Sanemi yasss, after having listened to this like hundred times I finally noticed that. Thank god!! It sounds the same as the pre debut song. Love her so much ❤️❤️
bro I just listened to it today and believe me, I'm lagging. Like literally lagging. I need time to digest her actual voice- LIKE WTH DOES YG NOT LET HER BLESS OUR EARS WITH HER DEEP VOICE-!???!!! WAEEE (T0T)
HeshSLVIP I mean he thanked and praised her a lot during the song release. He was like she has a really unique tone, she's young but have a really good voice and continuously thanked her
Why does she always seem so shy singing that song. It’s cute but I wanted to hear her sing it properly. Haha. Not hating, I actually love her. I’m just curious. :-)
I think the reason why she gets shy is because her technique before is different from her technique now. Rose got used to straining her voice so I think she didnt want to sing it because Yg changed her style of singing. Just to note she is a good singer but she was taught incorrectly
i hope yg stop trying to make her voice sounds like Park Bom,she has soooo good vocals,’Without You’ vocals is her real voice,and it need to be appreciated,just like Bom,her voice is pretty and unique
Txmilx ssi I WISH YOU WOULD ACTUALLY READ THE COMMENT BEFORE MAKING AN ANGRY REPLY Seriously Rosé sounded much more different than she did before, she used to have a nice deep singing voice, and now she's starting to sing more nasally every comeback, something that can damage her voice, EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO PARK BOM. They're not saying that BP 'copies' Bom but this is the same thing that happened to a previous YG artist, and it will probably continue to happen if someone doesn't put a stop to it, as YG apparently likes that nasally sound, aware that it's not proper technique...
actually i love 2ne1 and i love blackpink and i absolutely agree with you. Rose's real voice was in Without You. Now she is practising a lot and yg puts her more into Park Bom's vibe. The voice she has now..it really reminds me of Park Bom. And sometimes Rose seems like forcing her own self to sound like Park Bom. YG,please stop this. Park Bom is special on her own way. Same goes for Rose..Rose is special on her own way.. She used to have deep voice but now its like she tries hard to resemble Park Bom.. 😞
@Aneeka LIKE she owned the song. Few seconds of singing sometimes can bring some type of feeling to the listener so is it wrong for me to shate my opinion?😊
@Aneeka i guess you don't understand the whole thing here 😅 it's clearly a joke, that song obviously doesn't belong to jisoo bc she's not the one who recorded it in the first place. This whole "she owned the song" thingy means they sang it so well, even a tiny part of the song 😊
00:58 When she sang "gyeoulkuk"you will find out that actually her voice doesn't change,I watch another video of a voice coach comparing her voice before she debut and now,the voice coach said her voice didn't change, it's just she change the way how she sang to a more technique way,but she still can sing like before.I BET YG NEED SHE TO CHANGE HER VOICE WHEN WITH GROUP😭😭when you see her solo stage at the concert,her voice is just like before! I hope when she debut solo she can use both voices 💕💕it will be Good. Agree pls hit the like😂😂
It's 3 years later but I think she doesn't change her voice, I am a singer myself and when I sing Without you I just change my way of singing not really my voice. 😐🙃
@@Rosaa_dlo Yes, Rosé was untrained at the time and she was still finding her voice. I also tried to sing Without you, and normally I would just sing my lower register with more rounded tone to fit the verse
0:58 for y’all who are hating on chaeng’s current voice saying that it’s strained, it’s still exactly the same she just doesn’t sing in a low pitch anymore
She sounds sooooooo much different than before. U can literally hear that her voice used to be deeper and more powerful. She's refusing to sing cause she knows she sounds different and she's trying to hide it but come on we all know it. YG ruined her voice to be more "unique" and nasally it's annoying now. And plus she's straining so much when she sings which is gonna ruin her vocal cords in the long term. Yll can get mad at me for pointing out the obvious but kpop fans just need to learn how to take criticism. Not everyone's gonna agree with you people :) everyone has their own opinion and u gotta respect what they have to say :)
I think it's the truth because YG wants to make her voice become differently. Just like Park Bom in the past. They have just destroyed her powerful voice ,that's why some rumors are talking about this too. She is kinda try to hide it now T_T
Yes her voice sounds so different, i kinda feel it's annoying now just a bit but i still try to like it xD bc i like this group a lot, but i wish she tries another singing technique to sound better :(
listen to 'if it is you' and tell me her voice isn't the same and deep some of you rrly need to stop when you haven't even heard her do a proper ballad slow song or anything yes it's ok to worry but to say her voice is 'ruined' is too much
Rosé is just shy guys. Yes, she had better technique before, but even with her current technique, she will be able to sing it. Without You is one of my fave songs, and comparing that to BP's songs, Rosé can sing the song easily. And gmthey are just having fun, I am sure that if she performed this, she would slay! And plus, don't put all the blame to YG, yes he has a fault but not fully. Number one, YG is not the one who trains them. And number two, Rosé had a choice. Plus, blackpink just debuted, they have more time to improve and to grow as artists.
People only know judging without knowing what Rosé has been through all this time. Judging from vocal to body and call it as concern. You can have opinion, you can state it. But, sometimes you only need to keep silent when your opinion is just hurting others. Keep your noises on your own mind. Rosé is busy reaching her happy ending, while you are busy end other's happiness. I'm tired of all these internet vocal expert. 😑
Yeah rosé is a weak vocalist now because of YG Entertainment it’s all their fault. I’m pretty sure her hurting her vocals will make her more depressed than vocal experts stating the truth. Haters vs vocals experts are very different.
i dont understand if you dont like such comments why not just ignore them? also since when expressing opinions about someone else's singing ability is bad and what's with all this 'judging without rose has been through all this time'. do you know what she has been through? have you been there with her all this time? judging without knowing what? and also what is has to do with one's ability to sing or not. im sorry but i dont seem to grasp what are you trying to deliver. she may be through a lot, but if her singing isn't good that doesn't excuse it, or if she's an amazing singer that fact has nothing to do with how much she has been through. you either can sing or not its simple as that.
OK Rose's original singing voice is great and all but why is no one talking about jisoo at 0:09 this is the best she ever sounded YG we need to have a long talk
@@teasis8327 no sweetie jisoo has a naturally low tone compared to the other members so it's not really good for her to strain it by trying to reach a higher register. Jisoo has an amazing and unique voice but jisoo singing in her natural low tone and it doesn't damage her voice in the term
@@nessa.z5260 omg sorry i love jisoos voice i said ur blind cuz a lot of comments are talkin bout her voice and u said that no one is talkin bout it lmao sorry if i offended u
Anas Anisa Yg is trash They make Lisa rap more than Jennie they make Jennie sing more than jisoo they make rosè always sing in her high pitch tone they make jisoo the most least lines in every MV I can continue more but there is to many
Remember when YG make rose an anonymous member and only release her voice as a hint. That's the time i fell inlove to rose because of her voice and make her my first bias in the group! And love her more when YG reveal her face
Isn't she amazing she can shift her voice effortlessly 😉😍❤️💕 she is a really good singer ❤️ great singer naturally can do something amazing with their voice, their own style make them unique than other artists, her voice is also really unique ❤️😍 she got complimented a couple times that no one artists sounds like rose unnie ❤️💕 she can sang with different voices, she is so amazing. Her voice doesn't change she just using different technique in singing 😍🎶
The tone of every singers are a gift from God 👌 she has beautiful and unique tone it doesn't matter what's her technique because the tone of her voice is always be natural because that was her voice👌 whatever sounds comes out in her mouth it's her voice 👌 she has angelic voice 😍
She can sing it the same way actually she just doesnt remember the lyrics. if you listen to chaelisa audio ch+ youll know. and she's not being serious singing in vlive everytime regardless of the song. if you follow her youll notice it
Rose can still sing it but I think she is holding back bcoz its not that serious. Maybe if she performed it live she can sing it.. they are just having fun now.. One Rose will sing it with GD again
i feel like if we ask Rosé again she will sing it seriously. she seems shy to sing in these clips but right now she’s oozing with confidence and she isn’t shy anymore to sing!!! i’m going to spam her comment section when she does bored in the studio part 2 😭
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![ROSÉ(로제) - APT. (Band VER.) (With. 이영지) [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241129 방송](/img/1.gif)
Listen at the end when Rosé sang it again , it sounds perfect just like the song !! Her voice did not change but she uses different techniques .
Sanemi yasss, after having listened to this like hundred times I finally noticed that. Thank god!! It sounds the same as the pre debut song. Love her so much ❤️❤️
i legit thought i was the only one that heard her actually fully trying to sing at that part! it sounds so good
I really wish we can hear her original technique voice again
Sanemi i noticed that too! Her voice so beautiful and melodious😍
Her new technique is not healthy for her........... really she needs to stop or she will ruin her voice..
when you want her to sing it seriously throughout the entire video but she only sings it seriously at the very very end
jam jelly SO RELATABLE AF! I heard her sing it when it was already in the last part if the video ☹️ I WANT TO HEAR HE SING IT SO BADLY! 😭😭😭
mangoes 4Chae. this is me
Ikr. I want her to sing seriously😭 ugh maybe its not yet time
mangoes for Chaeng ikr
@@rivaille4026 its prolly because she cant do it anymore.
Without You was the reason why I was excited for BlackPink's debut. Just sad that I can't hear how wonderful that voice from before in their songs.
Ikr
Mine was Jennie when she sang “Black” with GD, I really loved her voice from there.
bro I just listened to it today and believe me, I'm lagging. Like literally lagging. I need time to digest her actual voice- LIKE WTH DOES YG NOT LET HER BLESS OUR EARS WITH HER DEEP VOICE-!???!!! WAEEE (T0T)
@@anshikajana7555 same I just found this song now its on repeat
I hope GD will sing with her Live on his World Tour!
HeshSLVIP GD thanked her during his concert so I really really hope that she would come as a guest and sing it with him
He did? When. As Far as I know He didn't sing Without You in any MOTTE Tour hold so far.
HeshSLVIP I mean he thanked and praised her a lot during the song release. He was like she has a really unique tone, she's young but have a really good voice and continuously thanked her
HeshSLVIP I
Me too
0:09 why no one talk bout this,i like when jisoo sing with her singing voice
Lol it's simply Because it is rosé's video
YES TBH
Me too
@@ifyouknowyouknow6754 ikrr🤦
Jisoo is so soft to chaeng 😄
Are you alive
0:57 pay attention to that part.
Also your very welcome
I think her young voice slightly different. After she grow older, ofcoz sometimes voices can change
Yes of course voice will change a bit
no, puberty stops at the age 14-15 for girls, she was around 16 when she sang with g dragon.
@@rajeshRajesh-sm3kl ^
Nah ❌
@@milkyuhnom5925 yes
Me at 00:09 OMG!! Is that really jisoo??😱😍😍
Me at 00:35 Okay......now that is really jisoo 😒😂😂
Me too
I wanna see her voice in that it sounds great
Leo Mario i
But her voice sounds good irl
Leo Mario z
Why does she always seem so shy singing that song. It’s cute but I wanted to hear her sing it properly. Haha.
Not hating, I actually love her. I’m just curious. :-)
Sonagi maybe because her voice changed
You could check her vlive. she sang it there
Sonagi yeah same
I think the reason why she gets shy is because her technique before is different from her technique now. Rose got used to straining her voice so I think she didnt want to sing it because Yg changed her style of singing. Just to note she is a good singer but she was taught incorrectly
Thirst V she's just shy it's not that deep
i hope yg stop trying to make her voice sounds like Park Bom,she has soooo good vocals,’Without You’ vocals is her real voice,and it need to be appreciated,just like Bom,her voice is pretty and unique
wtf calm down
They're not hating on BP wtf
Txmilx ssi I WISH YOU WOULD ACTUALLY READ THE COMMENT BEFORE MAKING AN ANGRY REPLY Seriously Rosé sounded much more different than she did before, she used to have a nice deep singing voice, and now she's starting to sing more nasally every comeback, something that can damage her voice, EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO PARK BOM. They're not saying that BP 'copies' Bom but this is the same thing that happened to a previous YG artist, and it will probably continue to happen if someone doesn't put a stop to it, as YG apparently likes that nasally sound, aware that it's not proper technique...
actually i love 2ne1 and i love blackpink and i absolutely agree with you.
Rose's real voice was in Without You.
Now she is practising a lot and yg puts her more into Park Bom's vibe.
The voice she has now..it really reminds me of Park Bom. And sometimes Rose seems like forcing her own self to sound like Park Bom.
YG,please stop this.
Park Bom is special on her own way. Same goes for Rose..Rose is special on her own way.. She used to have deep voice but now its like she tries hard to resemble Park Bom.. 😞
yeah i think her voice has changeeeddd a loooott, and i like her voice on without you
0:08 my fav part of jisoo's singing out of all her voices.. why does she sound soooo great here? like she owned the song!
@Aneeka LIKE she owned the song. Few seconds of singing sometimes can bring some type of feeling to the listener so is it wrong for me to shate my opinion?😊
Rosé sang the song with her natural deep voice but this one she sings in high pitch so it doesn’t fits well
@Aneeka i guess you don't understand the whole thing here 😅 it's clearly a joke, that song obviously doesn't belong to jisoo bc she's not the one who recorded it in the first place. This whole "she owned the song" thingy means they sang it so well, even a tiny part of the song 😊
00:58
When she sang "gyeoulkuk"you will find out that actually her voice doesn't change,I watch another video of a voice coach comparing her voice before she debut and now,the voice coach said her voice didn't change, it's just she change the way how she sang to a more technique way,but she still can sing like before.I BET YG NEED SHE TO CHANGE HER VOICE WHEN WITH GROUP😭😭when you see her solo stage at the concert,her voice is just like before! I hope when she debut solo she can use both voices 💕💕it will be Good.
Agree pls hit the like😂😂
It's 3 years later but I think she doesn't change her voice, I am a singer myself and when I sing Without you I just change my way of singing not really my voice. 😐🙃
@@Rosaa_dlo Yes, Rosé was untrained at the time and she was still finding her voice. I also tried to sing Without you, and normally I would just sing my lower register with more rounded tone to fit the verse
Rosé sang gone in mv with her deep voice ig?
0:35 JISOOO SO CUTE
0:58 for y’all who are hating on chaeng’s current voice saying that it’s strained, it’s still exactly the same she just doesn’t sing in a low pitch anymore
At 0:09 i want to hear more from Jisoo
0:36 that is the cutest thing i've ever heard in a week
0:58 OMG her natural voice is so beautiful,why YG whyyyyyy !!!!!!!!
She sounds sooooooo much different than before. U can literally hear that her voice used to be deeper and more powerful. She's refusing to sing cause she knows she sounds different and she's trying to hide it but come on we all know it. YG ruined her voice to be more "unique" and nasally it's annoying now. And plus she's straining so much when she sings which is gonna ruin her vocal cords in the long term. Yll can get mad at me for pointing out the obvious but kpop fans just need to learn how to take criticism. Not everyone's gonna agree with you people :) everyone has their own opinion and u gotta respect what they have to say :)
Totally agree. I bet she can't sing that song with her current voice
I think it's the truth because YG wants to make her voice become differently. Just like Park Bom in the past. They have just destroyed her powerful voice ,that's why some rumors are talking about this too. She is kinda try to hide it now T_T
Mae Mae i understand where you're coming from
Yes her voice sounds so different, i kinda feel it's annoying now just a bit but i still try to like it xD bc i like this group a lot, but i wish she tries another singing technique to sound better :(
listen to 'if it is you' and tell me her voice isn't the same and deep
some of you rrly need to stop when you haven't even heard her do a proper ballad slow song or anything yes it's ok to worry but to say her voice is 'ruined' is too much
I died when jisoo tried to sing it 😂 and I loved when Rose tries to hit the high notes with her aegyo voice 💖💖💖💖💖
0:09 WOAH JISOO SOUNDS SO GOOD
Rosé is just shy guys. Yes, she had better technique before, but even with her current technique, she will be able to sing it. Without You is one of my fave songs, and comparing that to BP's songs, Rosé can sing the song easily. And gmthey are just having fun, I am sure that if she performed this, she would slay! And plus, don't put all the blame to YG, yes he has a fault but not fully. Number one, YG is not the one who trains them. And number two, Rosé had a choice. Plus, blackpink just debuted, they have more time to improve and to grow as artists.
@Tina Tini wth is wrong with you lmao she can clearly sing and hit the notes. dont be dumb, you dont even know what youre talking about
People only know judging without knowing what Rosé has been through all this time.
Judging from vocal to body and call it as concern. You can have opinion, you can state it. But, sometimes you only need to keep silent when your opinion is just hurting others. Keep your noises on your own mind. Rosé is busy reaching her happy ending, while you are busy end other's happiness.
I'm tired of all these internet vocal expert. 😑
So true omg!!!
Yeah rosé is a weak vocalist now because of YG Entertainment it’s all their fault. I’m pretty sure her hurting her vocals will make her more depressed than vocal experts stating the truth. Haters vs vocals experts are very different.
I love u
There are no vocal experts saying she will hurt her voice. Even the vocal experts on RUclips
i dont understand if you dont like such comments why not just ignore them? also since when expressing opinions about someone else's singing ability is bad and what's with all this 'judging without rose has been through all this time'. do you know what she has been through? have you been there with her all this time? judging without knowing what? and also what is has to do with one's ability to sing or not. im sorry but i dont seem to grasp what are you trying to deliver. she may be through a lot, but if her singing isn't good that doesn't excuse it, or if she's an amazing singer that fact has nothing to do with how much she has been through. you either can sing or not its simple as that.
OK Rose's original singing voice is great and all but why is no one talking about jisoo at 0:09 this is the best she ever sounded YG we need to have a long talk
i think ur blind
@@teasis8327 no sweetie jisoo has a naturally low tone compared to the other members so it's not really good for her to strain it by trying to reach a higher register. Jisoo has an amazing and unique voice but jisoo singing in her natural low tone and it doesn't damage her voice in the term
@@teasis8327 listen to her yuki no hana cover were she sings in her natural low tone like she did here
@@nessa.z5260 omg sorry i love jisoos voice i said ur blind cuz a lot of comments are talkin bout her voice and u said that no one is talkin bout it lmao sorry if i offended u
@@teasis8327 oh no it's ok😂
00:09 Jisoo
00:35 ChiChi
💜💜💜
the last second when she actually sang it my heart fluttered because she sounded GOOD
Frrr
Can we talk about Jisoo at 0:10? Now I feel all of them had a way different voice predebut
Anas Anisa Yg is trash They make Lisa rap more than Jennie they make Jennie sing more than jisoo they make rosè always sing in her high pitch tone they make jisoo the most least lines in every MV I can continue more but there is to many
Jisoooooo soo sweeett♥♥
Jisoo K-POP so ccuutteee
At 0:39 that “HEY!” tho from jisoo was soooo cute
Rose voice is so beautiful and unique
Jisoo is cute
Her members: "kuuuguuuuuuu-uuuuuuu"😭
Rosé it's so cute❤
OMG JISOO at 00:09 😍😍😍😍😍 she blessed my ears
JISOO SO CUTE HEY
Jisoo so cute!😥😍
Remember when YG make rose an anonymous member and only release her voice as a hint. That's the time i fell inlove to rose because of her voice and make her my first bias in the group! And love her more when YG reveal her face
0:35 Jisoo looked so cute while singing it❤
Isn't she amazing she can shift her voice effortlessly 😉😍❤️💕 she is a really good singer ❤️ great singer naturally can do something amazing with their voice, their own style make them unique than other artists, her voice is also really unique ❤️😍 she got complimented a couple times that no one artists sounds like rose unnie ❤️💕 she can sang with different voices, she is so amazing. Her voice doesn't change she just using different technique in singing 😍🎶
jisoo 😂😂😂❤
Right at the end she sing properlyy
how can someone be so perfect
Her voice is so cute omg
0:09 omg very good 😍😍😍
Rosé ♡
I dont care , and I still love her voice.... 😍😍😍😍
Rose'🥺I love you so much❤
0:09 Jisoo had me SHOOK
Love you,Rosé😍
Seeing this after 7 years is so nostalgic 😭💗 want them back asap❤
Jisoo hahaha
On a side note Jisoo sounded really good
The tone of every singers are a gift from God 👌 she has beautiful and unique tone it doesn't matter what's her technique because the tone of her voice is always be natural because that was her voice👌 whatever sounds comes out in her mouth it's her voice 👌 she has angelic voice 😍
0:08-0:10 that 2 seconds is the best thing in this video.
I am waiting for the day that she is actually gonna sing it live it is gonna be LEGENDARY 😭❤️
I cant live without you rose i love you
Foodsé so awesome 👍
And jisoo also singing cutely
so cute 😊
She can sing it the same way actually she just doesnt remember the lyrics. if you listen to chaelisa audio ch+ youll know. and she's not being serious singing in vlive everytime regardless of the song. if you follow her youll notice it
I need a chaesoo collab asap....!!!!!😍
she actually sang it the way she does at the end almost at 0:59 💕
Oh My Chichoo
I love u rose
They all are so sweet 😘💞💕❤
Rosé is Queen😍
0:14 asli mukanya ngeselin bet, kek "nungguin ya" 😂
Golden vocal
My versatile queen, she can use different range ...best vocalist ❤🌹
Rose can still sing it but I think she is holding back bcoz its not that serious. Maybe if she performed it live she can sing it.. they are just having fun now.. One Rose will sing it with GD again
Jisoo so cute😂
0:35 jisoo's voice got me dead 💀
0:35 OMG Jisoo u so kyut! 😍💞💞
0:35 Jisoo solo ✨😭
i feel like if we ask Rosé again she will sing it seriously. she seems shy to sing in these clips but right now she’s oozing with confidence and she isn’t shy anymore to sing!!! i’m going to spam her comment section when she does bored in the studio part 2 😭
Roseee 😇😇😇😇
Y'all her current voice isn't "forced" or smth, a thing called puberty exists, in which females tend to have a higher pitch than before.
Now i know why IU want to collab with her.
that’s my fave song ❤
lol those comments saying she can’t sing it like before, watch til the end 😂
JICHU always doing aegyeo💜😫👌
0:35 JISOO DONT U DARE UR ATTACKING ME WITH UR CUTENESS AAAAAAAAAA
0:48 lisa's expression was priceless
The song is very good and unique I have fallen in love with the song😻👍👍
she was a young new trainee...she gave 200% effort to show what she's capable of. she's more relaxed since there's nothing more to prove.
0:35 Jisoo will always make my laugh with that
Rose is so cute when she says gyeolku(in the end)
I literally can't stop replying the last two seconds it was so beautiful wtfff
lol rip replay button. I just keep replaying the last part Haha
i really loved rosé old voice
Rosé is just sooo cute!! as well as Lisa Jisoo and Jennie they r all sooo cute
So cute 🥰
0:12 Jisoo's voice thoooo!
Rosé y Jisoo que lindas
Y Rosé apenada es muy linda ♥️😩
CUTE JISOO
To all the people saying Rosé is forcing her voice now Bruh NO its just a different technique
0:32 she is so cute
0:58 rosé really like to tease us and the pinks
0:36 cute voice 😅😂
The last second was blessed
0:11 Rose looking like a chipmunk aww so cute