(Dec 2021) Google has ruined the experience of this wonderful performance by inserting ads at a random point. Tragedy. I used to listen to this performance over and over years ago and finally undertook to learn the piano part and assemble a violinist and cellist to play with -- safely in a venue where ads do not pop up.
A very sensible interpretation. I remember when I played it with a violinist from the Vienna Symphonic Orchester and the cello soloist from the same orchester. When you live in Vienna you must play this. It is like oxygen or water, absolutely necessary to survive.
This performance is as good as any I have ever listened to. These players are far beyond their years in understanding. Right when I think the cellist is the best the pianist is right there. They are phenomenal.
15:54 memories of Barry Lyndon, what a great film and perfect soundtrack! Seriously, though, fantastic performance! Hope to hear you live somewhere, someday.
Wow, all the people commenting about the way the cellist looks when she plays honestly make me giggle a bit. Here's a shocking idea: Try LISTENING to the music and stop paying so much attention to irrelevant things. The best example of this I can think of was the great Russian pianist Sviatoslav Richer, who later in his career would often play recitals with only a small lamp on the piano so the audience could focus on what really mattered, the music! In his own words "...What's the point of watching a pianist's hands or face, when they only express the efforts being expended on the piece?" Obviously the majority of the musical world has no issue with this particular cellist, since for example in 2014, this trio gave over 50 concerts across the U.S. and Europe. What I see when I "look" at this cellist is someone who plays wonderful music, and clearly has a very bright future ahead of them, but also a few crabby people who have a very strange idea that one listens to music more with their eyes than their ears.
For what it's worth, I love seeing the expression on the faces of musicians. Specifically I think of Dame Mitsuko uchida and of Héleèn Grimaud. Personally, I find these expressions edifying. By contrast, I don't like Mischa Maisky--a wonderful player--who is completely absorbed in his impenetrable world, without visible contact with his fellow performers & the audience. I guess, it's the old saying, "To each his own." As to listening without looking, I can look and listen. There are ways to turn the f the screen light off, in case you didn't know that...
How do you know what the "world" thinks. Maybe most of the concert-goers are weirdos just hoping and praying to see her eyeballs pop out of their sockets. As far as "just listen to the music", I could do THAT much better on a super-bitrate Google Play audio stream recorded in a professional recording studio by reknowned musicians not still struggling to leave the womb of the conservatory. We go on RUclips to WATCH the performance. DUH.
I can say I'm addicted to the 2nd Movement. So slow and shadowy. It makes you the will of throwing everything up. But then it breaks into a warm and bright melody. Shubert is so emotional, I like that in music.
I was lucky to have heard this piece on CD several times before I saw it live and then here. It is absolutely symphonic in scope, taking us on a great journey. Think what Schubert could have done had he not died so young. This trio does a very fine job. Thanks for posting it.
Certainly are a lot of complainers out there. A beautiful, youthful performance of one of the all-time great trios. We are all lucky to get a chance to hear and see it.
Ma meilleure expérience musicale à vie: imaginez cette musique dans les oreilles, en pleine brousse africaine, avec personne autour. La pure magie! Merci Schubert pour ces moments de grâce.
Of all the wonderful chamber music that Schubert composed, for me this one is the strangest and most fascinating . I could hear it ten times and never fail to love and appreciate its innovations and daring.
Let´s just cut to the chase : This is a glorious playing of one of the most amazingly beautiful , glorious pieces of Music ever written , there are simply no other words for that . Bravi !!!
Splendid rendition of the opus 100 trio. The andante has a magical quality. Impossible not to remember Barry Lyndon of Lyndonhurst! Many thanks to the young interpreters. Beautiful video.
Brilliant Performance. I could listen to this performance daily. The pure stamina to play the piano, violin or cello has got to be challenging. Incredible.
superb ensemble, balance, intonation, phrasing and sheer musicality. what a pleasure to see so much talent in celebration of schubert. hope to see more of this trio in the future!
Why in this world will you cut this off and not let us hear the applause? Why do I not get to thank and acknowledge the players by clapping with the audience? What frustration! Especially after such wonderful playing of the genius of Schubert.
I am an amateur pianist, I've worked at it all my life, and I have played this piece multiple times, once in concert at Kneisel Hall, where this trio got their start. I know every note of it. This is a fantastic performance. I can't say enough about the pianist. This is no mean feat for the pianist and she carries it off brilliantly. The string players are also wonderful (Joel Krosnick's daughter is a fine cellist? What a surpise!). I love the tempo in the second movement, which is frequently played too slowly. It's Andante CON MOTO and that's what they gave us.
Congratulations for such a great interpretation! And many thanks for showing us your personalities with such candor; this is such a wonderful gift. I wish all musicians could play with their guts as much as you do.
Something wonderful to see young people play such beautiful music. Reminds me of Collegium 1704, who specialize in Zelenka, but who bring enthusiam to "serious" music. Reminds me, somehow, of Thelonius Monk, who would get so deeply into the music that, sometimes, he would stand up and dance while his sidemen took a solo. Monk lives, Schubert lives, and music lives!
The quality of the recording and the beauty of the music is a joy to the senses. It makes me happy to be able to hear such sounds. I'm amazed that this sort of quality is available for free on RUclips.
.....About how the cellist looks: One time, in a piano competition, I was videoed from every which angle -- first time I'd seen myself that way. I was embarrassed about the 'faces' I was making, a lot more 'far out' than what we see here. I decided to stifle it for the next round. I stunk. :-) Sometimes it's just part of our making of the music.
I would assert that some of that is *essential* to music-making, especially when it's natural (as opposed to faked), which it clearly is in this case. It's rare to encounter a musician who shows no emotional reaction to the music either through facial expressions or body movement or both and who plays with great feeling for and understanding of the music. Vladimir Horowitz was one. A rarity.
Needless to say, the music is heavenly. The Andante is painfully beautiful. It aches so much that it heals inner wounds! By the time its main theme recurs in the Allegro, we're already high up there -- in Paradise! As for the performance, it's at least 8/10.
Simply beautiful - I have listened to the performance twice now and still find it quite sublime. Trio Sublime, don't change a thing - you are artists of the first order - stay distinctive and original - God bless you all always.
Bravo guys. I wish I was on that level while in university! This trio would find its place in some all time top 20 chamber music pieces list. Not that the other one is bad, but this one is perfect. Schubert really wrote chamber music masterpieces:Trout,Death an the Maiden, and the greatest -string quintet with 2 cellos. Love his music.
Some comments on the Barry Lyndon interpretation, which was so much slower. Apparently some people would like this to be replicated here. I absolutely love the interpretation in the film Barry Lyndon. It is absolutely perfectly interpreted in that context. BUT This does not mean that the interpretation here cannot be equally good. There is no single truth in how to interpret a piece of music. It depends so much on the context and the mood of the moment, and the personality of the musicians. The musicians define what they want to give, and the art of listening is to open your heart so as to receive what is given. If you get stuck to one expectation, it must be a very dull life of listening, that life of yours!
Their mannerism may not be exactly orthodox. But for me, their performance is really high quality. Her mannerism is not affecting her performance. It is a beautiful, passionate performance of a incredibly beautiful piece of music.
A mature work by Schubert containing a glistening development in the sonata allegro movement. The players give it a beautiful sheen. The cellist must be the daughter or grand daughter of Joel Krosnik, professor at Julliard and long a member of the eponymous string quartet. Somehow the piano part rings like fine crystal, as the piano in the Trout Quintet.
An impishly Mozart-ine work, especially after 32:24, when Schubert playfully makes the melody pretend to "stutter" by repeating each of its notes, its "consonants," an equal number of times! Enchanting. Also, nowadays it's reassuring to hear a 200-year old trio played by a trio of wholesome twenty-year olds! No tattoos! Herrlich!
I remember this memorable recital as if were today. Schubert sounds exciting within our soul longing for the Romantic music as he can only deliver. BZ Niditch international surrealist poet and violinist.
Splendid! This is the liveliest interpretation of the piece I've found on RUclips so far. Any minor inaccuracies are more than compensated by their superb expressiveness.
By far this is the best version in my opinion. These incredibly talented musicians can look back many years from now and take delight in this wonderful performance. I'm posting this because I just purchased a 2-CD set which includes this work. Nope! - it's not as inspiring as Trio Cleonice.
Zionini, Corrado comments on this but I'm not clear if you already know the theme you refer to was used by Stanley Kubrick in his film Barry Lyndon. Apart from the fact that it does recur within the trio. An excellent performance and interpretation. I will keep my eyes opened for Cleonice. I'm not a musician and don't play the piano but I don't think one has to be to realise this music is not lacking in challenges for a pianist. Even if it weren't I totally agree with Galahad.
Bravo! I have to tell you, I flipped through recording after recording of this Trio to try to find one which (to my taste) does justice to that grand shift to major (it isn't really a "modulation," is it, although we could call it that) toward the end of the 4th movement. Subjective, of course, but, to my taste :-) there's an awfully long list of "name" performers who didn't. Thank you to you guys for DOING it. One of the great moments of the entire music literature, too often glossed over as though not much of anything is going on there....
Excellent performance of a great piece of music I hadn't listened to before. Thank you to the artists. Shame RUclips spoiled it by inserting a mindless advert as the movement was ending. I hope the RUclips numpty that invented it get promoted out of harm's way soon and someone more sensible scraps this graffiti advertising approach soon. I'm happy to listen to adverts before and after just not when it damages other people's work.
I. Allegro 0:14
II. Andante con Moto 15:53
III. Scherzo 24:18
IV. Allegro Moderato 31:10
thank you so much!
I came for Andante Con Moto. Thank you!
Oh~, you are great.
@@thedayinl.a.9104 Sure! Love the Cello part. ;) This second movement remembered me a bit of Beethoven's Trio "The Ghost".
I so love this piece of Schubert's music - so full of intensity without any loss of musicality. A fine rendition of it!
This whole piece gives me the good chills. And this young trio is AWESOME! Just beautiful.
(Dec 2021) Google has ruined the experience of this wonderful performance by inserting ads at a random point. Tragedy. I used to listen to this performance over and over years ago and finally undertook to learn the piano part and assemble a violinist and cellist to play with -- safely in a venue where ads do not pop up.
Mad respect for the lady reading and turning the pages for the piano
The cellist seems really 'into' her music and appears like she's having fun. I love it!
Ich kenne das Stück seit Jahrzehnten und liebe es, diese drei Musiker haben mir wieder gezeigt warum ich es liebe. Danke!
A very sensible interpretation. I remember when I played it with a violinist from the Vienna Symphonic Orchester and the cello soloist from the same orchester. When you live in Vienna you must play this. It is like oxygen or water, absolutely necessary to survive.
Hanse Hartmann, so well said,bro!! Grùss got!
+Hans Hartmann
Are you in any way related to Erich Hartmann?
this is the spirit of Schubert! music on the highest level, played on the highest level!
This performance is as good as any I have ever listened to. These players are far beyond their years in understanding. Right when I think the cellist is the best the pianist is right there. They are phenomenal.
Deep respect for that young woman with the glasses who turns the pages. She is a good reader.
I was thinking the same, thank you for expressing that thought!
Haha you're not a musician
So very beautiful 3 wonderful musicians. Good job
15:54 memories of Barry Lyndon, what a great film and perfect soundtrack! Seriously, though, fantastic performance! Hope to hear you live somewhere, someday.
I fell so much respect for the girl who tuns the pages. So professional.
Wow, all the people commenting about the way the cellist looks when she plays honestly make me giggle a bit. Here's a shocking idea: Try LISTENING to the music and stop paying so much attention to irrelevant things. The best example of this I can think of was the great Russian pianist Sviatoslav Richer, who later in his career would often play recitals with only a small lamp on the piano so the audience could focus on what really mattered, the music! In his own words "...What's the point of watching a pianist's hands or face, when they only express the efforts being expended on the piece?" Obviously the majority of the musical world has no issue with this particular cellist, since for example in 2014, this trio gave over 50 concerts across the U.S. and Europe. What I see when I "look" at this cellist is someone who plays wonderful music, and clearly has a very bright future ahead of them, but also a few crabby people who have a very strange idea that one listens to music more with their eyes than their ears.
I agree! The fact that she is so involved in the music that she is personally moved by it is so impressive, and it only leads to better music!
Anyone that finds fault with performers' expressive movements, facial or otherwise, clearly doesn't spend much time in live concert settings.
I love watching her.
For what it's worth, I love seeing the expression on the faces of musicians. Specifically I think of Dame Mitsuko uchida and of Héleèn Grimaud. Personally, I find these expressions edifying. By contrast, I don't like Mischa Maisky--a wonderful player--who is completely absorbed in his impenetrable world, without visible contact with his fellow performers & the audience. I guess, it's the old saying, "To each his own." As to listening without looking, I can look and listen. There are ways to turn the f the screen light off, in case you didn't know that...
How do you know what the "world" thinks. Maybe most of the concert-goers are weirdos just hoping and praying to see her eyeballs pop out of their sockets.
As far as "just listen to the music", I could do THAT much better on a super-bitrate Google Play audio stream recorded in a professional recording studio by reknowned musicians not still struggling to leave the womb of the conservatory. We go on RUclips to WATCH the performance. DUH.
la cellista es simplemente adorable, vibra con la musica y se nota.!! excelente trio, como todo lo del NEC
I agree 100% Eduardo-
Love, Laughter, Love
Du grand ART !! A écouter, re-écouter et savourer. Bravo à ces musiciens et merci Schubert ;-)
Sumptuous music. I really love the cellist's brio in the first minute!
Quelle interprétation enthousiaste de cette jeune et belle formation pour cette oeuvre majeure et inoubliable. Complimenti a tutti i tre, ragazzi !
Jacques C.
Passionate yet graceful performance, splendid!
Absolutely beautiful
+Hans Vuijk Not one of the best,,,,,
+Mark Kent of course: they are students ... mind that
Love the second movement very much~ Just so tender, with a little bit of sorrow.
I can say I'm addicted to the 2nd Movement. So slow and shadowy. It makes you the will of throwing everything up. But then it breaks into a warm and bright melody.
Shubert is so emotional, I like that in music.
I was lucky to have heard this piece on CD several times before I saw it live and then here. It is absolutely symphonic in scope, taking us on a great journey. Think what Schubert could have done had he not died so young. This trio does a very fine job. Thanks for posting it.
Certainly are a lot of complainers out there. A beautiful, youthful performance of one of the all-time great trios. We are all lucky to get a chance to hear and see it.
I totally agree. These young musicians are incredible. Their efforts in this lengthy performance are Herculean.
Ma meilleure expérience musicale à vie: imaginez cette musique dans les oreilles, en pleine brousse africaine, avec personne autour. La pure magie! Merci Schubert pour ces moments de grâce.
I keep coming back to this video. It’s the best version to my ears I’ve heard so far.
Of all the wonderful chamber music that Schubert composed, for me this one is the strangest and most fascinating . I could hear it ten times and never fail to love and appreciate its innovations and daring.
It's amazing - the two trios and the cello quintet were written during the last year of his life. Just think if he had lived even a few years longer.
Let´s just cut to the chase : This is a glorious playing of one of the most amazingly beautiful , glorious pieces of Music ever written , there are simply no other words for that . Bravi !!!
Splendid rendition of the opus 100 trio. The andante has a magical quality. Impossible not to remember Barry Lyndon of Lyndonhurst! Many thanks to the young interpreters. Beautiful video.
Brilliant Performance. I could listen to this performance daily. The pure stamina to play the piano, violin or cello has got to be challenging. Incredible.
Splendid performance. I think it's up to each performer to choose his or her's own manner in which to interpret and perform such compositions.
Sublime! Thank you so much! Nothing above this in chamber music. Sentient beyond this world.
superb ensemble, balance, intonation, phrasing and sheer musicality. what a pleasure to see so much talent in celebration of schubert. hope to see more of this trio in the future!
Why in this world will you cut this off and not let us hear the applause? Why do I not get to thank and acknowledge the players by clapping with the audience? What frustration! Especially after such wonderful playing of the genius of Schubert.
Superb. I have no critique when chills arise and my soul is lifted.
Ignore all comments, keep together and give joy to the world! Thank you for being so nice together.
素晴らしいトリオの演奏有り難う！！ピアノ。ヴアイオリン。チエロ ３人の熱気が伝わってくるような入魂の演奏でした！感動しました。
I am an amateur pianist, I've worked at it all my life, and I have played this piece multiple times, once in concert at Kneisel Hall, where this trio got their start. I know every note of it. This is a fantastic performance. I can't say enough about the pianist. This is no mean feat for the pianist and she carries it off brilliantly. The string players are also wonderful (Joel Krosnick's daughter is a fine cellist? What a surpise!). I love the tempo in the second movement, which is frequently played too slowly. It's Andante CON MOTO and that's what they gave us.
Congratulations for such a great interpretation!
And many thanks for showing us your personalities with such candor; this is such a wonderful gift. I wish all musicians could play with their guts as much as you do.
Beautifully played. I have watched this video over and over. Bravo!
Wonderfull performance. Love the cellist emotional feelings for the music, made me feel the music even more myself
Something wonderful to see young people play such beautiful music. Reminds me of Collegium 1704, who specialize in Zelenka, but who bring enthusiam to "serious" music. Reminds me, somehow, of Thelonius Monk, who would get so deeply into the music that, sometimes, he would stand up and dance while his sidemen took a solo. Monk lives, Schubert lives, and music lives!
Probably best piano trio ever. Great video production
Have you ever heard "Archduke" trio Op. 97 from Beethoven?
The quality of the recording and the beauty of the music is a joy to the senses. It makes me happy to be able to hear such sounds. I'm amazed that this sort of quality is available for free on RUclips.
.....About how the cellist looks: One time, in a piano competition, I was videoed from every which angle -- first time I'd seen myself that way. I was embarrassed about the 'faces' I was making, a lot more 'far out' than what we see here. I decided to stifle it for the next round.
I stunk. :-)
Sometimes it's just part of our making of the music.
I would assert that some of that is *essential* to music-making, especially when it's natural (as opposed to faked), which it clearly is in this case. It's rare to encounter a musician who shows no emotional reaction to the music either through facial expressions or body movement or both and who plays with great feeling for and understanding of the music. Vladimir Horowitz was one. A rarity.
@@larchmontmark1 You completely misread what I wrote. Read it again. I think this woman is genuine and that’s what I said.
Donald -- yes, SORRY!!! I just misread it -- didn't pay enough attention to the parentheses!
(And therefore I deleted that previous comment.)
Needless to say, the music is heavenly. The Andante is painfully beautiful. It aches so much that it heals inner wounds! By the time its main theme recurs in the Allegro, we're already high up there -- in Paradise! As for the performance, it's at least 8/10.
Incredible performance!
(Let's not forget about miss Paige Turner helping the pianist with the score.)
The poor Asian girl probably wants to be up there doing the first violin part and not flipping the pages for piano lol :/ she took one for the team XD
A terrific performance!! Indeed, just close your eyes and listen to the music.....
Mon trio préféré ....une très grande oeuvre de Schubert,beaucoup de contrastes !
Excellent! Magnifique travail au piano et aux cordes. Bravo!
Bravi....finalmente un' iterpretazione, tanta poesia ..........Il suono dei singoli e' eccellente.
Among my favorites ... almost at the top of the list. Bravo !
Really beautiful plying of a gorgeous piece! Congratulations to you!
maravillosa versión. además respetan los ritornellos y demás escrituras del compositor. bravo!!
The second movement was a little too fast for my taste, but overall a beautiful performance! Bravo
she isn't "straining" - she is diggin' it!
Simply beautiful - I have listened to the performance twice now and still find it quite sublime. Trio Sublime, don't change a thing - you are artists of the first order - stay distinctive and original - God bless you all always.
Bravo guys. I wish I was on that level while in university! This trio would find its place in some all time top 20 chamber music pieces list. Not that the other one is bad, but this one is perfect. Schubert really wrote chamber music masterpieces:Trout,Death an the Maiden, and the greatest -string quintet with 2 cellos. Love his music.
very happy after this beautifull interpretation, thank you !
Totally and completely enjoyed this , have played it several times and will continue to play it. Thank you wonderful dynamic musicians.
Some comments on the Barry Lyndon interpretation, which was so much slower. Apparently some people would like this to be replicated here.
I absolutely love the interpretation in the film Barry Lyndon. It is absolutely perfectly interpreted in that context.
BUT
This does not mean that the interpretation here cannot be equally good. There is no single truth in how to interpret a piece of music. It depends so much on the context and the mood of the moment, and the personality of the musicians. The musicians define what they want to give, and the art of listening is to open your heart so as to receive what is given. If you get stuck to one expectation, it must be a very dull life of listening, that life of yours!
Vivre la musique, pas simplement la "jouer"... Magnifique !
Their mannerism may not be exactly orthodox. But for me, their performance is really high quality. Her mannerism is not affecting her performance. It is a beautiful, passionate performance of a incredibly beautiful piece of music.
A mature work by Schubert containing a glistening development in the sonata allegro movement. The players give it a beautiful sheen. The cellist must be the daughter or grand daughter of Joel Krosnik, professor at Julliard and long a member of the eponymous string quartet. Somehow the piano part rings like fine crystal, as the piano in the Trout Quintet.
An impishly Mozart-ine work, especially after 32:24, when Schubert playfully makes the melody pretend to "stutter" by repeating each of its notes, its "consonants," an equal number of times! Enchanting. Also, nowadays it's reassuring to hear a 200-year old trio played by a trio of wholesome twenty-year olds! No tattoos! Herrlich!
Trio Cleonice é absolutamente magnífico!
I love love this piece of music.
TRIO CLEONICE, BRAVO!!!
I remember this memorable recital as if were today. Schubert sounds exciting within our soul longing for the Romantic music as he can only deliver.
BZ Niditch international surrealist poet and violinist.
Schon so oft gehört und gesehen, aber das hier ist wunderbar, voller Musizierlust und Inspiration. Großes Danke!
Splendid! This is the liveliest interpretation of the piece I've found on RUclips so far. Any minor inaccuracies are more than compensated by their superb expressiveness.
Beautiful music and beautiful interpretation. I'm adding this trio to my list of favorites. Gabe Meruelo.
Never heard the 2nd movement played at that tempo. Love it! Completely different, but appropriate character. Refreshing to hear!
Bravo! What a splendid performance of truly gorgeous music
By far this is the best version in my opinion. These incredibly talented musicians can look back many years from now and take delight in this wonderful performance. I'm posting this because I just purchased a 2-CD set which includes this work. Nope! - it's not as inspiring as Trio Cleonice.
Witzig für die Augen und sehr schön für die Ohren. Prima.
Amazing players! So beautifully conducted.
Bravo, trio Cleonice! Bravíssimo!
So wonderful to see passion in artists! Thanks for a great performance you three... you’ve added joy to my day!!!!
un Schubert d'évidence,admiration profonde
Excellent fiato among three of them. Good balance and tempo. Bravo!
Jordan hall's exquisite acoustics provides for us a place to feature your fine ensemble.
BZ Niditch ,poet and violinist.
Divino, como quase tudo de Franz Schubert!
Excelente!!! una perfecta interpretación de una obra maestra realmente maravilla!!!
Este Trio CLEONICE é demais! FENOMENAL!
wonderful trio!!
Trio Cleonice, sempre brilhante!
Zionini, Corrado comments on this but I'm not clear if you already know the theme you refer to was used by Stanley Kubrick in his film Barry Lyndon. Apart from the fact that it does recur within the trio. An excellent performance and interpretation. I will keep my eyes opened for Cleonice. I'm not a musician and don't play the piano but I don't think one has to be to realise this music is not lacking in challenges for a pianist. Even if it weren't I totally agree with Galahad.
Absolutely splendid performance!
one of my all-time faves..
Uma obra prima de Schubert!
cellist is over the top....chill
Brillante morceau. Merci pour votre upload.
Me encanta escuchar a Trio Cleonice.
If you listen to the great music w/o looking at the video,
it makes all the difference
Bravo! I have to tell you, I flipped through recording after recording of this Trio to try to find one which (to my taste) does justice to that grand shift to major (it isn't really a "modulation," is it, although we could call it that) toward the end of the 4th movement. Subjective, of course, but, to my taste :-) there's an awfully long list of "name" performers who didn't. Thank you to you guys for DOING it. One of the great moments of the entire music literature, too often glossed over as though not much of anything is going on there....
Relaxing music,guys,take a bow...!!!!
Eblouissant! Musicalité,compréhension sensibilité, tout y est!
Bravo,excellent playing by all three .
Gosto muito das obras do franz Schubert e eles fizeram uma linda performance explendido
Excellent performance of a great piece of music I hadn't listened to before. Thank you to the artists.
Shame RUclips spoiled it by inserting a mindless advert as the movement was ending. I hope the RUclips numpty that invented it get promoted out of harm's way soon and someone more sensible scraps this graffiti advertising approach soon. I'm happy to listen to adverts before and after just not when it damages other people's work.