Review - Trend Airshield Pro Respirator
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 авг 2024
- The Trend Airshield Pro is designed to protect the woodworker from dust and other hazards in the workshop. It weighs just 995 grams, is comfortable to wear and is not noisy. Do check the Trend web site for details specific to your country.
Хобби
I just purchased the Airshield Pro and unboxed just now as I watched your video. Your video made set up a snap! As a woodworker with allergies, I’m looking forward to trying this product out in my shop. Thank you for posting this informative and helpful video. Hello from Chicago, USA
Glad I could help! Cheers. Peter
Thank you Peter, another brilliant review as always. Very in depth and informative and I will probably buy one.
Nicely done, and looking brilliant in high definition!
Thank you for this review. It was most helpful as I am shopping for a respirator. This has helped me to confirm that this is what I need. Thanks from Nova Scotia, Canada.
Harold McLellan Hi Harold, I spent 2 fantastic years in Canada but did not visit Nova Scotia. Good luck with the respirator. Peter
@@NewBritWorkshop does this protect against fumes and the Corona virus?
Thank you Jaap for that insight. I certainly know from using it that it does the job. Peter
My elder brother and I learnt a lot from dear old Dad. We often talk about him and wonder how he would tackle this or that task. I will research TIMco. Enjoy your new Festools. Peter
A very clear video, thanks for that!
Glad it was helpful!
Glad I found this video as I had just bought a new air shield, Just got it charger yesterday and tested it last night, I would have to disagree with regard to the noise off the motor, as I found it quite bad and will have to use ear defenders even if I am only doing light work, I have been using an aircap for the past five years and it is much quieter.
Hi William,
My hearing is not so good and so I can put up with quite a bit! In the UK this is under £300 and is great value for money.
Peter
Hi, Peter my wife tells me the same, so I have put in a birthday request for the ear defenders, but will use plugs until then, it's only end off March.
Awesome! TY!!!
I am so sorry to hear about your grandfather. I have just become a granddad for the first time. Both of my grandfathers died before I was born and so I have never sat on granddad's knee unlike my new grandson. I started explaining the merits of Festool tools to him and the next thing I knew - he was fast asleep. Peter
I plan to do a shop tour soon and will include my various vacuums and extractors. Peter
I bought one of these two weeks ago for £189. I had to readjust the top band a few times as it was giving me a stiff neck and making me top heavy but now its much better. It would be better if the battery and filter were on your belt. The other downside is that it only protects you from dust and woodturners use solvents and aerosols.
I have been working with wood since 1962 (1958 if you count woodwork at school) and dust has accounted for almost half my lungs so hopefully this air pro will protect the other half.
Good luck with that - I agree the unit takes some getting used to. Peter
Just found your video. It is a very well made production. I bought the Trend in Australia. Here it costs the equivalent of 341 pounds. I am dreading having to pay for new filters. Its a good unit with strong airflow although it is top heavy and hard to get used to wearing particularly the tendency to tilt forward when you look down. Adjustments will prevent that to an extent but may also make it tight to wear. The only think your video did not mention was the level of protection offered by the face shield from flying timber bits.
+Greg T Hi Greg, The face shield is reasonably robust and is made from a non shattering material. It is impossible for me to test face shields and so we have to rely on the manufacturer's word and reputation. Cheers. Peter
Hi Greg, it's been 2 months since your comment. How have you found the airsheild so far? Do you find it worth the money? Do you know of any competition to the shield? And out of curiosity, what work do you do.
Cheers
+New Brit Workshop (Peter)
Hi peter, love your video I'll subscribe.
Do you know of any other battery dust mask/face shields.
I'm just curious of the competition if there is any.
+David Plüshy
Oh and what retail store dos you buy it
Woof
I bought it from Carbatec in Australia. It is a very effective mask but it is also bulky and takes a long while to adjust to suit. Carbatec sell another much smaller mask with a belt mounted, battery operated motor that is light and easy to use. However it can fog up your glasses occasionally which the Trend won't do. It is a lot cheaper than the Trend.
have full confedens in gating one , after your video x
Hi Steven, Super. Peter
Quite a voice you have
Your videos for the Trend Airshield Pro powered respirator and 3M Versa Flo respirators are very informative. After many years of use, what is your "go to" respirator for your every day woodworking?
Hi Doug, Without a doubt it is the Trend Airshield Pro - it is so easy to put on and take off, is comfortable for long periods and the battery lasts a good length of time. The ear defenders are also very comfortable. Cheers. Peter
Hi ,Peter since I replied to you last month I have been trying to get used to my new trend I have now found that my breath is condensing on the visor, I put it down to it being winter but it has not been that cold, I have tried my old air cap and have not had this problem, also find that the helmet tends to tilt forward when I am turning, any ideas as what the problem might be, everything is as tight as I can get it, or if anyone else has similar problem. thanks.
I was able to get it adjusted quite well but it is a little top heavy which is really something to get used to. I do mention the fitting in the video.
Peter
Hello.Does anyone know if this device need a face fit certificate in UK?
Good review Peter. Having tested both the Versaflow and the 3M system which would you recommend for quality and usability?
There is no doubt that "you pay for what you get". There is no fair comparison between the two as they are so different in price. The Trend provides an affordable solution with some minor compromises. The Versaflo, in my view, is absolutely fantastic and worth every penny. Peter
thanks for the fast response Peter, i'm going with the flo.....lol
Good decision. Peter
I am a little confused by his question and your response. Are you saying that the 3M versaflow is the superior product? (3M M-100 Series Versaflo Respiratory Faceshield Assembly M-107, with Premium Visor and Faceseal). It seems less expensive than the currently priced Trend unit... please let me know your thoughts as I am seriously considering this type of device. By the way, I am in Florida where it can be quite warm and humid much of the year.
Less expensive but without the respirator unit itself , the connecting tube and the filter cartridge, all those you buy separately. See: multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/781327O/3m-powered-and-supplied-air-purifying-respirator-systems-matrix.pdf
Thanks for the video, but one question about your shoes, what is the trade mark?
Thank you.
JustMeNoOther Nike. Peter
Hi Peter, looking to get something like this,do you still have yours and how do you like it. I was wondering if Axminster has something similar.....can't find too much here in Canada.....cheers
I am now using the 3M Versaflo as the Trend did not have a good solution for ear defenders. Axminster do both. Cheers. Peter
I have the Trend pro and also the evolution from axminster and the evolution is miles better, i have had problems with the Trend head strap breaking easily and after lots of different adjustments still find it uncomfortable to wear. battery lose and always bleeping. and there both around the same price to pay for. will soon be getting rid of my trend and will get an another evolution.
Hi Andrew, That is excellent feedback. I have not tried the Axminster Evolution but, from what you say, it sounds very good indeed. Cheers. Peter
Andrew. I don't doubt there are problems with the Trend (I have a Versaflo, so don't know first hand). BUT saying the Evolution is "miles better" ignores the significant difference in respiratory protection offered - you're not comparing like with like.
EN12941:2008 rates products by 'inward leakage' - how effective they are. Axminster 'Evolution' is TH1P, which means 10% inward leakage - in other words it's 90% effective. Trend Airshield Pro is TH2P, which means 2% inward leakage - in other words it's 98% effective.
In the context of hardwood dust being toxic (see HSE WIS30) and a known human carcinogen (see COSHH Schedule 1), the difference between 10% and 2% inward leakage seems quite significant.
The only thing that put me off was on the trend website "Warning The TREND AIRSHIELD PRO is not a RESPIRATOR nor a NIOSH approved device. Using the power visor against harmful substances may result in sickness or death. This filter will not protect your lungs. Misuse may result in sickness or death. For proper use, see supervisor or user instructions." probably only to cover themselves as it isn't niosh tested but off putting non the less..
Hello Peter, after about 6 years a question ... do you really use the Airshield Pro in your enviroment? Or the Airflo from 3M? It seems to me, that this products were eventually a hype?
I use the 3M Versaflo having started with the Trend. The latter was a little awkward and the ear defender option was not good at all. The 3M is brilliant. Peter
@@NewBritWorkshop Thank you for your reply. And how often do you use ist and in which usercases? Woodturning? circular saw or mitersaw? ...
I use it whenever I think that there might be excess dust. I always use it if cutting up sheets of MDF and often when planing large quantities of wood especially hard woods. Peter
@@NewBritWorkshop Thank you very much for your answers :-) and stay healthy :-)
When you are at your suppliers take your time when you try one on. Make sure that you adjust it properly - it should be quite comfortable. Do a quick search for the best internet prices and see what discount you can get. The bottom line is that everyone must protect their nose, throat and lungs. Peter
Thanks for the review Peter, very informative. I currently use the power pro ip cap but its coming to its end and will pick up a trend very soon. Off topic, I see you use a lot of festol. I was just wondering if you could run through your shop filtration system. Thanks in advance
i guys, i ve just bought this unit but have a some problems. 1, feeling a little cold. 2. smelling a sawdust while operating it. thanks
Hi Ales, I have not experienced this problem. Perhaps the face seal is not fitting as it should. Peter
Hi Peter, thanks for your response, I put on it again a couple of times and could smelt everything during cutting(sanding,..) The face seal it doesnt fitting as you said but its a brand new. I cant see that there is any chance to be improved. The seal cant be tight more there is always a little gap and air from outside penetrate inside. And as I mentioned, the air is a pretty cold after some times, I read some reviews and a quite a lot people experienced same problem. I really want to believe that this works but I'm highly disappointed. In my opinion, It is not worth it to spend money on it because simply it is not works as it is advertised..
Are the hearing protectors effective or just little muffs?
I did not show any ear defenders with this kit and I have not tried them at all. Others have reported that the ear defenders designed to fit with this kit are less than satisfactory. Peter
Thanks for the response because I was thinking they likely aren't the greatest due to their small appearance. I sent away for the helmet a few days ago and I guess I'll just have to wait and see. I have some pretty good ones, so now I'm wondering if I can "engineer" something effective from them if I need to.
The reduction in noise seems quite good but they are fiendishly difficult to assemble and fit. I’m 68 and my hands aren’t strong now. I’m disappointed with mine.
Hi Jim, Other people have said the same thing. It is a pity that the ear defenders let the system down. Peter
The Airshield is a good concept let down by poor design. The headband snaps, mine is held together by tie wraps, and the battery pack comes loose in it's mounting so it frequently sounds the "low battery" alarm. This is easily remedied by poking it with my finger. I also have a Powercap dust mask which also has design flaws. Out of the two the Airshield gets more use because it is quicker and easier to put on.
Les Heath Hi Les, It is useful to give people views like this from someone who has had theirs in use for a while and has discovered some potential faults. Many thanks. Peter
It's approved to EU standards, but not US standards. EU standards for most health/safety things are just as strict as US standards, if not stricter. It's just a matter of going through the bureaucracy.
I bought mine a month and a half ago. It came with broken pieces (I think it was returned by someone else and just sent back out) It's top heavy with the battery and I can't find a fit where the shield doesn't hit my glasses. Attempts to reach Trend failed both by phone and email.
I feel I wasted a lot of money.
David Enoch Hi David, I am sorry that you have had a bad experience. I did not have problems with my glasses but I agree that you have to get used to the weight. I still believe that the Trend setup is the best value in its price bracket - are you sure you got the adjustment right? Peter
Peter, I've tried every hole in the upper band, when it starts to feel close the visor hits my glasses. If I remove them, my nose hits the shield.
When I try again, and I will, I'm going to try bolstering the band that touches my brow to see if I can move the whole assembly forward.
D
David Enoch If you watch the video you can see that there is a huge amount of clearance between the front visor and my glasses. Perhaps the respirator is sitting too low and therefore you need to tighten the strap adjuster that is above the head of the wearer. Peter
I seem to gain more room the lower the unit sits. I'm sure when I'm less frustrated I'll try again. I'll get back with you one way or the other.
D
New Brit Workshop Peter, I finally took some time with the adjustments and think I've got it. It has been so long that I must recharge the battery before trying to use it. D
Anybody boughg cleanspace air powerd respirator?
This is anything but a "pro" product. I've had mine for around 3 months and use it in the shop mainly at weekends. Battery life is ok BUT if you should drop or bang it, the plastic strap at the back will break at one or both hinges. The plastic should have been at least double the thickness and it would have added hardly any weight. It's really not worth the money. It's also very top heavy. Very cheap quality.
Hi Joe, Can you recommend any other product in the same price range as this - it would be useful to get your views? Peter
This airshield has a serious design flaw. The plastic headband breaks easily, mine has broken, been replaced, and broken again...in less than a year. For an expensive item it should be better made.
This is the first report of such a problem. Have you contacted Trend about this ? Peter
noisy
not good enough
14hrs to charge a battery - what a joke
Hi Matthew, Yes, in this day and age it seems a lot but it can at least be done overnight. Cheers. Peter
New Brit Workshop sorry Peter That’s no good, a lot of people in the industry work 12 hrs a day and then if you count an hr home and back that’s 14 hrs a day.
The battery only lasts 8 hrs so it is no good at all - definitely not worth paying £200+ for a piece of junk that takes 14 hrs to charge and only lasts for 8 hrs - which means someone would actually need 4 batteries to make it worthwhile so you can take 2 to work & charge 2 while you are at work.
Which really is not really practical.
Furthermore how strong is the helmet?
Whilst wearing it you obviously can’t wear a hard hat on top of it which means the minute Health & Safety rock up on site I would be told to take it off.
While I do like the idea I do think it needs updating to Lithium Ion batteries and than bringing the helmet up to the same standard as a hard hat.
A lot of batteries on site now take 20 min to charge and last for hrs so really I think it is ridiculous to pay such a fortune for a piece of junk that’s been fitted with an outdated battery.
I for 1 will not be buying this rubbish but I will however wait until what I have suggested to happen before I consider buying one.
Furthermore whilst I can afford it I do think it is way to highly priced compared to other FFP3 masks on the market so I would also wait for it to come done in price.
I can pay like £1 -£3 for some of my Trend filters and just a little bit more for FFP3 filters.
Hi Matthew, I understand your points but in order to find a product with the capabilities that you seek you need to spend a lot more money. I would recommend the 3M Versaflo if you want perfection. Peter