How Indian Education System is Failing Students - Jasmine Kaur (4K)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 978

  • @CKDNath
    @CKDNath 4 месяца назад +118

    Learning: Practices that Indian educators can borrow:
    1. Investing in last 5-10 minutes at end of class for Reflections on learning / debrief..- helps to reinforce learning, closure
    2. Conducting scheduled Teacher training - observe another teacher, be student-teacher for a period - empowering teachers and upgrading their skills/practices
    3. Connecting with students on a daily basis ... helps Teachers create non-threatening atmosphere, level field and thus a safe environment for - as against bossy teacher culture in India.
    4. Investing in immersion - make efforts to understand the human (student) - empathise with the student
    5. Seeking feedback from students to evaluate own session and improve future sessions
    6. I do, we do, you do,... let go,.. helps to transfer responsibility, of learning - as against theory/example/exercise in India
    7. Making connect - SEL - social emotional learning , ensure equity, mental health
    8. Providing for Field education - internship during vacations, community service, externships to gain experience along with studies, learn to interact with people, expand perceptions, bring in social responsibility, build humility in the person... (In India school students are not encouraged to work.)
    9. Encouraging students to have opinion, build perspectives.... have a worldview and give them confidence - that empowers students to make choices/decisions (In India having opinion is seen as being disrespectful)
    10. Not being strict/bossy with students as it can hurt them, discourage them, etc
    non-academic comparisons:
    11. Healthcare in India and America,
    12. Feminism, economic independence of female children,
    13. Strengths of Indian culture - eating home cooked food, sharing, hospitality,
    My views:
    The ten practices that we can borrow makes the video interview very useful, thanks to the guest and the Host.
    The interview/video must have been titled, 'Learning from the American education system'
    The Indian reality has been neglected or overlooked in the discussion - In India
    1. Disciplining in India must be seen as developing followership (basic leadership) and not regimentation / conditioning - Americans are habituated to refusal in the name of freedom,...
    2. more than 75% are in rural areas,
    3. the class sizes are large (strength > 60),
    4. teachers do not want to work there,
    5. Mid-day meals programme is in place since decades in states like TN
    6. Conversation on 'borrowing best practices' could have been done without commenting (bashing?) on Indian schools/teachers also!
    7. did not see relevance of discussion on healthcare, feminism, culture
    I write on Employability in www.quora.com
    www.quora.com/profile/CK-Dwarakanath

    • @tularam1989
      @tularam1989 4 месяца назад +1

      @@CKDNath best overview

    • @Ankitmaths-ln6gl
      @Ankitmaths-ln6gl 3 месяца назад +7

      @@CKDNath
      No sir, we don't need to borrow anything
      We Indian educators are not paid enough to teach well

    • @jyotichauhan1881
      @jyotichauhan1881 3 месяца назад +1

      😊😊😊

    • @Razdanvinodk
      @Razdanvinodk 3 месяца назад +1

      Brilliant 👌

    • @MR-ef8xd
      @MR-ef8xd 3 месяца назад

      ​@@Ankitmaths-ln6gldo u think an assistant professor salary is less, i dont think so 😂, still even in iits they assign to guest or jr faculty and go to sleep😂😂😂

  • @rishikhanna5272
    @rishikhanna5272 4 месяца назад +78

    Indian education system is just a business now , no focus to encourage kids . Education should be very affordable & high quality like abroad

    • @Pudding_zip
      @Pudding_zip 2 месяца назад +4

      They will only focus on things that makes them money. They do not care wether the students are satisfied or not

    • @nigamroy
      @nigamroy 27 дней назад

      Indian private teachers are less paid than other jobs.
      Govt teachers do election duty , Jan ganana duty more than teaching.
      A bank or railway employee gets more respect than high school teacher. It's because society thinks when a person do not get any job he go for teaching.
      Private tution meh mat bhejo khud padhao agar tumhare knowledge hai toh nahi toh school ke master ke upar chor doh.

  • @ai172
    @ai172 4 месяца назад +86

    I am a public school teacher in California and I 100% validate Jasmine's opinions and facts. When I heard her speak, I felt she was my soul sister :) I wish to meet her someday and exchange our experiences . Great podcast❤

    • @travelwithindian
      @travelwithindian 4 месяца назад

    • @lapsnatnussa7460
      @lapsnatnussa7460 4 месяца назад

      May i have ur email id

    • @geetikagupta16
      @geetikagupta16 4 месяца назад +1

      Hello ai172

    • @geetikagupta16
      @geetikagupta16 4 месяца назад +3

      This video is eye opener. I have few questions regarding education for special needs in US schools. It will be very helpful to me. Can I please connect with you anyway?

    • @yogeshkumar-dm1zr
      @yogeshkumar-dm1zr 4 месяца назад

      @AI172 Hi, which subject do you teach there? If you teach English over there then I want to learn the English language from you.
      If you are interested please ping me!!

  • @skillsbypreetimishra9235
    @skillsbypreetimishra9235 3 месяца назад +204

    Me bhi apna baby govt. Hospital me delivery kiya tha. Me Dr. Ko bol rahi thi baby hone wala hai. Pr fir bhi vo mujhe dilevery room se waps le ai ki abhi time hai. Me natak kr rahi hu. Or waiting room me ate hi with in a 10 min. Meri baby Bina kisi Dr ki help k ho gai. Mene khud touch kr k Dr. Ko awaj lgai ki baby ki head aagaya hai. Or jb tk Dr mere pas ai meri baby bed pr aachuki thi.. ye haal hai govt hospital ka .

    • @lifefiftyfifty
      @lifefiftyfifty 3 месяца назад +8

      My God

    • @indubala2792
      @indubala2792 3 месяца назад +9

      Omg ye haal hai govt hospital ka

    • @s.z3717
      @s.z3717 3 месяца назад +1

      😠

    • @arijitadhikari8074
      @arijitadhikari8074 3 месяца назад +9

      Dr ko sayad pvt clinic mai jana tha.

    • @geetparentingvlog7711
      @geetparentingvlog7711 3 месяца назад +13

      Har hospital me aisa ni h. Meri 2 betiyan government hospital ki h. Dono ke mera experience bahut hi jyada accha h. Mujhe dekh k mere padosi log b ab government hospital Jane Lage h

  • @kritirastogi5360
    @kritirastogi5360 4 месяца назад +29

    Aap nai apne interview mai emotions, humanity, mental health, confidence, empowerment, child physiology ki baat ki... literally...mai shocked hu...y sb baate, kitne km ho gai hai...aap ne hme yaad dilya ki yhi hmera grass route hai..aur y hmery zindgi hai..
    Thankyou for remind me

    • @Parikshitvlog776
      @Parikshitvlog776 3 месяца назад

      That's not mean ki koi v ek student k future se khilwar kare.

  • @abhimanyusingh5865
    @abhimanyusingh5865 4 месяца назад +50

    Great discussion on the differences between the USA and India’s education systems. While the USA offers innovative teaching methods and critical thinking opportunities, it’s clear that India’s system needs significant improvements in terms of accessibility, curriculum modernization, and skill-based learning. It’s crucial to focus on education reform in India to better prepare students for the global stage.

    • @sumiptasamal4929
      @sumiptasamal4929 3 месяца назад +2

      Hum log unke jesa dikhna to chahte hain par ban na nehin chahte... It's so true

    • @sumiptasamal4929
      @sumiptasamal4929 3 месяца назад +1

      India me ham log bas khokle adarson ke sath mera Bharat Mahan keh dete hain par har hindustani janta hai ki uska Bharat andar se kitna Mahan hai...

    • @Trentz2
      @Trentz2 3 месяца назад

      Have you or your child been to US? How are you so sure about critical thinking. It’s all fluff and no substance here. If you or your child actually goes to school here day to day you will understand. To explain in easy way of how America peddles it’s education is they title it “probiotic yogurt risotto, tempered with seasonal garden fresh vegetables “, in reality it’s just curd rice with tadka of vegetables. So no content inside, only fancy name outside. Indian education while not ideal, provides better exposure. That’s why the successful Indians are who studied in India and then came here.
      Of course at masters level the story is totally different.

  • @shaziayahiya4628
    @shaziayahiya4628 4 месяца назад +44

    It's such an intelligent and innovative podcast.
    I really wish we hv this education system like America.
    In 8 years from Substitute teacher to Director.....is such an amazing growth.
    I student should feel safe in the class is such a deep comment.

  • @DeepakKumar-ne1gb
    @DeepakKumar-ne1gb 4 месяца назад +23

    "Age is not the limit,years of service are different. "
    very good ...

  • @jymh123
    @jymh123 4 месяца назад +169

    Teachers should be paid well bcz in India private schools literally exploit teachers..All the expectations are from teachers but no one bother about their mental health and financial stability..once they are well paid they will not struggle in coaching and tuitions.

    • @vijayarangan17
      @vijayarangan17 3 месяца назад +14

      Salaries of private school teachers should be on par with Govt school teachers and Principals at least, because they do not get pension as well.

    • @LihanaHaydel
      @LihanaHaydel 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@@vijayarangan17 100% right . we are doing much much better comparing to them
      we still get less pay..

    • @Rick72002
      @Rick72002 2 месяца назад +1

      Kaide se bharat ki literacy 35%-40% ke aaspas honi chahiye
      Lekin on paper 70% q+ h😂

    • @user-he9yd6wl5v
      @user-he9yd6wl5v Месяц назад +1

      teachers ke phone ko check kr k dekhu k wo jab school mein hote hai tab kitna phone chlate hai such sahmne aa jayega😂😂 aur yeh bhi chek kro kon kon mid day meal khata hai 😂😂

    • @Anonymous-5kj
      @Anonymous-5kj 25 дней назад +1

      ​@@Rick72002literacy ka matlab hai sirf likhna aur padhna aata h
      It doesn't mean educated

  • @amanbajwa233
    @amanbajwa233 4 месяца назад +121

    I was the quiet kid in school, my teachers called me gumsum but no one tried to know why. At the age of 27, I’ve learned that I’m autistic. I and everyone around me always thought I was different and awkward, I spent years of my life thinking something was wrong with me. An autism diagnosis would’ve helped me own it instead of trying to fit in and fail at it.

    • @sonupandey1342
      @sonupandey1342 4 месяца назад +1

      Hello, i have seen many autistic children and adults. And they are given special attention by special educators. How you came to know so late at age 27, although it is good that you came to know about yourself, but it would have been better if you would have known yourself better.

    • @flyupp
      @flyupp 4 месяца назад +1

      How it was diagnosed..

    • @singharkirat
      @singharkirat 4 месяца назад +1

      bro where did you get diagnosed.. we have a lot of ADD/ADHD , OCD parents who need to get diagnosed before they start parenting...

    • @abhijitbhattacharya2625
      @abhijitbhattacharya2625 4 месяца назад +3

      Nahi sir. It is better to not tag someone with label of diseases. Other ppl are not mature enough to use those labels

    • @user-co9ri7zk8b
      @user-co9ri7zk8b 4 месяца назад

      Jaise barfi film me priyanka chopra ko dikhaya gaya, autistic log aise nahi hote. Autistic logo ko stereotype kr dia gaya jabki real me koi pata tak nahi laga pata ki hamein autism hain kyuki ham bilkul normal hain. Bas bolte nhi h. Do tarah ke autistic log hote h, bilkul opposites but still similar.... ek jinko selective mutism hai aapke aur meri tarah aur dusre jo talkative hote h, always excited, overshare krte h. Autistic logo ko demean, stereotype, belittle, obscur, defame aur insult kia jata h bhaut. Backhanded compliments bhi bhaut milte h aur jo gifted bache ho unko nafrat bhaut milti h bematlab mein. Covert bullying bhaut hoti h aur gossip, smear campaigns, narc abuse. Stay strong and avoid everyone who do this or support this behaviour whether they are housemates or outsiders. Being alone is better than being in trouble without any fault. I think everyone should read about attachment styles and parenting styles. Attachment style ko heal karna zaruri hota h self esteem ke liye. Assertiveness, detachment, decisiveness aur authenticity bhi tabhi seekh sakta hai insaan. I had anxious attachment style. I became a people pleaser because people around me were entitled, overbearing, condescending but now i am straightforward.. not rude tho. Pehle i had selective mutism, i rarely talked and always smiled because of nervousness and now i can socialise comfortably. Now i became the talkative type.

  • @nikhatimtiaz331
    @nikhatimtiaz331 3 месяца назад +9

    As a teacher myself,I got lots of positive learning from you....I would love to connect with you in future...this podcast explains lots of teaching methods in simple ways can be applied here too..

  • @writetomir
    @writetomir 4 месяца назад +21

    Every parent and teacher must listen to this insightful discussion.

  • @namank93
    @namank93 3 месяца назад +21

    This is what a podcast is supposed to be like. So much informative and eye opening and yet entertaining enough not to get bored.

  • @nidhimanocha8574
    @nidhimanocha8574 12 дней назад +2

    I am a paraprofessional working at a California public school. I agree with what she is saying 💯. This is my sixth year. I was a stay at home mom for 10 years.

  • @kanhaiyajoshi4020
    @kanhaiyajoshi4020 4 месяца назад +34

    आप दानों को नमस्ते। I am a b.ed passout students, I want to tell you literally, की जितना मैंने टीचर ट्रेनिंग में नहीं सीखा, आज आपसे सिख लिया। इंडियन एजुकेशन सिस्टम को तेजी से सुधारने का एक तरीका आज जाना, महसूस किया कि यदि प्रत्येक इंडियन स्कूल में कम से कम एक टीचर ऐसा होना चाहिए। जिसकी टीचर ट्रेनिंग अमेरिका से हुई हो और वह इंडियन हो तो, मुझे लगता हैं,, हमारी एजुकेशन सिस्टम भी बहुत बेहतर हो सकती है ओर ऐसा करना हमारी गवर्नमेंट के लिए इंपोसिबल भी नहीं है।

    • @MsEternalpeace
      @MsEternalpeace 3 месяца назад

      Han bilkul sahi. Lekin dikkat ye hogi..ki her school se ek ek teacher jo US bheja jayega wo sirf kisi MP, MLA adi ki santan ya rishtedar honge. Jo US se wapis aake gayab ho jayenge.

    • @MsEternalpeace
      @MsEternalpeace 3 месяца назад

      Jokes apart...aap insta aur youtube se duniya k alag alagbteachers ko follow karke sekh sakte ho..unki class k atmosphere ko dekh sakte ho

    • @babjssk
      @babjssk 2 месяца назад

      Aapne kitne din B.Ed. ki class attend kiya tha imandari se puchna khud se

    • @Mana-dg2kb
      @Mana-dg2kb Месяц назад

      Absolutely right 👍

  • @ankurdubeysoftwaretesting4274
    @ankurdubeysoftwaretesting4274 8 дней назад +1

    This is the best podcast, I have ever listened, so practical. Thank you to both of you to bring it. A lot of useful lessons out of it. Miss Kaur explained a lot in single sentences only. So pleased to hear.

  • @Expressionjunction18
    @Expressionjunction18 3 месяца назад +34

    As a teacher this is an amazing podcast. In India the system is so bad....I joined school 2 years back..and unknowingly I was practicing all what you said and I was implementing new things in my class with my students...because I wanted to give them what wasn't offered to me as a student.....but what I got in return was humiliation disrespect exploitation and mental emotional harassment at the end of the day...that I have to left that school....that principal made me feel I was doing sth wrong and I felt bad about it....today after listening to your podcast I am feeling good atleast I havent done wrong with my students...what I was trying was right....and what he was saying was definitely wrong.....in India, parents and school management don't care about teachers.....their mental health is not considered important and they are mentally emotionally tortured...and if you are female you will be physically exploited...the working condition is not safe for womens that's what I have experienced....evry day after humiliation I feel I chosed a wrong profession.....

    • @sheebaaslam
      @sheebaaslam 3 месяца назад +1

      🫂

    • @anup2516
      @anup2516 23 дня назад +1

      Keep going, what you should be doing. I agree, society tries to get aside someone who make a difference.

    • @magpierobin21
      @magpierobin21 23 дня назад +2

      Please don't feel bad. I learnt a lot in few years what I have not in 20 years. So you already know it then follow and do things that you feel is the best.

    • @Expressionjunction18
      @Expressionjunction18 16 дней назад

      ​@@anup2516thank you so much for this much positivity ❤

    • @Expressionjunction18
      @Expressionjunction18 16 дней назад

      ​@@magpierobin21thank you so much for the kind words means a lot❤

  • @Aayushmanbhav461
    @Aayushmanbhav461 4 месяца назад +47

    Host is very intelligent..she is analysis very well ..great..

  • @brars4311
    @brars4311 4 месяца назад +43

    A girl in my known has recently shifted from australia to india .... She is in 9th standard icse board. She gets very tired with soooo much written work and feels very upset when teachers insult any child infront of the whole class for not performing well or incomplete work etc......

    • @sudhaagarwal9290
      @sudhaagarwal9290 4 месяца назад +7

      Yes human values are not taken care of in schools..they give so much of written work and activities

    • @pallavi_artstudio
      @pallavi_artstudio 3 месяца назад +1

      Yes, my daughter is studying in the 10th class under the CBSE board. Since junior KG, she has had a heavy burden of writing. Now, even in the 10th class, the heavy writing continues. If she hasn’t completed any work, the teacher insults her badly in front of the entire class. Because of this, my daughter started avoiding school from July to mid-August. However, we finally met with the Principal and explained that our daughter was afraid to attend school because of the teacher’s harsh scolding. The Principal assured us that no teacher would scold her for anything and encouraged us to send her to school, stressing the importance of the 10th class. Now, she is attending school regularly."

    • @xyzha6906
      @xyzha6906 3 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/XlnspY2wOVw/видео.htmlsi=2r7RgGtQlFX1cHK2

    • @srividyasubramanian6107
      @srividyasubramanian6107 3 месяца назад

      8:25.....platforms are available....madam......the session is so 😴

    • @studytipschannel2335
      @studytipschannel2335 3 месяца назад

      If you don't give lot of homework or written work, in India you are not considered to be a good teacher.

  • @Daljeet-RK
    @Daljeet-RK 4 месяца назад +8

    This is real and serious topics should be discussed. It's a beautiful podcast between Jasmine maam and Kintu maam Thank you 😊

  • @Heritagesagayoutube
    @Heritagesagayoutube 4 месяца назад +12

    The leaders and we the people failed this country on so many levels, i will have to say we are probably one of the most inhumane human beings.

  • @prakharpathak8d227
    @prakharpathak8d227 4 месяца назад +8

    Hats off to the host and appreciate info and vision of the guest
    I'm a teacher and going to share with all other teachers
    This video must be shared among all educators

  • @Muleslover
    @Muleslover 4 месяца назад +35

    Indian govt feel shame to provide free quality education ,but feel proud to provide free feed.

    • @shivangi1315
      @shivangi1315 4 месяца назад +4

      Both are necessity

    • @Love-dz1um
      @Love-dz1um 4 месяца назад +1

      People send kids to the school for the sake of free food itself.

    • @VedShilvanth
      @VedShilvanth 4 месяца назад +1

      Government know mother like teaching.if you feed kids they don't fall ill due to poverty and attend the classes they are taking. They feed because bad nutrition is a big problem for poor attention.education requires lots of attention. Atleast to get food they attend school 😊.

    • @Abhijit-12361
      @Abhijit-12361 3 месяца назад +1

      Konsa quality be

  • @rashak1298
    @rashak1298 Месяц назад +5

    That was a great conversation..change on the go..together we can. System is only failed not human❤

  • @ernaveenverma
    @ernaveenverma 2 месяца назад +4

    Very well explained video sharing the differences between India and the US education system. I would also like to add, in the US the system varies from State to State and within the state where they have more tax payers schools get more funding accordingly and provide facilities. That's why school ratings vary from place to place. Like she is from NYC and mentioned in school they provide free food. But in Washington State parents need to pay for food and stationery. But in general many things she has mentioned regarding the way of education taking care of kids with special needs are good just that again these facilities vary where schools are getting more funding they can support more therapies in school etc. So in short definitely better than what we have in government schools in India but still lags behind many other countries in Europe etc. Another point to clarify tution culture is not as bad as in India but it's definitely there. Like people go for different classes like Kummon is one of the popular and Russian Maths. One of the complaints of parents specifically Indians is that the standard of education is not as high as we have in India. What I mean is if we ask the 12th grade student in the US to clear the IIT exam in India they will suffer big time. But if we take a 12th grade student with a similar quality school in India like any CBSE or ICSE student they find it much easier to crack many US universities. That's why I am seeing many parents in the US keep their kids in India till grade 10th then sent to the US and the majority do far better.

  • @ganeshbalasubramanian8205
    @ganeshbalasubramanian8205 3 месяца назад +3

    Madam your channel is a hidden gold mine literally
    So much sensible relevant topics being discussed and we get beautiful perspectives

  • @prashantaryawanshi9612
    @prashantaryawanshi9612 4 месяца назад +10

    Truly an Excellent and much needed conversation.
    Thanks so much for doing this. 🙏❤️ Mai ye 2 din me aaraam aaraam se dekha because I had to make notes of it.
    I also subscribed to your channel, mam. 🙂

  • @nahidsyyed906
    @nahidsyyed906 3 месяца назад +10

    As a former English faculty in the Middle East for two decades, I can very well relate to the principles of pedagogy implied there.
    1. Students are free to voice their opinion.
    2. Students' Evaluation of Teacher (every sem)
    3. Unannounced HoDs visits for lesson observation
    4. No interaction outside school/college (No pvt coaching)
    5. Creating a stress free cordial, amicable learning classroom environment.
    6. Free education all thru'. Free transport, books, laptops plus the Govt.pays monthly allowance for accommodation.
    Though teaching Arab students, EFL was challenging, I simply loved my work.❤ The icing on the cake is, you get a thick pay packet & NO INCOME TAX!🎉

    • @rajputji1686
      @rajputji1686 3 месяца назад

      Aap apni shadi m khush hai ?😂
      Thats wholesome maam

    • @cottoncloudsinthesky1931
      @cottoncloudsinthesky1931 3 месяца назад

      @nahidsayyed - Ma'am I too want to join those schools. As a teacher of English should I do a CELTA as most schools prefer hiring native English speaking teachers. I wish if you could guide me further. Thank you. 🎉

    • @nahidsyyed906
      @nahidsyyed906 Месяц назад

      @@cottoncloudsinthesky1931 I appreciate your interest in joining the teaching fraternity, but since 2021, the locals (native Arabs) are being preferred over expats. Also u need to clear the IELTS exam, yes CELTA is a must.
      U can browse their (MoHE= Ministry of Higher Education) websites for opening n apply. Wishing u the very best!

    • @nahidsyyed906
      @nahidsyyed906 Месяц назад

      @@rajputji1686 Ofcourse! Kuch log toh rashk karnè lagay hum sè! 😃

  • @vibsv
    @vibsv 26 дней назад +1

    Very good conversation! All this not only applies to teachers but also as a parent that we all can apply for our kids. It all starts at home!

  • @DeepikaDubey-f6j
    @DeepikaDubey-f6j 3 месяца назад +4

    I love the grace of the host. What a wonderful personality

  • @jubilantmediastudios
    @jubilantmediastudios 4 месяца назад +27

    I'M AMAZED TO KNOW THE DIFFERENCE, & SHOCKED TO SEE SUCH LOW VIEWS.

  • @kapiljoshi8631
    @kapiljoshi8631 3 месяца назад +4

    Best of the bestest interview which I had ever seen... Thanks Jasmine.

  • @rishiraaj.580
    @rishiraaj.580 4 месяца назад +32

    This podcast Must reach every Indian Home. Eye Opening. 😐

  • @ritijadevkar9499
    @ritijadevkar9499 3 месяца назад +10

    The major challenge before Indian teachers at least in Mumbai is class strength....one teacher and 70 students.

  • @pallavi2371
    @pallavi2371 14 дней назад +2

    One of the valuable podcast I have ever seen.... 👍

  • @bopeep2468
    @bopeep2468 4 месяца назад +28

    Absolutely agree with her. Coaching classes should be stopped n teachers should be held accountable. It will ease the load on kids and take away the pressure.

    • @physicsenthusiast427
      @physicsenthusiast427 4 месяца назад +1

      Govt teacher sirf percentage aur experience exam pas krne se nhi milti paisa contact ho tab hota govt teacher banna aur private me salary itni Kam hai Ghar kaise chaloge

    • @kshamashah842
      @kshamashah842 2 месяца назад +2

      Who send them for coaching,it's parents not school

    • @chanchalikumari5902
      @chanchalikumari5902 Месяц назад

      Parents are so busy they are not able to take care of own children and they will send in coaching ....

  • @aslamferoz6817
    @aslamferoz6817 2 месяца назад +2

    Thanks for such an interview!

  • @aishk5744
    @aishk5744 3 месяца назад +4

    I live in Melbourne. I liked the podcast as she talked all good things about US education but no negative. Truth is the ones who want to study are valued and the ones who don’t want to study have an option to do something else if they are good at something. Also Indian kids also go through racism whether it’s whichever foreign country . Teachers are in so much pressure to educate kids & have less say . Here parents and kids are right always. Kids are rude to teachers , they misbehave, they answer back , so there are good & bad things also .Schools have bullying issues is a big problem but good thing is that teachers show care and support to the students and if there is a complaint they take it seriously. So it comes with good & bad . Here in Australia we don’t get free breakfast, lunch but the schools sometimes offer doughnuts or pizzas on some special occasions. Yes education is much better than India , less pressure. Kids love to go to school. Teachers are not rude and you can reach out to teachers or to principals directly and easily for any reason. There is no arrogance in any Principals or teachers. They are very calm and respectful plus welcoming.

  • @arisharif77
    @arisharif77 5 дней назад +1

    Just woow brilliant podcast and i alot learnt from this podcast my turning point is this.....

  • @pawanrai9311
    @pawanrai9311 Месяц назад +3

    Wow....such an eye opener interview after a long time.

  • @seemagite1712
    @seemagite1712 2 месяца назад +2

    Wow! I am in UK and able to relate each and every word of Jasmine.

  • @AshwaniKumar-p4n4e
    @AshwaniKumar-p4n4e 2 месяца назад +3

    Every Indian Must listen to this. Specially the policymakers. 👍✌️

  • @julianasamuel1824
    @julianasamuel1824 4 месяца назад +2

    U r so right that people don’t have a platform back home . I started as a sub para and DOE has paid all my Tution to go back to college as my bachelors degree from back home was not sufficient to get a teaching license . I am so grateful that I got this platform here in the US and after this fall 2024 semester I would complete my journey that I have been on for 8 long years and be a teacher soon .
    There is opportunity to move up the ladder in this country and especially teaching . Hopefully I will complete my masters sooner hopefully one year and after three years of service I do look forward to being an admin just like this lady

  • @buttery_molala_ot7441
    @buttery_molala_ot7441 3 месяца назад +3

    So enlightening podcast, Lovely interaction between the two intelligent people , very much truth in this conversation,I was so much shocked to know such things about the education system of America,no dóubt they have achieved so much.

  • @neeladas9486
    @neeladas9486 3 месяца назад +1

    Maam as a mother today i have learned many new things and thank you for sharing openly your experience.

  • @imature-dot-in
    @imature-dot-in 4 месяца назад +10

    Excellent conversation! I've been working fulltime in the domain of 21st century education and digital transformation of Indian schools. I found the host's questions coming from deep understanding of education, and the guest's answers very insightful!

  • @shashank95915
    @shashank95915 4 месяца назад +4

    One of the best podcasts on education I have ever seen.

  • @varenyaroy6152
    @varenyaroy6152 3 месяца назад +1

    One of the best podcasts! Thanks for uploading!! And the interviewer was able to touch upon so many topics that needed to be touched! Loved it

  • @sanachauhan9653
    @sanachauhan9653 3 месяца назад +5

    Education is not failing in india. The job generation policy is failing. The talent india has no other country is blessed with. The student studied here gained knowledge from india and did a job in foreign

    • @VaishuRajput-c3w
      @VaishuRajput-c3w 2 месяца назад

      And the dark reality is we just get knowledge form India.....but how to apply it, how to grow ourselves, how to use our creative mind, how to fit ourselves in different environment..............
      Knowledge to aap book se bhi leloge but baaki cheeze kha se laoge ........... India m bhot km chances h unfortunately......

    • @Albert.einstein904
      @Albert.einstein904 2 месяца назад

      education is only failure in India only some who are rich or intelligent can find work in foreign countries

  • @subhash1311b
    @subhash1311b Месяц назад +1

    I lost my first child in a government hospital due to their negligence. I was pressured by my maternal family to choose a government facility, as they believed a private hospital would perform an unnecessary operation that could harm my long-term health. As a first-time parent, I struggled to make the right decision.

  • @1OMSAIRAM
    @1OMSAIRAM 3 месяца назад +3

    Happy to listen the facts n values of education in USA.
    but it's only possible when parents have money.. then what about those parents who haven't enough money or knowledge.. India have to change their education system.. it's a humble request from all Indian Parents..

  • @Lazynews-u3l
    @Lazynews-u3l 3 месяца назад +2

    as a teacher i find this is a very interesting and useful podcast thank to Sheeba maam

  • @dr.ritasharma6413
    @dr.ritasharma6413 4 месяца назад +22

    In India our b.ed program also have practical teaching classes and observation classes but the irony is that it happens in non attending classes of b.ed program 😅

    • @FutureMathsSkillsHub
      @FutureMathsSkillsHub 21 день назад

      It is because a completely well-planned system has been created to destroy the education system. Neither those running the system want to make improvements, nor do the people whose children are part of this system.
      Anyway, there is a lot of profit in education, because such a business is not found anywhere else where the customer does not even complain that they have been given substandard goods.

  • @SukhwinderSinghRataul
    @SukhwinderSinghRataul 13 дней назад +1

    Very good interview, full of knowledge. enjoyed every second.

  • @SurenderSingh-ef2be
    @SurenderSingh-ef2be 4 месяца назад +16

    बहुत सही बात कही है मैडम ने लेकिन अमेरिका और इंडिया की दशाओं में बहुत फर्क है,यहां पैरेंट्स को बच्चों की रोजी रोटी ,शादी ,मेडिकल सुविधा की चिंता रहती है,जबकि अमेरिका में सबकी जिम्मेदारी सरकार की होती है इसलिए वहां ज्यादा आजादी है। जैस्मिन मैडम आपने सही कहावत बताई , भेड़ चाल ये हिंदी में भी यही कहावत है

    • @ajeetjoymassey9288
      @ajeetjoymassey9288 4 месяца назад

      Isse koyi farq nahi padta ki aapke uper kya responsibility hai, Bachche aapne paida kiya hai aur aapki responsibility banti hai ki aap mentally, emotionally har area me use growth provide kariye..

  • @shridharvyas1511
    @shridharvyas1511 2 месяца назад

    Jasmine you impressed me by concluding the discussion that our culture has strength which is way better than US or any western country. My both kids are there in USA and Canada for a long time. I visited there many times and I am socially active there.

  • @vikas.acharya
    @vikas.acharya 4 месяца назад +4

    Lots of positive insights. Interesting knowledge sharing.

  • @swetabaghel8726
    @swetabaghel8726 4 месяца назад +2

    Wonderful Sheeba Maam,
    This is acctully real podcast.
    Thanks Dear.

  • @yogitathakur9633
    @yogitathakur9633 4 месяца назад +9

    Good job. Plz do more podcasts on this topic.... Educational programs.....

  • @hukkuhukku6208
    @hukkuhukku6208 12 дней назад +1

    This podcast was awesome..can you do a discussion on homeschooling India?

  • @aashirwaadenterprises
    @aashirwaadenterprises 4 месяца назад +3

    I was in class 5 and fell sick for a few days later when I went back to school I missed some grammar chapters and my class classwork notebook was note up to date. When my English Language teacher (Mrs. Pamela) found this out instead of helping gave me a De-merit slip.
    That was the first De-merit slip that I got. After that incident I never felt comfortable in her classes.

  • @Nziabegum
    @Nziabegum Месяц назад

    Such an amazing podcast... Listened everything without skipping.. Both women are so well spoken!!!

  • @geetakaur3789
    @geetakaur3789 4 месяца назад +4

    What is the student teacher ratio in a class in New York? Here in India in a class there is 1 teacher on 53 students. Govt. brought(copied) some of it from outside but was not feasible in such scenarios.

    • @bhavisharajpurorohit5495
      @bhavisharajpurorohit5495 4 месяца назад

      When i was in scool we are 100 plus student in class highest in our scool but in other class also more 80 student...

  • @ReviewGuruIndia
    @ReviewGuruIndia 2 месяца назад +1

    So impressed, wow, why this channel is so underrated.❤

  • @abhimanyusingh5865
    @abhimanyusingh5865 4 месяца назад +4

    As a punjabi I am proud of Jasmine Kaur ji ❤

  • @rekhanegi8565
    @rekhanegi8565 22 дня назад

    I am watching this podcast and writing my thoughts in mid of this ongoing video which i felt very deeply, that it's very easy for everyone to blame the system and complaint but this podcast has made me realise how many changes i personally need in my own behaviour and thought process to bring the change from atleast from my side first. This is really a wonderful session.

  • @shamalingle1130
    @shamalingle1130 4 месяца назад +19

    India's education is, "Race" for family's name, for school's name, for Coaching's name for State's name, Country's name.. we don't teach or learn for educating ourselves, we do it to compete with others.. Sad!
    Kitna samjha hai.. maayne nahi rakh raha.😟

  • @dharampal5048
    @dharampal5048 4 месяца назад +1

    गजब 🎉, great watching this show. Sheeba ji I salute you to bring such experience. Jasmin shared her experience in such a humanitarian way, I am really impressed. 🙏 thanks a lot.
    If she were a hindu swarn woman, she would not have shared all this in true spirit.
    Swarn people made india hell, not humans but graded unequals.

  • @reetagoyal5559
    @reetagoyal5559 4 месяца назад +3

    Very true, my son -in -law has started med school at the age of 43 , earlier he was working with some company, my daughter is a medical doctor.

  • @savage9596
    @savage9596 3 месяца назад +1

    The interviewer Sheeba aslam is so perfect at her work
    U put sensible comments and build the communication smoothly

  • @Krodhimanav.---.---.
    @Krodhimanav.---.---. 4 месяца назад +3

    Superb and very eye opening for Indian teachers and parents.

  • @alekapfo4629
    @alekapfo4629 3 месяца назад +1

    Here I am in the same position for 13 years now... obviously a little raise in salary every year but still I look forward for a higher position and other securities with my years of experience and dedication to my work.
    After all a private school in India what can I expect more

  • @riseup2227
    @riseup2227 Месяц назад +3

    They have the best education and business standards and system and we have the largest desperate population wanting to uplift themselves perfect combination for making US a great Nation.

  • @dr.tsayyed3979
    @dr.tsayyed3979 3 месяца назад +1

    Great use of social media, thank you so much kintu parantu❤

  • @kamlasajwan4716
    @kamlasajwan4716 4 месяца назад +11

    बहुत अच्छा लगा अमेरिकन शिक्षा पद्धति के विषय में जानकर ।यदि दृढ़ सकंल्प शक्ति हो तो हमारी सरकार भी हमारी शिक्षा पद्धतिमें बदलाव लाकर बच्चों का भविष्य उज्जवल कर सकती है ।

  • @neeharikavardhan1794
    @neeharikavardhan1794 24 дня назад +1

    Thank ful that i got this podcast on my feed

  • @amandahiya1010
    @amandahiya1010 4 месяца назад +3

    The best podcast and one of the best teacher I have seen. 👍❤️

  • @thebohukitchen
    @thebohukitchen 4 месяца назад +1

    I totally agree with her. I can relate with her every word. We are very proud to be Indian but we have to change our system.

  • @SaumyaShiro
    @SaumyaShiro 3 месяца назад +10

    I hated going school...bcz of fear, anxiety, rude teachers, boring classes 😅😢

  • @aira5829
    @aira5829 3 месяца назад +1

    I'm glad i came across this video.Thumbs up .
    Do not agree with the thumbnail..It should have been thriving and failing systems on both sides.

  • @peusharora6733
    @peusharora6733 4 месяца назад +9

    Private school teachers are in even more pathetic conditions. No proper salary, no leaves, no pension, no gratuity, no medical insurance, no security. No respect, no recognition and extreme exploitation. There are two religions in the modern India - Govt. Job vs Private Job. Govt. Employees enjoy a good decent salary structure with medical, security pension fund etc benefits and almost no exploitation. One classroom has more than 50 students in private schools and it is almost impossible to control the class. Sarkari schools mein to kuch hota hi nahi sabko pata hai. Govt. teachers are paid hefty salary but no teaching is done.

    • @Starshine496
      @Starshine496 4 месяца назад +3

      I would disagree with u..though ur pov comes from the past trends but the ones who are newly recruited through exams and interviews into govt school are trying best to change this scenario. It is a systematic failure that our education system is like that. Change is happening for sure but the rate is slow. Whatever I can provide to better our children's future I am doing it. Because they are our future ( Govt teacher here).

    • @bhavisharajpurorohit5495
      @bhavisharajpurorohit5495 4 месяца назад

      Govt jada teachers q nahi higher karti,vese bhi itni unemployment hai desh mai logo ke pas job nahi or students k pas teachers nahi hai..hamare rajasthan mai gav k school mai 2 ya 3 teacher pura school chalate hai 4 ya 5 class k bachoo ko ek sath padhate hai.

    • @SanaZareenWarsi
      @SanaZareenWarsi 4 месяца назад

      No, in Bihar government teachers are not paid well, they are very overloaded with work & underpaid... These teachers are frustrated & sad...

    • @peusharora6733
      @peusharora6733 Месяц назад

      Why govt. Teachers/Employees children then study in private schools. It would take 500 yrs. to change/improve this system our corrupt politicians are Hippocrates..

  • @RajKumar-gd6tu
    @RajKumar-gd6tu 4 месяца назад +1

    Very good program. It may benefit many, individually. I advise you to come to India and contribute to transform our system. May God love you more!!!

  • @Balwan_Singh
    @Balwan_Singh 4 месяца назад +4

    Every Indian teachers should learn from this podcast.

    • @pyaripragyaofficial
      @pyaripragyaofficial 20 дней назад

      Teacher are also burdened...school administration should learn...and actually they dont want to learn except profit

  • @Theturmericclub
    @Theturmericclub Месяц назад +2

    I loved your podcast. I share the same views. I taught in US school for 20 years and share the same views.

  • @vartikachauhan5501
    @vartikachauhan5501 3 месяца назад +3

    What a podcast every thing she is said is true I am a teacher and I can feel that every line

  • @navyathapa140
    @navyathapa140 10 дней назад

    Indeed in India education is big profitable business in private school and in government school or semi government school negligence .
    Its time to change... very informative broadcast.
    Thank you angie your team.

  • @tularam1989
    @tularam1989 4 месяца назад +5

    Please mam one more interview with Jasmine mam in your channel... Mam please... Bta nahi sakta kitna sikhne ko mila .tq for such a knowledgeable video.

    • @sheebaaslam
      @sheebaaslam 4 месяца назад

      Thanks for your engagement Tularam ji.
      Sure would love to talk to Ms Jasmine again. Please send me your questions and themes that you want me to bring up.
      Regards

    • @tularam1989
      @tularam1989 4 месяца назад +1

      @@sheebaaslam first of all thank you mam for your reply. I would like to know some of the points of the American education system these are
      1. Evaluation system or exm pattern.
      2. Curricular activities that are included in system
      3. How are American students productive?
      4. Career counseling or personal counseling of the students
      Thank you 🙏

  • @magpierobin21
    @magpierobin21 23 дня назад +2

    Thanks for showing that non-native English teachers have opportunities abroad. Because I always thought otherwise.

  • @AdityaRajOfficial1
    @AdityaRajOfficial1 4 месяца назад +6

    Most Valuable video for Parents Teacher & Students.

  • @vasps7472
    @vasps7472 24 дня назад +1

    Good debate on education system in USA and India

  • @indirasharma8906
    @indirasharma8906 4 месяца назад +3

    Such more program needed

  • @BhaminiKulkarni
    @BhaminiKulkarni 4 месяца назад +3

    🙏🌻🙏 Really admire and appreciate the topic, the host and the guest, for the honest insight into the topic.
    Am only 11 mns into the conversation, but am eager to share just my 2 cents, because I don’t want to forget what I want to share.
    My view is top down approach will be a bandaid.
    We need to have bottom up approach. Let’s start with the basic value system (eg., mentioned in the Yoga sutras, etc) to be the building blocks of the curriculum starting from preschool. Let’s start awareness programs for newly weds, to educate them about healthy and spiritual conception and pregnancy and early childhood development.
    Let’s have teachers who are trained to be holistic educators. They need to have good remuneration because they are shaping the future of the world.

  • @zri4594
    @zri4594 3 месяца назад +2

    I want to be part of your journey sheeba mam becoz we are like minded..i want to change indian education system

  • @user-Janvarshala
    @user-Janvarshala 4 месяца назад +3

    This podcast is not about american and indian education, this is about the indian education in papers and policies and actual reality.

  • @hashtageditz7894
    @hashtageditz7894 4 месяца назад +2

    Amazing 👏 podcast.. I wish we can together come forward and speak abt these issues and instead of religion cast creed we shud pressurize our govt to make Indian Education system as such...so petty we hv best humanity background bt still we fail😢

  • @manojdhoomre8342
    @manojdhoomre8342 4 месяца назад +3

    I learned a lot from the podcast.

  • @kedarishereforyou
    @kedarishereforyou 23 дня назад +1

    Wow! Truly amazing.👏👏👌👌👍👍
    I learnt a lot. And I could co relate with my experiences and observations.
    Thank you for this video 🙏
    I am forwarding this as much as possible.

  • @nirapathak5340
    @nirapathak5340 4 месяца назад +23

    One thing I want to add not all teachers are fit for teaching.Not all are fit being teacher. Not all teacher knows how to handle children and there groth

    • @dr.hemasaini1792
      @dr.hemasaini1792 4 месяца назад

      Actually most of the people in India do jobs in India just for money...they don't love their job

    • @kavitathampy5137
      @kavitathampy5137 3 месяца назад

      Well said

  • @pradeepsagar1982
    @pradeepsagar1982 3 месяца назад +1

    Thanks for this podcast It's a Great Learning from this podcast and definitely It will give us a big Boost in our teaching carrier and we will try to develop a better society with our comprehensive effors..
    Thanks & Regards you both
    Pradeep Kumar

  • @haanizahid_7
    @haanizahid_7 4 месяца назад +3

    Sheeba sahiba is amazing! And also she is incredibly sweet and respectful.I love her dress.She asked intelligent Questions.
    We would want more podcasts like this.
    Thanks to Jasmine Sahiba for this Great information.
    Lot's of love and Respect!