birthday mv is basically about them going through various challenges and games to break into gingerbreads birthday after he denied them entrance to his birthday its very silly lol
Some reasons why Bye Bye sounds familiar: 1. That Wendy "I only had love for you..." line went viral on TikTok. 2. This song samples Beethoven's Fur Elise (yes the classical music) P.S. Birthday also sampled another classical piece from Gershwin.
ZOOM is one of my all time favorite B-sides. Everything about it. The instrumentation, tha sass, tha attitude.... It's the epitome of "Caught you, you lying b*st*rd!"
"Birthday" is the song need good music knowledge in order to understand it, we know the previous TT is "Feel my Rhythm" which use classical sample, "Birthday" starts with a short sample from "Rhapsody in Blue", this is the music that combines classical and jazz music, this song use the idea of it which mix all kinds of music elements form early jazz to EDM, rock, hip-hop, etc. You can imagine this song is a Kaleidoscope, each music element is like the colored piece. Red velvet never made bad music, just sometimes over many people's head.
Always love your Red Velvet reactions 😊 Bye Bye might sound familiar because it samples the melody from Fur Elise. I totally agree about their vocal ability being able to save a song with a “bad” instrumental. Their harmonies and adlibs are something else 😂 I would love to see your reaction to their mini album RBB!! Or one of the other Reve festivals. Their discography really is something else. I love watching you discover and enjoy their music 😊
Every song on this album was included on their R to V tour. Have you watched clips of the tour? If so, that explains your familiarity with the songs hahahaha
tbh, been here for 9 years and listening to red velvet have never got me worried about hearing a song not aligned to my taste (tho that very rarely happens) because the vocals make up for it. its insane to me how someone found these five and put them in a group, like you have gotta be a genius. a friend told me then that she wanna have red velvet's discography for her fave but that got me thinking, their discography is great not just because of the production aspect but vocals held an equal amount of contribution to it, might be even more. they achieved this very celebrated discography because its their vocals thats in there. you had to have these set of vocals, their greatness to be able to handle these songs. Its even more impressive to me knowing that the members especially wendy (i mean she does the demo of their songs) have so much say in the production and how much they know their craft.
The live performances were awesome for many of these songs in the recent R to V Concert. The choreo was spectacular too! There were so many Easter eggs in the MV it was awesome😂🎉. Notice Seulgi’s choice of weapon was the chain 😂
Thank you Pat for another RV album reaction! This album is Joy's era tbh and the teaser photos on this one damn! I hope you can react to their past album if you have time, I would recommend RBB album (R&B is R&B-ing' on that mini album). More subs to your channel. 💖
Of course you like Birthday now! HAHAHA Thank you to Edit Pat for the update hehe I really feel like Joy was SHINING SO BRIGHT on this mini album she really had such an incredible moment on every song. I really also love how you appreciate the high quality vocals and delivery on things that aren't just high notes and runs and whatnot - like when you were appreciating Wendy's delivery on Celebrate. She just SOUNDS SO GOOD what more do you need when someone can sound like that tbh?
Birthday album sounds like an interpolation of other Western songs from Coldplay and Ariana Grande and tracks like Bye-bye and Zoom were trending, which could be the reason why it sounded familiar. Loved your reaction. I hope we get an RBB mini-album reaction.
most underrated song of red velvet.. but i keep on listening to it everyday and its get better and realize it very very unique too..they were the concept queens
birthday is Red Velvet's most hated Title Track not only by GP who listen to Red Velvet but also by lots of reveluvs themselves. and i can totally understand why lots of people don't like the song. the other tracks on the album are fire tho, especially Zoom & BYE BYE. and till this day i still think if only Red Velvet choose either of BYE BYE, On a Ride, or Zoom to be the title track instead of Birthday this comeback would be so much more succesfull and definitely less hated now.
Thank u for reacting to red velvet💗 I always look forward to ur reactions. I hope u could release a reaction to Bini, a ppop girl group consists of 8 member. They're from the Philippines hence the letter p from ppop.
entertaining reaction as always! your energy is so contagious and fun to watch 😭 i usually dont request anything since people are bombarding you with stuff left and right im sure…but if you enjoyed this i know for a FACT youll enjoy unlock my world by Fromis_9 if you havent already headd that album. best kpop album of 2023 imo! anyways ❤️❤️❤️
Question: did you already listen to The Red album before reacting to red velvet on the channel? Cuz if not I really think you would enjoy reacting to that album. It’s one of my personal favorites.
For this album the title track really took away from the whole thing, cuz the sides are all fantastic. The live stages for both bye bye and zoom are completely different vibes but all amazing.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
That Wendy part in bye bye went viral on tiktok maybe that’s why
birthday mv is basically about them going through various challenges and games to break into gingerbreads birthday after he denied them entrance to his birthday its very silly lol
How dare did Gingerbread deny the entrance to the COSMIC WITCHES?
Well he had it coming lmfao hence why he was crying in the end of the mv 😭😭
Some reasons why Bye Bye sounds familiar:
1. That Wendy "I only had love for you..." line went viral on TikTok.
2. This song samples Beethoven's Fur Elise (yes the classical music)
P.S. Birthday also sampled another classical piece from Gershwin.
in my opinion Joy slayed this mini album so badly omg
zoom is literally trending everywhere poeple going crazy everytime the bridge comes in
It's Rev-uh. Bye Bye sounds familiar because it is sampling Beethoven's "Fur Elise"
18:59
"I feel like I've heard these songs before"
Wendy: Why are you lying? Tired man..
ZOOM is one of my all time favorite B-sides.
Everything about it.
The instrumentation, tha sass, tha attitude....
It's the epitome of "Caught you, you lying b*st*rd!"
"Birthday" is the song need good music knowledge in order to understand it, we know the previous TT is "Feel my Rhythm" which use classical sample, "Birthday" starts with a short sample from "Rhapsody in Blue", this is the music that combines classical and jazz music, this song use the idea of it which mix all kinds of music elements form early jazz to EDM, rock, hip-hop, etc. You can imagine this song is a Kaleidoscope, each music element is like the colored piece.
Red velvet never made bad music, just sometimes over many people's head.
the bsides trended on tiktok/reels for a while! you might've heard them there or from something that came out of those
RBB album is my personal favorite. Can’t recommend it enough!
omg same i can’t wait for the reaction
RBB and Birthday are such great mini albums. They're kind of the same, cause they have FANTASTIC b-sides, and very polarizing title tracks.
Sameee
Birthday is a grower, it became one of my favorite tt of them after a few listens
No the way it went from eh to one of my faves on probably one of my top RV albums was a ride.
Maybe you heard clips of the songs online it went pretty viral especially zoom with wendy, seulgi and joy’s verses probably why it sounds familiar
Always love your Red Velvet reactions 😊 Bye Bye might sound familiar because it samples the melody from Fur Elise. I totally agree about their vocal ability being able to save a song with a “bad” instrumental. Their harmonies and adlibs are something else 😂 I would love to see your reaction to their mini album RBB!! Or one of the other Reve festivals. Their discography really is something else. I love watching you discover and enjoy their music 😊
FINALLY.... The Bside on this album is one of the best in my opinion
There’s really something about joy lmao I felt that
Every song on this album was included on their R to V tour. Have you watched clips of the tour? If so, that explains your familiarity with the songs hahahaha
I also love Joy, I am smitten by her
tbh, been here for 9 years and listening to red velvet have never got me worried about hearing a song not aligned to my taste (tho that very rarely happens) because the vocals make up for it. its insane to me how someone found these five and put them in a group, like you have gotta be a genius.
a friend told me then that she wanna have red velvet's discography for her fave but that got me thinking, their discography is great not just because of the production aspect but vocals held an equal amount of contribution to it, might be even more. they achieved this very celebrated discography because its their vocals thats in there. you had to have these set of vocals, their greatness to be able to handle these songs. Its even more impressive to me knowing that the members especially wendy (i mean she does the demo of their songs) have so much say in the production and how much they know their craft.
The live performances were awesome for many of these songs in the recent R to V Concert. The choreo was spectacular too!
There were so many Easter eggs in the MV it was awesome😂🎉. Notice Seulgi’s choice of weapon was the chain 😂
Thank you Pat for another RV album reaction! This album is Joy's era tbh and the teaser photos on this one damn! I hope you can react to their past album if you have time, I would recommend RBB album (R&B is R&B-ing' on that mini album). More subs to your channel. 💖
Of course you like Birthday now! HAHAHA Thank you to Edit Pat for the update hehe
I really feel like Joy was SHINING SO BRIGHT on this mini album she really had such an incredible moment on every song. I really also love how you appreciate the high quality vocals and delivery on things that aren't just high notes and runs and whatnot - like when you were appreciating Wendy's delivery on Celebrate. She just SOUNDS SO GOOD what more do you need when someone can sound like that tbh?
18:57 The timing of this was impeccable lmao :D ... You saying you've heard these songs a bit and Wendy saying why u lying 🤣
Oh! Also if you get the chance. They perform this album live for their RtoV concert. Most of it is safe for youtube as well!!
Pat, the instrument you're thinking of is called an accordion.
Birthday album sounds like an interpolation of other Western songs from Coldplay and Ariana Grande and tracks like Bye-bye and Zoom were trending, which could be the reason why it sounded familiar. Loved your reaction. I hope we get an RBB mini-album reaction.
Honestly one of my fave minis!! For the next one, I’d probably suggest Red Summer or Summer Magic while it IS still summer lolol.
most underrated song of red velvet.. but i keep on listening to it everyday and its get better and realize it very very unique too..they were the concept queens
Birthday is like video game, rv members mission to execute the final boss and they winning and celebrate like a birthday party
8:08 if you're watching their RtoV concert then yeah you probably already heard it
You gotta Watch the performances, they were phenomenal
I'm with you Pat: LOVE Joy!
the reve festival day 2 let's gooo, can't wait for your eyes locked, hands locked reaction 🤍🤍
Rv will release a song today, 6pm kst. Sweet dreams, its a fan song.
RBB album for sure next
👏🏻 i enjoy your reaction thankyou
Finally finally finally I waiting this from long time reaction to birthday album thank you love you
These bsides went viral a lot for their vocals, its no surprise youve heard them somewhere lol especially zoom
Always live for your RV listens :) RBB album also has solid bsides! ❤
You have heard the instrumental from Birthday before, it's the same sample as the one used in Loossemble's Real World bside lol
You need to react to the RBB album next it’s one of their best in my opinion
I love your reactions Pat I’m glad to see you doing well!!
On a ride is my favourite from this album.
Pat are you uploading the RBB album or not I want to see your reaction!!!
you gotta do rbb next I swear... no skip album that's right 🙂↕️
YAAAAAY thanks for this
You might have heard them in a guide since you seem to recognize the chorus part.
hi pat, you should check out the GOT The Beat mini album too
I already heard their music before I started my channel.
@@justpat2316 its alright, tnx for answering!!
According to Taeyeon, we most likely won't be seeing another Got The Beat comeback. @@chrisssw_
RBB NEXTTTT
Zoom hit me so hard
birthday is Red Velvet's most hated Title Track not only by GP who listen to Red Velvet but also by lots of reveluvs themselves. and i can totally understand why lots of people don't like the song. the other tracks on the album are fire tho, especially Zoom & BYE BYE. and till this day i still think if only Red Velvet choose either of BYE BYE, On a Ride, or Zoom to be the title track instead of Birthday this comeback would be so much more succesfull and definitely less hated now.
i am so sorry for those who don't understand birthday. the beat hits hard every time and it just gets better the more i listen to it
No, I would say that RBB and Zimzalabim were hated WAY more than Birthday was.
@@riffgroove but people like these now
@onlyurbear Birthday was far and away Red Velvet's best selling album.
It couldn't have been THAT hated.
아마도 어디선가 들어봤다는 느낌이 드는것은 콘서트 클립을 어디선가 본 이유일거라고 추측합니다. 아마 작년이었죠?
Thank u for reacting to red velvet💗 I always look forward to ur reactions. I hope u could release a reaction to Bini, a ppop girl group consists of 8 member. They're from the Philippines hence the letter p from ppop.
entertaining reaction as always! your energy is so contagious and fun to watch 😭 i usually dont request anything since people are bombarding you with stuff left and right im sure…but if you enjoyed this i know for a FACT youll enjoy unlock my world by Fromis_9 if you havent already headd that album. best kpop album of 2023 imo! anyways ❤️❤️❤️
I love birthday album
RBB album next!!
react to the RBB mini album its SO GOOD
Question: did you already listen to The Red album before reacting to red velvet on the channel? Cuz if not I really think you would enjoy reacting to that album. It’s one of my personal favorites.
Bye bye had a sample melodie
bye bye it's unreal
For this album the title track really took away from the whole thing, cuz the sides are all fantastic. The live stages for both bye bye and zoom are completely different vibes but all amazing.
always love your red velvet reactions!! please react to DAY6🥹
Please do Reve Festival Day 1 & 2 reaction❤❤❤
are you in a redvelvet journey? shittt
What's that on your beard?
are you skip "really badboy album" ?
Cymbals?
Please react to the Boyz Japanese comeback gibberish 🙏
title dở nhất của vẹt =)) mắ ơi chưa bao giờ thích nổi con "birthday"