UV resistent alternative to ABS? - Plastika Trček ASA filament REVIEW
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 янв 2018
- I put some Slovenian ASA filament through its paces. Let's take a look at print quality, static strength, impact strength and temperature resistance.
Test samples and methods: / filament-test-16238656
Take a look at the ASA filament: www.plastikatrc...
💚 Support me 💚
Patreon: / cnckitchen
Join as a RUclips member!
Original CNC Kitchen Threaded Inserts: geni.us/CNCKIn...
Merch: teespring.com/...
Buy an Original Prusa i3 printer: geni.us/CNCKPrusa
PayPal: www.paypal.me/...
Shop at Matterhackers(US): www.matterhacke...
Shop at 3DJake(EU): geni.us/zHvnB
🎙Check out my PODCAST with Tom Sanladerer
/ @themeltzone
⚙ My gear (Affiliate Links):
🎥 CAMERAS & LENSES
Panasonic GH5 - Professional 4k60 camera: geni.us/LMN0CmS
Panasonic GX80/GX85 - Great value system camera: geni.us/M2Sm
10-25mm f1.4 - Awesome Lense: geni.us/ZTBH
30mm f2.8 macro - Great Macro Lense: geni.us/vEwqD
12-35mm f2.6 - Great allround lense: geni.us/S9GOsr
14-140mm f3.5-5.6 - My go-to travel lense: geni.us/fSAyKo
25mm f1.4 - Nice prime for photoraphy: geni.us/mqWM
🎙AUDIO
Rode Video Mic Pro - Shotgun mic: geni.us/6JFRdJ
Rode Film Maker Kit - Wireless mic: geni.us/XMD2N
Rode NT-USB - Studio Mic: geni.us/YVONvy
🔴 LIVE STREAMING
Elgatoo Stream Deck: geni.us/ppIiAL
Elgatoo HDMI USB Capture Card: geni.us/imhD
Logitech C920 - Overhead camera: geni.us/ViVgB
🏆 Do you want to help me cover my running costs? Send me a dollar or two over PayPal, it helps me a lot!
www.paypal.me/...
🌼 Even watching the ads before my videos helps me a lot!
Follow me on Twitter: / cnc_kitchen
DISCLAIMER: NONE of these tests were performed with any officially calibrated test equipment. The values presented in this video are for information/entertainment only and will not be comparable to any official tests! 
Наука
I finally started my in-depth filament test series. I hope you like my approach. What would you like to see next? Polymaker PC-Max, Colorfabb XT-CF20 or Filamentive bioPC?
Colorfabb XT-CF20
this is next level stuff (Y) great job! love it.
i'd vote for PC-Max. i'm using Plastika Trček PETG now and it's wanderful but i can't compare because this is my first roll of PETG
Hey CNC can you do an in-depth review on either makerbot abs or pla
Pc is famous for being strong but difficult. Is that difficulty worth? Pleade answer this. And also i would love to know good matherials in the nylon space specially those of lower temp spectrum.
I've only worked with PC-ABS so far and it was similarly "hard" to handle as ABS. I'm probably going to work on one of the PCs next, just to know, how they perform and are handling during printing.
I LOVE that you use slow macro shots of the print quality! Almost no other youtuber do that as detailed as you. It really makes the quality it more realistic as you see more imperfections in the real world than on a youtube video :)
What a professional test! I really like the fact that you do all those different tests on real samples
I totally agree!!! this is a great resource, I hope you do more tests like this.
Wow! My new favorite filament reviw serie! No star rating bullshit just raw nombers and images. I realy like that. Physical properties are very important for me, more than estetic and you cover everything!
Mmmm nom nom nombers
I think I'm going to really love your filament reviews! Data for days!
I love how you test the various filament characteristics of 3D printed Parts. You are one of a few sources when it comes to 3D material testig. Keep up the good work. One suggestion I might add is, that you should also test the raw filament. So you can also determin how much strength is left in the 3d printed part compaired to the not printed filament
Thanks for the suggestion. I've already been thinking about this for a while, but didn't finish the holder yet.
wow nice to see a review of Slovenian product, I am also using Plaskika Trček filament, especially because I live 9 km away from him in Slovenia.
first I thought it is our Czech product, because of similar names and unusual Č letter :)
Wow! Your reviews are the best! I'm always looking for technical information and you're the best source. Thank you!
Wow, first time seeing our Slovenian filament on RUclips. Amazing.
Trček have one of the best filaments that i tried.
Best test setup i have seen. Better than sanlanderer. Please make a video with the details of you test gear. I would love to know how those machines are made.
Awesome video! So informative, I subbed that's how much I appreciate the work that went into everything! :)
this review is gold, i mean methods are so good.
I used their HTPRO fillament and it's a very interesting version of PLA.
ASA became my favorite filament !
Thanks for the great video! I suggest to make test of the PoliPropylene (PP) filament next time. This material is outstanding and I think it's the best material with its features and resistant to almost everything (chemicaly, temperatures, hydrolysis, etc.) I ever used. You have to remember that there are different types of PP (mostly filaments are PP/PE copolimers), the more PP in copolymer, the more rigit material, more PE in copolymer and the filament is rubber like material. In some cases it can withstand 120 degrees and more which is great.
There is something coming 😉 really enjoyed printing with PP so far.
Great job! I hope the folks who watch this production appreciate your effort and the quality results. I certainly do. I'm a first time watcher, and a instant subscriber.
Thank you for your great research on ASA. ☺️
Regarding your question about the next materials you could test i would reccomend the exotic filament pack from conrad renkforce. There you get samples from PP, PC, ABS, PETG, PVA and other types for a good price. But I'm not quite sure if the sample size of these packs is enough to print all your specimen at once
Thank you for such a detailed video on this new material. I have several rolls from Filamentum that I'm just getting started with as I finally got my heated bed up and running. Quite different from printing with PLA.
Please, make a test of ASA prints printed in enclosure, and without it (with and without draft shield).
THX in advance
Im using his ASA right now, I make beautiful prints with awesome feel but the layer athesion is not that good. Its a tricky material to set up but shows great results when done good. And the company is great, we used more than 50kg of their material. Looking forward for more. Awesome job
How do you like it compared to ABS though? I was hoping to see this video focused soley on ASA testing vs ABS but im guessing he didnt do that because then there probably wouldnt be any differences in values except for the UV properties.
@@ChristopherJones16 I definitely prefer it over abs. I now use asa+ that warps less and has better layer athesion.
@@ChristopherJones16 I actually use filaments from "plastika trcek", if your from europe it makes sense, they are great, i get 4-5kg spools.
Thanks for the video! Was just looking into buying asa last night!
Your prusa is vibrating a lot!!
I was using formfutura ASA (ApolloX) and biggest problem I have is layer adhesion. I have managed to print some really steep angles and complicated pieces but at the sacrifice of layer height and print speed. I have no cooling at all when I use my ASA, from what I have found the best way to use it just just to get it as hot as possible and print as slow as possible.
If I was to upgrade my filament heater/hotend on my S5 would that improve adhesion?
Your tests are great. Good work!
Thanks for sharing 😀👍 happy new year to you
Please try with sunlu ASA too, to have more comparison on materials. Thanks!
I would like to see a comparison of the ASA filament with 3DXTech ASA-Carbon Fiber, will the carbon fiber give extra strength between layers as well as in the linear direction?
id like to see a new video covering the glass and cf ASA's out there now
Awesome! I'm from Slovenia and was trying to figure out whether or not Plastika Trček (the č is like the tsch in Deutschland) was a good firm or not. They really have prices comparable to cheap Chinese filaments so I had my doubts.
The last filament stop you'll ever need.. pa raj se oglas osebno, boš dubu še kkšn "količinski popust" :P
We use his filaments for over a year now and have been pretty happy, we only had two problems and they fixed them right away with no extra charge so they really good. If your from Ljubljana you can stop by my office and I can give you a few at the end rolls of his materials.
I also like using AzureFilm filament. Very good.
great testing!
Stefan, you should really have more subscribers. Few channels go to your depth when analyzing a product or material.
I wonder if at some point someone makes a system that copies spider silk manufacturing, with hardening happening when polymer is exposed to air instead of cooling down.
Feels like there so much things to come we haven't even seen yet in this field.
But does it have the same chemical exposure, like do u need to put it in an enclosure?
Would love to see a video on Impact Tester! Great Idea.
You can find the files on Thingiverse: www.thingiverse.com/thing:3511769
What is the best nozzle and bed temperature for ASA filament?
You actually did pronounce that right :)😊
Well, not really. He pronounced it TrEH-check instead of Tr-check. Close enough though! I'm only bothering to correct him because I just ordered a spool from them, haha.
Please note benchy layer height, speed, temp and rotational shot please.... Thanks
Will be adding that for the next one!
I always have weak layer adhesion with asa.
beautiful review
I've used ASA from rigid.ink a couple of times but never experienced the smell you mentioned. Walking should be 0 in an enclosure.
Also mehr so ein Sommer-Filament..:D Dann müsste ein Fotozelt ja ausreichen?
Great review! :D
Thank you for sharing Stefan! Would you share a video about different ways of printing with ASA? After watching your videos, I have tried printing with Forma ApolloX ASA but have had terrible results. I've tried different temperatures, drying the materials and different layer heights but never seem to have a "tough" part. In general my parts are always brittle and have very poor layer adhesion even though they look good and don't appear to have an obvious warping or layer separation.
What I have been using. Ender 3V2 w/ Microswiss Hotend. No enclosure, using draft shield. Attempted temperatures from 235 to 255.
Thanks again Stefan
I'm about to test out ASA for the first time.. what was your fan settings, and print speed? People say you need to printer slow with it and have the fan off or on at like 5%
@@ChristopherJones16 I have 0% cooling + I used aluminum tape to cover hotend because the fan was sending air not only to the hotend but also to the piece. I don't know how to explain.
ruclips.net/video/wjSpVN19x7A/видео.html
Here it's more clear
Great review
Nice work!
I ❤️ ASA ;-)
Great video! Can you please provide links to the printed testing objects e.g. Thingiverse ID. Thx
Car intake adapter ?
ASA ABS or PETG
I've been using PETG so far, but want to change to more durable filament
ASA would be a better choice for non enclosed printer ?
Looked at your wideos but can't make my mind up
Hey how about adding chemical resistance tests ?
I think ASA and ABS like the same printing environment.. both can be printed in non-enclosed printer but as long as the surrounding environment is controlled. (no windows nearby, room is heated well, etc). I heard simply printing in an enclosed printer just makes life easier for getting better prints. I heard of some people using cardboard boxes to build an enclosure to print ASA/ABS and some using a plastic garbage bag.
I hope FFFworld will send you some Filament to test. They even have POM-Filament.
will you compare different ASA suppilers?
+Andreas Scheuerer Maybe in the future but there are currently many other interesting materials in the queue.
So, which is better/easier to use for a dash cam console (e.g. I don't like the tilt of the windscreen and want an adapter between the glass and the camera)? This (no annealing needed), or the Volcano PLA?
Depends on your printer. If you can print ABS/ASA then these are the cheaper solutions.
@@CNCKitchen Thank you.
Also ich habe genau "Null" Geruchsbelästigung beim Prusament ASA hmmm
Hallo, sind die Dämpfe beim Drucken mit ASA giftig?
Gesund sind sie nicht. Vll nicht ganz so übel wie ABS, aber trotzdem ungesund!
How hard ASA is print with Prusa i3 MK3 printer? Is it worth to try? I want print some dualcolor labels to outside like postbox and something else that last in winter condition at outside.
Similar to ABS. Not the most easy material to print with but doable. If you have an enclosure than even better.
@@CNCKitchen is it possible print dualcolor with MK3? Which one is better asa or abs for outside like freezing tems like - 30 degrees?
Yes, you can pause the print and change the filament or you can buy the multi material upgrade and do real multi color printing. ABS and ASA should both do equally well /bad in the cold.
Have you tried polypropylene filament?
Yes, check my filament tests.
Still waiting for Titan Aero CR 10 video?!?
ASA frozen/hot vs ABS frozen/hot test. Lets goooo.
Hi Stephan,
Your video are really interesting, Continue like this, you are doing an awesome job !
Can you give us a cryptocurrency wallet for donation ? :)