I think like most New Zealanders this song always feels like 'ours' and now forever dedicated to not just 1 but 30 of our lost souls, RIP Greg and the Pike River 29
When I was 17 The Joshua Tree was released and I played it every night. This is the song I loved the most, and will always remind me of the only girl I've ever loved. "I'll see you again when the stars fall from the sky, and the moon has turned red over One Tree Hill"
It's not that often that a band can bring back a decades-old song and play it with just as much passion (if not more) than the original version. U2 are one of few bands that can do that, and this gorgeous performance is proof. I am only 17 years old but The Joshua Tree touches me more than anything from my lifetime.
The greatest album of all time matthew, i still listen to it nearly every day on the way to work in london, so glad young fellas like you are listening to great tunes and legends like U2 instead of the shit whats about today, bands like U2 come along once in a lifetime.
Matthew, in '87, when this album came out, it completely changed my life. I was 16 at the time, and every song hit me in a way that's simply indescribable . Just curious...what do you think of the öld" U2 versus the new U2?
What beautiful bass playing. Sublime. As much as Bono and the Edge get accolades for their songwriting, Adam's bass playing drives so many of their songs with his melodic, soulful bass playing.
Forget the haters and just enjoy their music U2 still going strong after 40 years. They were rocking way before most of the haters were even born lol...
Haters!show them this and if they still don’t like it then they haven’t got a clue about music ignorant tosses!You don’t have to be big fans of U2 to appreciate how great this this 👌🏻
No band has ever put on a live show to match u2 . I wouldnt say bono is the best live singer but its just the way he sings u2 songs . More emotion and more story telling than any band ever
I've been a fan since the mid 80's...I think the first song I heard was either "Bad" or "New Years Day". Regardless, it was "Bad" that cemented the deal for me. I became obsessed with them for a long, long time.
I saw the Joshua tree tour in the spring of in San Diego CA what a treat that was...we were having a tail gate party and I met some kids from Mexico. At first I thought no big deal Mexico border is just a few Miles away but as u got to know the 3 they were from Mexico city thousands of miles away and gave themselves 30 days to get there because of corrupt police anyway i had a extra ticket and one of the three needed a ticket so I gave it to them. They were so grateful for thus but my thought was they earned they deserved the ticket. Then by coincidence the four tickets were in the same section so we enjoyed the show together ....great memories..peace Terry
I remember driving to this concert, the flags were at half mast all along the way and when this song played you could feel the energy and the collective emotion in the stadium, it's something I'll never forget
Good? SO FUCKING GOOD, HARD TO DISCRIBE, HOW GOOD. THX U2, AGAIN, FOR THE LAST 40 YEARS . FOR ALL THE JOY AND BEAUTYFULL MUSIC. GRAETEST BAND OF TWO CENTURY'S AVONDS, ALREADY.
When I saw the names of those miners on the screen I got goosebumps... awesome, potent song, definately one of my favourites. The New Zealand people will never forget them
germanylicious Same here, never heard them do it live before. One of my favourite songs from Joshua Tree. I wish Bono wasn't so preachy all the time though. I have my own memories about this song....
and for the comment about the quite crowd, I was there and yes the crowd was quite for this song as we all came to terms with the enormity of the loss of 29 lives that had occurred 5 days before this concert. It was one of the most moving tributes I have ever had the privilege of witnessing
This is my fave U2 song, very moving.I love the Edges vocals on here. It says alot about the mana of Greg and his impact upon U2. I think it's awsum that they accompanied his body back home and attended the tangi. He was clearly a very special person and I hope his whanau take comfort in the song and legacy he left. Also, my thoughts with loved ones of the miners. Kia kaha, Kia toa, Kia manawanui.
This was one of the most touching moments of that night......Paying respect to the Pike River 29 and Greg Carroll. Singing a song that, with a certain generation of Kiwi's means so much. (showing my age). Thankyou so much to U2 for coming to our little country and playing this special song for us. Cheers!
I was at this concert, was a beautiful thing to honor the miners killed in that terrible disaster. a very special song to New Zealanders in more ways than one.
I believe it was written for his personal assistant, Gregg Carroll, who was killed while riding Bono’s motorcycle back to Bono’s home on a rainy evening
I was there for one of those two nights, the tribute that U2 gave to our miners that were killed at Pike River Mine left not a dry face in the mosh pit, a great band and will always be in the hearts of New Zealanders. Thanks for sharing this Mekvox, the Mrs and I had a great night that night, lots of memories in this vid for us.
That's quite a comment, but I'd be hesitant to disagree with you. The song's placement on the Joshua Tree is perfect also...would it sound quite as sublime if it came after WTSHNN or WOWY? Nope...all of the songs on JT are right where they belong, IMO.
19 days later and this is still one of my favourite RUclips videos of the moment. When Bono sticks to his day job, he's the best frontman in the world. The Edge is ! And always will be, a Od to me :)) beautiful song, beautiful sentiments, beautiful video
Wow, I was there the night this was recorded, but to hear it again... wow. I have U22 as well, and every time I hear this some I think of the families of the West Coast (and other places) who lost loved ones in the days just before the concert. Thanks Bono, Edge, Larry and Adam. Those left behind, we are always thinking of you.
im 53 and grew up listening to U2 , i first heard them in 1983 and when i heard the Pride Album i was hooked on them , greetings from Sydney Australia , great memories in the 80's in Sydney going to St Andrews Cathedral School
Not only is this a brilliant song, this also shows the human class of this great band ; They don't forget there friends who passed too early . I think it's great they still remember Greg in this massive tour . Really a class act !! And of course Excellent audio (you should listen this with a good head set) from Mek, as always .
Wow such a privilege to listen to U2 and this awesome One Tree Hill in memory of Gregg and our West Coast miners U2 are precious we are blessed to have their music to listen to thank you from Aotearoa arohanui :-)
We turn away to face the cold, enduring chill As the day begs the night for mercy love The sun so bright it leaves no shadows Only scars carved into stone On the face of earth The moon is up and over One Tree Hill We see the sun go down in your eyes You run like river, on like a sea You run like a river runs to the sea And in the world a heart of darkness A fire zone Where poets speak their heart Then bleed for it Jara sang, his song a weapon In the hands of love You know his blood still cries From the ground It runs like a river runs to the sea It runs like a river to the sea I don't believe in painted roses Or bleeding hearts While bullets rape the night of the merciful I'll see you again When the stars fall from the sky And the moon has turned red Over One Tree…
they sound fantastic - I was in Chicago July '11 when they played it for the 1st time in North America in fifteen years, they have it much more together on this version, I love the audio, thanks so much for your time and effort... got the chills...
Written for Greg Carroll. A member of the crew, Greg was killed on a motorcycle in 1986 while doing a favor for Bono. One Tree Hill is in New Zealand. Greg was a native New Zealander--a member of the Maori tribe.
One day I will see this group I first got the Joshua tree cassette tape couldn't give it a break rode with me to work watched me get ready put me to bed at night man I loved it I was 20 than I am now never mind still young enough to enjoy.
Had the privilege of seeing this live at the Boston Garden back in September of 1987...the night night they lost the lighting rig and had only the house lights for half the show. was a great night. a great show.
Whenever I haven’t heard this song in a long time and it pops up on my feed and I listen to it… I’m reminded of just how much of a gem it is. The lack of respect this song gets is criminal. This may be controversial… But in my opinion, this is their best song from Joshua Tree
Joshua Tree is a master-piece album,it came in perfect era and times-mid 80's,they were full with hope for better future! Also,abum Ten from Pearl Jam is a musical pearl...
Shit what a unknown tour, it doesnt deserve this less attention. Maybe because the band wasn't that relevant anymore at the time. We have to be thankful for such a big event.
![U2 Bad (360° Live From Rome) [Multicam 1080p By Mek with U22's Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LEzIV1Lc-cQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![U2 Magnificent (360° Live From Zurich) [Multicam 720p By Mek with U22's Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3WRv5NuHpnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![U2 Until The End Of The World (360° Live From Mexico City) [Multicam 1080p By Mek with U22's Audio]](/img/1.gif)
This song is a hidden gem that never got any radio play. Joshua Tree is definitely in my top 5 albums and this live version is really exceptional.
The best song off the best album by the best band. ❤️
100%
I think like most New Zealanders this song always feels like 'ours' and now forever dedicated to not just 1 but 30 of our lost souls, RIP Greg and the Pike River 29
It is yours.
true!!!❤
LOVE never ends, THANKFULL !!
Paul milne from england here, god bless you all and greggs family. I hope to move my to new zealand one day i really do.
2024 still tear up🙏😢from PNW USA❤
One of the most underrated songs of U2
there are so many of them my friend, like jewels hidden in the sands
viksios true...
This song makes me cry, every fecking time.
Who underrated it? It wasn't me. Was it you?
not underrated here in New Zealand :).. but i take the point.. many countries didnt see it as a single. real shame that
When I was 17 The Joshua Tree was released and I played it every night. This is the song I loved the most, and will always remind me of the only girl I've ever loved. "I'll see you again when the stars fall from the sky, and the moon has turned red over One Tree Hill"
You cant leave us hanging like that. Where is she now ? Did you marry someone else. Did she ? Do you still see her around ?
@@antseanbheanbocht4993 we need to know!!
I was 18 in '87...Same here.
wow, i was 16 and did the same thing, non stop my fav song,
Me too. I got this album for my 18th bday back in the 80's
It's not that often that a band can bring back a decades-old song and play it with just as much passion (if not more) than the original version. U2 are one of few bands that can do that, and this gorgeous performance is proof. I am only 17 years old but The Joshua Tree touches me more than anything from my lifetime.
The greatest album of all time matthew, i still listen to it nearly every day on the way to work in london, so glad young fellas like you are listening to great tunes and legends like U2 instead of the shit whats about today, bands like U2 come along once in a lifetime.
I agree! It's actually because one of The Joshua Tree ' s song, With Or Without You, that I'm a uge U2 fan. I'm only 18.
Really the only somewhat similar to it in rock history is The white album from the Beatles. Maybe dark side of the Moon from pink Floyd.
You have great taste, Matthew. Cheers mate.
Matthew, in '87, when this album came out, it completely changed my life. I was 16 at the time, and every song hit me in a way that's simply indescribable . Just curious...what do you think of the öld" U2 versus the new U2?
What beautiful bass playing. Sublime. As much as Bono and the Edge get accolades for their songwriting, Adam's bass playing drives so many of their songs with his melodic, soulful bass playing.
@MrBorderRat iii8
100% he’s class
@@stellajuliagames4546 ?
I agree
so true. Adam confines the music into a tight, bass inspired, box. Larry drives that beat beautifully with a consistent and precision down beay
U2's music still makes me cry, which is why I get so sick of the haters and internet trolls-they've meant so much to me growing up.
Fuck the haters what matters is what makes you feel good
Forget the haters and just enjoy their music U2 still going strong after 40 years. They were rocking way before most of the haters were even born lol...
Haters!show them this and if they still don’t like it then they haven’t got a clue about music ignorant tosses!You don’t have to be big fans of U2 to appreciate how great this this 👌🏻
Me too me too
No band has ever put on a live show to match u2 . I wouldnt say bono is the best live singer but its just the way he sings u2 songs . More emotion and more story telling than any band ever
I've never known until today that U2 used this track for Chester Bennington's concert tribute.
Truly a heartwarming song. RIP Chester.
I never get tired of this one. Any version. I LOVE this song. One of the most beautiful songs ever to grace my ears.
Shanni S , this is THE SONG, not many will get it, but this is it.
NEVER...❤
Fucking brilliant track from still the worlds greatest rock band
A fan of 30 years 👍
great great band ..
I've been a fan since the mid 80's...I think the first song I heard was either "Bad" or "New Years Day". Regardless, it was "Bad" that cemented the deal for me. I became obsessed with them for a long, long time.
Great pop band
God U2's rhythm section is just superb driving this song-Adam and Larry on top form as usual..
Wow, so interesting!
You posting that on every video dude…
I saw the Joshua tree tour in the spring of in San Diego CA what a treat that was...we were having a tail gate party and I met some kids from Mexico. At first I thought no big deal Mexico border is just a few Miles away but as u got to know the 3 they were from Mexico city thousands of miles away and gave themselves 30 days to get there because of corrupt police anyway i had a extra ticket and one of the three needed a ticket so I gave it to them. They were so grateful for thus but my thought was they earned they deserved the ticket. Then by coincidence the four tickets were in the same section so we enjoyed the show together ....great memories..peace Terry
Been in a bad place in life lately so been listening to this about 3 times a day love it
Sorry to read this Bubba, hoping it has helped you thru these times.
Bubba- I hope you have found the peace that transcends understanding. The love of Jesus is just that! Praying for your heart
@@stshazmat thank you.”.
I remember driving to this concert, the flags were at half mast all along the way and when this song played you could feel the energy and the collective emotion in the stadium, it's something I'll never forget
Good?
SO FUCKING GOOD, HARD TO DISCRIBE, HOW GOOD.
THX U2, AGAIN, FOR THE LAST 40 YEARS .
FOR ALL THE JOY AND BEAUTYFULL MUSIC.
GRAETEST BAND OF TWO CENTURY'S AVONDS, ALREADY.
probably the best guitar solo of The Edge playing One Tree Hill...!!!!!
One of my favorite U2 song, such a magic song love U2❤
When I saw the names of those miners on the screen I got goosebumps... awesome, potent song, definately one of my favourites. The New Zealand people will never forget them
This band is the greatest in live performances, no one could beat them.
Lean Lute R.E.M. I thought was better, never heard anything better in my life..U2 right with them
I was there..one of the most beautiful concerts i have ever experienced
Me too. Ruined me for all future concerts.
Me too. Great.
I was there on the first night, you could hear a pin drop when those names went up on the screen, it was totally surreal
It doesn’t matter in what year U2 play it’s songs, it is always as if it was the first time ❤️
One of my favorite U2 Songs
germanylicious Same here, never heard them do it live before. One of my favourite songs from Joshua Tree. I wish Bono wasn't so preachy all the time though. I have my own memories about this song....
D GW Yeah but at least he preaches peace over religion. And People do listen to him more than some random politician.
germanylicious Have to agree with you there.
Hello think you
Big connection,s between ireland and new Zealand ☘️❤️🙏
Loved the fact that Bono was surprised as Edge continued that beautifully picked solo which raang through the list. 😟💔❤🖤🤎💜💙💚💛🧡🤙
One of the Best songs ever. Very emotional.
You are not forgotten Greg Carroll. You are not forgotten Pike River Mine miners.
You could never get fed up of listening to U2 , I love them all and all their music 🎶 x 🎶✌️❤️💖💖💖
One of my favourite songs of the Joshua Tree, performed perfectly by Bono and his mates.
three years since the Pike River tragedy, there could be no better song to dedicate to them. R.I.P men
and for the comment about the quite crowd, I was there and yes the crowd was quite for this song as we all came to terms with the enormity of the loss of 29 lives that had occurred 5 days before this concert. It was one of the most moving tributes I have ever had the privilege of witnessing
It was an amazing night, an amazing rendition... RIP Pike River men.
paula laugesen I was there too, it was one of the most moving experiences I can remember
Incredible song
One of my favorite U2-songs. Love it. Beautiful.
you are beautiful
Good morning chao
This is my fave U2 song, very moving.I love the Edges vocals on here. It says alot about the mana of Greg and his impact upon U2. I think it's awsum that they accompanied his body back home and attended the tangi. He was clearly a very special person and I hope his whanau take comfort in the song and legacy he left. Also, my thoughts with loved ones of the miners. Kia kaha, Kia toa, Kia manawanui.
Bono sounds great on this! Sends chills down my spine when he starts. Fantastic song! Love this band!
This was one of the most touching moments of that night......Paying respect to the Pike River 29 and Greg Carroll. Singing a song that, with a certain generation of Kiwi's means so much. (showing my age). Thankyou so much to U2 for coming to our little country and playing this special song for us. Cheers!
I was at this concert, was a beautiful thing to honor the miners killed in that terrible disaster. a very special song to New Zealanders in more ways than one.
I believe it was written for his personal assistant, Gregg Carroll, who was killed while riding Bono’s motorcycle back to Bono’s home on a rainy evening
Let's not forget about Larry Mullen Jr in all this excitement - he's the backbone of this fine Irish band...
I looked up the true story behind this song. Only then do you realize how beautiful the text is. I love U2! 🎸
I was there I really appreciated U2 for acknowledging the coal miners .
one of my very favourite U2 Songs of all time
Greg Carroll can be seen lots of times in the footage of U2 at Live Aid.
One Tree Hill is a beautiful song.
May the Gods save this band for eternity🙏🏻🙏🏻
I was there for one of those two nights, the tribute that U2 gave to our miners that were killed at Pike River Mine left not a dry face in the mosh pit, a great band and will always be in the hearts of New Zealanders. Thanks for sharing this Mekvox, the Mrs and I had a great night that night, lots of memories in this vid for us.
Their best song. No contest.
That's quite a comment, but I'd be hesitant to disagree with you. The song's placement on the Joshua Tree is perfect also...would it sound quite as sublime if it came after WTSHNN or WOWY? Nope...all of the songs on JT are right where they belong, IMO.
They usually play it every time they come to New Zealand. I have seen it live 6 times. Always Awesome!
Touching , mesmerizing, profoundly beautiful. Edge' s harmonies vastly under rated.
Damn! This song gets to me every time I listen to it. Precious lyrics.
the best version i ve ever heard ... she is in my playlist
19 days later and this is still one of my favourite RUclips videos of the moment. When Bono sticks to his day job, he's the best frontman in the world. The Edge is ! And always will be, a Od to me :)) beautiful song, beautiful sentiments, beautiful video
Wonderful performance by a great band...very classy tribute for us here in New Zealand going through a tough time in 2010
+Earl Chatterton I previously didn't know U22 was recorded all around the world, and finding that this was recorded in Auckland was a thrill.
Wow, I was there the night this was recorded, but to hear it again... wow. I have U22 as well, and every time I hear this some I think of the families of the West Coast (and other places) who lost loved ones in the days just before the concert. Thanks Bono, Edge, Larry and Adam. Those left behind, we are always thinking of you.
Such an immpecable performance"👌👌👌
Bonos vocal is masterpiece material*****
im 53 and grew up listening to U2 , i first heard them in 1983 and when i heard the Pride Album i was hooked on them , greetings from Sydney Australia , great memories in the 80's in Sydney going to St Andrews Cathedral School
Happy to say i was at this concert in Auckland!
RIL Greg Carol/Pike River Miners West Coast my all time favourite of U2s always reminds me of you Mattie Heybridge HARD cuzz
I could bet this was one of the best performances among the 360 tour. Simply stunning.
One of the best U2 songs ever!
Pretty sure this is the best version of this great song.
Definitely check the ‘Rattle And Hum’ live version, this is still performed brilliantly
Not only is this a brilliant song, this also shows the human class of this great band ; They don't forget there friends who passed too early . I think it's great they still remember Greg in this massive tour . Really a class act !! And of course Excellent audio (you should listen this with a good head set) from Mek, as always .
RIP to Greg Carroll and the Pike River Miners in Aotearoa ❤
what a voice
When the live version gives you chills. I am always grateful for U2 being better live.
great,great, this is the best band in the world.
thanks mekvox
Listening to this song at 1:30 AM but oh man it's so refreshing and I feel like it's morning.
The best song and best band
I've been at one tree hill in Auckland. Singing in my head this song. A moment to remember.....
Tears like a river to the SEA...
U2, 3, 4, 5 ,6...20 years listening their amazing music. Thanks.
Such a complete act
Wow such a privilege to listen to U2 and this awesome One Tree Hill in memory of Gregg and our West Coast miners U2 are precious we are blessed to have their music to listen to thank you from Aotearoa arohanui :-)
Thank you for a great tribute to a great Kiwi artist. It’s a beautiful song.
Kia Kaha!
We turn away to face the cold, enduring chill
As the day begs the night for mercy love
The sun so bright it leaves no shadows
Only scars carved into stone
On the face of earth
The moon is up and over One Tree Hill
We see the sun go down in your eyes
You run like river, on like a sea
You run like a river runs to the sea
And in the world a heart of darkness
A fire zone
Where poets speak their heart
Then bleed for it
Jara sang, his song a weapon
In the hands of love
You know his blood still cries
From the ground
It runs like a river runs to the sea
It runs like a river to the sea
I don't believe in painted roses
Or bleeding hearts
While bullets rape the night of the merciful
I'll see you again
When the stars fall from the sky
And the moon has turned red
Over One Tree…
great song....
I love this song it's my favourite.dont want to sound morbid but this is what I'm having played at my funeral.awesome just love the lyrics !
We will all have a funeral together after all it will be “the day that the stars fall from the sky”
thnks for the tribute U2! to Gregs family an the Brothers in the west coast mining tragedy, may you's rock to this track in heaven
as soon as he starts singing ,,i get chills...may the Gods keep you singing for eternity🤘🏻
thx kiwi heart you rock thank you xx
spectacular! wow. the audience and balloons... just wonderful stuff. gives me goosebumps!
From Nz...loves 🎸🎼🎹
they sound fantastic - I was in Chicago July '11 when they played it for the 1st time in North America in fifteen years, they have it much more together on this version, I love the audio, thanks so much for your time and effort... got the chills...
Just beautiful....Awesome concert.
No better album than the Joshua tree...I've been back and forth over all u2 s records and nothing beats it in fact no one has beat it imo
Letra e melodia perfeita! Como não se emocionar por alguém que se foi para sempre! Bono é de mais!
Written for Greg Carroll. A member of the crew, Greg was killed on a motorcycle in 1986 while doing a favor for Bono. One Tree Hill is in New Zealand. Greg was a native New Zealander--a member of the Maori tribe.
Didn't know that. Thanks👍
it was July 3, 1986. 30 years ago...
So long ago and Bono still thinks of Greg. Bono is stunning and unique...
Wonder how many times Bono's thought what if
u2freak1974 I still think of people I lost over 30 years ago am I stunning and unique? FFS
jude999 Maori
Yes...just fucking yes!
Edge sounds awesome too and i love his backing vocals, nice voice
One day I will see this group I first got the Joshua tree cassette tape couldn't give it a break rode with me to work watched me get ready put me to bed at night man I loved it I was 20 than I am now never mind still young enough to enjoy.
you are the man Mr. Bono!! and Co...
The way they performed it reminds me so much of their great 1987. Even Bono's voice sounds younger.
When that final "and when it's raining" outro kicks in, your heart just stops. The pain in his voice freezes time
At times we all need to know that someone cares someone REALLY cares May God Bless You All !!!
lest we forget our brothers& sisters .we will see you agian
Great voice
Had the privilege of seeing this live at the Boston Garden back in September of 1987...the night night they lost the lighting rig and had only the house lights for half the show.
was a great night. a great show.
Sh1t, that is so special honoring the miners of Pike River mine. U2 will always have a special place in the heart of Kiwis with that song.
That guitar riff reminds me of being on a tropical island-magnificent!!!!
I love this song song so much. I LOVE U2. ❤
beautiful.moving, real, heartfelt, I always loved this song even more so now, so much emotion
Whenever I haven’t heard this song in a long time and it pops up on my feed and I listen to it… I’m reminded of just how much of a gem it is. The lack of respect this song gets is criminal. This may be controversial… But in my opinion, this is their best song from Joshua Tree
Is there a better collection of songs than the Joshua Tree?
+Adam Martin Achtung Baby.
+Adam Martin rattle and hum
+Adam Martin I agree. The Joshua Tree and War are my favorite U2 albums.
+Adam Martin yes: War, and rattle n Hum,
Joshua Tree is a master-piece album,it came in perfect era and times-mid 80's,they were full with hope for better future!
Also,abum Ten from Pearl Jam is a musical pearl...
Chills on my back. Amen & RIP for the miners.
Cheers.
Shit what a unknown tour, it doesnt deserve this less attention. Maybe because the band wasn't that relevant anymore at the time. We have to be thankful for such a big event.