Top 10 Strongest Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander Cards

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 162

  • @cart02
    @cart02 Год назад +52

    I don’t want Machine Mommy to get banned but I need that Beezy apology special

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад +17

      I am a man of my word!

    • @georgemarquez4308
      @georgemarquez4308 Год назад

      You think she will ?

    • @cart02
      @cart02 Год назад +6

      @@georgemarquez4308 No. I can’t see any reasonable justification for ban

    • @questionyourself718
      @questionyourself718 Год назад +2

      @@cart02 i can when bannings would be just about cards taking away fun. After all, this was the reason for bans in the past. But if they would be consistent with that there would have been way more bans in commander.

    • @cart02
      @cart02 Год назад

      @@questionyourself718 I guess it's possible. Personally, I don't like that justification but you're right if it sees a ton of play maybe they'll ban for "unfun."

  • @RobertoBunting
    @RobertoBunting Год назад +9

    I played the White Dominus yesterday with Anointed Procession. Beautiful.

  • @stinkypoodog
    @stinkypoodog Год назад +17

    Mondrak, glory dominus is absolutely insane in the 99 of myrkul, lord of bones. A token doubler, that also doubles as a sac outlet, that also synergizes with myrkul to come back as an enchantment when it dies... and it can give itself indestructible even as an enchantment... good lord... and when you sac your creatures to it, any non legendary creatures will come back as 2 copies of it as enchantments... and the fact it has phyrexian mana means you can pay life to get yourself to 20 or less life, making myrkul indestructible. good lord is all I can say.

    • @nebnesnah
      @nebnesnah Год назад

      Myrkul is good but I like Hofri better.

  • @kylem1989
    @kylem1989 Год назад +13

    I thought Tyrranax Rex, aka T-Rex would be on here. 7 mana for a 8/8 trample, can’t be countered, toxic 4, ward 4, trample and haste. ITS A DINOSAUR 🦖

  • @danmorgan7775
    @danmorgan7775 Год назад +1

    My Giada deck could always use a little more boardwipe protection so I was thrilled to see Clever Concealment. Yes your life total can change and you are vulnerable for a turn cycle, but if the board was wiped there won't be much coming after you in most cases. Looking forward to resolving it for free the first time.

  • @doktarr
    @doktarr Год назад +12

    I mentioned this in another video but the +1 on Nissa is great in Trostani, where it gets you life and allows you to start working your populate engine.
    Moxfield deserves to be at least #5 at 9:12

  • @ix8750
    @ix8750 Год назад +1

    I just pulled the white dominus and it's bittersweet because now I want a Parallel lives really bad since I have a doubling season and anointed procession in my token deck and it would be sweet to have all 4 of them.

  • @Cynsham
    @Cynsham Год назад +2

    I like Moxfield and I use it, but I think it really needs 2 important features in my opinion, to be able to filter searches based on price and to be able to filter out cedh/cedh primer decks. I don't build ultra budget decks by any means, but I am absolutely not willing to spend 500+ dollars on a deck just to play a commander at a moderately upgraded power level.

    • @Fausto_4841
      @Fausto_4841 Год назад +1

      If there was a way to filter decks to their cheapest printing. Seems like every other deck on there has foil expedition and inventions for cards that are normally less than 5$ and Alpha sol rings.

    • @HAYDS510
      @HAYDS510 7 месяцев назад

      I wish it could show me decks i have most of the cards for (and not just the blue tick when i do)

  • @ChrisLovesYahweh
    @ChrisLovesYahweh Год назад +2

    Mondrak and Elesh are busted in my Osgir equipment deck. At one game I had 6 copies of sword of fire and ice

  • @avatarofpapermagic
    @avatarofpapermagic Год назад +4

    Good morning you beautiful nerds! Hope you are well Joe and Beezy! Thank you once again for the daily videos. It must be hard work, but I appreciate you both for it!

  • @sinnaro13
    @sinnaro13 Год назад +1

    When you showed Eternal Wanderer, I immediately thought about my Brago deck.

  • @SorisMusic
    @SorisMusic Год назад +2

    I'm shocked that Venerated Rotpriest isn't on this list. That card is *scary* with how much potential it has to screw your opponents over

  • @danielgoldberg2129
    @danielgoldberg2129 Год назад +4

    I think I’m going to take apart my Atraxa +1/+1 deck and build a Toxic/Proliferate deck. I predict I will be very popular in my play group. I blame this set for all the cards with poison counters.😊

  • @drewpapenhoven5823
    @drewpapenhoven5823 Год назад +4

    Oh no. Beezy isn’t wearing into the AM shirt. Guess I gotta use the affiliate code again to keep him well dressed. Also moxfield add at 12:33

  • @JadeHex
    @JadeHex Год назад

    7:19 my moxfield senses are tingling - Theres a handful of cards that are neither big nor splashy in here, cankerbloom that new teferis protection-esque, another tamiyo's safekeeping in tyvar's stand.

  • @mbarker_lng
    @mbarker_lng Год назад

    My Norn deck is a lot of fun to play (using a proxy of course). Its largely a lifegain ETB where the lifegain triggers other effects. At the local LGS though, they nuked her every time I cast before it even went around once. Unfortunately for me, a player got lucky and milled my Swiftfoot boots early and the other protection stuff wasnt coming. The deck still did well without it's commander though and def look forward to bringing out the deck again.

  • @jongailey85
    @jongailey85 Год назад

    It’s insane in every deck that wants to make tokens, but Mondrak is absurd with Otharri, Sun’s Glory. I’ve already tested it out and I’ve been blown away at its performance thus far. Being able to attack and instantly create 6 or more 2/2 tokens easily per turn is SO much value.

  • @EntheogenShaman
    @EntheogenShaman Год назад +4

    When I saw The Eternal Wanderer, I immediately started thinking about what to take out of my Yorion deck to make space.

    • @youngnikos9625
      @youngnikos9625 Год назад

      I play Yorion too. What did you cut

    • @lysander3262
      @lysander3262 Год назад

      Fellow Yorioner here. I might try her out. The ability to remove something from the board for a turn cycle I think is more useful than self flickering.

    • @danewirostek1903
      @danewirostek1903 Год назад

      @@youngnikos9625 cut venser im sick of it

    • @sanfranfan53
      @sanfranfan53 Год назад

      @@danewirostek1903 😢 I love Planeswalker Venser.

  • @kamilwhaley-kalaora4839
    @kamilwhaley-kalaora4839 Год назад +1

    I’m currently building an elesh norn mother of machines deck and I’m putting in field of the dead :) with a fetch land and flickering sun titan once it gives me 8 zombies which is pretty sweet

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад +2

      YES I always approve of mono color Field of the Dead manabases

    • @nickstart2299
      @nickstart2299 Год назад +1

      @@NitpickingNerds If sol ring is a crutch why is Field not? 😂

    • @ix8750
      @ix8750 Год назад

      ​@@nickstart2299 I don't think either cards are crutches. Ones just kind of annoying and the other is questionably bannable fast mana. 😅

  • @djbisson9819
    @djbisson9819 Год назад +1

    Top 20 woulda been easily achieved with this set. I fancy quite a few cards in it my self.

  • @stuckinabucket6873
    @stuckinabucket6873 Год назад +2

    the mycosynth gardens have to tap to become a copy so wouldnt it stay tapped when it becomes a copy? That would still make the card good but you wouldnt be able to copy big mana rocks

  • @robertsweeney7040
    @robertsweeney7040 Год назад +1

    More Rats for my “You Dirty Rat (Ashcoat)” Deck! Course, these ten might be a teensy bit better…

    • @DaGraveCrowder
      @DaGraveCrowder Год назад +1

      Lots of copies of that new legendary rat too since it is included in bundles

    • @robertsweeney7040
      @robertsweeney7040 Год назад +1

      @@DaGraveCrowder my “Rat” deck is different, I use about 25 different rats (of the 34 creatures) - rather than 25 of just one - it has 40 different lands as well its a “going to have fun playing as many different effects as I can” type deck…

  • @mr45buster
    @mr45buster Год назад

    6:04 someone at my store (store owner, actually) did this! Its a pretty wild thing to play against

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад

      Omg that's cool! How did they incorporate the spellbook IRL?

    • @mr45buster
      @mr45buster Год назад

      @@NitpickingNerds They had a little "sideboard" of the spellbook and just randomly chose a card every time they used Ishkanah's effect

  • @claramonti3889
    @claramonti3889 Год назад

    mondrak is insane with helm of the host. I run the two in my Trostani deck, and in one turn I can create 6 copies.

  • @hermodnitter3902
    @hermodnitter3902 Год назад

    I'm so looking forward to playing my Lord of Tresserhorn deck against the new Elesh Norn... ;)

  • @simonchi5372
    @simonchi5372 Год назад

    I got a mondrak but dunno what to do with it yet. Sounds fun with ratadrabik tbh and the nightmare shepherd effects.
    Also got a venser that seem fun but there really isnt much proliferate in u/b.

  • @Caliban_80
    @Caliban_80 Год назад +1

    Primeval Titan is banned but this Elesh Norn is fine...

  • @philipmantos2544
    @philipmantos2544 Год назад

    I know this isn't relevant to the video but in a future video I was wondering if you could discuss mana crypt, demonic tutor, and there derivatives in mtgo. In non paper formats where the cards are available for ~10 dollars they are omnipresent and really prove that if cost wasn't a consideration they would be banned.

  • @RazorDevil1
    @RazorDevil1 Год назад +1

    cant wait to see that Beezy special apology video. oml

  • @jautele49
    @jautele49 Год назад

    Should do Top 25!! Great vid!

  • @SirStickBug
    @SirStickBug Год назад +1

    What colors are Amber’s 12-land stax deck?

  • @SunburntShinobi
    @SunburntShinobi Год назад

    I’m putting the nissa in my muldrotha horror tribal because it makes horror tokens and can do more if needed

  • @noxington4260
    @noxington4260 Год назад

    I think the ad is going to be after they talk about the 4th card. Never we had to guess a time 🤔

  • @Chaoslorden
    @Chaoslorden Год назад +1

    I've been looking at your videos of monocolored staples and they are around a year ok now atleast. I wonder with the rate new cards comes out, if you cold have a yearly reprisal of that kind of video.
    All these new cards this year so far and I'm like.. Looking through cards from baldurs gate to catch up and build with. I need to be a full time mtg employee or something to keep up.

  • @Daedraheart
    @Daedraheart Год назад +1

    i prefer mask of memory over glimmer lens

  • @lancenaquin8911
    @lancenaquin8911 Год назад

    Mycosynth garden was my pick for best card zero mana copy a mana crypt seems pretty good!

  • @matthewbell4897
    @matthewbell4897 Год назад +1

    Im about to be much less consistent with moxfield guessing, so let’s make this count. 15:20

  • @SWAT6809
    @SWAT6809 Год назад

    Moxfield ad should have been in phyrexian text

  • @logandooley4426
    @logandooley4426 Год назад

    It is worth noting that conduit of worlds is not able to cast any spell like those big x spells.
    it’s only permanent spells you can cast x creatures obviously ya but no big instants or sorceries x spells.
    All that being said yes it’s still amazing I run crucible of worlds anddddd the conduit of worlds because having the lands from the graveyard is so good in my landfall deck it’s a must to have try and get it every game

  • @brandonbrooks779
    @brandonbrooks779 Год назад

    Venerated Rotpriest will probably face a standard ban before Norn faces any

  • @geoffreyhavell3612
    @geoffreyhavell3612 Год назад

    I’m sorry but how does one think that glimmer cape is a good card while thinking phyrexian arena is also a bad card? That doesn’t make any sense.

  • @travisspaans1525
    @travisspaans1525 Год назад

    I'm surprised the tyrranax rex didn't make it on this list

  • @tendo339
    @tendo339 Год назад

    that set is straight fire

  • @zonko
    @zonko Год назад

    Can you try to find as many ways to abuse Monkey Cage triggers as you can lol

  • @ilove2pillage
    @ilove2pillage Год назад

    So Clever Concealment will always at least be two white mana. COVOKE only gets rid of the colorless casting cost. So good, but not quite as good as you were saying

    • @jayjayhooksch1
      @jayjayhooksch1 Год назад

      Read convoke again, you might be pleased to be wrong if you already liked clever concealment. Lethal Scheme is my favorite removal spell ever because convoke is busted.

  • @intelligentcounterspell16
    @intelligentcounterspell16 Год назад

    Ah I got to give it to u guys elesh norn number 1 , every one is hating on this card and it's good, just like sheoldred every hated and it's a banger

  • @thetogtube2
    @thetogtube2 Год назад

    Are you putting Elesh Mommy in your GE Oketra deck?

  • @MS-td6nq
    @MS-td6nq Год назад

    What is a commander set can you only get those cards from pre cons ?

  • @jameswalterii1911
    @jameswalterii1911 Год назад

    Mycosynth gardens taps for that ability... sol ring wouldn't work unless you can untap it right?

  • @SchemingGuide
    @SchemingGuide Год назад +2

    Moxfield for sure is 12:34

  • @yinosanchez
    @yinosanchez Год назад

    The mycosynth gardens needs to be tapped in order to become a copy of another artifact. How does it work with Sol Ring?

    • @midnightlemon4255
      @midnightlemon4255 Год назад +1

      It permanently becomes a copy of the target artifact. The effect does not end when the turn ends

    • @yinosanchez
      @yinosanchez Год назад

      @@midnightlemon4255 Oh. I see. Thank you

  • @imwearingshirtsnow2097
    @imwearingshirtsnow2097 Год назад

    Happy Monday nerds :)

  • @andrewsutherland1909
    @andrewsutherland1909 Год назад

    I have a feeling that infect/proliferate decks are going to cause many players to be unpopular with their play groups lol.

  • @mrjey3434
    @mrjey3434 Год назад

    Hi nerds!
    I want to add amphin mutineer to my sefris deck, should I cut ravenous chupacabra or shriekmaw?

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад +1

      You definitely could, I'd be careful about giving away a ton of 4/3's though, one is no big deal but if you keep flickering it you might get punched a few times

  • @bagosk8r90
    @bagosk8r90 Год назад

    Yall missed the #1....
    The cat

  • @Grimkahn1901
    @Grimkahn1901 Год назад

    I dont think Machine Mother is good enough to even be considered banned. It's susceptible to removal and can easily be dealt with by non etb effects. All in all its just a good card.

  • @lordkharnos6968
    @lordkharnos6968 Год назад

    Thoughts on Unctus, Grand Metatect?

  • @Chonus
    @Chonus Год назад

    Clever Concealment + Rotpriest + Vorinclex in response to a board wipe is disgusting

  • @hankhill69420
    @hankhill69420 Год назад

    so where does one find this 12 land stax deck? :)

  • @MforMovesets
    @MforMovesets Год назад

    *puts the Planeswalkers on his thumbnail* Instantly false.

  • @hanschristopherson8056
    @hanschristopherson8056 Год назад

    I am making the active choice not to play the eternal wanderer in my yorion deck because it is too oppressive

  • @nzephier
    @nzephier Год назад +1

    Is amber in the video guess: yes
    Did I cheat? Yes

  • @zackwilcox3183
    @zackwilcox3183 Год назад

    Mycosynth gardens and dark depths c: just use liquimetal coating or something

  • @freshcut3398
    @freshcut3398 Год назад

    "Tergrid is bad in 99."
    Definitely not as good as a seck built around her but what about mishra, tamer of mak fawa or other decks where opponents will be sacrificing permanents

  • @energetek661
    @energetek661 Год назад +1

    Where did Amber go?☹️

  • @branhasknowidea
    @branhasknowidea Год назад

    "Do those universes have a better ban list?" 🤣

  • @winniebowser4447
    @winniebowser4447 Год назад +1

    Elesh Norn is only playable in cards you want panharmonicon in. Also its a bad design tbh

  • @ANeonGenesis
    @ANeonGenesis Год назад +1

    Moxfield 8:42

  • @theodorealkro3583
    @theodorealkro3583 Год назад

    I still think font of progress is the best

  • @burningpapersun1
    @burningpapersun1 Год назад

    Amber is the reason I'm here

  • @frankwhite3865
    @frankwhite3865 Год назад

    Drivnod not in the review??

  • @Buchaus
    @Buchaus Год назад

    Moxfield ad guess: 4:22

  • @diegoperezsommariva2509
    @diegoperezsommariva2509 Год назад

    Doesnt Conduit of worlds can only play permanents from the grave?

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад +1

      We should have specified that you can cast big X spell creatures with it

    • @mr45buster
      @mr45buster Год назад

      Yes lol, it also only lets you use it on ur own turn

    • @matthewfrederick9959
      @matthewfrederick9959 Год назад

      Scared me too when beezy said you could cast a big instant on someone else's turn lol

    • @diegoperezsommariva2509
      @diegoperezsommariva2509 Год назад

      @@matthewfrederick9959 that would be pretty brutal

    • @diegoperezsommariva2509
      @diegoperezsommariva2509 Год назад

      @@NitpickingNerds I am now at peace

  • @gshrab6797
    @gshrab6797 Год назад

    What about atraxa

  • @JaimeAGB-pt4xl
    @JaimeAGB-pt4xl Год назад

    I don't believe Elesh Norm is ban worthy considering all other things in the list (could've been made double or even 3 white peeps for balance) ... However, because All colors can inflict Poison now, it should at least be moved to 20 Poison counters in commander

  • @matthewfrederick9959
    @matthewfrederick9959 Год назад

    The crucible only let's you play nonland permanents.

  • @Shimatzu95
    @Shimatzu95 Год назад

    2 funfacts for nissa.
    1. It is entirely possible to build a 5color deck with over 25 forests (she doesn't ask for basics)
    2. I will personally never play her just because i hate inconsistent tokens, as in how likely is it to get even 2 of her tokens to be the same size naturally.

  • @mr.mammuthusafricanavus8299
    @mr.mammuthusafricanavus8299 Год назад

    On Mycosynth Gardens
    Thanos: What did it cost?
    Nitpicking Nerds: Nothing
    Thanos: I am jealous
    Elesh was not actually that bad. I went 8-0 at prerelease with Elesh as my only rare/mythic in the deck, came in 2nd just because Elesh doubled the Rebel tokens on ''For Mirrodin'' and a couple other choice ETB creatures. Sadly despite being basically all Toxic creatures I never got to win with 10 poison counters :P LOL

  • @_boatyAU
    @_boatyAU Год назад

    Mill, discard, counter, blue in general, and now poison…. I’m out

  • @lunarlight3131
    @lunarlight3131 Год назад

    if mommy gets banned i'm officially selling all of my cards

  • @mayormccheese6509
    @mayormccheese6509 Год назад

    Phyrexian Vindicator is broken and is definitely going to get banned. Auto include in every white deck and every deck to play against it has to build around it.

  • @jacobglass5744
    @jacobglass5744 Год назад

    moxfield 12:32

  • @gilliganallmighty3
    @gilliganallmighty3 Год назад +1

    7:38

  • @nobodyfromnowwhere7510
    @nobodyfromnowwhere7510 Год назад

    Proliferation decks are going to ruin the meta with all those everyone gets a counter cards.
    It's SO easy to proliferate.

    • @gutsbadguy50
      @gutsbadguy50 Год назад +1

      Lol ruin the meta. If poison is too annoying people just wont play it. Same as land destruction, etc.

  • @benso309
    @benso309 Год назад

    When this video says teferi's protection is lame over clever concealment as being cool. Haha

  • @RobertTheSmall
    @RobertTheSmall Год назад

    "do those universes have better ban lists?" died and woke up in one of the Elesh Norn ban universes, Kokusho is banned and recurring nightmare is unbanned due to format all-star mardu woe reaper, I'll let y'all be the judge 😎
    Great episode y'all

  • @nicolechansawang4054
    @nicolechansawang4054 Год назад

    I too worship cheese

  • @andresperez7476
    @andresperez7476 Год назад +1

    I dont have any of these cards😤😖😓

  • @sanfranfan53
    @sanfranfan53 Год назад +1

    Tergrid must have really hurt y'all in a game. 😆

  • @fosterdawson7339
    @fosterdawson7339 Год назад

    WOOH AMBER

  • @1234ThePlayer5678
    @1234ThePlayer5678 Год назад

    I am curious why nobody talks about skyhunter strikeforce. it seems absolutely brutal to me and definitly deserves to be in the top 10 imo.

    • @anonymoususer5351
      @anonymoususer5351 Год назад

      I hadn't seen that card yet (I'd guess a lot of people hadn't) but yeah that seems insane, pretty much +3/+3 in your aggro deck for 3 Mana 😳😳😳 thanks for letting me know that exists

    • @1234ThePlayer5678
      @1234ThePlayer5678 Год назад

      @@anonymoususer5351 not only in aggro it fits in every token deck which includes white and i am pretty sure you can just include it into every creature based deck without regretting it (maybe only if your commander cmc

  • @brandonwarner876
    @brandonwarner876 Год назад

    MORE CAT

  • @Fausto_4841
    @Fausto_4841 Год назад

    Teferi's Protection IS lame.

  • @jarodhines6544
    @jarodhines6544 Год назад

    Lol u guys are great

  • @doktarr
    @doktarr Год назад

    Doesn't clever concealment require two white pips even if you convoke?

  • @allein8er
    @allein8er Год назад

    Does anyone else think they should up the amount of poison that people have to get to lose? I think it's so easy to win with it now. An extra 5 poison for each player I think would make it a little more fun.

  • @ericlizama8552
    @ericlizama8552 Год назад

    How is Mirran Safehouse not on here? It can be whatever you need it to be, AND it's an artifact, so even if you use it as an extra fetchland, you can just get it back with Muldrotha or the dozens of Artifact-matters commanders in the format.

  • @SH-wz3jo
    @SH-wz3jo Год назад

    Elesh Norn is bannable because it will find its way into almost every deck with white in it since it is too easy to cast in multi-colored decks, imo

  • @99wolfseditionify
    @99wolfseditionify Год назад

    Not Nissa, No.

  • @_boatyAU
    @_boatyAU Год назад

    You play a deck that isn’t fun for gameplay, I’m out