Deng's biggest contribution, in my eye, is to make the country and people to put pragmatism ahead of ideology, so that legitimacy should be based on outcome which drives the party and government to continually deliver to the people.
Trump wants President Putin to exposed Hunter Biden Hijacking Ukraine Oil and Gas Scam ! Sleepy Joe poll rating is dropping like a Stone. *Can Trump Kick Sleepy Joe out of the White House* ?
Deng and his successors were responsible for China being the economic powerhouse it is today with economic reforms, enabling China to join the WTO, opening up trade to west and welcoming foreign investments. China fostered good relations with other countries, there was a cultural exchange with foreigners coming to china to work and to visit, and chinese people going abroad to study and live. Things started changing when Xi wrested power... he's taking China two steps back to the Mao era, promoting nationalism and ideology(Xi Jinping thought and his own little red book). Clashes with other countries are more frequent now, public opinion of China in other countries is down, anti-foreigner sentiments are being pushed by the CCP/CPC, foreign cultural influence is being clamped down. I think he's trying to control the population with propaganda(50 cent army) and censorship. I'm concerned about what he has planned for China and SE/East Asia.
@@kittybrowneye3163 Tianmen massacre were just students demanding democracy, Jan 6 are like right winged militias like Oath Keepers, Proud Boys and many trump supporters. But the response was so disparingly different though. CHina responded against students with tanks and APCs while America only had a few Capitol Police on the scene if im not wrong.
@Daniel Piotrowicz IS it China's responsibility to save you and your country? There is today more inequalities in the US than China. Maybe you should take a look at that first.
Some errors which created by the trade embargo from 1949-1979; blocking PRC from accessing the "international market"; forcing PRC to trade with the socialist bloc only. See how the capitalist bloc/imperialist bloc uniting the anti-imperialist bloc and creating starvation? No western media dare to mention it.
"A century of revolution" what a good way to describe the CPC. Always changing, always adapting, nothing can stop the revolution of the Chinese civilization.
I am an expatriate in China since 1998. While I am not big fan of Mao, but people need to remember not only he brought the country into unity again, but he also laid the foundation for Deng. From 1949 to Mao's death, the countries life expectancy increased from 38 to 65, that's more than double the improvement in the world during the same period, that's equivalent to hundreds of millions of lives saved. Illiteracy rate dropped from 80% to 25%. He established social, racial and gender equality. Most Mainland Chinese regard him a hero with flaws, which I find more appropriate than him being branded a demon by people outside of China. This documentary also failed to mention that Tiananmen's Incident has a part to do with funding by the CIA, very much like the Hong Kong riot in 2019. More soldiers were killed than the students. Today, if we ask the Mainland Chinese the single person that they hate the most, one name regularly pops up, Chai Ling, the student leader who took money from the CIA to create the movement. She was as notorious as Li Hong Zhi, the founder of the Cult Fa Lun Gong.
@@ellis9084 Chai Ling encouraged her fellow students to continue their hunger strike and to be ready to shed blood, as she departed the square for the United States. In contrast to her and other "student leaders," the Chinese populace holds a greater degree of respect for Xiaobo Liu, not because they agree with Liu's proposition that "China needs to be colonized for 300 years to modernize," but because he held on his beliefs and engaged in a direct struggle with the CPC on Chinese soil.
a deep insight on CPC journey, highlighting the obstacles and development it achieved in 100 years. A great example to look forward. "Doesn't matter if the Cat is Black or White, as long as it catches the mouse, it is good". What a visionary Man Deng was. Long Live China!!!
WHAT CHINA HAS ACHEIVED THROUGH HARD WOFK N DISCIPLINE IS NOTHING SHORT OF INCREDIBLE . IN JUST 50 YEARS CHINA HAS BROUGHT THE FUTURE FORWARD TO THIS VERY MOMENT IN TIME. AS LONG AS THEY KEEP FOCUS N KNOW WHO IS WHO THEY WILL BE AROUND FOR MANY MANY DECADES TO COME. DETERMINATION N NEVER SAY NEVER IS AN ASIAN THING. BIG UP TO CHINA. TO KMOW IS THE GREATEST . BLESSSD LOVE N MAXIMUM RASPECT .. .
Finally an unbiased Documentary. Thank you CNA from Germany. The only thing we get told about China here in the West is that its bad. This opinion is leaded by the US who hates competition and is known for destroying countrys with other systems than the US is using. I Visited China 3 Times already, 2 times Japan and i want to visit Singapore when Covid lets us do it, someone has tips what is worth seeing around? doesnt matter if more rural or city, i would be very thankful.
Excellent documentary, only the Chinese people themselves are best positioned to comment on the whether the CPC has improved the quality of their lives. Haters: how much did the CPC pay CNA?
Ok wumao how about the uygurs why don't they get a vote? Your saying the people of china a country with a social credit score system are the only ones who can complain, but they can't or they'll be punished severely. So basically your saying no one can comment then? So done with Chinese propaganda bs the ccp is terrible and you gave yourself away as a shill when you used the dog whistle cpc. Your lies won't work forever wumao
Finally there is a foreigner understands we Chinese people. Western media has no right and qualifications to comment if the Cpc is good or bad. Only Chinese can talk about that.
@@junzheyang9743 no they can't that's why they have a social credit score you bash the ccp you pay for it so very few due. Wumao suck you guys are literally spending your day getting paid spreading propaganda so a totalitarian regime can persecute its own people and hurt millions all over the world. You guys are gross individuals
@@LaowaiDaveJCP That "greater good" was the same excuse that Hitler used while tossing 6 million Jews into furnaces. Same excuse that Mao used while selling grain to the USSR while 40 million Chines starved. Same excuse that Stalin used to send 5 million killed or to Siberia.
@@warrenlauzon5315 except that none of the incident or the big names you just mention has anything to do with China? I thought you're gonna include Thanos too lol🤣🤣 The greater good is right infront of you just get your eyes open once for godsake 🥱
@Lord Word those students died in 8964 are cancer cells? Well, quite the contrary. They are the benign ones. only cancer cells can match China's impressive growth rate. So do we only have cancer cells left in the country? Maybe Xi should eliminate those bad members that is not as evil and dishonest as those immoral and greedy ones, to further boost the growth rate?
@Lord Word those young students fighting for democracy in 1989 are not qualified to be called as cancer cells. they are unarmed, they are just too weak. The Party's Liberation Army is more qualified to be granted the crown. PLA cells are a lot more aggressive and powerful.
@Lord Word the invincibility illusion CPC wants its resident cells to believe the body is functioning perfectly is by suppressing all the feeling from pain nerve and mask it with pain killers, or completely cut off the neurons from the networks so you don't feel the pain. With all the early warnings turned off, Your limbs are already bleeding and damaging from the far end. It will come to your trunk. Just wait and see.
No matter the political system, individual prosperity and a decent life is above everything else that includes American style democracy. Singapore is the best and most successful example of all and China is very similar in that aspect.
Singapore Prime Minister Li Guang Yao participated in the design and construction of China. They may have wanted to build a larger version of Singapore
@@sleepya3129 yes, but only a giant country like china can advance in all fronts, such as artificial intelligence, military might, space exploration. While Singapore is wildly successful and inspired Beijing throughout the years, China is impressive in its own might..
Nice to see some unbiased objective Documentary on China for a change. A Political party is like a person in a new job. When he's new hire in the job, he'll make many mistakes, but what's important is whether he learns from those mistakes or not and CPC seems to be doing just that. They always learn from their mistake and change accordingly
On job training failed for 40 years with egghead communism countries, long enough to have 10 administration changes if in US. until switched to get help from other more capable colleagues like USA who helped push China into WTO and hand held China to get a lot of investments to set up factories and transferring orders. The thriving China owes US a sincere big thank you. To tutors like Taiwan and HK as well. After on job training for 70 years, despite slow start, for how much longer would the nanny Party let go control to give working class babies more room for speech, freedom to move within the border without Hukou hindrance, practice any religion as promised in the constitution? There are 300 million richer babies ready to become adult. Hurry up or those over 65 years old are going to eat up your pension funds. Time to Convert China from a giant nanny Party country to a modern responsible citizen owned country.
@Lord Word babies want to grow. Nannies should go and let the constitution do its job unless the nanny really is milking a lot out of baby leets. You are right, do it rather than say it. Be practical. Freedom of speech is just one of the rights in the Chinese constitution.
@Lord Word in your last comment you were talking about chairman Xi I said he could swing on a short rope you said you agreed now what is it since the thread magically disipered
China had the largest economy in the world before the optimum war 1848. So there should not be any surprise China will become the largest economy again 200 years later.
My personal dislike for KMT was their leader let Rape of Nanking happened. The soldiers trapped the Chinese civilians inside to slow the Japanese down. The nationalist soldiers wore civilians clothings to escape. They did the same thing in Taiwan with White terror. Anyway.. I asked this question and got some great responds. See the source for the credits. Can anyone explain to me why KMT lost to the CCP with only a few hundred members? Philip Ting: US supported the nationalist during China independence war because it allow Western colonial power to continue to own the land and businesses. They lost the war despite having overwhelming fire power and escape to Taiwan. The communist won because they were supported by most of the Chinese people as they were impoverished. Taiwan is still a colony of US. Maybe an autonomous colony. DG CU-T: The generals of CCP were more united and won several decisive battles, where as KMT was relatively corrupted and internal conflicts among different fractions only exacerbated the situation. The "evil CCP" depicted by the western media occurred probably 20 years later after the civil war; the warrior who slaughtered the dragon become dragon itself. Michael Zhang: Before ccp, there was a party called KMT that was corrupted and plunged China into poverty and civil war. Come here to China ask any elders beyond 70 yrs old hows their life before ccp. You'll know how grateful they are. (Yes I'm telling you from my personal experience because all the elders in my families love ccp.) Yin Zhen Yang: kmt has too many faction infighting, its run by ex noble and big landlord families. In a country consist mostly farmers and peasant and drought, feminine run wild. Every soldier u train potentially coming from poor rural farmer family, the vision of a country where everyone were equal, every fortune are share, is.way more attractive that fighting for the landlords whom doesnt treat u like a human. Basically kmt is in the situation of every collapsing dynasty, overthrow directly or indirectly by the peasant or farmer uprising. Source ruclips.net/video/uCylfY21l3Y/видео.html The fact is the economy was destroyed before CCP took over. Go to check what ROC did in Shanghai. The commodity price are rising every second, even university Professor’s monthly wage can not afford one meal. Further information you can go to check the results of the first 5 years plan and first 3 years plan. -Chaos Andy China was in deep poverty ever since the Qing Dynasty lost the Opium War and robbed by the western powers through treaties. KMT's corrupted government brought China into even deeper trouble. When KMT retreated to Taiwan, they transported hundreds of ships of gold with them hence China was basically valueless. CCP was left with nothing. -Jeff H If you're still reading, check this out. Chris wallace: Mao became a leader for the Chinese peasants by sheer grit, at a time when they took on both the brutal Japanese occupiers and the self-serving business elite (the Nationalists). Americans are appalling ignorant about China during the difficult years (1930's-40's). The US foreign service in China at the time (a highly competent, knowledgeable and professional group of civil servants) recommended that the US support Mao but the US government turned them down, kicked them out of China and replaced them with an inept but politically responsive legation that supported the Nationalists. This led to a freeze on Sino-US relations for the next 20+ years! 神州 Shenzhou: Mao Zedong saved China, he transformed China from a weak and divided country into strong and unified one today. When Dr Sun overthrew the previous Qing Dynasty China and established "democratic" Republic of China (1912-1949) China was divided into several areas, we lost control of Tibet, and various warlords ruled different parts of China and even Japan invaded China twice during this weak period of Chinese history. Dr. Sun tried to get help from the Western powers, but they laughed at the thought of China copying their democracy. They even gave away the Shandong province (which had been occupied by the Germans during WWI) to Japan, instead of returning it to China (even when China was part of the Allies during WWI). In the end, Dr. Sun died without ever realising a unified China under democracy. But then Mao Zedong came along, and he accomplished what the ROC could not, and reunifed China under communism, proclaiming the People's Republic of China in 1949 and Tibet was finally returned back to China in 1951. If not for Mao Zedong, China today would still be weak and divided country, fighting among ourselves, instead of the strong unified country we are today. The CPC had 600 battles vs the Japanese and kmt. A lot of brave soldiers lives were lost. Making a New China Ep 03: The Long March ruclips.net/video/LqidzkM3_RA/видео.html Facts Tell: What's behind the mainland-Taiwan divide? ruclips.net/video/ML9rpzgvlu4/видео.html
What should be emphasized is not internal conflict but external aggression, which gave rise to the pursuing internal conflict. Westerners do not want to confront this reality. The formation of the CPC has been the response to this external aggression.
the formation of the CPC was a good example of forieng power collusion with the aim to overthow the Chinese nation. CPC could justify its existence better should it respond to Japanese external aggressions during the WWII by actively participating into combats and protect the country. Unfortunately they didn't intend to but focus on growing their organization and military power during the war time. I wonder if intenal conflict doesn't need to be emphasized, why on earth the annual stability maintainance budget is at the same level as the China's defense budget? Isn't China a happy society without much conflicts?
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan The creation of the CPC had been in response to foreign aggression, without which there will be no CPC at all. That the Soviet had became much friendly, less racist, toward China after the Bolshevik Resolution had been an additional factor. China's cultural weakness only became salient and obvious to the Chinese as China suffered from foreign aggression, even as the struggle over cultural change could well be regarded as internal conflict. The first emphasis should be on the cause, with the consequences to follow.
@@woodensurferyour comment is just too abstract, not coming down to the earth. Just Explain to me two things: 1. where does the hammer and the sickle come from in CPC's emblem, is that genuinely from China? (Compared to KMT whose emblem from Lu How dong and the ideology coming from Dr Sun yat sen) By foreign aggression, is that Japan or what? Hasn't that been a present continuous since 1840 at that time? Read the CPC 1st national congress history, it was meant to be the Soviet's subsidiary in China. So this isn't a collusion with USSR? It clearly violates the national security law if it's today. 2. Why is the stability budget so high. Where is the instability if it's been so successful as CPC has been claiming.
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan First, I have just told you that the Soviet after the Bolshevik Revolution had became much more friendly and less racist to China than Czarist Russia. Second, a symbol is just a symbol of a certain facet; it does not need acceptance in totality, regardless. The Soviet was the only power that had aided China before the onset of WWII, for China it was 1937. The US backed the anti-republic establishment. It was not perplexing that Sun Yet-sen had warm feeling toward the Soviet. The Soviet, unlike Czarist Russia, was a new friend by the triumph of socialism. This is one reason why socialism has been viewed as salubrious--by association. Then one should not forget the Soviet war against Japan starting 1945, after which Northeastern China, aka Manchuria, was returned to China. War-lordship is a kind of internal conflict that had been common in China throughout history. How it could have ended should not be expected as revolutionary, while the fervent embrace of socialism should be. What is instability? I don't know what you are referring to, but threat to territorial integrity is one source.
@@woodensurfer ah! So you are not a Chinese resident? Sorry for not providing the context then. You probably don't know that the Chinese administration nowadays is accusing almost everything of collusion with foreign power and external entity influence and considers these national security threat. that's why I keep arguing the CPC itself ever since its establishment was a collusion to threaten the national security for the Chinese government back then. I am arguing to Chinese people that you can't just keep finger pointing but pretending the Party is already great, glorious, and just. Two, regarding the instability budget. The Chinese administration hires millions of people to censor their citizen to an extent that it is on par with their expenses on defense. Just search for "China stability maintenance budget"
The USA has never been a responsible world nation....it has been a profit-orientated nation that has shown little respect for human rights and democracy in countries it exploited or controlled. China may be authoritarian but internally it does have exchanges of opinions and democratic processes within the party. The western popular democracies are not like the original ideas of western democracy which was restricted to a minority of the population, only gradually it was extended to women and to people without means. If the group or party in power has integrity and shows good governance some of the elements of modern western democracies may not be important. A serious weakness of western democracies is that the voters generally are not very competent in what is necessary to make a country prosper but are easily influenced by misinformation, distortion of facts, media coverage, and single events. Also, it is basically impossible to make very long-term targets for future development. In reality, different interest groups seem to be the true drivers of the "democratic" process in the western democratic model making it nontransparent and maybe de facto less democratic than China.
@@ellis9084 Actually not, I think the CHinese people are just as smart as anybody else. What I say is democracy is something you have to learn. It is some expectations and some culture, it has to grow and evolve, this may take a couple of generations. When a people has been used to authoritarian rule, it is difficult to change the mind.
@@bjrnhjortshjandersen1286 I agree Chinese people very smart and if they had freedom they would be world leaders and prosperous just look at how successful the Taiwanese are
@@ellis9084 I believe they could.....but that is not really what they do. Have you ever reflected on how little you know about the politicians we elect? We elect a perception and some general beliefs about what values and politics they would like to support. But in the USA you have a lot of money involved ...and that feeds different levels of corruption....you can buy influence because money is needed to get elected. And more or less.... politicians are bought.
Interesting to listen to you Professor Wang. Yours must be one of the most interesting and significant descriptions of historical facts of our time. Thank you sir for telling it.
Authoritarianism if done right it can transform medieval society into modern country in pace of 40-50 years, China isnt the first, the mass mobilization of the entire nation have been done before under emperor Meiji of Japan then followed by Lee Kwan Yew way of ruling Singapore. If done wrong, it will be like Venezuela and North Korea
You're right in the sense, that a wise benevolent and immortal dictator is inherently more effective in getting things done for the good of the people compared to democracies - even the ancient Greek philosophers and Niccolo Machiavelli also attests to it though they also recognise its catch. As unfortunately, the only one whose CV matches those requirements is God, as Man is inherently flawed, where even the best of us makes mistakes and we aren't immortal to perpetuate such wisdom. Hence, democratic systems inherently lends itself to better governance (but not necessarily all the time) as it allows for greater checks and balance, and allows the citizenry to choose the best person to lead them in the direction that they wish to go (even if it's a bad one). Hence, like authoritarian regimes, democracy sometimes messes up when the majority makes bad choices especially when bitter pills need to be swallowed, but that's the inherent nature of choice. It should also be noted that not all "democratic" nations implement democracy well and have well functioning governments. On a side note, I think part of the rapid rise of the Asian Tigers was because we fast tracked the entire industrial revolution phase. Back when the Western powers were industrialising, they were still working on the R&D of the steam engine and globalisation wasn't that big a thing yet, so things were moving much slower.
You realise that both Venezuela and North Korea are under massive US sanctions? They literally can’t trade with the rest of the world except for a few who could afford to (Russia, China, Iran, etc...) AND all their assets, reserves and gold abroad have been -stolen- sized. Can you imagine how hard it is to manage a country under such restrictions?
Wang Gungwu's take is interesting when he says that now it's an international competition between a 'liberal capitalism' of US and 'authoritative capitalism' of China. Because the capitalist system itself is authoritative.
Every party and government will make mistakes. It's all up to how you react and respond afterwards. To have mistakes institutionalized, you would be doomed sooner or later. If you can push for self-reform to correct and avoid mistakes, you are evolving to be better.
@@gofar5185 That's what sets China apart from most nations. Chinese leaders can learn from leaders of the past, reforming and changing what didnt work while keeping what did work. Western governments are most of the time erasing what their predecessors did.
@@guilhermezardo7671 ancient china has many sages and philospers and many enlightened scholars who taught the "making and shaping an everlasting civilization" and leaders (big and small) listened to them... thus china/east asia civilization is gradually shaped and OUTLIVED many world civilizations...
44:03 "Will China be a responsible global power if it replaces the US?" I think this is a wrong question to ask. You should ask, has the US been a *responsible* world leader all these years? A world leader should be a just leader, treating everyone the same way, including himself. But what we see is, America is ganging with a bunch of hatchet men "allies" and go around the world to beat up anyone who dares to disagree with him. And worst, even make up lies about other countries, and then go in and kill their people destroy their homeland. And you westerners call this a "responsible" behavior? How would you like it if China does exactly the same way as America when it becomes the world leader?
It's not going to be a global leader don't believe the ccps lies Taiwan USA Japan great Britain and all the decent nations will never let it happen America is going to loose patience and cut off the oil supply and deny American dollars and then ccps fuked cos u can't use China's useless currency , why don't they just admit that America saved china from the Japanese in ww2 and just stick to being green with envy
This 32 year old CEO surely a joke. Studying music & art for decade in western country then became founder of multiple startups that unrelated to his expertise. Surely he was born to rich family or his father was high ranking Party Member. Nothing to be proud if you using your daddy money to start multiple startup.
In the last days of Deng when he was lying critically sick on the bed, he was asked what he thought his most outstanding achievement was. Everyone thought he was going to say opening-up, but he answered that his best achievement was maintaining Party leadership and stability after Tiananmen.
It was indeed the most dangerous time for the CPC and China... just imagine what would have happened if those so-called student leaders and freedom fighters took power in 1989.
And who are the motherfuckers who caused the deaths of 45 million Chinese during the Great Famine and another 30million duri8ng the Cultural Revolution again?
The title of this documentary is a bit misleading, asking what's next and then covering its history. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but not what I came here for
CPC came into existence thru democratic means: they won the war against KMT and the majority of people supported them. True, the vast majority in China till recently were from rural areas. Images of starvation showed in this video were taken during the war with Japan in the 1930s, not during the 1950s. The Cultural Revolution was the biggest mistake the then Gang of Four inflicted on Chinese cultural heritage. It's time to rebuild what was destroyed during this period.
@@PlanetCHINA.1 China is a paper dragon controlled by a totalitarian regime and your wolf warrior crap just made enemies with the entire world. Your not on the rise of anything, the ccp is about to get thrown off a cliff. It's too bad you guys spend your time spreading propaganda instead of removing the ccp. China rose up because the ccp allowed capitalism basically an admission communism doesn't work and the west allowed worked with them because they thought as they got richer they'd become freer, the ccp has proved that not to be the case and using our greedy western businessmen and stealing ip is going to get harder and harder. When stuff stops working out, the ccp will start getting more totalitarian and controlling which they're already doing and the people of China will suffer even more. You guys know as soon as you type cpc we know your paid wumao. Sure you upped your foreign propaganda spending 500% good for the ccp but it's not working, we all know it's propaganda
@@PlanetCHINA.1 you just lowered your poverty line to $471 lol, china's income per capita is 2 times lower than Brazils a poor country and 5 times lower than the US. The ccp still claims China as a developing nation and takes in billions of dollars in foreign aid, there are more slaves in China right now than America had in its entire history. I think you guys have some stuff to work on before you think about Mars maybe start with freeing and feeding your people. But your right there will most likely be a Chinatown on Mars one day but just like on earth it'll be built by another country. Chinatowns only exist where China isn't lol
@@kittybrowneye3163 why was China poor and in some parts still is, because some imperialists exploited it for hundred years, forced drugs selling and uneven treaties. You should learn your history before coming to debate. Same goes for the other colonized nations. Only thing is China got out of the cycle of beeing a victim. Now some say, former imperialists seem to be frightened.
8:10 Incorrect, the communists didn't unite the whole of China. They never captured, they've never controlled, the island of Taiwan, which was returned to the Republic of China ("Taiwan") in 1945, 4 years before the creation of the PRC.
31:00 This guy mentions about the HK business deals - how's "freedom" going in HK..... all those protesters must be protesting about nothing. And because China is a liberal open society, they treat protestors by locking them up and throwing them in prison... how is that a free society? Also where does all this technology and advancements come from? It comes from other countries when China steals technologies - China will do the same to Tesla. 45:00 "Wants the worlds respect by doing it China's way not the US way" - China has invaded Tibet with military force and HK and now wants to do the same thing to Taiwan and on and on and on. Obviously China has ambitions to seize lands in Japan and India etc - China can not be trusted, has not proven worthy of trust with their track record - *tariffs and sanctions* now before China starts WW3.
I'm waiting for Jinping's Cultural Revolution version 2.0. Actually it's starting to take place now, the recent shutting down of foreign language schools in mainland China and serious meddling in the tech sector is the start of this, although Jinping will call this "reforms", it's the start of Cultural Revolution 2.0 in all but name.
The global movement now, is division; Free world and Communist World (again). The CCP with it's Wolf Warrior megaphone diplomacy and Covid19 pandemic (released from Wuhan, coupled with CCP lies and coverup about the origin of the pandemic) is accelerating this political (and economic) process. Once again, you can't separate economics and politics.
The CCP loves to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. A military invasion of Taiwan will herald World War 3. Australia (Japan and India and most likely, the United States) is very clear about this.
Note that Chinese culture seems fixated by the "charismatic leader" syndome (in a similar manner to the dictator-emperors of the Roman Empire actually, and many historians know how unstable that could be under megalomanics like Caligua and Nero). Jinping is a another Nero-like figure; less vain, but he makes up for that with poisonous ideology.
Watch and support real Chinese patriots who want to make China a better place that respects other race and religion, and a Govt that respects the rule of Law and basic human rights. 1. Simon Yu 上海人 2. China Uncle Mikey 上海人 3. ChinaBill 成都人 4. Inside the Great Wall 5. Inconvenient truth by Jennifer Zeng 高学地球化学， 北大毕业, 四川人 6. Miles Guo 郭文贵,山东人 7. Dr. Miles Yu 余茂春,安徽人 8. Feng Suo Zhou 周锋锁， 人道中国创办人六四幸存。 9. Sarah Liang 梁珍 10. Mr. Chen RUclips 陈先生 11. Dong Xiang of Digging to China 12. Vicky Xu 许秀中,甘肃人
I would also add China Observer and China Insights they put out all the various issues that the CCP is falling to solve. Long live Democracy and Freedom of Press
@@yestomor7673 they stabbed many communist hun and ran over the rest in a truck maybe Afghanistan will flood them with weapon's to help the oppressed Muslims of the west
politics holds a scope to divide people(Based on Race, Religion, Ethnicity, Culture, Gender etc), But Economics will always unite people. Everyone wants to be rich.
42:20 I think prof. Wang has made a wrong assertion that the American way is "liberal" and "rule-based", while the Chinese way is "authoritarian" and "China First" and "non rule-based". First of all, China has proposed the idea of "shared human destiny" and not "China First". China will set up a rule-based order too, not unilaterally like America did, but with the rest of the world; and then follow the rules too, not the self-exceptionalist way like America. America way is "liberal"? Sure, it's liberal in the way that only America itself can write the rules, interpret and manipulate them the way it likes, and puts itself above these rules. Other countries have no say in writing the rules at all. And you call this a "rule-based" world order? You have to wonder, whose rules are these?
China has shown us that by deep introspection into one's own culture and civilization, the right model for economic and political progress is available to any who decide to work for it. China still has problems, of course, like everyone else, but they have the apparatus now to deal with them.
Funny how the pictures show military vehicles burnt during this Tiananmen square incident. A decent documentary which says it was a point of attention but maybe overexaggerating the crackdown.
He may've 'restored' stability but at what price? Was the Tiannmen Square massacre and the crushing of calls for greater freedom worth it all. After all, corruption has never been worse and it affects the workers, those same people the CCP claim to stand for.
Unlike other ancient civilization, Chinese sustain five thousand years and expect to continue, there is one very critical characteristic, the ability to domesticate foreign invasion. Various religions entered China and absorbed Chinese philosophy, various ethnic nations invaded and conquered China and naturalized into Chinese, various cultures entered China influenced and merged into native culture. Communism is the same, it entered China in the era of civil unrest and poor needed a push to rise up; however once the incentive is gone, Chinese soon modified the doctrine to their style. Today China is basically operating the same as empiric dynasty, same way of electing government officials, same political culture, same governing method, same Confucian based thoughts and same deep rooted Han center traditions. The only thing communism left is the name and the some propaganda slogans. Communism in China has long died along with Mao who never believed in communism in the first place.
Have you not heard about the story of the dragon that grew so fat that it got stuck in the cave and the citizens gold got stuck for ever? Socialism by 2049 huh?
Not bad but fails to mention multiple points for China. First is the fact that it’s high growth was heavily supported by an oversized housing bubble, second is the aging population and low birth rate, third is the destruction of the Environment through industrial pollution of water sources. Fourth is the Chinese governments “wolf warrior” diplomacy, which involves basically insulting other countries for no reason and then inciting nationalism by making it seem unjustified. Fifth is the ccp aggressive expansionism, which includes claiming the entire South China Sea as its own, contradicting international agreement that it is international waters. Is this enough to prove that this is pretty heavily biased towards China. If not, you can continue with the Chinese government failing to uphold its promises such as democracy in Hong Kong. Let’s not forget the ccp actively trying to create debt traps for other countries in order to gain land and resources from them. Is that enough yet?
Seriously, neither the east nor the west political system are any good. No option versus choosing between two bad options are really not much difference. The economic model might have evolved greatly, but political systems are ancient, with incumbent not interested in improving it, be it the west or the east.
Watching this documentary without knowing enough history is only going to give you a slanted (or at best an incomplete) history of the CPC and the PRC😑.
Said by Xi:" the history of the new China is an integrated thing. We can't use the first-thirty years to deny the second-thirty years, also, We can't use the later years to deny the former years." There's no point to argue who is greater, because without anyone of them, China won't be like this at today.
Overall it's a good documentary but missed a very significant point that is their territory expansion policy. It became a large country by conquering neighbor countries from Manchuria to Tibet, and now towards pacific ocean area.
I don't see how the Chinese CPC's increasingly alienation stance towards the West will help her further her position and agendas on the international stage. In fact China is making a big mistake! In late 1700s, Qianlong did the exact same thing, by refusing to allow the free exchange of trades and ideas with the West, barely 50 years, China was already on the brink of collapse. The only way China can move forward is opening itself up more to the West, more relaxation and reforms of Government policies and ideas, and gradually introducing more democracy because the Chinese society has become more sophisticated, intelligent and able to make informed decisions about their collective future. This is what China needs, not an authoritarian regime governed by an authoritarian who refuses to leave, wants to be leader for life, overstays his welcome and frequently making threats to the West like a frightened animal. Learn from North Korea! It doesn't pay to be engaged in long term conflicts with your neighbours because China isn't self-sufficient and there are many things that China needs from the outside than it wants to admit.
lmao i recognised the guy talking at 20:08 his the one that was talking like an aggressive warlord on ABC. he looks and sounds pretty descent when his not emulating a chihuahua
I find it ironic how all these protests have signs is English, just who were they speaking to, what audience are they directing their protest towards, where are they getting their ideas from???
Tiawen-1 Mars Lander, for that it wins a bronze medal. Being 45 years after NASA (the Americans) achieved it (Viking missions), and the Soviets achieved it even 5 years earlier than the Americans (Mars 2 and 3 mission). Hence, Mars has been American and Russian since ancient times.. as for the moon?
Deng's biggest contribution, in my eye, is to make the country and people to put pragmatism ahead of ideology, so that legitimacy should be based on outcome which drives the party and government to continually deliver to the people.
Let it be white or black, a good cat catches rats
是的, 正如邓小平所说的, 无论白猫黑猫(社会或经济制度),如果能使中国人民过得更好,更加有尊严,平等,自由和富有, 那就是"好猫"!
It's the ccp
Trump wants President Putin to exposed Hunter Biden Hijacking Ukraine Oil and Gas Scam ! Sleepy Joe poll rating is dropping like a Stone. *Can Trump Kick Sleepy Joe out of the White House* ?
Deng and his successors were responsible for China being the economic powerhouse it is today with economic reforms, enabling China to join the WTO, opening up trade to west and welcoming foreign investments. China fostered good relations with other countries, there was a cultural exchange with foreigners coming to china to work and to visit, and chinese people going abroad to study and live.
Things started changing when Xi wrested power... he's taking China two steps back to the Mao era, promoting nationalism and ideology(Xi Jinping thought and his own little red book). Clashes with other countries are more frequent now, public opinion of China in other countries is down, anti-foreigner sentiments are being pushed by the CCP/CPC, foreign cultural influence is being clamped down. I think he's trying to control the population with propaganda(50 cent army) and censorship. I'm concerned about what he has planned for China and SE/East Asia.
Now a days it's rare to see unbiased media like CNA.
I like the part where red guard was shooting people in the square in capitol
@Lord Word Capitol hill in jan the 6th , what a beautiful sight to behold
This is state run propaganda from the ccp lol
@Lord Word comparing Jan 6 to Tiananmen square lol shill harder
@@kittybrowneye3163 Tianmen massacre were just students demanding democracy, Jan 6 are like right winged militias like Oath Keepers, Proud Boys and many trump supporters. But the response was so disparingly different though. CHina responded against students with tanks and APCs while America only had a few Capitol Police on the scene if im not wrong.
What a remarkable growth story, all the expatriates Chinese overseas that flees during the Japanese wars feels very proud for what China has achieved.
The story of CPC sounds full of heroic and sacrifices…
They fled because of communism or that's what they say
@@glenmcculley9752 Most of us and our ancestors fled because of poverty. Many of us has returned.
@Daniel Piotrowicz IS it China's responsibility to save you and your country?
There is today more inequalities in the US than China. Maybe you should take a look at that first.
CPC and Chinese people did a extraordinarily job in past decades; even with some errors, it should be highly respected contribution.
What about the covid thing. Wait a minute before you go giving the award to Chynna😂😃😁😂😃😁😉
It is sad that there are always moron dun recognised other achievements
@@vincentchiew I'll give chyna the sneaky snake award what's Xi address😆😅😆😅😆
Some errors which created by the trade embargo from 1949-1979; blocking PRC from accessing the "international market"; forcing PRC to trade with the socialist bloc only. See how the capitalist bloc/imperialist bloc uniting the anti-imperialist bloc and creating starvation? No western media dare to mention it.
No, there were no errors.
"A century of revolution" what a good way to describe the CPC. Always changing, always adapting, nothing can stop the revolution of the Chinese civilization.
You wumao shills give yourself away when you dog whistle cpc
this is the best, balanced review of cpc. Not a bullshit biased western media.
I like the part where they showed the 89 uprising of the Chinese people in Beijing that was the best part was it yours to
I am an expatriate in China since 1998. While I am not big fan of Mao, but people need to remember not only he brought the country into unity again, but he also laid the foundation for Deng. From 1949 to Mao's death, the countries life expectancy increased from 38 to 65, that's more than double the improvement in the world during the same period, that's equivalent to hundreds of millions of lives saved. Illiteracy rate dropped from 80% to 25%. He established social, racial and gender equality. Most Mainland Chinese regard him a hero with flaws, which I find more appropriate than him being branded a demon by people outside of China. This documentary also failed to mention that Tiananmen's Incident has a part to do with funding by the CIA, very much like the Hong Kong riot in 2019. More soldiers were killed than the students. Today, if we ask the Mainland Chinese the single person that they hate the most, one name regularly pops up, Chai Ling, the student leader who took money from the CIA to create the movement. She was as notorious as Li Hong Zhi, the founder of the Cult Fa Lun Gong.
天安门事件因为时间久远，但是我们也能知道事件的原始情况，在中国当时的体制下那群学生做出了颠覆国家的举动，在我看来那群人都该死。香港事件已经不需要我再说，那就是一件被美国资助的事件，利用香港本地那群不愿意努力的年轻人发动胁迫政府的暴力行为，在我看来那群人也该死，应该剁碎丢海里。政府对他们太仁慈。
What utter crap you fell for the CCP s properganda and lies
@@ellis9084 You are the one being brainwashed
@@zeissiez criticising disgusting government's does not mean I think mine is perfect
@@ellis9084 Chai Ling encouraged her fellow students to continue their hunger strike and to be ready to shed blood, as she departed the square for the United States. In contrast to her and other "student leaders," the Chinese populace holds a greater degree of respect for Xiaobo Liu, not because they agree with Liu's proposition that "China needs to be colonized for 300 years to modernize," but because he held on his beliefs and engaged in a direct struggle with the CPC on Chinese soil.
India trolls incoming. Nevermind, they already here.
India don't care about China after they won border skirmish ox head
还有美国超自信种族主义者，还有各种谎言制造者。
a deep insight on CPC journey, highlighting the obstacles and development it achieved in 100 years. A great example to look forward. "Doesn't matter if the Cat is Black or White, as long as it catches the mouse, it is good". What a visionary Man Deng was. Long Live China!!!
Long live free China*
WHAT CHINA HAS ACHEIVED THROUGH HARD WOFK N DISCIPLINE IS NOTHING SHORT OF INCREDIBLE . IN JUST 50 YEARS CHINA HAS BROUGHT THE FUTURE FORWARD TO THIS VERY MOMENT IN TIME. AS LONG AS THEY KEEP FOCUS N KNOW WHO IS WHO THEY WILL BE AROUND FOR MANY MANY DECADES TO COME. DETERMINATION N NEVER SAY NEVER IS AN ASIAN THING. BIG UP TO CHINA. TO KMOW IS THE GREATEST . BLESSSD LOVE N MAXIMUM RASPECT ..
.
It doesn't matter if the cat is Japanese or Chinese as longthey are
Finally an unbiased Documentary. Thank you CNA from Germany. The only thing we get told about China here in the West is that its bad. This opinion is leaded by the US who hates competition and is known for destroying countrys with other systems than the US is using. I Visited China 3 Times already, 2 times Japan and i want to visit Singapore when Covid lets us do it, someone has tips what is worth seeing around? doesnt matter if more rural or city, i would be very thankful.
Welcome to Beijing!
Excellent documentary, only the Chinese people themselves are best positioned to comment on the whether the CPC has improved the quality of their lives. Haters: how much did the CPC pay CNA?
Ok wumao how about the uygurs why don't they get a vote? Your saying the people of china a country with a social credit score system are the only ones who can complain, but they can't or they'll be punished severely. So basically your saying no one can comment then? So done with Chinese propaganda bs the ccp is terrible and you gave yourself away as a shill when you used the dog whistle cpc. Your lies won't work forever wumao
Finally there is a foreigner understands we Chinese people. Western media has no right and qualifications to comment if the Cpc is good or bad. Only Chinese can talk about that.
@@junzheyang9743 no they can't that's why they have a social credit score you bash the ccp you pay for it so very few due. Wumao suck you guys are literally spending your day getting paid spreading propaganda so a totalitarian regime can persecute its own people and hurt millions all over the world. You guys are gross individuals
@@kittybrowneye3163 Blablabla, do you get paid based on word count? 😂
@@kittybrowneye3163 han people dont get to vote either lmao
At least CNA has the gut to show pictures of rioters burning Tanks and killing soilders.
It will not be seen in China.
@@GavinGill07 Doesn't Matter 300 or 10000 as both are propaganda numbers but today i believe it definitely was for the greater good.
@@LaowaiDaveJCP That "greater good" was the same excuse that Hitler used while tossing 6 million Jews into furnaces. Same excuse that Mao used while selling grain to the USSR while 40 million Chines starved. Same excuse that Stalin used to send 5 million killed or to Siberia.
@@warrenlauzon5315 except that none of the incident or the big names you just mention has anything to do with China? I thought you're gonna include Thanos too lol🤣🤣
The greater good is right infront of you just get your eyes open once for godsake 🥱
@@LaowaiDaveJCP You totally missed the point.
as a Marxist Leninist, China is a great example to follow. Mix central planning and market economy.
And with a sprinkle of surveillance by the cpc and no freedom of the press and a dash of grand delusion I could be communists too.😂😃😄😅😆😆😆😄😄
spoke like a useful idiot
So what's marxist about china?
The state still control the means of production.
Lol you think China is actually communist lol its just a totalitarian regime built on capitslism ,as a Marxist you're an idiot which is predictable
By far the best documentary on the matter. Also, the best docs on China in the internet...
Did you see the part where Chinese people rise up in Beijing in 89 that was best part.😂😁😁😅😁😁😆😁😁
000
@Lord Word those students died in 8964 are cancer cells? Well, quite the contrary. They are the benign ones. only cancer cells can match China's impressive growth rate. So do we only have cancer cells left in the country? Maybe Xi should eliminate those bad members that is not as evil and dishonest as those immoral and greedy ones, to further boost the growth rate?
@Lord Word those young students fighting for democracy in 1989 are not qualified to be called as cancer cells. they are unarmed, they are just too weak. The Party's Liberation Army is more qualified to be granted the crown. PLA cells are a lot more aggressive and powerful.
@Lord Word the invincibility illusion CPC wants its resident cells to believe the body is functioning perfectly is by suppressing all the feeling from pain nerve and mask it with pain killers, or completely cut off the neurons from the networks so you don't feel the pain. With all the early warnings turned off, Your limbs are already bleeding and damaging from the far end. It will come to your trunk. Just wait and see.
No matter the political system, individual prosperity and a decent life is above everything else that includes American style democracy. Singapore is the best and most successful example of all and China is very similar in that aspect.
Singapore Prime Minister Li Guang Yao participated in the design and construction of China. They may have wanted to build a larger version of Singapore
Don't forget Rwanda
@@sleepya3129 yes, but only a giant country like china can advance in all fronts, such as artificial intelligence, military might, space exploration. While Singapore is wildly successful and inspired Beijing throughout the years, China is impressive in its own might..
@@MichelleSuiComedy kindly dont sow any dot of discord between singapore and china... thank you...
@@gofar5185 I am sorry. I changed the comments.
Nice to see some unbiased objective Documentary on China for a change.
A Political party is like a person in a new job. When he's new hire in the job, he'll make many mistakes, but what's important is whether he learns from those mistakes or not and CPC seems to be doing just that. They always learn from their mistake and change accordingly
On job training failed for 40 years with egghead communism countries, long enough to have 10 administration changes if in US. until switched to get help from other more capable colleagues like USA who helped push China into WTO and hand held China to get a lot of investments to set up factories and transferring orders. The thriving China owes US a sincere big thank you. To tutors like Taiwan and HK as well.
After on job training for 70 years, despite slow start, for how much longer would the nanny Party let go control to give working class babies more room for speech, freedom to move within the border without Hukou hindrance, practice any religion as promised in the constitution?
There are 300 million richer babies ready to become adult. Hurry up or those over 65 years old are going to eat up your pension funds. Time to Convert China from a giant nanny Party country to a modern responsible citizen owned country.
@Lord Word babies want to grow. Nannies should go and let the constitution do its job unless the nanny really is milking a lot out of baby leets. You are right, do it rather than say it. Be practical. Freedom of speech is just one of the rights in the Chinese constitution.
@Lord Word in your last comment you were talking about chairman Xi I said he could swing on a short rope you said you agreed now what is it since the thread magically disipered
@Lord Word "lord"
@Lord Word "lord"
educational and objective as always
China had the largest economy in the world before the optimum war 1848. So there should not be any surprise China will become the largest economy again 200 years later.
My personal dislike for KMT was their leader let Rape of Nanking happened. The soldiers trapped the Chinese civilians inside to slow the Japanese down. The nationalist soldiers wore civilians clothings to escape. They did the same thing in Taiwan with White terror.
Anyway..
I asked this question and got some great responds. See the source for the credits.
Can anyone explain to me why KMT lost to the CCP with only a few hundred members?
Philip Ting: US supported the nationalist during China independence war because it allow Western colonial power to continue to own the land and businesses. They lost the war despite having overwhelming fire power and escape to Taiwan. The communist won because they were supported by most of the Chinese people as they were impoverished.
Taiwan is still a colony of US. Maybe an autonomous colony.
DG CU-T: The generals of CCP were more united and won several decisive battles, where as KMT was relatively corrupted and internal conflicts among different fractions only exacerbated the situation. The "evil CCP" depicted by the western media occurred probably 20 years later after the civil war; the warrior who slaughtered the dragon become dragon itself.
Michael Zhang: Before ccp, there was a party called KMT that was corrupted and plunged China into poverty and civil war. Come here to China ask any elders beyond 70 yrs old hows their life before ccp. You'll know how grateful they are. (Yes I'm telling you from my personal experience because all the elders in my families love ccp.)
Yin Zhen Yang: kmt has too many faction infighting, its run by ex noble and big landlord families. In a country consist mostly farmers and peasant and drought, feminine run wild.
Every soldier u train potentially coming from poor rural farmer family, the vision of a country where everyone were equal, every fortune are share, is.way more attractive that fighting for the landlords whom doesnt treat u like a human.
Basically kmt is in the situation of every collapsing dynasty, overthrow directly or indirectly by the peasant or farmer uprising.
Source
ruclips.net/video/uCylfY21l3Y/видео.html
The fact is the economy was destroyed before CCP took over. Go to check what ROC did in Shanghai. The commodity price are rising every second, even university Professor’s monthly wage can not afford one meal. Further information you can go to check the results of the first 5 years plan and first 3 years plan.
-Chaos Andy
China was in deep poverty ever since the Qing Dynasty lost the Opium War and robbed by the western powers through treaties. KMT's corrupted government brought China into even deeper trouble. When KMT retreated to Taiwan, they transported hundreds of ships of gold with them hence China was basically valueless. CCP was left with nothing.
-Jeff H
If you're still reading, check this out.
Chris wallace: Mao became a leader for the Chinese peasants by sheer grit, at a time when they took on both the brutal Japanese occupiers and the self-serving business elite (the Nationalists). Americans are appalling ignorant about China during the difficult years (1930's-40's). The US foreign service in China at the time (a highly competent, knowledgeable and professional group of civil servants) recommended that the US support Mao but the US government turned them down, kicked them out of China and replaced them with an inept but politically responsive legation that supported the Nationalists. This led to a freeze on Sino-US relations for the next 20+ years!
神州 Shenzhou: Mao Zedong saved China, he transformed China from a weak and divided country into strong and unified one today. When Dr Sun overthrew the previous Qing Dynasty China and established "democratic" Republic of China (1912-1949) China was divided into several areas, we lost control of Tibet, and various warlords ruled different parts of China and even Japan invaded China twice during this weak period of Chinese history. Dr. Sun tried to get help from the Western powers, but they laughed at the thought of China copying their democracy. They even gave away the Shandong province (which had been occupied by the Germans during WWI) to Japan, instead of returning it to China (even when China was part of the Allies during WWI). In the end, Dr. Sun died without ever realising a unified China under democracy.
But then Mao Zedong came along, and he accomplished what the ROC could not, and reunifed China under communism, proclaiming the People's Republic of China in 1949 and Tibet was finally returned back to China in 1951. If not for Mao Zedong, China today would still be weak and divided country, fighting among ourselves, instead of the strong unified country we are today.
The CPC had 600 battles vs the Japanese and kmt.
A lot of brave soldiers lives were lost.
Making a New China Ep 03: The Long March
ruclips.net/video/LqidzkM3_RA/видео.html
Facts Tell: What's behind the mainland-Taiwan divide?
ruclips.net/video/ML9rpzgvlu4/видео.html
True and Fair View and
Factual Informations.
Thank you CNA for your
incredible video.
What should be emphasized is not internal conflict but external aggression, which gave rise to the pursuing internal conflict. Westerners do not want to confront this reality. The formation of the CPC has been the response to this external aggression.
the formation of the CPC was a good example of forieng power collusion with the aim to overthow the Chinese nation.
CPC could justify its existence better should it respond to Japanese external aggressions during the WWII by actively participating into combats and protect the country. Unfortunately they didn't intend to but focus on growing their organization and military power during the war time.
I wonder if intenal conflict doesn't need to be emphasized, why on earth the annual stability maintainance budget is at the same level as the China's defense budget? Isn't China a happy society without much conflicts?
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan The creation of the CPC had been in response to foreign aggression, without which there will be no CPC at all. That the Soviet had became much friendly, less racist, toward China after the Bolshevik Resolution had been an additional factor.
China's cultural weakness only became salient and obvious to the Chinese as China suffered from foreign aggression, even as the struggle over cultural change could well be regarded as internal conflict. The first emphasis should be on the cause, with the consequences to follow.
@@woodensurferyour comment is just too abstract, not coming down to the earth. Just Explain to me two things: 1. where does the hammer and the sickle come from in CPC's emblem, is that genuinely from China? (Compared to KMT whose emblem from Lu How dong and the ideology coming from Dr Sun yat sen) By foreign aggression, is that Japan or what? Hasn't that been a present continuous since 1840 at that time? Read the CPC 1st national congress history, it was meant to be the Soviet's subsidiary in China. So this isn't a collusion with USSR? It clearly violates the national security law if it's today.
2. Why is the stability budget so high. Where is the instability if it's been so successful as CPC has been claiming.
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan First, I have just told you that the Soviet after the Bolshevik Revolution had became much more friendly and less racist to China than Czarist Russia. Second, a symbol is just a symbol of a certain facet; it does not need acceptance in totality, regardless. The Soviet was the only power that had aided China before the onset of WWII, for China it was 1937. The US backed the anti-republic establishment. It was not perplexing that Sun Yet-sen had warm feeling toward the Soviet. The Soviet, unlike Czarist Russia, was a new friend by the triumph of socialism. This is one reason why socialism has been viewed as salubrious--by association. Then one should not forget the Soviet war against Japan starting 1945, after which Northeastern China, aka Manchuria, was returned to China.
War-lordship is a kind of internal conflict that had been common in China throughout history. How it could have ended should not be expected as revolutionary, while the fervent embrace of socialism should be.
What is instability? I don't know what you are referring to, but threat to territorial integrity is one source.
@@woodensurfer ah! So you are not a Chinese resident? Sorry for not providing the context then. You probably don't know that the Chinese administration nowadays is accusing almost everything of collusion with foreign power and external entity influence and considers these national security threat. that's why I keep arguing the CPC itself ever since its establishment was a collusion to threaten the national security for the Chinese government back then. I am arguing to Chinese people that you can't just keep finger pointing but pretending the Party is already great, glorious, and just.
Two, regarding the instability budget. The Chinese administration hires millions of people to censor their citizen to an extent that it is on par with their expenses on defense. Just search for "China stability maintenance budget"
I've met many people from around the world 🌎 never met a bad Chinese person EVER
looool u are lucky
Whether it's a one-party system or a two-party system, their ultimate purpose is to make people's lives better
Except religious people...they're just persecuted, raped, arrested and murdered.
The USA has never been a responsible world nation....it has been a profit-orientated nation that has shown little respect for human rights and democracy in countries it exploited or controlled.
China may be authoritarian but internally it does have exchanges of opinions and democratic processes within the party. The western popular democracies are not like the original ideas of western democracy which was restricted to a minority of the population, only gradually it was extended to women and to people without means.
If the group or party in power has integrity and shows good governance some of the elements of modern western democracies may not be important. A serious weakness of western democracies is that the voters generally are not very competent in what is necessary to make a country prosper but are easily influenced by misinformation, distortion of facts, media coverage, and single events. Also, it is basically impossible to make very long-term targets for future development. In reality, different interest groups seem to be the true drivers of the "democratic" process in the western democratic model making it nontransparent and maybe de facto less democratic than China.
You are trying to say that the Chinese people are not intelligent enough to vote, shame on you
@@ellis9084 Actually not, I think the CHinese people are just as smart as anybody else. What I say is democracy is something you have to learn. It is some expectations and some culture, it has to grow and evolve, this may take a couple of generations. When a people has been used to authoritarian rule, it is difficult to change the mind.
@@bjrnhjortshjandersen1286 I agree Chinese people very smart and if they had freedom they would be world leaders and prosperous just look at how successful the Taiwanese are
@@bjrnhjortshjandersen1286 what utter crap Chinese people are res resourceful intelligent people who are more than capable of choosing the own leaders
@@ellis9084 I believe they could.....but that is not really what they do. Have you ever reflected on how little you know about the politicians we elect? We elect a perception and some general beliefs about what values and politics they would like to support. But in the USA you have a lot of money involved ...and that feeds different levels of corruption....you can buy influence because money is needed to get elected. And more or less.... politicians are bought.
Listen to the party, follow the party. Be faithful to the original aspirations and continue marching forward! 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 💪💪💪
🤣
Bastard then stop using youtube
Excellent video! Thank you for your fairness, CNA
Interesting to listen to you Professor Wang. Yours must be one of the most interesting and significant descriptions of historical facts of our time. Thank you sir for telling it.
Came here with popcorn to see the comments, was too early.
Same
Help me get some sodas
awaiting a fight match TW 1450, HK 黄尸，India ABNN Keyboard warriors vs. Ah Tiong 小红粉！
same
Authoritarianism if done right it can transform medieval society into modern country in pace of 40-50 years, China isnt the first, the mass mobilization of the entire nation have been done before under emperor Meiji of Japan then followed by Lee Kwan Yew way of ruling Singapore. If done wrong, it will be like Venezuela and North Korea
Well organ harvesting is legal that's why there are no homelessness 😃😃
@@glenmcculley9752 there is*
@@glenmcculley9752 did you even go to school or is that not a requirement in your backwards hillbilly town?
You're right in the sense, that a wise benevolent and immortal dictator is inherently more effective in getting things done for the good of the people compared to democracies - even the ancient Greek philosophers and Niccolo Machiavelli also attests to it though they also recognise its catch. As unfortunately, the only one whose CV matches those requirements is God, as Man is inherently flawed, where even the best of us makes mistakes and we aren't immortal to perpetuate such wisdom. Hence, democratic systems inherently lends itself to better governance (but not necessarily all the time) as it allows for greater checks and balance, and allows the citizenry to choose the best person to lead them in the direction that they wish to go (even if it's a bad one). Hence, like authoritarian regimes, democracy sometimes messes up when the majority makes bad choices especially when bitter pills need to be swallowed, but that's the inherent nature of choice. It should also be noted that not all "democratic" nations implement democracy well and have well functioning governments.
On a side note, I think part of the rapid rise of the Asian Tigers was because we fast tracked the entire industrial revolution phase. Back when the Western powers were industrialising, they were still working on the R&D of the steam engine and globalisation wasn't that big a thing yet, so things were moving much slower.
You realise that both Venezuela and North Korea are under massive US sanctions? They literally can’t trade with the rest of the world except for a few who could afford to (Russia, China, Iran, etc...) AND all their assets, reserves and gold abroad have been -stolen- sized. Can you imagine how hard it is to manage a country under such restrictions?
why arent they addressing the horrific side of communism such as treatment of people and treatment of the poor?
Wang Gungwu's take is interesting when he says that now it's an international competition between a 'liberal capitalism' of US and 'authoritative capitalism' of China. Because the capitalist system itself is authoritative.
Neither nation has capitalism
Every party and government will make mistakes. It's all up to how you react and respond afterwards. To have mistakes institutionalized, you would be doomed sooner or later. If you can push for self-reform to correct and avoid mistakes, you are evolving to be better.
very true... its a matter of succeeding leaders to rectify the mistakes/failures/lackings of their predecessors...
@@gofar5185 That's what sets China apart from most nations. Chinese leaders can learn from leaders of the past, reforming and changing what didnt work while keeping what did work. Western governments are most of the time erasing what their predecessors did.
@@guilhermezardo7671 ancient china has many sages and philospers and many enlightened scholars who taught the "making and shaping an everlasting civilization" and leaders (big and small) listened to them... thus china/east asia civilization is gradually shaped and OUTLIVED many world civilizations...
@@guilhermezardo7671 the west hemisphere has many great philosophers but they get persecuted/executed by their governments...
44:03 "Will China be a responsible global power if it replaces the US?"
I think this is a wrong question to ask. You should ask, has the US been a *responsible* world leader all these years?
A world leader should be a just leader, treating everyone the same way, including himself. But what we see is, America is ganging with a bunch of hatchet men "allies" and go around the world to beat up anyone who dares to disagree with him. And worst, even make up lies about other countries, and then go in and kill their people destroy their homeland. And you westerners call this a "responsible" behavior? How would you like it if China does exactly the same way as America when it becomes the world leader?
Hopefully America will be a global power forever and not let tyrants like the CCP become world powers Sic semper tyrannis
It's not going to be a global leader don't believe the ccps lies Taiwan USA Japan great Britain and all the decent nations will never let it happen America is going to loose patience and cut off the oil supply and deny American dollars and then ccps fuked cos u can't use China's useless currency , why don't they just admit that America saved china from the Japanese in ww2 and just stick to being green with envy
Great Documentary 👍
Watching this made me realized that all is made in China even the end of humanity is made in China
With 6,000+ nuclear bombs? Well, Yes, that country can certainly make the end of humanity.
Something something Hong Kong, something something Tibet, something something something Taiwan
what happend there? they belongs to china anyway
This 32 year old CEO surely a joke. Studying music & art for decade in western country then became founder of multiple startups that unrelated to his expertise. Surely he was born to rich family or his father was high ranking Party Member. Nothing to be proud if you using your daddy money to start multiple startup.
29:10 I asked a few citizens of the PRC about this. They said they are unaware of this agreement between them and the CCP.
In the last days of Deng when he was lying critically sick on the bed, he was asked what he thought his most outstanding achievement was. Everyone thought he was going to say opening-up, but he answered that his best achievement was maintaining Party leadership and stability after Tiananmen.
It was indeed the most dangerous time for the CPC and China... just imagine what would have happened if those so-called student leaders and freedom fighters took power in 1989.
God bless China and chinses people well deserve to be #1 SP we could have way better world if china was on this position 100 years ago!
The rising of the dragon!
More like sneaky snake
Didn't know there are still idiots in this world who still believe in dragons.
@@danielgoh1923 while treacherous idiots like your kind only believe in the west just like chiang kai sheik, the traitor of China and Chinese
@@dangshorty2029 A treacherous moron likeyou must have forgotten those communist barbarians detained Singapore owned goods in HKport in 2016
And who are the motherfuckers who caused the deaths of 45 million Chinese during the Great Famine and another 30million duri8ng the Cultural Revolution again?
'China is gonna be the No.1 in the world' is the Next
Smokin rocks homeboy
Viva china Felicidades por.sus 100 años 🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽
The title of this documentary is a bit misleading, asking what's next and then covering its history. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but not what I came here for
Formidable industrial powerhouse
Just as soon as china get toilet for 70% of country maybe then.
China really needs a progression towards democracy.
32 years old and already a CEO, my goodness, what on earth am I doing with my life? :-D
Work harder .Dont depend on silver spoon. Made you a better person
很惊讶吗？比如你一定知道的JDI老板，你可以查查他成为CEO的年龄，只会更小。这种事在中国实在太多，不用惊讶，也不用怀疑这是谎言。
All the BEST to China for her great goals,keep up the great work.Very happy for your county.😃👍👏
CPC came into existence thru democratic means: they won the war against KMT and the majority of people supported them. True, the vast majority in China till recently were from rural areas. Images of starvation showed in this video were taken during the war with Japan in the 1930s, not during the 1950s. The Cultural Revolution was the biggest mistake the then Gang of Four inflicted on Chinese cultural heritage. It's time to rebuild what was destroyed during this period.
No it did not wumao
@@PlanetCHINA.1 China is a paper dragon controlled by a totalitarian regime and your wolf warrior crap just made enemies with the entire world. Your not on the rise of anything, the ccp is about to get thrown off a cliff. It's too bad you guys spend your time spreading propaganda instead of removing the ccp. China rose up because the ccp allowed capitalism basically an admission communism doesn't work and the west allowed worked with them because they thought as they got richer they'd become freer, the ccp has proved that not to be the case and using our greedy western businessmen and stealing ip is going to get harder and harder. When stuff stops working out, the ccp will start getting more totalitarian and controlling which they're already doing and the people of China will suffer even more. You guys know as soon as you type cpc we know your paid wumao. Sure you upped your foreign propaganda spending 500% good for the ccp but it's not working, we all know it's propaganda
@@PlanetCHINA.1 you just lowered your poverty line to $471 lol, china's income per capita is 2 times lower than Brazils a poor country and 5 times lower than the US. The ccp still claims China as a developing nation and takes in billions of dollars in foreign aid, there are more slaves in China right now than America had in its entire history. I think you guys have some stuff to work on before you think about Mars maybe start with freeing and feeding your people. But your right there will most likely be a Chinatown on Mars one day but just like on earth it'll be built by another country. Chinatowns only exist where China isn't lol
@@kittybrowneye3163 why was China poor and in some parts still is, because some imperialists exploited it for hundred years, forced drugs selling and uneven treaties. You should learn your history before coming to debate. Same goes for the other colonized nations. Only thing is China got out of the cycle of beeing a victim. Now some say, former imperialists seem to be frightened.
Someone had an analogy, China among the colonized countries is like the kid from a poor family going to university, only beeing bullied by rich kids.
8:10 Incorrect, the communists didn't unite the whole of China. They never captured, they've never controlled, the island of Taiwan, which was returned to the Republic of China ("Taiwan") in 1945, 4 years before the creation of the PRC.
31:00 This guy mentions about the HK business deals - how's "freedom" going in HK..... all those protesters must be protesting about nothing. And because China is a liberal open society, they treat protestors by locking them up and throwing them in prison... how is that a free society? Also where does all this technology and advancements come from? It comes from other countries when China steals technologies - China will do the same to Tesla. 45:00 "Wants the worlds respect by doing it China's way not the US way" - China has invaded Tibet with military force and HK and now wants to do the same thing to Taiwan and on and on and on. Obviously China has ambitions to seize lands in Japan and India etc - China can not be trusted, has not proven worthy of trust with their track record - *tariffs and sanctions* now before China starts WW3.
抗议可以，自由也可以，但是这些暴徒影响了大多数人的生活，破坏大量公共设施的时候，他们就不是在执行自由而是暴徒。中国的轮不到你来发言。你可以问问美国因为新冠病毒死去的70万人，他们要的自由与民主在哪里？你也可以问问美国人因为枪支泛滥每年需要死去多少“自由民主”的人民。民主自由这两个词汇放在美国或者欧洲就是一个笑话。
it's gr8 that a communist party believes in capitalism 😳🙄
Superpower China 🇨🇳
Live Long and Prosper China
再造美丽的漢帶 重建輝煌的唐路
Great video
Interesting CNA doesn't dare to talk about Taiwan issue.
What;s there to talk about? Taiwan is a part of China, period. Same for Hong Kong, and Macau.
It's just not a main talking point in this grand topic.
I'm waiting for Jinping's Cultural Revolution version 2.0. Actually it's starting to take place now, the recent shutting down of foreign language schools in mainland China and serious meddling in the tech sector is the start of this, although Jinping will call this "reforms", it's the start of Cultural Revolution 2.0 in all but name.
The global movement now, is division; Free world and Communist World (again). The CCP with it's Wolf Warrior megaphone diplomacy and Covid19 pandemic (released from Wuhan, coupled with CCP lies and coverup about the origin of the pandemic) is accelerating this political (and economic) process. Once again, you can't separate economics and politics.
The CCP loves to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. A military invasion of Taiwan will herald World War 3. Australia (Japan and India and most likely, the United States) is very clear about this.
Note that Chinese culture seems fixated by the "charismatic leader" syndome (in a similar manner to the dictator-emperors of the Roman Empire actually, and many historians know how unstable that could be under megalomanics like Caligua and Nero). Jinping is a another Nero-like figure; less vain, but he makes up for that with poisonous ideology.
People claiming great documentary,etc are mostly chinese descendants 😂😂.
people watching documentaries to claim that people claiming great documentary are mostly chinese descendants are mostly internet trolls
Ooooo...the amount of butt hurt there....Lol
Watch and support real Chinese patriots who want to make China a better place that respects other race and religion, and a Govt that respects the rule of Law and basic human rights.
1. Simon Yu 上海人
2. China Uncle Mikey 上海人
3. ChinaBill 成都人
4. Inside the Great Wall
5. Inconvenient truth by Jennifer Zeng 高学地球化学， 北大毕业, 四川人
6. Miles Guo 郭文贵,山东人
7. Dr. Miles Yu 余茂春,安徽人
8. Feng Suo Zhou 周锋锁，
人道中国创办人六四幸存。
9. Sarah Liang 梁珍
10. Mr. Chen RUclips 陈先生
11. Dong Xiang of Digging to China
12. Vicky Xu 许秀中,甘肃人
I would also add China Observer and China Insights they put out all the various issues that the CCP is falling to solve. Long live Democracy and Freedom of Press
WE STAND WITH TAIWAN 🇹🇼
👎
Great to see CNA still uses the proper name "CPC", as opposed to that other abbreviation the West is spreading over recent years.
Lol what the problem with saying CCP instead of CPC
@@yotengoe7302 instead of USA would you say AUS?
@@timtam53191 sir communist party of china aka tyrants
@@yotengoe7302 CPC is a dogwhistle used by CCP propagandists
Instead of CCP say evil genocidal lying scumbags, parasites to our planet
Well done China 🇨🇳
If we'd clear out people in our gov who have excepted money from special interest groups, who would be left to govern us?
Free uighur Muslim ☪️❤
We need to get the Ughar weapons to defend that one China and to run the hun out
If Kunming Terrorist attack did not happen perhaps they would have much more freedom
They should be freed by you. Why don't you put out your gun and go fighting for them?
@@yestomor7673 they stabbed many communist hun and ran over the rest in a truck maybe Afghanistan will flood them with weapon's to help the oppressed Muslims of the west
@@ejei1839 you talking Chinese policy you could have organs harvested or jail
Dobra analiza.
Long live Taiwan and it's democracy
People there are dying for a extremely corrupt government, sadly
Where did you get that false impression?
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan and free Hong Kong
@@ChnesRep中華民國OfTaiwan China is very afraid of Taiwan and when America builds navy base China will know who is in charge
Long live your nightmare that Taiwan will be consolidated into China.
Wealth inequality and corruption.....democracy and monarchy have the same kind of problem if not worse.
politics holds a scope to divide people(Based on Race, Religion, Ethnicity, Culture, Gender etc), But Economics will always unite people. Everyone wants to be rich.
It's a shame Xi's a psycho commi, get rid of 'im !
42:20 I think prof. Wang has made a wrong assertion that the American way is "liberal" and "rule-based", while the Chinese way is "authoritarian" and "China First" and "non rule-based".
First of all, China has proposed the idea of "shared human destiny" and not "China First". China will set up a rule-based order too, not unilaterally like America did, but with the rest of the world; and then follow the rules too, not the self-exceptionalist way like America.
America way is "liberal"? Sure, it's liberal in the way that only America itself can write the rules, interpret and manipulate them the way it likes, and puts itself above these rules. Other countries have no say in writing the rules at all.
And you call this a "rule-based" world order? You have to wonder, whose rules are these?
Only me can Rule the world universe because I am God ❤️
China has shown us that by deep introspection into one's own culture and civilization, the right model for economic and political progress is available to any who decide to work for it. China still has problems, of course, like everyone else, but they have the apparatus now to deal with them.
Funny how the pictures show military vehicles burnt during this Tiananmen square incident. A decent documentary which says it was a point of attention but maybe overexaggerating the crackdown.
He may've 'restored' stability but at what price? Was the Tiannmen Square massacre and the crushing of calls for greater freedom worth it all. After all, corruption has never been worse and it affects the workers, those same people the CCP claim to stand for.
First time I saw a man sporting two watches and actually believed he needed both.
Unlike other ancient civilization, Chinese sustain five thousand years and expect to continue, there is one very critical characteristic, the ability to domesticate foreign invasion. Various religions entered China and absorbed Chinese philosophy, various ethnic nations invaded and conquered China and naturalized into Chinese, various cultures entered China influenced and merged into native culture. Communism is the same, it entered China in the era of civil unrest and poor needed a push to rise up; however once the incentive is gone, Chinese soon modified the doctrine to their style. Today China is basically operating the same as empiric dynasty, same way of electing government officials, same political culture, same governing method, same Confucian based thoughts and same deep rooted Han center traditions. The only thing communism left is the name and the some propaganda slogans. Communism in China has long died along with Mao who never believed in communism in the first place.
Have you not heard about the story of the dragon that grew so fat that it got stuck in the cave and the citizens gold got stuck for ever? Socialism by 2049 huh?
Yeah it’s a fairytale, and yes 2049
utmost gratitude to cna insider media for the 100 years history of china as a republic... under the governance/leadership of the communist party...
It’s not a republic it’s an authoritarian state
Not bad but fails to mention multiple points for China. First is the fact that it’s high growth was heavily supported by an oversized housing bubble, second is the aging population and low birth rate, third is the destruction of the Environment through industrial pollution of water sources. Fourth is the Chinese governments “wolf warrior” diplomacy, which involves basically insulting other countries for no reason and then inciting nationalism by making it seem unjustified. Fifth is the ccp aggressive expansionism, which includes claiming the entire South China Sea as its own, contradicting international agreement that it is international waters. Is this enough to prove that this is pretty heavily biased towards China. If not, you can continue with the Chinese government failing to uphold its promises such as democracy in Hong Kong. Let’s not forget the ccp actively trying to create debt traps for other countries in order to gain land and resources from them. Is that enough yet?
Seriously, neither the east nor the west political system are any good. No option versus choosing between two bad options are really not much difference. The economic model might have evolved greatly, but political systems are ancient, with incumbent not interested in improving it, be it the west or the east.
Watching this documentary without knowing enough history is only going to give you a slanted (or at best an incomplete) history of the CPC and the PRC😑.
中国人最喜欢赚钱了,过年见面第一句话就是: 发财啊!
S
questionnaire about who is greater and beloved between Mao and Deng.
mao built our country,deng rebuilt it .，mao is greater
Said by Xi:" the history of the new China is an integrated thing. We can't use the first-thirty years to deny the second-thirty years, also, We can't use the later years to deny the former years." There's no point to argue who is greater, because without anyone of them, China won't be like this at today.
MOREPOWERTOMOTHERCHINA
Overall it's a good documentary but missed a very significant point that is their territory expansion policy. It became a large country by conquering neighbor countries from Manchuria to Tibet, and now towards pacific ocean area.
Maybe let those Anglo Saxons get out of Australia, New Zealand, and the Americas first.
拜托,你应该花点时间学习中国5000年历史
Is America really a liberal capitalism?
24:54 June 6 1989… what a big mistake
那是国内高层内部的一次博弈，改革派以为学生运动是一群力量，结果却是一群乌合之众，直接导致改革派的惨败
It's June 4th 1989
I don't see how the Chinese CPC's increasingly alienation stance towards the West will help her further her position and agendas on the international stage. In fact China is making a big mistake! In late 1700s, Qianlong did the exact same thing, by refusing to allow the free exchange of trades and ideas with the West, barely 50 years, China was already on the brink of collapse. The only way China can move forward is opening itself up more to the West, more relaxation and reforms of Government policies and ideas, and gradually introducing more democracy because the Chinese society has become more sophisticated, intelligent and able to make informed decisions about their collective future. This is what China needs, not an authoritarian regime governed by an authoritarian who refuses to leave, wants to be leader for life, overstays his welcome and frequently making threats to the West like a frightened animal. Learn from North Korea! It doesn't pay to be engaged in long term conflicts with your neighbours because China isn't self-sufficient and there are many things that China needs from the outside than it wants to admit.
Good luck selling opium to China. Keep butthurtting
But how about the decreasing popullation of China
By the way. When is The War....?
Indirectly china is super power and it has shown to World great hard work by there people
lmao i recognised the guy talking at 20:08 his the one that was talking like an aggressive warlord on ABC. he looks and sounds pretty descent when his not emulating a chihuahua
I find it ironic how all these protests have signs is English, just who were they speaking to, what audience are they directing their protest towards, where are they getting their ideas from???
Exactly
还行，就是大跃进和文革的背景都没介绍全，还是西方那套
你拉倒吧，很给中共留面子了，介绍全了更难看
@@michaelma8776 有什么难看的？网上最多的就是以今论古，啥也不懂觉得人家都不行的键盘侠。要是建国那段时期是一个叫建国的游戏，给一万个人，能有一个在那么差的国际国内环境下，解放了妇女，基本完成全面教育，初步工业化，打倒了牛鬼蛇神，为以后几十年的经济腾飞打好了基础吗？
Tiawen-1 Mars Lander, for that it wins a bronze medal. Being 45 years after NASA (the Americans) achieved it (Viking missions), and the Soviets achieved it even 5 years earlier than the Americans (Mars 2 and 3 mission). Hence, Mars has been American and Russian since ancient times.. as for the moon?
你的说法很奇葩。换一个说法，中国人是不是可以向全世界征收几百年上千年的专利费用？比如纸，比如指南针，比如火药，世界要支付多少专利费用给中国才合理？你来告诉全世界！
well done china respect
In India poverty is very high
I wouldn’t bloody live there.
An abomination, The worst of all Horrors
in all of humanity repackaged as a Brand New Fairy Tale.
The most successful PR campaign ever!
what do you mean?
@@sleepya3129 Why don't you go get an education.