Don't worry Acharya ji, music mein kon agay kon pichay. Indian music, playback singers like Rafi saab, kishore kumar, Mukesh, Talat Mehmood, Manna dey, udit Narayan, Kumar Sanu, Lata & Asha; plus Indian Movies ki puri Dunya fan hai. Hum is jadu se hi nahi nikal saktey. ❤️from 🇵🇰
2:00 I can't thank you enough for pointing this out. So many friends of mine with zero clue regarding production always baselessly boast around how Indian artists like Sonu Nigam and Arijit Singh don't require any autotune and all, and call me stupid and get all offended when I try reasoning with them as a music producer that what autotune or pitch correction even is and how no artist is quite an exception to this, and how there's nothing really wrong with it (they've no idea about music production whatsoever and for the fact, don't even know what autotune really is or how is it supposed to work)
bhai log ye smjhte hai autotune word agar use hogya kahi, jaise apne SONU SIR and ARIJIT DA ka naam liya to ye singers autotune k sahare jee re hai.....log ye smjhte hai ki inhe aata hi ni gaana .....
Bro i am trying to understand this with an open mind... so with todays music and instruments, auto tune is a must... which includes the likes of Rahat saab as well? Ok maybe thats why the production quality and overall sound of todays songs are better to ear then compared to say Rafi saab and others. Can you please explain the timing factor as well? Does it mean older performances like that of Jagjit singh, Nusrat saab acrually had to prepare the performance to whole new level or that genre allows little bit of error?
@@GurpreetSingh-zj9nh bro i came to know only htrough thid video or comment... may be only for mix and mastring autotune is used in voices of these great singer, like he said about arijit and sonu sir....actually now in music, acoustic music is getting less importance in songs....and I don't think these singer actually need autuotune to to sing because in there lives perform well...and that Atif's part shown in this video can be easily sing...its not that difficult thing..
Kudos to you for bringing this fact to light that even the biggest artists use pitch correction and how it's crucial to blend vocals into the mix with perfection. People mostly have 0 clue about it and they've stigmatised it so much that its influence is being seen in something as high budget as Coke Studio! 🙌
@@JH_Jamil wdym "digital music"? CS Pakistan has pulled off western and eastern instruments and fusions amazingly. In season 9, "paar channaa de" they showed a Pakistani plucked string instrument, in season 14 they had a harp, in earlier seasons Ahad Nayani killed it on the drums, they've incorporated different national musical instruments e.g. rabab, just to mention a few examples. It's not a competition of who is better than the other tbh, but CS Pakistan take the cake here after giving us 14 seasons of amazing music
Agree to most of your points mate ! Although i dont feel that all the songs should have 'autotuned(or pitch corrected)' vocals ...some songs are great for their rawness ...for eg. the taqdeer song has that folk element and folk is supposed to be raw ..and if you need an example from the past CS India songs there is Chaudhary ..you can tell Mame Khan's voice is untouched there ... and to be honest the Bhoomi song Chorus sounds somewhat robotic because it is tuned and takes that rawness away from the song ..But again taste taste ki baat hai 😊. But haan overall mixing and production does need an improvement this season that i totally agree !
You’re right buddy. But the point is that Mame Khan has a better voice control overall, hence even without tuning it feels great. Same applies to some of the old classical songs - they’re evergreen kyunki unki vocal performance raw hi itni khubsurat thi. Tuning till an “extent” sounds natural but over-tuning can definitely spoil such tracks. Oh and, love your videos 🙏🏻🔥
Definitely some vocals sounds great without much processing nd tuning. Maintaining the rawness of the song is really important but as vasudev mentioned that nowadays electronic music is on trend that is why mixing and tuning has become very important aspect of music.
also i don't feel the "taqdeer banayo fakeer" line is not totally off the metronome, though the guitar (bass i think) which is being played with the line "taqdeer banayo faqeer" has some weird delay effect which makes it feel out of sinc . i may be totally wrong but that's what i felt when I heard it.
Been following you for a long time.... I agree to most of your point of views.... But not in this... Coke studio production looks so dull... The absence of Pitch correction is quite evident.... It doesn't sound up to date.... It sounds dated....
@@trisha2955 Well they're bragging because they're actually doing it. In fact you should feel fortunate that there's one Coke Studio Bangla making Bengali music. Otherwise no one gives a flying fuck about Bengali music here and we all know the condition of Coke studio Bharat. Learn to appreciate where it's due rather than spewing bs hatred.
This is much awaited video....really Pakistan coke studio have a really good team...big fan of Xulfi and many other.....India has incredible talent but it seems there is some issue
India- the heaven of mother culture! But CS Bharat has failed to represent the raw India this time whereas CS Bangla & CS Pakistan have been very much close to their roots. I really wish CS Bharat comes out strong with breathless performances.
Yes! Though vasudev bhai is absolutely correct autotune is used On Atif Aslam Sir's Voice in Dil Diya Gallan...."Das Laina ki Nakhra dikha ke" the word "laina" is totally autotuned....But I disagree with the point that vasudev bhai mentioned about that shakiness and rounding of notes...I would like to share a that The Unconventional Vibratos And Shakiness Was An X-factor along with his Vocal Texture that Made atif Aslam famous During his early days....Though nowadays he has Improved alot as a Singer "main agar" from Tubelight is a perfect example of his vocal abilities..the Falsettos he sung and the vocal dynamics he used There Are brilliant. But that doesn't mean that atif can't sing it live... checkout his live performance of dil Diya Gallan and you will get even more shakiness there
At the 2022 GRAMMY Awards, Arooj Aftab went from first-time GRAMMY nominee to history-making GRAMMY winner. Winning Best Global Music Performance for her single "Mohabbat," Aftab became the first Pakistani woman to ever win a GRAMMY.
One should listen to the beginning of Ni Oothaan Wale from Coke Studio Pk Season 4 to see the clearest effect of sound engineering in taking a song to another level when it kicks in and gives it that unique Rohail Hyatt sound
Finally somebody spoke it out... I always got hate whenever i pin pointed issues like these. It's relieving to see other people recognise this problem too. Hopefully it grows better.
Coke Studio Bangla Started their journey at the end of 2021. But it had done incredible job within few time. Coke studio Pakistan and Bangla is best.❤️
Very right ! Thank you for sharing this thing ❤ they should realise their mistakes .. it's not about labl or artist. It's about representing whole country.
Thank you for pointing it out to us. I did not know anything about this before but one thing was evident that CS Pak is doing much better. India needs to step us the game at all levels not only geopolitics or business methods. Music is in our culture, we need to show the world what we are capable of.
Very well pointed and very well said.. Happy to hear, at least someone with me on this.. I feel this too Coke Studio India can never match to Coke Studio Pakistan.. Somehow it was loosely handled.. There are few songs which I love- "Zariya-AR Sir" "Chhad de-Master Sleem" "Madaari-Vishal Dadlani" "Ki banu- Gurdasman saab & Diljit" but later on we lost it... Hope these little little mistakes are taken care of in future CS Bharat episods. Cheerz all.
JESUS! FINALLY! Someone put it out there!! We lost the essence of Coke Studio MTV/India the day we switched to this new tag/label. Man! What happened to our quality? The set design, the production, the melodies - everything is so mid, so tacky!!! Doesn't even come close to the tracks composed by Ram Sampath or Rahman or Salim-Sulaiman! All this while CS Pakistan and Bangladesh have focused on nothing but improvement and evolution. I mean, just look at how they bring something fresh and new every season!
Well said 🙌 I also felt that lack of tightness and pitch correction the day I heard coke studio Bharat. At first I thought that they will gonna match the level and format of the last coke studio pakistan with amazing songs like Kana Yaari, Thagyan and many others but it is no where near to that. There is also a way to blend the mix and still make it sound Raw. And also I felt somewhere the compositions are a little tricky to grab hold attention of audience.
This season is simply lacking in melody....no melodic hooks that will keep you coming back. I cannot even get through a whole track without skipping ahead to see if it improves, and then never see myself listening to it ever again. And, when you compound that with the fact that even the performance itself isn't live to begin with, it is inexcusable.
So True.. ❤❤❤ agreed With Single Single Point 👑 Must Needed 🔥🔥 Seriously The Level Is Going Down Using The Name of Our Country 😕 Even An Independent Artist is Doing Great As Compared To Them 🙏 They Need To Think On This ❤🔥 Thank You Sir For The Video 💪
I completely disagree with most of the points made. I've been producing electronic music for six years, and while I don't consider myself a great mix engineer, I do handle the mixing and mastering of my songs. The difference between Coke Studio mixes and others is intentional. Coke Studio aims to bring a "live concert" vibe to their videos, and they have a keen ear for it. Not every song needs to sound perfect; Coke Studio chooses this style deliberately. Autotune and over-processed vocals are common in songs designed for radio and streaming services. In reality, about 95% of singers and even rappers require heavy processing to sound decent. I've mixed for many rappers, and the raw recordings often sound terrible. Autotune and compression are essential to make them sound presentable. The Seedhe Maut video impressed me because they dared to keep their rap raw. Although it wasn't perfectly blended, it showcased their guts to experiment. This is what I appreciate in Coke Studio Bharat mixes. the rawness that makes it feel like they are genuinely jamming together, without the need for everything to be perfectly crisp all the time.
Jo baat aapne last me kahi, wo bilkul justify krti h sir. Jo true musicians hn, unhe to pta h lekin jo bs aise hi music me aa gye, unhe ye video dekhne k baad b kuch smjh ni aega. Qki hmaare yhan new generation me ek cheez bht common dekhne ko mil rhi h k wo music ko andr se dekhna hi ni chahte. Unhe lgta h k isme koi bdi baat ni h, bina seekhe hi achha kr skte hn. Log classical ko approach tk ni kr rhe hn. Ek saal seekhne k baad wo log vocals sikhaane lg rhe hn, jinke sur khud ni lg rhe hn. To I can see k future khan ja rha h..
Bro respect for your hard work . I am also a Musician however, i do not agree to your point of view about autotune coz i am Hardcore Classical listener . and belive me RAW sound gives me Goosebumps as compare to that soft autotuned voice which you r talking about . And brother I think this RAWness is the heart of Indian Culture
Hats off to you sir ye awareness aap se hi shuru hosakta hai hm sabka pura support hai mai bhi realise karta hun ki coke studio Pakistan ke songs kitne Perfect hote hai har maine me … respect for you vasu sir❤
Coke Studio Pakistan is unmatched!!! 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 Coke Studio India honestly just sounds so awful and such a mess now, it was at it’s peak when they had guest music producers on such as A.R. Rahman etc they need to go back to that.
Absolutely correct sir. I felt the same in that part of seedhe maut. And I couldn't listen to that other song till the end. Thanks for giving the reason for what was wrong. 🙌💯
You should help my teenage son mix and produce his songs. I wish I could get someone from CS Pakistan. Their mixing is almost perfect. Cheers from Florida.
It is pretty evident that now indian music industry is all about the looks and style because that's where most of their budget lies rather than investing money to polish the music itself.
coke studio bharat music se jyada costumes, looks, personal attire pe focus h. hae individual artist ko cool, fashionable aur alag dikhna h. Gaane k baare me nahi soch rhe. Bhole manusho agae gaana hit hua toh waisw tum bhi famous ho jaoge. par music par focus nahi h sabko bas cool, fashion smart dikhna h.
There are so many erros in Coke Studio Bharat. We all feel sad for this! But T-series mixtape is an very good alternative for this. The only difference is mixtape uses only T-series songs but their mixing, choice of singers, instruments, artist is one of the best👍👍
Hello Mr, Vasudev Can you please comment like this on new song coke studio "Khalasi" song this is good or poor...??? Can you please help me to understand
Lack of rehearsal, lack of professionalism, these should be improved and there should be a well trained and expert musician who will check minute details, notes while recoding a performance.
i have no idea what you're talking about. That song was perfect. Brij and Bhojpuri traditional vocals are supposed to have the rawness. It's like asking Mame Khan to leaved the rusticness of his voice. I for one listened to the song on 🔁. Sadly I don't agree with your take.
Sir, me kudh singer hun, Atif Aslam Bina auto tune ke vaisa hi ga sakta hi, in fact me bhi replecate karsakta hun aap chahe to.....Bina auto tune ...... "Ha auto tune lagaya hai i agree, but Bina auto tune Aisa nahi ga sakta" Jo aap bola hai who galat hai 😂
Spot on!! Coke studio Pakistan and Coke studio Bangladesh are doing much better. We seem to have lost our way😢
Apka T series haina or kia chahiye😅
@@Waseem_Baluch99 t sires keya tomluga cultural music banata hain?😑
It's ok!
Don't be frustrated.
Hope India will bring there quality.
Take love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Don't worry Acharya ji, music mein kon agay kon pichay. Indian music, playback singers like Rafi saab, kishore kumar, Mukesh, Talat Mehmood, Manna dey, udit Narayan, Kumar Sanu, Lata & Asha; plus Indian Movies ki puri Dunya fan hai. Hum is jadu se hi nahi nikal saktey. ❤️from 🇵🇰
Coke Studio Bangla has an incredible music arrangement.
100%
Nah it sucks
@@aiRizvi Coke Studio Bangla is far Better than your entire life, your family and your country
@@aiRizvi way better than coke studio India lol 😂
Think u didn’t listen properly or u are jealous of bangla song success 😂
Coke studio Bangla and coke studio pak has the best composition and mixing of instruments ❤
Coke studio Pak has the best mixing engineers. i have been fan of their mixing.. its amazing how they seamlessly blend hundreds of instruments.
talha anjum performance 🔥🔥🔥🔥
💯
So does Coke Studio Bangla
Coke studio Bangla is ❤❤❤
They are sending the masters overseas.
Coke Studio Pakistan is just unbeatable bruv!
Coke studio bangla is also impressive
Love u from Bangladesh dada🙏
As a Pakistani
You're right
Coke Studio Bangla is also very impressive and great
I always listen to it
Yes better than many coke studios but Ditto copy of coke studio Pakistan just languages are different!
@@Junaidraj1o Coke studio pakistan is legendary but you have zero knowledge about coke studio bangla and music 😂😂
@@WorldAroundMe1 I even Don't want to know like you do some work instead of having PhD on coke studio
Bharat had 10x budget than Pakistan season 14, seriously wondering pesa gya to gya kaha..
What😮 10x budget
And still pak is giving hits and Bharat is giving #
True Bro
Kha gaye lagta hai 🤐🤐
Ye Raaz bhi ussi k sath chala gaya
2:00 I can't thank you enough for pointing this out.
So many friends of mine with zero clue regarding production always baselessly boast around how Indian artists like Sonu Nigam and Arijit Singh don't require any autotune and all, and call me stupid and get all offended when I try reasoning with them as a music producer that what autotune or pitch correction even is and how no artist is quite an exception to this, and how there's nothing really wrong with it (they've no idea about music production whatsoever and for the fact, don't even know what autotune really is or how is it supposed to work)
bhai log ye smjhte hai autotune word agar use hogya kahi, jaise apne SONU SIR and ARIJIT DA ka naam liya to ye singers autotune k sahare jee re hai.....log ye smjhte hai ki inhe aata hi ni gaana .....
Bro i am trying to understand this with an open mind... so with todays music and instruments, auto tune is a must... which includes the likes of Rahat saab as well? Ok maybe thats why the production quality and overall sound of todays songs are better to ear then compared to say Rafi saab and others.
Can you please explain the timing factor as well? Does it mean older performances like that of Jagjit singh, Nusrat saab acrually had to prepare the performance to whole new level or that genre allows little bit of error?
@@GurpreetSingh-zj9nh Coke studio Bangladesh version is doing great work.
@@rishabhsharma1838 Coke studio Bangladesh version is doing great work.
@@GurpreetSingh-zj9nh bro i came to know only htrough thid video or comment... may be only for mix and mastring autotune is used in voices of these great singer, like he said about arijit and sonu sir....actually now in music, acoustic music is getting less importance in songs....and I don't think these singer actually need autuotune to to sing because in there lives perform well...and that Atif's part shown in this video can be easily sing...its not that difficult thing..
Not only Pakistan but coke Studio bangla (Bangladesh) is doing great.
Coke Studio bangla ❤❤. They represent Their culture 🥰.
Kudos to you for bringing this fact to light that even the biggest artists use pitch correction and how it's crucial to blend vocals into the mix with perfection. People mostly have 0 clue about it and they've stigmatised it so much that its influence is being seen in something as high budget as Coke Studio! 🙌
coke studio bangla is the perfect example of musical arrangement and mixing..
but not as perfect as coke studio Pakistan🔥
@@fhaal
CSP is good in terms of digital music..not instrumentally superior...CSB is far more better than CSP in terms of musical arrangements...
@@JH_Jamil wdym "digital music"? CS Pakistan has pulled off western and eastern instruments and fusions amazingly. In season 9, "paar channaa de" they showed a Pakistani plucked string instrument, in season 14 they had a harp, in earlier seasons Ahad Nayani killed it on the drums, they've incorporated different national musical instruments e.g. rabab, just to mention a few examples. It's not a competition of who is better than the other tbh, but CS Pakistan take the cake here after giving us 14 seasons of amazing music
@@JH_Jamil CSB can NEVER come nowhere near CSP they've nailed every genre
@@fhaal let us not compare and fight. Let us enjoy the music - which resembles peace !
Agree to most of your points mate ! Although i dont feel that all the songs should have 'autotuned(or pitch corrected)' vocals ...some songs are great for their rawness ...for eg. the taqdeer song has that folk element and folk is supposed to be raw ..and if you need an example from the past CS India songs there is Chaudhary ..you can tell Mame Khan's voice is untouched there ... and to be honest the Bhoomi song Chorus sounds somewhat robotic because it is tuned and takes that rawness away from the song ..But again taste taste ki baat hai 😊. But haan overall mixing and production does need an improvement this season that i totally agree !
You’re right buddy. But the point is that Mame Khan has a better voice control overall, hence even without tuning it feels great. Same applies to some of the old classical songs - they’re evergreen kyunki unki vocal performance raw hi itni khubsurat thi. Tuning till an “extent” sounds natural but over-tuning can definitely spoil such tracks. Oh and, love your videos 🙏🏻🔥
Definitely some vocals sounds great without much processing nd tuning. Maintaining the rawness of the song is really important but as vasudev mentioned that nowadays electronic music is on trend that is why mixing and tuning has become very important aspect of music.
also i don't feel the "taqdeer banayo fakeer" line is not totally off the metronome, though the guitar (bass i think) which is being played with the line "taqdeer banayo faqeer" has some weird delay effect which makes it feel out of sinc
. i may be totally wrong but that's what i felt when I heard it.
Been following you for a long time.... I agree to most of your point of views.... But not in this... Coke studio production looks so dull... The absence of Pitch correction is quite evident....
It doesn't sound up to date.... It sounds dated....
@@RishavBaruah Coke studio Bangladesh version is doing great work.
Coke studio bangla did excellent job, their song represents actual bangali texture 🇧🇩
Another day, another Bangladeshi bragging about "actual" bangali texture 🥱
@@trisha2955 and what Trisha???hating B word
@@trisha2955 Well they're bragging because they're actually doing it. In fact you should feel fortunate that there's one Coke Studio Bangla making Bengali music. Otherwise no one gives a flying fuck about Bengali music here and we all know the condition of Coke studio Bharat. Learn to appreciate where it's due rather than spewing bs hatred.
@@MH-jo7xo and you can praise your self in your own comment section. Are you guys praising yourself here 'cause no one else is?
@@trisha2955 I'm an Indian and i love how you ignored my comment. Why you so pressed tho? Which Bangladeshi has hurt ya lady?
Coke studio Bangla doing great 🇧🇩🔥❤ season 1 was superb and now season 2🔥
As a Proud Indian am saying that Coke Studio Bangla & Pakistan is doing great more than Coke Studio Bharat🥲
As everyone is saying, Coke Studio Bangla too is giving breathtaking musical experiences.
Always Coke Studio Pakistan
They are the best
No bro coke studio bangla is best
Are you joking?
Who said this?
Lol! 😂
@@sakibramim1993literally everyone.
Please recommend song
Coke studio Bangla is on another level
Arnob is smashing it
This is much awaited video....really Pakistan coke studio have a really good team...big fan of Xulfi and many other.....India has incredible talent but it seems there is some issue
India- the heaven of mother culture! But CS Bharat has failed to represent the raw India this time whereas CS Bangla & CS Pakistan have been very much close to their roots. I really wish CS Bharat comes out strong with breathless performances.
Atif can sing that shakiness without autotune
Yes! Though vasudev bhai is absolutely correct autotune is used On Atif Aslam Sir's Voice in Dil Diya Gallan...."Das Laina ki Nakhra dikha ke" the word "laina" is totally autotuned....But I disagree with the point that vasudev bhai mentioned about that shakiness and rounding of notes...I would like to share a that The Unconventional Vibratos And Shakiness Was An X-factor along with his Vocal Texture that Made atif Aslam famous During his early days....Though nowadays he has Improved alot as a Singer "main agar" from Tubelight is a perfect example of his vocal abilities..the Falsettos he sung and the vocal dynamics he used There Are brilliant. But that doesn't mean that atif can't sing it live... checkout his live performance of dil Diya Gallan and you will get even more shakiness there
@@jashansings are u talking about vibrato!
No one can beat coke studio Pakistan ❤
Coke studio Bangla ❤
Pepsi studio
Pakistan and Bangla both are on same level in terms of production quality, but Pakistan has an upper hand in terms of popularity
@@nyctophilecat itni Jalan achi nehi hai bahi.. Warna depression hojaiyr ga aap ko😂😂😂😂🌶🌶🌶🌶
@@IAK1992 😂 jala nahi yunhi majak kia.. 🙏
At the 2022 GRAMMY Awards, Arooj Aftab went from first-time GRAMMY nominee to history-making GRAMMY winner. Winning Best Global Music Performance for her single "Mohabbat," Aftab became the first Pakistani woman to ever win a GRAMMY.
One should listen to the beginning of Ni Oothaan Wale from Coke Studio Pk Season 4 to see the clearest effect of sound engineering in taking a song to another level when it kicks in and gives it that unique Rohail Hyatt sound
Totally agree with you Bro !!
Keep up the great work ❤
Coke studio Bangladesh version is doing great work.
'Kangna' was the epitome of music production. It still gives me shivers how Rohail Hyatt managed to pull it off.!!!!
Glad someone brought up this
Thank you for talking about this. More power to you!
Big fan 🙇🏻♂️🙏🏻
@@user-hr6uz7ui7m
Listen Coke Studio Bangla 💌 You will love it for sure 🤘
100%
Yah❤
Right!
Yessss❤ listen coke studio Pakistan alsooo
Coke studio pakistan and বাংলাদেশ is far better than coke studio bharat
Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan saab sing without autotune and amazing
*Abida Parveen sahiba*
Coke studio Pakistan have it's own level❤ Original is Original.
Finally somebody spoke it out...
I always got hate whenever i pin pointed issues like these. It's relieving to see other people recognise this problem too. Hopefully it grows better.
Coke studio Bangladesh version is doing great work.
Coke Studio Bangla Started their journey at the end of 2021. But it had done incredible job within few time. Coke studio Pakistan and Bangla is best.❤️
All you said is 100% true and hope people will get aware of these things.
Very right ! Thank you for sharing this thing ❤ they should realise their mistakes .. it's not about labl or artist.
It's about representing whole country.
This is the video we music lovers deserves! 💯🔥🙌 thanks Vasudev sir for this video to separate awareness 🙌
Sir, what's your opinion on Coke studio Bangla ???
The bangla is doing tremendously well
Thank you for pointing it out to us. I did not know anything about this before but one thing was evident that CS Pak is doing much better. India needs to step us the game at all levels not only geopolitics or business methods. Music is in our culture, we need to show the world what we are capable of.
Absolutely right vasudev sir
Perfect example of best mixes is Coke Studio Pakistan S14.
I personally love Pakistan Coke Studio and Nescafe Basement. The music is at another level.. Unique and of variety.
Are you a relative of sherry katthak
to be honest Coke studio pakistan is way too ahead . Pakistani artists are brilliant.
@@samarthjain145both are good
@@samarthjain145it doesn’t show in their Coke studio though
Very well pointed and very well said.. Happy to hear, at least someone with me on this.. I feel this too Coke Studio India can never match to Coke Studio Pakistan.. Somehow it was loosely handled.. There are few songs which I love- "Zariya-AR Sir" "Chhad de-Master Sleem" "Madaari-Vishal Dadlani" "Ki banu- Gurdasman saab & Diljit" but later on we lost it... Hope these little little mistakes are taken care of in future CS Bharat episods. Cheerz all.
JESUS! FINALLY! Someone put it out there!! We lost the essence of Coke Studio MTV/India the day we switched to this new tag/label. Man! What happened to our quality? The set design, the production, the melodies - everything is so mid, so tacky!!! Doesn't even come close to the tracks composed by Ram Sampath or Rahman or Salim-Sulaiman! All this while CS Pakistan and Bangladesh have focused on nothing but improvement and evolution. I mean, just look at how they bring something fresh and new every season!
Felt the same. Agreed 100% with you!
Thanks for making this video and spreading awareness.
Well said 🙌
I also felt that lack of tightness and pitch correction the day I heard coke studio Bharat.
At first I thought that they will gonna match the level and format of the last coke studio pakistan with amazing songs like Kana Yaari, Thagyan and many others but it is no where near to that. There is also a way to blend the mix and still make it sound Raw. And also I felt somewhere the compositions are a little tricky to grab hold attention of audience.
This season is simply lacking in melody....no melodic hooks that will keep you coming back. I cannot even get through a whole track without skipping ahead to see if it improves, and then never see myself listening to it ever again. And, when you compound that with the fact that even the performance itself isn't live to begin with, it is inexcusable.
So True.. ❤❤❤ agreed With Single Single Point 👑
Must Needed 🔥🔥
Seriously The Level Is Going Down Using The Name of Our Country 😕 Even An Independent Artist is Doing Great As Compared To Them 🙏
They Need To Think On This ❤🔥
Thank You Sir For The Video 💪
Music and drama vote for Pakistan ❤
Thanks sirji for saying this loud and clear, i really wanted someone to say this
Bro bhoomi is a gem. Great work from Salim-Sulaiman.
🙌
I completely disagree with most of the points made. I've been producing electronic music for six years, and while I don't consider myself a great mix engineer, I do handle the mixing and mastering of my songs. The difference between Coke Studio mixes and others is intentional. Coke Studio aims to bring a "live concert" vibe to their videos, and they have a keen ear for it. Not every song needs to sound perfect; Coke Studio chooses this style deliberately. Autotune and over-processed vocals are common in songs designed for radio and streaming services. In reality, about 95% of singers and even rappers require heavy processing to sound decent. I've mixed for many rappers, and the raw recordings often sound terrible. Autotune and compression are essential to make them sound presentable. The Seedhe Maut video impressed me because they dared to keep their rap raw. Although it wasn't perfectly blended, it showcased their guts to experiment. This is what I appreciate in Coke Studio Bharat mixes. the rawness that makes it feel like they are genuinely jamming together, without the need for everything to be perfectly crisp all the time.
I was exercising in gym suddenly play this song and this chorus part came “faqeer” I felt what’s going on
After release of GEEJAGA HAKKI, KHALASI, KYA KARIE KARIMOL
this video aged like milk😂😂😂😂😂
Jo baat aapne last me kahi, wo bilkul justify krti h sir. Jo true musicians hn, unhe to pta h lekin jo bs aise hi music me aa gye, unhe ye video dekhne k baad b kuch smjh ni aega. Qki hmaare yhan new generation me ek cheez bht common dekhne ko mil rhi h k wo music ko andr se dekhna hi ni chahte. Unhe lgta h k isme koi bdi baat ni h, bina seekhe hi achha kr skte hn. Log classical ko approach tk ni kr rhe hn. Ek saal seekhne k baad wo log vocals sikhaane lg rhe hn, jinke sur khud ni lg rhe hn. To I can see k future khan ja rha h..
Coke studio Bangla and pak is doing much better job 👍
Wow totally felt it in their music. Thank you for pointing out the reasons for dummies. Well done Vasudev Ji
Bro respect for your hard work . I am also a Musician however, i do not agree to your point of view about autotune coz i am Hardcore Classical listener . and belive me RAW sound gives me Goosebumps as compare to that soft autotuned voice which you r talking about . And brother I think this RAWness is the heart of Indian Culture
Classical singer ke sur aur aaj ke singers ke sur dekho bhai bina autotune ke khichadi bn jaegi 😂🙏🏻🙏🏻
SAHIL BHAI Bina microphone ke raw gana gao doordarshan mai
Kya raw raw lga rkha h use aalsi kehte h jb engineering na aye to
100% approved ,its been so long this is going on they really need to stop now and bring change.
love from coke studio bangla
Hats off to you sir ye awareness aap se hi shuru hosakta hai hm sabka pura support hai mai bhi realise karta hun ki coke studio Pakistan ke songs kitne Perfect hote hai har maine me … respect for you vasu sir❤
Pakistani music are fabously coke studio itself international plathform ,
100% True Brother. Very Well Said. 👍🏻
Coke Studio Pakistan is unmatched!!! 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 Coke Studio India honestly just sounds so awful and such a mess now, it was at it’s peak when they had guest music producers on such as A.R. Rahman etc they need to go back to that.
Absolutely correct sir. I felt the same in that part of seedhe maut. And I couldn't listen to that other song till the end. Thanks for giving the reason for what was wrong. 🙌💯
You should help my teenage son mix and produce his songs. I wish I could get someone from CS Pakistan. Their mixing is almost perfect. Cheers from Florida.
Truth has been spoken. Thanks Bhai!!
Please resist coke studio Bharat! It's a blunder! Complete defamation of Indian music.
Coke studio Pakistan is one of the biggest ICON at the moment
It is pretty evident that now indian music industry is all about the looks and style because that's where most of their budget lies rather than investing money to polish the music itself.
Please share your thoughts on Coke Studio Bangla
Hello sir
may i know the mic that you are using for vocal
Hats off for this much needed discussion ..very well said.
Mai ek classical flute player hu aur sikh bhi raha hu . aap bilkul sahi bol rahe ho sir ji .
Just thinking about the Era of Talat Mahmoodji , Mukeshji , Hemant Kumarji , Rafi Saab, Kishore Kumar and other legends ! 🤔🥲
very rightly said, its sad that "Bharat" is being used for such disastrous projects !!
Coke studio Bangla is doing great.
please review their work.
Pl teach me when chords are mix with melody I am basic learner of piano
Love the coke studio bangla, they did a great job
Right
Even they started in 2022 still they're doing GREAT
Impressive!
at 3:10 which song is this???
I love coke studio pakistan ❤
coke studio bharat music se jyada costumes, looks, personal attire pe focus h. hae individual artist ko cool, fashionable aur alag dikhna h. Gaane k baare me nahi soch rhe. Bhole manusho agae gaana hit hua toh waisw tum bhi famous ho jaoge. par music par focus nahi h sabko bas cool, fashion smart dikhna h.
Really appreciate your work to educate the public about this.
I am a big fan of Coke studio but Coke studio Bharat has disappointed me a lot ...
Much needed Discussion sir ❤❤❤
Hats off to your dedication & Mind🌺🌺🌺🙏🙏🙏🌺🌺🌺
There are so many erros in Coke Studio Bharat. We all feel sad for this! But T-series mixtape is an very good alternative for this. The only difference is mixtape uses only T-series songs but their mixing, choice of singers, instruments, artist is one of the best👍👍
Coke studio Pakistan and Coke studio Bangla best
Hello
Mr, Vasudev Can you please comment like this on new song coke studio "Khalasi" song this is good or poor...??? Can you please help me to understand
Coke studio bangla from Bangladesh doing better than coke studio India 😢
As a music lover, and i love to think critically about music and it's science. totally agree on your point
BUT ATIF ASLAM & ARIJIT SINGH SOUNDS THE SAME EVEN WHILE SINGING IN LIVE ❤️🔥❤️🔥
Right!
They both are LEGENDARY SINGERS ❤
Mere ko achchha laga "Hori Re Rasiya" khatam baat
Lack of rehearsal, lack of professionalism, these should be improved and there should be a well trained and expert musician who will check minute details, notes while recoding a performance.
Thank you 🙏 ❤ for covering this issue … man ki baat keh di apne @mixbyvasudev
👏👏👏
God Bless You 💝
Also...the artist of Mehram Coke Studio also won a grammy...in 2021 I think.
Yes.. Arooj Aftab
Sir focusrite Scarlett Gen 4 a gaya hai please do review
And should i buy it as my first audio interface
i have no idea what you're talking about. That song was perfect. Brij and Bhojpuri traditional vocals are supposed to have the rawness. It's like asking Mame Khan to leaved the rusticness of his voice. I for one listened to the song on 🔁. Sadly I don't agree with your take.
Whats that song at 7:25?
Seriously though, Coke Studio Bangla are doing better mixing than Coke Studio Bharat at this moment in time, let's hope they improve.
Thanks for letting us know.. Alwys with you. ❤
Really a topic to discuss and understand ❤
Sir, me kudh singer hun, Atif Aslam Bina auto tune ke vaisa hi ga sakta hi, in fact me bhi replecate karsakta hun aap chahe to.....Bina auto tune ......
"Ha auto tune lagaya hai i agree, but Bina auto tune Aisa nahi ga sakta" Jo aap bola hai who galat hai 😂