Why do we have museums? - J. V. Maranto

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025

Комментарии • 234

  • @noahfrench7412
    @noahfrench7412 10 лет назад +166

    The Gift Shop of Gift Shops will be the best sequel ever c:

    • @coenvannoord4976
      @coenvannoord4976 9 лет назад +9

      Would the giftshop of giftshops be a place where you can buy an intire shop as a present?

    • @PhoebeTheFairy56
      @PhoebeTheFairy56 7 лет назад +5

      Coen Van Noord maybe it sells tiny models of other gift shops

    • @주선미-i3h
      @주선미-i3h 7 лет назад +1

      That would be too disappointing.

    • @주선미-i3h
      @주선미-i3h 7 лет назад +1

      I mean, to Alison Jones

    • @josefholzer2433
      @josefholzer2433 3 года назад

      I couldn't find online store.

  • @peace8096
    @peace8096 Год назад +10

    The last bit about the accessibility of museums is of importance. My educational institution was the former residence of the British Governor of Bombay Presidency. We hold heritage walks, free of costs, for those interested in the history of the monumental structure. Free tours of such structures encourage research and a public engagement that is much needed for society as a whole to navigate their pasts.

  • @BrainStuffShow
    @BrainStuffShow 10 лет назад +129

    Well done TED animation explaining why we have museums.

  • @28Superficial
    @28Superficial 10 лет назад +13

    Love watching the Ted-Ed videos, they're so fun and the voice over are so good!

    • @Aritul
      @Aritul 2 года назад +1

      I was just going to say that.

  • @Webber-sr3xk
    @Webber-sr3xk 4 года назад +13

    Museums of ancient rome be like
    “And here this vase from... well... yesterday”

    • @clintgolub1751
      @clintgolub1751 3 года назад +2

      😂
      Truthfully though, the ancient Greeks both collected and venerated the ruins and artifacts of the ancient Mycenaeans 1000 years before them whom they viewed as a much greater civilization than their own. Greek mythology and Homer’s epics like ‘The Iliad’ and ‘The Odyssey” depict both real and fictional moments from that much older age leading up to the Macedonian Empire of the 800’s B.C.
      And going back even further than that, even those ancient Mycenaeans, Phoenicians, Egyptians of 1,200 B.C., and later the Achaemenid empire (before Persia) and Assyrian (before Babylonian) believed the cultures that inhabited Mesopotamia 1,000 years before them such as the Akkadian Empire of the early 2,000’s B.C. were closer to astrological truths and the divine nature of the gods. If we trace the world’s oldest monotheistic religion, Zoroastrianism (which was the precursor to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam and have TREMENDOUS similarities to Zoroaster’s cosmology), we go all the way back to the ancient city-state civilization of Sumer back in 3,000-3,500 B.C. and beyond which in turn considered itself very modern in comparison to the small kingdoms that pre-dated even that. Pretty much everything after the invention of agriculture in 10,000 B.C. slowly allowed human culture to flourish and coalesce into tribes, then small settlements, and thanks to increased trade, towns, cities, kingdoms, and finally continent-ruling empires 6,000 years ago. Looking at mankind’s history through this lens really does make our history from the Renaissance to now seem insanely modern! Centuries really aren’t that long if we’re being totally honest; it’s just our lifespans are so pitifully short, we loose sight of the macro view of things on a millennial level. And even then, 6-7,000 years of human development in language and culture is nothing in comparison to the eons our planet, Earth has evolved from 4.5 BILLION years ago. The real kicker here however is that throughout almost the entirety of human civilizations, we’ve always felt we were worse off than the preceding generations. The ancient Assyrians believed they were living in the last days, and in 700 B.C., the Ancient Greek poet Hesiod wrote in his book “Works and Days” a sequence of metallic ages depicting the ages of man, but they are degradations rather than progressions. Each age has less of a moral value than the preceding one. Of his own age he says: "And I wish that I were not any part of the fifth generation of men, but had died before it came, or had been born afterward."

  • @CraftedTomLion
    @CraftedTomLion 10 лет назад +132

    Next video: Why do we have gift shops?
    hehe

    • @MsSBVideos
      @MsSBVideos 9 лет назад +9

      +Tomeow To get the museum more money, even if the things the gift store sells have nothing to do with the museum.

    • @isaacbakan1295
      @isaacbakan1295 7 лет назад

      There is the Internet but that also has the money issue as Internet access and computers are not free

    • @ftnluizin3318
      @ftnluizin3318 4 года назад

      super poop

    • @jjmaker6422
      @jjmaker6422 4 года назад

      👎👎👎

  • @TheRyanLamont
    @TheRyanLamont 10 лет назад +20

    I love museums so this was fascinating to me!

  • @kenbobca
    @kenbobca 9 лет назад +34

    Very good video, I always learn something while watching TED-ed. Thank you.

  • @azipoor3468
    @azipoor3468 5 лет назад +6

    I remember that I always fell asleep when I went to a museum(held by school) or I visited the restaurants or cafes beside those museums😄

  • @merrymachiavelli2041
    @merrymachiavelli2041 10 лет назад +168

    It's weird, in the UK almost all museums are free, I didn't realise you had to pay in the US. Do you have to pay for all of them?

    • @derekmaynard1767
      @derekmaynard1767 10 лет назад +35

      I am yet to see a museum with free admission

    • @MuddieRain
      @MuddieRain 10 лет назад +2

      Only the bad ones cost money.

    • @SaraNicole613
      @SaraNicole613 10 лет назад +4

      I live in the U.S. and my family pays for a yearly membership. It works for multiple museums across the nation and some zoos (we've used it in TN, NC, and FL). All we have to do is show our membership card at the gate and we're allowed on through without paying any extra. I think it's something in the range of $30-$50 annually.

    • @merciadragon9425
      @merciadragon9425 10 лет назад +6

      They are FREE in Australia too.

    • @brian7168342
      @brian7168342 10 лет назад +5

      The payments for such things are probably made through taxes. If the gov't owns them, the people pay for it, but not directly.

  • @Theodora111Theo
    @Theodora111Theo 8 лет назад +58

    "GIFT SHOP OF GIFTSHOPS" DINGIT... I ACTUALLY LAUGHED AT THAT TERRIBLE JOKE. X'D

  • @sindarinelf1
    @sindarinelf1 10 лет назад +11

    Museums aren't free in my country Latvia, but they cost very little to enter! 1EUR, 2EUR, along those lines... I didn't even think that in US it might cost so much that someone can't get in...
    Also I didn't realise that in US museums aren't just public exhibition houses... They don't do any experiments or anything along those lines in our country... it's just exhibition, that's it!

    • @ShibashishMahapatra
      @ShibashishMahapatra 10 лет назад +3

      Museums are not just for exhibition. Only a small part of some museums are while a much larger part is reserved for experiment. A museum has a lot more things than those that are publicly displayed.

  • @localtriggerfan1998
    @localtriggerfan1998 7 лет назад +33

    "Just step into the wardrobe here. There you go. And we'll tour...NARNIA."

  • @Gears456123
    @Gears456123 10 лет назад

    We watched this in class today, awesome

  • @댕댕스-w8i
    @댕댕스-w8i Год назад +1

    The gift shop of gift shops will cost a lot of money to enter. It has many gift shops in it. LOL

  • @fjmh3933
    @fjmh3933 4 года назад

    My favourite museum is the Story Museum in Oxford, it's great fun and I loved it when I was younger.

  • @k.a.s1812
    @k.a.s1812 6 лет назад +2

    I don't really know why but I would love to hear whoever does the narrations for these videos to do audio books

  • @wyattwalker4866
    @wyattwalker4866 9 лет назад +47

    Did any. One else think the part when the guy is walking through with the kids looked like the foster home for imaginary friends?

  • @misssym769
    @misssym769 6 лет назад +2

    P.T. Barnum. Wow. This was actually in "The Greatest Showman". Wow wow

  • @kbinsobeih
    @kbinsobeih 8 лет назад +2

    this is incredible. btw i noticed in your videos sometimes the bg music is too high, it affects the voice over.

  • @strange_and_magnificent
    @strange_and_magnificent 4 года назад

    Great 👍 Ted ED!

  • @jupitired777
    @jupitired777 5 лет назад

    these lessons are great

  • @qaz8904
    @qaz8904 7 лет назад +1

    that had some great history

  • @ArkhipArt
    @ArkhipArt 4 месяца назад

    Very nice 👍👍👍👍👍

  • @annarose3354
    @annarose3354 5 лет назад +1

    Good point about ticket prices, I think museums should be free for everyone, adults included. Where I live in Aus generally only children are free. Sometimes the temporary exhibitions can be a bit expensive, and of course they're often the best ones.

  • @td5760
    @td5760 5 лет назад +5

    3:48 Is this where The Greatest Showman took inspiration with?

  • @KFunMuseum
    @KFunMuseum 8 месяцев назад

    very nice video.

  • @nighttimetelevision2969
    @nighttimetelevision2969 7 лет назад +4

    This video makes me want to visit a museum 😂

  • @mengkunsi9811
    @mengkunsi9811 Год назад +1

    Amazing

  • @niory
    @niory 10 лет назад +26

    many firsts were in Iraq ! its trully tragic what became of Iraq today ... a state of constant chaos ... the world has lots of ressons to do everything in their power to stop whats happening there and start digging for more History on that land

    • @ShibashishMahapatra
      @ShibashishMahapatra 10 лет назад

      It was Persia, after all.

    • @niory
      @niory 10 лет назад +1

      ***** suadi arabia was the birthplace of Islam and not Iraq :)

    • @niory
      @niory 10 лет назад +1

      ***** Baghdad in Iraq was build by the Islamic abbasid empire *Caliphate* and was the capital of the Islamic empire and the capital of all knowledge for hundred of years ! so Iraq has a big rule during the Islamic period which back then was quite admirable

    • @ShibashishMahapatra
      @ShibashishMahapatra 10 лет назад

      sara meachel 'Capital of all knowledge', I wouldn't agree to that.

    • @badneighbour999
      @badneighbour999 9 лет назад +1

      ***** and for the huns that catholiscm survived

  • @Wanderingby
    @Wanderingby 3 года назад +1

    Shocking lack of mention of musuems in the UK - Victoria & Albert or the Sir John Soane

  • @nalulumbay
    @nalulumbay 7 лет назад

    very well explained.

  • @MsSBVideos
    @MsSBVideos 9 лет назад +7

    Have you ever visited the store of stores or resteraunt of resteraunts?

  • @tigerwa
    @tigerwa 9 лет назад +1

    No mention of the Ashmolean?

  • @vl2809
    @vl2809 8 лет назад +7

    good video... unfortunately, this time you missed some crucial steps (clearly in favour of institutions known in the US). for example the very first institution called museum, the 16th century "museo" by italian historian Giovanni Dosio, a building at lake como where he collected portraits of important men of history. Or the very first art museum open to the public, the Pinakothek in Munich. Also, the predominantly royal Wunderkammern started off in the late 15th century and became really big in the 16th century, so it's a bit misleading to cite an example of the 17th century, whilst leaving out the 16th century entirely.

  • @varunprakash6207
    @varunprakash6207 5 лет назад

    Museum - Greek word - Muse collection of our ancient material preserve to showcase to the people 👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @DrN0rd
    @DrN0rd 10 лет назад +3

    I got that foster's house of imaginary friend's reference! :D

  • @ankittiwari1487
    @ankittiwari1487 4 месяца назад

    Is series mein next video daliye please
    Please refer musicology books museum books

  • @camilademussy3233
    @camilademussy3233 4 месяца назад

    Would be nice to also include, with a critical perspective, the history about how the collections were created, including the usually hidden colonial history.

  • @uriituw
    @uriituw 6 лет назад +1

    Why does there need to be a ‘price of entry’ discussion at the end?

  • @ssebuyungochris5735
    @ssebuyungochris5735 7 лет назад

    This is great to know

  • @abdelhaykabani8264
    @abdelhaykabani8264 3 года назад

    كمتعلم للغة الانكليزية عندي سؤال أتمنى أن تقع عليه عين المترجم و الذي هو كالآتي : أخي الفاضل أظن أن الترجمة لهذه الجملة: " temples built for the Muses, the goddesses of the arts and the sciences
    هي : معابد بنيت من أجل الآلهة اليونانية التي هي آلهة الفنون و العلوم" و قد استندت في ذلك على الثقافة اليونانية فهل هذه الترجمة صحيحة؟؟ لأن الترجمة في الفيديو تقول أن Musesمعناها مفكرون و ليس آلهة

  • @enigma1865
    @enigma1865 5 лет назад

    In my research, I noticed most Lincoln museums were closely related to the Dime Museum tradition.

  • @deleted-something
    @deleted-something Год назад

    museums are a part of society,

  • @ToxqJam
    @ToxqJam 9 лет назад +3

    @ 2:20 , speaking of western ignorance, where is the Black Sea on the map behind he tour guide?

  • @cattidesjar4229
    @cattidesjar4229 7 лет назад

    I love Addison Anderson's voice!

  • @alejandroojeda6604
    @alejandroojeda6604 7 лет назад +1

    did they mention any european museum beyond the seconds dedicated to the Louvre?

  • @bulbs_
    @bulbs_ 3 года назад

    In the uk museums (or at least most) are free to enter.

  • @dhruvsauran871
    @dhruvsauran871 3 года назад +1

    My mam is showing this to me , thanks for making me sad

  • @xSCHEF
    @xSCHEF 9 лет назад

    The Rijksmuseum, one of the worlds greatest museums and the home of Rembrandt and Vermeer and numerous other great artists, was opened in 1800, 40 years before 'the founder of museums' Burnum. America hur dur.

  • @JacktheRah
    @JacktheRah 8 лет назад

    You could have mention that in Germany after a old law all museums which aren't founded by a privat person are free to visit on sundays.

  • @bruh-bn3ni
    @bruh-bn3ni 2 года назад

    museums are the best

  • @pipercharms7374
    @pipercharms7374 3 года назад

    I feel like this is more of an American perspective? In the UK and I assume other countries Museums are free to enter? Also maybe its just my biased british learnings but I heard the first museum open to the public was Ashmolean Museum, yet theres no mention of that here,

  • @見外不怪
    @見外不怪 3 года назад +1

    What an amazing period! We discovered extraordinary secrets on the tour, and it's like time travel so that you could see how Chinese people were doing 100 years ago. @

  • @CoolGirl007
    @CoolGirl007 2 года назад

    I remembered the ticket charged for entering du louvre is quite expensive

  • @matildawolfram4687
    @matildawolfram4687 2 года назад +16

    Thanks to the author of the channel for a very fascinating tour! When visiting another city or country, every educated person must visit a museum. Visiting museums is very useful and fascinating. A love for the "eternal" and "beautiful" is awakened in a person, the beginnings of greatness and respect for history are inculcated. It is impossible to turn the excursion into something banal, ordinary and boring. The person should be a comprehensively developed person, cultured, educated, critically and analytically thinking, with knowledge of foreign languages. It is the knowledge of a foreign language that opens wide prospects for a person to realize his/her creative potential, career and financial growth. I would like to recommend the practical training course by Yuriy Ivantsiv "Polyglot Notes. Practical tips for learning foreign language", where you can find lots of useful information how to learn a foreign language quickly. Learn a foreign language and realize your creative potential on an international scale! The international community needs creative ideas!

  • @addamtan1791
    @addamtan1791 9 лет назад +2

    sid Meier's civilization V background soundtrack. did I heard it right?

  • @SharonLinfromTaiwan
    @SharonLinfromTaiwan 7 лет назад

    I love it!!!!

  • @espiinasnegras
    @espiinasnegras 9 лет назад

    In méxico almost all museums are free 1 day per week, others are free all the time. :)

  • @Skandar0007
    @Skandar0007 10 лет назад

    Yes, you pay for admission in the US but you get to see the best.

  • @crymea
    @crymea 8 лет назад

    museums of museums of museums of museums of museums.

  • @TalDreamcast
    @TalDreamcast 10 лет назад +5

    Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends... anyone?

  • @illanalevi6091
    @illanalevi6091 9 лет назад +2

    the gift shop of gift shops :)

  • @stevenn9072
    @stevenn9072 10 лет назад +1

    Is anyone else reminded of fosters home for imaginary friends intro?

  • @per_ringnes
    @per_ringnes 10 лет назад +1

    all museums should be free for everyone, and be funded by the government, by the tax payers money. just like schools, hospitals and libraries.

  • @Vexsus22
    @Vexsus22 8 лет назад +9

    "she must of had interesting parties." /wink
    ..... hrrmmmm

  • @Jordan-vr7ip
    @Jordan-vr7ip 6 лет назад +1

    A Museum is like humanity's resume'. If aliens ever visit us and want to know everything about us and Earth we take them to a Museum.

  • @MuseosAbiertos
    @MuseosAbiertos 7 лет назад

    hey, the link to TED lesson is broken :-(

  • @annissagultom6213
    @annissagultom6213 4 года назад +1

    Talk about western ignorance, why no mention of colonialism and it's role post Renaissance era in the "development" of museums? This video needs a sequel

  • @vennonetes4805
    @vennonetes4805 9 лет назад +1

    Wasn't the first museum open to the public the Musei Capitolini opened to the public in 1734 by Pope Clemems XII?

  • @wrcclim3602
    @wrcclim3602 8 лет назад +1

    4:56 Actually, it's the modern age.

  • @andhikasoehalim3170
    @andhikasoehalim3170 10 лет назад

    The front of the museum looked a bit like the Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends building.

  • @tanyushing2494
    @tanyushing2494 9 лет назад +3

    +1 culture

  • @XSpamDragonX
    @XSpamDragonX 9 лет назад +1

    Isn't the plural of museum "musea"?

  • @TurnipBoy666
    @TurnipBoy666 5 лет назад +1

    you mean the museum age factorial
    yeah, i did it again

  • @flavialuz6221
    @flavialuz6221 4 года назад

    pq o video é ingês e o titulo portugues?

  • @cadensacc
    @cadensacc 4 года назад +1

    People here from school!/ ms saad

  • @jjmaker6422
    @jjmaker6422 4 года назад

    Come in here~~~\/

  • @Michael-xm4ux
    @Michael-xm4ux 9 лет назад +2

    museum is the second choice when you failed at the bank

  • @dilanmachado4239
    @dilanmachado4239 5 лет назад +1

    US=>35000 museums
    Rest of the world= about 20500 museums
    This is weird

  • @mariamawda1075
    @mariamawda1075 6 лет назад

    the first museum was created in 530 B.C in what is now Iraq ✌✌

  • @BallotBoxer
    @BallotBoxer 10 лет назад +4

    I think all museums should strive to be objective as possible. Present the facts in a neutral space so the viewer can learn.
    I don't like biased museums like the Creation Museum in Petersburg, KY. If you haven't heard of it, the museum skews scientific discoveries to conform to biblical interpretations.

  • @ebrahimjamshid8328
    @ebrahimjamshid8328 7 лет назад

    Da fuck
    Is it only in the U.K. Where museums are free for all.

  • @nevercallmebyname
    @nevercallmebyname 7 лет назад

    the gift shop of gift shops doesnt sell gift shops does it? because that would be excessively dumb

  • @pontusedberg
    @pontusedberg 10 лет назад

    i want someone to build this, and have your voice as an audio tour, :3, also interesting what gitftshop of giftshop sells,

    • @jumbochamploon2591
      @jumbochamploon2591 10 лет назад

      probably gift shops.. but what do THOSE gift shops sell?

  • @coenvannoord4976
    @coenvannoord4976 9 лет назад

    The problem with museums is that they are to far apart
    i have to take a train to go to a museum o natural history wich realy bums me out

  • @pfgram292
    @pfgram292 10 лет назад

    Would the catholic monasteries be considered museums because of their vast recordings of literature?

    • @YdeB
      @YdeB 10 лет назад +5

      I believe a vast collection of literature is usually described with the word 'library'-

  • @n.d.324
    @n.d.324 5 лет назад +1

    The Louvre is actually free for people demanding asylum in France.

  • @UatuOmega
    @UatuOmega 10 лет назад +1

    So THAT'S what Addison looks like... ;)

  • @crosslight4175
    @crosslight4175 9 лет назад +41

    "After almost a millennium of western ignorance."
    Still subscribing to that whole ~Dark Ages~ myth, huh. The only ignorance on display is that of the scriptwriter.

    • @nicholasmcleod9019
      @nicholasmcleod9019 9 лет назад

      +Crosslight They obviously have never been to the vatican museums...

    • @LehySnek
      @LehySnek 9 лет назад +40

      +Crosslight The Middle Ages (6th to 13th) is a period of intellectual darkness as the extinguishing of Rome. I am italian, and I saw with my eyes what the Middle ages did to the romans. Temples, Colosseums, completely pillaged, either destroyed or to steal the bronze and iron inside the columns, statues big as titans taken down, Italy divided in many small countries fighting each other, disease, pestilence and famine, genocides in name of a god... It was a period of ignorance!
      The Italian Renaissance, il Rinascimento, was brilliant though, but they only said a millenium after the fall of rome which was 476 bc.
      The term ignorance is referred as intellectual ignorance anyways. So if you can point a world changing discovery that was made in that period of time, go ahead and do it, i don't see many.

    • @byance97
      @byance97 8 лет назад

      Lehy I invite you to check the "dark ages" video from this channel, as well, some of the most important philosophers of the time.

  • @MrQwerty2524
    @MrQwerty2524 10 лет назад +1

    So Museums belong in museums? *Mind blown*

  • @Pilum1000
    @Pilum1000 4 года назад

    I don't think that museums have anything to do with the circus.
    Barnum is he there or not Barnum. in fact and in essence

    • @miriga3927
      @miriga3927 4 года назад

      Museum are quite similar to a circus back then, though they had acts and such, people came for the novelty of an exotic animal of an unordinary person- museums were just scientific oddities not so mischievous different .

  • @soapymarshmallow
    @soapymarshmallow 7 лет назад +1

    clay labels.
    claybels

  • @hihowareyou4087
    @hihowareyou4087 9 лет назад +1

    I thought it was cause we researched archeology

  • @msdeora22
    @msdeora22 6 лет назад

    Sure most of the Museum history is from West. Because China, India and Japan etc didn't have any of those collections until White People civilized them.

  • @Montork
    @Montork 8 лет назад +1

    women invented museums.
    but then women invented sewing, textile arts, cooking,.. art.

    • @emackb1457
      @emackb1457 8 лет назад

      montork I don't think women invented art. That's a very narrow view of the world to assume just one gender invented art.

    • @Montork
      @Montork 8 лет назад

      ????? some of the earliest recorded art is hand spraying.. hand prints left by spraying paint around the hand, its a complex process involving a bowl of pigment and a hollow tube... anyway, the vast majority of the hand prints where from females... like 75% female. these are placed all over, even alongside cave paintings of horses and other animals.

    • @Montork
      @Montork 8 лет назад

      the thing i find most odd is your strange double standard. its narrow to assume just one gender invented something.........
      ....... and yet what has been done the majority of recorded history?
      but then the idea that only one gender did something becomes an issue only when females are getting credit for something?
      thats bullshit.

    • @emackb1457
      @emackb1457 8 лет назад

      montork I am a female, I am not being sexist against women, or not giving credit where it is due. I just don't think it is necessary to attach art to any one gender.

    • @Montork
      @Montork 8 лет назад

      it's not. but people are more then happy to do it.

  • @osGFXman
    @osGFXman 10 лет назад +1

    and now google make it digital! #google_art_project

  • @HaiLsKuNkY
    @HaiLsKuNkY 8 лет назад +4

    British museums are free

    • @nasser314
      @nasser314 8 лет назад +2

      If you are citzen of Britain or EU. When I came to visit Britain (im from Brasil) I had to pay to enter. Not complaining, I know that they need money to maintain the most beutifull artifacts that I saw but still, nothing is free

    • @emackb1457
      @emackb1457 8 лет назад

      HaiLsKuNkY yeah cuz your taxes pay for it. Funny how it feels like it's free, isn't it? Not that it's wrong it's just that nothing is ever free.

    • @HaiLsKuNkY
      @HaiLsKuNkY 8 лет назад

      its free you must have paid for the tour or something www.visitlondon.com/things-to-do/place/285709-british-museum#bDrSfz5EOaQomWHS.97

    • @HaiLsKuNkY
      @HaiLsKuNkY 8 лет назад

      its not state owned its a limited company. no taxes pay for it. ""The British Museum Company Limited ""

  • @Franciscavid
    @Franciscavid 10 лет назад +1

    and then the internet came

  • @gregoriarodriguez8159
    @gregoriarodriguez8159 7 лет назад

    sad bit true