Chile: 50 years after Augusto Pinochet | DW Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2023
- On 11 September 1973, a military coup brought Augusto Pinochet to power in Chile. Now, almost 30 years after his dictatorship ended, its neoliberal constitution - and the privatization that resulted from it - is coming under fire.
Today, the legacy of Chile’s dictatorship continues to shape peoples‘ lives. Augusto Pinochet’s 1980 constitution relied on a completely free market to regulate the economy. But the privatization of markets in Chile has benefited the few and left many Chileans struggling. For example: in Chile, education is not free. The public health care system is underfunded and many cannot afford private insurance. Elderly people barely survive on meagre pension payouts. Even drinking water is private property.
In 2019, masses of people took to the streets in Chile to protest the country’s constitution. A year later, more than 75% of voters approved changing it in a referendum. This documentary accompanies Chileans who worked on this new constitution. They include a young woman for whom social justice and the right to abortion without punishment are central; a conservative who thinks the whole process is wrong; and indigenous people who hope that a new constitution will make their concerns heard.
In 2022, the first draft was rejected in a new referendum. But the process continues -- as does the struggle for a better future for Chile.
#documentary #dwdocumentary #chile
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
Millions of Chileans thank Pinochet every day for having laid the foundations for the development of our country, which went from being one of the poorest on the continent to being the most prosperous in Latin America. thanks you Pinochet. VIVA CHILE
Viva General Augusto Pinochet Ugarte! Salvador de Chile!!!!!!!!
Not sure what you are talking about. All I saw in the video was a third world country. Lol you must have a very low standard for calling that prosperous. 😂
America stands with you
@libertarian_Pol_Pot username checks out
Is there a stats for this comment ?
Let's not forget that it was the US who helped Pinochet make a coup d'etat, kill a democraticly elected leader and supported a dictatorship ... Let's not forget how the US came to have all the power they have today ... Let's not forget that the US did this in maaany countries, not only in Chile
Allende was a KGB plant who destroyed the Chilean economy and the Chilean people.
Did you just say democratic leader ??? I think you better study history. He was considered inconstitucional and he didn’t want to leave the power. And the other thing that made the alcoholic Allende worse, was that he didn’t win the elections !!!! He was elected because the parliament decided it.
Yep they supported Marcos here 😢 quite a Sad reality
Let's not forget that Fidel Castro and the Soviets were actively courting Salvador Allende and that Chile was critical to Castro's plans! Case in point Cuba, Venezuela, Nicaragua...all wonderful countries...NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@carlosacta8726 Did Salvador Allende kill people? He was democratically elected and he didn't commit any human right violation ... so he was bad only because his friends were bad? Hmmm I see now how you think
One big reason I love dw documentaries is their on time voice overs since it's soo tiring to read subtitles. Kudos DW 🎉👍
'murican moment...
True especially for people who mostly watches YT vids on their smart phones and don't have good eyesight like me.
I usually have these on in the background while I'm working almost like a podcast, so having the dubbed voice overs is very important since I rarely have time to sit and watch an hour long documentary where I'd have to focus on nothing else at the same time to read subtitles.
Thank you very much DW for this documentary. Unfortunately, it is outdated: on September 4, 2022, the constitutional proposal was rejected by 62% of the votes. Now, there is a second process, very different from the previous one, and whose text will be submitted to a plebiscite on December 17. We'll see what happens in my country.
Basically, Pinochet and his finance minister sold the country, its water, the health and education of its peoples , externalized environmental costs and boasted about the "wealth" created for a tiny faction, while mega corporations like Bechtel take the profit, minus of course Pino's kabals cut. Important to remember Chiles CIA Kissinger arranged 9/11 on this day of States annual display of hypocritical self pity
Unfortunately????? Thanks lord! No communism in Chile. Diciembre 17. against the illegal process
This is why they need a Thomas Jefferson, instead of an entire group, to write a constitution.
😂
@@omarsanchez9709 James Madison (4th president) is often credited as the father of the constitution due to his role in drafting it and promoting its need over the old articles of confederation, via the Virginia Plan and the Federalist Papers. While the constitution was debated during the constitutional convention, without James Madison's contributions to the Virginia Plan and the constitution, as well as Madison's and Hamilton's contributions to the Federalist Papers, the US government may have turned out much differently, and the US may not have had such a long lasting constitution.
Did you watch the entire video? This is already addressed in it.
The Constitution should be created (ideas) by the people and written by professionals.
Who defines professionals? The government? History has shown that when the government writes constitutions they always empower the state not the people..
@@markvolker1145
English Professors. So it reads efficiently. Politicians could still manipulate the meaning, but at least the constitution would be by the people.
this time the socialist revolution was derailed by identity politics
Socialists were illogical and irrational since there inception . It hasent worked elsewhere in the world .
Pinochet was right about you people
Education and health care are not privatized. There are public and private institutions, just like in Germany.
They're lying and they know it. It wasn't a mistake.
Just like in Germany is definetely not. That is a lie. There is yes private and public institutions, but very different to how it works in Germany. The result and impact of their existance is what makes the difference.
Incredibly awful yes, with almost zero funding… it’s a joke to say it’s the same as Germany historically.
In Germany both sides accept this not in Chile
@@raquetdude Zero funding? The Chilean State doesn't lack money; it lacks the proper human capital with the talent and integrity to make the most of it. This administration has quickly built an infamous reputation for both their mediocre, unprofessional people as well as the massive amounts of public funds they have stolen, and they have the nerve to want to further increase taxation 😂
Exactly. There is an education and healthcare public system and it's free, but the quality is not good compared to the private one. It just needs more funding and there's also a clear lack of doctors.
At the end more than 60% of the voters rejected the proposal……it’s what happens when unprepared people works on such an important project.
Not prepared sufficiently by communist ideologues. Soros should put some more work into Chile to destroy, ehm, to reform it.
you mean the misinformation and fake news...
Now, we have a second chance for to get a democratic solution for our problems.
Over 70% of the voters wanted these ppl to make the proposal though right?
@@franciscaacuna8723 True, you guys do engrage in that often.
Chilian economic power and quality of life was of the top of all South america because they adobted capitalism. But as soon as socialism comes into the picutre the quality of life will become lower. Its an old story and new and ppl will never learn.
latin america has been capistalist for 200 years and its not going too well it seems.
it was thanks to socialists that now we have labour and human rights in our countries, so take your BS somewhere else
This mirrors point by point the distortions that plagued the October 2023 Australian referendum for an Indigenous Voice to Parliament. It’s uncanny and sad.
Chile doesn't need a new constitution. They need to amend the areas that are not working for all Chileans. Chile needs to see its neighbor, Argentina, and then think twice.
Argentina has not had a new constitution since 1853 and done exactly what you said so bad example.
@@mauricio9564reason why Argentina is so bad : Peronismo/KEYNES
By any chance, could you add english subtitles in your videos??
Automatic subtitles are not accurate. If you can't, it is fine . No offense
Augusto José Ramón Pinochet Ugarte supported by American.
The US was worried about Chile going over to the Soviets. So they helped the monster overthrow Ajende. The stupid part was that the Ajende Government would have collapsed because it was giving away more than it had.
First of all we have to set in the table the cold war context. US war against an idea it wasnt just spies and nuclear bombs, that argument that US was worried about Chile going over to the soviets is not very accurate if you know where Chile is
@jksmith4651
You support mass murder then? You support extra-judicial assassination? Putting a huge proportion of the population under the duress of arbitrary arrest, potential 'disappearance', sweeping democratic choice off the table if it's not conservative choice. Give us your whole thought process. I'm certain that you have this all worked through.
Keep crying.
And many Chileans
It's comical that people pretend a Marxist would have survived in conservative Chile "if only the US didn't intervene!"😂😂😂
informative
It's nothing short of leftist propaganda. Just like everywhere in the world, this push for solving "social issues" bring nothing else than misery to all but a few privileged political "elite". An overspending bloated state that will ruin any glimmer of prosperity and self determination.
Excelente análisis y documental!
Thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers to comment on our channel in English
so that we can answer questions and encourage dialogue.
Thank you and all the best,
The DW Documentary Team
Too many cooks in the kitchen writing the constitution. This won’t amount to anything.
In my homecountry Sweden many from Chile fled during the dictatorship
Subtitle Indonesia please 🙌
I dont understand why DW would intentionally put out a one sided story that leaves its public blind to what is going on in Chile.
Ok guy, what do *you* think is going on in Chile?
because you are blind
Yeah... please tell Chileans what's really going on in their country, assuming you live there?
Im Chilean huevon. I can speak about my country anytime.@@canthinkaboutone
I am Chilean I can say he is right, this is beyond biased. The people depicted here are not in the least bit representative of the common Chilean, the main girl they show even looks like a foreigner. This evidenced by Kast's (a right wing conservative) recent victory and the previous rechazo of that idiotic constitution. People elected a left wing president mostly due to the previous president's failure to do his job, he presented himself as a conservative and that's what got him elected, he them went on to not do anything conservative making him look liberal in the eyes of those who elected him only. The pendulum will swing in the opposite direction next time, because people will find plenty of flaws with Boric as well, not to mention the millions who despise him and the liberal subculture he represents already, this is now associated with lack of order, crime and graffiti. @@canthinkaboutone
They need him more than ever now. The world does too
You know he’s dead, right?
@@coimbralaw obviously. We need leaders like him today
@@coimbralaw We all know. Given the circumstances... wish people knew more about the situation before making opinion in regards to Pinochet. Afterall, Allende was the one that promoted him and Allende was a hypocrite by suppressing protests by using Pinochet, the irony ... if that's not foreshadowing i don't know what its. Down with socialism... that system does nothing but omit things and no accountability
I hope they will keep going forward.
They are going backwards rn
I am a Chilean and I’ll tell you. We better not get going into the communist way.
For political nothing and a lot of donation money.
This documentary is terribly outdated.
Buen documental
Thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers to comment on our channel in English
so that we can answer questions and encourage dialogue.
Thank you and all the best,
The DW Documentary Team
Thank you DW!!
Every country are deciding contribution
Down with Tankies, long live Pinochet!
Start up the rotors
Couple all of these issues with a terrible, inexperienced, and incapable President Boric and it’s a real mess
Chile Curicó ❤❤❤❤ Leonardo Javier mella Retamal Chile Curicó
If you do not like drastic changes. 2 party system is not for you.
Chile’s peaceful multi-nations country is an inspiring and promising an all inclusive example
This The Same In Peoria Illinois. Usa... Two Tier For Sure....
I’m originally from Morton. It’s not just there in Illinois, the entire U.S. is like this, particularly rural areas and even more particularly, red states. If you vote for the Fascist Republicans, this this is their legacy.
What is progressive and advances democracy? All agreed and disagreed’s interest shall be hear and cared, all parties taking compromise of others is true caring society…
Hope is never easy
But hope must come!
When your proposed Constitution is rejected by 62% of the voters, it signals a massive disconnect between the drafting members and the populace at large. This piece by DW unfortunately is so biased it neglects to focus on the complete failure of draft. Quite disappointing DW.
i worked in the final votation, the people was very ignorant about everything, many people was thinking that the proposed constitution was gonna expropiate houses and all sort of lies of the pinochet followers..
Exactly that, a leftist hit piece. Highlighting the pro side and slipping in a few against opinions leaving out the fundamentals of why this considered is a bad (leftist) constitution.
Fun fact: el mamarracho is the ONLY constitutional draft ever rejected in a referendum.
You can be proud of that my dear snowflakes.
DW got paid to generate such a biased crap. Journalism has been dead for a long time now.
@@franciscaacuna8723 Yeah sure, the same old thing that the draft is good but the people are stupid LOL
Those that opposed voted for international globalisation and multinational corporations to continue as they have been… if they voted to pass it would have been a vote AGAINST the IMF and globalisation…
just copy the US or EU constitution, and change a few words here and there in terms of what are the specifics to the situation in Chile
I've read a book based on his reign called When I Lived on Butterfly Hill
I voted against the new constitution because I didn't trust the people who would've wrote it. I've lived in Chile long enough to know everybody in the political circles take egregious shortcuts and nobody is free of biases. I know some of the people who would've wrote it would've use ChatGPT to write a whole article.
Access to basic drinking water is the most basic human right on this planet.
not according to CEO of Nestle
no it's not, especially not when it comes at the expense of others
For another go!🕊
Great documentary, glad to see Arthur's little sister doing meaningful work nowadays, she used to be very annoying.
Part of the list of countries that answer the question: "what if Activision wrote part of your country's Constitution?"
I think abortion is the responsibility for man .
To not to cause it !
News for you, Abdulla. Women get to make decisions about their own bodies. You get to make decisions about 'your' body. See how that works? Try to be brave, my friend. I know it's hard.
@@9UaYXxB
The baby or the child always belongs to the father
Said
The Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him
@@abdullahozek8016 🤣 people like you have to be trolling
@@anonymousanonym450 there is no people like me
Having lived in Chile before Ajende, I can witness the gulf between rich and poor. There is an especially brutal treatment of indigenous peoples.
The problem is basic: with limited resources Socialism attempts to distribute, while capitalism produces the wealth.
Falso!! Los indígenas tienen mas beneficios que nosotros....que somos los que trabajamos.......averiguen biéb antes de opinar estamos en 2023
@@elymiranda2971 que más beneficios hablas loll
working people produce the wealth.
capitalists merely steal it.
("legally" of course.
because they write the laws)
@@elymiranda2971 I would like to know how old you are? I was an eye witness to the abuse of the indigenous peoples of Chile before Ajende. Chile was a highly stratified society then. When I visited the Lota coal mine, I observed 1st hand how the workers were mistreated and essentially worked as indentured slaves, while the management lived liked royalty.
We lived in house only a Block away from the cayumpas shanty town. The shacks had no running water or sewage connection.
On of our friends at Univeridad de Concepcion was murded when Pinochet came to power.
A lot has changed in Chile since I left almost 60 years ago, and I wish the Chilanos all the best. You have a beautiful country and hopefully you can have a country with equal justice for all and prosperity.
Capitalism creates inequality but pays for social programs through taxation. Socialism creates equality of misery and poverty for everyone. Socialism punishes success and hard working people who eventually leave the country and go to places where their work is appreciated. Chile is the most developed and prosperous country in Latin America for a reason.
A report quite biased to progressivism, according to DW Chileans want a new constitution, but the reality is that there are divided opinions, some want it, some don't, most interviewees are on one side and are allowed to explain their views, almost none of those who reject a new constitution appear. Why has DW gone so far sideways? Do German taxpayers know that their taxes are used to finance political positions?
Y les faltó mostrar , que mas encima ahora hay que sumarle la mantención, dr los caribeños provenientes de países fallidos😀😀
“When people say, ‘Oh, ask the people!’, it’s childish rubbish ... They say people can think for themselves? Do you honestly believe that the chap who can’t pass primary six knows the consequences of his choice when he answers a questions viscerally on language, culture and religion? ... we would starve, we would have race riots. We would disintegrate.”
Quoted in "Lee Kuan Yew: The Man and His Ideas, 1998"
100 % agree with you
So, you think your vote is worth more than that of a chap who can't pass primary six? Why not exclude unemployed and low income people while we are at it? Everybody's vote is equal.
@@mlynto that's the difference between you and the rest of us.
@@DennistheMenace2011if you want my vote, come and take it. It will cost you far more than your willing to pay for it though, boy.
Simping for authoritarians lol
damn man people writting their own constitution brings tears to my eyes and at the same time hate for conservatives who want a strong man in charge because they have daddy issues or something.
get therapy bro
ok commie
Looking at Chile giving me hope of far future humanity… btw, I’m ch!na-ian not Chinese ( nese is for things, not for people)
Pinochet dictatorship lasted 17 years only so you can imagine what the cubans have endure for the past 60+ years and the Venezuelans the past 30+ years.
Dont forget Nicaragua😢 poor people, boric want to make us believe left wind believe in democracy, so, what a liar
Can we talk about the legacy of the National Socialist German Workers' Party on Germany, otherwise known as the Nazi Party.
Chile ain’t perfect but socialism is not the answer!
Thanks 😊 DW. Interesting. No more strongmen dictators please. Keep trying.
Thanks for watching and for the feedback!
Maduro Castro Noruega kin yo un???
As a Chilean I feel ASHAMED to be represented by Valentina Miranda. She DOES NOT represent the common Chilean AT ALL; we don't look like that, we don't think like that and we don't act like it either. People of that sort are a MINOROTY which is being empowered by people who will benefit from their incompetence and lack of intellectualism. At least the Mapuches make it known
bueno entonces estas mintiendo, se ve super chilena, segun tu como se ven los chilenos?
it's quite humorous seeing an unnamed account that's only a day or two old (with an about page reading "Alexander Sokolov" in cyrillic), claiming Valentina Miranda doesn't look like the "common chilean". More humorous is seeing being told in straight spanish by an account (that is more likely chilean) that they're lying. It's obv that .RU disinformists don't even try anymore...
ajaja a llorar a otro lado. valentina es una mujer normal, encima inteligente y comprometida. lo que pasa es que personas como tu necesitan ver gente como kast o matthei en el poder. tu amor por el patrón no te deja verte en el espejo. vasallo
The Araucania (Mapucheland for those who don't know) is the most Right wing-leaned region in Chile by far, and that includes the mapuche-majority locations. You can look at the elections in Wikipedia. All the Guerrilla supporters are campus hipsters and activists living in the capital.
@@elgusaniiiodeljuego6823 only 10% of mapuche people vote, so you cant talk for all of them.
🚁
🤸♂️
🤸♂️
🌊
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It is so funny that random people from across the country are writing the Constitution of a country, which is the very essense of a welfare state.
Ofcrse the people are the primary stakeholder in this Constitution making, and their views and concerns do need to be represented. But just leaving the enormous task of writing such a vital document of a country to random people with no legal expertise will only turn out to be a fuss.
It would have been good if they could select proper well learned individuals in legal matters and law, then the people can speak through these individuals.
It is not a joke to simply write a Constitution, cause we are gonna be governed according to it. So we need proper and thorough study and research to deal with writing a Constitution. It is not simply about bringing our concerns and problems together and write it.
I think this approach will never produce a strong and comprehensive Constitution which will benefit the people.
Pinochet is the Father of our Nation. Viva Chile.🇨🇱
It was a wonderful introducing and truthful documentary show about several kinds of problems in Chile... departed dictator Pinochet constitution still is relying on for ruling Chelli..majority of Chellian population are demanding rewriting constitution for better lifestyle of peoples...it was a great document.thank you ( DW) documentary channel for sharing
HAHAHAHHAHA The majority of the population did not even ask for a new constitution, that is only in their wet dreams. Stop being intellectually indecent.
Mentira el 63% drl padrón electoral rn 2022 rechazó, el proyecto fr vonstitución onunista, globslista ......yo vivo rn provincia, y no soy rica.....viva el gra. pinochet!!
We are chileans, not chelians. Nowadays, people have no interest in the current process. The right wind have won the last election and are writting the new comstitution. We realize we dont want big changes the left told to people. We need peace.
Get your facts straight, there is not "unity" on getting rid of the "Pinochet" constitution.
GRANDE MI GENERAL PINOCHET ❤❤❤❤
An interesting documentary. The translation doesn't really convey what is actually being said. Rather, a lot of DW's Leftwing slant is being pushed here.
Pinochet was a hero who (along with the Chicago boys) made Chile by far the wealthiest country in Latin America (and that means all classes.... middle and lower classes are better off in Chile than anywhere else in Latin America). Inequality might be high in Chile but who cares. What really matters is how people are doing in absolute terms and the poor and middle classes in Chile are doing better than anywhere else in Latin America. Pinochet did some ugly things that we don't ever want to repeat but the pros of his administration greatly outweigh the cons. Stop listening to left wing propoganga and do your own research.
The best dictator in the world is the one and only lee kuan yew, can bring singapore from poor country to prosperity
In general the cold war right wing dictatorships had a better management of the economy, a far lesser death toll and transitioned eventually.
All praise Murica for their constant meddling in the affairs of other nations. Socialism for the rich and callous capitalism for the poor!
Stop being weak then.
Socialism for the weak minded, hungry, and fools. There were bread lines under Allende. So screw socialism.
Pinochets history of giving free helicopter rides to the mentally disabled should never be forgotten. It makes him an automatic hero in my book.
Chile is a great example of how democracy and capitalism are incompatible. Public opinion is bought through media and so effectively, that the people resist anything that's against the interest of wealthy owners of capital.
The best places to live in the world, The Nordic countries, are both democratic and capitalist with low corruption and strong welfare.
It’s clearly possible. Don’t expect perfection everywhere.
@@maxmillianwiegel1643 The Scandinavian countries face the same issue, they are not exempt from this. They are great places to live, but even the places where public opinion has resisted them most in the past face lobbyism, asymetric media exposure of political positions and after-the-fact corruption.
I quite frankly don't understand the logic in your point - the issue remains and demands reform of democracy to prevent it, even in the best working democracies that have it, doesn't it?
@@maxmillianwiegel1643 Barnevernet... All is not well in little Norway
What nonsense. Capitalism works well with democracy if there are enough resources for everyone. In a poor country, nothing works.
@@maxmillianwiegel1643 The key is to not privatize everything, especially not stuff people need to survive and infrastructure.
In Norway the Oil fund is a huge revenue for every Norwegian civilian.
I agree that not everything should be nationalized, but rental housing f.e. should be owned by the government.
It would be an extra money flow and the government wouldn't be so profit oriented.
Things that shouldn't be privatized too are electricity, mobile communications and water network, schools and universities, roads, train tracks, water, army, insurance, pharmazeutical (doesn't has to be) and medical sector.
The Nordics are the best example capitalism can work, aslong as it has a social component.
Aslong as that isn't the case, capitalism is the worst economic ideology out there. Only the rich and powerful profit.
And if you say, well they learned their stuff, then I will tell you most of them didn't.
Today you don't earn money with working, but with managing, corruption, swindling, stealing, inheriting or become famous.
These are the best ways to make money, working is outdated.
The Chilean constitution is also written by kids! Wow thats an innovation.... And does Chile have the money to implement a social state? most of the European states does have it...
Written by young
She should be sent to a labor camp, not a constitution convention
I was on Vacation there for 3 months when this happened. Had no idea until we were walking in Downtown Santiago (don'T recommend) when a rock flew in front of me, and hit a giant Police water cannon truck. Gf and I ran a block over, and then saw the protestors get the canon, and some arrested. Im unsure why the protestors needed to start throwing rocks.
Shame on dw. chavez also changed Venezuela’s constitution
my sad country
How about world peace let’s do that
that requires jobs and a lifestyle
The Muscovite empire disagrees also. There is no profit in not annexing other countries' land, genocide, rape, torture, murder. @@timmy-wj2hc
Like it or not, Indigenous people are the original owners, landlords of the land. If you want their land, buy it or rent it. Or else return it, don't steal it.
Los mapuches son foraneos....llegarón de las pampas argentinas.....uďs..hablan puras estúpideces
Congratulations Chile this is a big step. I rather have a constitution drafted and approved by diverse people who are still young and alive than by a group of no more than 10 white slave owners that died more than 100 years ago. A constitution is not the solution to all problems but it is a huge step forward.
Alright comrade! Fist up! Let's ruin everything because "young people".
Sure bro, that's why we MASSIVELY rejected your mamarracho constitution. I flew more than 1000 miles to vote against it and I'm damn proud.
DW IS ULTRA LEFT WING MEDIA!!! 😂
The Constitution should at least be neutral, not socially conservative and economically neoliberal, nor socialist/progressive, not written by lawyers like late Jaime Guzmán of the catholic conservative nationalist authoritarian/fascist military council government that were in power between 1973 and 1990,
it's imposible make an apolitical Constitution..
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
R.I.P my tio-abuelo Pinochet⚡🙏 U L T R A S ⚡
Lol 😂🎉 Pemala 🎉😊
Still better than communism.
This is outdated😂😂
Thank you Pinochet for avoiding Chile a civil war and keeping it clear of communist totalitarianism.
que hablas gringo loco. fue un dictador sanguinario iguales a los totalitaristas comunistas que piensas, la dictadura y las dictaduras mundiales se ven con los mismos ojos. un error que los países deben evitar
Agree, Pinochet did a good job transforming Chile into a prosperous country. Dictatorship morphed into democracy eventually but Chile did prosper. Communist dictatorships of Europe left misery, poverty and wars behind it. 62% rejection rate is huge. Obviously Chilean citizens are not stupid.
@@mlynto No sabes lo que sucedió en sí en ese proceso la verdad. ese "milagro económico" de Pinochet fue absolutamente desmontado por economistas a la vuelta de la democracia, con las crisis económicas del 83 y el crecimiento que eran menores a lo esperable. nunca existió una prosperidad en Chile durante la dictadura y en Chile ya tenemos esos datos que lo avalan.
en el proceso constituyente sucedió algo que la derecha y si investigas un poco más de como fue todo, las fake news y los malos entendidos se sirvieron excelente para la derecha y rechazar la propuesta. en sí, jugaron al juego sucio de la mentira y como dice el dicho: "es fácil engañar a la gente pero díficil decirles que fueron engañados". y eso lamentablemente le sucedió a mi país
What do you mean he prevented totalitarism with a dictatorship? I don't know if I have to cry or laugh, but firstly I'm dying in a sea of cringe.
@@25mbl1995didn’t Pinochet leave the Chilean economy more fragile? I feel like it was super prone to economic collapse. Poverty exploded during his rule it sounds like. Maybe I’m wrong idk.
Another one-sided documentary
it's an hour long and doesn't get around to mentioning the USA's role once?
In Germany, media does not mention US influence/interference. The US is branded as an ally.
Mídia ocidental 😂
Because that was so long ago and it was mostly the Chlean people's own fault.
@@ernst91 yes it's a long time ago so what lol, if they're going to make the video looking into something that happened a long time ago in the first place, then how do they spend an hour talking about it without mentioning how the dictatorship came into being or how it was perpetuated for whose benefit. And it was all the local people's fault, nothing external?
@@xeode If you blame America's role in Pinochet's rise to power for problems Chile experienced while he was in power in Chile then you have to give them credit for the successes Chile experienced while Pinochet was in power. Can't have it both ways!
3:10 This girl is just like dora the explore
30:38 50 % female quote means that males will be a minority? because you have to squeeze the rest of the spectrum in the remaining 50 % 🤔
Chile is the richest south American country thanks to General Pinochet.
No
They need to have Jesus Christ as the head of the country or Jesus will make it so by force of a man just see
Diversity brings on division.
Not here to support dictatorship or Pinochet's brutal regime or any such thing, but just reading this video's description makes it clear that the intent of this presentation is incredibly biased towards left wing statist systems and a government that is too powerful and intrusive and promotes the belief that people cannot control their own destiny nor do they have the responsibility to do so. Desiring paternalistic or messianic solutions, be it caudillismo or so-called democratic socialism, seems baked into Latin American political culture and therefore so are classism, corruption, failure, and inequity. Chile seems headed in the wrong direction. I'd also like to point out that "free" education and healthcare *are not free.* They involve costs that somebody has to pay. And that somebody is the citizenry, one way or another. Either by direct taxation or the higher cost of goods produced by companies who pay the taxes or the inflation caused by debt funded (unfunded) governmental spending.
!not here to support Pinochet" but supporting right wing abuse without thinking twice. But all this because left wing politics will cost the companies more taxes, plus oh the marrket, oh the inflation, blablabla. I'm happy to live in Brazil now that this trash right wing was banned for good and this false idea of individual taking decisions, which is impossible living in a sociaty where you have to work, to follow the rules, to learn your place, is again debunked and people are less sleepy. Merotocracy and individual DOESN'T EXIST, no matter how u good u sell this idea, it will never work.
What an absolute load of ideologised rubbish
@@solanjedere What abuse did I support? And in particular, what "right-wing" abuse did I support? What is your definition of "right-wing" and how does that apply to free market systems or "laissez-faire" economic philosophy? You don't believe leftist systems are inherently tyrannical or are automatically and always less so than "right-wing" (whatever that means) systems? By what twists of logic do you support that? How exactly were the ideals of free will, self motivation, and individual initiative and merit "debunked" in your mind? Of course individuals exist. They're everywhere. Even *you* are one of them and here you are expressing that fact on youtube. Meritocracy clearly exists. More so in some places than in others and always at least somewhat imperfectly in this imperfect world, but it does exist. Except where corruption or bureaucracy interferes with it or people make the conscious decision to ignore it. The next time you get on an airplane or cross a bridge or ride an elevator or have surgery you might think about the benefits of meritocracy and a system that requires people to have applied themselves and earned their positions. I wonder who it is that isn't thinking here 🙄
@@w___s Omg hahahaha..."next time u get a plane, elevator". I was about to answer u seriously but u seem to live in that irrational world where people think that socialism or communism is a lifetime contract with simplicity and poverty. Next time you makes those assumptions, think of China and ask yourself again if it doesn't work. You may be using RIGHT now a cellphone or a fabric, or a simple phone cable mad ein a COMMUNIST country. Don'r fool yourself in your liberal views because is clearly blinding you for reality. LOL
“Statist systems” and what is your alternative and was the alternative in Chiles case?Well Allende democratic socialist system killed zero people meanwhile Pinochet killed 10,000 people alone all in the name of free markets.Also read the history of capitalism,markets required and requiere violence and coercion to exist.Meritocracy being used as an excuse for inequality under capitalism is nonsense,is 8 people really worth more than 3 billion of the worlds poor combined?Or is it more likely that just in in feudalism and slavery before it a system of violence and inequality is enforced through law that gives some people ownership over key resources and some not?
The dictaorship has never ended, we are still living in fear and ooberty, suffering all the time
Old news!
We love Pinochet
Chile is and always will be the grave of communism
We rejected the communist constitution in 2022
El RECHAZO won!
Chile is a land of Order and Capitalism
🇨🇱
Yes! Quieren, modificar la Constitución, para que la ONU, tome el dominio sobre Chile, e imponer su Progresismo. Y los políticos actuales, ganando altos sueldos, en puestos estatales, quedando como "Casta". Y quiénes son contrarios a su Idiologia, Doctrina, los desprecian!
Show to 2
.3 percent people of the world u all r dead for me..
Add He was installed by the United States
The woman said certain services that the people have a right to. People have to right to others services just because you want them.. This is exactly the same logic if one said without slaves who would pick the cotton.. That's called utility, and it's not moral. No one has a right to someone else's labor without paying.. Just like you don't have a right to their kidney!
It's unbelievable that this has to even be said! It's because communism is in this for the long con / game. Communists are my sworn enemy! Socialists too which is just communism in which they try to sell it as humane and it never is!
The right to water, to bodily autonomy and the right to a roof over your head isn't radical. Are you against women having a right to their bodies? Are you against people having water? You sound like a bigot who justifies controlling a woman's body without her consent. Women have the right to their bodies and damn any man who would say otherwise.
There is no need to rewrite the Constitution. It is fine as it is. Pinochet was a great man❤
Aweonao
A hero.
Pinochet is the reason why Chile is not a poophole like Cuba
I agree that the constitution Pinochet gave Chile has not been the problem and agree that stopping Allende was vital as pointed out here by MultiRingtail, but Pinochet's murderous and inhumane brutality prevents me from agreeing that he was a great or good man. Several things can be true at once.
Psycho
Enough with this woke nonsense!!!!!
Indigenous are the owners of Territory Chile. The Chilean government and immigrants settlers have discriminated and stole Mapuche Land.
Mentira los mapuches son migrantes de las pampas argentina...no hablen ni se inmiscullan, en temas que no conocen!!!
@@elymiranda2971Primeras Naciones de Chile son "INDIGENAS" que sobreviven por siglos y siglos en medio de la Discriminacion y abuso. por la ignorancia de muchos! No reconcoer a los Indigenas como parte suya
Es ignorar la historia de Chile.y del resto de Planeta!
What proof do you have the Mapuche were there first?
コカイン服用。芥子樹脂服用は、厳禁です。
Geopolitics Not Chur Forte Clearly AmiGo ⚖ 💡 ✔
Indeed The Sarcasm Rocks Likke A Big Pulll 3am Across 🇺🇸 💉 Hilarious 💀 fentanyl Rocks ThE Cartels Supreamacy 🐎 🗽 💪 ✝ 🌶
US imperialism moment
One of the rare moments when US imperialism was a good thing
@@MultiRingtailpeople cant afford even the basics in chile's sprwling slums
@@MultiRingtail Guess you missed the part where it stated they have no access to water.
@@nomesobrenome336 That would still happen under Allende but with higher crime rates. If it was not for Pinochet, Chile today would be more like Cuba which is more similar to Allende’s policies
@@MultiRingtail yeah yeah, just like when lula gave a coup in 2002 brazil or something. Those damn commies, you know...
Giving opinions stright up your ass when reality is right upon your nose is peak right wing commentary