'Perpetuating myths' about Indigenous Australians 'doing more damage' than good
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 апр 2021
- Alice Springs Deputy Mayor Jacinta Price says she is "sick to death of Q&A" but the fact "they continue to perpetuate myths" about Indigenous Australians is "doing more damage" than good.
Ms Price said the problem with many descendants of Indigenous Australians is they didn't understand the cultural context of Aboriginal people before white settlers.
"I'm absolutely done with the fact over and over again we're seen as not having to take responsibility for the issues we face, for the incredible rates of domestic and family violence that go on within our communities," she said.
"It's always someone else's fault and we wonder why we can't solve these issues; we wonder why we have higher rates of incarceration."
Jacinta Price . The voice of sense and logic👍👍
Jacintha also has a solid head on her shoulders .
@ቆረቆዳ አለሽ go away Dan bot
@ቆረቆዳ አለሽ whoa an Ethiopian!!!
@ቆረቆዳ አለሽ oh look another recent CCP mouth piece ghost account.
@ቆረቆዳ አለሽ I know a lot about Ethiopia as I am married to one for 25 years!
This is the real problem for indigenous Australians, not what that other inner suburban yuppy was dribbling.
Thankyou for bringing truth to the table.
So disgusted with ABC lies. We all want the truth.
To paraphrase Thomas Sowell: Racism is not dead. It's on life support, kept alive by politicians, race hustlers, and people who get a sense of superiority by denouncing others as racists. #TheirABC and guests include the latter two categories: race hustlers, and people who get a sense of superiority by denouncing others as racists.
351 gt * 😂😂
These people just attacked the ABC on a completely different topic to what was being discussed. That’s pretty weird. They didn’t give the Channel 10 presenter a right of reply either. That’s pretty weak and pathetic.
Why does the ABC still exist? It’s gone the way of the BBC- which must surely be on its last legs!
@@windsong2875 why does the ABC exist? Because the vast majority of Australians like, want and respect the ABC. Most are annoyed the budget is continually being cut. So if you get outside of your bubble you’d understand this to be true.
I can remember seeing an aboriginal guy come out of the pub and get the stuffing beat out of him by an aboriginal women. These two ladies have got it dead right substance abuse is the number one cause for dmv.
So Brett you just argued against the two Jacinta’s and confirmed that Aboriginal patriarchy is different to European patriarchy. Why do you argue against the SkyNews guests then say they are right?
@Anthony Timmers You sound like a knob. You have no idea what you are talking about. There was no war just a take over and yet 3.3% who are Aboriginal still remain. But You seem to know better.
@@chrispomfret8592 It was a war though,
"a state of armed conflict between different countries or different groups within a country."
I would say the Colonists and the Tribes who sided with them are a group,
And that the Tribes who fought against them are a group,
And id say the tribes and colonists did possess weapons of war making it a armed conflict
'Albanese doesn't want to empower Indigenous people...only his voter base'. Truth! 👍🏾
"Albanese doesn't want to empower women, he wants to empower feminist." Another fact!
TRUTH!
These women decline to be victims. I love it.
The sooner Jacinta Price gets into Federal politics the better!! She has the voice and now just needs the power to finally make some real positive changes for all the indigenous people of this country!!
Unfortunately there is a small group that don’t want things to change .
Like every politician, they will do as they're told by those pushing the agenda or they will be gone..
@@EdHarrisonMusic well said . 🙏
Perhaps she's better off outside politics where she can speak freely.
She is one delusional girl that Q&A lady. And what’s scarier is the number of drongos that will accept every word without blinking.
But much love to these two Aboriginal women in this interview. There’s no joy or aha moments and it’s so sad to hear what they’re saying, which we all know to be true. It’s courageous of them to speak the truth and hearing them be so matter of fact and up front makes my heart break for the Indigenous people suffering in these afflicted communities.
If only there was a way to help, but I don’t know what that is.
The one way to help is to actually listen. They argued about completely different issues. That is pathetic.
@@chrispomfret8592
Oh... horseshit !
Clean out your bloody ears!
I think Jancintha McAvoy-Geia did so well. One can tell someone who's not used to speaking on such a forum. It can't have been easy. Well done!
They didn’t even directly address the topic. They couldn’t even remember the names of people they were attacking. It’s gutter level to not even give the people they are attacking the right of reoly
@@chrispomfret8592
Christ ..you're a clueless windbag!
@@sharischwing-austen4011 I think we gave a troll...lol!
@@chrispomfret8592 aren’t you going to reoly to that?😂
Love Jacinta Price !
On another program Narelda Jacobs said "Defund the Police, I'm just putting it out there." She lives in an alternate universe.
People like Narelda Jacobs, who live in alternate universes, don't need police if anything goes wrong. As a space cadet, she'll call the star marshals!
If you think defunding Police is as basic as removing all the funding to police then you don’t get the argument. The movement is advocating for different approaches to conflict resolution, police training and first responses. For example they are saying they should employ social workers or psychologists to go with police to advise them on some cases. We do it in Australia in some places with great success. It’s too easy to attack the message without understanding the message.
@@chrispomfret8592
You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about , you posturing pseudo moralistic virtue signaller !
As a fat 70 year old white guy, I must say it is so good to hear the younger indigenous view - well done. You have given me hope for the future and I would like to hear more from these two young ladies. Future Australians of the year maybe?
Jacinta Price is spot on - unfortunately some so called urban based groups have no interest in helping communities because the golden goose may take flight if problems are resolved, limited or improved
I listen to these three ladies for real news.
It's about time we stopped misusing the divisive term "Racism", when the real issue and behaviour that needs to change is cultural. A "race" can host multiple cultures and any culture can be toxic.
Two very good spokes women for the Indigenous Australians. Common sense is being spoken.
I live in a community an with Covid money some night's are like a war
zone.
'60k years of continuous culture" is just a euphemism for "stuck in the stone age.'
They had no reason to develop, they were so in tune with living off the land.
@@daniellebcooper7160 Living off the land? Everybody lives off the land. Most hunter/gatherers lived on the edge of survival, population determined by food. Domestication and food storage just raised the population, which required social changes.
Yes, we never hear about all the good that's been done .
@@daniellebcooper7160 lol okay. In other words you mean subsistence. Primitive is primitive. I suppose they never has disease and it was a land of milk and honey.
@@stephennenadov6709 Most people get their food from markets. Living off the land means hunting wildlife and foraging for grubs and berries and such. Which the Australian Aborigines, like most indigenous races, were good at. Apart from other tribes, they had no other competition, so why would they have developed any further?. and they didnt.
This is one of the greatest interviews I have watched in so long. Truth, reason and respectful conversation in which these three great women talk reality about the struggles of life. The honest truth is the more we speak about real life issues without shaming and defaming people, the soon we will become a whole and diverse people that are unite under one nation culturally, historically and diverse but one in spirit.
What about all of Australia for all Australians.
Jacinta Price should be the Premier of a State if not Prime Minister
There's a new resurgence of the "noble savage" idea. I think it resurfaces periodically and has done for the past 2 or 3 hundred years.. It says that certain societies were perfect. They had no history and no politics. They were conflict-free utopias in which time stood still, in contrast to our own societies which, driven by conflict, are always changing. They had ancient wisdom unsullied by modern technology. This is how these societies are being presented including pre colonial aboriginal society. It's perhaps only in it's current form that people dare not question it's ahistoricism for fear of being cancelled as racists. I doubt this aboriginal lady journalist really knows much about gender and power dynamics in ancient aboriginal society. She's a journalist not an anthropologist or historian but her identity permits her to speak with authority on something she'd know little about.
My friend used to work across from an aboriginal shelter. They used to get drunk every day and hit each other with iron bars. The ambulance was there every day.
How DARE you speak truth in the face of leftistideologyandnarrative?? No matter WHAT happened, it was the white people's fault...even the baby that your wife hasn't had yet, it was his/her fault too! Just ask any leftist...
I believe that archaeologists have discovered that female Indigenous skeletons frequently showed damage from violent assaults. The early settlers, themselves no shrinking violets, were appalled at the violence with which Indigenous women were treated by their men.
Wheres your link? No link no believe
@@7thNoteOfficial quadrant.org.au/opinion/bennelong-papers/2013/05/the-long-bloody-history-of-aboriginal-violence/
@@credenza1 sad if true.
Narelda please just stop rewriting Aboriginal history and culture. Spend some time with my family and we'll burst your perfect little bubble. The left has some delusional views of Aboriginal culture and society.
I'm a foreigner. Can I have my own voice and my own government as well?Go Jacinta Price!
Please listen to these women, it can help make indigenous communities better, every child indigenous or not, that is not exposed to violence is a huge win and a better future for Australia
I love this interview. What amazing women who can see through all the bs of politicians and Facebook-friendly lobbyists with their own agendas.
As long as you can blame someone else for your actions then you will never change your actions.
I feel sorry for anyone that needs to do that. It displays very low self esteem that you need to blame others and create a fantasy to position yourself in a pecking order with your colleagues. And that due to skin color you know more than others - the very definition of racism ironically
For years I have used the joke "as long as there is someone else to blame there isn't a problem". Unfortunately this absurd philosophy has now been adopted as truth by a significant segment of society.
you can guarantee there is going to be a LOT of wailing an gnashing of teeth from activists over this interview.
These two guests are brilliant truth tellers.
Keep up the good fight Jacintas. Decades of failed policy and bigotry of low expectations need to be given the boot. I hope your thoughtful solutions get implemented.
If it wasn't British civilisation it would have been another European power (say Belgium) and then Imperial Japan and it would not be have been very pretty.
@drew sale Or China.
Malcolm wasn’t having it, he had to chill down by drinking water 😂
Really enjoyed watching this.
Keep fighting for the truth ladies.
Perhaps the insidious people of Australia would have preferred to be taken over by conquistadores or maybe by the Nazi's.
The British did far more good than harm in this world, I wished people would stop bashing and calling the race card every 2 minutes.
... or the Arabs or the Turks... Mongols? the list goes on...
You just did play the race card unfortunately
No need to beat up on any race
Agreed, if western society is so bad, why do so many want to come to its countries?.
@@someonewhocares5924 I’m not in the spotlight using the same old chestnut, I for one am sick of it, it’s not even worth discussing people need to try getting along and withhold freedom and values
@@Ni9kye withhold freedom and values??
I’m sick of it all too
Yes all Labor do is throw money at Aboriginal people not the answer get both these indigenous women on the front bench of federal parliament bloody fantastic women
Aboriginal people should rightly be very proud of their heritage and traditions, but you never fully grow as a people until all the cupboards are opened, curtains drawn, and light shed on abuses, shame, and cruelty ... the youth will make you stronger, happier and more successful, education, education, education ...
Very nice young ladies. GOD bless them.
deputy mayor Jacinta, wow, what an amazing spokesperson for her community.
Jacinta is so switched on.
These women should be in Canberra
Great to see these young ladies on the side of reality.
Narelda Jacobs is living in a dreamlike dreamtime... aboriginals didn't recognize homosexuals like herself back then, they thought it was a disease and would cast those people, along with other weak minded kind, into nevernever land, If they didn't just straight up spear them.
They were nomadic and for the survival of the clan it was a matter of keep the fittest and cast the weak.
Both genders had their respective roles within the group, the men would be gone for days hunting, while the women would keep camp gathering and caring.
2021... now the women are the matriarch of the family and the men are left with no role other than to get drunk and break the family apart...bar some exceptions.
I'm just pleased they are still with us and not the result of an asian occupation.
Jacinta Price needs to take herself in to Federal politics.
If ANY other industrialists had discovered Australia's hunter/gatherer paradise before Europeans, they wouldn't even exist today.
Oh, so that makes it OK?
Respect for both ladies!!
It is becoming increasingly difficult to respond without cursing!
they had transgender in the 1700's? wow who knew
I'm so very proud of these two women.
Finally some strong real leadership from the aboriginal community is being heard
I think they made up arguments that were not even being discussed. They have no idea about the word patriarchy for a start. They have no idea about the difference between easily European Patriarchy and local indigenous patriarchy nor how it relates to today. It’s pathetic to attack without giving the person the right to reply.
@@chrispomfret8592
How frigging old are you ...12?
Jacinta and Jacinta should both be in federal politics and Jacinta Price would make a wonderful Prime Minister.
Nice to hear some truth!!! The ABC has lost the plot!!!
Two smart women speaking up.
Jacinta Price just gets better and better. I honestly hope we can see her in Cabinet (if not PM) someday. She’s exceptional.
Excellent conversation ladies, thank you
I've got tears in my eyes...35 TIMES Hospitalization rate of Aboriginal women due to domestic violence!!...I love these two women they are 100% correct, this is the revolution we need, an honest look at reality.
Narelda Jacobs: "If I can cast our mind back to some of the history books here. Where I come from, Whadjuk Noongar country, traditionally people were born knowing exactly their purpose, exactly where they belong, their identity. Women were equal, if not the leader of their families and their mob. Sister girls, brother boys, non-binary people were all completely accepted as living their purpose. Everybody was born in the body that they were meant to be, you were there because you were meant to be there in the form that you were born, and you were all living your purpose.When the colonisers came and invaders came along, they brought with them the patriarchy.
And the symptoms of the patriarchy and colonialism is misogyny, sexism, racism, discrimination, homophobia, transphobia. None of those things existed before the colonisers came."
An adult who is also a prominent media identity (who should know better) actually spouted that utter garbage! And it being on the ABC, naturally, it went unchecked. In Narelda's world, as always, the ills that beset aboriginals in this country are - drum roll please - white man's fault!
Toot toot! The Victim Train rolls on!
Toot toot. An Aboriginal friend told me, "We should be thanking you blokes. If not for the white man, we'd still be running around the desert in loin cloths, freezing our butts off every winter." .. I once asked her to introduce me to her brothers so that I might take part in a real traditional corroboree. She said, "No. My brothers are violent men. If they get you alone in the bush at night, they will surely take advantage of you."
Very good Jacinta's they've all been throwing ridiculous amounts of money at the aboriginal communities and seems very little has improved, someone needs to take a hard line on lots of issues black and white
Oh yes I remember seeing the famous Aboriginals cross dressing painting. The Original Priscilla queen of the desert.
She could have just led with the phrase, "the colonizers." Then I would have known I didn't need to listen any further. Everywhere people are rewriting the past to create a basis for political dominance.
Smart, intelligent, informed women speaking the truth, because that's the *only* way to positive change - stay strong ladies, you make Australians of every colour proud.
thank god for these two woman who has a brain
Wow the Labour Party are doing exactly the same to indigenous people across the Tasman.
Great views.......great interview........and I think its probably a good thing that Australia wasn’t taken over by Korean or Chinese rule back in the day ........that could’ve been a lot worse
She must have long arms to draw such a long bow
This is why i watch Sky News Australia and don't watch ABC at all any more...
Typical ABC Q@A needs defunding.
Narelda Jacobs speaking from a position of privelidge talking about a culture she has never experienced.
WELL SPOKEN JACINTA
Australian Labor and US Democrats using the same play book :(
Go Jacinta - wonderful to hear your commonsense views.
Wishing you support and success with clearing the untruths.
You are a dynamic duo - just what is needed to bridge us all into one not all the separatism that many are behind but making. Our they are trying to sort the problem.
GO GIRLS!🤗💖😘
What a load of hogwash. Reminds me of the woman who said "You need to turn those horns backward on the highway deer crossing signs. Deer like you depict would get stuck in every tree." So, the state changed all the deer signs to backward facing horns. Until, they realized, after lots of ridicule, that they were duped by an ignorant woman.
And Will the Indigenous "Voice to Parliament" Produce the Same Lightning Response it Elicits For the Rest of Us?!!
With the ABC's commitment to diversity and inclusion, it's surprising we never see either Jacinta on any of their programs eh?
Wise woman there
This just came up on my device, Jacinta price, you speak truth as you all did,well done ladies
I love Jacinta Price - she’s so brave snd strong as well as a clear thinker . I do not know the other Jacinta , but she spoke from knowledge rather than theory or dogma. Keep it up - you are both leaders and role models fir both your nrn and your women!
Ladies you are so sensible...a measured response to these allegations!!
That's what I call a cluster
Are we so guilty that we believe we would all be much better off living a hunter and gatherer's life unchanged for centuries even in hostility with other tribes, no books, Bachs , Aristotles, God and Jesus.......
My taxpayers dollars to ABC how disgusting
You will find more indigeous bodies if you dig Australian land comparing to Canada
Good on you ladies for your honesty
Thankyou wonderful ladies for your courage and honesty so good to hear the truth it is like living water to a thirsty soul. Blessings.
The plums of war are bleating
Alice Springs. Heard some good things about that town, and the aborigines there many many years ago.
This literally is making viewers dumber. These two Jacintas clearly do not understand what the word patriarchy is nor how it was being referenced to European patriarchy. They argued about completely different issues to what was said and discussed on QandA. This is typical of SkyNews. They attack the ABC or others without right of reply. It’s really pathetic. It’s seriously misleading
Jordan B Peterson RULE #1 in his New book is Do not carelessly denigrate social institutions or creative achievement. That Gem and Sage of a Man! I need more JBP in my YT life again, Sigh...
PS. I could tell you a story that would bring Australia to its knees and it was covered up by the government departments!!
Please tell. What about the book by Fiona Barnett?
Bet we wont hear more 😂🤣
@Paul Grant, So -
1) Which government department did you work for?
2) Why would you not tell the story?
3) How fragile do you think the population of Australia is, that they would be on their knees after being told?
4) If your story turned out to be bullshit, what should the penalty be for someone exposing it as fact?
5) If your story is fact, what would you like to see done about it?
If you are not prepared to tell the story, you are just as bad as the people you are accusing of covering it up - either put up - or shut up.
I would not listen to anybody who shares a platform with Turdbull. Birds of a feather flock together.
Tell them to get over it
Words could not define or articulate, express the GENERATIONAL GAP nor the relentless stereotyping and NEGLIGENCE , and Massive MEDICAL and EDUCATIONALl GAP ....
~ENUF SED~
Don't get me started on tribal wars ...
If you're not noticeably darker skinned , you get ignored in the aboriginal community ..
Thank you all for your open and honest conversation 👍🙏🙏🙏❤ so true about albanese! Only there for the vote
I see the same attitude with the Canadian indigenous. Let's take a look Canada, USA, Australia have a lot of in common with this particular problem. Politicians take advantage of this. I would say everywhere around the world are very aggressive people but the reasons are different.
The first thing is to identify the problem then there is a way forward to solve that problem .
If the problem is not identified it does not exist and there will never be a solution
I like this lady Jacinta Price.
Love her honesty and it’s honesty and the want for us all to move forward as an inclusive society. Good and bad in all races everyone needs to try a little harder.
It's all about behaviour and not skin colour!
Two strong women there! God bless! Q&A is dead to me too - too biased - left side! Aboriginal men need to be Men! Proper way - respectful and care for Family! The way we used to be. IMO!
How refreshing from both girls....the truth will set you free..doing some good stuff lately Rita..
Narelda Jacobs appears to be doing quite well from "colonisation." The two Jacintas are right on the button, we need more voices like theirs to be heard.
Well put ladies