XL Voyager Meat Cut Test: Plain Edge Clip Point vs Serrated Vaquero

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 дек 2024

Комментарии • 71

  • @MarkedInBlack
    @MarkedInBlack 9 лет назад +32

    I made my kids watch the cuts just to show them why I keep telling them to respect sharp objects... that they are not toys, so to speak :)

  • @THEMERCIFULONE
    @THEMERCIFULONE 11 лет назад +5

    Great vid. I've been going nuts about serrations vs plain for the last six months!
    Some people say serrations will simply slide off clothing... but this test proved differently.
    Thx for taking the time for this test. Very helpful.

  • @mikkirurk1
    @mikkirurk1 8 лет назад +23

    No matter what you carry as long as you carry it everyday and everywhere. Still, there are 3 things to remember: *training, training, training.*

  • @PH-hk8mb
    @PH-hk8mb 8 дней назад

    Im impressed how well the plain edge did and you made alot of great points in the video

  • @TheStratman007
    @TheStratman007 2 года назад +6

    Outstanding presentation. Having been in executive protection for 25 years, I prefer the plain edge for one main reason. The serrated edge can and often snags on clothing. Each adversary is dressed differently. For bare skin, the serrated blade is beyond devastating.

    • @MB-jg4tr
      @MB-jg4tr 2 года назад +5

      I've seen a serrated vaquero go through 6 layers of denim effortlessly.

    • @xlilnetx
      @xlilnetx Год назад

      Maybe if you have been stuck in an office for most your life and have tiny chop stick arms hahaha 🤣

  • @dsbiddle
    @dsbiddle 10 лет назад +16

    "HELLO, 911? HEEEELP! SEND A COP CAR! NO, SEND THE WHOLE FORCE! CAN YOU GET THE NATIONAL GUARD HERE? IF YOU HAVE ANY ROBOT SOLDIERS OR CYBORGS, SEND THEM TOO! THERE ARE TWO STRANGE BOYS RITUALISTICALLY SACRIFICING A ROAST BEEF WHICH THEY'VE DRESSED UP LIKE A CANADIAN HILLBILLY AND TIED TO A TREE! THERE'S NOT MUCH TIME! HURRY!"

  • @gungrabber970
    @gungrabber970 5 лет назад +3

    7:44 saved for reference. Thanks for your efforts.

  • @philliplehl5578
    @philliplehl5578 Год назад +1

    Great video, guys. You think y'all could do an update on the vaquero? I just bought one and I love seeing these demonstrations

  • @dsbiddle
    @dsbiddle 9 лет назад +4

    I just ordered a 4" Talwar , fully serrated. I love the Vaquero shape but the thickness of the Voyagers was the only factor in me shying away from them. They're not overly thick but that 1/8" or so might end up being a reason why I stop using it for daily carry. I don't care how good it cuts - it won't help if I don't have it with me. They should do a Vaquero blade with a Talwar-style handle - G10 slabs with the small steel liners to support the pivot in the G10. I would pick it up in a heartbeat.

  • @BADD1ONE
    @BADD1ONE Год назад +2

    As a skater in the 90s we wore very loose fitting pants. When you slide across asphalt you were less likely to get tore up

  • @ald.5147
    @ald.5147 3 месяца назад

    Cold steel sells the serrations sharpener. It's a ceramic rod with small grooves that match the serrations.

  • @Kylef7735
    @Kylef7735 11 лет назад

    Your videos demonstrating your experience and tactics are awesome....

  • @MrEdium
    @MrEdium 9 лет назад +2

    Great Review. I think for EDC the Plain Clip Point is way better, now if the Vaquero was a plain edge then maybe but the Plain Clip point is still better for everyday use. I'm sorry but I don't like any serrations on my knives. Again your review answers the main questions. The "Clip Point" WINS ! Thank You.

  • @davidr9876
    @davidr9876 4 года назад +2

    i wonder how the Raja 2 would perform in this test. No serrations but heavier/bigger blade and nice Kukri shape. Handle is better on the Voyager but the Rajah handle is not bad.

  • @Gieszkanne
    @Gieszkanne 22 дня назад

    Without your talking just from observation they look both the same in the cut result. Interesting that the serration get so easily deformed just from slightly hitting bamboo. That is also to consider for a fighting knife because you also would/could hit bone.

  • @triskel3t
    @triskel3t 2 месяца назад

    The bad thing about serrations in edc is that you cant work with wood - chop or carving, end of the video clearly shows that. And with voyager xl you'd definetely want to chop something sometimes - its acceptable for this task.

  • @MarkedInBlack
    @MarkedInBlack 9 лет назад

    Good test, fellas. Knives are no joke.

  • @coolsly64
    @coolsly64 9 лет назад +1

    I'd like to see a rehash of that same serrated vaquero in the bd-1 steel and see if you still have tooth deformation after the test...

    • @mathewrculbertson
      @mathewrculbertson  9 лет назад

      Great question! There might be a difference, but I think the main flaw is in how CS serrations are designed. The teeth are tinny and lack support, but you question is still great!

    • @coolsly64
      @coolsly64 9 лет назад +1

      true they will still more then likely fail maybe not as easily because it's a tougher steel but by design they won't last long I think cold steel should take page from kershaw or veff serrations but I like the kershaw serrations better only because even if the tip of the point break off they tend to round off as apposed to breaking off and even rounded they are still sharp as heck and continue to cut like they used to plus both of those serrations are fairly easy to sharpen/strop if one part should start to get alittle duller then the others. I still would like to see you guys redo this test comparing the new steels cuts to the aus 8a's cutting abilities it would be interesting to see if it makes a difference and/or how much of a difference...

  • @trap-du3hd
    @trap-du3hd 8 лет назад +4

    vaquero looks like the Kukri's nephew

  • @jorgefernandez6407
    @jorgefernandez6407 2 года назад

    Great video! VERY informative...

  • @jeffbilbo3313
    @jeffbilbo3313 3 года назад

    You pray you never need to! What is better for self defense only serrated or plan bladed? I love your videos. Thank you. I can only carry a four inch pocket knife.

    • @jeanpaulgartier3404
      @jeanpaulgartier3404 3 года назад +1

      Serrations for pure self defense, they hurt a lot more.

  • @juliannepatel5002
    @juliannepatel5002 9 лет назад

    at 2:54 when he said "if you really want to abuse your tip" I WAS DYING XD

  • @Casexxkiller07
    @Casexxkiller07 11 лет назад +1

    Can the sharpmaker sharpen cold steel serrations

  • @Texaslonghorn_
    @Texaslonghorn_ 2 года назад

    Do you recommend a certain type of sharpener that you have used for cold steel serrations?

  • @dean4545
    @dean4545 7 лет назад

    Hello. Can you make some tests on the cold steel voyager tanto or maybe some other tanto lades? Thanks!

  • @HerbWalker
    @HerbWalker 6 лет назад +2

    Less Yackin' and more SMACKIN' :P

  • @jamese7167
    @jamese7167 11 лет назад

    I love your videos btw. I find them very informative.

  • @CliffStamp
    @CliffStamp 11 лет назад

    It might be interesting to compare the serrated vs plain edge with the plain edge at a lower grit finish (but still of high sharpness, i.e., still shaving but with an x-coarse DMT finish for example).

  • @chrisd933
    @chrisd933 5 лет назад

    I do think serrations will make a nastier wound and better for self defense especially with a blade like the voyager vaquero with the recurve. When you bring it down onto an attacker the serrations go in pretty well but when you pull the blade back out the serrations will make a nastier hole and open the target up more then a sharp plain edge. But it’s just a theory, I still prefer plain edge 🤷‍♂️

  • @Kayakwinds
    @Kayakwinds 7 лет назад

    Did you do any tests on heavy clothing? If you have, I am missing them. Thanks for a fine video.

  • @alexschwan625
    @alexschwan625 Год назад

    Good review

  • @mathewrculbertson
    @mathewrculbertson  11 лет назад

    Thank you watching.

  • @bae313
    @bae313 9 лет назад

    Nice vid. Do you think anyone didn't raise their hand to request the snap cut display?

  • @Sharpbevel
    @Sharpbevel 11 лет назад

    Awesome job men.

  • @jonathanross4196
    @jonathanross4196 9 лет назад +2

    he thing with Cold Steel serrations is that they are a pain in the ass to re sharpen. A plain edge with a good edge could out perform a serration. Had to tell. Nice video.

  • @Mc007Queen
    @Mc007Queen 6 лет назад

    I just received mine but it had a plain edge and a bit me in the index finger , blade closed on my finger lol ... The blade is pretty thin so you can get a pretty good sharp Edge on that Carpenter steel lol the knife when it's open it's 12 in Long with 5.5 inch blade it's humongous lol

  • @trap-du3hd
    @trap-du3hd 8 лет назад +1

    they say the serrated blades cut 3x as good because they sell 1/3 as good as plain, if that was true they wouldn't be cheaper.
    or your plain edge must be dull

  • @knighthawk3759
    @knighthawk3759 10 лет назад +4

    I spent over 200.00 on knives.....cant afford another "pair of meat"...lol

    • @modijr7180
      @modijr7180 4 года назад

      Buy sugar cane for cutting training

  • @mathewrculbertson
    @mathewrculbertson  11 лет назад

    Im sure it would do well against the clip point, but might be somewhat harder to sharpen for the novice.

  • @FringeSniper
    @FringeSniper 11 лет назад

    Interesting, well done video.

  • @Greg_M308
    @Greg_M308 6 лет назад

    Very helpful.

  • @GRILLBUOY101
    @GRILLBUOY101 2 года назад

    i saw him carry the nachez bowie

  • @mathewrculbertson
    @mathewrculbertson  11 лет назад

    thank you!

  • @pleasentlysurprised
    @pleasentlysurprised 9 лет назад

    "I think that's a big ol' cut though." hahah YUP!!

  • @kurtasiak
    @kurtasiak 7 месяцев назад

    super

  • @knighthawk3759
    @knighthawk3759 10 лет назад

    Is lynn Thompson your best friend or something? Since your on a first name basis.....

    • @DCgeek13
      @DCgeek13 8 лет назад +4

      Why do you care ?

  • @pat__4
    @pat__4 2 года назад

    i carry both of those knives everyday

  • @ald.5147
    @ald.5147 2 месяца назад

    The serrations get caught on "fibrous" material. Thats the drawback with those type of serrations.

  • @firewire8912
    @firewire8912 10 лет назад

    Good vid

  • @jamese7167
    @jamese7167 11 лет назад +1

    I would like to suggest learning a different fighting style because all though that could probably do a lot against people who don't know about knife fighting. If you get in a fight with someone who does fight with knives then you will easily lose your bad. The best way to fight is holding the knife with a reverse grip. keep all limbs close to your body and move out of the way till they reach out far then strike quickly. Also smaller knives can be a lot easier to hide then strike with.

  • @dmadril8474
    @dmadril8474 3 года назад

    Lol the tape measo, the cut matto

  • @fukemnukem1525
    @fukemnukem1525 3 года назад +1

    I carry my XL Voyager precisely for the people that wear skinny jeans. LoL. I'm just kidding.... I'll defend myself equally across all groups and sexes.

  • @sergiovision6850
    @sergiovision6850 7 лет назад

    clip point penetrates better, but im tell about deep wounds, u cant feel diferences in this manner

  • @TheJamesinat0r
    @TheJamesinat0r 8 лет назад

    He sounds like chaw

  • @bayonne
    @bayonne 4 года назад

    Tapemeasual LoL

  • @BdogFinal14
    @BdogFinal14 2 года назад

    You talk too much in your video. A good demonstration is all you need.