How Coop Was Saved From The Black Hole In Interstellar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 авг 2024
- Interstellar is a fantastic tale of time, space, and love. But if you got a bit lost in the final act of the film, we wouldn’t blame you. Here's how Cooper was saved from the black hole.
#Film #Interstellar #SciFi
Watch Full Video: • The Ending Of Interste...
![Kodak Black - Sharp Vibes [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oEV0OoLJeIs/mqdefault.jpg)
They established in the movie that "they" are "Us" from future
No, they didn't.
Cooper claimed they were future humans. The movie never established that his completely baseless speculation was correct.
They are humas million of years in the future who built the tesefact so cooper can communicate with murph and she can save the world
@@patrickd8654 "They" can't be humans because if humans were not gonna survive in the first place then how could there be "Future Humans"
Or to simply put, this means that no species on earth should ever go extinct
because their "future intelligent self"" will come and save them.
@@princeydv6759
Side note: Most species on Earth will never have descendants intelligent enough to develop space travel.
Main point: Futue humans creating the time loop is not necessarily a paradox. It would be possible if the eternalist view of time is correct, which the movie explicitly assumes to be the case.
From a five-or-more-dimensional perspective, the past and future always exist. As Brand said when she was Blatantly Foreshadowing (as Nolan characters do), the future is like a hill and the past like a valley, and the five-d people can access them as easily as humans move around space.
There was no "first place" in which present humans become extinct, because the future humans were "always" there to help them.
Even if the wormhole builders are not humans from the future, the movie still requires circular casuality. Cooper sends a message urging his past self to stay, which past Cooper disregards. He sends past self coordinates to NASA, which past self follows up on. And he sends past Murphy data from the black hole (Murphy was about 90 years old when Cooper entered the black hole, but about 40 when she got the data he sent.)
All three are unambiguous cases of future events causing past events.
@@princeydv6759cooper saved the humans on earth. But the people that made the tesseract were from that planet that Brand helped colonize. If that makes sense
They are not "otherworldly beings". They are future humans. The film is pretty clear about this. They are not "mysterious". They are not a mystery. C'mon, guys. Don't make explainers if you don't understand what you're explaining.
Technically they are otherworldly beings because we know they don’t live on Earth anymore.
If they are humans you are stuck in a paradox.
The film is not clear that the five-dimensional beings are future humans. The film shows Cooper claiming -- with perfect certainty yet absolutely no evidence -- that the builders are future humans. It never shows us any indication that he is correct.
@@bymicromizeCooper still chose to show their past selves the coordinates for NASA even though he knew it already happened. He still did it because he knew it was his duty.
you can see the full video first.
One of the greatest films ever made imo, I really liked how it was grounded in real science as well. Cooper can say he was the only human to have ever survived a black hole!
"It was grounded in real science"
"the only human to have ever survived a black hole"
One of these claims is not like the other. 🤪
@@patrickd8654obviously it’s science fiction but most things (not all) are based in science and almost 100% correct (according to what scientists knew at that time) so yes the “surviving a blackhole” thing is a bit unrealistic but it’s not impossible if the blackhole is big enough and it’s rendered correctly.
It was co-produced and advised by a real theoretical physicist after all
Hey, they were right about black holes 🤷♂️
The black hole bit is complete baloney yes we don’t know much about black holes but there’s enough equations that explain some of the possibilities the secretion disc itself is 1 million degrees so you’d probably die before being remotely close to the event horizon let’s assume cooper space suit was heat proof if his whole space craft got ripped to shreds how did he get away with it even going further back into the film how would they even be able to walk on miller’s planet being that close to a black hole
Wish I could watch something like this again for the first time
It’s in netflix
@@aryaavyshaliraj6448"for the first time"
@@aryaavyshaliraj6448it is not on netflix
Same here dude, however i do remember how it was for the first time. It’s always special
That "5 dimensional library" is just a time tesseract
It's *Space-Time Tessaract
I thought a tesseract was a 4th dimensional cube
@@zxlillilllilxz304 It's a Geometrical Description
Well that clears it up
Yeha we know what that is tf
Bruh, the ones that made the tesseract are "US" but a future generation
My theory is that the past NASA mission they were also carrying 30k fertilize egg and the astronaut successfully found a habitable planet to live in and raise the eggs and time is diffrent in other planets so they probably got a head start with the NASA technology and improve and they became the better humans
Straight up it’s out higher selves
United States? Damn
America built the wormhole
I thought the movie was about love...the love of a father for his daughter that bended space and time creating a wormhole to habitable worlds and traveling through a blackhole and to study it and send the data to his daughter to save her from death..
Actually the movie is about Theoretical Physics, Not Practical Physics.
It's a pure sci-fi movie. Nolan added some emotional drama to grab more viewers.
Spoiler Alert: The "beings" are the same humans in the same timeline as when Lil Cooper and big Cooper. They just lived another 60 years 😂😂
Superb film , one of my faves....
Another 900 iq move by Nolan
In a black hole time and space flip. That's how he was able to move back and forth throughout time.
This is all a death dream session. He's mentally revisiting his life as he dies. That's a common occurence
They are not other worldly beings. They are future human. Very very far future. It’s embarrassing for looper to miss this!😂
“They” are us from the future which then begs the question how did “they” survive the blight in order to live and become so advance that “they” are able to create wormholes and the tesseract.
Because coop and daughter
Did u have ur eyes closed the whole movie 🤡
@@blueferal8626 No, its a paradox, because Cooper from the future in order to save Cooper from the past he would have had to survive the past cataclysm. So yes, aliens as the builders of the wormhole is a much plausible explanation.
@@virgil1981 wow no way
Thanks bro
I had my eyes closed the whole movie 🦖
@@blueferal8626 nope my eyes where opened the whole time both the first time and many times after I have seen this wonderful movie. If you’re gonna be negative and not contribute anything this a simple yet paradox related question go crawl away to another corner to loath about your life choices. I wish you the best friend and good fortune.
Nope- future humans
Maybe. Maybe not. The movie never shows us for sure.
@@patrickd8654 it makes it very clear that it was future humans
@@Finnbobjimbob
No. It makes very clear that Cooper is totally convinced, based on negligible evidence, that future humans built the time loop.
The movie never gives us any reason to think Cooper is right.
@@patrickd8654You think that but can’t prove it with substantial evidence can ya Bud?
@@Randomcookie1099
What are you asking me to prove?
The movie is ambiguous about who built the wormhole and the time loop. Cooper is absolutely certain it was built by future humans, but has no evidence whatsoever to support this. The movie never shows us any reason to think humans built the thing.
I don't have any evidence because I am not the one making a positive claim. The burden of proof is on people who say humans built it, not on people who say we don't know who built it.
i like how you never explained how he actually got out of the black hole 😂
Because he died once he was launched out the shuttle.
There is a theory, that after he fell into the black hole, was him hallucinating before he died
They saved him bro,didn't u listen? The same beings who put the worm hole there,the same ones who put the tesseract there
@@kb1248 cooper go in black hole. tesseract in black hole. cooper go in tesseract. tesseract disappear. where cooper?
@@sorenkair Cooper drifts away in space for a while,beings who put wormhole there,see him. beings save him and the robot man.
We all know that “they” are millennials who grew up helping their parents figure out smart phones and Facebook.
It's not a library it's a Tesseract 💅💅
'Damnit, Marie!'
A movie like this can't be bad with a director like Christopher Nolan who got help with all the science stuff from a physics Nobel Prize winner like Kip Thorne. Oh, by the way "They" were future humans.
Christopher Nolan : ok so this is gonna be the black hole scene
Actors : damn so the black holes gonna be one big CGI yea?
Chris : da fucks a CGI? (*revs up his secret Warp drive*)
They built it as a test to see if we are worthy of the knowledge they have.
We arnt yet but have potential
A beautiful film which defines science and spirituality together
The movie is an infinite loop. The humans did bring themselves into the future human beings. The movie shows a linear timeline where Cooper and his daughter saved the world so we know this happend so that a 3 dimensional being can understand the events happend. But to a 5th dimension being they are always saving the world, the events are always happening because they have control of time and gravity, thus an inifinite loop.
'them' are the future humans
I was thinking they are the people who were saved in Edmund’s planet for plan b. But then who put the worm-whole there as well. The thing about higher dimensions is that time doesn’t have to have causation. An ant that is traveling on line might have begging and end but that line on sphere has no end or beginning, it is all relative. So everything is happening at the same time. They are those in the past and they are those in the future, they help each other and there is no paradox.
Imagine being cooper and you watch her teenage years
“Them” is suspected to be more likely future humans
They/them are truly complex
looper gettin schooled in the comments fr
Them where the hunans from the future ..thats is a crazy paradox
I remember this movie... I remember not understanding any of it because I couldn't HEAR anything that was said! I could hear sound effects, but that was about it.
RRRRRRAAAANGGGGGGGGG
(Hans Zimmer fell asleep again on the organ)
That is tesseract
They are us from the future ,more advanced with technology so they finish the loop
Wow, Looper sure doesn't get that right. Yikes
What did they get wrong?
@@patrickd8654the “they” is “us” from the future, and that isn’t 5th dimension that is a 3rd dimension depiction of the 4th dimension
@@anthonyrobino145
The video posted here is an excerpt from a longer video which includes Cooper's completely basesless speculation that "they" are "us" from the future.
Good point about the hypercube. I think Looper explained that poorly, assuming the people who made the video even understood it themselves.
if there's a wormhole then.. Multiverse, we can go into anime's, Minecraft?!
They are higher dimensions beings and it's a terresect cube
You made it more confusing.
Them are "us" from the future.
”Them” was actually them in the future.
So if they are us from the future helping us, how did we survive to make it to the future?
IF they are us from the future (a big "if") then present humans survive into the future precisely because the future humans helped us.
The movie very explicitly embraces the "eternalist" view of time, with some of Nolan's trademark hamfisted exposition to make that clear.
The premise is that the past and the future are just as real as the present, that they "always exist" and that five-dimensional beings are able to move between past and future as easily as humans walk up and down a hill.
In other words, there is no "first play through" in which the future humans do not exist yet to help the present humans.
To be clear, I don't agree with all the slavish Nolan acolytes who think the movie is clear about whether the time loop was built by future humans. All we have is Cooper insisting (via Argument by Assertion, perhaps the most obnoxious of all logical fallacies) that humans built the thing.
But whether humans built it or not, we still have Cooper sending his past self messages, including the coordinates to NASA. So the movie requires eternalism and circular causality regardless of who built the time loop.
Stop saying wormhole wtf ... thats a black hole. and there are no otherworld being they are us from the future.
A wormhole and a black hole are two different things, and both of them appear in the movie.
Also, the movie never gives us any reason to think future humans built the time loop. Cooper thinks future humans built it, but he never offers a shred of evidence, nor does anything the movie shows us support Cooper's wild speculation.
it mentions both the worm hole and black hole if you keep listening
If Coop could travel to any time in Murphs bedroom why didn’t he travel to the earths present moment when older Murph was getting her things and leaving?
Mfs will die in ignorance before giving the Creator his credit
THEY IS OUR HIGHER SELVES
Amazing scene
Phenomenal part and great movie
He wasn't saved. He saw his child before he died
No he did infact survive.
That’s the scary part you see. They might’ve not saved humanity because they were benevolent, but because they wanted their live stocks to still keep on living. Perhaps we produce some kind of an energy when we die and they farm that? That’s one theory.
Truly delighted that I am not alone in thinking that. I don't even necessarily think they are malevolent.
But there is definitely a lot more we don't know about them than the average Nolan acolyte who thinks he figured this movie out realizes.
My head canon: Contrary to Cooper's entirely baseless speculation, the wormhole and the time loop were not created by future humans. They were created by aliens who are native to the galaxy that includes Gargantua, but who have outposts in multiple galaxies.
The aliens also created the blight, which is why it is so resilient, is so widespread and is able to rapidly evolve until it eventually kills every kind of crop, which would be kind of ludicrous if it were a naturally occurring blight.
The whole thing is an effort by the aliens to force humanity to move to the alien galaxy, for some inscrutable motive that only five-dimensional space gods would understand.
So the Annunaki mixed with the machines from The Matrix
Did you not watch the movie?
You’re idiots
@@patrickd8654 Dumbass
TARS and CASE are the best 🤖🤖.
I’m a blood. Blatt.
Type 3 civilisation: allow me to introduce myself
We need a part 2 Interstellar 🕳️
I think they are far future humans
I honestly believe its just The Lord
Plot Twist: Cooper was actually dreaming the entire movie which was created by Cobb from Inception who planted this idea in Cooper’s mind. 🤯
Or with the fact that that black hole wouldn't had of killed him either way
He literally said, 'they' are us. didnt you watch the movie before you post this bs?
is not even library, is just murphy's bedroom 🙄
"face palm".....................................................
Let’s be honest what alien would gaf about humans
It's a movie lil bro
He is not spared....he died!!!
Wrong , that’s literally not what happened nor has anyone working on the film ever said that .
We need a Interstellar 2 exploring about "they" more and other Interstellar mysteries
Absolutely not. Can't mess with a masterpiece.
NO!
HELL NAH. Its those thoughts that give us shitty sequals 💀
The Jackson 5 is them
I enjoyed this movie and was disappointed at the same time.
we're in the same boat
I enjoyed this movie and was amazed at the same time.
“Other worldly beings” heh Jesus, how’s about you actually watch the movie and pay CLOSE attention to what they say in the film before you go off making assumptions and passing out nicknames like it’s expired Halloween candy?
Akashic Records
CERN?
Kool
Lol this voice doesn’t have any explanation right n is confusing more.. the fact is cooper constructs it by himself bounded by love. That is the only explanation he gave at last
Ah yes, the non-binary They/Them beings saved humanity
Isn’t this deus ex machina?
I wouldn't say it was confusing. It's more like it was a disappointing ending to a pretty good movie.
Nuh uh
Wdym it was a perfect ending
Still confusing
Plot twist: cooper wasn’t saved from the black hole and actually died
Thats why pronouns "they/them" are wanted by some humans because they are smart💀
🤡☕️
Actually the aliens "THEY" is us the future humans ...if we stay in the earth we wont develop as they were now in the future so they decide to destroy the earth to get the humans ...to the other world where the present "THEY" aliens living now with the future planning 😂😂
*"They them"* sounds something like... LGBT 🤔
"They" is God
trust in the word of God, Matthew 7:24-27 Jesus says here, Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock: and the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell not: for it was founded upon a rock. And every one that heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man, which built his house upon the sand: and the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell: and great was the fall of it. Jesus saves, God bless.😊😊😊😊
ye shabh chijh mere liye kardo haa haa mujhe dekhna haa anevale kal me haa haa haa haa haa ok yarr haa
Bro stop
Now were talking to pronouns
They way you say "they /them" almost like this is a story about LGBT community
It seems almost like you are trying to start a debate about real world identity politics in the comment section of a video about science fictional aliens.
@@patrickd8654 yeah. things just popped out of my head when I watch this
@@psycho_dictator
LOL. That happens to me sometimes. 😜
Sorry if I misunderstood your intent.
@@patrickd8654 nah... it's OK really. no problem
🤣🤣🤣
And you're denying Qur'an
They have “they/them” pronouns?? Jezuzzzzz
Was "They" transgender? Please, get out of my head 😂
What a stupid movie
Well, it’s science FICTION, which is not supposed to be completely realistic by the way
@@andy.a5215 so you're saying fiction = stupid.
@@based8223 If you didn’t like it doesn’t mean it’s stupid
Great movie. Horrible ending.
Great movie. Marvelous ending.
Easily Nolan's worst.
How so? If you're saying this based off the video, worry not because this video is "explaining" something they have no fucking clue about
@@pixelgamer4985
What did they get wrong?
I would say "Tenet" is his worst. That one is like a parody of Nolan movies in general and of "Interstellar" and "Memento" in particular.
Easily Nolan's best.
I remember this movie... I remember not understanding any of it because I couldn't HEAR anything that was said! I could hear sound effects, but that was about it.
That's a sound settings issue on your part rather than the movie itself. I had to play around with my sound system settings a bit but once I did everything was clear and the effect levels were still enough to blow me off the couch