Agreed. I love her voice now, but it sounds like she's damaging her voice :/ I hope she realizes this and stops taking lessons that make her use harmful techniques. Her voice then was beautiful, why did YG need to change it?
I don't even think she can even go this low anymore. If you listened to their Loser cover, she had trouble hitting the low notes.... If it was then, it would have been no problem
yall this is her real voice. her voice now is influenced by YGs vocal instructors. they taught her techniques to make her voice more unique- just like how YG wants it. in one radio interview rose admitted that they changed her voice and akmu said the same thing. i think her actual voice sounds way better than the one shes trained to use
Euna Lee if she can’t use her old technique she had in yg it would better when once her contract with yg ends she will quit the company .I know there might be no more blackpink but I don’t want her to damge her vocals.
I WANT ROSÉ TO SING LIKE THIS AGAIN😭 this mature voice suits her so much rn she has like a child voice and tbh I don't like that much😩🤷🏻♀️ but she still slays😻👌🏻
SME BP i am crying I think she would be never able to sing like this... She trained for 4 years that means they already damaged heir voice... In my opinion she had the best voice in kpop I am so sad yg please bring this rose back !!! :(((
YG WE WANT ROSÉ VOCAL BACK!!! I WANT TO HEAR THIS VOICE AGAIN THE HIGH NOTES HIGH PITCH GOOD TECHNIQUE GOOD CONTROL ON BLACKPINK'S COMEBACK!! *AGAIN WE WANT THIS VOICE BACK*
for me, she has the best voice among blackpink members....her voice stood out when i first listened to blackpink's songs, didn't know her name, searched for it, found out her name is Rose.
joseph bourne yup her vocal color is really unique. although jisoo and jennie's voices are powerful, hers is more on the soulful side, and i think that's the reason why she's the main vocalist.
joseph bourne omg I did the same thing although I did it when I first saw blackpink as if it's your last I liked jisoo first on her part but when I found rose bruh I died I was like she's my favoritee and found out her name was rose #rosealltheway
strawberriemilktea because Jisoo cannot hold for that note very long and she cannot reach high notes, I saw her singing clarity she struggled to reach the high notes even though it wasn’t high for me
Dang, she was my bias in the visuals aspect, and although in the dance practice lisa was the best she still rocks af. Now I can say she's my ultimate biad😍
well, after listening to this i'm starting to wonder what really happened to her voice color. it sounds so different now. :/ i think i kinda prefer this one a lot more than her current one.
Hamimah Anuar bcz the color in this vid doesn't suit blackpink's style so she made changes but I think if she was given a chance to sing alone maybe she will use this color
CAMILLE _SINCE Well she could've used this voice when they covered Loser, but you can definitely tell she was having troubles reaching the lower notes (the same with really really)
Because YG wants his vocals to use bad techniques to sound nasal and "unique" which basically just ruins their voices, best example would be Bom, Bom sounded A LOT better before debut and after debut her voice became sloppy and inconsistent and over time it got really damaged due to improper vocal teachings YG tries to push on his idols. Another example would be Junhoe from iKon, he basically just sounds like hes shouting not singing. So it would be best to quit vocal lessons while you still can like Suhyun from AKMU did
Yall need to stop saying "her voice sounded so much better back then". Yall do realize she can still sing like this she just uses a different technique. Look up the hidden vocals for ktl and you'll see that she can still sing like this
YG is forcing her to change her voice the Rose you hear now isnt her. YG is teaching her a different way to sing so she can have a "unique" voice This could damage her vocal cords cause your forcing yourself to change it I dont know man but this right here is already Unique YG is putting her in danger. This is Rose REAL singing voice They say shes the weakesr vocalist cause she cant do highnotes. She cant do highnotes becuase YG changed the way their suppose to teach her
i don't know but everytime i hear this song with rosè beautiful voice, reminds of my good old times. when everything is fine. her voice make crying oh my godness😭😭 my hearteu is my heartru is oh my god
i feel it is her. yg changed rose voice little bit for it to be more unique and appropriate to some of their songs. her voice sounds different from now because yg also changed her style of singing. just for me
I'm not even a BlackPink stan but I think we can all agree that YG choosing vocal colour over technique is awful. Poor Rosé, her voice is probably going to end up damaged in the future all because of YG. Her voice here is so natural and relaxed, it's so sad to see how they have changed that.
I went here after hearing blackpink Loser cover lol. Now I want to hear this pure vocals from rosé and not that country, indie twang vocal style that shes using right now. It seems that YG is probably forcing Rose to sing with a more unique vocal color than using her natural vocal techniques. I fear that it would hurt her vocals if she continue on doing that, another case of BOM.
This is rose!!????? OMG! I became a blink in 2020 and now i am seeing this in 2022. I can't believe this is rose's voice. She is really a queen who can slay in both deep and high pitched voice...
always loved without you and im a blink but how much did YG make her change her voice? how come she sounds here like a woman when she was 15 and now 5years later she sounds more like a child animation chara.?? rose ist still great but if you think of her as singer then its definetely BAD to forcefully change the VOICE its hurts her voice and even the mental aspect cant be forgotten. no matter which voice is real only she knows i hope she can be herself! BLINK YALL
her voice used to be so beautiful. her technique was amazing and her voice was actually supported, but YG just had to mess that up just so she could be "unique"😭😭😒
for all the people who keep saying her voice has changed, roses voice has not changed. she merely uses different techniques and she can clearly sing this song and perfect it as she did in the past. her voice and singing will forever be my favourite.
Who know Time spend so fast Can't imagine She is the most amazing singer now Can't wait for her solo I want her another collaboration with our iu Only true artists know other artist's talent
Throwback She collaborated with G dragon She went to masked singer She covered the song eyes closed by Halsey She had a acoustic stage two times with other idols She went to fantastic duo 2 ...even more She is super amazing My favourite idol rose the one and only and blackpink my one and only most favourite girl group which I have ever seen and watching uptil now
Roses voice was always my favorite because it thought it was so unique and pretty but now hearing this Im completely blown away. Her voice sounds so natural and beautiful. Seeing the difference worries me, having to always make your voice high like that could be straining her voice.
LISTEN THIS WITH EARPHONE. FOR ME HER VOICE IS NOT CHANGE LIKE Y'LL HAVE BEEN SAID. 1ST PART 0:09-0:43 IS THE VOICE SHE'S NOT YET SHOWN TO US ON BLACKPINK'S SONGS. 0:52 2ND PART IS HER VOICE THAT SHE ALWAYS DO ON EVERY BLACKPINK SONG. JUST CHECK THE DIFFERENCE.
Nella Andona i agree with you. i also noticed like what you said. i think she can sing in 2 different voices. and the first part is still hidden. i hope yg will let rose sing like in the first part.
For everyone who wants to hear her lower register or says she can't sing like this anymore, listen to her Livin la vida loca and If it is you on Masked Singer, also listen to "Rosé singing Without You" and listen to the last part, she still can sing it, she's just shy. Of course she can't sing it exactly like before since she was only 14(?) there.
It sounds like in BP she’s made to sing higher than her natural voice. I much prefer this tone. It has so much depth and richness making her stand out from the crowd.
This is what I call the Real Unique voice of her❤️ And if she was trained with that voice. i think she could also do more high notes without straining, she’ll be more stable and definitely SHE’LL BIAS WRECK ME MORE THAN EVER❤️😌 Hope that her voice would be like this again😢❤️
Her voice is already unique yg, there’s no need to make her sing in head voice all the time for more “uniqueness”.That can damage her voice in the future and you can hear the strain in her voice. This voice is so much better imo and I think that if she sang more like this, she would feel more comfortable 1 and 2 it would be so much better live because she would be more stable.
I can't stop listening to this and crying over how Yg is ruining her voice. They should stop before it's too late. I prefer her original voice over her "Fake one" and it gives me goosebumps. I'm so sad, that they don't accept it and that they have changed it so much
Isn't she amazing she can shift her voice effortlessly 😉😍❤️💕 she is a really good singer ❤️ great singer naturally can do something amazing with their voice, their own style make them unique than other artists, her voice is also really unique ❤️😍 she got complimented a couple times that no one artists sounds like rose unnie ❤️💕
I feel so sad... Her real voice is just amazing ! I dont understand why they wanted to change her voice because she is always unique with her natural voice ! 😭❤️❤️ I hope she will have this voice again.... 😭❤️❤️.
As a Blink, I want Rosé to show more of her vocals here besides hidden vocals and Hope Not’s 2nd verse. I’m up for both vocals pitches as long as Rosé doesn’t sing in her high voice too much.
![[RADIO STAR] 라디오스타 - Ji-soo, Rose, sung 'Love Yourself' 20170111](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cqzldD6pHcs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
her voice was so natural here... YG what are you even doing?
Agreed. I love her voice now, but it sounds like she's damaging her voice :/ I hope she realizes this and stops taking lessons that make her use harmful techniques. Her voice then was beautiful, why did YG need to change it?
I don't even think she can even go this low anymore. If you listened to their Loser cover, she had trouble hitting the low notes.... If it was then, it would have been no problem
Aria Goddess ikr :( Im worried for her voice too. WTF YG
i know her voice was so good back then like im not saying she sucks at singing now but i wish yg didnt interfere with his artists vocals
Agreed.
she was 15 in this song. can't believe it, her voice was this good at the age of 15 y/o
*14
StarGirl XO 14 international but 15 in korea
she was 16
Her voice was better than how it sounds now, honestly.
So young when I was her age I sang like a dying whale
yall this is her real voice. her voice now is influenced by YGs vocal instructors. they taught her techniques to make her voice more unique- just like how YG wants it. in one radio interview rose admitted that they changed her voice and akmu said the same thing. i think her actual voice sounds way better than the one shes trained to use
Euna Lee wait which radio show I want to know
Kookielisa BtsXblackpink Same.
Kookielisa BtsXblackpink me too lol
Euna Lee what radio show was it.?
Euna Lee if she can’t use her old technique she had in yg it would better when once her contract with yg ends she will quit the company .I know there might be no more blackpink but I don’t want her to damge her vocals.
I wish Rosé sung like this now :')
@@Mina-gm2ie oh sorry
@@Mina-gm2ie it's not a force it's a technique bcs bps songs are high pitched and the other 2 lead Vocalist have deeper voices already
@@yassi6478 not about deep or not, its just the technique
She will sound more powerful and can compare with jyp and sm vocals if she sang like that, but lose the "uniqueness"
Of the voice. Just in case ppl dk, that unique voice is made using nasal singing technique.
I WANT ROSÉ TO SING LIKE THIS AGAIN😭 this mature voice suits her so much rn she has like a child voice and tbh I don't like that much😩🤷🏻♀️ but she still slays😻👌🏻
i don't think so. It's different
SME BP i am crying I think she would be never able to sing like this... She trained for 4 years that means they already damaged heir voice... In my opinion she had the best voice in kpop I am so sad yg please bring this rose back !!! :(((
I feel like people would mix her up with Jennie with this voice a little!
Lisa and Lena SAAAME
this voice is more powerful than rightnow.
Her voice when she was younger sounds deeper and richer..
BLACKPINK'S THROWN actually there was a few times (now) I caught her singing in her real voice
And sexier
Yes! I agree
Ikrr agree
YG WE WANT ROSÉ VOCAL BACK!!! I WANT TO HEAR THIS VOICE AGAIN THE HIGH NOTES HIGH PITCH GOOD TECHNIQUE GOOD CONTROL ON BLACKPINK'S COMEBACK!! *AGAIN WE WANT THIS VOICE BACK*
I Stan YG groups and Entertainment SAME!!
SAME
Same...
Me too I feel really disappointed.
Blink let's make yg do it again...
for me, she has the best voice among blackpink members....her voice stood out when i first listened to blackpink's songs, didn't know her name, searched for it, found out her name is Rose.
joseph bourne yup her vocal color is really unique. although jisoo and jennie's voices are powerful, hers is more on the soulful side, and i think that's the reason why she's the main vocalist.
joseph bourne omg I did the same thing although I did it when I first saw blackpink as if it's your last I liked jisoo first on her part but when I found rose bruh I died I was like she's my favoritee and found out her name was rose #rosealltheway
joseph bourne she’s the main vocalist for a reason, Jisoo is so amazing but Rosé just always takes my breath away
strawberriemilktea because Jisoo cannot hold for that note very long and she cannot reach high notes, I saw her singing clarity she struggled to reach the high notes even though it wasn’t high for me
Dang, she was my bias in the visuals aspect, and although in the dance practice lisa was the best she still rocks af. Now I can say she's my ultimate biad😍
CP DC lucky for you, i'm still torn between those 3.rose lisa jennie
Jisoo is my bias .. Jennie is the wercker
camilla de castro sameeeeee
*Bias
@@zazafqa what about jisoo?
well, after listening to this i'm starting to wonder what really happened to her voice color. it sounds so different now. :/ i think i kinda prefer this one a lot more than her current one.
Hamimah Anuar bcz the color in this vid doesn't suit blackpink's style so she made changes but I think if she was given a chance to sing alone maybe she will use this color
Hamimah Anuar YG's vocal lessons changed her vocal color and technique
CAMILLE _SINCE Well she could've used this voice when they covered Loser, but you can definitely tell she was having troubles reaching the lower notes (the same with really really)
animegirl1424_rAnDoM She can reach those low notes in the Masked Singer-If it's you. Check it out
Because YG wants his vocals to use bad techniques to sound nasal and "unique" which basically just ruins their voices, best example would be Bom, Bom sounded A LOT better before debut and after debut her voice became sloppy and inconsistent and over time it got really damaged due to improper vocal teachings YG tries to push on his idols. Another example would be Junhoe from iKon, he basically just sounds like hes shouting not singing. So it would be best to quit vocal lessons while you still can like Suhyun from AKMU did
shes freaking 15 years old when they recorded this song and what now? im excited😄😄😄
She was actually 14, but yeah it's amazing.
Gdragon was 13 when he performed with YGfamily on stage. YG continuing the tradition =)
gherifaith she was 14 when the song released
wait how do yall know her age when this was recorded/released
Damn, these satzu feels if you know her birth date and the year the song was released haha
Omg her voice is so fucking beautiful!! 😍😍😍😍😍
Lol we both have the same pic profile wtf
Peep Lol the power of Lisa(?) 😁
Cielo Azul We all love Lisa
Peep
That's rigth. You said it perfectly 😊👍💖
oh wow we have the same username
her voice is beautiful
look like baddads but the way she talk its so adorable
Her natural voice is so gorgeous and it sounds so natural and her high notes are amazing. YG is seriously wasting this amazing opportunity
This girl is a STAR.
Now it's queen
found my bias already
Kmood
She sounds so different now 😧😭😦
ROSE has the most Unique beautiful, and gorgeous voice in all the kpop girls group. Rigth guys?
i agree so much
Felicity Tuah hmmm not really. There are many more idols with unique voices in other gg.
@@alicepark7545 yeah but hers is much more unique you can hear it even if 30 people are singing with her at the same volume.
killed the replay
Yall need to stop saying "her voice sounded so much better back then". Yall do realize she can still sing like this she just uses a different technique. Look up the hidden vocals for ktl and you'll see that she can still sing like this
YG is forcing her to change her voice the Rose you hear now isnt her.
YG is teaching her a different way to sing so she can have a "unique" voice
This could damage her vocal cords cause your forcing yourself to change it
I dont know man but this right here is already Unique YG is putting her in danger.
This is Rose REAL singing voice
They say shes the weakesr vocalist cause she cant do highnotes.
She cant do highnotes becuase YG changed the way their suppose to teach her
love ittt her voice is unique
Her voice is sooo low here woahh 😍❤️❤️
i don't know but everytime i hear this song with rosè beautiful voice, reminds of my good old times. when everything is fine. her voice make crying oh my godness😭😭 my hearteu is my heartru is oh my god
i feel it is her. yg changed rose voice little bit for it to be more unique and appropriate to some of their songs. her voice sounds different from now because yg also changed her style of singing.
just for me
Ronniell Mahinay her style of singing is indie
I already love her voice since I heard this song :") which eventually become one of my fav
Beautiful voice, beautiful face, beautiful personality. Oh Chaeyoung!!
park chaeyoung is her real name but i hope u dont mean chaeyoung twice
I want Rosé sing like this again. 😭
Okay respect Rosé.
She say " i found a new way to show my voice"
at first when i saw the teasers i thought she's the rapper because her vibe is like of a rapper.
SAME.
We blinks want this voice again
I'm not even a BlackPink stan but I think we can all agree that YG choosing vocal colour over technique is awful. Poor Rosé, her voice is probably going to end up damaged in the future all because of YG. Her voice here is so natural and relaxed, it's so sad to see how they have changed that.
I went here after hearing blackpink Loser cover lol.
Now I want to hear this pure vocals from rosé and not that country, indie twang vocal style that shes using right now.
It seems that YG is probably forcing Rose to sing with a more unique vocal color than using her natural vocal techniques.
I fear that it would hurt her vocals if she continue on doing that, another case of BOM.
Bruh, YG made her go through some Britney Spears level voice alteration to make her sound like she does now...
Holy moly she sang like an angel. I mean her voice is beautiful now too but back then i risk to say it was even more beautiful
I love her voice it's so soothing and beautiful. It's sounds so mature.
who the fuck disliked this ???
KOKO BAP haters
YG lol
KOKO BAP the fuck haters who deaf cant hear rose heaven voice !
who watched it upside down
guys....u'll soon hear her rapping side too.....just have patience to wait for square 3....
Tashi Dema 1 year later....
in 2030
Lmao it won't be with YG. They Are JUST going to end like 2ne1
This is rose!!?????
OMG! I became a blink in 2020 and now i am seeing this in 2022. I can't believe this is rose's voice.
She is really a queen who can slay in both deep and high pitched voice...
Since she became an idol she had been singing with this rage of her voice 0:52
YG should let her sing with her natural voice honestly
Yep, I noticed that after I tapped your time stamp and listened
always loved without you and im a blink but how much did YG make her change her voice? how come she sounds here like a woman when she was 15 and now 5years later she sounds more like a child animation chara.??
rose ist still great but if you think of her as singer then its definetely BAD to forcefully change the VOICE its hurts her voice and even the mental aspect cant be forgotten. no matter which voice is real only she knows i hope she can be herself!
BLINK YALL
She's my bias, and I hope she stops this :( I love her voice, so I wouldn't want her losing it because of the damaging techniques she's being teached
They're forcing her to stylized here voice
This voice is a diamond..yg failed to know the worth
Yesss!
I want this voice in future CB so baddddd
her voice used to be so beautiful. her technique was amazing and her voice was actually supported, but YG just had to mess that up just so she could be "unique"😭😭😒
Thats the tone we need in their next comeback
PS: ROSÉ CAN sing like this, just listen to her covers on sea of hope
she feels so relax and comfortable with this voice
Can someone wipe my tears....omg!!!!her voice is sooo beautiful
Her vocal her high note o my god rose you best vocalist in kpop
OMG her voice is killing meeee!😍
*With this voice, I actually get goosebumps. With the "Unique" voice I have no feeling to it*
I can't I am crying for help I can not breath she sings I can't find the words that is how good she sounds
unique & angelic 💕
for all the people who keep saying her voice has changed, roses voice has not changed. she merely uses different techniques and she can clearly sing this song and perfect it as she did in the past. her voice and singing will forever be my favourite.
Her vocals were way better here than now Stan a natural idol
I can’t get this song out of my head OMG
Who know
Time spend so fast
Can't imagine
She is the most amazing singer now
Can't wait for her solo
I want her another collaboration with our iu
Only true artists know other artist's talent
I can't wait to hear her on YGNGG's records!! *dies*
im so proud of them now
Throwback
She collaborated with G dragon
She went to masked singer
She covered the song eyes closed by Halsey
She had a acoustic stage two times with other idols
She went to fantastic duo 2
...even more
She is super amazing
My favourite idol rose the one and only and blackpink my one and only most favourite girl group which I have ever seen and watching uptil now
Miss Roseanne, no word can describe how much I admire you...
Roses voice was always my favorite because it thought it was so unique and pretty but now hearing this Im completely blown away. Her voice sounds so natural and beautiful. Seeing the difference worries me, having to always make your voice high like that could be straining her voice.
LISTEN THIS WITH EARPHONE. FOR ME HER VOICE IS NOT CHANGE LIKE Y'LL HAVE BEEN SAID. 1ST PART 0:09-0:43 IS THE VOICE SHE'S NOT YET SHOWN TO US ON BLACKPINK'S SONGS. 0:52 2ND PART IS HER VOICE THAT SHE ALWAYS DO ON EVERY BLACKPINK SONG. JUST CHECK THE DIFFERENCE.
Nella Andona i agree with you. i also noticed like what you said. i think she can sing in 2 different voices. and the first part is still hidden. i hope yg will let rose sing like in the first part.
I love blackpink and I love rose, but somehow i prefer her voice when she was younger
LoveStealsHeart I agree I love her voice but I feel like she forces her voice to be higher sometimes
its not she who forces it its YG
@Alex Black
It’s not forced, she’s simply singing in her higher voice.
im so excited for rosé. all mah girls are so talenteddd 💕
Rosé is so PERFECT......A very gorgeous goddess, a goddess with a legendary voice , and has a kind heart....Really love her ......
Wow! Rose has such a beautiful voice!!!! I heard she sang this song when she was only 15!?! Rose is my bias
SHE WAS 14 Y.O IN THIS SONG OMGGGGGGG
she was 16
Why does her have this voice when only 14 years old 😵
Such a mesmerizing voice
I LOVE ROSÉ
Her voice is so beautiful 😍💞
For everyone who wants to hear her lower register or says she can't sing like this anymore, listen to her Livin la vida loca and If it is you on Masked Singer, also listen to "Rosé singing Without You" and listen to the last part, she still can sing it, she's just shy. Of course she can't sing it exactly like before since she was only 14(?) there.
YG needs to change Rosè.. Her voice today and before is different.. it sound unnatural compared to thjs one
0:55 This is so Rosé xD
It sounds like in BP she’s made to sing higher than her natural voice. I much prefer this tone. It has so much depth and richness making her stand out from the crowd.
Amazing Voice!!!!! Love her>,
This is what I call the Real Unique voice of her❤️ And if she was trained with that voice. i think she could also do more high notes without straining, she’ll be more stable and definitely SHE’LL BIAS WRECK ME MORE THAN EVER❤️😌 Hope that her voice would be like this again😢❤️
Her voice is already unique yg, there’s no need to make her sing in head voice all the time for more “uniqueness”.That can damage her voice in the future and you can hear the strain in her voice. This voice is so much better imo and I think that if she sang more like this, she would feel more comfortable 1 and 2 it would be so much better live because she would be more stable.
This is so much beautiful
I can't stop watching this since her debut with the rest ..... Her Voice Is So Beautiful
I wish she sing like tha again 💔😭😭
Why I'm crying heard rosé natural voice😭🖤
Her voice is gold
I can't stop listening to this and crying over how Yg is ruining her voice. They should stop before it's too late. I prefer her original voice over her "Fake one" and it gives me goosebumps. I'm so sad, that they don't accept it and that they have changed it so much
her voice is so amazing
I luv ur voice Rosé so much,,,SARANGHE!!!
Omg roseeeee her voice is sooo awesome ah my heart I really love her
I really like this version of her voice😭 Its really beautiful for god sake😭 ILOVEYOUU ROSÈ❤❤❤
Bless you for this cut!!
our beautiful rosie my baby girl, can't wait to wait her beautiful songs in her solo album uwu
😍😭her voice is so beautiful...She is so beautiful...I'm crying ! !
Yg should give her vocal lines with high notes!
Yea
I'mma listen to this everyday until day of her comeback! 😍😍😍❤❤❤
She is so beautiful! 😭❤️
I understand using her baby voice, but what she used both of these????? This is absolutely amazing. I was shocked
Isn't she amazing she can shift her voice effortlessly 😉😍❤️💕 she is a really good singer ❤️ great singer naturally can do something amazing with their voice, their own style make them unique than other artists, her voice is also really unique ❤️😍 she got complimented a couple times that no one artists sounds like rose unnie ❤️💕
I feel so sad... Her real voice is just amazing ! I dont understand why they wanted to change her voice because she is always unique with her natural voice ! 😭❤️❤️ I hope she will have this voice again.... 😭❤️❤️.
I need this in loop!!!
I REALLY LOVE HER.. MY QUEEN ! 💙
This part is my fovorite part of all songs ❤
ahhhh her voice is perfect
As a Blink, I want Rosé to show more of her vocals here besides hidden vocals and Hope Not’s 2nd verse. I’m up for both vocals pitches as long as Rosé doesn’t sing in her high voice too much.
i love her voice here i wish she would sing like this again