This is an amazing song - Yes I have heard it through David Gilmour but whoever wrote this lyric is a genius .. and the music is fantastic .. great stuff.
Thank you David Gilmour for making me discover this song. Romany's version is amazing. But this, this is a masterpiece, lyrics so honest and truthful. Roger's singing really sends shivers thru your body. I truly identify with these lyrics... EDIT: Just found out he passed away... now i'm even more depressed. RIP🙁
So cool when some musical piece long overlooked and buried is revived in later days. Hopefully Roger is looking down and smiling, knowing his music is ringing through the ears of many today. RIP to someone who died way to young.
25 дней назад+19
Such a beautiful song. I play it over and over and over. Thank you M Bros for this and thank you to Gilmour and daughter for bringing it back.
Broke an early promise Put trust in an unknown Fell headlong into the arms Of the first that stood me Unsteadied a steady heart That took me to a place I've never been A place I've never been since Stopped hoping at an early age Stopped guessing at an early age Start accepting things from day one And then things can’t go too wrong Just let them walk all over you Laugh through the punches and the pain Let the lifeblood drain away from you They're right you're wrong And you can see it in the way they look at you Feel it in the way they treat you Always the last to know Always the first to leave And when sky begins to fall The blame all along you knew was yours Wakes you with a fever at five Your guardian angel gives up the ghost And you can see it in the way they look at you Feel it in the way they treat you Always the last to know Always the first to leave Just let them walk all over you Laugh through the punches and the pain Let the lifeblood drain away from you They're right you're wrong
Very nice. Not familiar with this material until now. I read that David Gilmour is doing a cover of this song for his new album! Sounds reminiscent of some of Steven Wilson's solo stuff.
Like it, nice song shame Roger Quigley has died, I thought that's what DG said in an interview somewhere, great cover from the Gilmours the song deserves to be heard 😊
The Gilmour tour rehearsal version appeared on my RUclips yesterday and I was blown away by it. Then found out it was a cover so ended up here. What a beautiful song! Can't believe this has been around for 25 years and I never heard it before. Better late than never, huh?
Je ne connaissais pas la version originale... je suis sur les fesses ! J'aime autant l'ancienne version que celle de David et Romany Gilmour. Quel sacré roublard...
assolutamente meravigliosa....... grazie a Gilmour per avermela fatta conoscere..... entrambe le versioni sono stupende ed e' davvero difficile, se non impossibile, definire quale sia migliore. Siamo quindi grati e felici che esistano entrambe e godiamone, e' un dono del cielo!
David Gilmour covering this is already giving me more hope for the album. His daughter who will be performing on it has a nice voice as evidenced by Yes I Have Ghosts which will be on the CD and surround sound editions of Luck and Strange
Came here from Gilmore's channel , cause some geezer said this was better . I'd say both have their place , this guy here isn't a terribly strong singer as I like to be honest but an original has some value by virtue .
![David Gilmour - Vita Brevis/ Between Two Points [Live From Circo Massimo, Roma🇮🇹 (27/09/2024)]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ViyaL40LdCA/mqdefault.jpg)
![David Gilmour - Vita Brevis/ Between Two Points [Live From Circo Massimo, Roma🇮🇹 (27/09/2024)]](/img/tr.png)
I'm here for Gilmour
Same
Me Too 🙋♂(Brasileiro é Brasileiro rssrs).
I can definitely imagine what Gilmour's voice and guitar on this would be. Can't wait til Sept 6!
Same . Looking forward to it..
Beat me to it.
Thanks to David and Romany for making me discover this beautiful melody... both interpretations are distant but also very close...Thank You
I understand why Gilmour choose this
yeah the awful lyrics and rhyming fit his style
Because it's a beautiful song
I love both versions.
🌹
Yeah really, wow.
Romany & her papa brought me here. Maybe going headlong down this rabbit hole.
Agreed..also before a million covers come out..from penny whistles to the spoons..!
Yep me to!
And me!
Same here. Also a great version.
This song must live on. Thank you Gilmour and Romany for bringing it back from oblivion!
@@hugoalarcon4215 lol
A great song is a great song - so thanks to DG I'm going to explore more by this band
I too
This is an amazing song - Yes I have heard it through David Gilmour but whoever wrote this lyric is a genius .. and the music is fantastic .. great stuff.
Thanks David Gilmour I'm here for you...!!!
Thank you David Gilmour for making me discover this song.
Romany's version is amazing. But this, this is a masterpiece, lyrics so honest and truthful.
Roger's singing really sends shivers thru your body.
I truly identify with these lyrics...
EDIT: Just found out he passed away... now i'm even more depressed.
RIP🙁
Wow..beautiful song..cant wait for david gilmours version
ruclips.net/video/hCQcKUtg9kc/видео.htmlsi=2dyYPpUVs1jSX-Tq
It is out now....
I've probably listened to Gilmours' over half a dozen times today. This one? Over a dozen. It really takes me down. Almost hypnotic.
Just had to hear the original, indeed a beautiful song. Romany Gilmour honors it magnificently
Got this when it 1st dropped time to rediscover it now
David version is superbe, but original is a masterpiece.
So cool when some musical piece long overlooked and buried is revived in later days. Hopefully Roger is looking down and smiling, knowing his music is ringing through the ears of many today. RIP to someone who died way to young.
Such a beautiful song. I play it over and over and over. Thank you M Bros for this and thank you to Gilmour and daughter for bringing it back.
Me too.
Never heard this. Never heard of them. Thanks to David I'm here now.... Shazamed. NOW IT'S MINE!!! Thanks
Came here due to Romany and David but mesmerized
I never heard this song..its beautiful..and thanks to Gilmour and daughter I really liked it..well done to this band.
I found out today that Gilmour's version was a cover. I love the cover, and I also love the original!
I like Gilmour, but this version is better.
Me too
RIP Roger Quigley.
💔
Grande perda... RIP😢
6 minutes is nowhere near long enough...
6 minutes for life
This band is fantastic and i never heard of them.Thanks Dave.
Broke an early promise
Put trust in an unknown
Fell headlong into the arms
Of the first that stood me
Unsteadied a steady heart
That took me to a place I've never been
A place I've never been since
Stopped hoping at an early age
Stopped guessing at an early age
Start accepting things from day one
And then things can’t go too wrong
Just let them walk all over you
Laugh through the punches and the pain
Let the lifeblood drain away from you
They're right you're wrong
And you can see it in the way they look at you
Feel it in the way they treat you
Always the last to know
Always the first to leave
And when sky begins to fall
The blame all along you knew was yours
Wakes you with a fever at five
Your guardian angel gives up the ghost
And you can see it in the way they look at you
Feel it in the way they treat you
Always the last to know
Always the first to leave
Just let them walk all over you
Laugh through the punches and the pain
Let the lifeblood drain away from you
They're right you're wrong
The first that stirred me. *
"Theyre Right, youre Wrong" -- terrifyingly true esp since covid ppl waking up slow
@@helenquigley6726❤
is that the lyrics?
Thank you Gilmor for give me the chance to find this masterpiece
Here for Montgolfier Brothers.❤️
Me too, since 1999
This is a Gilmour thing, please find other places.
@@123provawhy?
@@123prova don't understand your point of view. This is a Montgolfier Brothers' original song
@@Pigmento-Music sorry for the confusion, I did my checks and you guys are right
Can’t tell you how many times I played this those summer nights. Beautiful.
At last the world is awakening to the genius of Mark Tranmer and the late, great Quigley AKA GNAC / The Montgolfier Brothers
one of my all time favourite bands
Very nice. Not familiar with this material until now. I read that David Gilmour is doing a cover of this song for his new album! Sounds reminiscent of some of Steven Wilson's solo stuff.
I came for the same reason
Had same thought
Great song! Just heard it for the first time! Thanks to Gilmour!
also I for david but this song is very very nice...I go see david for my 3 times...milano 24 and 25 march of 2006 and roma in 28 sectember 2024...
The saddest stories ever told. Brilliance!!
Yes, but somehow they keep calling you back, over the years...
Not taking anything from the brilliance of this one, but the saddest song is Steven Wilson’s Routine… magnificent song 🤘
Like it, nice song shame Roger Quigley has died, I thought that's what DG said in an interview somewhere, great cover from the Gilmours the song deserves to be heard 😊
D. GILMOUR supported his daughter with only his guitar contributing a voice. She deserved the spotlight.
Wonderful hypnotic melody , true words of true Life . Love
The Gilmour tour rehearsal version appeared on my RUclips yesterday and I was blown away by it. Then found out it was a cover so ended up here. What a beautiful song! Can't believe this has been around for 25 years and I never heard it before. Better late than never, huh?
Gilmour brought me…
Seems like I read Gilmour’s daughter will sing it. I like this song.
It's out today.....she does.....and NAILS it!!
Please try Roger Quigley's solo "In bed with your best friend" from Album "At swim two birds".
this is the better one...the original !
Three words...pure poetry...between two points...
Romany nadałaś tchnienie, życie na nowo. Wskrzesiłaś z zapomnianych utworów.
Had to check the original after hearing David Gilmour version....both are excellent
Had to find this original track to see what Romney and David remade. Both are well done. I like both versions.
Thank David
and
Thank You
Non conoscevo questo capolavoro. Grazie ai Gilmour❤❤❤
This original version is good, but I much prefer the Romany version. Especially the rehearsal video. It’s so nice.
Je ne connaissais pas la version originale... je suis sur les fesses !
J'aime autant l'ancienne version que celle de David et Romany Gilmour.
Quel sacré roublard...
Moi aussi… brilliant Song
Thanks David Gilmour, I'm here for you...!!!
I'm here for the Montgolfier brothers (after Gilmour's cover, admittedely )
I thought she wrote it...😮...oh well...the gilmours did magnifiscent job....
Vine por David Gilmour, esto va hacer la locura espacial 😮. Espero ansioso !!!
Romany did great. Happy Dad gave this to her to sing.
So sad that Roger is no longer with us lovely man shared a few drinks with him at the new Oxford in Salford before he passed …
....perfection....
Wow... Both versions are amazing!!
Cool! A new band to check out. Great song admittedly discovered through the brilliant cover. Let the journey begin!
A nice song. It has a very somber vibe. Palpable.
Sound like David could of wrote this but Gilmour made it their own with Romany singing. Great tune.
Would be interesting if Tears for Fears would cover this song.
A very sad song, and very beautiful.
Fell headlong....
credit due these guys, haunting song, love both versions
My favourite album, ever...
Here from Gilmour's solo record. Nice song.
Bellissima questa versione originale ❤
What a great find - thanks Mr Gilmour !
Found the original. Gilmour said he had been a fan of the song since 1999. I'm not sure I have heard this song before the cover.
'...feel it in the way they treat you...'
No-one else ever sounded like this...
Yes, Romany Gilmour does
Very special song
Hadn't heard of this band before David Gilmour announced he's covering this song! Looking forward to it
Too bad, listen to the entire Montgolfier album, it's memorable.
@@spycory1 I will check it out, I really dug this track!
assolutamente meravigliosa....... grazie a Gilmour per avermela fatta conoscere..... entrambe le versioni sono stupende ed e' davvero difficile, se non impossibile, definire quale sia migliore. Siamo quindi grati e felici che esistano entrambe e godiamone, e' un dono del cielo!
Beautiful song. Can’t wait to hear Romany singing this. I imagine David will be on vocals as well, I hope they trade off verses.
Out today. WOW!!!!
With all respect for the original , David's guitar gives a different perspective and depth
Realmente diferente porém ambas belas cada uma de sua forma.
I haven’t heard this song for so long. And David Gilmour and his Daughter Romany do a cover of it which is a gem.
Fuggin hell …. It’s bloody gorgeous !
Wow. What a track
Thanks David Gilmour.
Thanks Montgolfier Brothers😅
Very good song from Montgolfier Brothers ! 👍❤
Maybe with Gilmour version, these Montgolfier Brothers will rise higher by greater fame ? 😉
I'm here because David and Romany and their fantastic cover version. Such a great bridge over the generations - THX 2 ALL! 🙏
110% Beautiful.
I miss Roger Quigley. As great as underrated
💔
@@helenquigley1334 His music meant a lot to me
Amazing tune and expression. Thank you ..
Come back, Montgolfier Brothers....we need you...
♥️ Breathtaking Beautiful song....goosebumps♥️
Great song.The power of david brought me.
RIP Roger Quigley....so young. So much to say...
Almeno stavolta l'ispirazione non è stato il Jingle delle SNCF 😂😂. Complimenti a tutta la Gilmour Family ❤❤
Quigley
💔
David Gilmour covering this is already giving me more hope for the album. His daughter who will be performing on it has a nice voice as evidenced by Yes I Have Ghosts which will be on the CD and surround sound editions of Luck and Strange
L' originale è sempre l' originale... cmq bravi anche Gilmour e la figlia... però questa voce è stupefacente. 👍👍👍
Romany ha una voce meravigliosa
he is a real Pisces
Thanks David, for helping me discover the songwriters.
Thank you for writing this beautiful, touching song. Honoring the source! 😇
Here for Gilmour... and I discover a beautifoul band....ciao from Italy
David and Romany sent me.
Sound a lot like Marillion with Steve Hogarth.
Nah, a Steven Wilson track through and through
Thank you David. Thank you Romany. And, above all, thank you Roger.
Came here from Gilmore's channel , cause some geezer said this was better . I'd say both have their place , this guy here isn't a terribly strong singer as I like to be honest but an original has some value by virtue .
Just heard this on Floydian slip...amazing
One of the best bands from the late nineties/early noughts...
Didn't realize this had been covered. I'm loving this version (assuming this is the original. I was wrong before, and sadly, I'm not that smart)