As the wife of a retired Family Doctor, this movie reminded me of the times my husband fought insurance companies and bureaucracies on behalf of his patients. Also, the times he missed school plays or recitals because he was holding a patient’s hand while delivering bad news or watching them pass. People don’t understand how much of their patients doctors carry with them, day after day, year after year. The secrets and fears they shared with him are with him even now. Most folks leave the office and don’t give it another thought until they return in the morning. Doctors don’t have that luxury. Their patients become part of them. Their lives are forever inextricably intertwined. Their pain, his pain. Their fears, his fears. Their secrets, his secrets. Even though he now suffers from dementia, I’ll make sure he watches this movie later today. I know it will bring him joy.
He must have been a wonderful doctor, a rare to find. And, you are such an understanding wife. Its not easy to be the spouse of a good, sincere, caring doctor. You sure are one. My prayers for both of you.
And hilariously Grants prediction came true. Doctors today ARE electronic. you go to your GP, they input your symptoms into a computer and the computer spits out what you may have and what tests you should be given
Say what you will about the credits of famous actresses. Margaret Hamilton earned hers with her portrayal of the witch in The Wizard of Oz, overshadowed of course by Judy Garland. However, Ms. Hamilton in this movie, professes the highest example of an entertainer that I have EVER witnessed in Hollywood's history! She has, thru these many years, so underestimated, that she truly belongs among the greatest!!! May she rest in peace as she has left an indelible mark in Hollywood!!! Thanks for sharing this reply with me. I hope you will agree with this very late assessment of an icon that shall remain in memory forever!!
Plus if you did know who plays them for no cost?! My favorite An Affair to Remember. The best part is when the little boy says m, “Everyone is talking about you” Carey Grants says well who? He said, “I don’t know every time I go in they leave”!😂 something like that. So when we get together that’s our inside joke about gossipers😂
"Shunderson" delivers one of the finest closings to a most excellent soliloquoy - his Death then Life Story followed by "You're a little man." What a grand script this was.
I worked with a Family Physician for many years as a nurse. He was also my physician. I remember patients who were elderly or people who had no insurance bringing in skinned chickens and rabbits to pay on their bill. He always accepted it as payment.
I have to admit that it's taken me a certain age to appreciate a well written script..It's true , we work hard..we're tired whether we know it or not...we plant ourselves in front of the idiot tube and if there's enough action or noise or sexual innuendos...we accept that we've seen something good..This film we've just watched together, wherever we are, was Extremely well written, extremely well played and worth it's title of a Hollywood made film...Thank you for the upload...
Such a wonderful movie and the writers of the script hit the nail on the head when talking of how doctors would devolve into electronic healers with no personal interest in the patient. 😢
My doctors are great. They face me and we have a conversation, they listen and never look at their watches. I think we had a couple of "better living through science!" generations, but that trend has definitely started to fade out, thank God.
@@carbine090909 My doctors are great too. Its just that for certain ones, my GP for instance, he sold his practice to a big corporation like so many doctors are being forced to do today because of all the paperwork both government and insurance. He is still excellent. Its GETTING to him that's the problem You deal with staff who are not medically minded but corporate minded and never bear in mind they are dealing with sick people. They max out the appointments for profit so if you have an emergent need, you cannot get in. Case in point. I caught a breakthrough case of Covid last week. I have numerous preexisting conditions so I called my GP. The ignorant corporate staff member said 'if you have Covid they DO recommended you come in and be seen. The next available is January 23rd!' I said 'my good woman, one of TWO things will happen by then. I will either be better, or I will be dead!' She then said 'then we recommended you go to the emergency room.' I said 'so instead of spending fifteen dollars for a copay for my doctor, I can spend three hundred dollars in deductibles for the emergency room to get the exact same advice. Lovely.'
A very high moment in the film to me especially bc it’s what we are experiencing now, 2022, before & after. Are going to continue to repeating ourselves forever?
This movie has been on my favorites list since the first time I saw it many years ago - it has Cary Grant who never gave a poor performance in his entire career and has a messagefor all to heed ..... Love thy fellow man
Seems movies of this era, heavily relied on the dialogue and how the dialogue was presented, not action, and this dialogue, to me, seems to make them timeless and entertaining! I suspect the reliance on dialogue was inherited from the stage, where the scope for action is limited.
@@keithad6485i agree they couldn't flash breasts so they had to have a plot ❤ i love all the old films. I love anime I love science fiction. They are all wonderful genre's
Based on the German play by Curt Goetz, which was made into a movie in Germany (Doktor med. Hiob Prätorius, 1950). I didn't know until today that there was a film version with Cary Grant and only knew the German film version. I am very happy to be able to see this wonderful version now.
Anything written by Joseph L. Mankiewicz is a pure delight. I can't believe I can watch this here free! All About Eve and A Letter to Three Wives are two similar films with sophisticated dialogue like in this gem. In any film written by Mankiewicz, a character will mention "Wilkes-Barre," an homage to the Pennsylvania city where he was born.
Actually this movie is based on a play by Curt Goetz and the play had a far better ending and also the Cary Grant movie has a very goog beginning, the one of Goetz is even better, in the Goetz version Praetorios and his wife die in a car accident (and yes, Curt Goetz can make even this funny in a nonoffensive way!), Too bad Grant did not another Goetz movie, one of his other plays "Hokuspokus" is even better.
Oh my gosh, I was leaving this comment to thank you for educating us about Mankiewicz. Then you mention Wilkes-Barre PA I was born and raised in Wilkes-Barre. There was a time in Wilkes-Barre’s history where it was wonderful to live there. I loved growing up in that old town. There were a lot of kind people. I have the sweetest memories of adults (strangers actually) being kind to me. When I was around five years old. I would get the bus at the corner where the firehouse was. And I remember there was this one man and he used to hold me up in his arms and we would watch out the window for the bus to come so I wouldn’t have to be outside cold all by myself. What a sweet man! My father wasn’t around & that man made me feel so special. It was loving and innocent and pure. It’s sad to think today that the same situation. they’d be so worried about the guy being a perv. Sadly you do need to be that way, so super careful, but I believe because of the way I am that there are still some good kind adults that love children and it’s natural for them to be loving and kind to kids in general. Thank you so much for your post ! Hope you have a merry Christmas ! 🎄
Classic b & w movies use to be aired for free on regular TV on Saturday and Sunday nights by Frank Avruch The Great Entertainment that show ran for almost 2 decades on Boston's WCVB-TV, channel 5. we also had the Movie Loft channel WSBK-TV channel 38 and no extra loud shocking & unrelated interruptions like there is on yt.
LOVE me some Cary Grant! He is always SO classy, yet funny in his roles. Him along with William Powell were the BEST in their day! I miss actors of their character 😔
Fine fun film. Finlay Currie as "Mr. Shunderson" plays a phenomenal part and his story at the end is told so flat and direct with only the slightest embellishment that it should have been given a best supporting actor Oscar award. His parting words to Hume Cronyn as Prof. Rodney Elwell are so well said with both the strangest bit of grace and humility that I just can't describe how magnificent Elwell's well deserved comeuppance was given.
Margaret Brainard Hamilton, who plays Miss Pickett here, was best known for her portrayal of the Wicked Witch of the West, and her Kansas counterpart Almira Gulch, in Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer's film The Wizard of Oz (1939).
the bit after the 'trial' when Elwell almost goes through the door (presumably to the concert), then turns and walks away alone is one of the saddest moments in any film.
I love the scene where Dr. Praetorius (Noah) talks to that elderly sick lady who doesn't want to live any more. "So you'd rather lay around in a coffin all day, doing nothing?" 😄 Cary Grant was so funny!
@@camouflageartist8897 You're clueless. Grant was known for having a quick wit and great comedic timing, so directors and producers frequently let him "enrich" the script with his ad libs. Stop blabbing ignorance.
@@catherinelw9365 I have a great sense of humor too, better than Grant. Stop celebrating actors. They read from scripts written by people with imagination and talent. Also, don’t forget to acknowledge directors and directors of photography.
There is no more elegant actor, character, or man than Cary Grant. They certainly don't make men like him any more... he is pure magic! I am, have always been, and always will be completely smitten. 💜💜💜
What a remarkable movie! Perhaps the most obscure movie ever, and decades ahead of its time. No wonder it's been lost to cinematic history - the people of that day probably couldn't make heads or tales of it. I've never enountered a denser and more thoughtful script. So much food for thought here!!!
I absolutely adore this movie. I watch it a few times a year. Brilliant actors, all-star cast, wonderful Americana feels, and many worthy life lessons make this a classic winner. 👏
We had never heard of this fabulous movie before - much less seen it. We were 4 years old when it was made. We came across it now quite by accident. Thank you for preserving this wonderful study of human nature and allowing it to be seen and enjoyed.
Cary Grant is a natural when humor is around. Even a serious film like North By Northwest could not deny a witty line "somebody call the police!" when he was lying on a police station bench in drunken stupor! Balu, india.
How come all the great movies were made before I was born?Superb acting here.Cary Grant at his usual best.The man is suave,handsome,extremely charming and funny.Beautiful movie.❤
Because there were higher standards and better writing in the past. No cgi no overt sexual themes no vulgar language. And better acting in my opinion. And Cary grant is just wonderful.
Superb movie with a brilliant and funny script - no one else could have played the part of dr pretorious better than Cary Grant. A natural born actor. Thanks for uploading this great movie.
I honestly love how he’s matured along with his roles. As he was younger he was a goofball and then had serious roles later in life. I will always love his goofball-ness but damn his mature stages were 🤌🏻 eye candy
This film is highly unusual, and it is also highly prophetic about the medical profession. The play, the script, the direction, Cray Grant and others are exceptional. Nobody will ever be able to make a remake of it.
What a beautiful film.....compassion.......something today's films seem to lack. Some people have a charisma, not many, but some have a light when they walk into a room, not necessarily looks but the sound of their voice, personality, a light within.
A delightful film and so right about the role of a doctor who must above all be a real human being, listen to his patients and give them the will to get better by behaving towards them as if they existed as persons and not only as symptoms. We rely too much nowadays on tests, analyses, pills and shots... And Cary Grant is always so charming !
This movie is a favorite of mine. Both the protagonist and the antagonist parts were played with real gusto. Grant was the heroic dedicated doctor and Cronyn was the dedicated villen the interaction was well done.
I am part German and thanks for the info. Carey Grant was a gentleman and a good actor for his time. Plus very attractive. I like this movie very much.
Perhaps one of the characteristics of a great movie is whether it can still stand over time - which , for me , this movie represents such. it seems a light comedy but has certain circumstances and dialogue which make it much more . For instance , I loved the part after the train wreck incident Deborah is crying - " ...I put all those candles on your cake and you're really only 9 years old" - very funny!! Yet, the comment of Mr. Shaughnessy to the professor , who instigated the "trial " , ( You're a little man...} was priceless.... and touchingly loyal to Dr. Pretorius. Cary Grant and Jeanne Crain were great, as usual - in fact the whole cast did a great job to make this movie very entertaining. Thank you
So well written and beautifully acted. One of my favorite movies. Cary Grant and Jeanne Crain had great chemistry. Hume Cronin makes a marvelous villain.
This is one of my favorite Cary Grant movies! I have watched it so many times, and my favorite part is the joy he shows when conducting the concert. Every time I hear that piece played, I picture him conducting it! Tears of joy at the end!
Same for me! He really looks like he’s really enjoying singing a few lines & conducting here! I can tell he studied a bit from when he was conducting the Mitchell boy’s choir in The Bishop’s Wife.
Thank you! This is a favorite movie of mine. It's rare to see it. This is quite unique. Cary Grant plays a doctor who is frankly ahead of his day, practicing holistic medicine. Our American doctors have become even worse than they were back in this movie, with MacDonald's fast food medicine 15 minute in/out, impersonal HMO medicine. The profession has devolved. American medical profession is devoid of soul. Doctors gripe about being rushed and not making enough money. Nobody put a gun to their heads to force them into this line of work. They need to care about individuals, and they need to have heart and compassion. They also need to stop investing in Big Pharma on the side. Our physicians were complicit with Big Pharma and pushed opioids on their patients without shame. Bring back humanity to American medicine.
There still actually are physicians who care for rhe whole person and give them the time needed. I worked for one who spent one day each week in a very poor, rural community. He wasn't Christian, but he'd say that his pro bono cases out there were "AFJ," all for jesus. I discovered he made actual house calls one day in our city, for a fragile older lady with no social support system.
An unusual, thoughtful film. Cary Grant is always a joy to watch, so good looking too. Noah's style of empathic medicine has rather been lost to us now, so the film is quite prophetic in that regard. Much of the film could be called light comedy, but it is quite philosophical too and would have seemed unusual in its day and thought-provoking.
Jeanne Craine was really good at playing characters in movies that dealt with socially taboo topics. Underrated actress. Interesting movie. Love Cary Grant!
This movie is a little gem. It is a film that has stuck with me all through the years. Thanks for posting what has become one of my favorites not just for Grant and Crane, but all those great character actors that appear in it.
Love this movie every time I see it. Got something else out of it this time. Nothing new under the sun. All doctors, et al, should have this perspective. It's not about business, but all about the patient and getting him/her well. Bravo!
💝it’s true, only love, compassion and and an understanding with intent of bringing up a another person energy can heal. The rest are placebo effects, as we know now but are still trying to be rid of that programme we was taught growing up. We are our own medicine and we can share with each other to heal everything, this is coming back into fruition 🙏🏻
Most of todays illness are caused by an emotional struggle. It could be tiny, we then have physical symptoms of the cause. Tablets can’t cure this, they may help ease the situation but we must look at the cause rather than just treating the symptoms 💗
Superb film. I've watched it a number of times. And I'll watch it a number of times again. Cary Grant is just great in this film as he is in every film.
This film has heart, humanity wonderful acting and an amazing script by Joe Mankiewicz. It must have seemed so revolutionary for its time. I can't help but marvel about the amazing production values particularly the Frank Lloyd inspired clinic setting so modern and elegant. Building and medical care in perfect harmony with nature. A beautiful work.
As the wife of a retired Family Doctor, this movie reminded me of the times my husband fought insurance companies and bureaucracies on behalf of his patients. Also, the times he missed school plays or recitals because he was holding a patient’s hand while delivering bad news or watching them pass. People don’t understand how much of their patients doctors carry with them, day after day, year after year. The secrets and fears they shared with him are with him even now. Most folks leave the office and don’t give it another thought until they return in the morning. Doctors don’t have that luxury. Their patients become part of them. Their lives are forever inextricably intertwined. Their pain, his pain. Their fears, his fears. Their secrets, his secrets. Even though he now suffers from dementia, I’ll make sure he watches this movie later today. I know it will bring him joy.
Hello Nancy I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it❤
May God bless you both. And thank you both. For your humanity 💙✌️🙏🕊️
I am sure his patients all rose up and called him blessed, for such a doctor is worth his weight in gold.
God bless you both.
He must have been a wonderful doctor, a rare to find. And, you are such an understanding wife. Its not easy to be the spouse of a good, sincere, caring doctor. You sure are one. My prayers for both of you.
This movie and it's messages about health care (and overly sterilized food) are even more relevant today than when it was made. Great movie.
EXACTLY
And hilariously Grants prediction came true. Doctors today ARE electronic. you go to your GP, they input your symptoms into a computer and the computer spits out what you may have and what tests you should be given
Say what you will about the credits of famous actresses. Margaret Hamilton earned hers with her portrayal of the witch in The Wizard of Oz, overshadowed of course by Judy Garland. However, Ms. Hamilton in this movie, professes the highest example of an entertainer that I have EVER witnessed in Hollywood's history!
She has, thru these many years, so underestimated, that she truly belongs among the greatest!!!
May she rest in peace as she has left an indelible mark in Hollywood!!!
Thanks for sharing this reply with me. I hope you will agree with this very late assessment of an
icon that shall remain in memory forever!!
@@AnnoyedNoodles-fb8hw Really liked her in 13 Ghosts. As a kid, actually saw her in that before I saw her in Wizard Of Oz.
Beautiful ❤️
Cary Grant...the one and only...the more he matured the better he became...in all respects! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yea, and he was a wife- basher! Ladies, keep your phantasies .
@@gabrielleaumont3971
That is a lie, and you are a disgusting excuse for a human being.'
I'm reporting this,
please--Cary Grant always played Cary Grant, even to the same suits...
Slezak was great here
You Tube has made it possible to easily view hundreds of great old classic films that we would never have know about.
Tubi is a good streaming channel for classic movies also.
YES IT HAS!
Love Carry an Jennie
Plus if you did know who plays them for no cost?! My favorite An Affair to Remember. The best part is when the little boy says m, “Everyone is talking about you” Carey Grants says well who? He said, “I don’t know every time I go in they leave”!😂 something like that. So when we get together that’s our inside joke about gossipers😂
Ronan holiday was lovely to ❤@@voniquej
more than 70 years and still a masterpiece
Thats why them are masterpieces.
@@kristineberegsari THAT'S WHY THEY ARE MASTERPIECES!😊
A very Very clever Script & immaculate performance, from all players! 😊
@@kristineberegsari Yes.
This film, so ahead of its time. Consider the historical era, and the other films being produced.
Hello I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤?
a movie about heart, courage & integrity, things without which mankind will cease to exist
Cloverlodge938....you took the words out of my mouth!
"Shunderson" delivers one of the finest closings to a most excellent soliloquoy - his Death then Life Story followed by "You're a little man." What a grand script this was.
Wasn’t that spectacular?!!!
I've not seen this movie before. I'm sick in bed and watched it on my phone. What a heartwarming story and example of compassion and loyalty.
He’s been loyal for years. Screw everything else.
He felt genuine love for his patient but that wasn’t enough.
He’s dying.
here’s to praying you are better…..❤️🙏
I pray that you are feeling better in Jesus' name. AMEN.
Get Well soon. Aloha from Hawaii. Oh, Happy New Year🌺🙏🏾✝️🎺
@@ladennayoung2939 Beautiful prayer!!🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾✝️🌺✈️Maranatha✈️
I worked with a Family Physician for many years as a nurse. He was also my physician. I remember patients who were elderly or people who had no insurance bringing in skinned chickens and rabbits to pay on their bill. He always accepted it as payment.
Fabulous
Reminds of the movie "Doc Hollywood" w/Michael J. Fox
He must have been a wonderful, loving Doctor
Hey nothing wrong with fresh produce. I say thats a better trade❤
Cary Grant never disappoints
Exactly!
That’s true.
He is miscast in this film because few can see Cary Grant as a medical doctor and professor. He cannot act the part.
@@jean6872I don't totally agree with you. He is very good actor.
He was able to play whoever, whatever.I love him the best of actor.
@@jean6872
He is perfect.
That movie deserves a standing ovation. Bravo!❤
👌👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
A story that wouldn't ever come out of Hollywood now. Beautiful story of life being respected.
Cynical balderdash! Sure it could.
♥️🙏🏼
Also a story of all kinds of boundary and ethical issues between doctor and patient, lol
Hello I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤
@@cynthiaennis3107❤❤
" You over estimate both of us!" One of the funniest lines EVER!
I have to admit that it's taken me a certain age to appreciate a well written script..It's true , we work hard..we're tired whether we know it or not...we plant ourselves in front of the idiot tube and if there's enough action or noise or sexual innuendos...we accept that we've seen something good..This film we've just watched together, wherever we are, was Extremely well written, extremely well played and worth it's title of a Hollywood made film...Thank you for the upload...
Very satisfying comment.
Lovely write up by you
Such a wonderful movie and the writers of the script hit the nail on the head when talking of how doctors would devolve into electronic healers with no personal interest in the patient. 😢
They are that NOW 😬
I made a note of that electronic doctor comment! so poignant for our times!
My doctors are great. They face me and we have a conversation, they listen and never look at their watches. I think we had a couple of "better living through science!" generations, but that trend has definitely started to fade out, thank God.
@@carbine090909 My doctors are great too. Its just that for certain ones, my GP for instance, he sold his practice to a big corporation like so many doctors are being forced to do today because of all the paperwork both government and insurance. He is still excellent. Its GETTING to him that's the problem
You deal with staff who are not medically minded but corporate minded and never bear in mind they are dealing with sick people. They max out the appointments for profit so if you have an emergent need, you cannot get in. Case in point. I caught a breakthrough case of Covid last week. I have numerous preexisting conditions so I called my GP. The ignorant corporate staff member said 'if you have Covid they DO recommended you come in and be seen. The next available is January 23rd!' I said 'my good woman, one of TWO things will happen by then. I will either be better, or I will be dead!' She then said 'then we recommended you go to the emergency room.' I said 'so instead of spending fifteen dollars for a copay for my doctor, I can spend three hundred dollars in deductibles for the emergency room to get the exact same advice. Lovely.'
A very high moment in the film to me especially bc it’s what we are experiencing now, 2022, before & after. Are going to continue to repeating ourselves forever?
This movie has been on my favorites list since the first time I saw it many years ago - it has Cary Grant who never gave a poor performance in his entire career and has a messagefor all to heed ..... Love thy fellow man
Watch “The Bishop’s Wife.” You’ll love it, especially this time of year.
🧡
He was so versatile and great in every genre - it's insane that he never won an Oscar.
There is a different message in this film. It is more about forgiving your neighbors, especially for Germans after WWII.
I can see yoiur message and will ADD it to my take
They don't make movies like these anymore...what a masterpiece
Technology dominates today. No talent. No better stories to inspire all family members.
And oddly, it was not well received when it came out! I really think this is a fine movie!
Seems movies of this era, heavily relied on the dialogue and how the dialogue was presented, not action, and this dialogue, to me, seems to make them timeless and entertaining! I suspect the reliance on dialogue was inherited from the stage, where the scope for action is limited.
@@keithad6485i agree they couldn't flash breasts so they had to have a plot ❤ i love all the old films.
I love anime
I love science fiction.
They are all wonderful genre's
Geniuses at work
The plot,the characters,everything
Make me return to the Classics
Mr Shunderson's story is whipped cream on this great story.
It is! Great way to put it.
Based on the German play by Curt Goetz, which was made into a movie in Germany (Doktor med. Hiob Prätorius, 1950). I didn't know until today that there was a film version with Cary Grant and only knew the German film version. I am very happy to be able to see this wonderful version now.
Didn't know this either.
And I never knew it was based on a German play!
Anything written by Joseph L. Mankiewicz is a pure delight. I can't believe I can watch this here free! All About Eve and A Letter to Three Wives are two similar films with sophisticated dialogue like in this gem. In any film written by Mankiewicz, a character will mention "Wilkes-Barre," an homage to the Pennsylvania city where he was born.
Actually this movie is based on a play by Curt Goetz and the play had a far better ending and also the Cary Grant movie has a very goog beginning, the one of Goetz is even better, in the Goetz version Praetorios and his wife die in a car accident (and yes, Curt Goetz can make even this funny in a nonoffensive way!), Too bad Grant did not another Goetz movie, one of his other plays "Hokuspokus" is even better.
Oh my gosh, I was leaving this comment to thank you for educating us about Mankiewicz. Then you mention Wilkes-Barre PA I was born and raised in Wilkes-Barre. There was a time in Wilkes-Barre’s history where it was wonderful to live there. I loved growing up in that old town. There were a lot of kind people. I have the sweetest memories of adults (strangers actually) being kind to me. When I was around five years old. I would get the bus at the corner where the firehouse was. And I remember there was this one man and he used to hold me up in his arms and we would watch out the window for the bus to come so I wouldn’t have to be outside cold all by myself. What a sweet man! My father wasn’t around & that man made me feel so special. It was loving and innocent and pure. It’s sad to think today that the same situation. they’d be so worried about the guy being a perv. Sadly you do need to be that way, so super careful, but I believe because of the way I am that there are still some good kind adults that love children and it’s natural for them to be loving and kind to kids in general.
Thank you so much for your post !
Hope you have a merry Christmas ! 🎄
Yes, didn't know about the " Wilkes-Barre connection. Thanks V
Thank you for indicating where I can find more of this man’s work!
Classic b & w movies use to be aired for free on regular TV on Saturday and Sunday nights by Frank Avruch The Great Entertainment that show ran for almost 2 decades on Boston's WCVB-TV, channel 5. we also had the Movie Loft channel WSBK-TV channel 38 and no extra loud shocking & unrelated interruptions like there is on yt.
LOVE me some Cary Grant! He is always SO classy, yet funny in his roles. Him along with William Powell were the BEST in their day! I miss actors of their character 😔
Jean Crain is so beautiful and her voice is so smooth! Love the message of this movie and I love their accidental, mistake-ridden, silly lovely love!
Fine fun film. Finlay Currie as "Mr. Shunderson" plays a phenomenal part and his story at the end is told so flat and direct with only the slightest embellishment that it should have been given a best supporting actor Oscar award. His parting words to Hume Cronyn as Prof. Rodney Elwell are so well said with both the strangest bit of grace and humility that I just can't describe how magnificent Elwell's well deserved comeuppance was given.
Margaret Brainard Hamilton, who plays Miss Pickett here, was best known for her portrayal of the Wicked Witch of the West, and her Kansas counterpart Almira Gulch, in Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer's film The Wizard of Oz (1939).
@@divalivingston1664 Thank you, I"m well aware of the many roles that Margaret Hamilton played, usually being typecast based on her looks.
@@divalivingston1664 We know...........
Also those Maxwell House coffee commercials back in the '70's.
Thanks. I thought I recognized her voice.
the bit after the 'trial' when Elwell almost goes through the door (presumably to the concert), then turns and walks away alone is one of the saddest moments in any film.
I love the scene where Dr. Praetorius (Noah) talks to that elderly sick lady who doesn't want to live any more. "So you'd rather lay around in a coffin all day, doing nothing?" 😄 Cary Grant was so funny!
En que minuto es la escena ?
Gary Grant wasn't funny. Script was written by someone you don't want to acknowledge. Someone who was funny. Grant only read his lines.
@@camouflageartist8897 You're clueless. Grant was known for having a quick wit and great comedic timing, so directors and producers frequently let him "enrich" the script with his ad libs. Stop blabbing ignorance.
@@tommy553013 I've tried posting the time stamp twice and it was deleted every time. Try 14 mins and 50 sec.
@@catherinelw9365 I have a great sense of humor too, better than Grant. Stop celebrating actors. They read from scripts written by people with imagination and talent. Also, don’t forget to acknowledge directors and directors of photography.
Ha very first character is the woman that plays the bad witch in the Wizard of Oz! What a great actress 😄👍
She was the housekeeper who stole from him in his story later...it explained her sneaky behavior. Great actress ...
Margaret Hamilton is her name. I was lucky enough to see her summer home one day day in Southport Maine, she lived near my mother in law.
I knew when I saw that first scene that we were in for a good movie!
It's very oddly directed. The characters act out of character.
@@cheryldevine42 how cool that is!
One of my favorite of Cary Grants movies I’ll watch over and over again. Thanks.
All the character actors were marvellous ! Can’t make movies like this again. Such a shame.
At least we can look back on them with joy.
There is no more elegant actor, character, or man than Cary Grant. They certainly don't make men like him any more... he is pure magic! I am, have always been, and always will be completely smitten. 💜💜💜
Johnny Depp
Johnny the GOAT GREATEST OF ALL TIME
Jean crane was a beauty a good Catholic and many children
Cary Grant was brilliant
What a remarkable movie! Perhaps the most obscure movie ever, and decades ahead of its time. No wonder it's been lost to cinematic history - the people of that day probably couldn't make heads or tales of it. I've never enountered a denser and more thoughtful script. So much food for thought here!!!
I absolutely adore this movie. I watch it a few times a year. Brilliant actors, all-star cast, wonderful Americana feels, and many worthy life lessons make this a classic winner. 👏
SO DO I 😊
3:46 f@@jeanbaumgartner4052
I watched it for the first time last year around Christmas and here I am again! Love it 💖
We had never heard of this fabulous movie before - much less seen it. We were 4 years old when it was made. We came across it now quite by accident. Thank you for preserving this wonderful study of human nature and allowing it to be seen and enjoyed.
Cary Grant is a natural when humor is around. Even a serious film like North By Northwest could not deny a witty line "somebody call the police!" when he was lying on a police station bench in drunken stupor! Balu, india.
Thanks, same for me… ( born 1947), **interestingly, i do not think We have seen the Movie: Spouse a big CARY GRANT Fan…………
Same here James!
@@balasubramanian477 THAT WAS HILARIOUS 😂!🥳
@@opera93 I WAS BORN ON AUGUST 6TH 1960!I'VE REMEMBERED SEEN EVERY ONE OF CARY GRANT MOVIES 🎥 ON TV 📺 IN THE 1960S AND 1970S!
How come all the great movies were made before I was born?Superb acting here.Cary Grant at his usual best.The man is suave,handsome,extremely charming and funny.Beautiful movie.❤
Because there were higher standards and better writing in the past. No cgi no overt sexual themes no vulgar language. And better acting in my opinion. And Cary grant is just wonderful.
@@patricebetts6531 I "ll add this. No politically charged messaging in those days
@@bharatg8542 You’re absolutely correct!
Wow, what a story, what a movie, what acting 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🙏🏻❤
🌬☠🏴☠️
I love this movie from start to finish! They just don’t make movies like this anymore which is a shame! Really enjoyed! Thanks!
Superb movie with a brilliant and funny script - no one else could have played the part of dr pretorious better than Cary Grant. A natural born actor. Thanks for uploading this great movie.
By saying so, you are actually insulting an enormous number of other actors!
I'm disinclined to agree with the "no one else..." part.
I wouldn't go so far as to to say NO ONE else. But he IS one of the few who could pull it off!
@@haviskam Lol, oh p-lease!
Hello Sheila I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤
I honestly love how he’s matured along with his roles. As he was younger he was a goofball and then had serious roles later in life. I will always love his goofball-ness but damn his mature stages were 🤌🏻 eye candy
♥️🥰♥️
OOOOOHHHHH CARY GRANT IS SO DREAMY!🥰😍🤩😘😗☺️😚😙🥲😋😛🥳🥸😎🤓😮😯😲😳🥺😺😸😹😻😼😽💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💌💘💝💖💗💓💞💕🍦🍧🍨🍩🍪🎂🍰🧁🥧🍫🍬🍭🍯
What a fantastic movie indeed!! Carry Grant, debonair as ever, did a fantastic job together with the cast of great actors! Enjoy!!
I love the old classics, wherein movies were dedicated to certain groups of society, with words of encouragement and gratitude.
This film is highly unusual, and it is also highly prophetic about the medical profession. The play, the script, the direction, Cray Grant and others are exceptional. Nobody will ever be able to make a remake of it.
Most prophetic in the mention of automated or electronic doctoring ,with robotic surgery now in its infancy.
@@bobbythorman7421 That's right! I thought of the same the moment I read the message above.
@kuldipdhiman Nonetheless, since Hollywood is completely devoid of creativity, they will eventually work their way around to remaking this one.
😀 In deed
@@Inigo_The_Son i really don’t think they want to promote the idea of an alternative MD, unfortunately.
What a greatttt story......indeed our world is full of great man of integrity, dignity, honor and understanding,
What a beautiful film.....compassion.......something today's films seem to lack. Some people have a charisma, not many, but some have a light when they walk into a room, not necessarily looks but the sound of their voice, personality, a light within.
Cary Grant is The GOAT!
YES HE IS!!! ♥️ 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
So true
I love the main character of Dr. Praetorious for his compassion and nobility in the true sense.
Wonderful film, not at all what I thought it was about and doesn't matter that it's in black and white. One of my new favourites.🥰
It really is! I love the Black & White film! 😊
A delightful film and so right about the role of a doctor who must above all be a real human being, listen to his patients and give them the will to get better by behaving towards them as if they existed as persons and not only as symptoms. We rely too much nowadays on tests, analyses, pills and shots... And Cary Grant is always so charming !
Truly!
DR😷 CARY GRANT!🤤😊🥰😍🤩😏😺😸😹😻😼😽
"Your a little man and now your even smaller than before " great movie line.... very good and unusual movie for its time.
Loved the calm and on-point dressing down that Shunderson gave Elwell at the end. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This movie is a favorite of mine. Both the protagonist and the antagonist parts were played
with real gusto. Grant was the heroic dedicated doctor and Cronyn was the dedicated villen
the interaction was well done.
I am part German and thanks for the info. Carey Grant was a gentleman and a good actor for his time. Plus very attractive. I like this movie very much.
He was a good actor for any time, it just then. He's withstood the test of time. It was a combination of talent plus good choices of manuscripts.
Wow! What a great picture!
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
This is so unbelievably unique. I love old films and Cary Grant and had never heard of this.
The dialogue is superb! What a good movie and I love that mega train set.
A movie away ahead of his time ! Ι loved it with all my heart!
Sadly it didn’t show
OMGosh...Grrrr.. There is NO SUCH THING as ahead of it's time. If it is done or said now IT IS IT'S TIME.
@@j.p.bourget2045 REALLY!?🤔
of all the very good actors and actresses in this movie, my favourite is the dog he outplays them all and doesn't say a word brilliant
One of my favorite Cary Grants movies. The conversations are just elegant.
Back in the days when people - especially ladies - never used dirty words in public and took great care to speak as nicely as possible.
It’s one of mine, too! I LOVE this movie!
@@lindaatkinson3962 Hello I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤?
@@jerrypark236 - You certainly can !
@@lindaatkinson3962
Happiness is gone for awhile. Will it ever be recaptured?
IF IT IS
It will be a miracle
Perhaps one of the characteristics of a great movie is whether it can still stand over time - which , for me , this movie represents such.
it seems a light comedy but has certain circumstances and dialogue which make it much more . For instance , I loved the part after the train wreck incident Deborah is crying - " ...I put all those candles on your cake and you're really only 9 years old" - very funny!!
Yet, the comment of Mr. Shaughnessy to the professor , who instigated the "trial " , ( You're a little man...} was priceless.... and touchingly loyal to Dr. Pretorius. Cary Grant and Jeanne Crain were great, as usual - in fact the whole cast did a great job to make this movie very entertaining. Thank you
"Beep beep! 😠"
"Beep beep beep! 😠"
"Beep 😠"
It had such range into the particularity of the characters.
Hello Sandra I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤
Stand still over time (your comment)
One definition of REGENERATION is
(Restored to a state better than the original state)
Claimed
Outstanding. It is a shame that there are no movies being made today of such quality.
One of my favorites… I love this story!
Hello Jane I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤?
I have always loved this movie. It is a movie that taught me as a child that things are never as they appear, and to alway question authority.
Doctors don’t take the time to understand their patients.
Very sad
Very good. Very curious, charming and life trusting film.
❤❤
So well written and beautifully acted. One of my favorite movies. Cary Grant and Jeanne Crain had great chemistry. Hume Cronin makes a marvelous villain.
Love Cary Grant and this is my one of my favourite of his movies, thank you for sharing.
One of my favorite Cary Grant movies, also!
I love this movie!!! One of Cary Grant's best movies!!!
Plus jean Crain ❤💃🏼🚀
I do too! One of his best, for sure! ♥️
@@cynthiaennis3107 I can't understand why I have never heard of it, I had better watch it.
Utterly superb film,had never seen this one. Left my heart soaring 🥰
What a remarkable movie! Kindness and compassion so important for life.
My how times have fortunately changed!
Still love Grant.
Lol, you think so?
Fortunately??
@@whiterabbit6341
Thinking the rabbit died
Just fabulous! Thank you…❤
Love this movie! Probably have watched it 100 times over the years!! ❤
This is one of my favorite Cary Grant movies! I have watched it so many times, and my favorite part is the joy he shows when conducting the concert. Every time I hear that piece played, I picture him conducting it! Tears of joy at the end!
Same for me! He really looks like he’s really enjoying singing a few lines & conducting here! I can tell he studied a bit from when he was conducting the Mitchell boy’s choir in The Bishop’s Wife.
Thank you for making this wonderful film available. A beautiful and moving film. So glad I found it.
Thank you!
This is a favorite movie of mine. It's rare to see it. This is quite unique. Cary Grant plays a doctor who is frankly ahead of his day, practicing holistic medicine. Our American doctors have become even worse than they were back in this movie, with MacDonald's fast food medicine 15 minute in/out, impersonal HMO medicine. The profession has devolved. American medical profession is devoid of soul. Doctors gripe about being rushed and not making enough money. Nobody put a gun to their heads to force them into this line of work. They need to care about individuals, and they need to have heart and compassion. They also need to stop investing in Big Pharma on the side. Our physicians were complicit with Big Pharma and pushed opioids on their patients without shame. Bring back humanity to American medicine.
There still actually are physicians who care for rhe whole person and give them the time needed. I worked for one who spent one day each week in a very poor, rural community. He wasn't Christian, but he'd say that his pro bono cases out there were "AFJ," all for jesus. I discovered he made actual house calls one day in our city, for a fragile older lady with no social support system.
We are blessed with our family Dr. he takes his time with us and he really does listen. Also he’s very caring. I wish more Dr’s were like this
An unusual, thoughtful film. Cary Grant is always a joy to watch, so good looking too. Noah's style of empathic medicine has rather been lost to us now, so the film is quite prophetic in that regard. Much of the film could be called light comedy, but it is quite philosophical too and would have seemed unusual in its day and thought-provoking.
I disagree. In its day, it was a big hit.
@@elainedaprano9130 IT STILL IS!😂😅
Jeanne Craine was really good at playing characters in movies that dealt with socially taboo topics. Underrated actress. Interesting movie. Love Cary Grant!
This movie is a little gem. It is a film that has stuck with me all through the years. Thanks for posting what has become one of my favorites not just for Grant and Crane, but all those great character actors that appear in it.
Excellent!! Excellent!!❤❤❤❤❤
Love these classic clean movies! No cussing, violence nor nudity!
Can we have films made like this in this day and age!!! It's fantastic
What an amazing movie!! I miss these types of actors!!
A deeply beautiful film of how unique talent & compassion can engender envy & enemies; while doing great good .
1:25:30 to 1:26. That close up with the accompanying dialogue. Talented professionals at their best. Love it!!
Love this movie every time I see it. Got something else out of it this time. Nothing new under the sun. All doctors, et al, should have this perspective. It's not about business, but all about the patient and getting him/her well. Bravo!
I love this movie. I think it is one of his finest.
I’ve become Un Doctored. No doctor of today can heal me of any dis ease.
Dr Noah is the epitome of love for humanity.
Look out for a British film "My Brother Jonathan" also about a doctor. Wonderful film.
@ Τhanks. Happy New Year. 🥳
@ Can’t find the complete movie. Hope it will be posted eventually.
💝it’s true, only love, compassion and and an understanding with intent of bringing up a another person energy can heal. The rest are placebo effects, as we know now but are still trying to be rid of that programme we was taught growing up. We are our own medicine and we can share with each other to heal everything, this is coming back into fruition 🙏🏻
Most of todays illness are caused by an emotional struggle. It could be tiny, we then have physical symptoms of the cause. Tablets can’t cure this, they may help ease the situation but we must look at the cause rather than just treating the symptoms 💗
Thank you for sharing this. 💗
Happy St. Patrick's Day Red.
5 minutes in and I love it. Born in 57.. I thought oh well..
Thank you, for this wonderful movie, and all these truly meaningful masterpieces of the past -- that you show and share with all of us!!! ❤
What a great story !
Such a delight to watch this ! What a class. Beautiful and respectful.
What a wonderful film.
Superb film. I've watched it a number of times. And I'll watch it a number of times again. Cary Grant is just great in this film as he is in every film.
What a beautiful movie, thank you.
This film has heart, humanity wonderful acting and an amazing script by Joe Mankiewicz. It must have seemed so revolutionary for its time. I can't help but marvel about the amazing production values particularly the Frank Lloyd inspired clinic setting so modern and elegant. Building and medical care in perfect harmony with nature. A beautiful work.
This is a heartwarming movie and the actors were superb. Thank you for sharing it with us. 🌹
Hello Catherine I see happiness all around you, can I please share from it ❤?
This is one of my favorite Cary Grant movies!
Best movie I have ever seen in a long time!
I thought I had seen all of Cary Grant's movies, what a delightful discovery!!
A fantastic film. Four stars and more!!!!!❤️🙌❤️
What a great heartwarming film
One of my favorite movies of Cary grants. He is such a wonderful actor in does such a great job.
Seeing this for the first time (I am 66) it`s was good, better than 85% of what I see in the last few decades.