I Paid 5 Logo Designers On Fiverr To Design The SAME Logo... 💰

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 158

  • @willpatersondesign
    @willpatersondesign  Год назад +21

    Hope you guys enjoyed the video! If you did here's another one you'd love: ruclips.net/video/VZ_dMl-vaUE/видео.html

    • @howk00006
      @howk00006 Год назад

      Please sir i want to show you my work

    • @punotomalf6408
      @punotomalf6408 Год назад

      I saw a comment on youtube saying "A logo isn't designed iconic. a logo is designed and 'becomes' iconic."
      what can you say about this?

  • @benjaminmordiconi4170
    @benjaminmordiconi4170 Год назад +126

    9:32 This logo looks the same as "Thomas Cook". He copied everything. The plane mockup is identical to the real Thomas Cook planes

    • @esochibuike8477
      @esochibuike8477 Год назад +29

      You're 100 percent right. I had to do a quick Google search and it was true. Even the mockups are original. This is why we should source logo designs from reputable designers. Imagine if JetSet was a real company and they had a similar logo from a collapsed airline. Won't be Good for the overall image of the airline and for the lawsuits too.

    • @sunders8784
      @sunders8784 Год назад +11

      Searching the comments to see if anyone else said this! Looks exactly the same.

    • @carlanaranja
      @carlanaranja Год назад +3

      Wow! True

    • @TheNaijaGosiper
      @TheNaijaGosiper Год назад +2

      Yes he copied but it is not the exact same thing though.
      Thomas cook logo is more of a “V” shape and his is “☑️ “ yeah he got the idea from there.

    • @jeepen8385
      @jeepen8385 Год назад

      Yes and its also a ripoff from ”VING”

  • @africanboyflyasabird2511
    @africanboyflyasabird2511 Год назад +77

    There is never a perfect logo when it comes to designers. The logos we all love have nothing to do with design, its the storytelling behind a company's brand that makes us fall in love with the logo.

  • @harrisonnock7623
    @harrisonnock7623 Год назад +51

    most of these designs are an example of not spending enough time planning and thinking laterally about the best way to represent an airline,. Logo and brand design has to be thought about from so many different perspectives in order to create a professional and legible design.. None of them were bad but I'm so surprised that out of 5 designers not one design hit the nail on the head all the way through even with so many great books and videos out there to learn from. Other than that great video keep killing it Will!

  • @ramaraoketineni7975
    @ramaraoketineni7975 Год назад +66

    Will ! Mean no offence but ive been following this series since this beginning, From a designers perspective as your audience we would love to see your rendition of the brief too. It would be inspiring and motivating as to where did you actually want the brief to go ;)

    • @willpatersondesign
      @willpatersondesign  Год назад +20

      I'm going to do this! Probably in the next few weeks :)

    • @ramaraoketineni7975
      @ramaraoketineni7975 Год назад +1

      @@willpatersondesign So stoked about your reply! will keep an eye out :D

  • @cfuj
    @cfuj Год назад +16

    The rounded corners in T or J reminds me an airplane wing. Maybe thats the reason why they decided to use that resource.

  • @seanchristopherjohn
    @seanchristopherjohn Год назад +280

    The $300 logo was the worst one, seems like no thought went into that. The $220 logo was the best one. Just goes to show, that its not always about how much you spe d ots picking the best designer :) great video as always!

    • @gromgmail
      @gromgmail Год назад +10

      As for me it's obvious that someone just kidding, and took AI generated prompt as his work result. Insanely bad work.

    • @TheIanHammer
      @TheIanHammer Год назад +23

      220 is a straight thomas cook air ripoff

    • @99xara99
      @99xara99 Год назад

      @@gromgmail Kidding? Oh yea the jokes that cost me $300 on my own expense are simply the best 😂

    • @ChaossX77
      @ChaossX77 Год назад +3

      I think just the opposite.

    • @uz8587
      @uz8587 Год назад +1

      they were all pretty terrible, how are these people charging so much

  • @siya_the_brother
    @siya_the_brother Год назад +15

    Jetset, not as easy as it seems. I appreciate the critique, really cool. I still wonder how does a successful logo for JetSet looks like.

  • @sobanawan7098
    @sobanawan7098 Год назад +10

    As a fiverr seller I think the marketplace is so much saturated that it costs the professional designers to set their rates beneath the average cost. There are upto 400k design services out of which only few deliver the value. But, it's not a problem with how they promote sellers there. The marketplace is controled by buyers but fiverr is good for the people with small budgets and when it comes to the purpose of freelance marketplace it's great that people get their work done even with small budget. Anyways, fiverr is one of the best out there.
    And, I really like the videos about showcasing the projects. I learnt alot from these videos; the kerning issues, the acutal vibe of the design, the layout and the typography. Keep making these kind of videos. These are helpful 🙂🥰❤

  • @jennyglans6908
    @jennyglans6908 Год назад +23

    Love these types of videos! :D I would love to see the prices not being so close to each other. Maybe having one for $500, $10, $200, etc. I would love to see the difference! :D

  • @eaglespowerhousenation5780
    @eaglespowerhousenation5780 9 месяцев назад

    Liridon28’s design is the reason clients trust very little in Fiverr designers. The copy and paste of the Thomas Cook Airlines logo is outrageous.

  • @thawk2563
    @thawk2563 Год назад +3

    Just putting it out there that whilst Lridon's work was clean, in my opinion he just tweaked the old Thomas Cook logo and brand colours .

  • @danielat544
    @danielat544 Год назад +11

    I'm not going to lie, I expected better from them, although they tried to make an entertainment commercial airline logo, it doesn't impact that much for an airline company. Nice content still!

  • @rebeccaammon9072
    @rebeccaammon9072 Год назад +5

    6:38 I feel so seen when someone recognizes the tiniest movement takes time to decide on 😂

  • @Shanspirational
    @Shanspirational Год назад +4

    These videos are always so interesting to watch! I just recently became a Fiverr seller, got my first review yesterday :) I'm planning to do a mix of illustration and graphic design gigs

    • @building_uvstudio
      @building_uvstudio Год назад +1

      Hey @Shanspirational. I'm super interested in how to actually start working with clients on fiverr too. Im just starting out. Hoping to talk more about it if you're free.

  • @naomipaterson9300
    @naomipaterson9300 Год назад +12

    Love these kinds of videos ❤ All the designers are so nice too 😍

  • @jamesbrummelhuis2753
    @jamesbrummelhuis2753 Год назад +1

    The mock up on the last one annoyed me every time it appeared on screen because it the logo was SO flat. It didn't look like it was actually on the plane but just put there.

  • @thinkdezign
    @thinkdezign Год назад +3

    I would love to see Zimri Vs Will take on this same brief

  • @JeffWhisky
    @JeffWhisky Год назад +25

    The presentation put together by Liridon is sooo clean, but couldn't see anything but a duck in the icon! Be great to see your take on this brief Will. Cheers 🥃

  • @jaws5204
    @jaws5204 Год назад +4

    As a graphic designer I wouldn't make a logo for a airline for that cheap. Fivver or not

  • @umutcanyldz6913
    @umutcanyldz6913 Год назад

    In second design, falling airplane is the best idea for airline company.

  • @TheRealMeowMeow01
    @TheRealMeowMeow01 Год назад +2

    7:36 Looks like an Asian airline, not a European one. It would work for a Chinese airline or Chinese-speaking one imho

  • @paulsbourne
    @paulsbourne Год назад +3

    Always love these! Someday I’ll be a part of one 🙏😄

  • @ShahidAli-kn4te
    @ShahidAli-kn4te Год назад +2

    Really, I was a bit disappointed with all the entries, logos just didn't scream AIRLINE, TRAVEL, FAST, SAFE or Luxury class.
    Colors & Fonts weren't nether Dynamic or dramatic.
    Over all 3⭐ratings.

  • @jessicasanguino4814
    @jessicasanguino4814 Год назад +2

    I actually found medseen icon really nice even tho the fin is not te fist you see i got it even before you mention it, the colors too I can see it for a tropical airline, it's different and fun. Maybe the type could use a little more attention

  • @igorshima3074
    @igorshima3074 Год назад

    I love these videos of Will as they go through multiple designers and we see different levels of presentation.
    But can we agree that the part where Will made a joke of the 4th logo looking like a tick, someone had to do a real mock-up of a tick"insect airline"😅😅😅

  • @FensBRL
    @FensBRL Год назад +5

    good video, liking the new fun edits

  • @dsigner
    @dsigner Год назад +4

    in one of your video, you said logo doesnt really have to show what business you are. im a bit confused now.

  • @MURTHARG
    @MURTHARG Год назад +2

    I like this Video. But guessing right away is a hard task.

  • @DnKZone
    @DnKZone Год назад +1

    300$ is just waste of money
    I liked the 12$ one more

  • @hollum1648
    @hollum1648 Год назад

    The most expensive one is just tan Pepsi 😳

  • @Kholaslittlespot1
    @Kholaslittlespot1 Год назад

    Would love to see something on theatrical posters and programmes.

  • @carspn1
    @carspn1 Год назад +1

    Love this series!

  • @kawaneehamilton4038
    @kawaneehamilton4038 Год назад

    I think Symbolex was trying to make the first symbol look like an E for the entertainment in the tail fin.

  • @shalaz1981
    @shalaz1981 Год назад

    The $220 check mark one actually looks like an airplane taking off.

  • @kotusias
    @kotusias Год назад

    first one with S + plane shape I really liked

  • @EmiIy7662
    @EmiIy7662 Год назад +1

    The $220 one reminded me too much of Thomas Cook's logo... Even the ''sun'' idea is a total rip-off

  • @designwithsyedali
    @designwithsyedali Год назад +1

    I love these type of videos. Keep it up

  • @rizly7334
    @rizly7334 Год назад

    4th one represented a heart for me

  • @catebligh
    @catebligh Год назад

    The $300 reminded me of Pepsi, but I liked the gold colors, should have gone with the gold and black I think would look better than gold and white

  • @adugboleoluwaseun8980
    @adugboleoluwaseun8980 Год назад +1

    Hi Will, I am a graphic designer as well, and I enjoyed the video. Just that I couldn't really follow through on the design details. Could you please drop a link where one could view the submitted designs better?

  • @DaniDKPlayz
    @DaniDKPlayz Год назад

    The fourth logo reminds me very much of the Spies logo

  • @keirisklaus2193
    @keirisklaus2193 Год назад +1

    Now l think l need a certificate from WILL PATERSON, because you made me Sir.

  • @MohaMmedMQ
    @MohaMmedMQ Год назад +1

    Please also put your version of the logo

  • @TheGamingNorwegian
    @TheGamingNorwegian Год назад

    Honestly, most of these logo`s looks more like those hotel search websites like Trivago... And the orange one made by Liridon is straight up a copy of Thomas Cook Airlines, if an actual airline where to be using that logo they'd more than likely get sued.

  • @nicolasfiore8341
    @nicolasfiore8341 Год назад

    For me, the first one is by far the best

  • @Aftab-t2k
    @Aftab-t2k Год назад +1

    Thanks for the amazing videos, I learn a lot from, watching ur videos for 3 years 🙌🙌

  • @zainabanjum8702
    @zainabanjum8702 Год назад

    Actually there's a local airline in Pakistan (Air sial)that has a star logo but it's different and I think it looks better the the star logo here.. it has a airplane icon type as the middle of the star and the sides as wings I guess

  • @flippantohio66gamer
    @flippantohio66gamer Год назад

    The tick one looks a bit too much like the danish travel company Spies

  • @PandaBoi813
    @PandaBoi813 Год назад +2

    That $300 one looks absolutely terrible 😅

  • @_chenn
    @_chenn Год назад +1

    Was hoping you’d show us your interpretation at the end :(

  • @roshandeselfa5820
    @roshandeselfa5820 Год назад

    "-but thats ok!...i forgive many things.."

  • @Lefty_Tiger
    @Lefty_Tiger 5 месяцев назад

    thats a falling guy icon on a craft 😂

  • @mateuszm9409
    @mateuszm9409 Год назад

    10:50 "That airlpane mockup is actually pretty decent, I like that" What are you smoking, Will...🤦

  • @jeremyzapsmash
    @jeremyzapsmash 7 месяцев назад

    I like the third one better.
    The fourth one was just a random blob.

  • @142vids
    @142vids Год назад

    Fiverr seller: 6 years in 99designs. Recently joined fiverr. Could use some sales.

  • @n_mckean
    @n_mckean Год назад +3

    "Let me know in the comments how much you thought...." --- right as the answer comes up on screen.

  • @shahirmansoor2008
    @shahirmansoor2008 Год назад

    sometimes this guy remind me alfie solomon from show peaky blinders

  • @nobles_customs
    @nobles_customs Год назад

    I made a logo in Canva based of the brief. I wish I could send it to you.

  • @7flashfacts
    @7flashfacts Год назад

    hey really appreciate your video. How do you annotate with those cool colors annotations and they disappear? can you tell me the software name, please?

  • @hodaelmesawi
    @hodaelmesawi Год назад

    Would you consider doing a video for Upwork sellers or are you bound to Fiverr cause it's a sponsor?

  • @pushgames1140
    @pushgames1140 Год назад

    I m learning right now.. one day .. ( INSHALLAH ) I we'll snd you my logo design. For testing .. 💖💖 love you thanks for your time and help to make design to my self designer it's not easy but I trying 1000hrs challenge.. .
    Again thanks 👍 ❤

  • @daily.YaLayli
    @daily.YaLayli Год назад

    hi boss im fiverr seller and i have this question i've been asked to many times the question is '' will the logo you make for me be copyright protected? and when you make a logo on fiverr, doesn’t it anyway give me ownership of the logo?

    • @sagetusk
      @sagetusk 8 месяцев назад +1

      When you sell them a logo design, usually you do so with the understanding that they will 100% own the design afterwards. It would then be the company's responsibility to look into copywriting/trademarking that logo

    • @daily.YaLayli
      @daily.YaLayli 8 месяцев назад

      thank you man@@sagetusk

  • @MrMostaa
    @MrMostaa Год назад +1

    I just started on Fiverr yesterday as a seller profile name: mostaaaaa 😆

  • @GilliMarieMoody
    @GilliMarieMoody Год назад

    I liked the third one. Only. Cheers.

  • @DaP84
    @DaP84 Год назад +4

    Most "logo designers" on Fiverr are so bad

    • @livingroomvids71
      @livingroomvids71 Год назад +1

      Trying to get fiverr work freelance is impossible IMO. for every 1 person offering a livable wage per design there are 100 people offering a design for $15. Its ridiculous..

    • @DaP84
      @DaP84 Год назад

      @@livingroomvids71 I get that, lot of quantity. That sucks! And now that we have AI that can generate designs, it shouldn't be worth it paying for those crappy, cheap logotypes at all, for anyone

  • @pauguti
    @pauguti Год назад +2

    Let's go!

  • @rayz790
    @rayz790 Год назад

    8:03 I like ducks

  • @salviguanzon4319
    @salviguanzon4319 Год назад +2

    I'm your new subscriber you are amazing.

  • @aminebentameur3080
    @aminebentameur3080 Год назад +1

    Where is "better call saul logos " video ? 🧐

  • @not..A..channel
    @not..A..channel Год назад

    why its always the one who asks for more, delivers the less amount of contect around the main project. and most of the time those artist are, not bein offensive; over-pricing themselves when we compare it with someone who asks for less money.

  • @Mr_Web
    @Mr_Web Год назад

    WHY do you have a US keyboard? It's not like Keychron don't have any UK distributors... Weird???

  • @OH.A.M.
    @OH.A.M. Год назад +5

    Forget Fiverr, how bout you do one for the subscribers? Have every subscriber make a logo brand and you choose your top 3 and have us receive some cash 😜🤘🎉 that will be fun

    • @willpatersondesign
      @willpatersondesign  Год назад +9

      I've done that on other videos! In fact, I'm making more of these where subscribers will get the chance to take part :D

  • @ChaossX77
    @ChaossX77 Год назад

    9:32 Looks like a duck.

  • @elixtonzo
    @elixtonzo Год назад

    The fourth one is literally Thomas cook, it a copy

  • @ChaossX77
    @ChaossX77 Год назад

    3:37 Why doesn't that make sense? It's an uppercase J not a lowercase one.

  • @davidlopezserret12
    @davidlopezserret12 Год назад +1

    I won’t pretend I’m far better designer, but I can certainly say that all of those logos are horrible, they don’t work as logos.

  • @greathdmoviez2529
    @greathdmoviez2529 Год назад +2

    I am also a designer on fiverr

  • @Self-Discovery-Saga
    @Self-Discovery-Saga 5 месяцев назад

    I would have done similar logos for you in 10 dollars 😂

  • @expectationlost
    @expectationlost Год назад

    Like a Money Plane?

  • @HARRISKEDITS
    @HARRISKEDITS Год назад

    its amazing i am logo designer on fiverr but i am visually impaired

  • @kawaneehamilton4038
    @kawaneehamilton4038 Год назад

    I think the one with

  • @Asia_Bangladesh
    @Asia_Bangladesh Год назад

    Not bad

  • @oossmano3762
    @oossmano3762 Год назад

    Im in fivver for like 5 months and I didn't get a single order

  • @kevynlevine
    @kevynlevine Год назад +1

    Hat.

  • @howk00006
    @howk00006 Год назад

    Hey, i make a design for jetset i want to show you

  • @gangimathar
    @gangimathar 6 месяцев назад

    Omg I still charge 50 per logo and mine are in my opinion still better than these :/ Maybe I need to up the prices..

  • @science87
    @science87 Год назад

    Try My service😂(only in 30 dollars)

  • @YTmingle
    @YTmingle Год назад +1

    You are amazing 🤩 😊

  • @Di_yay
    @Di_yay Год назад +1

    I disagree with most of what you say 😅

  • @declan_franklin
    @declan_franklin Год назад

    I'm a fiver seller, but I haven't had any client

    • @Kholaslittlespot1
      @Kholaslittlespot1 Год назад

      This is the issue. I also worry about the effect is having on some industries.
      Still, I'm probably going to end up there xD

  • @khizarshykh
    @khizarshykh 10 месяцев назад

    Why my eyes are hurting to see these logos I'm not saying foul about them but for 300$ !!! I think I could have done a better job. Even though I'm not getting any clients because the market is just so crowded

  • @alexflores7773
    @alexflores7773 Год назад

    I want you to design my logo 😂😂😂😂

  • @yas_art
    @yas_art 2 месяца назад

    Is it just me or this guy appreciate the bad ones most purposefully. Ruining the price game of the market

  • @alxmtncstudio2066
    @alxmtncstudio2066 Год назад +1

    "The logo MUST represent what the company does". Are you sure?
    Because it's hardly true. That's a designer's fantasy, nothing else. It's never been true nor necessary. At most you'll be tied to represent how the company wants to be feeled like. Like our subway company here doesn't say subway at all, it says "humans" (RATP company).
    An apple is nothing of a tech company yet it's the biggest tech company's logo. What must be represented is very large and far beyond the technicality of it's a jet company there has to be an airplane. No, make it feel like it flies in some way perhaps yes, but that's all. Well add to the balance that a logo MUSTN'T look like the company does smth else far away than what it does.

  • @adiicism
    @adiicism Год назад

    I'm a fiverr seller too.

  • @lockettlv
    @lockettlv Год назад

    What the hell even was that last one, worst of them all by a mile

  • @sss6528
    @sss6528 Год назад

    Those logo’s are all horrible for the price lol.
    No overshooting
    Wrong curning
    Didn’t follow the brief
    All generic icons

  • @pedfer8241
    @pedfer8241 Год назад +1

    Im a fiver seller!!!

  • @MuhammadNaseem-rv9eo
    @MuhammadNaseem-rv9eo 7 месяцев назад

    Here I'm 🙋🏻‍♂️