Ranking Every DBD Primary Weapon

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 122

  • @unstablejumo8098
    @unstablejumo8098 2 года назад +51

    I think Oni could have been given a bump in creativity. That katana likely took many many hours to make by a master smith. The knives could have just been stamped so no problems there. Also, I disagree with your opinion and that means you are an objectively horrible person ... Am I doing this internet thing right? Another good vid. Looking forward to RE2 on the second channel.

  • @Blockzify
    @Blockzify 2 года назад +89

    Legion's hunting knife is actually a tactical knife. Ghostface's tactical knife is actually a hunting knife. 😂

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +16

      I know right!🤣 I had wanted to mention that in the video but I forgot 😭

    • @MillieDuu
      @MillieDuu 2 года назад +12

      I like to think that legion stole ghostface's knife lmao

    • @-_deploy_-
      @-_deploy_- 2 года назад +1

      @@MillieDuu oh he wouldn't like it

    • @theauditor3224
      @theauditor3224 Год назад

      Amazing

  • @eevee_lunice
    @eevee_lunice 2 года назад +55

    Fun fact, the Great Knife is actually a giant scissor blade, not actually a knife. That giant bolt in the hilt is where the blades connect.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +14

      Wait? What?! Mind blown 🤯

    • @Cinderdragmire666
      @Cinderdragmire666 2 года назад

      Wtf I always throught it was a knife mixed with a sword

    • @gabeyman9587
      @gabeyman9587 2 года назад +1

      p head is ryuko?

    • @fluffybum204
      @fluffybum204 Год назад

      Oh my god that's why I always thought it looked a bit odd as a knife

    • @Sin-Nombre04
      @Sin-Nombre04 Год назад +1

      I think its actually is a kitchen knife modificated by the mind of James in Silent Hill
      I think its also said in the description of the weapon

  • @papabear6611
    @papabear6611 2 года назад +43

    Spirit practicality should be 3. The blade is broken and dulled out, so any force to cut is entirely within her swing power.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +7

      I can understand this perspective, I wasn't thinking about it possibly being dull. The broken part could be explained away with "ghost powers" cause it's not like any part of that coming literally out of her is normal.

    • @Sin-Nombre04
      @Sin-Nombre04 Год назад

      I mean you can see in his mori that she doesn't cut through much skin and when she first attack you on the ground you can see how she strugles to get the katana out of the body because it wasen't a clean cut

  • @SulfuricAither
    @SulfuricAither Год назад +4

    You were not wrong with what you said about Amanda. In the original saw, the only time the hidden blade appears, it was actually John Cramer, the original jigsaw, who used the blade on Detective Tapp. Meanwhile, Amanda never used any kind of blade when she was the pig.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      Thanks for confirming! I have yet to see any of the Saw movies so I have to rely on viewers like you to fill in my ignorance 😁

  • @crimso_nn
    @crimso_nn Год назад +3

    No way you put Trapper's regular ass cleaver in the same tier as Trickster, Artist, Slinger, Amanda, Wraith and many more killers that had so much cooler weapons

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      LOL I honestly can't remember where I put things, but the rating scale I made up for myself at the beginning probably skewed a few things poorly. If I was just going to rate them holistically, some rankings would have been different

  • @basedqacist7526
    @basedqacist7526 Год назад +2

    Pyramid heads great knife is actually the other half of a large pair of scissors. In sh2, James can attain the other half of the scissors, expressing how pyramid head serves as the other half of James psyche, his desire for punishment.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      I had heard this fact but no the explanation. Thank you! That somehow makes his weapon even more terrifying 😱😅

    • @basedqacist7526
      @basedqacist7526 Год назад

      @@theARoberts and dbd lore makes it confusing as it insinuates this pyramid head is actually Cheryl’s “pyramid head”. As in it’s her desire for punishment and penance that kinda manifests ph in the entities realm. Oh yeah in sh pyramid head manifests differently for different people and their idea of an executioner 🤷🏽‍♂️

  • @S0L3SURV1V0R
    @S0L3SURV1V0R 2 года назад +8

    I think the reason Demo’s claws feel like they would do more damage is A. The size of its arms and body are much larger than Hag’s and B. Demo has two of them meaning it can attack from either direction whereas Hag is a lot more limited in her options

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +1

      That's a very good point. I hadn't connected that he legit has 2 while she has 1. Thanks for pointing that out!

    • @shaquilloatmeal7546
      @shaquilloatmeal7546 2 года назад +3

      Not to mention demo uses his entire body and does a full vertical to down swing when he hits survs

  • @zyphayt
    @zyphayt 2 года назад +8

    Great video man. Have to say I agree with all of ur placements. Tho I think Plague's is more creative thus deserving an A, I have to agree that it doesn't have much practicality. But yh I rlly like the way u structured this tier list. Giving them a score out of five for each category and then ranking em accordingly is kinda genius ngl. U won't be the first to this idea, but ur the first I've seen do it. So if I ever take this approach, I will be sure to credit u aha 👍

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +2

      Hey mate! I appreciate the feedback and glad you'd agree with most of the placements 😄Yeah, it hurt to put Plague as low as I did, I just felt the practicality wasn't there. That said, it is one of the coolest weapons to look at from the first person perspective, except for the fact it takes up 1/4 of the screen 😂Thanks for watching friend!

    • @zyphayt
      @zyphayt 2 года назад

      @@theARoberts fully agree ahah. no problem mate! 👊

  • @Typically_asleep
    @Typically_asleep Год назад +2

    Jigsaw fan here Amanda was in fact….. NOT the original user of the hidden blade

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      I actually did know that in my very limited Saw movie knowledge 😅

    • @Typically_asleep
      @Typically_asleep Год назад

      @@theARoberts I’m proud of u!

  • @PeavilTheEel
    @PeavilTheEel 2 года назад +2

    John Kramer uses a hidden blade in Saw 1, slitting Tapps throat.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      I actually did not know this until people have been pointing it out in the comments. Probably would bump it up a tier or two for me then. Thanks!

  • @mantb207
    @mantb207 2 года назад +2

    regular knife: 5 points practicality
    giant ass knife: 2 points practicality
    now thats what i call math

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      Just because it's bigger doesn't mean it's practical. I'd much rather take a katana into a fight than a broadsword.

    • @mantb207
      @mantb207 2 года назад

      @@theARoberts yeah but im pretty sure in reality it would cut you in half so idk man

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      ​@@mantb207 Oh I have no doubt Pyramid Head could cut me in half with that thing, just because it's not as practical doesn't mean it wouldn't be lethal in his hands. Pretty sure he doesn't even need the great knife!

  • @flevami
    @flevami 2 года назад +4

    I feel like the Twins weapons deserves a higher score. I would imagine getting hit with that certainly breaks your skull. Especially with the nail insides as well. Depending on the angle it is used

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +1

      Oh no doubt it would be lethal, it just seemed a little less practical to me overall, but certainly effective still. (I honestly can't remember what score I gave it when I shot this 😅)

  • @isabellamolina107
    @isabellamolina107 Год назад +5

    Personally I absolutely love blights weapon now it isnt creative in the sense that i built it and added fun things to it but like cmon when do you see a horror villain with a cane??? Also i think it fits his character perfectly it works well with the time period he was from and when the blight started to affect him it makes sense for him to have to use a cane so yeah JUSTICE FOR BLIGHT😭

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +2

      It really does match him well, I can appreciate that

  • @christophermartin1315
    @christophermartin1315 Год назад +1

    The weapon was used by Amanda. She was one of several people who used the pig costume and weapon.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      Thanks for that info! I still haven't watched any of the Saw movies so I'm dependent upon y'all.

  • @Truehexptsd
    @Truehexptsd Год назад +1

    I could be wrong but I do believe John used it in one of the films

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      I'm assuming you're referring to Pig? I believe you are correct.

  • @MildlydepressedLucario
    @MildlydepressedLucario 2 года назад +2

    For the artist I would give it a 2 in practicality. It's a sharp pointy blade but it breaks and deforms upon impact and has to reform with each hit. That would suck as a weapon. Plus it's made out of ink, unique but very impractical.
    Same could go for spirit having to summon/de-summon her katana but she seems to assemble and disassemble it fast. So it's not so much a problem because she's quick with it but it's a hit or miss.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      I'd say that's a fair assessment of both. The otherworldliness of some of these weapons makes it interesting to think through. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

  • @AverageSlav
    @AverageSlav 2 года назад +4

    You could probably bump clowns creativity just a bit. Yes it is a knife but it’s heavily customized to fit his lore. From the bird feather blade to the let’s say “unique” grip
    I also think there should have been some weapon scaling, pigs and myers knives won’t do the same levels of damage to the victim and both would dwarf in comparison to pyramid head
    As much as I hate to we could knock nemesis lore slot down a peg, he didn’t only use his fists if anything he used other weapons just as much.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      These are some fair critiques, I appreciate you sharing them👍Something to keep in mind if I ever do an update to this one

  • @1UPReaper
    @1UPReaper 2 года назад +2

    the top part of the blight's Bonebuster is made of mettle

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      That's fair. Still seems like one of the least useful weapons in the game to me, but then again, I've never been hit by a pointy metal cane so I'm prepared to be wrong 😅

  • @Afterasilence
    @Afterasilence 2 года назад +1

    I like Ghostface’s weapon so much because it’s such a specific and character fitting knife.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      That's true, it fits him very well.

  • @Deathknight6833
    @Deathknight6833 2 года назад

    TRUE FUN FACT OVERLORD:The survivor hitbox is a cylinder and with the survivor vaulting it takes exactly 0.5 seconds to get to the other side but while the survivor is vaulting the hitbox stays on the opposite side of the pallet or window then in the direction of them vaulting so when they do actually land on the other side of the vault the hitbox basically teleports to the other side and this also explains why some laggy killers get hits from the other side of the pallet when the survivor vaults and if the survivor is laggy you will get hit from ridiculous spots | off the record, breakdown, resurgence and renewal will apply if you kobe | The lingering aura of Awakened Awareness is still there, it's just coded to 0 seconds, so if you bring lethal pursuer with this you can bring back the original effect to 2 seconds of extra Aura | Doctors max static blast range is 40 meters by default but you can increase it with terror radius perks | While Demanifested as the Ònryó you also lose collision | while Myers is in tier 1 you have a 5% vault buff tier 2 you have a 10% vault buff and In tier 3 it's 15% | while you are stalking as either Myers or Ghost face you lose your collision and survivors can go right through you | Any type of insta down will be countered by off the record | Trickster only needs one blade to blind you with hex:third seal | Death slinger can shoot you then miss on purpose but you'll still be blinded by hex:third seal | your terror radius doesn't immediately disappear, your terror radius decreases by 10 meters per second.

  • @Tavemanic
    @Tavemanic Год назад +1

    I had a feeling deathslinger and Amanda would be really high up

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      I should have put Deathslinger higher TBH, a viewer pointed out that I ranked his based on his special attack, not his M1 attack which was the rule I set forth at the beginning. His bayonet is much more practical, which means I messed that up.

  • @sackjalter7001
    @sackjalter7001 Год назад

    The reason the dredges arm does damage it’s because the purple add on the tiling blade is what’s under all those hands and skin on the dredges arm

  • @SixballQ45
    @SixballQ45 2 года назад +1

    Freddy’s glove is rather practical.
    If you’re a killer, 4 lacerations are harder to repair than a single slash from your knives.
    The glove cause more damage per swing.
    The additional length of the blades and Freddy’s outstretched hand gives them more range than a closed first around a knife.
    Will have to respectfully disagree with the 2

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +1

      I respect your reasoning. My biggest question and probably what drove my ranking was whether or not the blades would be as secure via the glove when compared with holding a knife. That said, if they were strapped securely enough then I could be convinced. I would agree then in that case because as you pointed out you'd essentially have 4 knives and you wouldn't have to be concerned about dropping them.

    • @tophat_darkness
      @tophat_darkness Год назад

      @@theARoberts So fun fact - Freddy's glove in DBD, based on the 2010 Remake, the claws are welded onto a metal glove "skeleton" that has a clasp for the wrist that screws closed. That thing isn't coming off, and because he crafted it himself I'd assume it fits... like a glove. Forgive the pun, but I think practicality for his weapon is definitely high. Still a great video btw.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      @@tophat_darkness I appreciate that explanation. Definitely makes me think it'd be more practical than I gave it credit for. Thanks!

  • @Blockzify
    @Blockzify 2 года назад +1

    I don't think the blade is ever used in Saw (1-4 at least) because Jigsaw wanted the victims to be unharmed until their game.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      That would explain why it was hard for me to try to figure that out. Thanks!

    • @PeavilTheEel
      @PeavilTheEel 2 года назад +5

      John Kramer uses it on Tapp, slitting his throat in Saw 1.

    • @fluffybum204
      @fluffybum204 Год назад

      It was used once by John to escape from tapp
      That's the only time it was used

  • @ethancoolbro18gamer86
    @ethancoolbro18gamer86 2 года назад +1

    I'd put Freddy's glove in S tier because it's iconic and Freddy is my favorite horror movie villain.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +1

      Him being your favorite, I can definitely understand his weapon being S-tier for you.

    • @SixballQ45
      @SixballQ45 2 года назад +1

      also, for a killer, 4 blades that cause massive damage and hard-to-stitch wounds is very practical.
      Add also that the blade lengths give him a longer reach as his hands is extended with the additional blade length can hit further away than a closed fist with a knife.
      For a killer, his gloves are very practical, not deserving of a 2

  • @Cinderdragmire666
    @Cinderdragmire666 2 года назад +1

    I would say with pyramid head to him the great knife would be light and for others it would just completely crush them to death

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      I think you are probably spot on there. Pyramid Head already defies logic to begin with which is what makes him so creepy.

    • @Cinderdragmire666
      @Cinderdragmire666 2 года назад

      @@theARoberts true I still want to know how he can even see. Whenever I'm blinded while playing as him I always say to myself *how can that even be possible he doesn't have eyes and his helmet should protect him if he even has eyes*

  • @NoNameTheFirst
    @NoNameTheFirst 2 года назад +1

    Strongly disagree with Deathslinger's practicality rating. You said the weapon itself was silly complex, and while this might be true of the power, the video is on the killer's primary weapon. The way Deathslinger uses his primary weapon is as a bayonet. The bayonet was used for hundreds of years as a weapon in battles, and while not the most effective weapon in that arena, it'd do fine as a stabbing weapon against survivors who can't fight back. It seemed you were ranking his weapon on the harpoon feature, but that is his power not his primary weapon.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      So you are 100% correct, I totally missed breaking my own rule there😅Thank you for correcting me! Let's say maybe a 4 for practicality then? I still feel like some of the others would be more practical but you're right, the bayonet is a tried and true weapon.

  • @petersfilmstudios24
    @petersfilmstudios24 Год назад

    I personally would put the Redeemer as an S tier. It's very creative and assuming all the mechanisms are built right, it'd be pretty effective.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      So someone pointed out that the Redeemer is actually the special for Deathslinger, not his M1, which by my rules was what I was ranking. So I actually screwed up and should have been ranking his bayonet 😅

  • @rainb0wmatrix605
    @rainb0wmatrix605 Год назад +1

    I would have rated nemesis’s fists just a little higher on practicality my guy can punch through brick walls I’m sure he can break ribs in one punch the rest of the video I totally agree with

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      That's an entirely fair point. To be honest, sometimes I forget how I rate things and months later I look back and think "what was I thinking?"

    • @fluffybum204
      @fluffybum204 Год назад

      ​@@theARoberts I'm sure we have have been there at least once lol

  • @adoramay9410
    @adoramay9410 11 месяцев назад

    I feel like wraiths practicality should have been docked a point for having the point facing the wielder. A weapon that has a large chance of impaling you every time you swing it isn’t that practical.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  11 месяцев назад

      I did give it a 3/5, but its blade placement is really not all that much more precarious than a lot of real life bladed weapons.

  • @martinnoreallymartin3661
    @martinnoreallymartin3661 2 года назад

    The bayonet victims would like to argue with your deathslinger numbers

  • @Jvwoomy
    @Jvwoomy Год назад

    Deaths linger at least deserves a 3 for practically. Even if the whole gun didn’t even work, it’s still a bayonet and it will do damage.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      You're 100% right. Someone else pointed out that I screwed that up because the spear gun is not his M1 attack, it's the bayonet. I broke my own rule 😅

  • @JacobKing-to4hl
    @JacobKing-to4hl Год назад +1

    I see the clown using a hammer

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      I could see that, but it would require changing the whole collecting fingers thing

  • @tw1stedcut
    @tw1stedcut 2 года назад

    I think clown’s weapon should have been an actual butterfly knife, it would make sense with his performer backround

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      That's a great point! I hadn't even thought about the fact that it's not an actual butterfly knife. I'm surprised they haven't even given him a cosmetic one in the shop.

  • @PinguKrueger
    @PinguKrueger Год назад

    How is a cane as a weapon the most boring?

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      I dunno, I just don't find it all that interesting, but respect if you do

  • @ZoeyZoco
    @ZoeyZoco 2 года назад +1

    *LEIGON* does not deserve to be in *B* tier, like at all LOL and they have the most boring knife out of the bunch…

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      I respectfully disagree 😉 I think they have the best of the knife bunch

    • @danalynch118
      @danalynch118 Год назад

      @@theARoberts I like it bc even tho it’s not all that interesting of unique it’s still fits them as a character. It makes sense that they wouldn’t have some crazy weapon. They’re a bunch of teenagers going around killing people. They aren’t like supernatural or polished so it makes perfect sense

  • @noahmeier6825
    @noahmeier6825 2 года назад

    Yo you should do a killers you could beat up tier list

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      I feel like the answer to all of them would be no, could not beat them up 😅😂

    • @noahmeier6825
      @noahmeier6825 2 года назад

      @@theARoberts what about favourite survivors tier List based off just about everything

  • @Collosus
    @Collosus 2 года назад

    You telling me that a rifle that can catch your victim and impale someone is not a 5 for practicality? Also I think you did a great injustice to nemesis since if he punched you in real life, you would be dead instantly. But at the end of the day any weapon that is used by one of these killers is going to be deadly.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      LOL something tells me that's just silly complex and wouldn't work well IRL😂And that's fair about Nemesis, I suppose a guy who could punch through walls would be pretty devastating. Thanks for watching mate!

  • @Finzombie
    @Finzombie Год назад

    Nice job! NOW DO THE COSMETICS

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад

      It's a little outdated now, but ruclips.net/video/ybS4SeqzNOs/видео.html

  • @rodrigovianna7257
    @rodrigovianna7257 Год назад

    Deathslinger’s weapon not being an S is just sad, he has the coolest weapon in the whole game

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      I agree it's very cool. But by the criteria I set out at the beginning that unfortunately brought it down. That said, someone pointed out I screwed up on Deathslinger's because his M1 attack isn't his speargun, it's the bayonet on the end, so it's actually much more practical than I gave it credit for in the video. One day I may do an updated list and fix that.

  • @Typically_asleep
    @Typically_asleep Год назад

    But as a nemmy enjoyer he literally punches threw walls in re he deserve a tier :(

  • @ahbraveconscript997
    @ahbraveconscript997 2 года назад

    “i give it a B!”

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад +1

      LOL I did find myself saying that quite a bit, didn't I 😂

  • @nerdgasm5949
    @nerdgasm5949 Год назад

    freddy S teir for sure

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  Год назад +1

      If I hadn't made a point system at the start and just went off gut level reaction, I might have ranked it higher.

  • @camerons7901
    @camerons7901 Год назад

    Demodog didn’t get God tier. L opinion. Dislike. Unsubscribed. Can’t believe this heresy I’m baring witness to

  • @maniacalmurderer4123
    @maniacalmurderer4123 2 года назад +1

    What is with you and downplaying slinger? Man’s is one of the coolest lord killers in the game, not to mention the practicality of the weapon is probably the highest. It’s a speargun that reels survivors in when hit and seeing how it is in the field it obviously is efficient, not to mention the bayonet on the end to slash them when they are close.

    • @theARoberts
      @theARoberts  2 года назад

      So I really do love Deathslinger, I just don't agree that his spear gun is what I would call practical. That said, another viewer pointed out that I made a mistake and that his spear gun is technically his special attack, but his M1 attack is his bayonet, which I'd agree is entirely practical. So I'll totally own that I was wrong on this one 😅