I played it on release. I decided to replay it. It’s been like 6 years now I think, and I forgot everything besides the ending. I’m on chapter 4 and enjoying it very much.
I decided to get 100% completion, and after spending ages hunting specific birds and picking all those stupid flowers, I decided to visit Arthur's grave as my very final action on the game, cos it just felt right to end on that note. Really hit differently when the 100% completion achievement popped up
@@angeljones255 You can find most of them all over the place, but as far as I am aware there are 4 that only grow in the deserts in New Austin. There are quite a few orchids in the trees by the river next to Caliga Hall.
Exactly what I did. I’m on the 4th play over and I’m still finding people I’ve never met and little hidden caches I’ve never found previous run throughs. Plus by the 3rd and 4th run through it so much easier to notice little things because you pay more 😂😂😂.
I'm about to do that right this second lol. This was my first playthrough. I knew I'd regret not taking my time more but I work a lot and the story was just so captivating I couldn't help playing the story missions lol. Can I keep my finished playthrough save file when starting a new game ?
@@mannmann314 I Don think you can actually. I think because its auto save, it doesn't do separate files. Be sure and explore the southern part of the map to its fullest with John though. There is loads to do down there 😉
@@eddiebear34 ok, thanks for the reply, I play with auto save off do you think that might make it possible? And really ? I've made it to armadillo and tumbleweed and I haven't found a damn thing to do besides pick herbs for some dude
I honestly can’t get bored with the redemption games after 100% completion. I’ve done it so many times now I’ve lost count but with these 2 games (mainly RDR2 because of all the detail) I can fully relax And during a tough time irl RDR2 was my escape from reality. So personally I’m never bored of the game.
@@RAYOUILLE best thing to do I’d say. Is do everything that’s in your area during each chapter. Between missions do challenges, strangers etc. Then the further you go down the game most things will be completed. This way it doesn’t feel like you’re going out of the way to do other things. But most of all mate, have fun. If you go on the game just to relax. Avoid the main story missions and just do herbalist challenges, bones, camp interactions, hunting. Don’t rush because if you rush then it will feel longer. Enjoy your time, take your time and you’ll complete it quicker while having a better experience
@@tannerfox4474 Yeah that’s completely up to you Personally I don’t think that way goes with the story well. However it does give you more to do as John
I just started a 100% run for thr 1st time and there is a very good guide on how to do everything on a timely and straighyfoward manner, so u get everything as u go while not straying to far off.
somehow i dont feel like playing all the side content as John, but I am amazed that the devs allow you to do that, writing all those pages of dialogue for both characters. Incredible.
I actually want to save most of it for John. As much as Arthur is a legendary character, John is still the OG and deserves his adventure and time in the sun. Especially since we know how his story ends.
@@DaBearsManiac2 The only thing to remember when playing as John is that he can't swim. I was way down south, got a boat and tried to row to Mexico. After drinking so many tonics as it's a fair old trip, over halfway across John just stepped out of the boat and drowned.
I remember attaining 100% and one of the things that kinda bothered me was the amount of collectables you had to do, but on the flip side it taught me alot about historical characters in the rdr universe, then stuff like dominoes was so hard i decided to watch a guide on it and its one of the best achievements i ever did on this game.
Can’t believe I’m only just starting this . Absolutely in love with it right now, it’s been years since I played rd1. the fishing and legendary animals topped it for me 💯
dude i feel you i just got the game 2 weeks ago & i can’t put it down! i cant believe i didn’t play this when it first came out. I was huge fan of the first Red Dead Redemption so i’m excited to play as John again but i don’t want Arthur to die so i’m taking my sweet time playing this.
Doing all these things are more fun as Arthur.. because we know he dies so we’re just building his legacy till then.. the slower you play the greater his legacy becomes
Just got this game. Finished the main story, and now doing many of the things in this video as John. Amazing game! It definitely deserves another play through.
I’ve waited for so long but bought it in 2024. just got to the epilogue so still going. I’m 250h in and 78% This is still truly a masterpiece and I’ll be living it until GTA6 comes to pc
@@gabriellisboa5366I finished this game just today actually I bought it when it was on sale for 24$ in Canada A while back but I kinda forgot about it.
Thanks for showing this. After all these years I just finished the game. Hopefully some of the side missions I missed will Pop up. I know with a few they kept disappearing when I would get to them as John.
On a funny note, I remember seeing a video a couple years ago for things to do once you’ve completed the story mode… And the person said…and I’m not making this up, “Pat a dog”
I made a point to pat every dog I encountered (except the handful that would only attack)...it was cool to see them remember my character as time went on.
No kidding....I just watched a video where over 1/2 of it was really basic stuff, like "get a haircut", "try different ammo", "steal a boat" (even though Marsten can't swim), etc. My only expression was just WTF....I was already doing this stuff during the game as Arthur.
After finishing the game first time today. I can say that this game is a masterpiece. The character development is just great. The game makes you connected to the characters as someone close to you. RDR2 and TLOU (both parts) are quite the only few games that felt like a journey.
I found out that you can actually take in the jail wagon prisoner to the valentine jail but he won't be arrested, he'll start murdering the lawmen until he gets shot
Been playing as you know since launch but have had well over a year away from playing story mode im at 98% completion on story. But gave up to play online for quite a while. Think its dominoes and killing cougars with a bow all i need to do to 100% story,i must get back into it and get it finished. Great vid as always Phil thank you much love x
@@FilbeeGaming i love dominoes too but after trying to beat the guys in the station for hrs i kinda got fed up of trying to win so many games to get the achievment lol...The cougars with the bow was crazy hard for me too🤣 you can only keep getting mauled to death for so long x
tip for the dominos if you want to cheese it slightly to get the 100% completion - play All Fives at the little park in St Denis across the road from the theatre Raleur. its a bit less of a coin toss than draw dominos at Emerald Ranch, and fairly easy to win if you pay attention. but if your opponent gets close to 100 points and looks like winning a game, stand up from the table and sit back down. a new game will start but it doesn't count as a loss unless your opponent actually gets the 100 points. you can't save the game and come back, that will reset the counter on the challenge, so you have to do it all in one game session, but it shouldn't take more than half an hour or so.
I'm on my second play through,I spent like 3 weeks on it the first time finished like 60 percent and didn't pick it up again for over a year I realized I missed so much not looking for strangers hunting all the animals finding all the treasure doing all the bounties, I've been playing this tim and im only on chapter 3 after a month but have way more weapons, satchels,horses hell I didn't even craft or modify my weapons the forst time this is a game that's not meant to be ran through like Mario it's meant to be immersive and Rockstar knocked this one out the park definitely could be the best game ever made.....
I was the same but mostly because I didn't watch any videos for spoilers so I only saw what I ran across. Now I'm in Ch 3 not progressing further and found a great stopping point to do everything with Arthur now. Last playthrough I didn't do any legendary fish, any challenges for fun belts, or any collectables so I'll have all those now before I get to play with John. I still finished at 87% last time but so much I didn't finish
Yeah love this game, i fixed the platinum and my last trophy was the one where you have to visit al you're friends graves. The last grave was Arthur and then it poped next to my buddy.
You absolutely must finish everything that's avaliable as Arthur. That means basically everything besides the herbalist and horseman challenges (unless you have a wagon and/or a ton of tonics), dino bones and grave sites. The rest really needs to be done as Arthur. Mostly because Art is undeniably the better character.
That’s just the attitude of someone who’s not old enough to have played RDR when it first came out. All I mud older folks felt the exact same way about John years ago as people do of Arthur now. John is the more interesting character
@@wildcat8598 not even close. I was a senior in high school when rdr came out. Arthur remains the same best fictional character that's ever been written, at least by rockstar. When John dies I thought "that sucks" when Arthur died I actually got emotional and it's the first fictional death that's ever made me feel anything.
What I like doing is roleplaying on the PC version of the game with mods, I would roleplay John and Jack on adventures hunting animals and doing side quests its actually a lot of fun Jack would follow along like a small companion.
I am at 99.30% right now i need to visit 3 graves only i kept it for the last thing i need to do played this game for 200hrs which was very enjoyable it took me 8 month of gameplay to reach 99% i dont have time to play that much but its a very polished game u can not just let it go and move on to other games, this is by far the best game out there ..
I went through the game once, although nowhere near 100%. I restarted and am in chapter six but haven't been able to bring myself to finish it knowing what happens. I had no idea you could finish missions you started as Arthur. Maybe I'll try to get through it again and spend more time as John.
OMG me too. I've only gone through the entire story once. I get to Chapter 4 and I start getting so sad...as Chapter 5 and 6 move alone and Arthur gets sicker...I haven't been able to go through the whole story again and just start a new game. But I think I'll try it again so I can finish some of this stuff mentioned.
Just finished my first play thru and by far my favorite video game ever. Not only are the guns, clothes, and facial hair options really cool but Im a huge fan of the southwest US and am about to move to a state out west in the next couple months. Shout out to Tahitian mango farmers!
The only thing that I wish they added for John is like more interactions with the family. Take Jack fishing or hunting or take Abigail on a date. Get drunk with uncle just something. And should have a lot more bounties for John. Don't get me started on New Austin. So boring
It's a shame that you really don't have much to purchase by the time you get to the epilogue as John . By then the guns have been purchased and most of the horses . Other then some outfits , you really can't take advantage of the money you get .
@number7red619 Never lost on on the trains but the Murrfee Brood seems to like to shoot horses. On an ambush by them it was the first thing that happened, twice. I tried to save my horse but ended up dead as well both times. Only wounded on the third and I manage to save him. BTW there is no more Murrfee brood members left alive just for just that reason. It really made me mad.. I'll remember to be more careful around trains, thanks. This is my second play through the first went kind of fast but all I did was follow the story line. However I recently realized that there is no way for me to get a 100% completion as I am missing a couple of weapons from the gunslingers side mission. Guess I'll just have to play the game again, poor me, lol. By the way this only the second game I ever played. I'm 78 so I guess you could call me a late blooming gamer.
I remember doing the serial killer side quest during 3-4 am, it was so relaxing. I at first was disappointed when I didn't get any unique item in the end, but realized the journey was the reward all long
After 5 years I finally 100% rdr2 and while I feel happy and relieved after many of the annoyances you have to do in order to obtain 100% completion apart of me feels kind of sad that I will never be able to do anything for the first time again in rdr2
That SOB Arthur died on me… he was supposed to beat black lung after dodging death through train heist after train heist and then a few bank robberies and then being trapped on an island that SOB was supposed to survive.
1:24 actually you can get Micah’s revolver in the mission in chapter 1 where you raid the enemy gang camp all you need to do is disarm one of the enemy gang members and then lead them to micha who will get tackled and drop his gun
If the Epilogue happens few years after the main story end, how is it that those secondary missions are still available when playing John? Means the photographer and the guy who lost his animals have been sitting there for years ? 😅
You get 20+ K at the end of the game, what difference is 8$ gonna make lmao. Not that doing some farm work is not immersive, its a cool element actually.
After killing Micah: restart the game over and over, multiple times, Never getting bored, and never will. Playing as Arthur just Fills my dark and empty Soul with happiness. I love playing as John as well, and like them both equally, just playing as Arthur Feels more Special.
It is possible to do all the challenges as Arthur, horseman 10 is easy as Arthur, horseman 9 is also perfectly doable so long as you ensure you have plenty of tonics in your satchel. Herbalist 9 takes a wagon, patience and bags of practice to succeed however and frankly I've never managed it 😅
@@Mr.Moose.3 Assuming "lote" means Legend of the East, yes, Arthur can get it. Horseman 9 as Arthur is actually reasonably easy. Herbalist 9 is possible, but very difficult. The Legend of the East outfit can be obtained in Chapter 2 or Chapter 3. For Chapter 3, do all the challenges or all but Herbalist. For Chapter 2, do all the challenges _except_ for Bandit. Basically, complete whatever challenges you can _except_ for the Gambler Challenge. If you want the outfit in Chapter 2, then you _must_ complete the Herbalist Challenge. If you decide that Herbalist 9 is too difficult, then you must advance to Chapter 3 in order to access the horse fence in order to complete the Bandit Challenge. To complete Herbalist 9 as Arthur, steal a buggy from St. Denis. Take the buggy to New Austin. The sniper can't shoot you because the buggy is used as a shield. In settings, camera follow has been turned off. It's best to find a video on RUclips showing how it's done so you will know _where_ to locate the herbs. Eagle Eye won't activate when in the buggy. Now...assuming you complete Herbalist 9, Bandit Challenge isn't necessary. If you decide that Herbalist 9 is too difficult, go on to Chapter 3 and complete Bandit Challenge. Okay...so you're now in Chapter 2 or Chapter 3. You have completed all of the challenges except for Gambler and either Herbalist or Bandit. *NOW* you want to complete the Gambler Challenge. For Gambler 10 (win 3 hands of poker in a row), you want to _replay_ the Chapter 2 Reverend Swanson mission. You can either go to Flatneck Station and win 2 hands and _then_ replay the mission, or you can elect to simply replay the mission. When asked to play poker, naturally you accept. You will _always_ win that first hand. Once you win 3 hands in a row, exit the _poker_ game and rescue Reverend Swanson and return him to camp. You now have the Legend of the East outfit. If you win your third hand in a row _without_ replaying the mission, you will have completed the Gambler Challenge...but will still need to complete Herbalist Challenge or Bandit Challenge (whichever one you didn't complete earlier).
@@iwasright9686it is 100% possible to finish all challenges as Arthur. Look up some RUclips videos, there’s plenty of videos showing Arthur doing Herb 9 and Horseman 9 & 10
HORSEMAN: I always complete this 10 challenges in the beginning of CH 2. As you do not need to ride to Blackwater. You can ride - after the bridge - immediately to the left ‘Island’ (peninsula) (left of Bkackwater). Easy ride. The broken bridge is the way harder option.
@@FilbeeGaming me cover a video? no Boss thank you but I don't know how, but personally I like the mysteries the paranormal and the creepy story, you could tell beautiful terrifying stories with your voice, traditional stories, urban legends of the time by the fireside a bit like campers in RDR
Ever since I completed the story, whenever I play or even think about the game, I get this fuzzy feeling in my stomach. I realized how much this game has impacted me. I am changed man now, but I am one without Arthur. This game will NEVER be the same without Mr. Morgan.
Kinda wish the Epilogue continued a bit longer before reaching American Venom. It feels cut short when just starting to build up a story for John, Charles, Sadie, Uncle and family. Some more story content in New Austin would have been nice too.
@@motionprimeaep Mr Wasp's flower quest was the worst bit about 100% for me, just takes too damn long, it's a drag... Loved the gun and the hat's the best in the game.
@@DW3010Algernon Wasp's Exotics quest, collecting all the rare orchids and plants... Absolute nightmare of a quest, was the worst bit of my 100% playthrough
The one side mission I had the most trouble with was the lumber. By the time I got the wagon to the house, it was built. Then that lumber company ups and vanishes. 😂
I’m presently grinding just the story. I’m skipping absolutely everything else. Just to see how much John can actually do. I’m holding off beginning stranger missions and challenges and side quests. I do have a fully bonded Arabian and Shire parked in the stable.
At this point, I expect switching protagonist at the end of the game is just going to become a tradition with this franchise, if they ever make another one
I finished 100% on story line, 100% on challenges and 100% on compendium. Then I tried RDO (Red Dead Online), but found it full of griefers and modders. It is as good as un-playable. I made my own server (lobby) but that seems to defeat the purpose of the MORPG. So I searched the fora on Facebook and Discord, but only encountered more griefers and modders, or fools who post ridiculous flashing GIFs. I am still looking for some mature players to invite to my RDO server.
you can get micahs revolver in literally the second mission in the game while you're still in colter lol furthermore you can finish all the challenges and collect all the dinosaur bones as arthur (w/o using any mods)
After completing the main story and the epilogue i rode south and came across Fort Mercer and remembered half of RDR 1 is John gathering folks to take down this fort. So i thought i will take down it single handedly and kept my distance snipped everyone in the fort and entered the fort there were two enemies with two gatling guns. Took one out with a dynamite and one out by cover shooting. And ended up finding 200 dollars inside the fort. 10/10 game. Entertaining even after completing the game.
you can get micahs revolver as arthur in chapter 1 in the old friends mission you can get an o'driscoll to disarm micah and you can pick up his revolver
I finished the master hunter challenges on chapter2 you don’t have to particularly hunt all legendary animals but you do need to complete 1-9 because challenge 10 is the legendary panther or cugar
I was able to complete all but the herbalist challenge as Arthur. (just last month - (I have the latest version on PS4))? Still trying... The buggy idea is not as easy as some make it look! I've only ever done 99%. Hate that mission for hat feathers!
Working through my second play through, taking my time with it as I missed so much first time round. I’ve had the game since launch and still to this date is my favourite game of all time.
Watching Wallaby Kid RP online it's amazing. He does such a good job with the charecter. Over 200 episodes 6 hours each in length. You get addicted if you start watching.
Thank You for this inspiring video! I didn't know that i can meet Mary Beth in Valentine (i had a little crush on her). By the way: You can meet Tilly in Saint Denis ... I am about 300 hours and i can not stop playing RDR2. It is the best computer game i ever played. I would love to buy a DLC with a few more quests, encounters and enterable buildings even so many years after release.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
I wish I could wipe my memory of rdr2 after every playthrough nothing beats the first time experience 😢
Same bro
I'm with you both on this
I play story once a year always brings back that same feeling 😢
I played it on release. I decided to replay it. It’s been like 6 years now I think, and I forgot everything besides the ending. I’m on chapter 4 and enjoying it very much.
Same here @@ugotarbysvag9078
All I want to do is keep playing as Arthur
Exactly
Same
There is a way. Search YT for "how to be Arthur again rdr2" there are some glitches tho.
Thats why i will replay the game
Replay again and dont go past chapter 4
I decided to get 100% completion, and after spending ages hunting specific birds and picking all those stupid flowers, I decided to visit Arthur's grave as my very final action on the game, cos it just felt right to end on that note.
Really hit differently when the 100% completion achievement popped up
i did it but didnt get an achievement :( fucking scam
I'm trying to get all those stupid flowers now. Where did you look?
@@angeljones255 You can find most of them all over the place, but as far as I am aware there are 4 that only grow in the deserts in New Austin. There are quite a few orchids in the trees by the river next to Caliga Hall.
I immediately went to find arthur grave after killing Micah. thought there might a dialogue for it but there wasn't 😅
There's a dialogue at his grave after you get 100% completion
Everytime i cough in real life i can't help thinking :"damn that tuberculosis!!!!"
Same😂
@@dukeelling3380 smoke a cigarette
@@dukeelling3380 this game got me smoking cigarettes 😆
@@ChiefmarlboroStop if you can
@@SHIP_THROWER I'm on my last pack and I'm done
Arthur is one of those well made and well loved characters, that you could easily restart the whole thing directly after finishing it.
Exactly what I did. I’m on the 4th play over and I’m still finding people I’ve never met and little hidden caches I’ve never found previous run throughs. Plus by the 3rd and 4th run through it so much easier to notice little things because you pay more 😂😂😂.
@robbiedunc27 I've just finished my 3rd play through. Just looking to 100% as john now. Those challenges cam be a slog though
I'm about to do that right this second lol. This was my first playthrough. I knew I'd regret not taking my time more but I work a lot and the story was just so captivating I couldn't help playing the story missions lol. Can I keep my finished playthrough save file when starting a new game ?
@@mannmann314 I Don think you can actually. I think because its auto save, it doesn't do separate files.
Be sure and explore the southern part of the map to its fullest with John though. There is loads to do down there 😉
@@eddiebear34 ok, thanks for the reply, I play with auto save off do you think that might make it possible? And really ? I've made it to armadillo and tumbleweed and I haven't found a damn thing to do besides pick herbs for some dude
I honestly can’t get bored with the redemption games after 100% completion. I’ve done it so many times now I’ve lost count but with these 2 games (mainly RDR2 because of all the detail) I can fully relax
And during a tough time irl RDR2 was my escape from reality.
So personally I’m never bored of the game.
do you have any advice for a first timer trying to get 100% completion as efficiently as possible?
@@RAYOUILLE best thing to do I’d say. Is do everything that’s in your area during each chapter.
Between missions do challenges, strangers etc.
Then the further you go down the game most things will be completed. This way it doesn’t feel like you’re going out of the way to do other things. But most of all mate, have fun.
If you go on the game just to relax. Avoid the main story missions and just do herbalist challenges, bones, camp interactions, hunting.
Don’t rush because if you rush then it will feel longer. Enjoy your time, take your time and you’ll complete it quicker while having a better experience
@r3idmcread212 I did over half the challenges after having complete the story
@@tannerfox4474 Yeah that’s completely up to you
Personally I don’t think that way goes with the story well. However it does give you more to do as John
I just started a 100% run for thr 1st time and there is a very good guide on how to do everything on a timely and straighyfoward manner, so u get everything as u go while not straying to far off.
somehow i dont feel like playing all the side content as John, but I am amazed that the devs allow you to do that, writing all those pages of dialogue for both characters. Incredible.
I actually want to save most of it for John.
As much as Arthur is a legendary character, John is still the OG and deserves his adventure and time in the sun. Especially since we know how his story ends.
@@DaBearsManiac2 The only thing to remember when playing as John is that he can't swim. I was way down south, got a boat and tried to row to Mexico. After drinking so many tonics as it's a fair old trip, over halfway across John just stepped out of the boat and drowned.
@@johnbird7357😂😂
@@johnbird7357bro 😭😭
might be a hot take but arthur is a better character than john. I've grown way more attached to him and his writing is so much better
I remember attaining 100% and one of the things that kinda bothered me was the amount of collectables you had to do, but on the flip side it taught me alot about historical characters in the rdr universe, then stuff like dominoes was so hard i decided to watch a guide on it and its one of the best achievements i ever did on this game.
Dominoes.... Eff dominoes.
Dominoes.... Eff dominoes.
how do you achieve 100% anyways? I wanna try it out but i dont know the requirements
@@Agent_3Cat follow the checklist. Super easy to track.
MAN, THE DOMINOES, I was going NUTS, I spent 3 hours, it was nearly impossible, BUT I MADE IT
Can’t believe I’m only just starting this . Absolutely in love with it right now, it’s been years since I played rd1. the fishing and legendary animals topped it for me 💯
This is an amazing game, take your time, enjoy, explore, hang out in camp a lot and listen to the dialogue, it's more than a game, it's an experience.
It’s the best game IMO. So much to do & the world is full of surprises. Enjoy the game my friend. Don’t rush it
@GuataTTV the fishing tikes me off😂...getting in those legendary fish Is a lot of work
dude i feel you i just got the game 2 weeks ago & i can’t put it down! i cant believe i didn’t play this when it first came out. I was huge fan of the first Red Dead Redemption so i’m excited to play as John again but i don’t want Arthur to die so i’m taking my sweet time playing this.
Thanks man, i went from being clueless on if there was anything else to do to being overwhelmed
Doing all these things are more fun as Arthur.. because we know he dies so we’re just building his legacy till then.. the slower you play the greater his legacy becomes
The game is all about john Marston
@@dodulkumardatta1262 Wrong opinion
Just got this game. Finished the main story, and now doing many of the things in this video as John. Amazing game! It definitely deserves another play through.
Be careful mate, John can't swim.
In the second play through u will do it slowly and wish to spend more time with Arthur
I’ve waited for so long but bought it in 2024. just got to the epilogue so still going.
I’m 250h in and 78%
This is still truly a masterpiece and I’ll be living it until GTA6 comes to pc
i dont know if youll ever see this but watching this was soo nice because of your voice and tempo at which you talk at, great video!
I saw it dude, thank you. Glad you enjoyed it
500+ hours and I’m still at 93.2% lol. But I never get tired of playing this masterpiece.
Literally the same.. took me a week to finish the fishing legendaries
@@rocktober420hey bro i just started the epilogue with John and i miss Arthur so much how John looks like is good or not? Sorry for my English
@@rocktober420took me 3 days 93%
What is the best chapter to play arthur for exploring everything
@@Deffiles 3 or 4 imo
Folk still playing story mode in 2023 makes me so happy
my son bought me rdr2 for father's day (June) & i finished it yesterday 91.4%
@@monkee1969 Howdy!
@@gabriellisboa5366I finished this game just today actually I bought it when it was on sale for 24$ in Canada
A while back but I kinda forgot about it.
I just got it now. After two days i'm on 64% and in tears.
@@gabriellisboa5366 finished the campaign for the first time 2 weeks ago, at over 90% completion
Thanks for showing this. After all these years I just finished the game. Hopefully some of the side missions I missed will Pop up. I know with a few they kept disappearing when I would get to them as John.
Some can only be done at night.
Some I believe are exclusive to the chapter you’re in as well
Getting 100% in the game is by far my favourite PlayStation trophy I’ve ever gotten.
Well done!
On a funny note, I remember seeing a video a couple years ago for things to do once you’ve completed the story mode… And the person said…and I’m not making this up, “Pat a dog”
I made a point to pat every dog I encountered (except the handful that would only attack)...it was cool to see them remember my character as time went on.
No kidding....I just watched a video where over 1/2 of it was really basic stuff, like "get a haircut", "try different ammo", "steal a boat" (even though Marsten can't swim), etc. My only expression was just WTF....I was already doing this stuff during the game as Arthur.
@@cmdrwraithe1857you end up finding anything else to do
After finishing the game first time today. I can say that this game is a masterpiece. The character development is just great. The game makes you connected to the characters as someone close to you. RDR2 and TLOU (both parts) are quite the only few games that felt like a journey.
I found out that you can actually take in the jail wagon prisoner to the valentine jail but he won't be arrested, he'll start murdering the lawmen until he gets shot
Been playing as you know since launch but have had well over a year away from playing story mode im at 98% completion on story. But gave up to play online for quite a while.
Think its dominoes and killing cougars with a bow all i need to do to 100% story,i must get back into it and get it finished. Great vid as always Phil thank you much love x
Thank you Kat. I love domino's, but I loved Liars Dice more from RDR1 X
@@FilbeeGaming i love dominoes too but after trying to beat the guys in the station for hrs i kinda got fed up of trying to win so many games to get the achievment lol...The cougars with the bow was crazy hard for me too🤣 you can only keep getting mauled to death for so long x
@@Kat-X Emerald Ranch, I know exactly ehere you mean. I've never beaten them neither xx
tip for the dominos if you want to cheese it slightly to get the 100% completion - play All Fives at the little park in St Denis across the road from the theatre Raleur. its a bit less of a coin toss than draw dominos at Emerald Ranch, and fairly easy to win if you pay attention. but if your opponent gets close to 100 points and looks like winning a game, stand up from the table and sit back down. a new game will start but it doesn't count as a loss unless your opponent actually gets the 100 points. you can't save the game and come back, that will reset the counter on the challenge, so you have to do it all in one game session, but it shouldn't take more than half an hour or so.
@@-yeme- wow thank you will definatly give that a go! Great tip will certainly try that 🤞👍👍👍
I wish they would release Story Dlcs where the Games continues a little bit in Mexico or something like that they could easy sell that ...
You can finish master hunter challenge as arthur. No need to hunt all legendary animals for that
I'm on my second play through,I spent like 3 weeks on it the first time finished like 60 percent and didn't pick it up again for over a year I realized I missed so much not looking for strangers hunting all the animals finding all the treasure doing all the bounties, I've been playing this tim and im only on chapter 3 after a month but have way more weapons, satchels,horses hell I didn't even craft or modify my weapons the forst time this is a game that's not meant to be ran through like Mario it's meant to be immersive and Rockstar knocked this one out the park definitely could be the best game ever made.....
I was the same but mostly because I didn't watch any videos for spoilers so I only saw what I ran across. Now I'm in Ch 3 not progressing further and found a great stopping point to do everything with Arthur now. Last playthrough I didn't do any legendary fish, any challenges for fun belts, or any collectables so I'll have all those now before I get to play with John. I still finished at 87% last time but so much I didn't finish
Yeah love this game, i fixed the platinum and my last trophy was the one where you have to visit al you're friends graves. The last grave was Arthur and then it poped next to my buddy.
You absolutely must finish everything that's avaliable as Arthur. That means basically everything besides the herbalist and horseman challenges (unless you have a wagon and/or a ton of tonics), dino bones and grave sites. The rest really needs to be done as Arthur. Mostly because Art is undeniably the better character.
Did you not play RDR1?
That’s just the attitude of someone who’s not old enough to have played RDR when it first came out. All I mud older folks felt the exact same way about John years ago as people do of Arthur now. John is the more interesting character
Wait till you play rdr1 mate. .....you will find that you like them equally after that
@@wildcat8598 not even close. I was a senior in high school when rdr came out. Arthur remains the same best fictional character that's ever been written, at least by rockstar. When John dies I thought "that sucks" when Arthur died I actually got emotional and it's the first fictional death that's ever made me feel anything.
@@michaelstarratt4868 I have. John's not even half as good as Arthur.
Top thing to do after completing the story: DO IT ALL OVER AGAIN!
What I like doing is roleplaying on the PC version of the game with mods, I would roleplay John and Jack on adventures hunting animals and doing side quests its actually a lot of fun Jack would follow along like a small companion.
Such an excellent idea
How do you even get these type of mods???
@@matthewfuller3971 Nexus Mods
@YCFTNE You can just look for Jack Marston Teen in the mod, he should be number 330 around that.
@YCFTNE It should be on Nexus Mods or RDR2 Mods search for Followers.
Easily the best game ever made
@JonathanPeters-ww8fywhere can i get it the vid
@@danialfairuz4973 dont get it. its a rat!
Boring af
@@Thingmie As if u bellend
@@Thingmie did you even beat it
I am at 99.30% right now i need to visit 3 graves only i kept it for the last thing i need to do played this game for 200hrs which was very enjoyable it took me 8 month of gameplay to reach 99% i dont have time to play that much but its a very polished game u can not just let it go and move on to other games, this is by far the best game out there ..
Why not 100% and Then visit the graves? As I heard, you can do anything after 100% still?
I went through the game once, although nowhere near 100%. I restarted and am in chapter six but haven't been able to bring myself to finish it knowing what happens. I had no idea you could finish missions you started as Arthur. Maybe I'll try to get through it again and spend more time as John.
OMG me too. I've only gone through the entire story once. I get to Chapter 4 and I start getting so sad...as Chapter 5 and 6 move alone and Arthur gets sicker...I haven't been able to go through the whole story again and just start a new game. But I think I'll try it again so I can finish some of this stuff mentioned.
@@rachelsheppard7232 I almost cried when I thought Sadie and Charles died 😭
Just finished my first play thru and by far my favorite video game ever. Not only are the guns, clothes, and facial hair options really cool but Im a huge fan of the southwest US and am about to move to a state out west in the next couple months. Shout out to Tahitian mango farmers!
The only thing that I wish they added for John is like more interactions with the family. Take Jack fishing or hunting or take Abigail on a date. Get drunk with uncle just something. And should have a lot more bounties for John. Don't get me started on New Austin. So boring
It's a shame that you really don't have much to purchase by the time you get to the epilogue as John . By then the guns have been purchased and most of the horses . Other then some outfits , you really can't take advantage of the money you get .
@number7red619 Damn, I thought I was the only one that had that happen. Really ticked me off every time they shot my horse.
@number7red619 Never lost on on the trains but the Murrfee Brood seems to like to shoot horses. On an ambush by them it was the first thing that happened, twice. I tried to save my horse but ended up dead as well both times. Only wounded on the third and I manage to save him. BTW there is no more Murrfee brood members left alive just for just that reason. It really made me mad.. I'll remember to be more careful around trains, thanks.
This is my second play through the first went kind of fast but all I did was follow the story line. However I recently realized that there is no way for me to get a 100% completion as I am missing a couple of weapons from the gunslingers side mission. Guess I'll just have to play the game again, poor me, lol. By the way this only the second game I ever played. I'm 78 so I guess you could call me a late blooming gamer.
You can actually get Micah’s revolver in colter all you Gotta do is knock an O’driscals gun out his hand and lead him too Micah
This is the only game I’ve ever fully played through more than once
I remember doing the serial killer side quest during 3-4 am, it was so relaxing. I at first was disappointed when I didn't get any unique item in the end, but realized the journey was the reward all long
Great and detailed vid ! Did a first playthrough by only playing the main missions with some side quests and i can see how much i actually missed
After 5 years I finally 100% rdr2 and while I feel happy and relieved after many of the annoyances you have to do in order to obtain 100% completion apart of me feels kind of sad that I will never be able to do anything for the first time again in rdr2
That SOB Arthur died on me… he was supposed to beat black lung after dodging death through train heist after train heist and then a few bank robberies and then being trapped on an island that SOB was supposed to survive.
1:24 actually you can get Micah’s revolver in the mission in chapter 1 where you raid the enemy gang camp all you need to do is disarm one of the enemy gang members and then lead them to micha who will get tackled and drop his gun
If the Epilogue happens few years after the main story end, how is it that those secondary missions are still available when playing John? Means the photographer and the guy who lost his animals have been sitting there for years ? 😅
Just finished my second play through, prolly do Hamish missions then visit Charlotte and start over
Also hunt for perfect pelts to make all outfits item from the trapper. that should keep my busy for a long while.
I will always enjoy working at Beecher’s Hope. It’s so relaxing and a easy way to make some money
The 15 honour points are handy but it's a lot of work for a measly $8
You get 20+ K at the end of the game, what difference is 8$ gonna make lmao. Not that doing some farm work is not immersive, its a cool element actually.
After killing Micah: restart the game over and over, multiple times, Never getting bored, and never will. Playing as Arthur just Fills my dark and empty Soul with happiness. I love playing as John as well, and like them both equally, just playing as Arthur Feels more Special.
It is possible to do all the challenges as Arthur, horseman 10 is easy as Arthur, horseman 9 is also perfectly doable so long as you ensure you have plenty of tonics in your satchel. Herbalist 9 takes a wagon, patience and bags of practice to succeed however and frankly I've never managed it 😅
It's pretty easy besides lote looks better with Arthur
@@imranarmanshah2446how can you get lote as Arthur? I know horseman 9 could perhaps be possible, but not herbalist…right?
@@Mr.Moose.3 Assuming "lote" means Legend of the East, yes, Arthur can get it. Horseman 9 as Arthur is actually reasonably easy. Herbalist 9 is possible, but very difficult. The Legend of the East outfit can be obtained in Chapter 2 or Chapter 3.
For Chapter 3, do all the challenges or all but Herbalist. For Chapter 2, do all the challenges _except_ for Bandit.
Basically, complete whatever challenges you can _except_ for the Gambler Challenge. If you want the outfit in Chapter 2, then you _must_ complete the Herbalist Challenge. If you decide that Herbalist 9 is too difficult, then you must advance to Chapter 3 in order to access the horse fence in order to complete the Bandit Challenge.
To complete Herbalist 9 as Arthur, steal a buggy from St. Denis. Take the buggy to New Austin. The sniper can't shoot you because the buggy is used as a shield. In settings, camera follow has been turned off. It's best to find a video on RUclips showing how it's done so you will know _where_ to locate the herbs. Eagle Eye won't activate when in the buggy.
Now...assuming you complete Herbalist 9, Bandit Challenge isn't necessary. If you decide that Herbalist 9 is too difficult, go on to Chapter 3 and complete Bandit Challenge.
Okay...so you're now in Chapter 2 or Chapter 3. You have completed all of the challenges except for Gambler and either Herbalist or Bandit. *NOW* you want to complete the Gambler Challenge. For Gambler 10 (win 3 hands of poker in a row), you want to _replay_ the Chapter 2 Reverend Swanson mission.
You can either go to Flatneck Station and win 2 hands and _then_ replay the mission, or you can elect to simply replay the mission. When asked to play poker, naturally you accept. You will _always_ win that first hand. Once you win 3 hands in a row, exit the _poker_ game and rescue Reverend Swanson and return him to camp. You now have the Legend of the East outfit. If you win your third hand in a row _without_ replaying the mission, you will have completed the Gambler Challenge...but will still need to complete Herbalist Challenge or Bandit Challenge (whichever one you didn't complete earlier).
@@Mr.Moose.3You are correct. It’s impossible to finish all the challenges as Arthur. Sucks too.
@@iwasright9686it is 100% possible to finish all challenges as Arthur. Look up some RUclips videos, there’s plenty of videos showing Arthur doing Herb 9 and Horseman 9 & 10
You can find Tilly at saint denis and Rains Fall at the annesburg Train station
I like john because i played and beaten the rdr 1 so i love JOHN
Fishing is so monotonous to me, it’s a damn chore.. I have no inclination to complete the legendary fish quest.
Monotonous, tedious and tiresome, it shouldn't be that annoying
I'm still playing game(chapther 3) 300 hours ,playing slowly, almost all crafted and all stuff bought,my map is rich with animals,flowers and findings
Every time I get through the epilogue I wanna stop playing. I just want John to stay with Abigail and Jack
took me about 30hrs to complete arthurs story and about 5 for the epilogue, now i just fish hunt and play poker. It's a good life
Another banger 🤙🏼
HORSEMAN:
I always complete this 10 challenges in the beginning of CH 2.
As you do not need to ride to Blackwater. You can ride - after the bridge - immediately to the left ‘Island’ (peninsula) (left of Bkackwater). Easy ride. The broken bridge is the way harder option.
After getting 100% I went for the platinum trophy. Even more challenges like completing the whole compendium
You should post more often
Best game ever made, nothing comes close.
Fr
Hello, thank you for this video
As usual we like, we comment and we share
Thank you Ahkel! If you want any specific videos covered, just let me know!
@@FilbeeGaming me cover a video? no Boss thank you but I don't know how, but personally I like the mysteries the paranormal and the creepy story, you could tell beautiful terrifying stories with your voice, traditional stories, urban legends of the time by the fireside a bit like campers in RDR
Finally finished the game after years of owning it. I was missing out for sure
Ever since I completed the story, whenever I play or even think about the game, I get this fuzzy feeling in my stomach. I realized how much this game has impacted me. I am changed man now, but I am one without Arthur. This game will NEVER be the same without Mr. Morgan.
I'm replaying missions for "gold rush" trophy and just couple of them left to reach the Platinum trophy. Grindy as hell but satisfying as well.
Kinda wish the Epilogue continued a bit longer before reaching American Venom. It feels cut short when just starting to build up a story for John, Charles, Sadie, Uncle and family. Some more story content in New Austin would have been nice too.
It’s crazy you can actually feel the difference in the map when playing as Arthur compared to John
Yep i like Arthur's insults vs John's
I literally wanna complete the game 100 for once, but damn the gambler challenges
I like how he says its updated quite often but the game hasn't really been serviced in two years.
Did you missed 1.31 update on march 2023 for example?? google it...i like how people missed things but still talk about it
I had to sit through the update in March..... surprised you didn't
Question, after the last mission, does John get some money that Dutch was hiding?
@Ruin_Shattered yes, after you finish the epilogue.
I miss being Arthur there man the time i wasn't allowed in blackwater etc
his voice for a reason: 🚪 🚪 🖤 🖤 🚪 🚪
I must be the only one who loves playing as John
Nah dude, me too
I like that you actually narrate. So many RUclipsrs are silent.
100% completion… Anyone who’s done that knows that gambler blackjack Challenge very well!!!
@@motionprimeaep ???
@@motionprimeaep
Mr Wasp's flower quest was the worst bit about 100% for me, just takes too damn long, it's a drag...
Loved the gun and the hat's the best in the game.
@@DW3010Algernon Wasp's Exotics quest, collecting all the rare orchids and plants...
Absolute nightmare of a quest, was the worst bit of my 100% playthrough
@@mickyb.8014 ah ok. We’re on the same page now. 😄
Dominoes took me longest if all .....fucking hate dominoes
The one side mission I had the most trouble with was the lumber. By the time I got the wagon to the house, it was built. Then that lumber company ups and vanishes. 😂
You can do all the master hunter challenges as Arthur
Great video as I'm replaying but that stuck out; iirc you can do all the challenges as Arthur
Just finished the story and saw this video, thanks bro!❤
Sure thing, I hope you enjoyed
I’m presently grinding just the story. I’m skipping absolutely everything else. Just to see how much John can actually do. I’m holding off beginning stranger missions and challenges and side quests.
I do have a fully bonded Arabian and Shire parked in the stable.
At this point, I expect switching protagonist at the end of the game is just going to become a tradition with this franchise, if they ever make another one
I just got really bored of being drawn to be honest so I just went to my saves and went back as Arthur Morgan. It feels so good
Bruh I’m still on chapter 3 and have just been running around as Arthur for the past 6 years lmao I’m scared to finish it
Loved this ❤
What a video W video 💗🤩
You can also hunt a vampire but idk if you need that for 100%completion.
I broke all the wild horses as Arthur twice without entering New Austin
I finished 100% on story line, 100% on challenges and 100% on compendium. Then I tried RDO (Red Dead Online), but found it full of griefers and modders. It is as good as un-playable. I made my own server (lobby) but that seems to defeat the purpose of the MORPG. So I searched the fora on Facebook and Discord, but only encountered more griefers and modders, or fools who post ridiculous flashing GIFs. I am still looking for some mature players to invite to my RDO server.
Great video. Please more of these
you can get micahs revolver in literally the second mission in the game while you're still in colter lol furthermore you can finish all the challenges and collect all the dinosaur bones as arthur (w/o using any mods)
Dropping fire bottles and dynamite in towns, that's what.
After completing the main story and the epilogue i rode south and came across Fort Mercer and remembered half of RDR 1 is John gathering folks to take down this fort. So i thought i will take down it single handedly and kept my distance snipped everyone in the fort and entered the fort there were two enemies with two gatling guns. Took one out with a dynamite and one out by cover shooting. And ended up finding 200 dollars inside the fort. 10/10 game. Entertaining even after completing the game.
4:45 hahah is that mel gibson haa kidding
@@MikeHenry3280 yessss 🤪
you can get micahs revolver as arthur in chapter 1 in the old friends mission you can get an o'driscoll to disarm micah and you can pick up his revolver
There’s only one thing to do; start over.
I finished the master hunter challenges on chapter2 you don’t have to particularly hunt all legendary animals but you do need to complete 1-9 because challenge 10 is the legendary panther or cugar
Don’t forget extra side missions in swamp and cabin in tall trees.
I enjoyed this. Your voice reminds me of Klaw from Avengers: Age of Ultron.
Cuttlefish!!!!
I was able to complete all but the herbalist challenge as Arthur. (just last month - (I have the latest version on PS4))? Still trying... The buggy idea is not as easy as some make it look! I've only ever done 99%. Hate that mission for hat feathers!
Working through my second play through, taking my time with it as I missed so much first time round.
I’ve had the game since launch and still to this date is my favourite game of all time.
Watching Wallaby Kid RP online it's amazing. He does such a good job with the charecter. Over 200 episodes 6 hours each in length. You get addicted if you start watching.
All I do is explore the wild west I made it to mexico with mods
Still running single player in 2025
@@TTVBunnyDougie just got a ps4 for Christmas 😅. I've been playing ps3 until last month 🙃 just played rdr1 last month
I just finished story😢😢 ive visited arthur grave one last time before logout
Finished my first play through yesterday
Thank You for this inspiring video! I didn't know that i can meet Mary Beth in Valentine (i had a little crush on her). By the way: You can meet Tilly in Saint Denis ...
I am about 300 hours and i can not stop playing RDR2. It is the best computer game i ever played.
I would love to buy a DLC with a few more quests, encounters and enterable buildings even so many years after release.