LED vs CFL Bulbs
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 май 2013
- This video by www.illustralighting.com compares an LED light bulb to CFL in terms of durability, light quality, costs, efficiency, health risks, and eco-friendliness.
Visit our blog: www.illustralighting.com/blog for the latest in LED lighting technology as well as guides and how-tos information regarding LED technology and LED lighting. 
Наука
Excellent video. It's clear, informative and to the point. Everything you talked about was relative and information that I needed. Thank you very much. Thumbs up!
Gradually changing my CFL's to LEDs in my house.
Thank you. I learned more about light bulbs than school has ever taught!
I have watched approximately 20 videos pertaining to CFL and LED lighting and I've got to say that you successfully condensed multiple hours worth of videos into 4 minutes and I think there was even some new information. Great Video!!!!! This is where I will direct anyone in the future who has basic questions on the subject. (otherwise I'll spend an hour fumbling out an answer myself and likely confuse them in the process)
was thinking the same thing man.. nice video.
Excellent introduction to bulbs.
Great video! Easy to understand. Thank you
Great video with the right arguments versus CFL. People have to much the idea that CFL bulbs are the best option in regards to savings and efficiency. Thank you
great vid to give me an intro to these LED bulbs
Some of the newer LEDs do emit light in all directions. Search for "Phillips LED" on Amazon and you will find some very good ones. The Slim Line one is pretty good and cheap too.
great, easily understood info. Thanks for explaining CRI - I wondered what that # meant!
I have been running 8W LEDs globes at home (and just replaced half of them back to CFL) the CFL might use twice the power as an LED but it is twice as bright. i found it hard to read, cook, etc with the low output of a LED light (well the 8W models)
Thanks. I appreciate the no hype straightforward information. Very helpful.
Good video with helpful information!
thank you this video was really important, I'm giving you credit in my bibliography when I upload my video :D
Just bought a 3 way LED bulb, 30, 60, 100...something like that, cost $25 + tax!!!! It was an impulse buy as my hardware store had a huge display going on, I will say I'm very happy with it.
Very very helpful.. This almost save my life.. I can't tell how helful it is... Wow.. Thanks a lot...
Great video. Can you post a video or chart about comparing Incandescent wattage to convert to led watts/lumens?
As I shop for LED bulbs, they label the wattage but not always the lumens, so I am having a hard time figuring out what an 8 watt light is in comparison to in an incandescent bulb.
Thanks
There is nothing better than incandescent Reveal light bulbs.
very useful. THANK YOU!
very informative!
thnx!
Very nice RUclips. Still I have a fine point question. Do LED's distort color? I've been in the
residential design industry for years and notice a certain loss of nuanced color features
from LED can lights...a dulling of color. The task lighting feature is excellent but
seeing custom paint color diminished by the LED light is less than desirable. Any product testing on this area of the LED function? Thank you.
VERY informative and we'll explained!
Whatever CFL manufacturers claim, CFLs burn out way faster than their rated lives, at least for me. In fixtures that see a lot of on-off use (kitchen, bedrooms, bathroom), they can die in less than a year. I know they'll last longer if you leave them on for up to four hours at a time, but then you're not actually saving any energy over an old 60W bulb you can flick on and off in 30 seconds with no worries. I for one welcome the incoming LED master race.
I switched to LEDs primarily because when I walk into a room and hit the switch I don't want to wait minutes for the bulb to hit full brightness. The Cree LEDs are amazing..
Haha... new wifi led bulbs released, CCT and brightness adjusting by a remote controller or your smart phone app.
Im gonna put these for my exterior lightning. I have 7 of these, and im planning on letting them run 24-7. I estimate the cost of electricity to less than 2.50$ per month! Also perfect for the cold weather! Im a big fan of cfl, i have some in my lightpost outside that are on for a couple years without failing now. Firsttime im buying led to replace the incandescent spots that i never turn on.
I got a camera without UV filtering *smirks* Mmm so I can make pictures of IR and UV. And well I did test it out and my LED bulb.. nothing. Nothing at all just normal light. My CFL bulb .. oh a lovely purplish stream of something poured out. That lovely purple is the color of UV/IR on the foveon sensor.
A rather cool experiment.
Awesome video.
Wow, a savings of $1.50 per year? Need me some LED bulbs!
No he's stupid, my box I bought says $1.50 3hrs/day for 1 year is what it would cost to run the led bulb.
luckycharms8282 very good. i'm led star
Dear Friends：
We are a professional China's high-power LED lighting manufacturers ,
We want to have the best price and high quality , with your cooperation
LED T8 tubes, LED bulbs , LED mining lamp,LED High Bay Light
come to our Alibaba AliExpress shop now!
www.aliexpress.com/store/1407617
Better quality, faster delivery , transport faster, more secure payments
LED Small wholesale sellers
Waiting for you to come and have a surprise！
You can contact us through QQ: 361302987
Mail : szyfyrk@163.com
Or station letter
From China
Ren Kevin No, we all want free lights. :)
Thanks for the video
Thank you for the video
Heat is definitely related to design and the manufacturer. Illustra LED globes are not going to burn anyone, even after being on all night. I know I test them!
What application uses a 500 watt halogen bulb? That's pretty big! Generally only about 100W of LED would be needed to replace 500W of Incandescent light output - and a 100W LED heat sink isn't too big.
Whats tough at the moment is getting LED to replace 1000W HID (for car dealerships etc) - but even that is more and more common
Yeah it can depend on the fixture the A19 globe is in. If that fixture doesn't trap too much light the CFL can be brighter. But also some LED globes have low lumens per watt, and be on the lower end of LED efficacy.
I would also like to mention that the LED Globes still get very hot (nearly burnt myself on a Phillips heat sink after it had been on for an hour) (8W LED non dimmable)
I'm gradually switching over to all-LED just so that I can avoid the mercury!
dose it look like I'm petrified of mercury?
+Nicholas “The Warionator” Martin I already broke a CFL light bulb (more like shattered) as it exploded into a million pieces around the kitchen and dining room when it fell and I have kids... We simply banned the kids to their bedrooms and swept and mopped every nook and cranny and disposed of it. Cant afford a Hazmat team and we are all ok.
But the light try to aim at one straight direction only.
I don't have a single bulb that's not LED in my apartment. I mean they're like 4 bucks for a pack of 2 at walmart
Hi Polly,
We're sorry to hear about this incident. Maybe we could help!
GlassGuard specialises in shatterproof lamps, keeping food and children safe. Check out our website for more details: glassguard.co.uk/
I had looked in all 7 stores in town and did not find one led bulb under $25, I do not know where you shop, but I want to :)
For sure most LED bulbs are still over $20 retail. But CFL's most commonly replace the household A19 Incandescent bulb. And in Home Depot at least, the LED A19 from CREE is $10.
When it comes to light output per dollar - that is one of the best LED bulbs on the market.
If I take the 5000k LED bulb (Pure cool white)....over time will it lose that cool white colour??
Great love this!
Thank you
Which color temprature creates more shadow becoz i would to use the lights in video shooting which creates less shadow
shadow is more a function of the direction of a light source. If you want less shadow, you should use more light sources in differing directions. Basically, shadows are cast when one object stands in between a light and another object (on which the shadow is cast). if you light behind and around the shadow casting object, you're more likely to eliminate the shadows, or at least greatly reduce them.
THANKS!
Been waiting for LED technology to be able to produce the same white temperature as CFL, but they still can't do it. I think they look weird still, either too warm yellow or too cold blue. If you buy something equivalent to "bright white" the Kelvin is wrong so it looks weird. LED technology is still struggling to produce a neutral white too.
when i first purchase my house 2 years ago, i replaced all the incandescent lightbulbs with cfls. I noticed the electric bill difference right away, i wonder if i change to leds will i see a big difference. I know leds are still very expensive, hopefully in a couple of years the price will go down.
they need to come down alot more in price before it's worth switching from CFL to LED. Give it a few more years, just keep the CFL till they burn out and replace them with LED when that happens, definitely don't remove a working bulb, the savings aren't as dramatic as the 75% reduction in power usage from switching from an incandescent to a CFL.
When I first heard about led bulbs I thought $15 for a bulb. But when they finally hit $12 I bit and got 2 for my desk area as I kept getting headaches and was having problems focusing on printed text or info on the computer. After a week my headaches stopped (I don't think I have had a headache in almost a year now while working when I used to get one at least once a week.) Also the light seemed dimmer, but I could read better. LED's are difficult to put in a living room because they do focus the light in a directional way. We ended up getting a light box on opposite walls and bouncing the light off the ceiling gives a much better "general lighting"
1:52 Get your facts right, it's $1.50 to run 3hrs/day for one year. According to what the box says that bulbs came in.
so good video , led light is the trend in the future. we are professional led lighting factory .
it's very interesting :)
It's true that for the standard household shape (A19) the strongest LED bulbs are only replacing 60W incandescent. But soon, very soon. ALL LED is only getting stronger in light output, longer in lifetime, and cheaper in price!
10dls per bulb is a bit pricey. Most of what I looked for online list around 6usd, but I think you need to buy in a bulk.
LEDs aren't "instant on". I installed LED Vanity lights that took about half a second to turn on after flipping the switch.
the new leds are but my old ones take a few seconds!
John Caldwell Ah, and what caused that?
It is the driver
How come no halogen comparison? Safest of all.
10 dollars for an led? Here in Canada I bought a pack of three light for under 3 dollars at Canadian Tire this spring
cfl also has bad cos Phi, and inefficient drivers making the real power consumption higher than stated
M Goudsmits Incorrect in most 1st world countries which regulate such things. An inefficient driver would make the CFL bulb still use the stated wattage but would produce less light.
However, the same thing happens with LED bulbs. The cheaper ones, especially generic brands, tend to use less efficient drivers so they have lower lumens per wattage. Cheap bulbs often have only 50 to 70 lumens per watt while modern major brand LED bulbs today have about 80+ lumens per watt. Future readers, take note of the date. Next year these numbers will be higher and then higher the next year and so on.
CFL bulb efficiency will not rise much more but LED bulb efficiency will continue to climb slowly for at least the next few years as great advancements have been made in recent years and there is no reason to believe that will stop soon.
Stinky Cheese you say : An inefficient driver would make the CFL bulb still use the stated wattage but would produce less light. yes so relative higher power consumption I said.
80+ lumens per watt, is no longer the standard, most led's and LED strips and Lamps using pcb mounted LED that I work with have 120 to 130 lumens per Watt
M Goudsmits It's all about context. 80+ lumens is the standard for affordable light bulbs. A light bulb is an integrated product with losses from the driver circuit accounted for and derated for heat lumen reduction, the phosphor dome, globe, and sometimes a reflector.
It is never accurate to just use the LED spec sheet value instead of the actual measured lumen output of a product!
Sure, there are LEDs with 200 lumens/watt now but then you integrate them into a product and make it into something cost effective that people want to buy, THEN measure the lumens. You seem to be unfamiliar with LED light bulbs to not realize the truth in my statement about 80+ lumens, today... next year the figure will be higher and the next year higher still.
Stinky Cheese have no idea why youst start this discussion unless you wanna claim cfl is better than LED
M Goudsmits
It's not about which is better, it's about clear, accurate information which you were drifting away from with comments like the suggestion that inefficient drivers are a concern with CFL when they are far more of a concern with generic LED bulbs.
There is a larger difference in efficiency between good and bad LED bulb drivers than between good and bad CFL unless you go back decades ago to early prototypes that had a huge linear double-line-frequency transformer driver output instead of a switching boost ballast circuit.
Many people already have CFL not only in use but a stock to replace those in use so the question can become at what point should people abandon and throw away perfectly working CFL lights and spend money to replace them with LED, particularly when good LED bulbs still cost ~ 4X as much as average CFL bulbs. Sadly there isn't a way to include average LED bulbs in the discussion because there is a very large divide between the quality of the bad and good LED bulbs, much more so than good and bad CFL because the good ones are only pennies more per bulb.
CFL is definitely not better than "GOOD" quality LED bulbs. The ones in this video aren't very good. 4' tube T8 fluorescent still beats all LED & CFL, except in high on-off cycling applications or very low temperatures a good LED bulb pulls ahead, but ironically enough in very low temperatures many people would be better off with incan bulbs to serve a double purpose as miniature space heaters.
shouldnt that light chart be: warm, cool, and daylight
just in case anybody cares CFL bulbs last a really long time if they stay on for long periods of time they're not like LEDs. I have a few CFL bulbs left that I use outside my home that are still going after 10 years because they're not frequent turned off and on. if that's the case for you. I would go with LEDs, LEDs will last a long time even if turned off and on. I like the daylight ones because they throw a cool bright color just an FYI.
Yeah i have some 5 watts cfl that are on for a few years! Just bought my first led lights, lets see !
insulationking congrats. I recommend the cool White.
Guy is cute. Wish they would import some over here in US.
great vid
I still don't know what i'm looking for in a lightbulb. I've always hated LED because it feels like 1. it's in everything 2. It's irritating to the eye
very good. i'm led star
My bulbs keep blowing every few weeks that's why I'm switching to led
Since this was recorded in 2013, it is not up to date. LED lights can cause irreparable damage to the retinas of persons who use LED lights. Check for yourself.
Color temperature actually has more visual affect on colors than CRI of lights.
Color temperature quite clearly affects rendered colors. A warm light just like the sunset will make things look yellow washed and not like you usually see them.
The sun has a higher color temperature of midday than at sunset or morning. Typically 5600k as midday and as low as 2000k at sunset and morning.
CRI is legit but generally color temperature has more of an effect on how things appear. At the end of the day true color is all relative as it all depends on the light source. No one can say what is the godly perfect light source. Who can really dictate what color temperature is "correct" heck other suns even have different color temperatures to ours and up in space our sun is a different color temperature as to what we experience down here under the atmosphere.
So......
CRI is when a white light appears white but in fact doesn't have equal amounts of frequencies. Thus when hitting something like a bowl of fruit one particular fruit may seem more vivid than the other because it has more available light in that spectrum to bounce back.
In no way does that mean it's correct or incorrect though. No such thing as correct light and objects really have no real color or brightness. It's all relative to the light source.
The amount of light reflected from them is in no way correct or incorrect. You could have a lot of light bouncing off or only a little or then in the middle. Nowhere is "correct".
7 YO video (now 2020), so LEDs are even more advantageous, as the price advantage of CFLs are even less.
How did this get in my recamended xD
If Thomas Edison was Alive he would really do his best making a Movie that tells how bad LED Lights would be and that will make Nikola Tesla laugh. HAHAHAHAHHAHA
What are you on about? While Edison did invent the Incandescent bulb, Tesla didn't invent the LED. And just because Edison invented the incandescent bulb doesn't mean he would be against all other bulbs.
I'm not saying that Tesla invented the LED bulbs, I'm just saying how Thomas Edison would hate to know that some other bulbs is Better than his Incandescent Bulb, it was like How Thomas Edison made an Advertisement about how bad and Dangerous AC Generators are by Electrocuting a living Elephant, And just because Nikola Hates Edison and so as Edison to Tesla and that the very reason I included Tesla.
David Irving Edison didnt invent the incandescent light bulb. He robbed lots of peoples inventions and took credit fro them himself. Joseph Swan invented it.
John Cleeve It's known Edison actually did not invent incandescent light bulb.
+Conor -last white hope- Steroids Edison was a business man that would buy inventions.
he looks like vitalyzdtv
I hope the LED lights doesn't have lead in them.
But I often eat smart phones O.O
Actually, the diodes in LED bulbs have toxic chemicals in them. But they're in solid form, & not as much as in a compact floro bulb. So they're easier to dispose of & easier to contain if broken.
just like every electronic device. Most semiconductor electric components have boron and phosphorus in them
Nothing compared to a Fluorescent tube having mercury and emitting pure UV light that emits with a coating on the glass.
LED's have some phosphorus. Wow. Eviiiiiil. lol.
By that logic you should not even but any electronic device as virtually all have something that isn't totally safe to eat. Such as most batteries, Or even lead solder on a PCB, lol.
But to compare those things to Fluorescent tubes it's quite the same. Fluorescent tubes are just nasty in most ways.
@@Leonelf0 Germanium?
@@calvinkulit germanium also uses boron, phosphorus and arsenic as dopants.
1) 50% of CFL light isn't trapped in a can light because they make BR30 CFL for this purpose with reflector integrated. You might say you were comparing a different bulb style but this apples to apples because the BR30 LED version would be the one used properly in the can lights. Ironically a few seconds later your can downlight example even had a BR30 bulb in it!
2) LED bulbs today don't just point their light down. There are ample designs out there where they achieve nearly 360' illumination.
3) A 15W CFL would produce significantly more light, around 800 lumens while the 7W and 8W A19 bulbs you offer are only 450-480 lumens. If lesser light is acceptable then a lesser wattage CFL would be too. The LED bulbs ARE more efficient, but not nearly as much as implied in the video and there are MUCH more efficient LED bulbs available in the market.
4) Nobody is actually getting 50K hours out of LED bulbs in typical use scenarios. Components like capacitors inside most are only rated for about 3K to 10K hours but manufacturers are being despicable in only rating for the LED life when it's one of the last components in the bulb to fail on its own without an upstream component failure to blame.
5) The CFL equivalent is not $4. I can get them for $1 to $2 each or the local electric company is giving them away free. Granted, since the making of the video, prices on LED bulbs have dropped greatly too so for something as essential as lighting, any other parameter would be a better one to focus on rather than cost. Energy savings of either swamp the rest when converting from incandescent bulbs.
6) Drawback myths:
- There is barely any mercury in modern CFL. Exposure levels if broken would be lower than eating a tuna fish sandwich.
- Durability? Perhaps in some unique situations but the average person seldom breaks light bulbs.
I am not arguing that CFL is superior, not at all. There are great LED bulbs out there which I prefer to CFL but only if I'm being picky. Those bulbs have enough merit that people don't need to mislead in order for their advantages to be obvious.
Why LED's are more expensive, maybe because they perform just better? OLED might use even less energy.
LED's light bulbs are still more expensive because research and development for high-quality bulbs are made, also, LED need heat sinks (the metal fins under the light, which are usually made from aluminum) because these semiconductors are prone to too much heat, just like computer processors. That increases the costs as well.
Now another problem is the market. They just aren't pushing LED's that much yet.
LED - main perpendicular maara
CFL - main tangent maara
LEDs really seem like a no brainier to me. They're the most efficient, least likely to malfunction and burn your house down, don't generally contain toxic materials, and last so much longer.
That is not my experience , all the CFLs that i have still work , all the LEDs that i got , died , only 1 remains and that one buzzes now so im sure its going to die soon .Also your face is green , so its not hard for me to see that it is a bad light , its not a tungsten light , that was a LED light for video . And clearly i can see it , what is more important is skin , its most seen in the skin . So if you want perfect skin , there is no substitute for tungsten . Sadly .
50, 0000 Hrs are really BS!
The cool white and neutral white bulbs makes a house look cheap and ugly.
Incandescent for me, please. LED sucks