Power of sc st obc reservation, 1950s me sc st reservation se IAS bun chuke k grandchildren aaj bhi reservation le rahe aur sc st obc reservation se millionaire mayawati malikarjun kharge hemant Soren lalu yadav ya Akhilesh Yadav aaj bhi political reservation le rahe!
EVERY IAS AND IPS OFFICER IN THIS COUNTRY MUST MAKE A PUBLIC DECLARATION OF THEIR INCOME AND ASSETS OWNED BY THEM. EACH AND EVERY OFFICER WILL BE FOUND GUILTY. GUARANTEE 100%
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
Very professional anchor... doesn't shout or interrupt during the show. We need more anchors like him...most news debates are just a shouting match. Vineet is well mannered, good voice modulation, other channels can learn a lot from him.
She may be groom up the way which reflects her such nefarious mindset. She comes from super rich family and father is retired IAS definitely dishonest, power misuser, system dishonoured personality while was in power. She probably got through this environment. She shall immediately removed from the service to uplift the image of burocracy
That's why people wants to leave country because here powerful people can do anything according to their needs....fake disability and fake obc Ncl certificate by using their power and became IAS😅 all the rules and regulations are for poors
She was apprehended due to her foolishness in demanding everything and drawing attention to herself. I am concerned about how many other IAS and IPS officers are similar to her and have not yet been caught.
Everyone in India knows that bureaucrats acts like master of the country after politicians. Only a minority might be honest and work with humility. Majority might be drunk in power. The Delhi case where IAS couple wanted the stadium empty which is there for athletes to practice just because the IAF couple wanted to walk with their dog. It's a rotten system with colonial hangover.
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
Her family members come from civil service background. It is possible that they use their influence either through their seniors, batch-mates or juniors. Public sector needs to implement punishment policies like private sector. Public sector has serious accountability issue. Which is why we are third world country. Learn from Singapore, how their bureaucracy works.
Exactly!!! Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳 Whosoever is governing the country will never ever think of wiping out this strong tool of reservations to be in power. That's why people who have the capability, intelligence and resources are moving out of this country.🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
Sarjana Yadav AIR 126 UPSC CSE 2019 Father: IES, Superintending Engineer, ESIC. Initially UPSC rejected her candidature and did not allocate any post due to dubious OBC NON CREAMY LAYER CERTIFICATE, as father was a directly appointed Group A officer (apart from private earnings). But she went to CAT and was mysteriously allocated to IAS
Forgery caste certificates are common among job seekers many persons depromoted in PSU. They should scrutiny of certificates of 10 years ias ips ifs batches. strict criminal action to be taken
They need power. Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
There is lot of issues ..Just think if she can fake PWD /OBC for IAS.. what about other govt jobs and educational institute...I know few guys who have got jobs/educational institutional(IIT/NIT) with fake OBC and EWS even though they are very well off and quite rich..there is no way to verify it...I even know few people who can provide this certificates for 10k Rs..it is very sad but true..
How can any politician or any ruling government(BJP, CONGRESS) stop corruption when 50 percent of d system especially IAS,IPS officers r corrupt n it's actually not known to anybody
IAS and IPS have becomes a joke..all you need to do is check up on retired officers and see what assets they actually have. Not saying all of them are bad but a distressing number of them are...something a poor country like India cannot afford..
An IAS officer can earn worth assets 40 crores 116 acres of land 6 plots and 7 flats , audi car, Jewels etc. My God. That is why people crazy on IAS, IPS.
🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳 Mr Peer has very rightly said that why this lady was given reservation when her family background is very rich with her father worth 40 crores. Why she was not considered in creamy layer. Why the government make a data to offer the reservation to one member one family on the basis of which the concept of reservations came into being. But it was never done, the voting tool. Its so disgusting.🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
The quotas shld be given only 4 economically deprived. Y rich ppl(no matter what community)need quotas at all? Then yu collect income tax based on income n not based on community now? I don't understand this logic at all.
Very well conducted by the anchor, giving chance to each of the speakers to express their views. Us viewers would appreciate such debates rather than those where speakers talk over each other. So, well done NewsX!
Her conduct raises a doubt whether she passed her medical course honestly and UPSC exam honestly. There is power in the hands of the government. She can be dismissed by the President without any enquiry. Previously there is one precedence of dismissal by the President of India. I am unable to remember since it happened long back and I am Eighty years old.
Mera question ye h ki uska medical test may 2022 me hua joki 2021 exam ke anusar But 2022 ke exam m isko 821 rank Mila h jiska medical test may 2023 m hona tha. Vo ku nhi hui or agar hua bhi galat ku pakad nhi hua.
Sir wat r u saying , civil service rule this country,they are the bosses! Action should be taken against all people opposing this officer for insulting the govt servant
I am fully agree with Jyotikaji. These people still live in colonial era. We are changing colonial many systems, but why are we not changing this IAS systems?
Our Janta Money is being used for these baster*&&&& We should start our Corrupt, Supreme Court, Hight Court, Advocate, Janta Ke Naukar and Janta ke Sewak
Mr. Dhananjay, integrity is something you are not putting a premium on! A person who is supposed to honestly govern a district/ department must be above these accusations! In the private IT company I worked in, a General Manager of 20 years of service was visibly suspended for submitting false medical bills! Genuine bills pertaining to his mothers illness- but outside the purview of company policies
Friends, most of the time OBC non creamy layer certificates are subjective. As per governent order the children of officers entered as class1 officers come under creamy layer of OBC though they are from OBC. Meaning these candidates come under general category only. The status of their parents when they entered the service is the only criterion to know whether one comes under cremy layer or non creamy layer, ever after the retirement of their parents no change. It means though one belongs to OBC, but entered in gov as class1 begore 36 years of age, then his/her children will be under creamy layer permanently. Now class1 officer and other similar officers in university, college, psu, bank etc mapping is given. Here subjectivity comes in through kickoff. I entered the goverment service through CES examination of UPSC in 1985 as a class1 officer. Though I belong to OBC, my son could not get OBC reservation as he is coming under creamy layer as per gov order. However the son of my relative a retired professor of aided college could get selected under OBC category. Its all in the hand of official issuing the creamy layer certificate.
If Redkar can manipulate documents, there may be other unidentified cases that have quietly been absorbed into the system. It's crucial to investigate all potential instances to maintain trust in the system.
Ms Basu speaks from the top of her head. She should prepare much better before appearing on a panel. Otherwise, she should shut up. Haven't seen such ignorance and superficial knowledge.
The funny thing is no one raised even an eyebrow when her father declared his assets when running for elections. Declaring assets is one thing, trying to find how people in public office get those assets should be scrutinized. Big brother seems to be watching only those who are not in the "creamy layers."
One more such case just 2 years back . One Ips demanded Biryani free from thehotels under her area jurisdiction.what happens to her . Is there Any action on her
Sumit peer has put the right question that the khedkar lady is already settled. Now did she need reservation when she having lot of family's like khedkar should give up reservation for needy and capable.
GOV job must be 5 PC CTC Will save 5 lakh CR monthly Use that to reduce Petrol Diesel Gas Electricity Veg Food Medicine price for 143 CR 1 family max 1 GOV job That's true SABKA SAATH SABKA VIKAS 1 SC ST OBC EWS benefit per family 70% India have SC ST OBC EWS If you seek VOTE from all families give job to all FAMILY Not all reservation to 1 family That's biggest SCAM
As long as media is corrupt and political , any one can misuse any thing. Even mental person can become an IAS officer and we do not have how many IAS mentals are still in power?????
I would like to request Honourable CJI Mr Chandrachuda sir and honourable SC as a whole to take a look at the whole reservation system for riview to know whether it acting for the real people it is meant for.
Central Administrative Tribunal is like Hon Supreme Court ? Worst elements get all sympathy empathy humanitarian grounds leniency opportunity to reform
Leave Pooja. Focus on UPSC, SSC, DOPT, CSS. You will find biggest issues. Can Media do??/ Can you bring out?? I doubt. You people can just attack on single person or a family only.
How one can read titles and writings which you change so quickly ? This is mockery of viewers. At first place think over it that why are you presenting news in writings?
The Father should be investigated too for disproportionate assets being an Govt Servant......
Exactly
Power of sc st obc reservation, 1950s me sc st reservation se IAS bun chuke k grandchildren aaj bhi reservation le rahe aur sc st obc reservation se millionaire mayawati malikarjun kharge hemant Soren lalu yadav ya Akhilesh Yadav aaj bhi political reservation le rahe!
@@thephysicscatalyst6048 even EWS are welloff but are availing reservations...their properties should also be re examined 🤘
She already used the OBC Card to get into Medical college
System sucks
If she was from EWS, you would've shut yourself.
EVERY IAS AND IPS OFFICER IN THIS COUNTRY MUST MAKE A PUBLIC DECLARATION OF THEIR INCOME AND ASSETS OWNED BY THEM. EACH AND EVERY OFFICER WILL BE FOUND GUILTY. GUARANTEE 100%
They do
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
All certificates should be investigated
Say no to RESERVATION
Binami ...they don't need to show..
The FRAUDSTER should be FIRED from IAS.
Very professional anchor... doesn't shout or interrupt during the show. We need more anchors like him...most news debates are just a shouting match. Vineet is well mannered, good voice modulation, other channels can learn a lot from him.
100 crore OBC IAS . Ghatia constitution and judges .
She may be groom up the way which reflects her such nefarious mindset. She comes from super rich family and father is retired IAS definitely dishonest, power misuser, system dishonoured personality while was in power. She probably got through this environment.
She shall immediately removed from the service to uplift the image of burocracy
Our country systems are truly unique comedy show compared to rest of the world😂😂😂
Blame the govt
That's why people wants to leave country because here powerful people can do anything according to their needs....fake disability and fake obc Ncl certificate by using their power and became IAS😅 all the rules and regulations are for poors
Shame. No one knows how many more skeletons.
Cancel reseevation on caste.
Only economic background
She was apprehended due to her foolishness in demanding everything and drawing attention to herself. I am concerned about how many other IAS and IPS officers are similar to her and have not yet been caught.
Her father should be investigated. How can he earn so much wealth by honest means
Everyone in India knows that bureaucrats acts like master of the country after politicians. Only a minority might be honest and work with humility. Majority might be drunk in power. The Delhi case where IAS couple wanted the stadium empty which is there for athletes to practice just because the IAF couple wanted to walk with their dog. It's a rotten system with colonial hangover.
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
Not IAF but IAS
full family is fraud...and she acts innocent...how cunning
Her family members come from civil service background. It is possible that they use their influence either through their seniors, batch-mates or juniors. Public sector needs to implement punishment policies like private sector. Public sector has serious accountability issue. Which is why we are third world country. Learn from Singapore, how their bureaucracy works.
Exactly!!! Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
People of India 🇮🇳 How many people think enough is enough. With OBC ST and other caste Benefits .Really tired of it 😪
🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳 Whosoever is governing the country will never ever think of wiping out this strong tool of reservations to be in power. That's why people who have the capability, intelligence and resources are moving out of this country.🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
She might have gotten away with it if she wasn't so greedy and entitled. There's a lesson in this whichever angle you view it from.
IAS have Maharaja syndrome. Instead of serving public they want public to serve them.
90% of ias ips etc r corrupt n maleficent only 10% r honest n r sidelined
These fraud one's are not real aspirants.. they buy Jobs..
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
System is gamed
Lots of Pujas
Fake SC ST Certificate
Lots of them amass wealth beyond their means and income
Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
India mai
Paisa bolta hai babu....
Chahe Porsche case ho
Chahe NEET Exam ho
Chahe UPSC exam ho
Ram Rajya hai bhai....
Her mbbs should also be checked how she got into medical college and did mbbs 😊😊😊she should be jailed
Her father is an activist of Obc reservation
He also should be investigated for curuption of 40 crores during govt. Job😢😢
Sarjana Yadav AIR 126 UPSC CSE 2019 Father: IES, Superintending Engineer, ESIC.
Initially UPSC rejected her candidature and did not allocate any post due to dubious OBC NON CREAMY LAYER CERTIFICATE, as father was a directly appointed Group A officer (apart from private earnings). But she went to CAT and was mysteriously allocated to IAS
Official property 40 CR ,! Real property 1000 CR
Forgery caste certificates are common among job seekers many persons depromoted in PSU. They should scrutiny of certificates of 10 years ias ips ifs batches. strict criminal action to be taken
For all government jobs
@@vikrampuri5613 They depromoted in PSU that's all.
Her father has 100 cr rupee. SHe doesn't need job.
They need power. Entire ancient and inefficient bureaucratic system needs huge reforms from its candidate selection process to public service delivery. We the people can remove corrupt incompetent politicians through democratic elections. But corrupt incompetent UPSC officers cannot be removed and have lack of accountability to the public.
She's supposed to be physically, mentally disabled. Eyesight impaired. 100 cr not enough as dowry with so many deficiencies.
With all her misdemanors still not arrested and not even suspended! Our system sucks!
After Pune Porsche case, now IAS muck... where are we going?
The thing is it's very difficult to suspend a corrupt officer after he or she getting into higher services like IAS, IPS.
Handicap certificate is important to crack upsc mpsc
Dismiss and jail her
Upsc should now Investigate all candidates who got admission using caste or low income certificates
The system does not appreciate sincere hardworking people!
There is lot of issues ..Just think if she can fake PWD /OBC for IAS.. what about other govt jobs and educational institute...I know few guys who have got jobs/educational institutional(IIT/NIT) with fake OBC and EWS even though they are very well off and quite rich..there is no way to verify it...I even know few people who can provide this certificates for 10k Rs..it is very sad but true..
Charge her for fraud
There are laws but they are never enforced specially in case of govt servants and also corrupt politicians!
How can any politician or any ruling government(BJP, CONGRESS) stop corruption when 50 percent of d system especially IAS,IPS officers r corrupt n it's actually not known to anybody
our country is really messed up may god help us.
thanks to our courts too through their judgements they prevents transparency in the exam.
This old system should be abolished
Why do you showing that she belong to family dedicated to public service? It is more like they looted the public and become stinking rich!!
" Aditi hi Nisha hai, Parr Nisha toh Munni hai ". - Bhagam Bhag (2006)
This is shows how bad the whole system is.
Only transfer 😂😂 madam ची तर lottery लागली . आरक्षणामुळे कुठे नेऊन ठेवलाय देश माझा
Transfer tya misbehaviour mule zaliye..ata sgli paala Kula nightil ..hopefully Tila kayamch dismiss krtil😊
IAS and IPS have becomes a joke..all you need to do is check up on retired officers and see what assets they actually have. Not saying all of them are bad but a distressing number of them are...something a poor country like India cannot afford..
His Father also investigated that how he earned 40 crores from govt. Job😢😢
An IAS officer can earn worth assets 40 crores 116 acres of land 6 plots and 7 flats , audi car, Jewels etc. My God. That is why people crazy on IAS, IPS.
🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳 Mr Peer has very rightly said that why this lady was given reservation when her family background is very rich with her father worth 40 crores. Why she was not considered in creamy layer.
Why the government make a data to offer the reservation to one member one family on the basis of which the concept of reservations came into being. But it was never done, the voting tool. Its so disgusting.🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Without checking validity of Multi disability and OBC, how can UPSC can issue appointment order?
when this much of negligence is going on UPSC , what about rest of selection of jobs
The whole creamy layer stipulation is prone to fraud. The whole reservation system must be reviewed and revised.
The quotas shld be given only 4 economically deprived. Y rich ppl(no matter what community)need quotas at all? Then yu collect income tax based on income n not based on community now? I don't understand this logic at all.
Very well conducted by the anchor, giving chance to each of the speakers to express their views. Us viewers would appreciate such debates rather than those where speakers talk over each other. So, well done NewsX!
Her conduct raises a doubt whether she passed her medical course honestly and UPSC exam honestly. There is power in the hands of the government. She can be dismissed by the President without any enquiry. Previously there is one precedence of dismissal by the President of India. I am unable to remember since it happened long back and I am Eighty years old.
Only transfer ? Sumit sir is right 👍
Mera question ye h ki uska medical test may 2022 me hua joki 2021 exam ke anusar
But 2022 ke exam m isko 821 rank Mila h jiska medical test may 2023 m hona tha.
Vo ku nhi hui or agar hua bhi galat ku pakad nhi hua.
Nothing will happen to Pooja.. Only people will shout on channels.. Aise to kitne IAS guse hoye honge..
Strong action
Well said Mr Sumit.
Pujaji thanks for the information for becoming an I.A.S officer
Soon I will become an i.a.s officer.
Sir wat r u saying , civil service rule this country,they are the bosses! Action should be taken against all people opposing this officer for insulting the govt servant
Fire her...she cheated....and gets a transfer...shocked
I am fully agree with Jyotikaji. These people still live in colonial era. We are changing colonial many systems, but why are we not changing this IAS systems?
Zyadatar Sarkari Log sarkari naukari isliye karte hain ke koi kaam nahin karna pade.
Good, learned lawyer on the show. Well said, Arrest her, her father..
Our Janta Money is being used for these baster*&&&&
We should start our Corrupt, Supreme Court, Hight Court, Advocate, Janta Ke Naukar and Janta ke Sewak
Mr. Dhananjay, integrity is something you are not putting a premium on! A person who is supposed to honestly govern a district/ department must be above these accusations! In the private IT company I worked in, a General Manager of 20 years of service was visibly suspended for submitting false medical bills! Genuine bills pertaining to his mothers illness- but outside the purview of company policies
Friends, most of the time OBC non creamy layer certificates are subjective. As per governent order the children of
officers entered as class1 officers come under creamy layer of OBC though they are from OBC. Meaning these candidates come under general category only. The status of their parents when they entered the service is the only criterion to know whether one comes under cremy layer or non creamy layer, ever after the retirement of their parents no change. It means though one belongs to OBC, but entered in gov as class1 begore 36 years of age, then his/her children will be under creamy layer permanently.
Now class1 officer and other similar officers in university, college, psu, bank etc mapping is given. Here subjectivity comes in through kickoff.
I entered the goverment service through CES examination of UPSC in 1985 as a class1 officer. Though I belong to OBC, my son could not get OBC reservation as he is coming under creamy layer as per gov order. However the son of my relative a retired professor of aided college could get selected under OBC category. Its all in the hand of official issuing the creamy layer certificate.
If Redkar can manipulate documents, there may be other unidentified cases that have quietly been absorbed into the system. It's crucial to investigate all potential instances to maintain trust in the system.
These IASS is a big joke .....should be scrapped....trust is gone over years...
Ms Basu speaks from the top of her head. She should prepare much better before appearing on a panel. Otherwise, she should shut up.
Haven't seen such ignorance and superficial knowledge.
She struggles to create one sentence properly.
That spine of India is completely broken under Modi🐈🐈⬛🐶🐕🦮🐕🦺
कुछ नही होने वाला 😄देख लेना, फ्रॉड होने के बावजूद उसे अभी पोस्टिंग मिला है, समझ गये 😄 मेरा देश महान 🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺
Suspended her
The funny thing is no one raised even an eyebrow when her father declared his assets when running for elections. Declaring assets is one thing, trying to find how people in public office get those assets should be scrutinized. Big brother seems to be watching only those who are not in the "creamy layers."
No system is screwed up
because of shameless officers like her, other officers are also stereotyped. strict action must be taken against her
One more such case just 2 years back . One Ips demanded Biryani free from thehotels under her area jurisdiction.what happens to her . Is there Any action on her
Nice question 😂 put garland and give her promotion
Her father must be complicit in this 😅
Sumit peer has put the right question that the khedkar lady is already settled. Now did she need reservation when she having lot of family's like khedkar should give up reservation for needy and capable.
He is right
GOV job must be 5 PC CTC
Will save 5 lakh CR monthly
Use that to reduce
Petrol
Diesel
Gas
Electricity
Veg
Food
Medicine price for 143 CR
1 family max 1 GOV job
That's true SABKA SAATH SABKA VIKAS
1 SC ST OBC EWS benefit per family
70% India have SC ST OBC EWS
If you seek VOTE from all families give job to all FAMILY
Not all reservation to 1 family
That's biggest SCAM
Right now, speak about this lady... and thru her various alleged misdeeds, speak about every step that has been misused and abused
Media debates would only make the enquiry comitee richer.
Medical seat also she would have taken on falls certificate,
Gone Into The Blue's !
As long as media is corrupt and political , any one can misuse any thing. Even mental person can become an IAS officer and we do not have how many IAS mentals are still in power?????
UPSC LOST ITS CREDIBILITY.WHY SHOULD WE PREPARE IF THE EX SERVICES CHILD HAVE BACK ENTRY
This is 60 yrs consequences.
I would like to request Honourable CJI Mr Chandrachuda sir and honourable SC as a whole to take a look at the whole reservation system for riview to know whether it acting for the real people it is meant for.
Everybody should think about the Reservations how it is misusing
why did they even let this cheat in?
Central Administrative Tribunal is like Hon Supreme Court ? Worst elements get all sympathy empathy humanitarian grounds leniency opportunity to reform
Now these r not 5% but 50 %
That breaking news in the bottom is funny. Now even RBI (demonetizer) and SBI (electoral bonds collaborator) considers pakora selling a job😂
Leave Pooja. Focus on UPSC, SSC, DOPT, CSS. You will find biggest issues. Can Media do??/ Can you bring out?? I doubt. You people can just attack on single person or a family only.
I will leave india as soon as i get enough money, i cant tolerate negativity and events happening in India
100 cr is not a small amount.. 😂
What about our honorable, speakers daughter
Wil she be punished or as usual , money wil make them win
See how Fmr Principal secretary defending her😂
How one can read titles and writings which you change so quickly ? This is mockery of viewers. At first place think over it that why are you presenting news in writings?
No action against her, bcoz of our Excellent system , UPSC Board also like a Big Joke in this country