AJR occupies an interesting place in music where they've achieved success despite being the direct antithesis of everything most critics deem to be objectively good.
@@cooperhawk988 I mean, their clusterfuck production and the privileged, pretentious and unlikeable persona doesn't exactly help. Granted they've been getting better since the days of yore, but they're still DEFINITELY divisive.
@@DeltaT45 It's not a situation, it's just how music works. I guarantee a big reason many music critics don't like ajr because they themselves don't have that success and are confused on why the band that should be objectively bad, just isn't
As an AJR fan, we do have problems with some songs and people are so rude and disgusting just to hate on a band? Everyone has different taste but they just say horrible things
As someone diagnosed with ADHD the chaotic nature of their music is super nice to listen to in the background and keeps my brain stimulated. Surprisingly it is the only thing that can make me focus and it’s super nice music. Thanks for a positive take!
They're my favorite band, and i never knew so many people despise them, i love their music, but i understand why people dislike their music. Ultimately, i wish people were less hateful about their music
SAME! Obviously, there are always haters with every band but I didn't realize they had a reputation as "the worst band." I refuse to believe that. They're the best band in my eyes. Anyone who thinks they're the worst hasn't listened to enough songs.
@unusualpotato42 Yeah, I will say, as I spend a lot of my time in AJR communities in apps like reddit and whatnot. we definitely, as fans, have a bad wrap, mostly for retaliating when someone says AJR is bad. That bring said, I understand why people don't like their music, but damn I never thought they were as hated lol, so same boat here lol
I agree. The hate they get seems too strong. It's fine if people dislike their music but some take it too far and completely despise the band as if their music is downright offensive.
@@beetlebat Ohohoho yeah, Tally Hall would be a fantastic band for you to investigate! Although I'm not sure they qualify as a controversial music act, I don't think I've ever heard anyone hate on them, come to think of it.
my ajr experience: heard the intro of "thirsty," thought i'd found the worst band ever, watched a live performance of the song to laugh, ended up not just laughing but enjoying how they seemed to be taking it lightly too. i respect these dudes for their unabashed silliness
I can’t even express in words how annoying this is. There are quite a few haters that hate the band for thirsty. It is not at all a representation of the band and it’s just a joke song they made when they were kids.
@@LiamhvetBecause being a teenager isn’t an excuse for making mediocre art? Compare what these guys made when they were in their teens with the lyrics and stuff Billie Eilish made when she was a teenager. No comparison in terms of maturity, tastefulness, or cringe level. Billie has them beat by miles and she’s like a decade younger than the oldest AJR I think. And this is coming from someone who’s not even a fan of either her or AJR…
I've only started listening to AJR for less than a year, through recommended songs on Spotify like Come Hang Out, but when That Maybe Man came out, it just got me in a way no other album has ever done. Inertia was just a song describing the feeling I've had since the pandemia ended and came back "to normal" and I had so much trouble explaining to people. The Maybe Man is just a compilation of the feelings of my early 20's. Right now I'm just hoping they came to Brazil with TMM, maybe in 2024 I'll have the chance to see them live, their shows just look amazing (been watching on RUclips some of then).
Agreed, Inertia is one of my favorites off of TMM. I feel like many people in their 20s relate to AJR. That seems to be the majority of the audience anyway. I personally am 21 and fell in love with their music back when OK O came out.
@@alemaof3492 Mano, o tanto que esses caras iam bombar aqui no Brasil caso eles aparecessem aqui no Brasil num Rock In Rio da vida fazendo um show na vibe dos que foram os de Neotheater ia ser incrível. Acho que esses garotos iriam também amar a vibe dos brasileiros de sempre cantar e aproveito ao máximo o show até os últimos segundos
As someone who was a fan of AJR as a teen when "Weak" came out, but grew out of it, this video is pretty nostalgic. Awesome trip through the band's history.
Honestly as a life long fan I grew out of their first 2 albums but this new one really brought me back. Being right around Jacks age, the songs have grown as I did in life.
@@charisma1322 I did a listening party with my friends when it came out. The lyricism and what they chose to sample just arent something I enjoy, but it's clear that they worked hard on the album. I've heard a lot of their fans loved it.
I am a die hard AJR fan for many reasons, so many reasons that I couldn’t list all of them. I don’t actually mind that a lot of people hate AJR, everybody loves their own kind of music! The thing that makes me sad is when people go out of their way to hate on them… To stoop so low as to tell someone else what they like is bad? Just let me get excited about my favorite band!! And they’re such good people, who write from the heart.
@@THE_funnyalt I Literally saw, I think it was brad but don’t quote me, someone start personally insulting jack and calling him a man child and going saying how much he hates their music. Completely unprompted. Like I don’t understand how that’s ok to do.
Well said! I absolutely _love_ AJR, and it’s totally fine if people don’t like their music, but it’s disheartening when people go out of their way to be mean and insulting about their dislike… Bright side is that pretty much all the AJR fans I’ve interacted with online have been super chill and it’s always fun getting excited with other fans
As one of the biggest AJR fans, I appreciate this video. It's so easy to go online and see hate towards them, and harder to find people who genuinely like their music. I enjoyed hearing your perspective and it was even cool to see Brad recommend this video, considering he despises AJR's music. I've personally been a fan since "100 Bad Days", although I had heard and enjoyed their music before. My current favorite song is off of "The Maybe Man" called "Steve's Going to London" because its a very carefree song that embraces the idea that music doesn't always have to be super meaningful.
Bro, how is it even possible to be "one of the biggest fans"? You would have to be 100% white in order to enjoy their music that much. In addition to that, you would have to have grown up only on Disney movies and basically have no connection to real culture at all. It's literally impossible to listen to that soy boy music as a normal person.
Personally, my current favorite is Maybe Man and DJ is crying for help, and i liked the Dj more after i saw that it was recorded and edited in just 2 days between there tour
I started out kind of a fan with their Neotheater songs, but when OK Orchestra Hit, I genuinely loved their music. Not because the songs bang, but they also convey positive messages to people overcoming obstacles based on mental trauma or being stuck in a hard place. I genuinely really hate that they are getting so much hate over their own style of music, they are a very talented group of people that will never stop to make me smile.
I can't lie; I loved "Weak" in the day. My girlfriend likes some AJR songs, so I asked if she wanted to see them (I love live music, and it can make or break an artist). She was skeptical, but she agreed. We went, and we had a blast (it was on June 9th at the Westville Music Bowl). The brothers are truly fantastic live performers who interact with the crowd and put a smile on everyone's faces.
I got into AJR in one of the most difficult times in my life, and though it sounds corny, their music helped me get through so many hard things and a lot of serious mental health issues. I can’t listen to a lot of their songs without crying because it takes me back to when I listened to their lyrics about being lonely, anxious, depressed, and just resonated so much with them.
IMO, what makes AJR so special to me and millions of other fans, is that the longer you've been a fan, the more invested you become. I've been a fan for 4-5 years now, and watching how their music perfectly showcases not only what they themselves are going through, but what many of their fans also go through, makes them feel more personable than any other band. Also, they've mentioned time and time again that they love performing on stage for their fans, which to me is proof that they just love to entertain and spread joy and form a deep connection with their fans. I mean hell, what other band plays dodgeball or gives lessons on making music to their VIP members for tours. It's just so unique and that's why I love them.
Agreed! I’ve only seen videos of their shows, but they look awesome- the way they introduce their songs like telling a story…definitely want to go to a concert one day! It’s clear their passionate about what they do- it’s a positive, emotional vibe and I love it
As someone who has been a fan of them since their very first album, I feel like I grew up with them. Their music speaks to me and gives me music with lyrics I can’t find anywhere else. Based on just how life is, no romanized or depressing songs, just stuff that is super relatable! Ngl I’ve had a few songs that I didn’t like or fit the image I have, but those guys are very real and genuine human beings. For someone who is just an everyday person, I’ve never related so hard to a band that has those record numbers. Also putting it out there, their shows are so good and they clearly try to blow you away every single time. :) I really liked the video btw, it was a great perspective!
As someone who is a massive fan of AJR, it’s not something I can describe. I love their music, but I also love them as people too. I feel like I have such a deep connection with them through the music, which is exactly what they’re going for. I know I’m not alone here, they just have something that once you hear them, you’ll get sucked in if you are the right person. The people who get it, get it. The rest of the people don’t. That’s something I love about them too. Like I said, I really don’t know how to put it into words.
cannot be hated by the world if you are a complete unknown band, if they are that hated it means their music was able to reach an incredible amount of people, and i love that.
Wow, you did your research!! Awesome video! As of fan of AJR since 2014, what first appealed to me was their personalities, they’re genuine and kind people, no matter how you feel about the music you can’t deny they’re nice guys ❤️ Some other nice things they’ve done for their fans is given them cocoa while waiting in line in the cold for a concert, Adam waited with fans while their cab came to make sure they got home safe in NY, they’ve given their fans gifts and free M&G, the list goes on! I love their music but I enjoy it 10x more knowing the people behind have a good heart.
As someone who loves and has been an AJR fan since Middle School (Now a sophomore in college) I can definitely see when people don't like al of their music. Amazing video covering the band overall. One thing I will say is if you can see them live, do it.
I am the same age and I started listening to AJR during COVID (my junior year), and Neotheater hit really hard my senior year when I was about to live at college, away from home for over half of the year
I didn’t realize that so many people hated on them, but they’re one of my favorites. Their mix of meaningful lyrics with catchy beats is what keeps me coming back. Also, as a theatre kid, I LOVE that they have an Overture on each album.
Im an AJR fan and its been so fun to see how their music style has changed over the years. TMM is their best one yet. I get how people don't like them, they do have an extremely unique style, but everyone has different tastes and their sound is so appealing to me. Good video man.
As a pretty big AJR fan, I loved this video. Perfectly captured people’s opinions on the band (whether it’s good or bad) in an unbiased way. Keep up the good work
I really have no idea why I like their music, the weird sounds and funky tunes just kind of scratches my brain idk. I love how you can never predict what they're going to do with a song, or what sounds they're gonna use. And I can relate to a lot of the themes of course, their new album came out at the perfect time and I'm currently going through a lot of the things they describe in that album. I do think their older albums have a lot of pretty bad songs (thirsty is an eternal stain on their discography), but I am a big fan of their newer albums, particularly OKO and TMM. I get why people don't like them, not everyone likes their style of music, but I kind of wish people would leave them alone a bit - like yeah, you don't like their music, obviously there's always going to be music you don't like, that's just how art in general is. There's no need to dedicate so much time and effort into expressing how much you hate them, just accept you don't like the music and move on, y'know? But to be honest hating on stuff can be kinda fun so I get it. Thanks for making an unbiased video like this, I'll show this to anybody if I need to introduce them to the band and why I like them. Keep it up :)
recently got really into ajr earlier in the year after listening to "Break My Face". i used to hate on them (i dont remember why) but now i love them so much and listen each day. love this perspective
AJR is my favorite band of all time, their beats are amazing but the lyrics truly hit you like a truck, I’ve been listening since The Click, and AJR has genuinely saved my life throughout the hardest times I’ve been going through.
great video, ajr is my fav band for many reasons. the relatable lyrics, catchy melodies, funny personality, down to earth, and even their album cover art. my fav song from this is finale, also SERIOUSLY the line "kinda wish i was still a virgin, dying to finally see what s*x is like" IS IT TRYING, DYING OR TIME I KEEP BEING TOLD DIFFERENT THINGS
I fell in love with OK Orchestra when Spotify recommended it to me during the pandemic. I watched the countdown for Maybe Man and listened as soon as it launched. They've become my favorite band and basically the only music I listen to. And I had no clue that people hated them until watching your video. I never even considered that some people would even dislike their music, let alone farm youtube view shouting vitriol for them. wild.
I was a big AJR fan in middle school. When I hit highschool, I really switched to my tally hall, lemon demon, will wood era. But I love AJR, and how it helped me through that time. Someone said “a real AJR fan doesn’t get mad when AJR get criticized, we sigh and listen to neotheater.” Which is so true. Neotheater is my favorite album from them, cause there messages are really relatable to me. Idk. I like the sensory overload :3 (I’m neurodivergent)
AJR is interesting; I'm not a huge fan of their music, but I honestly have a high level of respect for what they do. Great video and make Falling in Reverse next
The reason i resonate with AJR so much is how much i relate to the music. I have a sister named Winter, so whenever we hang out we always bring up “Dear Winter” and have a laugh. Also, about a month after they released “God is Really Real,” my father passed, and it was nice to have a song that i could relate to that strongly with. AJR is not for everyone, but it will always hold a special place in my heart no matter what. Also, thank you for doing actual research on them! A lot of people just write them off without looking at who they are! Thank you for the video
as someone who grew up as an ajr fan but has since grown out of their music, i can say that their music is very helpful for capturing how you feel (i believe their overly general and simple lyrics make this possible), and that their showmanship is truly next level. One thing no online critic has done is go to a show, but when you go to an ajr show it is so evident how much choreography goes into it. They frequently interact with the crowd with multiple (almost bits) segments to the point where you feel almost on stage.
A lot of people knock on AJR for having simplistic lyrics, but that's one of my favorite things about them. Often, internal thoughts aren't metaphors or similes but just direct language. It's really helpful sometimes to hear a beautiful instrumental paired with straightforward lyrics that speak to you. For example, hearing "I've gotta get better, I'm all that I've got" at the end of 2085, on my first listen of TMM, was just heavenly. I could feel the intention and I could relate to it.
I started listining to them in middle school, and now I'm a college sophomore and I'm still obsessed. I just love the way the do the instruments and the sounds. I also just like their personality and vibes, but really its just how happy their music makes me on a fundamental level.
As someone who is a massive AJR fan, their music just makes me happy. I never really listen to the lyrics of songs, I just listen to how it feels to me. AJR scratches the itch that no other band can consistantly scratch. I would always make self-depricating jokes about my liking of AJR because it was funny, but after I saw them live for the first time, I vowed to never justify my enjoyment of them again. Inertia and Maybe Man are definitely my favorite songs from them. They're the first songs that I've ever felt like I could actually relate to.
Gonna chip in from someone that's been closely following them and being heavily involved with their community since Neotheater released and would genuinely consider them my favorite band. When I was listening through Neotheater for the first time, I really didn't think of it too much until it got to their song Karma. Something about that song hit me as it had perfectly described what I had been going through at that time, but I had NO idea how to put it into words. I remember by the time the song finished, I had cried, something I hadn't done with a song in YEARS. From there I fell in love with the band. How honest they were in their music. How honest they were as people. They really helped me get through high school as I was 14 when Neotheater released so the general theme of the album regarding growing up really struck a nerve with me. Neotheater and their music in general has genuinely helped me get through some of the worst and hardest moments of my life so far and without them, I don't think I would have gotten through things. Neotheater honestly changed my life and I really wouldn't be who I am without it. It helped me fall in love with music and going to their Neotheater tour made me fall in love with live music as it was my first concert and I've gone to all of their tours since (as well seeing my other favorite artists live!). Being with them for over 4 years now, it feels like I've grown up with the band now as I'm in college (I'm gonna be 20 next year 🥲) and yet they're still able to release songs at the right times in my life when I need them the most, and they still hit as hard as ever. I was able to meet them last year during their OK Orchestra tour and I was able to pour my heart out to them really about how much they helped me. I knew they were nice already, but that day I really felt their love and appreciation towards their fans. They were so kind and patient with me about it all to where they upgraded me to pit for free just so I could get the button (which was the big finale of that tour where they picked an audience member to push a button). The button has a really big meaning behind it regarding mental health which I really recommend looking into for anyone who doesn't know, but it literally meant the entire world to me. They absolutely love their fans so much and that night further proved it to me. I do get why people don't like/care for them honestly. I really do and that's totally okay!! The issue I have is where people needlessly go out of their way to attack the artist and their fans over them not liking AJR. It goes for any artist really; I wish people could just simply ignore them and move on with their lives instead of wasting it on bashing something they don't even like. I wish people would treat each other nicer with music taste and opinions in general, but sadly what can you do. I do remember in an interview that they acknowledged this massive amount of hate that they get and Jack responds with a comment like "If we have a million haters but if we're able to help at least one person with it, that's all that matters" which speaks volumes about how much they care about their fans and how that's their main priority. This was a great video!! Really refreshing to see videos like this of AJR. All for having mature discussions about them!
I found out about AJR a few years ago from a friend, but really never listened to their music until Worlds Smallest Violin started trending on Tiktok. One thing lead to another and now hear I am, they're my favorite band. I obviously understand that their music is different and not for everyone, but I am always shocked at how much scathing hate they get for just- making music the way they want to. I don't think I've ever seen another artist get so attacked just for- making music? Their music has definitely helped me through some rough times and I can find myself relating to a lot of the lyrics.
I’m a pretty big fan of AJR, but I can’t say they don’t have their faults. Their lyrics are weird sometimes, they have songs that just don’t have a rhythm that sounds nice, but they definitely have improved which each album. They’ve grown and have just about perfected their craft. They aren’t for everyone, no music will ever be, ( other than maybe Kahoot music ) and I appreciate you not being one sided on liking or disliking, but being open minded to both sides.
Would you ever consider making a video for “The Appeal of Tones and I”? As an Australian, it’s been an….interesting journey watching her from being a beach-side busker, to getting nationwide airplay on Triple J, to having Dance Monkey becoming a worldwide hit, then finally getting that infamous 0 from Fantano. I personally don’t like her music but I feel like it would be a good topic to cover.
I met (pun intended?) AJR at a record signing for their latest album. The store gave priority entry to everyone who pre-ordered the album, which I did. I had put the CD and pre-order receipt in my coat pocket. When it was almost my turn, I took the case out and discovered the receipt's adhesive had stuck to the case, but it didn't tear off cleanly. I showed the guys and apologized, but they said I didn't need to apologize for that. Super nice guys. The other fans in line were nice too. The kid in front of me had a drawing he made of the band to show them. One of the songs playing on the loudspeaker was a song I learned they made for charity a few years ago about domestic violence. They're not bad people, but while they certainly have good ideas, I think the execution in their songs often leaves something to be desired. There's a lot of irony and cynicism in their lyrics, like in Birthday Party. I imagine that means the sugary, over-the-top production common in the band's music is meant to be ironic too. Or at least I hope so. I refuse to believe a song like Thirsty was meant to be taken seriously.
I'm a musician and a big AJR fan. Their music is unique and just perfectly chaotic enough to be interesting but not too much to just be a mess, their lyrics always hit all the spots (safe to say that I am definitely in their target demographic) and the fact that they produce all their music themselves is definitely a plus for me currently making and learning how to produce my own songs myself. However I have noticed that a lot of my other musician friends seem to have this hate for the band and I've never understood why. So this video was certainly informative and entartatining.
loved this video, as AJR fan sometimes it's hard for other people not understanding why you like the stuff you enjoy I made plenty of AJR videos on why I love them and most of the time people don't seem to like it but it's their messages on why they are a great band because some of the stuff they are saying you can picture yourself in those certain situation (or at least that is why i love them)
I only started getting into AJR because of my son but then some songs started to grow on me- now they seem to satisfy a tickle in my brain and I don’t know why I can’t stop smiling and moving when I hear them. Fave song is Bummerland. We went to their concert in April and I get it now. I understand what the draw is for those people that are their fans. It just hits different. It’s not music about big booties or WAP, or tragic breakups. It’s life. It’s what we go through and we’re on that journey together.
@@beetlebat I think that’s why I like it. It’s uncomplicated. I listen to a lot of styles of music and much is full of deep complicated meaning- but this is just kinda freeing.
My favourite band is AJR . Especially there latest album the maybe man . From what i have realised in my journey is that AJR is way way different than mainstream song writers it is what attracts people to them but also makes people stay away . Ajr fans are some of the nicest and most respectful fans you will find . There concerts are amazing and the songs so relatable. I have found myself communities of AJR fans which i am really happy to be i
I’ve been listening to AJR since 2019. The appeal for me is the insane relatability of most of their songs. The chaos of the instruments and sounds reflects the feeling of spiraling into something like not knowing who you are or when you’re gonna die. Neotheater and OK Orchestra helped me get through really tough times in my life. I’m also just a huge sucker for theatrical music!
AJR is my favorite band, and I think what made me a fan of them is not just their music but the genuinness of it and how down to earth there lyrics can be or how raw their feelings are in their music. It feels like it's truly them because it is truly them. They create the whole song themselves. I was originally introduced to them when I would watch RUclips short animations, then rediscovered them through TikTok from world's smallest violin and I've been a fan ever since.
I’ve loved this band since they started. As someone who has adhd and anxiety, the lyrics and the beats are what have kept me with them for this long, as well as everything they say in each song and album having a reason for being there, it’s just amazing how these guys make music
A lot of people would agree with you. I don’t have ADHD (i think) but there were several comments left by people on that spectrum who enjoy AJR for that person. Their chaotic nature sound appeals to their brain processing. It’s interesting
I found out about AJR because of World's Smallest Violin and my first impression was that they were fine but not memorable. I looked up their YT channel and listened to Dj is crying for help and it genuinely made me tear up. I have been battling depression and anxiety disorder for years now and I found it cathartic that a song could help me release emotions without me causing physical pain to myself. From that moment onwards I became a fan. Every time I have a panic attack or depressive episode, I just listen to their songs and they help me cope. I truly get why people don't like their music. It's niche and indie. But seeing the extent of hate their music gets really make me sad about the world. That music that make sad people happy are called bad and cringe because normal (neurotypical) people don't understand them. There are some AJR songs I dont like (Thirsty, The Trick, Call my Dad) and I acknowledge that they do make some unpleasant quirky sounds but I liked the chaos of it. It reminds me constantly that being different and unappealing is not the end of the world. Weird people exist and weird music can be popular but bullies/haters will always have the loudest voice because being hateful and negative is better than amicable neutrality. Like I know this is a weird tangent on the topic but to have it blatantly pointed out that the mental issues I wholeheartedly relate to in AJR's songs are just shallow/sheltered/cringe views of what real grief/sorrow/pain feels like, makes me realize that this world never really had a place for people who think differently from the norm.
I've listened to AJR for years and love almost every song because I'm a sucker for storytelling, especially through music. As someone who also loves to create and tell stories (through drawing, writing, or creating videos), AJR's music has always had a special spot in my head and the lyrics have definitely influenced my writing style in some way. The way they do music is just so different than the what most people around me listen to so I can always tell when one of their songs come on and put a smile on my face.
One thing I really admire about them is how they are maturing and growing, a clear result of which is The Maybe Man, which has more focused and easy-to-listen songs, without exaggeration and more mature lyrics, without a real example of children's lyrics on this album as on neotheater there's a lot of the click, I'm really excited to see their next releases (they make very good acoustics)
Im a fan of AJR but even more a fan of Owl City. I feel like Owl City falls into the same boat of disliked because of lyrics and production but has a lot of fans that love his musical style and relatability. I personally love how each song has so many layers and harmonies and synths that sound amazing (again, similar to AJR) Also its just one guy (Adam Young) that does all the production, writing and vocals which is really cool.
True, I can see that. Owl City has Fireflies a generational classic. So the general public adores him just for that. I’m sure the music critics aren’t too fond on his other stuff though
AJR’s work is like all the ideas that pop into my head that a bit cringe and far from perfect but mean something to me in some way, but they had the courage and passion to manifest them to completion. I have to give them respect for it.
AJR's a band I would occasionally listen to when I was younger - specifically when 'Infinity' and 'I'm Ready' got released, but since I wasn't seeing their music advertised much, I did start to forget about them. it was only back in 2019 after the release of '100 Bad Days' that I started listening to their music again. A lot of the reasons that I listen to them are featured in the video but the one at 16:51 is one of the main ones - '100 Bad Days' came out when I was struggling mentally and at the time (and even now) I find the message through the upbeat rhythm and lyrics comforting. 'Karma' and 'Don't Throw Out My Legos' are two other songs I found comforting and whose lyrics helped me understand how I was feeling and feel less alone. Their music isn't typical so I kind of understand why people don't like them, but I don't think they deserve a lot of the backlash they get. They're a very talented band who, to me, just experiment and create beats that sound amazing in a weird way. It's not a bad thing to create something or be a little different and AJR's obviously found their audience. They're not for everyone, but everything's subjective, from music to art to movies etc., and everyone's allowed to choose what they like and dislike. Also, their concert's are very fun :)
A friend kept playing their songs on discord when we played league with our friends back in the pandemic on late 2020. I totally fell in love with their music and felt listened. Been following since then. eternally grateful with my friend for that.
I love AJR so much, mostly because they actually feel like real people and make music like they really care about their fans. They aren’t like the artists that just abuse being able to write absolute nonsense or write songs about sleeping with a bunch of women with no respect for themselves, but instead write relatable songs that someone can think about once it’s over.
I gotta say I really appreciate this outsode view of AJR. I've recently made a couple of tiktoks about how I like their new album and some people went FERAL (like, telling me to end myself feral). I understand people really like them, and that some people really hate them. But I really admire your ability to pull groups together with your videos that are able to respectfully talk about it!!! You seem super cool dude and I'm excited to see more!
Honestly, as an AJR fan, I appreciate your honesty with the video. I think you do a good job of getting their appeal while also acknowledging their criticisms. What I appreciate most about AJR is that they are willing to take creative risks in their songs. Doing that makes you inherently polarizing, but as someone who enjoys the silliness of thirsty and other similarly goofy songs, that kind of buckwildness is what draws me to their music. I understand why musically and lyrically people aren't a fan of their music, but I can't lie and say the music doesn't appeal to me and I love listening to it. So I'm glad you have this video that helps articulate why I feel the way I feel about them. Also something you didn't mention, but their concerts are genuinely amazing, I haven't been to one of them yet, but from what I've seen a footage they go out of their way to put on an incredible show and I got to respect him for that. Like I said, great video.
They have so many sounds in most of their songs that you can listen to it over and over again because you find a new sound every time. The other type of their songs is the more emotional songs which has beautiful instrumentals. Greatest band!
Massive AJR fan here!! Great video, loved the different perspectives it gave! My favourite AJR song is currently 2085, the message that life never gets less complicated and to just do it instead of wasting time thinking about it hits right at home. Also, as an aroace person, the Turning Out trilogy, and their themes of growing up, etc. being just as common than themes of love is really refreshing!
I could talk for hours on why I like AJR. I can’t say I’m the number one AJR fan or that I like every one of their songs but Damnit, I’ve listened to them for like 3 weeks straight at this point and I think my family hates me for it. Their older songs, like pre click, I genuinely cannot listen to, but hey, improvement happens and they’re getting better every year! Second reason I like them so much, I’m a theatre kid with too much childhood trauma. I don’t wanna go too deep into it but like. Damn My Play and the general theatre and childish vibes hits close to home. Third, I’ve found myself in the most. AJR situation imaginable. I’m going to college this year, and potentially moving out and making life changing decisions while my parents are in the other room arguing about their divorce. So, AJR has definitely helped me out mentally so much. Fourth reason: I’m autistic and it effects how I listen to music. Not every autistic person is like me, but my autism has definitely effected my music taste. (This can be seen through how most music artists I follow have a somewhat large autistic fan base as well. It’s also how I learned I was autistic.) I find the sounds of AJR to be stimulating but not overstimulating. Actually even helping in some situations where I would normally get overstimmed. 5th reason: (I am not being consistent with how I list these. Fight me) im autistic but this time it effects it in a different way. I’m often hyperfixated on things, and one thing I’ve always been hyperfixated on is my own OCs or original characters. AJR’s music reflects their story in such a way I find unique so it’s always fun to imagine little animations in my head to them. 6th: AJR is somehow always there when I need them. Like fuck dude. What do you mean you made a song about relating the concept of inertia to daily life and not being able to move on/being stuck in the past the day after I cry about being stuck in the past and also learn the concept of inertia in my physics class? It’s always so specifically on the nose for me it’s slightly terrifying in a way but you know what. We ball.
I'm SO happy to see someone who appreciates Livin' on Love, as a big AJR fan I really love that song!! It's one of my favorites and I wish more people knew it existed.
"How long is this song?" "Bout two and a half minutes" "And how long did it take to make?" "bout two and a half years" I'm in my 30s, I gotta be real AJR being so open about their creative process has been very validating. I write all kinds of things, music included, but part of me always felt like if I couldn't write it out all in one go, it wasn't really properly writing something true. But after seeing these guys live... they've just put so much hard work into creating. It makes you wanna put something out there too, you know?
Thank you, it’s nice to have more positivity and fairness for them out on the internet! People can dislike them or not vibe with them, but the sheer amount of dogpiling and mocking and over-critical nonsense people lay on thick on these guys is insane.. I’ve literally seen a video where the reviewer criticised the song they wrote for their dying dad harshly for “lyrics that don’t make sense” when they make perfect sense.. There’s no band quite like these lovely brothers, and they’re my favourite band ever. It’s so fun to listen to their old stuff and hear them find their sound over time, let alone the incredible work they”re making now!
@@beetlebat I think you actually included a clip of the guy’s video in yours while talking about the harsh critics. I haven’t seen much of his stuff/can’t remember his name/channel, but he seems to have a reputation with his fans for despising AJR and reviewing them regardless despite already having decided that he hates it.. like, who pauses a song less than a minute in on the first listen to complain about something as silly as not thinking “gods really real, til he’s not” makes sense? (No hate on the reviewer, but if he’s Christian then I can see why that line ruffled feathers, but that doesn’t mean it’s bad, ya know?)
Some reasons I personally love AJR are all the weird noises and high-pitched vocals! It adds character and makes their music unique. One of my favorite songs of theirs is "Joe", and that has a shit ton of funky sounds! Although the sounds in "Inertia" and "2085" at the beginning are probably my favorites. They both had me hooked instantly, which is another thing AJR is good at. I especially love it when they use a bunch of different instruments. It really stands out in their album "OK Orchestra", where they use trumpets, violins, keyboards, guitars, and the list goes on! And they know how to make them all work together perfectly. The Maybe Man truly made me appreciate their lyrics. It genuinely does show how honest they are in their feelings, as you mentioned. Some of their lyrics are just silly or cheesy, like in "Steve's Going to London", and others are sad or deep, like in "God is Really Real" and "Weak". They have made me really appreciate the lyrics in songs more than the sound itself. Some of my favorite lyrics are from the song "Maybe Man". I can relate to them, and it gets me thinking about so much more than just the music and sound. I don't think they deserve this kind of hate and no one really does! It all just depends on your type of music, so I get why people don't like them. (Oops I ranted. Sorry for that I just love AJR so fucking much lmaoo)
I’ve been a fan of AJR since 100 Bad Days came out and have been following the band as they have been growing for some time. I had no idea that they were so hated until this year. It breaks my heart that so many people go out of their way to hate something just because somebody else enjoys it. Especially because AJR has personally helped me through quite a bit through so much of their personalized lyrics. They have a lot of songs that can be very raw and open about mental health that can really speak to people who struggle with it. Like Karma, Inertia, the Turning Out Series- Drama helped me when I was struggling to get away from a very bad friend group. They have a way of coming across with very emotional and heavier lyrics that are widespread levels of relatable despite having an upbeat presentation.
As someone with sensory overload, this band is amazing. AJR's music just hits that part of me that loves sounds like this, without overwhelming me- Plus they just feel so genuine. They don't hold back, they say exactly what they feel, and it's nice. Refreshing, kinda.
@@beetlebat Oh, it's not for me either lmao. I get intense mental breakdowns- AJR songs just don't trigger that, but they have a bunch of cool composition and stuff in the background that I really like.
My college roommate would play AJR *constantly.* As a result, I have a certain loathing of overplay, but also I have a big fondness for particular songs that I did end up having grow on me.
i think i feel the same way about AJR as i do about similarly hated pop artists by people like me; i had to listen to some of their biggest hits ad nauseum in high school as my art teacher would play millennial pop stuff 24/7 and while i never actively enjoyed their stuff, i can't say i ever really grew sick of it despite how often i'd hear them. i remember seeing the cover art for the click during class and thinking it looked cute and looked up the album's reception out of curiosity and was a bit surprised to see that people hate their stuff. even now i still feel indifferent towards them, and i think because of that disconnect and the association of their music with some of my best experiences in high school (those being all of my art classes), i kind of secretly hope they'll come through some day with something genuinely good
I just got into AJR and I really love their music. Sure it sounds weird but I like that! It makes them unique! Their performances are always lovely and enjoyable! They were my first concert this past June. And I love the messages like in inertia and way less sad! They’ve really helped me 🩵
I am extremely proud to say that I’m a die hard AJR fan. I think their music is incredible and relatable and have personally changed my life. Their songs made me cry, smile and laugh but regardless make me happy. I think they’re great and make such powerful messages through unique and inspirational music. I do understand why people my not like them, as you need to understand and relate to songs to love them. I’m always and forever proud of them ❤
Bradford sent me. This video is fantastic at explaining why people like some of this goofy band’s music as much as they do lol. Excellent video as always 😉
Beetlebat, thank you for making this very high-quality video I love how you took the time to heart every single person’s comment and comment on almost every single persons comment as well. I admire how involved you are with your fans and I respect that a lot. So I just wanna say good job, I’m proud of you.
This means so much man damn.. I try to get involved with everyone that comments here. I love what I do here on RUclips and I’m blessed with what I’ve created. You’re awesome
AJR is my favorite band, and it genuinely makes me really sad when people bash them for absolutely no reason. Once I saw someone call their music "soulless, corporate slop", which doesn't even make any sense. Haters aside, I love that they're not afraid to talk about things other than love, breakups, etc. They're unique, and they wholeheartedly embrace that. Some of my favorite songs by them are "Wow, I'm Not Crazy", "Inertia", and "Way Less Sad" :)
Ok I really appreciate this video. I got into AJR back when I was a freshman in high school, and their song "Come hang out" immediately clicked with me. I'll always remember the first time I listened to it, I was blown away by how it sounded and what the song was about. I was missing out hanging out with friends and was feeling really left out, and although the song's message is a bit different (they chose to not hang out with friends but it wasn't a choice for me) it still really comforted me. I honestly really enjoyed the way the albums were concept albums. I never really heard that before, so I was blown away by the stories and connections in the songs, especially in neotheater. The turning out songs always hit me on an extremely personal level, those songs are very special to me (although I have only listened to part 1 and 2 as of typing this). I really only listened to the click and neotheater, and started to wane off of them when I got obsessed with other artists and they started to get more hate. That's why I appreciate this video so much, it's completely unbiased and emphasizes how the songs are meaningful to the listener. You really just have to be the target audience, or the young naïve high schooler, to like/get into their music sometimes. The people who hate their music just aren't the target audience. Their music is definitely a bit corny and sometimes a bit cringey when I come back to them as an adult now, but maybe I'll have to give their new album a try since it's been mentioned that it's more mature. So yeah, thank you for this video. I think I'll always have a strange little soft spot for AJR in my heart.
I don’t like AJR, but I have to admit they know how to make a song move you. Not in any deep lyrics or strong melodies, but they know how to make music with a really strong sense of momentum. Each bar leads into each other and builds up in a satisfying way. I dislike most of their songs most of the time, but I’ll admit some of the music has given me chills. I can totally see why people like them.
Coming from the opposite side as a fan, but I really love this point! The endings to 2085 and Ok Overture come to mind. Those huge build ups never fail to give me chills.
i find it hard to believe this guy has only 4k subs. this is very in-depth video and actually one of the best things i've seen on youtube in recent weeks
Ajr is just such a fun loving group, yet they're simultaneously able to tackle some of the deeper, more pressing issues they and their fans face. I wouldn't consider myself a die-hard fan, and yet they're one of the few artists I listen to where I'll literally save the entirity of each new album they produce (rather than just picking and choosing songs here and there). I also have to give them props for the energy they bring to live venues, I don't know how anyone can dance and jump around that much for hours on end, especially while belting a high tenor chorus. Watching them in concert was a joy I hope to get to experience again.
I'm a very big AJR fan. Because of them I started listening to music a year ago. I could write a novel about why I love them and there music so much but I'm here to say that this was an amazing video. It's fantastic to see you from a neutral perspective. You share your thoughts and clearly express your positive and negative aspects of the band. I love this Video. Thank you for you're Work :)
Great video, couldn't have said it better myself! Perhaps in future videos, you could keep the volume on a similar level? I had to keep fiddling with the volume whenever you hopped between song and talking.
I've been a big fan of theirs for a few years, thanks to one of my friends. I just recently went to one of their TMM tour concerts and it was absolutely breathtaking, genuinely the best performance I've ever seen presentation-wise. People are certainly allowed to have differing opinions on them, that's totally understandable; what really gets me are the people saying "well, I don't like them so neither can you" or "they're rated so poorly, how could you possibly enjoy it?" Literally one time in college, I told some friends that I liked their music and their reactions were just absolutely disgusted and I just don't see the need for that. Everyone's going to disagree on music taste to some degree, but it's so much easier to just let people enjoy whatever they want. As long as they're not harming anyone/thing, why not?
I started listening to AJR last year thanks to my teenage son. Recently being diagnosed with AuADHD, AJR's music has helped him/us feel less different and even accept our "quirkiness". He has found new friends because of AJR's music. I remember watching how that very small group of friends got to dance to The Dumb Song at Prom last year... the only song that made them feel seen. I listened to the lyrics for the first time and felt so proud of them at that moment. AJR's music has a special effect on neurodivergent people. I now listen to them while working. It lifts my spirit somehow with their sad/relatable lyrics and upbeat sound. We are for sure going to their concert this summer and can't wait to share the experience with him.
i only became a fan of their music a little while ago and when i looked them up online i was genuinely baffled how much vitriol about them there is. i still am. when i hear a song i don't like i just stop listening to it and move on with my day. you're telling me people take precious time out of their day to rant about how they hate one specific band? wouldn't they be much happier ignoring ajr and just listening to the songs they like?
AJR fans and certainly AJR themselves know that their music isn't for everyone (to put it lightly), but, as a long-time fan of theirs, I think that's kind of the point. If they make music that they really like, they have every reason to share it. And as long as they have even just a few people who also like it, they'll keep making their brand of music. This is a perfect, unbiased review of AJR. Thank you for this video!
I've ben a fan of AJR since first hearing Bang!, but out of everything I love about AJR, my favorite thing has got to be their relatable lyrics. Sober Up, 2085, the Maybe Man, Netflix Trip, The DJ is Crying for Help, and the ending of Ok Overture are my favorite examples of this. With Sober Up being a top contender for my favorite song ever. I usually just see album reactions to AJR so this video is a welcome addition to my feed. I loved the deep dive and your explanations for everything. I hope to see more of you in the future!
Casual ajr enjoyer here! I love the effort they put into their music, and the realness of their lyrics. Recently I saw a video of a girl freaking out meeting them, saying that they saved her life and said everything that she couldn't find the words for. As someone who could say the same about twenty one pilots, I was heartbroken to find every single comment hating on the girl and/or ajr. Some were death threats. I can't say I'm their biggest fan. Some of their songs, I can't stand. But it's not like the band is made of bad people, and the girl definitely didn't deserve that hate. So I'm glad to find fellow ajr appreciators. As weird as it seems, it restores my faith in humanity.
i wasn’t ever a huge ajr fan, but i listened to living room when it first came out and pitchfork kids was my the track that i loved the most, even joining my rotation when i shifted my music taste to heavier sounds. hearing it again in this video reminded me that even if I’m not a fan of their newer stuff that track still goes pretty hard!
I used to be a massive AJR fan! I have autism, so sometimes the “sensory overload” would honestly be great for grounding me- sounds backwards but that’s just how it is lol. I like how honest and childish they are- I’m 23 and I can relate a lot to their struggles of being in that weird stage of growing up. I don’t like them as much anymore, but I think my favorite songs would have to be Turning Out part 1 & 2 (I haven’t listened to the new album). I really appreciate you being honest without bashing the people who genuinely enjoy their stuff. It’s not for everyone- it isn’t even for most people- but it means a lot to some who do enjoy it.
AJR occupies an interesting place in music where they've achieved success despite being the direct antithesis of everything most critics deem to be objectively good.
It’s an accomplishment for sure
Part of why music critics hate them so much is because they remind them that there is not such thing as objective when it comes to music
@@cooperhawk988wait, does that mean it’s basically a “popular opinion” situation?
@@cooperhawk988 I mean, their clusterfuck production and the privileged, pretentious and unlikeable persona doesn't exactly help. Granted they've been getting better since the days of yore, but they're still DEFINITELY divisive.
@@DeltaT45 It's not a situation, it's just how music works. I guarantee a big reason many music critics don't like ajr because they themselves don't have that success and are confused on why the band that should be objectively bad, just isn't
I’m not an AJR fan myself, but the fact that some people will genuinely hate you for your inconsequential opinion on a band is actually mind-boggling.
It’s just how the world is sadly
As an AJR fan, we do have problems with some songs and people are so rude and disgusting just to hate on a band? Everyone has different taste but they just say horrible things
I dont genuinely hate people for liking AJR but they are definitely NEVER getting the AUX in my car
@@ruok6506that's fair
Yeah most of my friends just have an irrational fear of AJR for no apparent reason
As someone diagnosed with ADHD the chaotic nature of their music is super nice to listen to in the background and keeps my brain stimulated. Surprisingly it is the only thing that can make me focus and it’s super nice music. Thanks for a positive take!
Thanks for the positive comment!
As someone who also has adhd, their ‘burnt out gifted kid’ energy songs just hit really hard for me
@@table2.0 oh yeah that's totally me
I'm neurodivergent and ditto
*autocorrect broke it, I meant same
They're my favorite band, and i never knew so many people despise them, i love their music, but i understand why people dislike their music. Ultimately, i wish people were less hateful about their music
Agree, people go WAY TOO HARD on em
SAME! Obviously, there are always haters with every band but I didn't realize they had a reputation as "the worst band." I refuse to believe that. They're the best band in my eyes. Anyone who thinks they're the worst hasn't listened to enough songs.
@unusualpotato42 Yeah, I will say, as I spend a lot of my time in AJR communities in apps like reddit and whatnot. we definitely, as fans, have a bad wrap, mostly for retaliating when someone says AJR is bad.
That bring said, I understand why people don't like their music, but damn I never thought they were as hated lol, so same boat here lol
Same, when he said they are hated, I was like "whaaaat!?!"
I agree. The hate they get seems too strong. It's fine if people dislike their music but some take it too far and completely despise the band as if their music is downright offensive.
As someone who grew up as a theater kid and was obsessed with Tally Hall, AJR is like the perfect band for me lol
I’ve heard a lot about them, might need to see what the hype is about
@@beetlebat Ohohoho yeah, Tally Hall would be a fantastic band for you to investigate! Although I'm not sure they qualify as a controversial music act, I don't think I've ever heard anyone hate on them, come to think of it.
@@AwkwardCat23 haha hell yeah, this one gets me
@@AwkwardCat23 Same here! Definitely some type of pattern.
@@cineblazerjoe hawley had some controversy around him, tho pretty sure it wasn’t all true
my ajr experience: heard the intro of "thirsty," thought i'd found the worst band ever, watched a live performance of the song to laugh, ended up not just laughing but enjoying how they seemed to be taking it lightly too. i respect these dudes for their unabashed silliness
Why do people judge a band for a song they made many years ago? They were teens.
I can’t even express in words how annoying this is. There are quite a few haters that hate the band for thirsty. It is not at all a representation of the band and it’s just a joke song they made when they were kids.
@@Cashcorn ...you're annoyed that i was able to grow to appreciate the song? i do not understand lol
@@Liamhvet this is a comment about me realizing i misjudged the song please click read more lmao
@@LiamhvetBecause being a teenager isn’t an excuse for making mediocre art? Compare what these guys made when they were in their teens with the lyrics and stuff Billie Eilish made when she was a teenager. No comparison in terms of maturity, tastefulness, or cringe level. Billie has them beat by miles and she’s like a decade younger than the oldest AJR I think. And this is coming from someone who’s not even a fan of either her or AJR…
I've only started listening to AJR for less than a year, through recommended songs on Spotify like Come Hang Out, but when That Maybe Man came out, it just got me in a way no other album has ever done. Inertia was just a song describing the feeling I've had since the pandemia ended and came back "to normal" and I had so much trouble explaining to people. The Maybe Man is just a compilation of the feelings of my early 20's. Right now I'm just hoping they came to Brazil with TMM, maybe in 2024 I'll have the chance to see them live, their shows just look amazing (been watching on RUclips some of then).
The Maybe Man is an important record for a lot of people
Agreed, Inertia is one of my favorites off of TMM. I feel like many people in their 20s relate to AJR. That seems to be the majority of the audience anyway. I personally am 21 and fell in love with their music back when OK O came out.
Se eles viessem pro Brasil, eu ia pirar de alegria kkkkkkkkk
Eu já me enganei q tem chance deles virem pro Rock in Rio, já tô perdido na esperança kkkk @@alemaof3492
@@alemaof3492 Mano, o tanto que esses caras iam bombar aqui no Brasil caso eles aparecessem aqui no Brasil num Rock In Rio da vida fazendo um show na vibe dos que foram os de Neotheater ia ser incrível. Acho que esses garotos iriam também amar a vibe dos brasileiros de sempre cantar e aproveito ao máximo o show até os últimos segundos
As someone who was a fan of AJR as a teen when "Weak" came out, but grew out of it, this video is pretty nostalgic. Awesome trip through the band's history.
I love Weak, kinda nostalgic to me too. Appreciate the watch
Honestly as a life long fan I grew out of their first 2 albums but this new one really brought me back. Being right around Jacks age, the songs have grown as I did in life.
Maybe try the new album? They’ve grown so much since weak and you might love it :)
@@charisma1322 I did a listening party with my friends when it came out. The lyricism and what they chose to sample just arent something I enjoy, but it's clear that they worked hard on the album. I've heard a lot of their fans loved it.
I am a die hard AJR fan for many reasons, so many reasons that I couldn’t list all of them. I don’t actually mind that a lot of people hate AJR, everybody loves their own kind of music! The thing that makes me sad is when people go out of their way to hate on them… To stoop so low as to tell someone else what they like is bad? Just let me get excited about my favorite band!! And they’re such good people, who write from the heart.
It’s sad, I don’t like when people hate just to hate
bradtasteinmusic reading this comment:
@@THE_funnyalt I Literally saw, I think it was brad but don’t quote me, someone start personally insulting jack and calling him a man child and going saying how much he hates their music. Completely unprompted. Like I don’t understand how that’s ok to do.
Well said! I absolutely _love_ AJR, and it’s totally fine if people don’t like their music, but it’s disheartening when people go out of their way to be mean and insulting about their dislike…
Bright side is that pretty much all the AJR fans I’ve interacted with online have been super chill and it’s always fun getting excited with other fans
As one of the biggest AJR fans, I appreciate this video. It's so easy to go online and see hate towards them, and harder to find people who genuinely like their music. I enjoyed hearing your perspective and it was even cool to see Brad recommend this video, considering he despises AJR's music. I've personally been a fan since "100 Bad Days", although I had heard and enjoyed their music before. My current favorite song is off of "The Maybe Man" called "Steve's Going to London" because its a very carefree song that embraces the idea that music doesn't always have to be super meaningful.
That song is pretty carefree I agree, good note
Bro, how is it even possible to be "one of the biggest fans"? You would have to be 100% white in order to enjoy their music that much. In addition to that, you would have to have grown up only on Disney movies and basically have no connection to real culture at all. It's literally impossible to listen to that soy boy music as a normal person.
Steve's going to london is also one of my favourite songs
Same i love this song 😂
Personally, my current favorite is Maybe Man and DJ is crying for help, and i liked the Dj more after i saw that it was recorded and edited in just 2 days between there tour
AJR is known for being very unique and stuff, and my old friend would make fun of me for liking them calling them “unoriginal” 😭
They aren’t unoriginal haha
They're super original what's your old friend on 💀
I started out kind of a fan with their Neotheater songs, but when OK Orchestra Hit, I genuinely loved their music. Not because the songs bang, but they also convey positive messages to people overcoming obstacles based on mental trauma or being stuck in a hard place. I genuinely really hate that they are getting so much hate over their own style of music, they are a very talented group of people that will never stop to make me smile.
They are very based
I can't lie; I loved "Weak" in the day. My girlfriend likes some AJR songs, so I asked if she wanted to see them (I love live music, and it can make or break an artist). She was skeptical, but she agreed. We went, and we had a blast (it was on June 9th at the Westville Music Bowl). The brothers are truly fantastic live performers who interact with the crowd and put a smile on everyone's faces.
I LOVE WEAK, but that is so cute bro
Here from Brad. Absolute banger of a video. Keep it up man 👍
Will do man! Brad a homie
I got into AJR in one of the most difficult times in my life, and though it sounds corny, their music helped me get through so many hard things and a lot of serious mental health issues. I can’t listen to a lot of their songs without crying because it takes me back to when I listened to their lyrics about being lonely, anxious, depressed, and just resonated so much with them.
Well i’m just glad they helped you so much either way
As a person who definitely doesn't like ajr, I appreciate seeing someone else's perspective. Great video
I tried to fill in that perspective the best I could!
it’s not a good perspective. they’re truly being given too much credit. AJR is the one of only “bands” that should be criticized like they are
@@ghijbvhiigvh3940:/ you’re exactly the type of person who’s behavior this video discourages.
@@ghijbvhiigvh3940explain why as most people who say this never truly explain their criticisms against ajr
@@ghijbvhiigvh3940bro they just make songs if you dont like them dont listen to them
IMO, what makes AJR so special to me and millions of other fans, is that the longer you've been a fan, the more invested you become. I've been a fan for 4-5 years now, and watching how their music perfectly showcases not only what they themselves are going through, but what many of their fans also go through, makes them feel more personable than any other band. Also, they've mentioned time and time again that they love performing on stage for their fans, which to me is proof that they just love to entertain and spread joy and form a deep connection with their fans. I mean hell, what other band plays dodgeball or gives lessons on making music to their VIP members for tours. It's just so unique and that's why I love them.
A show sounds mad fun you know
I’m so hyped to go to one of their concerts next summer!
Agreed! I’ve only seen videos of their shows, but they look awesome- the way they introduce their songs like telling a story…definitely want to go to a concert one day! It’s clear their passionate about what they do- it’s a positive, emotional vibe and I love it
As someone who has been a fan of them since their very first album, I feel like I grew up with them. Their music speaks to me and gives me music with lyrics I can’t find anywhere else. Based on just how life is, no romanized or depressing songs, just stuff that is super relatable!
Ngl I’ve had a few songs that I didn’t like or fit the image I have, but those guys are very real and genuine human beings. For someone who is just an everyday person, I’ve never related so hard to a band that has those record numbers.
Also putting it out there, their shows are so good and they clearly try to blow you away every single time. :)
I really liked the video btw, it was a great perspective!
They’re relatable, down to earth people
As someone who is a massive fan of AJR, it’s not something I can describe. I love their music, but I also love them as people too. I feel like I have such a deep connection with them through the music, which is exactly what they’re going for. I know I’m not alone here, they just have something that once you hear them, you’ll get sucked in if you are the right person. The people who get it, get it. The rest of the people don’t. That’s something I love about them too. Like I said, I really don’t know how to put it into words.
I feel ya
cannot be hated by the world if you are a complete unknown band, if they are that hated it means their music was able to reach an incredible amount of people, and i love that.
That is true!
Wow, you did your research!! Awesome video!
As of fan of AJR since 2014, what first appealed to me was their personalities, they’re genuine and kind people, no matter how you feel about the music you can’t deny they’re nice guys ❤️
Some other nice things they’ve done for their fans is given them cocoa while waiting in line in the cold for a concert, Adam waited with fans while their cab came to make sure they got home safe in NY, they’ve given their fans gifts and free M&G, the list goes on!
I love their music but I enjoy it 10x more knowing the people behind have a good heart.
Aww that cocoa thing is so nice! Ajr are good guys for sure
OMG HEY YOU! :D
@@Hedgey2025hello!! I saw your comment featured in the video, pretty cool! ^_^
Wish I was there to talk
@@FanofAJR Yeah!
As someone who loves and has been an AJR fan since Middle School (Now a sophomore in college) I can definitely see when people don't like al of their music. Amazing video covering the band overall. One thing I will say is if you can see them live, do it.
These comments are gonna convince me to see them live
I am the same age and I started listening to AJR during COVID (my junior year), and Neotheater hit really hard my senior year when I was about to live at college, away from home for over half of the year
@@beetlebattheir live shows are like nothing else it's amazing
Their live show is actually pretty wack
omg i have the same tiing, i got obsessed in middle school with the click, and now Im a sophmore
They articulate feelings on top of feel good music.
I often refer to them as "Existential Crisis" The Band
That's the appeal
“EXISTENCE CRISIS” haha
I didn’t realize that so many people hated on them, but they’re one of my favorites. Their mix of meaningful lyrics with catchy beats is what keeps me coming back.
Also, as a theatre kid, I LOVE that they have an Overture on each album.
I bet so haha
Im an AJR fan and its been so fun to see how their music style has changed over the years. TMM is their best one yet. I get how people don't like them, they do have an extremely unique style, but everyone has different tastes and their sound is so appealing to me. Good video man.
Living Room to The Maybe Man is quite the evolution
As a pretty big AJR fan, I loved this video. Perfectly captured people’s opinions on the band (whether it’s good or bad) in an unbiased way. Keep up the good work
Gotta keep it neutral
I really have no idea why I like their music, the weird sounds and funky tunes just kind of scratches my brain idk. I love how you can never predict what they're going to do with a song, or what sounds they're gonna use. And I can relate to a lot of the themes of course, their new album came out at the perfect time and I'm currently going through a lot of the things they describe in that album. I do think their older albums have a lot of pretty bad songs (thirsty is an eternal stain on their discography), but I am a big fan of their newer albums, particularly OKO and TMM. I get why people don't like them, not everyone likes their style of music, but I kind of wish people would leave them alone a bit - like yeah, you don't like their music, obviously there's always going to be music you don't like, that's just how art in general is. There's no need to dedicate so much time and effort into expressing how much you hate them, just accept you don't like the music and move on, y'know? But to be honest hating on stuff can be kinda fun so I get it.
Thanks for making an unbiased video like this, I'll show this to anybody if I need to introduce them to the band and why I like them. Keep it up :)
They are certainly unpredictable lol
recently got really into ajr earlier in the year after listening to "Break My Face". i used to hate on them (i dont remember why) but now i love them so much and listen each day. love this perspective
That’s how I was with Bailey Zimmerman. I didn’t like some of his stuff but now he’s favorite country act
AJR is my favorite band of all time, their beats are amazing but the lyrics truly hit you like a truck, I’ve been listening since The Click, and AJR has genuinely saved my life throughout the hardest times I’ve been going through.
I’m glad you’re still here with us bro
great video, ajr is my fav band for many reasons. the relatable lyrics, catchy melodies, funny personality, down to earth, and even their album cover art. my fav song from this is finale, also SERIOUSLY the line "kinda wish i was still a virgin, dying to finally see what s*x is like" IS IT TRYING, DYING OR TIME I KEEP BEING TOLD DIFFERENT THINGS
@@MikeTheMaster102 Dying lol
I fell in love with OK Orchestra when Spotify recommended it to me during the pandemic. I watched the countdown for Maybe Man and listened as soon as it launched. They've become my favorite band and basically the only music I listen to. And I had no clue that people hated them until watching your video. I never even considered that some people would even dislike their music, let alone farm youtube view shouting vitriol for them. wild.
It’s a toxic world ain’t it
I was a big AJR fan in middle school. When I hit highschool, I really switched to my tally hall, lemon demon, will wood era. But I love AJR, and how it helped me through that time. Someone said “a real AJR fan doesn’t get mad when AJR get criticized, we sigh and listen to neotheater.” Which is so true. Neotheater is my favorite album from them, cause there messages are really relatable to me. Idk. I like the sensory overload :3 (I’m neurodivergent)
Never heard that quote before
AJR is interesting; I'm not a huge fan of their music, but I honestly have a high level of respect for what they do. Great video and make Falling in Reverse next
Falling In Reverse will happen at one point trust me
The reason i resonate with AJR so much is how much i relate to the music. I have a sister named Winter, so whenever we hang out we always bring up “Dear Winter” and have a laugh. Also, about a month after they released “God is Really Real,” my father passed, and it was nice to have a song that i could relate to that strongly with. AJR is not for everyone, but it will always hold a special place in my heart no matter what. Also, thank you for doing actual research on them! A lot of people just write them off without looking at who they are! Thank you for the video
Aww that’s sweet. “Dear Winter”
as someone who grew up as an ajr fan but has since grown out of their music, i can say that their music is very helpful for capturing how you feel (i believe their overly general and simple lyrics make this possible), and that their showmanship is truly next level. One thing no online critic has done is go to a show, but when you go to an ajr show it is so evident how much choreography goes into it. They frequently interact with the crowd with multiple (almost bits) segments to the point where you feel almost on stage.
Their shows seem like a blast
A lot of people knock on AJR for having simplistic lyrics, but that's one of my favorite things about them. Often, internal thoughts aren't metaphors or similes but just direct language. It's really helpful sometimes to hear a beautiful instrumental paired with straightforward lyrics that speak to you.
For example, hearing "I've gotta get better, I'm all that I've got" at the end of 2085, on my first listen of TMM, was just heavenly. I could feel the intention and I could relate to it.
And you will get better
@@beetlebat thanks, dude. this video is amazing and your channel is definitely destined for more.
I started listining to them in middle school, and now I'm a college sophomore and I'm still obsessed. I just love the way the do the instruments and the sounds. I also just like their personality and vibes, but really its just how happy their music makes me on a fundamental level.
happy they make you happy
As someone who is a massive AJR fan, their music just makes me happy. I never really listen to the lyrics of songs, I just listen to how it feels to me. AJR scratches the itch that no other band can consistantly scratch.
I would always make self-depricating jokes about my liking of AJR because it was funny, but after I saw them live for the first time, I vowed to never justify my enjoyment of them again.
Inertia and Maybe Man are definitely my favorite songs from them. They're the first songs that I've ever felt like I could actually relate to.
It makes you way less sad I guess you could say
@@beetlebatyou could indeed lol
Gonna chip in from someone that's been closely following them and being heavily involved with their community since Neotheater released and would genuinely consider them my favorite band.
When I was listening through Neotheater for the first time, I really didn't think of it too much until it got to their song Karma. Something about that song hit me as it had perfectly described what I had been going through at that time, but I had NO idea how to put it into words. I remember by the time the song finished, I had cried, something I hadn't done with a song in YEARS. From there I fell in love with the band. How honest they were in their music. How honest they were as people. They really helped me get through high school as I was 14 when Neotheater released so the general theme of the album regarding growing up really struck a nerve with me. Neotheater and their music in general has genuinely helped me get through some of the worst and hardest moments of my life so far and without them, I don't think I would have gotten through things. Neotheater honestly changed my life and I really wouldn't be who I am without it. It helped me fall in love with music and going to their Neotheater tour made me fall in love with live music as it was my first concert and I've gone to all of their tours since (as well seeing my other favorite artists live!). Being with them for over 4 years now, it feels like I've grown up with the band now as I'm in college (I'm gonna be 20 next year 🥲) and yet they're still able to release songs at the right times in my life when I need them the most, and they still hit as hard as ever.
I was able to meet them last year during their OK Orchestra tour and I was able to pour my heart out to them really about how much they helped me. I knew they were nice already, but that day I really felt their love and appreciation towards their fans. They were so kind and patient with me about it all to where they upgraded me to pit for free just so I could get the button (which was the big finale of that tour where they picked an audience member to push a button). The button has a really big meaning behind it regarding mental health which I really recommend looking into for anyone who doesn't know, but it literally meant the entire world to me. They absolutely love their fans so much and that night further proved it to me.
I do get why people don't like/care for them honestly. I really do and that's totally okay!! The issue I have is where people needlessly go out of their way to attack the artist and their fans over them not liking AJR. It goes for any artist really; I wish people could just simply ignore them and move on with their lives instead of wasting it on bashing something they don't even like. I wish people would treat each other nicer with music taste and opinions in general, but sadly what can you do.
I do remember in an interview that they acknowledged this massive amount of hate that they get and Jack responds with a comment like "If we have a million haters but if we're able to help at least one person with it, that's all that matters" which speaks volumes about how much they care about their fans and how that's their main priority.
This was a great video!! Really refreshing to see videos like this of AJR. All for having mature discussions about them!
Wow, thank you for sharing all of this. I’m glad you’ve had such a great experience with the band.
My experience was actually very much like this, except with my I poster syndrome and the world's smallest violin.
I found out about AJR a few years ago from a friend, but really never listened to their music until Worlds Smallest Violin started trending on Tiktok. One thing lead to another and now hear I am, they're my favorite band. I obviously understand that their music is different and not for everyone, but I am always shocked at how much scathing hate they get for just- making music the way they want to. I don't think I've ever seen another artist get so attacked just for- making music? Their music has definitely helped me through some rough times and I can find myself relating to a lot of the lyrics.
@@your_local_bardbear Unfortunately, negativity rules our world
I’m a pretty big fan of AJR, but I can’t say they don’t have their faults. Their lyrics are weird sometimes, they have songs that just don’t have a rhythm that sounds nice, but they definitely have improved which each album. They’ve grown and have just about perfected their craft. They aren’t for everyone, no music will ever be, ( other than maybe Kahoot music ) and I appreciate you not being one sided on liking or disliking, but being open minded to both sides.
Every band has their imperfections, it’s important to acknowledge their flaws and highs.
Would you ever consider making a video for “The Appeal of Tones and I”?
As an Australian, it’s been an….interesting journey watching her from being a beach-side busker, to getting nationwide airplay on Triple J, to having Dance Monkey becoming a worldwide hit, then finally getting that infamous 0 from Fantano.
I personally don’t like her music but I feel like it would be a good topic to cover.
That’s certainly a suggestion. I’ve only heard her one album but i’ll look at her story a bit more
I met (pun intended?) AJR at a record signing for their latest album. The store gave priority entry to everyone who pre-ordered the album, which I did. I had put the CD and pre-order receipt in my coat pocket. When it was almost my turn, I took the case out and discovered the receipt's adhesive had stuck to the case, but it didn't tear off cleanly. I showed the guys and apologized, but they said I didn't need to apologize for that. Super nice guys.
The other fans in line were nice too. The kid in front of me had a drawing he made of the band to show them. One of the songs playing on the loudspeaker was a song I learned they made for charity a few years ago about domestic violence.
They're not bad people, but while they certainly have good ideas, I think the execution in their songs often leaves something to be desired. There's a lot of irony and cynicism in their lyrics, like in Birthday Party. I imagine that means the sugary, over-the-top production common in the band's music is meant to be ironic too. Or at least I hope so. I refuse to believe a song like Thirsty was meant to be taken seriously.
I can’t imagine Thirsty being taken seriously!! Have you seen the music video?
I feel like they are half ironic and half serious, i like that
@@beetlebat yeah! Its like their “fake deepness” is actually pretty deep if you look closer.
I'm a musician and a big AJR fan. Their music is unique and just perfectly chaotic enough to be interesting but not too much to just be a mess, their lyrics always hit all the spots (safe to say that I am definitely in their target demographic) and the fact that they produce all their music themselves is definitely a plus for me currently making and learning how to produce my own songs myself. However I have noticed that a lot of my other musician friends seem to have this hate for the band and I've never understood why. So this video was certainly informative and entartatining.
Glad I showed you the other nasty side of all this. It’s a weird space isn’t it
Even though I don’t like their music at all, I still respect what they’ve accomplished and they seem like really nice guys
Respectful
People will complain about whatever they don’t like and say it sounds the same. But to the people who like it, they see all the differences.
i definitely see the differences haha
As an Ajr fan, I can confirm that we don’t talk about living room
We Don’t Talk About Living Rooommmm
Y'all gotta give it some credit for Bleecker Street though
@@jack-is-back true
as an ajr fan, we don't talk about thirsty.
Wdym it’s fantastic
loved this video, as AJR fan sometimes it's hard for other people not understanding why you like the stuff you enjoy I made plenty of AJR videos on why I love them and most of the time people don't seem to like it but it's their messages on why they are a great band because some of the stuff they are saying you can picture yourself in those certain situation (or at least that is why i love them)
Glad you make content about what you love, neat stuff bro
I only started getting into AJR because of my son but then some songs started to grow on me- now they seem to satisfy a tickle in my brain and I don’t know why I can’t stop smiling and moving when I hear them. Fave song is Bummerland. We went to their concert in April and I get it now. I understand what the draw is for those people that are their fans. It just hits different. It’s not music about big booties or WAP, or tragic breakups. It’s life. It’s what we go through and we’re on that journey together.
It’s quite raw lyrically
@@beetlebat I think that’s why I like it. It’s uncomplicated. I listen to a lot of styles of music and much is full of deep complicated meaning- but this is just kinda freeing.
My favourite band is AJR . Especially there latest album the maybe man . From what i have realised in my journey is that AJR is way way different than mainstream song writers it is what attracts people to them but also makes people stay away .
Ajr fans are some of the nicest and most respectful fans you will find .
There concerts are amazing and the songs so relatable. I have found myself communities of AJR fans which i am really happy to be i
Glad you found great people through the band’s music, that’s incredible
I personally think living room is their best, I ain’t really vibing with TMM ngl
I’ve been listening to AJR since 2019. The appeal for me is the insane relatability of most of their songs. The chaos of the instruments and sounds reflects the feeling of spiraling into something like not knowing who you are or when you’re gonna die. Neotheater and OK Orchestra helped me get through really tough times in my life. I’m also just a huge sucker for theatrical music!
AJR is my favorite band, and I think what made me a fan of them is not just their music but the genuinness of it and how down to earth there lyrics can be or how raw their feelings are in their music. It feels like it's truly them because it is truly them. They create the whole song themselves. I was originally introduced to them when I would watch RUclips short animations, then rediscovered them through TikTok from world's smallest violin and I've been a fan ever since.
That WSV song was a huge moment for them, crazy how tiktok can influence artists
One thing I have to say, is this is the first review ish type thing that I’ve seen that doesn’t insult AJR constantly. So good job on that.
That’s what I try to do
@@beetlebat And I appreciate it!
I’ve loved this band since they started. As someone who has adhd and anxiety, the lyrics and the beats are what have kept me with them for this long, as well as everything they say in each song and album having a reason for being there, it’s just amazing how these guys make music
A lot of people would agree with you. I don’t have ADHD (i think) but there were several comments left by people on that spectrum who enjoy AJR for that person. Their chaotic nature sound appeals to their brain processing. It’s interesting
I found out about AJR because of World's Smallest Violin and my first impression was that they were fine but not memorable. I looked up their YT channel and listened to Dj is crying for help and it genuinely made me tear up. I have been battling depression and anxiety disorder for years now and I found it cathartic that a song could help me release emotions without me causing physical pain to myself. From that moment onwards I became a fan. Every time I have a panic attack or depressive episode, I just listen to their songs and they help me cope.
I truly get why people don't like their music. It's niche and indie. But seeing the extent of hate their music gets really make me sad about the world. That music that make sad people happy are called bad and cringe because normal (neurotypical) people don't understand them. There are some AJR songs I dont like (Thirsty, The Trick, Call my Dad) and I acknowledge that they do make some unpleasant quirky sounds but I liked the chaos of it. It reminds me constantly that being different and unappealing is not the end of the world. Weird people exist and weird music can be popular but bullies/haters will always have the loudest voice because being hateful and negative is better than amicable neutrality. Like I know this is a weird tangent on the topic but to have it blatantly pointed out that the mental issues I wholeheartedly relate to in AJR's songs are just shallow/sheltered/cringe views of what real grief/sorrow/pain feels like, makes me realize that this world never really had a place for people who think differently from the norm.
Happy you found a safe space, you’re awesome
I've listened to AJR for years and love almost every song because I'm a sucker for storytelling, especially through music. As someone who also loves to create and tell stories (through drawing, writing, or creating videos), AJR's music has always had a special spot in my head and the lyrics have definitely influenced my writing style in some way. The way they do music is just so different than the what most people around me listen to so I can always tell when one of their songs come on and put a smile on my face.
That’s me when I hear specific songs in public. Can’t help but smile and get closer to it
One thing I really admire about them is how they are maturing and growing, a clear result of which is The Maybe Man, which has more focused and easy-to-listen songs, without exaggeration and more mature lyrics, without a real example of children's lyrics on this album as on neotheater there's a lot of the click, I'm really excited to see their next releases (they make very good acoustics)
We gonna get a dad rock album soon at this rate
Im a fan of AJR but even more a fan of Owl City. I feel like Owl City falls into the same boat of disliked because of lyrics and production but has a lot of fans that love his musical style and relatability. I personally love how each song has so many layers and harmonies and synths that sound amazing (again, similar to AJR) Also its just one guy (Adam Young) that does all the production, writing and vocals which is really cool.
True, I can see that. Owl City has Fireflies a generational classic. So the general public adores him just for that. I’m sure the music critics aren’t too fond on his other stuff though
AJR’s work is like all the ideas that pop into my head that a bit cringe and far from perfect but mean something to me in some way, but they had the courage and passion to manifest them to completion.
I have to give them respect for it.
It’s cringe in a wholesome way
AJR's a band I would occasionally listen to when I was younger - specifically when 'Infinity' and 'I'm Ready' got released, but since I wasn't seeing their music advertised much, I did start to forget about them.
it was only back in 2019 after the release of '100 Bad Days' that I started listening to their music again.
A lot of the reasons that I listen to them are featured in the video but the one at 16:51 is one of the main ones - '100 Bad Days' came out when I was struggling mentally and at the time (and even now) I find the message through the upbeat rhythm and lyrics comforting. 'Karma' and 'Don't Throw Out My Legos' are two other songs I found comforting and whose lyrics helped me understand how I was feeling and feel less alone.
Their music isn't typical so I kind of understand why people don't like them, but I don't think they deserve a lot of the backlash they get. They're a very talented band who, to me, just experiment and create beats that sound amazing in a weird way. It's not a bad thing to create something or be a little different and AJR's obviously found their audience.
They're not for everyone, but everything's subjective, from music to art to movies etc., and everyone's allowed to choose what they like and dislike.
Also, their concert's are very fun :)
Fair, some of the messages aren’t for me at the moment
@@beetlebat That's also fair
A friend kept playing their songs on discord when we played league with our friends back in the pandemic on late 2020. I totally fell in love with their music and felt listened. Been following since then. eternally grateful with my friend for that.
I love AJR so much, mostly because they actually feel like real people and make music like they really care about their fans. They aren’t like the artists that just abuse being able to write absolute nonsense or write songs about sleeping with a bunch of women with no respect for themselves, but instead write relatable songs that someone can think about once it’s over.
That’s certainly a positive
I gotta say I really appreciate this outsode view of AJR. I've recently made a couple of tiktoks about how I like their new album and some people went FERAL (like, telling me to end myself feral). I understand people really like them, and that some people really hate them. But I really admire your ability to pull groups together with your videos that are able to respectfully talk about it!!! You seem super cool dude and I'm excited to see more!
Wow, people are so mean to you damn. Nobody deserves to be treated like that. Thank you for taking the time to watch this, I got some great stuff otw
Honestly, as an AJR fan, I appreciate your honesty with the video. I think you do a good job of getting their appeal while also acknowledging their criticisms. What I appreciate most about AJR is that they are willing to take creative risks in their songs. Doing that makes you inherently polarizing, but as someone who enjoys the silliness of thirsty and other similarly goofy songs, that kind of buckwildness is what draws me to their music. I understand why musically and lyrically people aren't a fan of their music, but I can't lie and say the music doesn't appeal to me and I love listening to it. So I'm glad you have this video that helps articulate why I feel the way I feel about them. Also something you didn't mention, but their concerts are genuinely amazing, I haven't been to one of them yet, but from what I've seen a footage they go out of their way to put on an incredible show and I got to respect him for that. Like I said, great video.
Oh yeah, they have great shows!
They have so many sounds in most of their songs that you can listen to it over and over again because you find a new sound every time. The other type of their songs is the more emotional songs which has beautiful instrumentals. Greatest band!
@@blokhed70 A unique one!
Massive AJR fan here!! Great video, loved the different perspectives it gave! My favourite AJR song is currently 2085, the message that life never gets less complicated and to just do it instead of wasting time thinking about it hits right at home. Also, as an aroace person, the Turning Out trilogy, and their themes of growing up, etc. being just as common than themes of love is really refreshing!
2085 is a stellar outro
I could talk for hours on why I like AJR. I can’t say I’m the number one AJR fan or that I like every one of their songs but Damnit, I’ve listened to them for like 3 weeks straight at this point and I think my family hates me for it.
Their older songs, like pre click, I genuinely cannot listen to, but hey, improvement happens and they’re getting better every year!
Second reason I like them so much, I’m a theatre kid with too much childhood trauma. I don’t wanna go too deep into it but like. Damn My Play and the general theatre and childish vibes hits close to home.
Third, I’ve found myself in the most. AJR situation imaginable. I’m going to college this year, and potentially moving out and making life changing decisions while my parents are in the other room arguing about their divorce. So, AJR has definitely helped me out mentally so much.
Fourth reason: I’m autistic and it effects how I listen to music. Not every autistic person is like me, but my autism has definitely effected my music taste. (This can be seen through how most music artists I follow have a somewhat large autistic fan base as well. It’s also how I learned I was autistic.) I find the sounds of AJR to be stimulating but not overstimulating. Actually even helping in some situations where I would normally get overstimmed.
5th reason: (I am not being consistent with how I list these. Fight me) im autistic but this time it effects it in a different way. I’m often hyperfixated on things, and one thing I’ve always been hyperfixated on is my own OCs or original characters. AJR’s music reflects their story in such a way I find unique so it’s always fun to imagine little animations in my head to them.
6th: AJR is somehow always there when I need them. Like fuck dude. What do you mean you made a song about relating the concept of inertia to daily life and not being able to move on/being stuck in the past the day after I cry about being stuck in the past and also learn the concept of inertia in my physics class? It’s always so specifically on the nose for me it’s slightly terrifying in a way but you know what. We ball.
Appreciate you for telling ur story and experience with AJR. Truly deep stuff here
I'm SO happy to see someone who appreciates Livin' on Love, as a big AJR fan I really love that song!! It's one of my favorites and I wish more people knew it existed.
ITS SOOO GOOD
"How long is this song?" "Bout two and a half minutes" "And how long did it take to make?" "bout two and a half years" I'm in my 30s, I gotta be real AJR being so open about their creative process has been very validating. I write all kinds of things, music included, but part of me always felt like if I couldn't write it out all in one go, it wasn't really properly writing something true. But after seeing these guys live... they've just put so much hard work into creating. It makes you wanna put something out there too, you know?
Thank you, it’s nice to have more positivity and fairness for them out on the internet! People can dislike them or not vibe with them, but the sheer amount of dogpiling and mocking and over-critical nonsense people lay on thick on these guys is insane..
I’ve literally seen a video where the reviewer criticised the song they wrote for their dying dad harshly for “lyrics that don’t make sense” when they make perfect sense..
There’s no band quite like these lovely brothers, and they’re my favourite band ever. It’s so fun to listen to their old stuff and hear them find their sound over time, let alone the incredible work they”re making now!
I wonder who the reviewer is…
@@beetlebat I think you actually included a clip of the guy’s video in yours while talking about the harsh critics. I haven’t seen much of his stuff/can’t remember his name/channel, but he seems to have a reputation with his fans for despising AJR and reviewing them regardless despite already having decided that he hates it.. like, who pauses a song less than a minute in on the first listen to complain about something as silly as not thinking “gods really real, til he’s not” makes sense? (No hate on the reviewer, but if he’s Christian then I can see why that line ruffled feathers, but that doesn’t mean it’s bad, ya know?)
The reason I like AJR is cause I am a young adult and I do relate to the lyrics. Also I love the whacky sounds so much.
We are all young adults at heart
Some reasons I personally love AJR are all the weird noises and high-pitched vocals! It adds character and makes their music unique. One of my favorite songs of theirs is "Joe", and that has a shit ton of funky sounds! Although the sounds in "Inertia" and "2085" at the beginning are probably my favorites. They both had me hooked instantly, which is another thing AJR is good at.
I especially love it when they use a bunch of different instruments. It really stands out in their album "OK Orchestra", where they use trumpets, violins, keyboards, guitars, and the list goes on! And they know how to make them all work together perfectly.
The Maybe Man truly made me appreciate their lyrics. It genuinely does show how honest they are in their feelings, as you mentioned. Some of their lyrics are just silly or cheesy, like in "Steve's Going to London", and others are sad or deep, like in "God is Really Real" and "Weak". They have made me really appreciate the lyrics in songs more than the sound itself. Some of my favorite lyrics are from the song "Maybe Man". I can relate to them, and it gets me thinking about so much more than just the music and sound.
I don't think they deserve this kind of hate and no one really does! It all just depends on your type of music, so I get why people don't like them. (Oops I ranted. Sorry for that I just love AJR so fucking much lmaoo)
I’ve been a fan of AJR since 100 Bad Days came out and have been following the band as they have been growing for some time. I had no idea that they were so hated until this year. It breaks my heart that so many people go out of their way to hate something just because somebody else enjoys it. Especially because AJR has personally helped me through quite a bit through so much of their personalized lyrics.
They have a lot of songs that can be very raw and open about mental health that can really speak to people who struggle with it. Like Karma, Inertia, the Turning Out Series-
Drama helped me when I was struggling to get away from a very bad friend group.
They have a way of coming across with very emotional and heavier lyrics that are widespread levels of relatable despite having an upbeat presentation.
Yeah i completely get it. when people find ways to hate acts i like, i can get defensive too
absolutely love this video!! I can imagine it must have taken a while, so very good job, I really like AJR
keep it up!!
It took quite a few hours haha
As someone with sensory overload, this band is amazing. AJR's music just hits that part of me that loves sounds like this, without overwhelming me-
Plus they just feel so genuine. They don't hold back, they say exactly what they feel, and it's nice. Refreshing, kinda.
sensory overload isn’t for me personally but I get why people like you find it fascinating
@@beetlebat Oh, it's not for me either lmao. I get intense mental breakdowns- AJR songs just don't trigger that, but they have a bunch of cool composition and stuff in the background that I really like.
My college roommate would play AJR *constantly.* As a result, I have a certain loathing of overplay, but also I have a big fondness for particular songs that I did end up having grow on me.
Me with One Direction and Justin Bieber when my sister’s blasted them
i think i feel the same way about AJR as i do about similarly hated pop artists by people like me; i had to listen to some of their biggest hits ad nauseum in high school as my art teacher would play millennial pop stuff 24/7 and while i never actively enjoyed their stuff, i can't say i ever really grew sick of it despite how often i'd hear them. i remember seeing the cover art for the click during class and thinking it looked cute and looked up the album's reception out of curiosity and was a bit surprised to see that people hate their stuff. even now i still feel indifferent towards them, and i think because of that disconnect and the association of their music with some of my best experiences in high school (those being all of my art classes), i kind of secretly hope they'll come through some day with something genuinely good
I do like the cover arts, pretty neat
During the finale of their maybe man arena tour they actually speak up to all the haters.
interesting
I just got into AJR and I really love their music. Sure it sounds weird but I like that! It makes them unique! Their performances are always lovely and enjoyable! They were my first concert this past June. And I love the messages like in inertia and way less sad! They’ve really helped me 🩵
Nothin wrong with being a lil weird ay
As someone with ADHD, AJR songs are basically what is in my head all the time. (Also, all their songs at once, as they're my favorite band.)
Many people would agree with you!
I am extremely proud to say that I’m a die hard AJR fan. I think their music is incredible and relatable and have personally changed my life. Their songs made me cry, smile and laugh but regardless make me happy. I think they’re great and make such powerful messages through unique and inspirational music. I do understand why people my not like them, as you need to understand and relate to songs to love them. I’m always and forever proud of them ❤
Proud of you!
Bradford sent me. This video is fantastic at explaining why people like some of this goofy band’s music as much as they do lol. Excellent video as always 😉
Shoutout Bradford
Beetlebat, thank you for making this very high-quality video I love how you took the time to heart every single person’s comment and comment on almost every single persons comment as well. I admire how involved you are with your fans and I respect that a lot. So I just wanna say good job, I’m proud of you.
This means so much man damn.. I try to get involved with everyone that comments here. I love what I do here on RUclips and I’m blessed with what I’ve created. You’re awesome
AJR is my favorite band, and it genuinely makes me really sad when people bash them for absolutely no reason. Once I saw someone call their music "soulless, corporate slop", which doesn't even make any sense. Haters aside, I love that they're not afraid to talk about things other than love, breakups, etc. They're unique, and they wholeheartedly embrace that. Some of my favorite songs by them are "Wow, I'm Not Crazy", "Inertia", and "Way Less Sad" :)
Nahh they sure ain’t soulless, i can tell they put a lot of effort into what they do
Ok I really appreciate this video. I got into AJR back when I was a freshman in high school, and their song "Come hang out" immediately clicked with me. I'll always remember the first time I listened to it, I was blown away by how it sounded and what the song was about. I was missing out hanging out with friends and was feeling really left out, and although the song's message is a bit different (they chose to not hang out with friends but it wasn't a choice for me) it still really comforted me. I honestly really enjoyed the way the albums were concept albums. I never really heard that before, so I was blown away by the stories and connections in the songs, especially in neotheater. The turning out songs always hit me on an extremely personal level, those songs are very special to me (although I have only listened to part 1 and 2 as of typing this). I really only listened to the click and neotheater, and started to wane off of them when I got obsessed with other artists and they started to get more hate. That's why I appreciate this video so much, it's completely unbiased and emphasizes how the songs are meaningful to the listener. You really just have to be the target audience, or the young naïve high schooler, to like/get into their music sometimes. The people who hate their music just aren't the target audience. Their music is definitely a bit corny and sometimes a bit cringey when I come back to them as an adult now, but maybe I'll have to give their new album a try since it's been mentioned that it's more mature. So yeah, thank you for this video. I think I'll always have a strange little soft spot for AJR in my heart.
Definitely check out The Maybe Man. Their best yet, glad you liked this!
I don’t like AJR, but I have to admit they know how to make a song move you. Not in any deep lyrics or strong melodies, but they know how to make music with a really strong sense of momentum. Each bar leads into each other and builds up in a satisfying way. I dislike most of their songs most of the time, but I’ll admit some of the music has given me chills. I can totally see why people like them.
Turning Out and God Is Really Real come to mind
Coming from the opposite side as a fan, but I really love this point! The endings to 2085 and Ok Overture come to mind. Those huge build ups never fail to give me chills.
i find it hard to believe this guy has only 4k subs. this is very in-depth video and actually one of the best things i've seen on youtube in recent weeks
Thank you 🙏 got more awesome content otw
Ajr is just such a fun loving group, yet they're simultaneously able to tackle some of the deeper, more pressing issues they and their fans face. I wouldn't consider myself a die-hard fan, and yet they're one of the few artists I listen to where I'll literally save the entirity of each new album they produce (rather than just picking and choosing songs here and there). I also have to give them props for the energy they bring to live venues, I don't know how anyone can dance and jump around that much for hours on end, especially while belting a high tenor chorus. Watching them in concert was a joy I hope to get to experience again.
As someone who has performed live before, it gets tiring and it requires a lot of practice in the gym
I'm a very big AJR fan. Because of them I started listening to music a year ago. I could write a novel about why I love them and there music so much but I'm here to say that this was an amazing video. It's fantastic to see you from a neutral perspective. You share your thoughts and clearly express your positive and negative aspects of the band. I love this Video. Thank you for you're Work :)
Appreciate that, it’s awesome you wrote a novel too!!
Great video, couldn't have said it better myself! Perhaps in future videos, you could keep the volume on a similar level? I had to keep fiddling with the volume whenever you hopped between song and talking.
Will do haha
I've been a big fan of theirs for a few years, thanks to one of my friends. I just recently went to one of their TMM tour concerts and it was absolutely breathtaking, genuinely the best performance I've ever seen presentation-wise. People are certainly allowed to have differing opinions on them, that's totally understandable; what really gets me are the people saying "well, I don't like them so neither can you" or "they're rated so poorly, how could you possibly enjoy it?" Literally one time in college, I told some friends that I liked their music and their reactions were just absolutely disgusted and I just don't see the need for that. Everyone's going to disagree on music taste to some degree, but it's so much easier to just let people enjoy whatever they want. As long as they're not harming anyone/thing, why not?
Yeah I wish people weren’t so judgmental about them
I started listening to AJR last year thanks to my teenage son. Recently being diagnosed with AuADHD, AJR's music has helped him/us feel less different and even accept our "quirkiness". He has found new friends because of AJR's music. I remember watching how that very small group of friends got to dance to The Dumb Song at Prom last year... the only song that made them feel seen. I listened to the lyrics for the first time and felt so proud of them at that moment. AJR's music has a special effect on neurodivergent people. I now listen to them while working. It lifts my spirit somehow with their sad/relatable lyrics and upbeat sound. We are for sure going to their concert this summer and can't wait to share the experience with him.
That is amazing! Family is important
i only became a fan of their music a little while ago and when i looked them up online i was genuinely baffled how much vitriol about them there is. i still am. when i hear a song i don't like i just stop listening to it and move on with my day. you're telling me people take precious time out of their day to rant about how they hate one specific band? wouldn't they be much happier ignoring ajr and just listening to the songs they like?
There are some wild reviews out there. Spectrum Pulse’s The Click is one of them. Great review but DAMN people are vicious
AJR fans and certainly AJR themselves know that their music isn't for everyone (to put it lightly), but, as a long-time fan of theirs, I think that's kind of the point. If they make music that they really like, they have every reason to share it. And as long as they have even just a few people who also like it, they'll keep making their brand of music. This is a perfect, unbiased review of AJR. Thank you for this video!
as they should, ty!
I've ben a fan of AJR since first hearing Bang!, but out of everything I love about AJR, my favorite thing has got to be their relatable lyrics. Sober Up, 2085, the Maybe Man, Netflix Trip, The DJ is Crying for Help, and the ending of Ok Overture are my favorite examples of this. With Sober Up being a top contender for my favorite song ever.
I usually just see album reactions to AJR so this video is a welcome addition to my feed. I loved the deep dive and your explanations for everything. I hope to see more of you in the future!
I was surprised there wasn’t a whole lot of ajr video essays out there
I love this band, I don't care if someone I know hates them. As there is always someone out there that does love them.
That’s what matters
Casual ajr enjoyer here! I love the effort they put into their music, and the realness of their lyrics. Recently I saw a video of a girl freaking out meeting them, saying that they saved her life and said everything that she couldn't find the words for. As someone who could say the same about twenty one pilots, I was heartbroken to find every single comment hating on the girl and/or ajr. Some were death threats.
I can't say I'm their biggest fan. Some of their songs, I can't stand. But it's not like the band is made of bad people, and the girl definitely didn't deserve that hate.
So I'm glad to find fellow ajr appreciators. As weird as it seems, it restores my faith in humanity.
I saw that video, it was so sweet and ugh those comments were terrible.
i wasn’t ever a huge ajr fan, but i listened to living room when it first came out and pitchfork kids was my the track that i loved the most, even joining my rotation when i shifted my music taste to heavier sounds. hearing it again in this video reminded me that even if I’m not a fan of their newer stuff that track still goes pretty hard!
I just think the title is funny
I used to be a massive AJR fan! I have autism, so sometimes the “sensory overload” would honestly be great for grounding me- sounds backwards but that’s just how it is lol. I like how honest and childish they are- I’m 23 and I can relate a lot to their struggles of being in that weird stage of growing up. I don’t like them as much anymore, but I think my favorite songs would have to be Turning Out part 1 & 2 (I haven’t listened to the new album). I really appreciate you being honest without bashing the people who genuinely enjoy their stuff. It’s not for everyone- it isn’t even for most people- but it means a lot to some who do enjoy it.
The sensory overload is certainly a rollercoaster
that's why i like metal so much, it centers me. meshuggah really does it for me
@@shrimpscampin i love metal (especially meshuggah) but also love ajr
@@mitchstarr I respect tf out of that ngl