Every Survivor Winner Ranked (Spoilers) - 2022 Edition
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 июл 2024
- All 42 winners of CBS Survivor ranked by you, the fans of this incredible show. As we move on to seasons 43 and 44, I thought why not rank who has won so far based on gameplay and general likability.
Every Winner Video - • Survivor Winner Stories
Rank The Seasons 2022 Edition - • Every Survivor Season ...
Patreon - / onceuponanislandchannel
Facebook - / onceuponanislandchannel
Twitter - / upon_island
Instagram - / once_upon_an_island_ch...
Email - ouaichannel@gmail.com
00:00 - How The Rankings Work
01:12 - #42 (A Big Bag of Underwhelming)
02:23 - #41
03:08 - #40
03:53 - #39
05:00 - #38
06:07 - #37
07:02 - #36 (They're Okay, I Guess)
07:43 - #35
08:26 - #34
09:19 - #33
10:08 - #32
11:06 - #31 (Good, But Not Great)
12:03 - #30
12:45 - #29
13:32 - #28
14:14 - #27
15:16 - #26
16:11 - #25 (On The Cusp of Greatness)
17:01 - #24
17:57 - #23
18:46 - #22
19:39 - #21
20:40 - #20
21:33 - #19
22:37 - #18
22:24 - #17
24:13 - #16
24:56 - #15
25:45 - #14
26:39 - #13
27:20 - #12 (Greatness Achieved)
28:00 - #11
28:40 - #10
29:46 - #9
30:33 - #8
31:14 - #7
32:10 - #6
32:51 - #5
33:38 - #4
34:28 - #3 (Royalty)
35:28 - #2
36:06 - #1
Paramount Plus
Hulu
Netflix
CBS
Here are the UPDATED 2023 winner rankings! - ruclips.net/video/YuvNCQkhNQQ/видео.html
😊😊
I’m so glad that people recognize how great Yul’s performance in Cook Islands is. Honestly, in the dark times of Survivor, some viewers would’ve danced the sugarplum fairy in order to get a winner like Yul in one of those seasons. His game was that ahead of its time.
Hes good but like Tony the super idol makes his game a lot less impressive. Its so much easier and safer to play when u have 100% guaranteree ur not going home and u dont even need to worry about playing the idol at the right tine
@@survivorbest4589 That’s fair, but Yul’s idol play even with a super idol is some of the best ever. The way he is so level headed but can be calculated and cold. He forces Jonathan to go with Aitu and then votes him off anyway, he perfectly blindsides Cao-Boi to protect his idol after using his alliance to figure out its weakness and destroy it, and he found it with ease (the quickest super idol ever found). Everything else about his game is astounding, his jury management is perfect, his strategy, social game and alliance making and even challenge prowess is all brilliant. He is a one of the GOATs
@@survivorbest4589 And, he had the whole of Raro telling his alliance to vote him for days, and painting a target on his back, which they could have flushed his idol and sent a raro member home and then voted him off but his social game and strategic game was all phenomenal to the point where nobody would or could target him until it was too late
@@survivorbest4589 I agree. That's why I don't care that much for Tony's or Yul's win, and I'm kinda rolling my eyes whenever people hype up Tony's first season. His game in WaW is incredible, but honestly, I don't see the hype for his first win. And I definitely wouldn't rate it anywhere near #4
I love yul but I just wish Ozzy got it
Bob wearing his buff as a bow tie was adorable though lol
Honestly though! I hate that no one ever brings that up.
Something you forgot to mention about Yul's win is that it came against maybe the greatest challenge beast/ pure "survivor" of all time in Ozzy. Yul needed to play essentially a perfect game in order to edge out the FTC
Yul only won cause of the super idol and twist final 3. One of the least impressive wins
Buttery jury.
Bitter*
@@goofygooberya2number2love butter juries, lol
Yummy
The fact that Adam lost points for yelling all of his confessionals 😂😂😂
I think you are underselling Parvati a little. She really only flirted with James. She was one of the first that had an alliance on a separate tribe (Natalie and Alexis) and an alliance with her own tribe (Amanda and Cirie) which always put her in the best position.
I don’t get the jeremy hate. Dude was going to sweep the board regardless of the sob story he told at the end. And he played a dominant game. The only votes where he wasn’t in the loop was when his closest ally was blindsided and wentworth negated 10 votes
Right? I love Jeremy.
Literally, nobody respected Tasha's game and nobody liked Spencer all that much. Jeremy's reveal changed absolutely nothing, he was gonna dominate FTC either way.
I love Jeremy but if he didn’t need to make his big confession to win than I wish he hadn’t done so. It’s bad optics when the jury votes for someone after learning something about him or her that has nothing to do with the show.
I love Spencer too and am forever going back and forth on whether I would have preferred seeing him win instead, but it’s a moot point since apparently he was never in it.
I hate how when Tasha is asked what she did to show agency in the game she claims to have been riding Spencer’s coattails and doesn’t even mention how she saved herself from near-certain elimination when she was swapped to the expansion tribe. It’s one of the most skillful squeezes through a tight space that I’ve ever seen.
I’m a huge Spencer fan but I totally see why Jeremy won
I kinda feel the same about Adam (MvGenX). He didn't need to tell the jury about his mom to win their votes, but unfortunately since he did mention it, audiences think he got pity votes.
my favorite season and winner both placed #2 on each, how ironic
Natalie Anderson doesn’t get the credit she deserves. She’s far too hidden in the first half of SJDS but her post merge game reminds me of Parv in both HvV and Micronesia. She and Parv are top 2 female winners for me.
Totally agree. When she pretends she accidentally voted for someone because she was confused and John believes her??? And turning on Baylor? I was genuinely upset when she didn’t win winners at war
Natalie's game is one of my favorites and honestly, one of the strongest of the show imo. She played that beautifully, navigating all these couples to perfection despite being the first person to lose hers.
Agreed, definitely one of the strongest performances ever towards the end game.
Yep. Natalie was one of the most dominating winners ever. Great socially, strategically, and physically. Taking control from the drop. Very underrated.
I’m obsessed with Nat Anderson. She’s amazing!
Chris Daughtry is my favorite winner. He went from potential first boot to last man standing to winner. What a great journey
I feel like Parvati had the best winning strategy HANDS DOWN! I personally wouldn’t say she’s #6 but a brilliant strategy. I feel like her game is the best for modern Survivor: Actively burn a early jury to paint yourself as a jury goat. This is risky but it paved the road for her endgame as she was a #1 to everyone within her alliance and knew she’d be sending people out she knew loved her. Not only only her social game saved her but her perception of it to her competition did. Not only did that make Amanda a prime target of taking a shot at Parvmanda but also if Amanda ever DID get eliminated. Parvati falls into a bunch of back-up plans being a #1 to both Cirie and Natalie. If Erik bulldozed his way through immunities, Parvati has a likely chance to make f3, even f2 as Cirie was staying loyal to Parvmanda which clear HURT Cirie’s game as her, Natalie and Amanda were all so loyal to the person who had the hugest shot to make it to FTC instead of say.. Cirie taking a shot at that. (Believe me, I think Cirie played the best game and had great strategies but Parvati had great longterm ones!)
Love how you put spoiler warning in title. I don’t think it’s possible to talk about winners without spoilers, unless you’re like “my favourite is winner of season 20” 😆
The bow tie buff is pretty cool. Also, great video!
Chris Daugherty is easy a top 5 winner, absolutely flawless! His final tribal performance is a thing of absolute beauty
Amen.
Happy to see Fabio make it higher than he usually does on winner rankings. Definitely not a strong strategic winner, but his personality and the unlikeliness of someone like him winning makes him my favorite.
Wasn’t Fabio actually smart but he played dumb,Am I correct on that?
@@nvm9040 Yeah! I do think that's accurate! I personally like his game a lot, as he was socially aware enough to know how he needed to play to survive.
@@Greeples8 I agree with that,Fabio wasn’t the brightest winner but he played a character that was dumb
I have to say that Fabio is probably my second favorite winner of all time, after my dude Todd Herzog. Just my personal second favorite because he was alot of fun to watch and super entertaining. He actually played a good strategy for that starting tribe. Being a dopey fun loving guy took a target off his back. He let all the drama and nonsense happen around him until he got to a spot where he could try and go on an immunity run. So glad that happened and Fabio could polish the turd that was Nicaragua.
@@evanmacbride4796This is a great point, I really do think that Nicaragua would overall be a much worse season without Fabio’s win.
I think Sarah is criminally low. I think this game was a masterclass and had me rooting for her the whole time. From day 1 you could see her studying every single little thing about every other player
A male discrediting women’s gameplay what’s new
she’s definitely top 10. i put her in top 5. i’d also put kim in top 10 as she’s one of the most dominant winners of all time. i really don’t understand this guy’s ranking
Agreed. I'd place her 3rd behind both of Tony's games.
This isn't HIS ranking, this is the ranking based on average score of the viewers
@@likacl As stated in the video 00:19
I expected to hate this list but I actually really like it, even the rankings I disagree with I 100% understand the rationale behind like Kim, rob, and earl playing against week casts or Brian, aras, and chochran, getting there alliances pagonged if they enter the merge without the numbers, and the underedditing of winners like tommy and Sophie. I do think this lost works almost better as a player rankings then a winner rankings personally but that is absolutely not a bad thing ether. Personally I usually rank winners based on there winning game and nothing else but that often gets players like Brian and Boston rob ranked higher then they would be on a player rankings and people like Michelle and Ben near the bottom when they are genuinely solid and consistent players of survivor. Basically what I’m trying to say is even if you disagree with the rankings at least try to understand the rationale behind it (heck, OUAI literally gave his criteria at the beginning of the video) instead of writing it off completely. And even if you still disagree, can’t we just all get along for once
I agree with you tbh. It heavily depends on the type of list, especially because you can have people that are much better players than what their game showed like Sandra’s or Michele’s, and also players who played masterful games, but are much high-variance like Cochran or Boston Rob
Jenna felt way too low. She was the first time a challenge beast won, as well as one of the first landslide victories. She played a good social game between both genders and managed her perceived threat level really well
The whole list is a mess
Jenna was on the verge of quitting and basically gave up on the game after Heidi got voted out. Rob literally had to convince her to play lol
@@TrueGuardify so? she still rocks i don't get ur point
@@abook2141 She's probably one of-if not the weakest winner in American Survivor history off the top of my head.
Tbh every winner besides Chris and Brian felt like they should’ve been higher so it’s understandable why some had to fall lower then they felt like they deserved.
I feel the label is wrong. This is not a winner's gameplay ranking, is a winner's likeability ranking. And as that is pretty accurate. Tony, Todd and Yul are the holly trinity. I though Sandra was more liked, but maybe her further appearances affected her?
The rankings are based on gameplay and character equally.
@@OnceUponAnIsland A little late and out of topic but I thank you for your channel! You put a lot of work for us to have good content
I think Bob is an underrated winner. Yeah his final tribal council wasn’t the best but he had a great social game. He made the first successful fake idol, he was the most likable of the whole cast except for maybe Marcus, he won a lot of individual challenges, and his social game and relationship with Sugar gave him the chance to make fire. He practiced and he won. Even though most of the cast sucked he still had a solid win.
no strategy though.
Tina top 10, I LOVE to see it. She set the standard for everyone! I needed her on Heroes vs Villains so bad just to take J.T.'s note, burn it, and convince him to vote himself out right there
I love this ranking! It's very reasonable imo. The only one I was baffled with was Kim. I understand that entertaininment value played a part, but #16 is kinda of insane.
Maryanne knocked Sophie off her perch as my favorite winner. I adore her energy, honesty, and think she played a perfectly timed game. The idol pull at FTC was the icing on the cake.
At least Sophie deserved the win.
Yeah.. but top 20? I like her but by transitional standards she’s a low tier winner.
Bro has awful taste in survivor winners
Sophie is such an underrated winner
Sophie is in my top 5 least favorite winners
I've said it a million times and I'll say it again
Natalie played a FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR better game than the edit gives her credit for.
Ye she got screwed over by her edit because of Russell hogging the screen
What evidence is there for this? The show established her role in taking out Eric and showed her building social bonds with people, and that's all she sold herself on at FTC and that's why she won. It was the most unsatisfying win in Survivor history at the time if not still.
@@stogerat There's a re-edited version that uses a bunch of her secret scenes which literally TRIPLES her confessional count. Yes, the edit did her dirty.
@@Julian-lz5pd Ok, so she had unaired confessionals. I've seen all the secret scenes, nothing in them really suggests she played harder than the show itself suggested. The secret scene confessionals with her don't show her making any big moves or anything of the sort.
@@stogerat Ok. But she still set the Galu’s pagonging into motion. Got his tribe to turn on him with an idol in his pocket. Thus prevented her other tribe from a bulletproof plan and had her goat play an idol successfully.
Also, she was an upper jury threat at best for a while since f9. She beats her goat, Mick, John, Jaison and Shambo via a jury.
Unlike other winners like Chris U, Bob/Fabio, Ben and to an extent Michelle and Sandra HvV game. She never had to win out or expressed any bad gameplay or had any flaws whatsoever. She always knew what was going on, never was out of the loop on anything, road coattails to someone that handed her the million on hand and never changed that strategy ever.
Strategy-wise, she’s flawless and she was good socially. Never made any strategic blunders, never needed to make a move. She’s not a top tier or even a great winner but she should be higher than where she is.
I’m not gonna post a petty rant but this list is… well… something 🙄 appreciate you showing everyone what the fandom is currently into though! But goodness
Here's my argument for why Boston' Rob's win on RI is far superior to his almost win on AS- coming into AS he was a last minute addition to the cast, not nearly the power player that Lex and Kathy were, so expectations for and towards him (from his castmates) were low. He was never a threat to be an early boot like the bigger players (Colby, Ethan) so once he got his hooks in, he could ride that to the end.
But that means that he had a huge target coming into RI- that he was able to work and charm his way into his tribe is a testament to his immense social skills. Then, once he's in and in the power seat, he has to contend with another alpha male in Grant, and a total loose canon in Philip. When people evaluate his tribe, they tend to only look at the girls, without giving Rob the credit to manage two tricky male players.
IMO, the reason Rob's tribe looked like a bunch of dummies is due to how expertly he played them.
A lot of Rob's tribe on RI have admitted to only seeing him on HvV. Most of them had never seen All Stars or Marquesas, so they only saw the likable underdog that got screwed over by Russell. Then when he was put on the season in opposition to Russell, his tribe naturally were excited to get him.
I can never fault Rob himself for the cast they chose to put him with, and his game was impressive considering the cards he was dealt. But overall, it's just hard to feel that impressed when he had so much stacked in his favor.
Rob on RI is a game that I love because i loved AS Rob so I basically got the same thing here but Rob was more social
@@nvm9040 He was just so smooth, using the carrot instead of the stick. It's clear he read a lot about how to influence people, and he figured out what each person wanted and gave them that.
I really don't think he gets enough credit in how he dealt with Phillip, who was not just annoying, but also unpredictable and erratic.
I think a lot of objection towards Rob comes from opposition to captain seasons rather than his actual performance.
Please his RI win is the single most overrated game in history. He deserved to win, but it is far from one of the best. He loses a jury vote to everyone but Phillip and Natalie, which shows his jury management was absolute garbage. It was a piss poor cast. He was in danger of being the merge boot. He had no options outside his alliance. And he made 2 or 3 visible strategic errors too.
I look forward to watching your story videos on my favorites!
Tony and Parvati will always be my favorite winners. Both playing aggressive and strategic.
Tony’s win in winners at war by itself makes him the best player of all time in my opinion. But when you stack that on top of his Cagayan win, he’s the undisputed GOAT
Parvati, she always have a huge target and she managed to go to the end and the very end and everyone knows
Love your vids
Brian being ranked below Bob is mind blowing to me
People really don't like Brian. He received the most votes for least liked winner.
@@OnceUponAnIsland yeah I saw your other reply but it feels bias from the voters, assumed this fanbase might be a little more analytical and appreciate his gameplay, or at least more so than the likes of Natalie and Bob. Then again maybe I’m missing something 🤷🏻♂️.
@@visc4314 I was thinking the same thing,I love Bob in Gabon but he had no strategic game and he almost lost to Susie but Brian had the strategic game to be social in a way to steer the game in his direction
It’s also ridiculous to claim that Brian “barely” won. Was it close on paper? Yes. But he secured the votes he needed to win, and there was never doubt about that. That level of control is impressive.
Yh was definitely surprised after that
Great list. I can’t argue with it.
It's crazy how low Tom Westman is on this list. People don't like him because of how he manipulated his tribe? What about Todd Herzog and Parvati Shallow, who were way more manipulative, but rank 6th and 2nd? Tom was a much better winner than both of them and many higher than him on the list. He was a challenge beast, a good strategist, very likable and friendly, and served his country as a firefighter. Nobody, except maybe Ian, would have won against him in the end.
I don't think that's the actual reason, I think it's moreso that people aren't impressed with winners that go on comp runs. I think his strategic game was also pretty solid for his season but when compared to the Parvati's, the Boston Rob's, the Todd's, the Kim's of the world, his win is not especially exciting tbh. Plus, he's not really fully playing the actual game of Survivor until the merge (a gripe people also have with winners like Michelle and Erika) and some of his individual wins were crapshoots where he would've gotten voted out had luck not been on his side that day (that one challenge with the number combination comes to mind, Ian would've beat him if Tom hadn't stumbled on the correct order by chance). Still impressive, winning Survivor is inherently impressive, but he wouldn't breach my top 15 tbh.
Tom definitely deserves to be way higher
People who I would have loved to see win are David, Rick Devens, and Spencer. People who played this game really well but just couldn't make it to the end.
Natalie Anderson will always be my no.1. She palyed such a great game throughout
Just wanted to say I don’t think it got boring when Mike Holloway kept winning immunity. It kept it interesting, cause he was the underdog. If he lost and got eliminated, the season would have been far worse off.
My favorite winner is Adam by a long shot.
MvGX was the season that made me fan of Survivor once again after I stopped watching it as a kid.
And having mom, who also went through cancer and beat it, I related to Adam so much, since I know very well how difficult it is.
Then he won and I was so ecstatic, but when he said that his mom died, I just lost it. Literal waterfalls of tears.
No one can in my eyes replace Adam as my favorite winner. And with MvGX being my absolute favorite season, it's like the perfect recommendation from me to anyone, who wants to start watching Survivor.
10 Rob 22
9 Natalie A 29
8 Yul 13
7 Jt 18
6 Tony Cageyan
5 Tony WAW
4 Kim 24
3 Todd 15
2 Jeremy 31
1 PARVATI!!!!!! 16
Those are my top 10 I hope you like it
Aras is a great character. He would have been ten times more entertaining if he wasn’t in a tribe with Shane/Courtney/Danielle/Bob-Dawg/Bruce and Cirie. They were so much bigger personalities.
I just love how Aras, as the hippy yoga guy, would have been the weirdo on most other tribes. But on that one he's the straight man
Tony’s final tribal in WaW is the greatest ever in my opinion. Yul and JT will forever be my favorite winners.
I think it's unfair to have Chris the last ranking just because of the production. If we were to stick with how the individual player played, Chris really did play tenaciously. Him having to stay in EoE and winning the last comeback challenge and surviving the tribal councils after and also risking the final spot by playing fire despite winning the final immunity is just sickening. People have to give credit where credit is due. Despite him getting a freebie of an idol when he returned, he still fought his way back. He played a good balance of social and physical game. He basically did a Natalie of Season 40 except that Natalie didnt win, and everyone loved Natalie in season 40 so why cant we give the same to Chris though.
…He was literally eliminated via a vote and missed out on the season for 28 days. No other winner can say that.
Yeah he did play fantastic…. For 6 days
I'm dissatisfied with brian being 40, like he sucks outside the game but in the game he did play a really good game
Brian has the most strategic gameplay out of the first 8 seasons in my opinion so I would rank a little higher for his strategic game and his challenge wins
@@nvm9040 I think Tina does. I think being solely strategic has to have a social game too which Tina did have while dominating the game like Brian
@@devondonato4609 okay it agree with that but she overshadowed by the edit the whole season
The only ones I would switch are Tony’s wins. You have to remember with his first win is that is came with no individual immunity wins (unless I’m forgetting one). Overall though, really good list.
I honestly can't wrap my head around watching 42 seasons of what is essentially adults doing middle school field day competitions
And yet it is now up to 46 seasons!
21% for bob is a little bit higher than I thought the general community would give him, but hey, his wit, ingenuity, and physical game definitely grants him the win
Bob was the winner a trainwreck like Gabon deserved.
I don’t think Natalie W deserves to be so low either, she played the exact game she needed to to set up her win, much better than a lot of the other lower ranked winners.
Real ones never forget when Adam thought the thing was an idol at tribal Council 😂😂
Im happy for next ranking. I want ask one question. WHO Is your favorite from this winners? If u want my Is eathan
Tom being at #19 is criminal, what the hell?
Tom is a criminal?
Tina didnt convince Colby to throw his game away. Colby didnt want easy win against Keith and lost by one vote. The deciding factor was Alicia vote and she was 50/50 coming to final tribal.
I was watching the show at the time and I didn't think it was a terrible decision. Keith wasn't that terrible and I think the jury would have saw Colby as fake if he would have voted out Tina because he made it very known that he didn't like Keith. Survivor was different then and Colby had a 50/50 shot at beating Tina and keeping his good guy image. You can't compare it to Woo taking Tony instead of Kass. Nobody would have held it against Woo.
@@zeaferjones1404 Colby would have won 5-2 or 6-1 vs Keith. Maybe 7-0.
@@SurvivorIce colby would 7-0 against kieth easily bro.
@@SurvivorIce colby would sweep keith.
I feel like Bob's win was very refreshing in Gabon. Considering how much that season included a group of mostly toxic, bashful, conniving, and mean-spirited players, Bob winning through playing a very honest and pure game and pulling through was a breath of fresh air. Although I do want to say I love Ken's run that season. He played great until he didnt.
Surprised how low Kim was. She's my #1 winner game
She's definitely one of the most dominant when it comes to play style.
By & large, I think the fans got it pretty darn close.
Can’t wait to see where everyone puts Gabler. I’d argue his game better than a majority of winners but I guess the 2023 vote will tell where he is!
Chris is the forever underdog man. I was so happy when he won the challenge, what an awesome dude and story
Until this video I hadn't realized bob's bow tie was his buff !!
Sandra should've been way higher on the list, and definitely higher up than Boston Rob. She won twice before he even got his lone victory on a season custom made for him and placed higher than him in both seasons she played together with him.
Wasn't Sandra one jury vote away from a perfect game in Pearl Islands?
Yeah
I need a new one with the 43 winner!
This next summer we will do one with the 43 and 44 winner included.
@@OnceUponAnIsland can’t wait!!
I'll just say to prevent spoilers. No1 was exactly who I had hoped.
Are they still number 1 in the updated 2023 rankings?
i like the list, personally would change things obviously, anyone would, but id say its pretty solid for the most part, kinda shocked sandra doesnt even crack top 10 though
Nick should be top 10. D v G season was STACKED. Many great social players & Comp threats. He also exemplified what the season was about. Certainly one of the most important seasons in the shows running.
Don’t understand how Chris is last he was great that season and it’s a great story how he comes back after getting voted out then wins. Also not to mention giving up his final immunity then winning the fire making challenge was nothing short of amazing.
It just feels like it goes against the whole point of survivor. He just just to play hard strategically for a few days to win
Who's the most deserving to win among the final three? 🤔
1. The Challenge beast 💪
2. The Strategist 🧐
3. The Mr. Nice guy 😇
Won all immunity straight
Dictates who's gonna be voted out
Very likeable & never get voted
Tom and Kim not in top 10 is a travesty
Jeff Probst says when idols happen votes do not count so yes Jeremy counts as a perfect winner
My Rankings:
42. Amber
41. Jenna
40. Natalie W.
39. Chris U.
38. Fabio
37. Brian
36. Bob
35. Michele
34. Aras
33. Ben
32. Mike
31. Erica
30. Tina
29. Tommy
28. Danni
27. Chris D.
26. Ethan
25. Sarah
24. Sophie
23. Maryanne
22. Wendell
21. Nick
20. Sandra (Pearl Islands)
19. Vecepia
18. Sandra (Heroes Vs. Villains)
17. J.T.
16. Rich
15. Adam
14. Tyson
13. Jeremy
12. Tom
11. Rob
10. Earl
9. Yul
8. Tony (Cagayan)
7. Todd
6. Denise
5. Kim
4. Cochran
3. Natalie A.
2. Parvati
1. Tony (Winners At War)
Sugar would've also been a great winner for Survivor: Gabon as well
Parvati is pretty and flirty sweet and devious gets her fish hooked fast without fish knowing they are hooked u go girl 😅
hold up Bens win was really fun and interesting. why so low.
I guess a lot of poeple voted based on the quality of the season and the entertainment by the winner but man, you guys really did Tommy dirty. Tommy is atleast top 20, for me even top 10 :(
People gave him good marks for gameplay but were bored by him as a character.
Definitely top 10 in game play, just a lot of people hate that season
I really agree with this opinion
i was happy Vecepia is ranked higher than she usually does,,, but still she should be higher
My favorite Winners: Natalie Anderson, Pavarti, Yul, and Tony!
YES! SO GLAD TONY IS 1ST! DEFINITELY MY FAVORITE PLAYER.
I’d love to see rankings now that the current season has ended.
Make sure to vote when we do the 2023 rankings!
The top of the list is great. Love seeing Yul and Todd get credit for their amazing play in their wins. Tony's wins at the top are well deserved. Kim's win should be way, wayyyyy higher, and I disagree with some at the bottom and middle as well. Still a fun video.
This is really bad take 😭
@@goofygooberya2number2 Ok!
You should do one about how much each winner deserves the win
Great idea. I basically cover that in each winner's story video.
Have to say that Ben was presented as much more likable in Winners At War and Challenge USA, but it's hard to disagree with the ranking, as I consider it to be an indictment of the shenanigans that led to his win more than the man himself.
I agree. I like Tina. She's amazing!
Todd shocked me but I agree 1000%
Poor chris underwood ); he played a solid game, and the dropping imunitty was fantastic strategy
He still got voted out. Something that 40 other winners can’t say about their games.
Am i the only one who thinks that maryanne is way too high, shes all personality and didnt really play a strategic game at all. she just hid behind all the big threats the whole game and i dont even think she deserved to win, then to put her infront of sophie on the tierlist? i dont think maryanne should be so high
The poll was done not too long after 42 aired, I wonder if she will drop when we do it again next summer?
@@OnceUponAnIsland maybe, I feel like the 26 days changes the dynamic of the game a lot so maybe I’m just not used to it yet
if anything she's way too low, she proved that you don't need to make moves all the time just the right moves in the right moments, with one of the best final jury speeches she deserves her spot
Putting Marianne above Boston rob is just blasphemy lol
Chris at 14 just shows these 'fans' haven't watched season 9..
I understand Erica not getting ranked higher, because of that one twist. Not her fault - you play the hand you're dealt - but the Hourglass twist probably left a sour taste in most people's mouths, and it's always going to affect her winner's ranking.
BTW, I loved that Danny (and Kiki) got some measure of redemption by winning The Challenge USA.
(edit) also, was not a fan of Cagayan Tony and the general chaos of that season. So I think he was ranked too high here. His Winners At War ranking I'm ok with, although it did seem that most of the jury were unwilling to give Nat a win (fair enough given the circumstances). Figured it would be a closer vote than we got.
You’re tripping if u don’t think Tony’s the goat. Cagayan he was clearly the best there by a mile. His chaos is what made him so fun. Winners at war, 20 winners he didn’t get a single vote and controlled almost every single vote. Natalie was voted out 1st. If she would’ve won she would’ve been the worst winner imo. She relied only on her physical play over on exile. Tony stayed the whole game and never received an advantage, with Natalie actively trying to get him out the whole game. Yet never got one vote. Greatest game ever played by the greatest to ever do it
@@tristangriffin6687 If your criteria for being the best is "his chaos made him fun", you're not giving me the best case for him being the best. Willing to hear you out, just give me some better reasoning.
For WAW, you misunderstood me a bit, as I said that I'm ok with Tony's ranking for that. So let me expand a little bit on my thinking.
I don't think Nat would've won, but I felt that more jurors would've given her credit for doing whatever it took to get back into the game, and that she and Michelle did control those last few Tribals. Then again, I thought Michelle would get a vote as well. She didn't play poorly, and a no-vote final doesn't really do her justice.
I don't think Tony played a perfect game on WAW, but he showed a lot more maturity than he did on Game Changers - he tried to play the same game as he did on Cagayan there, and people were not having it. Chaos? I would say it was there, but in a controlled fashion. And I think that control is what helped him get to the winner's circle on WAW.
Still baffles me how underappreciated Michele is... I would've voted for her to win Winners At War
Damn, I don’t understand the rationale on over half of these rankings whatsoever. Top tier winners being ranked below people like Amber who did little to nothing over the course of her season and Fabio who’s Fabio. I’m literally laughing about most of these because it’s not even me disagreeing with them, they’re just wrong.
half of the weighting of the scores is likability. I'm not sure how you can say someone's opinion on who they liked/rooted for in a season is "wrong". it's subjective.
Very unpopular opinion: Amber is my favorite winner. Her gameplay might not be #1, but it's definitely underrated and she's such a likeable person
19:42 “rustle” some feathers - Hayden
Tony (Cagayan) is royalty too!
Brian heidick Is one of the best ever he identified the votes in ftc he needed and got them, let the bitter jurors stew. Wins without kissing the annoying jurors asses
Tom W. was amazing, I'm surprised he isn't higher on the list!
Yul and Todd are my all time Top 2. Glad you almost agree!
Todd??? Your crazy
YAY! GO TODD!!!!
Poor Jenna M, once Heidi went out she turned up her game and did actually start playing hard, I think she did more than some winners like Nat White or Fabio
I loved Jenna in her season and I don’t knock her decision for quitting in AS because anyone would do the same thing
@@nvm9040 I was bummed to not see her in WAW since she had to leave for family reasons in AS
@@stogerat I wanted to see some more old school winners in WAW but it’s whatever
I know that this is more of a popularity contest than anything else, but I had to stop watching when I saw that the great Jenna Morasca was ranked 41st (!). She is the most underrated winner in Survivor history in my view. I'd easily rank her in the top 20 at a minimum.
She is just not by any standard
Frrr Brian at 40 and Tommy at 35💀💀 I don’t think this guy understand survivor
00:18
@@OnceUponAnIsland Right. I understand. Like I said, it's a popularity contest.
@@snakeranger4514 Dude, Jenna won 6-1. She also won four immunity challenges and only had her name written down three times. And two of those votes were because she made a smart move to protect her No. 1 ally. She's an excellent winner with a bad edit.
Fabio is above Amber?
Brian is at the very bottom, just above Jenna and Chris Underwood?
Meh.
Wow I thought Aras was a great winner man…He played a fantastic game on one of the most underrated seasons ever
Maryanne is a top ten winner for me. I love her so much and her endgame is one of the best in survivor