who prefers story, characters and music, automata is more replayable for me.
Stellar blades story and characters are it's worst part and having to go through that again and again when I'm just not invested enough is just kind of draining.
Automata has such an excessively well written story, narrative, characters, etc that you can constantly and consistently find new appreciation and value in what it does and conveys in replays.
Also consider this; automata was designed as a story to be replayed to get the full story. Have you considered how different replaying that completed story is?
Have you considered the insane amount of side materials that are out there for automata that contain Canon lore with very important details on the characters and world?
Playing Automata knowing all the details from the side materials actually elevates the emotional impact of the game to insane heights even beyond the crazy amount of depressing, sadness filled suffering the games story is as a first time experience.
I would go as far as saying that automata can genuinely be played for the 1st time twice. It's really a whole different experience replaying it with a whole and complete understanding. Especially if you have a complete or at least robust understanding of the entirety of the DrakenNieR verse/series.
The quality of writing is absurd in Automata.
@trevorveillette8415 I get that not everyone values story and gameplay the same, but where NieR excels in story Stellar blade excels in combat.
You can't really play through Automata multiple times for all the endings, since you have to complete all 4 main routes on the same file to complete the story anyways, if you dont have A, B, C, D, and E then you haven't actually completed the story, you've completed a chapter of the game.
Now, if you're going for 100% completion and platinum
Personally I don't consider endings A, C, D, and E to be different playthroughs because they all occur on the same file and tell different halves of the overall story and are needed to get the game's ending, the "playthroughs" are better described as completing chapters and not the game. If someone only did route A, you would tell them they didn't actually beat the game. So it can't be considered a full playthrough, because it isn't. I only consider B to be a playthrough because it's just route A from 9's perspective.
With Stellar blade, you're looking at one playthrough of being close to 100% and 2 additional playthroughs. The game also added ng+, which added to the game, and they're also adding boss rush. This and the game being more enjoyable combat wise gives it more overall replay value to me than NieR did even if NieR has a better story.
When it comes to single-player games, I generally value story over gameplay, but once I've experienced a story, I've experienced it. I have no reason to play a game again solely for the story, which is when the gameplay actually starts to matter more to me, because if I revisit a game I usually do it for the gameplay.
I think completionists and gameplay freaks get more value out of SB than NieR because SB seems to incentivize you to actually play multiple new playthroughs for things like the platinum trophy, new costumes, and new skills.
@@deadpool3302Most of Nier's endings are joke endings and most of them are just sequels of the story and the actual ending except for the Emil one, B and the alternative ending if you choose to use A2 against 9s in the ending.
I love Both Games, i stayed for Nier Replicant and Automata cause of its story and Characters , and stayed for Stellar Blade for its addictive Combat, gameplay loop and bosses, while the story isn't bad and is engaging enough, it just doesn't come close to niers storytelling, but both games are amazing on their own way, i can't wait for Stellar Blade 2
Nier automata is slightly better overall, storylinewise and also Nier has easier fishing gameplay, Stellar blade just has better physics, water exploration and graphics, but think if Nier was made these days like a brand new updated game it would still be king. Stellar blade took inspiration from Nier so it's not entirely unique or original but it is a great game that's almost as good as Nier automata as a whole.
I have Stellar Blade but never played Nier Automata. I can see how Nier how Nier had an influence.
Great video/editing, thank you!
"Can you pet the robot?"
2B: pat* whos the good boi~
Eve: Adam!! Laser go BZZZ!!!
The only thing Stellar Blade needs is more depth in the writing. For example if you guys remember the map you can find in Eidos 7 eve comments “what is this?” And Adam responds telling Eve it’s a map. Then Eve says “how do you triangulate your position?” And Adam just groans or makes some noise without answering the question. What would have been better is if Adam said something like : “well, it would be hard to explain through the drone but how about you pick it up and I’ll show you later.” Then Eve could’ve picked up the map and they could have had a short cutscene on their way to Xion or later in the game where Adam brings it up and shows Eve how to use a map the old fashioned way. They could’ve tied it into the map we use in game and it would have helped build an emotional connection to our friends. This is only one example, there are plenty of other examples throughout the game where they could’ve added more depth to the writing that would have made this game that much better.
i had a lot of fun with both games but i just wish nier automata had the graphics quality it really deserves.
Both are incredible titles. While SB boasts it's gorgeously detailed Eve, NieR has iconic 2B. The combat in both games are exciting to say the least. In Automata you can do some seriously cinematic sequence given that you have mastered the game. While SB has a more brutal and raw combat with QTEs. One thing that matters most is the deeper impact of the plot. And NieR wins clearly there. I'd buy SB in a heartbeat if it came in PC.
U sure know a lot for someone that not even play it yet
there is just something about nier automata, the moment i get to hear the 'City Ruins' soundtrack, i am just sucked into another world emotionally.
Сколько лет между выходом игр ? В Nier можно было с новыми технологиями всё сделать ещё лучше, единственный её минус - пустой мир.
Automata вышла в 2017м году, так что с момента ее выхода прошло уже 7 лет)
На год выхода даже у Nier была посредственная графика и геймплей, а в этом году Stellar Blade лучшая игра по графике и геймплею. Не спорю что Nier произведение искусства, просто не надо искажать факты если фанаты Nier, Stellar Blade тоже прекрасная игра. Просто Nier больше про рассказ, а SB про геймплей
@@Vengeance_I_m нет, даже геймплей в Nier, имхо, лучше. Фича с переходом из 3д в 2д, внезапный переход в shmup и всё такое. Это очень хорошо разбавляет геймплей. В Stellar Blade же только унылая суходрочка мобов с посредственной боевкой и с отвратительными анимациями.
Соглашусь только с графикой, Stellar Blade в этом плане превосходит оба Nier'а.
액션 및 전투 재미를 생각하면 스텔라 블레이드의 압승입니다. 니어오토마타는 너무 단조롭고 재미가 없어요 가드도 없고 회피기는 단 하나 뿐
Wowwww.... Nier automata release in 2017. But... Woooww...
Nice video idea
As to which is "better" I think the interview between Kim and Yoko Taro says all that needs to be said
There but great games, with some similarities...just have fun
nier sepenuhnya cyborg,sedangkan stellar blade,manusia berkostum super😂
Benar 👌.
I really need to see them in a Death Battle!
Nier me parece superior, solo que stellar blade es mas moderno y tiene mejores graficos, en algunas jugabilidades es mejor que Nier pero nivel historia Nier le hace trizas
The differences is you can change outfit of stellar blade like nude outfit rather than nier doesnt have..😁😁
4:22 bro there's sand area ahead. why you used that area
Square enix is known for their graphical prowess. Kinda unfair but pretty neat to seat how much steller blade tried.
Just got Neir Automata Yohra edition from Ebay cause I finally got sick of not knowing what the big deal was about it
Just remember when you beat the game the first time that’s just the beginning not the full experience
@@OMEKS_1 should I buy and play Replicant first?
@@drunksquirrel2051 No, it’s definitely not necessary. It does help with understanding some references about the history of the world though. Then again, if you want the full picture about the game’s world and lore, you’d also need to play the Drakengard games. I didn’t play those other games before though and I’m pretty sure a lot of other people that loved Automata didn’t either
@@drunksquirrel2051Yes. Both games are made better by playing Replicant first and Automata second.
@@OMEKS_1The only game that really links to Automata is Drakengard 1 through Nier.
Personally I like the whole series including the Drakengard games but it's only worth it to play Drakengard 1 if you really want to know the origin of what caused Nier's world to be the way that it is.
Am i the only one who wants to see a Death Battle between these ladies?😅
Man.
Nier muaic>
Nier story>
Characterization of nier>
Play style>
Anyone who likes this new game just likes an attractive girl
And if you are comparing because of the quality, it is better to know that nier was made in 2017.
The only thing that is very focused in this game is the physics of the main character's breasts
👁👄👁
Nier Automata does better considering the technical limitations of the release platform. uses the environment in a complex way and is more inventive. You believe in this world, because the functionality of invented things is visible not only in battles.
Stellar blade has a place to be, but it is rather contemplative and no more. it is better not to think about the meaning of what is happening. Content for the sake of content.
Waiting for release SB on pc btw
They need to do a Death Battle on RUclips now
I'll say that it's not enough Nier:Automata+stella Blade= Secret 😅🤔
I love soundtrack in stellar blade "beyond fate" feels relaxing
"Both?"
"Both."
"Both is good."
-Men of culture.
I just know both Eve and 2B is my wife
the character design of Nier Automata is just unmatched.
Stellar Blade has that weird style found in many korean games... like a style checklist. I see why they went with it tho, many like it.
Which 'many other" Korean games? Because the artist also did artwork for Magnacarta, Blade & Soul and Destiny Child. No other game uses his artstyle
Stellar is only superior in some graphical and battle combo areas. Otherwise Nier Auto solos
Really? Stellar Blade is undeniably the better looking of the two. One was developed with the PS4 in mind and the other PS5, so it makes sense.
The bosses in Nier only spams that red ball lol
@@MiguelRodriguez-lp9et Thats what he said, Graphics and battle combos. Nier didn't had the same budget as Stellar Blade had. It's not about the console generation.
I love Nier A and it's so obvious you're clouded by the story that you're blatantly ignoring a lot of Nier A's flaws
Just as an example in Nier A you're literally forced some really stupid camera angles in some of sections and battles
It's been 7 years between these games i love nearautomata story stelar is just copy cat with big ass and newer graphics
it plays completely different though
100% true.
@@jonnyfendi2003the vibe is similar
Still gonna play it cuz it looks like Nier 🤷🏾♂️
It's been 7 years since Nier Automata and you still haven't learned how to spell the game that you so called love?
r34 gonna be pretty lit
Always has been some artist already make it
Man them mfs fast as hell it’s almost scary lol🤣
To see these two face off, i think 2B would definitely win. They need to remaster Nier Automata.
They absolutely don’t need to remaster Nier automata it is perfectly fine and playable on current systems.
They should do a sequel.
I saw a comment that said Eve would destroy 2B I just laughed 💀
@@FelixS. I'll be happy with either.
stellar blade is the game of the year
Nier so much better, Stellar Blade has no soul and personality.
Why game from 2017 has more smooth model animation cutscene than 2024 game?
2B is still more beautiful, to the point of inhuman perfection.
I feel like you cannot really compare these 2 games I say nier is more relatable, to like a devil may cry fight system and stellar blade like god of war 4 mixed with sekiro
Stellar Blade don´t have dune sliding, NieR automata wins, that and the superior writing, I like SB story but next to Nier...
well you can see what they put the budget into in stellar blade. i think her interacting with the water causes less distortion then cyberpunk originally did 😅😅 plus for some reason eve doesnt get wet at all.
if you look closer, her skin is allways wet, i think there is an ,, oil'' reasone for that :D
I'm really tempted to get Stellar Blade but I think I will just play NieR: Automata.. ever finished that game for some reason.
Well, I know you just don’t own a ps5 and that’s why. There is no reason to skip this game for real😂
@@superduper6419what that have to do with not owning PS5? if he lost interest in that game there has to be some personal reason for him.
@MaRgEd.ZamaSU Yea, it's called being a fanboy.
@@superduper6419Yeah if you have a PS5 you need to get Stellar Blade because it's like the only game the PS5 has lmao.
Nier automata is unplayable on ps5 you can't be on the city long enough for a fight cause it crushes for some reason
No More Heroes clears both for MILES!!
I love both but nier >stellar
NieR 2B 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Nier had very low budget but the art and physique is so F beautiful. I enjoy watching Nier to play with her big sword! Stellar is not even close.
If Nier has a lot higher budget, I bet it can make as pretty graphics as Stella.
I am very impressed on Nier and Japanese to make such game only by such low budget!
Stay out of my room, im trying to conduct rethirst- RESEARCH! I said research.
Both amazing games.
graphic wise... SB is PS5 vs NA is PS4.
Both!
are there any MMOs that look this good? (I'm still playing wow retail).
Graphical quality obviously goes to stellar blade but Nier Automata owns it in the departments: art direction, soundtrack, combat fluidity, story and writing.
2b cant swim maybe because she weight 328lbs/149kg? but iam pretty sure she can walk fine underwater
how dare u, comparing 2024's game and 2017's game about physc, graphic, texture etc, that's ridiculous weirdo
I only fished once in NieR and found the Pod
Nier Automata is Art and masterpiece. Stellar Blade is GAME.
1:53 Am I crazy or did they take inspiration from Yakuza 0? Looks very similar to when you successfully catch a fish in that game.