FF7 Rebirth - Who Is Cloud Strife's Dad? Is It Glenn Lodbrok From First Soldier/Ever Crisis?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 97

  • @Clouds12012
    @Clouds12012 29 дней назад +5

    Glenn being Cloud father reflects and fits perfectly into everything we already know about the entire game's lore.
    I dont care about the few people in the comments saying they hate it cuz its "too predictable". Its only predictable because it fits so perfectly and also interwoven story plots of FF7 are not about their relationship anyway so there is literally no reason to hate Glenn being Clouds father.
    Someone said they want Cloud to be another one of Shinra's illegitimate kids but that would devalue Cloud as a character and overly convolute the story.
    Glenn being Cloud's dad would move the story along more naturally while the main plot can continue to move with the new additional interwoven aspects expanding the original story instead of complicating things further (Shinra being Cloud father would over complicate the story cuz we would have to tie up that loose end later) While Cloud and Glenn being family is simple enough to work it out in maybe a conversation in the game and maybe a reveal scene later.

  • @TheWorstPartyMember
    @TheWorstPartyMember 7 месяцев назад +4

    At risk of being crucified by the fandom, I can think of a few interesting ideas Glenn being Cloud's father could bring to the story. I would be totally down to see it become true. But I also don't think Cloud needs to meet and have a relationship with him. Best way to handle it would be to reveal it to the audience, but Cloud himself doesn't ever need to learn the truth.

  • @AdamBrewster
    @AdamBrewster 7 месяцев назад +12

    I think the factor which could be the most convincing (for me at least) with pointing to Glen as Cloud’s dad is a bit indirect, but bear with me:
    In Crisis Core, there’s the whole issue with Genesis/Angeal getting Jenova cells but not being as “perfect” of specimens - but Sephiroth, who was born of Jenova-infused Lucretia, was a “better specimen.”
    Hojo initially wrote Cloud off as a failed experiment, but was surprised when he turned out to be a better “specimen”…
    What if the reason is the Glenn - already mako-infused soldier passed along mako-infused genetic material when he was with Claudia, so when she gave birth to Cloud, his body was better adapted to take on Jenova cells/Sephiroth cells when Hojo later experimented on him?
    It’s admittedly convoluted, but narratively, it tracks/mirrors other things we already know about characters in the game…

    • @theargawalathing
      @theargawalathing 7 месяцев назад +2

      I actually really appreciate your thought through all of that, and it matches the logic of how Sephiroth was able to ingest Jenova cells easier via Lucrecia's pregnancy.

    • @DonShotta24
      @DonShotta24 7 месяцев назад +1

      Won’t work as Glenn was not Mako infused

    • @theonlyryotking
      @theonlyryotking 3 месяца назад

      The reason why Cloud was comatosed after Zack reacues him, is because he has had no previous expoaure to Mako, unlike Zack who is a 1st class S Soldier. Angeals mother(Gillian)had Jenova implanted DNA, Genesis was introduced to Gillian post birth, but Sephiroth, under Hojo and Lucretias gaze, was injected with Jenova cells as a fetus, which maybe qhy Lucretia had pains, because it was degrading her baby, thus why he is born with Silver hair like Jenova, but the others degrade and get silver hair as they do so.

    • @theonlyryotking
      @theonlyryotking 3 месяца назад

      Also, Glenn, Matt, and Lucia are Passive 0/P:0 Soldiers, which means they havent had any unorganic alterations made to them unlike G and S Class Soldiers. So, even if Glen were Clouds father theres still no pre-mako/pre-jenova infusion there.

  • @BradPiper1977
    @BradPiper1977 7 месяцев назад +4

    Great video David, I'm learning new things. FF7 Parts 3 is sure to spin up more drama on this subject. The general opinion from the audience and other content creators is that people don't want the subject addressed, they want Square to leave it alone. However, we don't know how they spin the story, they could spin the story into crap, or they could turn it in some legendary plot twist nobody saw coming. It could be epic, like the spin in Bioshock "Would You Kindly..."

  • @eddstrife241
    @eddstrife241 7 месяцев назад +6

    Maybe the real reason why tifas dad tells cloud to stay away from her is because he’s clouds dad too.

  • @TravaillesDuChanson
    @TravaillesDuChanson 7 месяцев назад +8

    Have you read the short story about Cloud that they recently published? The interesting tidbit of information in that story is it talks about 2000 Gill. That is a reference to Cloud using 2000 Gill as a price and then Glenn having used 2000 gil believe at some point? There was mention about Claudia in the story from what I've heard and people have mentioned it is another piece of this whole puzzle. Obviously you should read it when you get the chance.

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +2

      I have seen some quick translations of the story but idk that I’ve seen everything. If there’s a 2,000 Gil thing with Glenn that would kinda solidify I’d say.

    • @TravaillesDuChanson
      @TravaillesDuChanson 7 месяцев назад +3

      @@DashingDavid Once there is evidence then of course then the question would be is why did he leave Claudia? Was it of his own will or another situation?

  • @bigcob85
    @bigcob85 6 месяцев назад +1

    New first soldier chapters released last night. Good stuff 👍

  • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
    @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 6 месяцев назад +3

    It makes perfect harmonic sense I like the idea. Where did he get the strength to fight or be a mission wildcard? Not just the S cells and mako but the soldier induced and heavy lifting weaponry genetics.

  • @ApexCalibre
    @ApexCalibre 6 месяцев назад +2

    People don't understand that if this is true, that means Sephiroth has history with both Cloud's parents.
    And that he will always be tormenting the son of his once good friend.

  • @88killerific
    @88killerific 7 месяцев назад +12

    Cloud's dad doesn't need to have any greater importance in the story other than having died when he was young, like Tifa's mum. Maybe to help explain why he was socially awkward/loner, but that's it. The most we should get is a cherished childhood memory of him before he passed, to make his passing a core character building event for cloud. I don't think there should be any more than that tbh.

    • @velvet_victor
      @velvet_victor 7 месяцев назад +1

      I agree. We don’t need to know who his dad is

    • @Mukation
      @Mukation 7 месяцев назад +1

      Yup, Cloud struggles with masculinity, which is common for kids raised without fathers.
      Who his dad is of no significance

    • @loregasmic
      @loregasmic 7 месяцев назад

      Wouldn’t make sense anyway. According to Cloud his mother had no issue with him joining SOLDIER. If his father was really Glenn I find it hard to believe she’d be cool with that. Same goes for if he was another bastard son of President Shinra.

    • @takotako808
      @takotako808 3 месяца назад

      Guessing all of you grew up without fathers 🤯🤯🤯. My dad was there until he passed away and id love to know who his father is...... Even if he was no one important

    • @88killerific
      @88killerific 3 месяца назад

      @@takotako808 how very presumptuous and disrespectful of you. My dad did pass away, but I didn't grow up without him...
      My opinion is based on the writers potentially doing a disservice to the story, and the main characters Cloud and Tifa, if they start to flesh out their dead parents more, seeing as they were written dead in the first place to give depth and commonality to those two.
      If they are fleshed out at all, it should be to emphasise how beloved they were to the protagonists, and to maximise the tragedy of their loss. Not to convolute the plot.

  • @DJChamber
    @DJChamber 7 месяцев назад +23

    A better twist would be if Glenn was yet another son of President Shinra, and Rufus discovers he actually killed his half brother in game 3. Glenn/Sephiroth also says "The plan is already in motion. Our promised land will become a reality. A father's dream, accomplished by his son." Nice twist if he is actually talking about himself maybe.

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +9

      Better is subjective but I wouldn’t hate that idea tbh. There’s definitely more to Glenn than what we’ve seen so far.

    • @rrs1669
      @rrs1669 7 месяцев назад

      Nah bruh that’s the usual generic type of storyline.

    • @dontacrowder4319
      @dontacrowder4319 7 месяцев назад +1

      I thought he was talking about Hojo, but just remembered Hojo didn't believe in a promised land.

    • @ETHomerin
      @ETHomerin 7 месяцев назад +1

      This was the impression I was actually getting during the game.

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад

      @@dontacrowder4319 nah he most likely talking about Rufus & President Shinra. But the line could be interpreted different ways.

  • @PetarBladeStrok
    @PetarBladeStrok 7 месяцев назад +3

    MJ is the man. But yeah. It seems Glenn will really end up Cloud's dad. People hate it and I'm not sure how I feel about it. I love Glenn's character in EC though. His relationship with Sephiroth is great.

    • @paleriderpalehorse55
      @paleriderpalehorse55 7 месяцев назад +2

      That's the thing, not a lot of people played EC. If they did, I think people would be interested in the idea of Clouds dad being someone who was like an actual father to Sephiroth in a way. That would bring the characters of Cloud and Sephiroth even more in parallel to each other. Sephiroth always felt like the dark reflections of Clouds aspiration and negative side of his own personal issues with identity and psychological health. They would be the most twisted pair of brothers.

  • @ChristianCaliberNetwork
    @ChristianCaliberNetwork 7 месяцев назад +1

    This could be the case, and the name of the weapon sounds like the word ignorant which would add towards cloud not knowing his father.

  • @brandonmeadows7972
    @brandonmeadows7972 7 месяцев назад +2

    You might think im crazy but I would rather Glenn be a clone of President Shinra created by Hojo as a SOLDIER prototype than have him be Clouds dad. Hell maybe Rufus is a President Shinra Clone too. Shinra backed out of it as soon as it was discovered soldiers cells degraded. Cant imagine President Shinra falling in love and fathering kids. Probably wanted to live forever and we know Hojo was experimenting with transferring consciousness in Deep Ground.

  • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
    @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 7 месяцев назад +2

    What next? Matt is Tifa's uncle because of red eyes ???
    EDIT: I'm beginning to get intrigued after you point out the birth years and generation of Glenn . I take back my sarcasm.

  • @greghaggerty9996
    @greghaggerty9996 7 месяцев назад +1

    God I hope not, that would be so dumb. I think the fact that Cloud is essentially a nobody is a big part of what makes his story so special. His dad being someone important would take away from that

  • @motionista
    @motionista 3 месяца назад +1

    I might be in the minority but I won’t really mind if Glenn is Cloud’s father. But I do think it would be more interesting if it is not fully confirmed, just like a bunch of hints scattered here and there. Of course having a noname dude as a dad is the best option in terms of Cloud’s uniqueness as a character, but if they wanted to actually introduce Cloud’s father, creating Glenn for that purpose would make sense.

  • @austinhensley5705
    @austinhensley5705 6 месяцев назад

    I kind of remember a scene when the group gets to the Corel reactor where Yuffie starts talking about Glenn and it almost kind of seemed to me like his name meant something to cloud. I’ll have to go back and replay it though

    • @cloudstruck2785
      @cloudstruck2785 5 месяцев назад

      I remember that bit too, I think Cloud says to Yuffie :"What did you say his name was?" as though he kinda vaguely recalls it.

  • @p4ndorA
    @p4ndorA 7 месяцев назад +2

    i like the idea and that everything lines up but i dont see the big payoff. if he would be related to shinra somehow it has more impact for rufus etc. if he would say cloud im your father clouds response in my head would be: not interested or whatever :D

  • @DoctorCarth
    @DoctorCarth 7 месяцев назад

    Don't know if it means anything but the Igneous Saber is one of Cloud's weapons in Evercrisis. I assume they just pulled from that in Rebirth but who knows.

  • @darryl7803
    @darryl7803 7 месяцев назад +2

    if Claudia loves Glenn so much, Cloud should be named Cloud Lodbrok instead of Cloud Strife

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +5

      Not necessarily. They didn’t have to be married. Also Cloud’s name has been established since 1997. And there hasn’t really been any lore for his dad until recent years. Like at all.

  • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
    @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 7 месяцев назад

    In Traces wasn't Cloud rendezvoused to Midgar via a helicopter pickup if I'm not mistaken? Special treatment for a reason? Could it mean Shinra knew him or his genetics and potential?

  • @ETHomerin
    @ETHomerin 7 месяцев назад

    I could see Glenn being one of Shinra's sons. I couldn't see him being Cloud's dad because such a lie would make Claudia less likable, and her death is the center of Cloud's trauma. But what if Glenn is actually a true experiment created in a lab with false memories, the way Sephiroth describes Cloud to be in OG, or what Genesis said Project S to be in CC? Cloud's dad could have been one of the makonoids used in making Glenn. A DNA lie with the truth to be thrown right at Cloud in the Whirlwind Maze when he doesn't want to be real.

  • @ForzaTerra89
    @ForzaTerra89 7 месяцев назад +1

    What’s that book mentioning clouds dad called? I wasn’t aware of that?

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +1

      Traces of Two Pasts
      www.amazon.com/Final-Fantasy-VII-Remake-Traces/dp/1646091779/ref=asc_df_1646091779/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=564732386341&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=9976634294890232922&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=1024290&hvtargid=pla-1641464294331&psc=1&mcid=24f05662c1843cb39379c158f095ca35&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI16WF_ZLkhQMVxEH_AR2pewghEAQYASABEgLXCvD_BwE

    • @ForzaTerra89
      @ForzaTerra89 7 месяцев назад

      @@DashingDavid oh wow, okay great. Thanks for posting.

  • @xcom54
    @xcom54 7 месяцев назад

    Sephiroth: "No, Cloud, I am your father."

  • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
    @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 7 месяцев назад +1

    I don't think so well I hope not because if Sephiroth has seen Star Wars then all he needs to do is get him in a Luke Skywalker style fit "I am your father hahahahaha" and it could all go Anakin-like and in puppet mode it will be Cloud' starring in Attack of the Clone.

    • @BradPiper1977
      @BradPiper1977 7 месяцев назад

      That's a great idea, putting the Anakin spin on the FF7 story - I like it!

    • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
      @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@BradPiper1977 stick to Star War lol!

  • @jordanlu8947
    @jordanlu8947 7 месяцев назад

    You guys all wrong, darth vader is the father, case closed

  • @OldManSakaki
    @OldManSakaki 7 месяцев назад

    I just like trolling Cloud fans on Twitter with this tbh lol

  • @ajinkyamore940
    @ajinkyamore940 7 месяцев назад +3

    Definitely he's not clouds dad during ever crisis event when sephiroth and Glenn teleported in nibelheim Glenn tells sephiroth he never visited this place that's means he's not clouds father

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +4

      Could have memory loss

    • @ajinkyamore940
      @ajinkyamore940 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@DashingDavidyes

    • @papertyga5056
      @papertyga5056 7 месяцев назад +3

      @@ajinkyamore940 false memories are a thing in ffvii, remember?

  • @flyaroundyourfire
    @flyaroundyourfire 7 месяцев назад +1

    Hi 🤓

  • @velvet_victor
    @velvet_victor 7 месяцев назад +4

    Well, I really hope not. That would be effing stupid

  • @docmanhattan7675
    @docmanhattan7675 7 месяцев назад

    Right just like Vincent is Sephiroths dads.
    We’ve been trying to turn FF7 into Maury since day one. I say leave it alone. Ngl I like the idea of Glenn being Rufus brother.

  • @DFTNSHEXGRM
    @DFTNSHEXGRM 7 месяцев назад +2

    When they announced the Remake trilogy, literally no one was asking “I hope they tell us who Cloud’s dad is!”. I’ve absolutely loved the Remakes and what they are doing with the story but god please no devs, don’t make Glen Cloud’s dad, it does absolutely nothing for the story. Leave his father a mystery. It definitely feels like the seeds have been planted and they can go that route if they want to, but god I hope not.

    • @michaeledwards1644
      @michaeledwards1644 7 месяцев назад +2

      everyone has to have parents, they showed Zack's and Aeriths.. why not Cloud and Sephiroth's?

  • @anthonybertuzzi9686
    @anthonybertuzzi9686 7 месяцев назад +1

    Cloud was able to stab Sephiroth because he had pre-emptive materia equipped to his buster sword ..... Seriously go look

  • @McLovinYoMuffin
    @McLovinYoMuffin 7 месяцев назад +1

    90% of the Re series is amazing…. but there are certain tropes in it that just take the air out of everything…. multiverse, cliche father crap…. How can they have such a incredible narrative in most of the games then throw out these grenades?

  • @Advorsaeresdocet
    @Advorsaeresdocet 7 месяцев назад +3

    God I hope we never find out 😂I’d rather it be Corneo TBH

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  7 месяцев назад +1

      LMAO wild ass comment 😅

  • @Koniving
    @Koniving 7 месяцев назад

    Extremely unlikely, because if we follow Glenn's story, yes, Glenn has been to Nibelheim in some side content in which he says he's never been there before.. He appeared there, and disappeared. But unless there was some time travel involved, he appeared there after 15 years ago, and Cloud is 20 years old.
    It is also worth noting that any time before his First Soldier journey into becoming a P0 soldier, he trained along the real Glenn Lodbrok, murdered him [as he himself failed the training] and took his identity. Prior to that, his job was to haul Ifalna around for tests in Hojo's lab.
    So... he never really had any time to knock Claudia up, and he showed up 5 years too late in some side content holiday event. The only thing they have in common is an obsession over 2,000 gil.
    What kept driving me nuts, is he looks like a ripoff of Rufus's model aged up, which gives me Lazard/Evan vibes, aka a brother-figure. He also looks kinda unlike First Soldier's Glenn? Maybe it's the cheek gaunt..

  • @NoctisStrife88
    @NoctisStrife88 7 месяцев назад +1

    Ehhhhhh I don’t think so. To my knowledge isn’t Cloud basically a sephiroth reject. According to Hojo. But hey this is FF. Lol we don’t care we just want more story

    • @nekogamer2508
      @nekogamer2508 7 месяцев назад +3

      He has an actual mother and was friends with Tifa

  • @AmorFati777X
    @AmorFati777X 6 месяцев назад

    I don't understand why everyone loves these stupid new characters so much. There are plenty of legacy carriers that are far better that get none of the attention and it just baffles me.

  • @SleepiZero
    @SleepiZero 6 месяцев назад

    Holy shit slow down when you talk bro chill the video ain't going no. Where lmao

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  6 месяцев назад +1

      Listen faster

    • @SleepiZero
      @SleepiZero 6 месяцев назад

      I have a disability and can't understand thing like

  • @martingomez3221
    @martingomez3221 6 месяцев назад

    Glenn is Cloud from the future obviously.

  • @Otis-Spunks
    @Otis-Spunks 7 месяцев назад

    I am not a fan of Jenova cells playing the sole role for Cloud's abilities because then we are looking at a skywalker-like scenario which I think cheapens the story.
    Thats not to say I don't want an inherited skill set. For example, my father is extremely handy and scientifically inclined, my mother is very artistic and musically inclined. As a result I am blessed with similar talents myself by trading both my carpentry and 3D art skills.
    Why not have Cloud's natural talent for combative skills, derive from his father, and not the experiments his father underwent? We know that SOLIDER candidates are required to have prerequisites before being inducted, surely the Type-0s were no different.
    As for whether or not Glenn is the missing daddy, I have no idea. What I can say is if Cloud's dad didn't matter then they would have found a body. To specifically note that no remains were found is a classic Chekhov's gun situation. You don't say something like that without the intention to elaborate later.

    • @sonic4life
      @sonic4life 7 месяцев назад

      I don't think Glen needs to be a reason for Cloud's prowess, especially since they use different weapons. Zack already covers the reason for Cloud's prowess.

  • @hom-sha-bom
    @hom-sha-bom 6 месяцев назад

    bro this aint ff8

  • @phillystevesteak6982
    @phillystevesteak6982 6 месяцев назад

    I'm honestly sick of every protagonist's parents having to be someone important or highly capable. At this point, it would be more interesting if we never found out, or if it was revealed his dad was just some dude.

  • @Advorsaeresdocet
    @Advorsaeresdocet 6 месяцев назад

    Can we just pretend he’s his own character and has nothing to do with cloud ? I’d rather Don corneo be clouds dad or president shinra then ardyn, I mean Glenn

    • @DashingDavid
      @DashingDavid  6 месяцев назад +1

      Astronomically bad take

    • @Advorsaeresdocet
      @Advorsaeresdocet 6 месяцев назад

      @@DashingDavid 😂 Shinra, corneo, or ardyn?

  • @JeremyNegerman
    @JeremyNegerman 7 месяцев назад

    Glenn lodbrock / cloud strife
    Last name don’t add up
    So I don’t think he is clouds father

    • @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897
      @xizilionyizzexeliqer3897 7 месяцев назад

      Mama Strife decided if he was going by the name Cloud Lodbrock he will grow up becoming depressed and that's before all that mako exposure and Sephiroth.