@@gabindupuy6036 Yeah I started op10 n1. Its very simple but to play it at the speed require has to be hard.At least that it what iv heard from many people
@@greenapple306 I play all of those etudes, and I can tell you that there aren't absolutes here because all of that depends on the actual person and what their specific technique issues are. In my case, op 10 no 2 was harder for me than this etude, though not by much.
@@jukeban646 There is. Mainly in the left hand. Playing this peace is very funny, coz you may hear some harmonies which you won't see or hear just with youtube or cd. There is still a huge difference between hearing it on CD or playing it on the piano. Especially you hear some more Disharmonie
He captures the MOOD of nocturnal mystery in the remarkably good performance. I've always felt it was like sitting on a terrace in the moonlight watching lunar moths flit about while below a jeweled python writhes and curls itself -- almost lazily -- on the stones beneath. Although it requires the most highly developed technique this strange and wonderful work is not meant to be a display piec e for an incisively brilliant technique. It's essence is SUBTLE -- almost EERIE --, and Eric Liu capturs THAT better than anyone else I've ever heard -- and I've learnt it, myself, worked on it for decades, and heard HUNDREDS perform it wth ease and fluency, but THIS is very special. Eric Liu seems destned for greatness. He is a true ARTIST not merely a virtuoso. God bless you, Eric. I wish you much success and happiness.
If you play Chopin 25.6 then explain why he plays A natural in measure 7 in the trill. I play it too but that's not how the music is written. It's sharp.
Na ... if you've learned the figure once, you got them all. But of course it's very difficult. But nobody would say, that it's harder than Rachmaninoffs Piano concert, last set ;)
Mastery and beautiful music making! Also interesting that some very fine pianists at these Warsaw Chopin Competitions (Bozhanov, Osokins, Lu, Fedorova) are choosing Yamaha or Shigeru Kawai over Steinway.
WAAAAYYY better than Trifonov who can hardly play it despite all the comments praising him as a genius. Now this guy actually can play it very very well!!
Depends on what kind of hands you have but it's definetly considered top 4 and arguably top 3. Op10 no 2 Op10 no 1 this etude and Op 25 no 11 are considered the hardest.
@@em8714 Op.25 no. 11 is not as hard as you think. The other three are more mind blowing than that one. Op. 25 no. 11 otherwise referred as Winter Wind is personally comfortable to my fingers and is quite easy to play as a result.
1:15 I absolutely LOVE that left hand melody and how he exposes it through the right hand. Amazing!
His playing is insanely controlled might be one of the best performances of this etude because of how controlled his dynamics and tempo is
I think this is the most difficult piece among the whole Chopin's etudes.
op10n2 op10 n1 are harder
@@gabindupuy6036 Yeah I started op10 n1. Its very simple but to play it at the speed require has to be hard.At least that it what iv heard from many people
dunno why the hard. at is blue
@@greenapple306 I play all of those etudes, and I can tell you that there aren't absolutes here because all of that depends on the actual person and what their specific technique issues are. In my case, op 10 no 2 was harder for me than this etude, though not by much.
@@greenapple306 You must be joking. Youre literally comparing 345 chromatic and arpeggios, to double third trills.
This is by far one of the most accurate interpretations I have heard, It's like hearing Richter play the rachmaninoff in the late 1900s...
Trifinov’s was way better imo
와 어떻게 손가락이 저렇게 움직이지...볼때마다 놀랍다
So hard, but also one of the most beautiful pieces of Chopin
no it's not
@@jukeban646 It ist. It's 1 of the 100 most beautiful of Chopin ;)
@@hfor2419 a lot of People hate it because there is no melody
@@jukeban646 There is. Mainly in the left hand. Playing this peace is very funny, coz you may hear some harmonies which you won't see or hear just with youtube or cd. There is still a huge difference between hearing it on CD or playing it on the piano. Especially you hear some more Disharmonie
@@jukeban646 hate? Oops.
He captures the MOOD of nocturnal mystery in the remarkably good performance. I've always felt it was like sitting on a terrace in the moonlight watching lunar moths flit about while below a jeweled python writhes and curls itself -- almost lazily -- on the stones beneath. Although it requires the most highly developed technique this strange and wonderful work is not meant to be a display piec e for an incisively brilliant technique. It's essence is SUBTLE -- almost EERIE --, and Eric Liu capturs THAT better than anyone else I've ever heard -- and I've learnt it, myself, worked on it for decades, and heard HUNDREDS perform it wth ease and fluency, but THIS is very special. Eric Liu seems destned for greatness. He is a true ARTIST not merely a virtuoso. God bless you, Eric. I wish you much success and happiness.
Is this one nice?: ruclips.net/video/Q6OvxqJ6T6M/видео.html
If you play Chopin 25.6 then explain why he plays A natural in measure 7 in the trill. I play it too but that's not how the music is written. It's sharp.
Love the LH part at 1:12
One of the hardest pieces in music history, amazing!
kason cheese no
kason cheese yes
Na ... if you've learned the figure once, you got them all. But of course it's very difficult.
But nobody would say, that it's harder than Rachmaninoffs
Piano concert, last set ;)
Peter Berger OF COURSE it's difficult, why else would've I commented?
It is hard but is no match compared to Islamey
Outstanding, Eric! You leave me in the dust.
Luke you're the man
에뛰드 장인이시네요 얼마나 연습했을지 😭
Wonderful phrasing 😍
Beautiful.
Mastery and beautiful music making! Also interesting that some very fine pianists at these Warsaw Chopin Competitions (Bozhanov, Osokins, Lu, Fedorova) are choosing Yamaha or Shigeru Kawai over Steinway.
More than beautifully.
🌸🐦🌸🕊🌸💞
so beautiful... Chopin
Wow he's good
that was soooo clean
어쩜 이렇게 감미로운지 ..^^
WOW!!!!!!
류예린 amazing pianist!
WAAAAYYY better than Trifonov who can hardly play it despite all the comments praising him as a genius. Now this guy actually can play it very very well!!
Nice!
WOW - fantastic!
Hands down, hands down this is the most difficult chopin etude.
his left hand is so nice
1:15 amazing😆
What sound is so clear
에튀드는 에릭루가 젤 잘치는듯
I can’t play this etude.
This etude’s irregular moves destroy my fingers and brain.
0:50 kudos for not slowing down here
@@NatangxEducation ??
Nathaniel Tang epic
@@NatangxEducation epic get lost noah
Is this the best version ever?
Wow... massive hands with enormous amount of flexibility...
He is very tall so he definitely has nice big hands. Perfect for piano.
1:23 핑거링이 궁금한 부분
Perfect
Sounds like Rachmaninov, excellent interpretation btw
전생에 요조숙녀였을듯
Changhun Cho ㅌㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄴㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ미치겠닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이거 볼때마다 요조숙녀 생각나서 웃음이나와욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아직도 웃음나옴
나 이 댓글 본 이후로 에릭루만 보면 요조숙녀 생각나서 미치겠음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ이제 나한테 에릭루 = 요조숙녀임ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 어쩔거예요 책임져요.......................
WOW
Wow almost as great as John Browning's version
FIRST........
... to say THIS IS AWESOME.
It is the most difficult of chopin's etudes , right ?
Depends on what kind of hands you have but it's definetly considered top 4 and arguably top 3. Op10 no 2 Op10 no 1 this etude and Op 25 no 11 are considered the hardest.
@@em8714 Op.25 no. 11 is not as hard as you think. The other three are more mind blowing than that one. Op. 25 no. 11 otherwise referred as Winter Wind is personally comfortable to my fingers and is quite easy to play as a result.
1:37 it feels so awkward :/
Sur Ondes-Bleues ,le 10 avril 2023
개잘치는구만
Superb and comparable to Josef Lhevinne.
spotted
테크닉 미쳤다
저거 어캐한거임?
He had his revenge
와 써드를;
Daniil Trifonov does a pretty good interpretation too
피아노 위에 옥구슬 굴러간다~~~~~
제비는 조성진님
눈송이는 에릭루님
추격은 리시차님
인듯...
에릭루 햇빛연주도 기가막혀요 ㅜㅜ그거보다 여기까지 오게됨
저는
흑건은 케이트리우님
햇빛은 에릭루님
승리는 조성진님
이게 우승이 아니라고?
2015 쇼콩쿨 좀 전체적으로 다 잘한듯 ㄹㅇ
이 곡 자체는 너무 예쁜데 (살인적인 테크닉에 비해..)다른 화려한 곡들에 비해서 좀 덜 화려하게 들려서 그런건 아닐까요 ㅠㅠ
Why does he play A natural in measure 7 over and over in the trill??? That's not how it's written!
As for me, the really first is here: (from 16:30) ruclips.net/video/DMuN8qRpA-4/видео.html
Don't like this playing. He seems to think there are tremolos in the score.
You almost made me spill my drink. Lmao.
It sounds terrible on that yamaha piano, but it’s not the pianists fault.