Why Soldiers HATED The M9 Bayonet

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024

Комментарии • 1,2 тыс.

  • @pyrobob5724
    @pyrobob5724 2 месяца назад +10484

    A knife the weight of an arming sword that doesn't have a full tang is wild

    • @tricksterjoy9740
      @tricksterjoy9740 Месяц назад +297

      Shit I’ve never thought about it like that.

    • @Indiana_Jesus
      @Indiana_Jesus Месяц назад +356

      ​ @tricksterjoy9740 That's the first s
      Thing that popped into my head because I was like 8 years old when I figured out how a katana and a baseball bat are roughly both the same weight 2 lb it always pops into my head as a reference point of weight because it was the first thing I really learned regarding weapons
      I also found it interesting because as a kid, I thought a baseball bat was heavier than 2 lb. That's when I first really learned about leverages and how weight can feel different depending on how it's distributed

    • @charleysimmons427
      @charleysimmons427 Месяц назад +50

      @@Indiana_Jesus not all baseball bats are 2lbs but on average it's true

    • @AtomicBreadCannon
      @AtomicBreadCannon Месяц назад +76

      I was going to say the same thing. The fact it didn't have a full tang is a crime

    • @oblivionshadow9453
      @oblivionshadow9453 Месяц назад +59

      The original rationale for the short screw tang was for the knife to be modular with different handles, however this never materialized so the M9 was left with a compromised tang.

  • @unclescipio3136
    @unclescipio3136 Месяц назад +6841

    "We made it thick so you can use it as a pry-bar, then gave it a tiny short tang so you can't use it as a pry-bar."

    • @1xayekim
      @1xayekim Месяц назад +295

      * Checks requisition form "Looks about right"

    • @pamelarobinson859
      @pamelarobinson859 Месяц назад +186

      Good Ole Army logic

    • @thadrobinson8343
      @thadrobinson8343 Месяц назад +212

      You have a future in government contracting.

    • @dieterhrabak4947
      @dieterhrabak4947 Месяц назад +77

      The ideal meets the economist..
      The end result something that makes the beancounters, cosplayers, video gamers happy at the cost of the unending ire and dissatisfaction from its users..
      Win-win solution i wouldn't say..

    • @patrickancona1193
      @patrickancona1193 Месяц назад +100

      Sound like “military grade” to me, the cheapest crap possible so politicians can embezzle the highest amount possible….+ 10% to the big guy

  • @jessemorris744
    @jessemorris744 2 месяца назад +10495

    A two pound knife SHOULD be unbreakable, thats wild

    • @anarchyandempires5452
      @anarchyandempires5452 Месяц назад +442

      I had to use this thing, I had convince a friend of mine from the German contingent To get an extra Glock for me since I didn't trust this thing for shit.
      BTW I mean the Glock knife not that Pistol although it's the same company, the German military used a really nice knife made by glock back in the day, I don't know if they still use it but it was excellent, pretty sure it's what made Glock famous well before they even had their pistols hard to remember it's been quite a few decades so I might be wrong.

    • @tim4570
      @tim4570 Месяц назад

      @@anarchyandempires5452What’s even more amazing is you can still buy them

    • @paudan1284
      @paudan1284 Месяц назад +75

      @@anarchyandempires5452I’m pretty sure they did horses before that iirc but that’s a separate company now

    • @Trve_Kvlt
      @Trve_Kvlt Месяц назад +46

      ​@@anarchyandempires5452It was replaced by the Eickhorn KM 2000 in the Bundeswehr, also a fantastic knife from what I've heard.

    • @munkemune
      @munkemune Месяц назад

      ​@@Trve_Kvltbusweizer?

  • @AVibinGoose
    @AVibinGoose Месяц назад +3787

    A pry bar, without any bar in the handle.

    • @orbatos
      @orbatos Месяц назад +89

      Yeah, it's such a bizarre weak point for such an unnecessarily heavy blade. Heavier than a shark knife and less durable. Everything about them sucks.

    • @MaximGhost
      @MaximGhost Месяц назад +3

      He's cherry-picking. Makes more sense had he said wirecutters instead of pry bar.

    • @cryotic7626
      @cryotic7626 Месяц назад +1

      That's not a tang... that's a joke...

  • @AGPWA
    @AGPWA Месяц назад +1184

    Remember: military grade means the lowest possible quality but enough to be serviceable.

    • @Algorithm_work_your_magic
      @Algorithm_work_your_magic Месяц назад +45

      I am laying on my 50 year old Marine poncho literally right now, works fine, sea bags work perfectly fine, saw an Etool in the store maybe 3 weeks ago, almost bought it but it didn´t come with a case

    • @sockpuppermcgee7920
      @sockpuppermcgee7920 Месяц назад +76

      Mixed bag. Military grade doesn't mean better, it just adheres to regulations set by the respective military. Their goods are typically made to be shock resistant, more durable, extremely weather resistant, etc. But not always, depends on the regulations and intended use.
      Custom stuff can be better, by a mile. They're often tailored to specific individuals, or handmade by stupidly skilled craftsmen. For weapons tho, it's hardly necessary. Gun shoot bullet, bullet kill, gunman happi. For melee weapons, clothing, backpacks, different story.
      They're not meant to be low quality or mass produced. Due to regulations, it can actually be harder and slower to produce these items, and if the regulations aren't "good enough", the items can be of lower quality than the industry standard in some cases.
      TL;DR, more expensive because of red tape, can be worse than regular items.

    • @pharaohsmagician8329
      @pharaohsmagician8329 Месяц назад

      ​@@sockpuppermcgee7920that's only in peace time. In war time, especially when the war drags on and actually become a fight for a nation's very survival, and supplies run low and are running out, military grade is the worst possible thing you can get! Lots of stories of WW2 and Vietnam soldiers getting really shoddy supplies or experimental aircraft/vehicles which didn't really hold up in realistic scenarios but looked good on paper. Military grade is never a good thing but yeah regulation and red tape gets in the way. And old gear that never got used gets sent off somewhere else or shows up decades later. Like on Russia Ukraine right now, they are using Soviet era stockpiles to get rid of them before they even start using the real modern gear so people especially conscripts and getting sent out with ancient technology knowing they are meant to be expendable lives, it's not even about gaining any territory it's just fueling the war to keep it alive until a political decision in another part of the world can be reached. Lots of middle East conflicts are also using Soviet era gear against modern American gear too. So the best military grade stuff of the past would be really old and not useful anymore but still forced in people's hands.

    • @yokai1235
      @yokai1235 Месяц назад +7

      ​@@Algorithm_work_your_magic he said military grade not special units grade

    • @logan7159
      @logan7159 25 дней назад +2

      So not the best you'll get but you could certainly get worse

  • @CrimsonFox36
    @CrimsonFox36 Месяц назад +1249

    as soon as i saw the tang, i understood

    • @acidz0037
      @acidz0037 Месяц назад +57

      Screw-in tang with a blade thickness of about a quarter inch? Yeah.. bad design 🤔

    • @Sharkwedge
      @Sharkwedge Месяц назад +8

      @@acidz0037 Mentioning screw-in in a reply to a furry with a fox pfp is double accurate

    • @acidz0037
      @acidz0037 Месяц назад +4

      @@Sharkwedge 😂🤣😂

    • @EeveeRealSenpai
      @EeveeRealSenpai 22 дня назад +1

      ​@@Sharkwedge mood

    • @johnnystankiewicz295
      @johnnystankiewicz295 3 дня назад

      WHY FOR FUCKS SAKES, WHY WOULD YOU GIVE THAT TINY DONG FOR A MONOLITHIC SIZED BLADE?
      They have wasted a fortune on making the absolute steel bar of the blade, so i doubt that i was about saving that bit of metal to just make a proper tang like in a glock fm78.

  • @markycash9368
    @markycash9368 2 месяца назад +1883

    That little screw at the end of the blade is a joke like why why do that so many better options

  • @choc0late_milk
    @choc0late_milk Месяц назад +496

    it being designed to be a pry bar and not having a full tang is insane

    • @WynnofThule
      @WynnofThule Месяц назад

      Not even a half tang, it's just a chode

    • @LouvreJaramill
      @LouvreJaramill 22 дня назад

      N

    • @WynnofThule
      @WynnofThule 22 дня назад

      @@LouvreJaramill What's up with your pfp? Do you hate the Jewish Autonomous Oblast that much?

  • @Ohnoitsthatguy-620
    @Ohnoitsthatguy-620 Месяц назад +900

    My squad leader, who was not a knife guy loved the M9. My section leader (The guy in charge of the Bradley's we rode in) was a total knife geek and I never saw him carrying or talking about the M9. That's all the confirmation I need.

    • @Quickdrawingartist
      @Quickdrawingartist Месяц назад +72

      Sounds kinda like the Codec call between Naked Snake and Sigint about the knife.

    • @highadmiraljt5853
      @highadmiraljt5853 Месяц назад +19

      @@Quickdrawingartistexactly my thoughts

    • @AR15andGOD
      @AR15andGOD Месяц назад

      Then ur a moron cuz that means nothing at all

    • @AR15andGOD
      @AR15andGOD Месяц назад +8

      Said yourself he wants a knife guy. Explains why he liked it

    • @MaximGhost
      @MaximGhost Месяц назад +8

      We were issued M7s when I was in. They were useless being so small. Now they're great?
      I call boolshite.

  • @bigbo1764
    @bigbo1764 Месяц назад +561

    Used to have surplus one as a emergency survival knife, shit broke in half when I needed it, luckily I was rescued pretty quickly, but since then I’ve only carried full tang knives.

    • @dunklezwiebel
      @dunklezwiebel Месяц назад +8

      @@bigbo1764 did it break in the handle or did the blade broke?

    • @KampucheanDemon
      @KampucheanDemon Месяц назад +46

      @@dunklezwiebelblade prob broke off at the handle.

    • @pohfromipoh
      @pohfromipoh Месяц назад +14

      Get the Soviet AK bayonet haha

    • @Ayeskint
      @Ayeskint Месяц назад +7

      Glad you got out safe, mate.

    • @bigbo1764
      @bigbo1764 Месяц назад +9

      @@dunklezwiebel broke off the handle

  • @cwbbakker
    @cwbbakker Месяц назад +1859

    Remembers of the COD quote: “Never forget that your weapon was build by the lowest bidder”

    • @SonJWri
      @SonJWri Месяц назад +18

      That doesn’t mean that it’s of cheap quality.

    • @UncleAsmos2005
      @UncleAsmos2005 Месяц назад +243

      ​@@SonJWri But what did we just see about one of these weapons?

    • @LiberPater777
      @LiberPater777 Месяц назад +42

      That goes waaaay back before COD

    • @Valentin_126
      @Valentin_126 Месяц назад +123

      ​@@SonJWri 99% of the time, it does. Very few times in history had the lowest bidder made quality stuff for the military. Anyone who's been in the military knows their equipment, gear, weapons, and vehicles are made of grade A Chinesium, and yeah you'd be surprised by how much the US relies on China. If China tomorrow said “we're not trading with the US any more” then the US military industrial complex would probably fall apart.

    • @Kratos-eg7ez
      @Kratos-eg7ez Месяц назад

      ​​@@Valentin_126 you clearly haven't been in the military and are 100% lying about it. Tell me again how they choose the lowest bidder when they spend billions on top-tier ammunition. Tell me again how they choose the lowest bidder when aircraft bolts cost over 80k. Tell me again how they choose the crappy cheap option when they chose the 1911, the m4, the Humvee, the Abrams, the f16, etcetera. Now I'm not saying everything is great, nor are the prices worth it like on the $80k aircraft bolts or the shitty Vietnam m16 or this shitty knife, but you're clearly bullshitting and lying. Not everything is made of chinesium, not everything is from the lowest bidder, not everything is the lowest quality. In fact, 99% of shit is very high quality, and we just nitpick through that last 1% and say that everything is crappy. So you had it completely backwards, n either that's complete negligence, or you intentionally lied.

  • @Cyberslugg77
    @Cyberslugg77 Месяц назад +51

    The fact this was meant to be a pry bar while having a baby tang is the kinda shit that makes me roll my eyes when someone tells me military procurement is a logical and well vetted process.

    • @damongeisler265
      @damongeisler265 20 дней назад +1

      If you have not seen Pentagon Wars, you should. Kelsey Grammer and Carey Elwes movie.

    • @clamdeity
      @clamdeity День назад

      The belief that anything of that scale can be a logical and well-vetted process is insane

    • @Noximillien-LHorloger
      @Noximillien-LHorloger День назад

      Except that movie should be taken as satire, nothing about the bradley is right tho its a funny version of how procurement can go wrong, just dont see anything as factual ​@@damongeisler265

  • @colemair5367
    @colemair5367 2 месяца назад +295

    It’s heavy to use as a prybar but it’s not strong enough to actually use as a prybar it’s too thick to use as a cutting Utensils which is its main purpose. Try sticking a bunch of Utility in some thing eventually it’s going to be less effective at each of those tasks.

    • @TheRealAaronSmith
      @TheRealAaronSmith Месяц назад +4

      The main purpose of a bayonet is NOT to slice. It's primarily a stabbing weapon, though slashes are implemented as well, though they aren't expected to be particularly effective at incapacitating anyone.
      These are meant to primarily be used as weapons. They can more or less hold up to use as such. They CAN be pressed into use as an improvised tool. That is not what they are meant for, nor should they be unless you have no other choice in an emergency.

    • @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj
      @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj Месяц назад +6

      I dont even get the product, like.. you have 2 pounds of metal, make the thing 50% longer and have a full tand at the cost of thickness.

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад +5

      Cutting is not it's main purpose. Stabbing is. Which it sucks at.

    • @ntfoperative9432
      @ntfoperative9432 Месяц назад +8

      @@TheRealAaronSmithanything that doesn’t have a full tang is pretty bloody useless as a weapon, because all you have to do is stab just the wrong way, and suddenly you don’t have a blade anymore

    • @TheRealAaronSmith
      @TheRealAaronSmith Месяц назад +1

      @@ntfoperative9432 behold the idiocy of the people arguing with me here:
      ruclips.net/video/mXYHOSdO1A4/видео.htmlsi=2cvOH8K4RhJAPhLn
      Also, doctrinally, bayonets are kind of a last ditch/standoff weapon. Ideally you're not using them for much but tearing open MREs and other trivial tasks suitable for a knife from the dollar store or some shit.
      You'll notice most SOF guys don't even bother with the bayonet, but they do carry a field knife. They are significantly more practical in nearly every aspect. Except potentially reach, since you're not gonna have an easy time securely mounting a field knife to a rifle, carbine, etc.
      Anyways. Are we done? Cause I'm getting sick of arguing with idiots and proving them wrong.

  • @MarcusKeith-z7b
    @MarcusKeith-z7b 2 месяца назад +201

    It’s become common for troops just to purchase their own knife. You get something suitable for your needs. I was a Seabee I carried both a fixed blade and folding knife. As well as a pair of linesman pliers every where I went.

    • @jersey3686
      @jersey3686 Месяц назад +11

      I was never issued a knife but I carried a nice Leatherman and a fixed bladed full tang kabar style with a serrated rear edge on my cutter ❤️

    • @glennschlorf1285
      @glennschlorf1285 Месяц назад +7

      Seabees!!!! Can do brother...

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад +13

      I used a cold steel SRK in Iraq. The police stole it from me when I got home.

    • @chuckschillingvideos
      @chuckschillingvideos Месяц назад +6

      When my stepson was sent to the sandbox, my wife and I made sure he went with an actual fighting bowie, a camp knife for cooking, and a multitool. He never once needed a prybar.

    • @jersey3686
      @jersey3686 Месяц назад

      @@ShellShock11C of course they did. Fuck cops 💀

  • @chainsawchanselour5452
    @chainsawchanselour5452 2 месяца назад +640

    I mean 2 pounds is the weight of some samurai swords
    Not to mention, imagine making a "prybar" with a fucking rat tang
    And the justification was "combatibility with multiple handles
    But like why would you need to replace the handle if the blade breaks lmao

    • @MosesPaulShelest
      @MosesPaulShelest 2 месяца назад +61

      Not to mention you can make a full blade tang and still have it be compatible.

    • @chainsawchanselour5452
      @chainsawchanselour5452 2 месяца назад +11

      @moshikon44 I mean the trench knife was doing it back in 1918

    • @reanukeeves4436
      @reanukeeves4436 Месяц назад +33

      2 pounds is the weight of some European LONGSWORDS

    • @mateomorales1653
      @mateomorales1653 Месяц назад +20

      Probably just some officers friend was part of the company doing the bid. Just how Glock beat out Sig in the performance trials by a considerable margin but the military still adopted the M17/18

    • @fionasabre
      @fionasabre Месяц назад +7

      2-3 pounds is pretty much the average of any sword if you exclude great swords😅

  • @gregtso7505
    @gregtso7505 Месяц назад +215

    Ah, good ol' DoD shitting the bed. Forever and always.

    • @bleekskaduwee6762
      @bleekskaduwee6762 Месяц назад +5

      That is what they are the best at

    • @theap0killyp1k2
      @theap0killyp1k2 Месяц назад +6

      ​@@bleekskaduwee6762That and wasting money.

    • @hateferlife
      @hateferlife Месяц назад +3

      @@theap0killyp1k2 Is it really a waste if it's intentional?

    • @will6671
      @will6671 Месяц назад +3

      I'm related to some of the employees... they seem to have a type they go for when hiring...

    • @subjectc7505
      @subjectc7505 Месяц назад +1

      Welcome to America

  • @1dcondave
    @1dcondave Месяц назад +76

    When I was in, the knife everyone wanted was the Gerber Mk 2, a slender, leaf-bladed, double-edged dagger with serrations near the hilt.

    • @chuckschillingvideos
      @chuckschillingvideos Месяц назад +8

      Yeah, because when there's an actual chance you might be in close combat, you probably want a good fighting knife.

    • @jacqirius
      @jacqirius Месяц назад +15

      ​@@chuckschillingvideos i can assure you that there is not a single incidence of a knife fight happening between a regular infantryman of the US and anyone else since 50 years

    • @mcRydes
      @mcRydes Месяц назад +4

      are the serrations on knifes like this ever actually useful? They seem so useless on my camp knives. . .

    • @chuckschillingvideos
      @chuckschillingvideos Месяц назад +8

      @@mcRydes I would imagine they might be useful for rough cutting things like rope and canvas - tasks that would dull the edge of a blade very quickly. But you can't really sharpen a serrated edge, so it's not useful on the working edge of a knife in my opinion.

    • @77wolf89
      @77wolf89 Месяц назад +6

      i was in for a long time and i had an old Cold Steel recon tanto i had to keep a very close eye on because team mates were trying to "borrow it" or trade me for inferior POS knives. That was/still is an amazing knife i will trust with my life

  • @Quickdrawingartist
    @Quickdrawingartist Месяц назад +19

    Our Army vet friend was watching me play REmake 2 and said "checks out" when the Combat Knife broke, and told me and my younger brother how shit it was when I broke another in the game.

  • @Gfunk8008
    @Gfunk8008 Месяц назад +25

    Think about how many people had to look over this design before it was finalized, put into production and then shipped out in the field. You’d think at least one person who knows anything about knives or the militaries needs would look at it and think there’s maybe a design flaw or two or ten. Just shows the people making them aren’t actually using them for their intended purpose

  • @user-eg3yv3xr7s
    @user-eg3yv3xr7s Месяц назад +30

    I've never heard anything good about the M9. When I was in the service, I was issued an M7. I found a great many uses for it. It never broke or let me down. I still have it after all these years.

    • @GazB85
      @GazB85 Месяц назад +1

      Is the M7 full tang?

    • @user-eg3yv3xr7s
      @user-eg3yv3xr7s Месяц назад +3

      @@GazB85 Yes

    • @GazB85
      @GazB85 Месяц назад +1

      @@user-eg3yv3xr7s Thanks.
      You don't happen to known I'd the Glock bayonet is full tang as well so you?
      I'm planning on getting either a US military bayonet, the AK47 bayonet or a glock but I want it to be full tang.

    • @user-eg3yv3xr7s
      @user-eg3yv3xr7s Месяц назад +4

      @@GazB85 No my friend, I don't know anything about the Glock bayonet. I'm not positive, but if you check the Glock website, you might find the answer to your question there.

    • @alanmeyers3957
      @alanmeyers3957 Месяц назад

      @@GazB85the Glock knife is not a bayonet

  • @lonewonderer7657
    @lonewonderer7657 Месяц назад +21

    I think the quote for this knife was "Jack of all trades... Master of none"

    • @Alsry1
      @Alsry1 Месяц назад +5

      Is oftentimes better than a master of one.
      But that quote doesn't apply.

    • @UGNAvalon
      @UGNAvalon Месяц назад +6

      While that may have been the intended quote that inspired it, the one it ended up embodying was “you try to satisfy everyone, you end up satisfying no one”.

    • @lonewonderer7657
      @lonewonderer7657 Месяц назад +2

      @@UGNAvalon in my mind trying to make a new bayonet is like trying to reinvent the wheel, i think the most useful design is the AK bayonet and anything else just use a multitool

  • @Arthiem
    @Arthiem Месяц назад +10

    "Lets make the blade extra thicc so it can be used to pry things open, oh thats a lot of money on steel. Lets get rid of that extra bit in the handle. You can't even see it!"

  • @bodiekarns2252
    @bodiekarns2252 2 месяца назад +7

    I have the Soviet counter part ten times better

    • @rareknives
      @rareknives Месяц назад

      but the steel is also shit

  • @TheColosiss
    @TheColosiss Месяц назад +6

    During 4-H by my instructor broke one to show the importance of structure in any tool. He is a Vietnam Marine Vet and taught us many important things. He also gave us context and real demonstrations to prove his knowledge. It is because of him that my pack is lightweight, and well-used during camping and hiking trips. Ounces turn to pounds, and in the Mid-West; WATER is far more important. 2 lbs is water for a good trek...

  • @lowkeyarki7091
    @lowkeyarki7091 Месяц назад +21

    2 pounds with a tang that short? i'd be more surprised if it didnt break

    • @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj
      @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj Месяц назад +1

      whats even more impressive is the fact its made of 420 stainless steel. its hard to work with, is expensive and is quite brittle but hard (good for cutting)
      yet they fucked up every part.. too thick to cut, too heavy for the tang to survive, expensive metal but cheap handle..
      they could have just had a decent plastic handle with actual pins holding it, from a downpoint view the handle is egg shaped so it wouldnt twist around. the knife could have a tougher but softer spine made of cheap metal to not shatter as easily + have the original 420 as the cutting edge with 30-50% of the weight off

    • @lowkeyarki7091
      @lowkeyarki7091 Месяц назад +2

      @@SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj honestly its better off being reforged, use that extra thickness to make it a full tang and give it a proper handle

    • @dimitriosxvt991
      @dimitriosxvt991 Месяц назад

      @@lowkeyarki7091 they are actually very reliable bc that little tang there is very thick, like the rest of the blade

    • @lowkeyarki7091
      @lowkeyarki7091 Месяц назад +1

      @@dimitriosxvt991 really? even if its that thick, if the tang doesnt even reach halfe of the handle wont the leverage from it getting stuck just break the handle instead?

    • @dimitriosxvt991
      @dimitriosxvt991 Месяц назад

      @@lowkeyarki7091 yes really, there is still a review on youtube where its getting extremely tested (breaking bricks, prying etc), look up for the "ontario m9 destruction test"

  • @dougjones3305
    @dougjones3305 Месяц назад +8

    Wanting it to be a pry bar without a full tang is one of the dumbest things I've ever seen.

  • @zaholykrusedar1459
    @zaholykrusedar1459 2 месяца назад +46

    Remember, military quality means munition quality, mass-produce as cheap as possible, still good enough to be usable but definitely NOT high grade

    • @johnywang8138
      @johnywang8138 Месяц назад +5

      milspec 😂😂😂 a cheapest sht they could afford so they can pocket themselves a million

  • @waynesmallwood6027
    @waynesmallwood6027 2 месяца назад +121

    Made from 420 steel, so they were supposedly unbreakable, but wouldn't hold an edge. I didn't know about the lack of a proper tang. Our tax dollars at work.

    • @thenotsodiscretewolf2098
      @thenotsodiscretewolf2098 2 месяца назад +5

      No tang was probably to drop waight, thickness and cost, the edge part was probably as a consequence of being too hard. Tho a weird thing is happening with camping knifes they are losing tangs. serious why do we update designs like the seax or something of them older designs.

    • @tcpieschke
      @tcpieschke 2 месяца назад +12

      @@thenotsodiscretewolf2098the lack of tang and screw on handle were for modular attachments that were designed but unfortunately never fielded.

    • @CreativeUsernameHere-r1k
      @CreativeUsernameHere-r1k Месяц назад +8

      ​@@thenotsodiscretewolf2098 not holding an edge and 420 stainless steel go hand in hand, it's basicaly a chinese kitchen knife. My ww1 M1895 Mannlicher or my soviet ak bayonet is way better for their designs.

    • @TheRealAaronSmith
      @TheRealAaronSmith Месяц назад +1

      Ffs people, they're bayonets, the intended purpose isn't cutting or slicing, it's stabbing/puncturing. And they hold up pretty solidly to that.
      If you want a field knife, go get a field knife. Not a bayonet.

    • @Dav624
      @Dav624 Месяц назад +1

      @@TheRealAaronSmith my man if ur telling me the government can't produce even a unbreakable knife for all outdoor needs a soldier may have during service whilst ur paying taxes to fund them specifically for that purpose and giving ur life for them than it's clear joining the military is just a scam and that the government doesn't even care about their own soldiers let alone winning or losing wars

  • @seabornetomcat2340
    @seabornetomcat2340 2 месяца назад +63

    Me and my dad found one in the mountains while hiking. That knife was a beast. I’ve split campfire wood with it while camping. I didn’t know about the tang being so small and I wouldn’t have guessed how bad it was with how much that knife did.

    • @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj
      @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj Месяц назад +14

      its pretty easy to fix if you want to blacksmith as a side hoby, either use a welder or forge weld on a full tang, then stretch out that knife and bend some higher quality steel into a taco shape around its original edge, use a welder and then forgeweld it evenly out, then sharpen it and even it out on a grinder

    • @Lukronius
      @Lukronius Месяц назад +8

      @@SebastiansSebastian-fc4pjWhy on earth would anyone do that? If you’re already using pieces of steel to fix basically everything about the blade, just get some flat bar stock, profile it, heat treat, use the grip off the M9 if you want.

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад +4

      You FOUND one!? That ruined someones day big time. Those thinks are a couple hundred a piece. I have one.

    • @smithsmith1956
      @smithsmith1956 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@ShellShock11C$99 for mine. It was made by Onterio. They're supposed to be really good knife makers.

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад +2

      @@smithsmith1956 They are, but they dropped the ball on the design with the M9 in a big way. It should NEVER have been a rat tail design. Ever.

  • @chillios2222
    @chillios2222 2 месяца назад +61

    issued mine in the 101st , really worked well actually for field tasks

    • @hankmann627
      @hankmann627 Месяц назад +1

      I use an M10, that thing is genuinely so much better

  • @Off-HandedBarrel
    @Off-HandedBarrel Месяц назад +6

    This is why I carried a SEAL Pup and a multi-tool.

  • @famvirious
    @famvirious Месяц назад +4

    A tang is LITERALLY the most important structural part of your knife. A thin or short (especially short) tang makes a knife near worthless ESPECIALLY IF USED AS A FKING PRYBAR

  • @piotrmalewski8178
    @piotrmalewski8178 Месяц назад +3

    One thing do add about AK-47 bayonet vs. this one, is that was not necessarily even supposed to be used. My uncle was in military in Communist Poland in 1950s, they got brand new AK-47s and he said they would never have bayonets and regarded having a bayonet on AK as 'a stupid idea'.
    He also often mentioned the triangular bayonet on the Mosin rifle. He remarked; that it served as a weight balancer for shooting and argues that 'it was a humanitarian weapon because unlike American's, it was traingular without any blade, so whoever you stabbed would be knocked down, but had better chance of survival'.

    • @flatheadgg2443
      @flatheadgg2443 Месяц назад +2

      Um isn't the whole point of triangular blades to make the wound even worse?

  • @Kishqui
    @Kishqui Месяц назад +5

    Former infantry here.
    Everything he said is true.
    They also broke easily (stupid, non-existent tang.)

  • @darkdancer9563
    @darkdancer9563 Месяц назад +7

    2 POUNDS? That is a goddamn sword💀

    • @Jayseanderson5
      @Jayseanderson5 Месяц назад

      ik its to heavy they need something lighter in a hand to hand combat

    • @dtester
      @dtester Месяц назад

      It's actually 1 pound. Video made a mistake but even 1 pound is considered heavy for a knife.

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад +1

      @@Jayseanderson5 Hand to hand combat isn't really a thing anymore. If it comes down to that, soldiers carry a pistol.

    • @UGNAvalon
      @UGNAvalon Месяц назад

      @ShellShock11C And when your pistol jams or runs out of ammo?

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад

      @@UGNAvalon Then you're a moron who is about to die because they didn't maintain their firearms, or you clear the jam. The M9 was my third firearm. After my Machine gun and rifle. If ALL of those are down, the fault is on me, or the shooter.

  • @Tiannoran
    @Tiannoran Месяц назад +2

    Well, that explains why my knife was constantly breaking on me in Resident Evil 4.

  • @PROJEKT_R3D
    @PROJEKT_R3D Месяц назад +7

    I was actually given one of these from a relative as a graduation gift. As clunky and bulky as it is, I've been glad I've had it while working around my woods and yard more times than I can count. Living in the NE means you find barb wire grown into trees everywhere, vines and pricker bushes, everywhere and I've even used it to field dress. I can see why it would suck in combat, but from a civilian standpoint, I love this thing

    • @FalconWindblader
      @FalconWindblader Месяц назад +1

      I'd wager that if you've had been given something just a modicum better & wayyyy lighter for its intended purposes to work with, you too would've spitted on this one like everyone else.

    • @PROJEKT_R3D
      @PROJEKT_R3D Месяц назад +1

      @@FalconWindblader whatever you wagered you owe me. I have many many knives, kabars to mauser bayonets. I just prefer this for when I'm outside

  • @ianyoung6706
    @ianyoung6706 Месяц назад +1

    “Hey, let’s say it’s heavy so you can pry with it”
    -gives it a quarter-inch tang

  • @cougar9610
    @cougar9610 Месяц назад +3

    "Can be used as a prybar"
    - Tiny ass tang
    Wtf was the thought process?

  • @basaltcrust1915
    @basaltcrust1915 22 дня назад +1

    This is why its important to remember that "Military Grade" doesnt mean "Badass Super Cool Grade" but instead means "Able To Be Mass Produced Grade"

  • @Nara.Shikamaru
    @Nara.Shikamaru Месяц назад +3

    Really? They can’t even feed their own people, but they can afford full tangs? Fuck the cheapness of our government knows no bounds.

  • @vincentvalentine4401
    @vincentvalentine4401 22 дня назад +2

    Holy crap that knife looked so good! Wtf were they thinking?!

  • @hfOnyx
    @hfOnyx Месяц назад +9

    No that tang is the death of it would absolutely snap off the handle

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад

      I've never seen it happen, but I agree.

  • @Jazzman-bj9fq
    @Jazzman-bj9fq Месяц назад +1

    The funny thing is when I was going to be deploying to Somalia back in the day Central Issue Supply wouldn't issue me an M7 bayonet so I bought my own M9 from U.S. Cavalry. Spent alot of money on it even then in '92 but I won't get rid of it 30 plus years later. They're worth some decent money now too.

  • @oucquan2436
    @oucquan2436 Месяц назад +3

    "To be use as a pry bar if needed"
    Proceed to remove the tang
    Who the hell design this thing?

  • @evanf1443
    @evanf1443 Месяц назад +1

    You can have a thick-spined knife that still cuts well, so that’s more of a point against it than you’d think.

  • @Foundry_made
    @Foundry_made Месяц назад +3

    Broke 2 on tires in the bayonet course at Parris Island.

  • @mitchellsmith4690
    @mitchellsmith4690 Месяц назад +1

    We didnt hate it. We considered it an improvement.

  • @ferrisbueller9991
    @ferrisbueller9991 2 месяца назад +9

    A survival knife should be what is carried on the hip... why not have an ultra-light dagger that can be fixed for the bayonet option. Two knives isn’t streamlined enough.
    Honestly normal survival knife and a folding spike on the gun would be fine.

    • @G1NZOU
      @G1NZOU 2 месяца назад +5

      To be fair, Austria did it right with the Glock knife, it functions as a bayonet while still being a decent knife and the handle is pretty good even though it's not full tang.

    • @Themaxwithnoname
      @Themaxwithnoname 2 месяца назад +5

      ​@@G1NZOUwhile the Glock knife isn't a full tang, it's like 3/4 of the handle or so, it's significantly more substantial than that.

    • @G1NZOU
      @G1NZOU 2 месяца назад +2

      @@Themaxwithnoname Very true, it's not absolutely indestructible, but it's very well made and sturdy.

    • @CollinMcLean
      @CollinMcLean Месяц назад

      @@G1NZOU Plus you can use the guard as a bottle opener.

  • @logangrimnar3800
    @logangrimnar3800 Месяц назад +1

    Marching with these was terrifying. I remember every left step watching the tip of the blade in front of me teeter towards my right eye.

  • @marth8000
    @marth8000 Месяц назад +3

    a 2lb knife that doesn't even have a full tang...
    What the fu** where they thinking?

  • @TealScarab
    @TealScarab 2 дня назад

    From a blade designers perspective, the thing I find immediately striking is the round handle!!

  • @justin764
    @justin764 2 месяца назад +9

    The worst of all is that it's blade material was 440 steel. 440 steel is material commonly used for kitchen knives, easy to sharpen but not strong enough to be used as a tool.

    • @slappy8941
      @slappy8941 2 месяца назад

      "It's" is a contraction of "it is", and "its" is possessive.

    • @rareknives
      @rareknives Месяц назад

      it was 420 not 440

    • @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj
      @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj Месяц назад

      thats cause its brittle but hard, the opposite is tough but soft.
      its a high carbon metal used for scalpels that can easily shatter, at least a lower carbon spine would have justified the weight
      this shit is just horrible. literally needs a stronger spine and a longer tang.

    • @chuckschillingvideos
      @chuckschillingvideos Месяц назад +1

      @@rareknives Which is even softer and cheaper.

  • @xeno.6146
    @xeno.6146 Месяц назад +2

    "Military grade" at its finest

  • @georgecampbell2279
    @georgecampbell2279 2 месяца назад +13

    I liked them. 1997 - 2004 Army.

  • @tophmerc
    @tophmerc 8 часов назад

    I dunno why but the digital texts is so funny cause it makes me think that actual people in the war wrote them 😭

  • @Leftyotism
    @Leftyotism 2 месяца назад +6

    You mean thickness behind the edge, when you say thickness behind the blade.

  • @Book-bz8ns
    @Book-bz8ns Месяц назад

    That particular bayonet is great.
    As long as it stays in a footlocker.
    The tang is the main problem. I've seen a lot of the broken at that point.

  • @marvinbrock960
    @marvinbrock960 2 месяца назад +9

    I can testify.. it sucks. It seems like whoever the military delegates to pick this stuff does not have a clue about what they’re choosing… and it never ends.. 🤷‍♂️

    • @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj
      @SebastiansSebastian-fc4pj Месяц назад

      no they just see you as a meaningless number. its actually beneficial if the product is good enough to win a war but at the cost of multipe casualties.
      breeds out the strongest men with strongest willpower to actually influence their country.. Ruby Ridge didnt end well.. but what did is when the veterans faught against a corrupt police station in the 80s or so

  • @pirobot668beta
    @pirobot668beta Месяц назад +2

    We were issued M7's way back when...1977?
    We were told they were 'stabbing only' weapons when mounted on the rifle.
    When not mounted to the rifle, we had to return the blade to the Armorer!
    Come to think of it, they only time we carried bayonets was during a Parade...never on field exercises.
    Signal Corps was built different.

    • @gregoryhagen8801
      @gregoryhagen8801 Месяц назад

      & it wouldn't stay sharp. I carried a box cutter. 11B.

  • @spiderbugbear3721
    @spiderbugbear3721 2 месяца назад +3

    I am a soldier and I love it. 😂 The rumors are vastly exaggerated

    • @Dav624
      @Dav624 2 месяца назад +10

      Are u perhaps a keyboard soldier?Or a csgo soldier?Because that would explain a lot

    • @justyourlocalwitchhunter9184
      @justyourlocalwitchhunter9184 Месяц назад +6

      You like knife that made of same material as kitchen knife, with petruded metal that constanly stab your leg, and super fragile despite the weight that rival a goddam samurai sword.

    • @yobrodontshoot1130
      @yobrodontshoot1130 Месяц назад +1

      @@Dav624He mustn’t be a Soldier because he has a different opinion than you and this video?

    • @yobrodontshoot1130
      @yobrodontshoot1130 Месяц назад +1

      @@justyourlocalwitchhunter9184Yeah, he does. If it works for him, it works for him.
      I literally only used a folding knife when I was in. Those are by and large way more likely to break than this.

    • @Dav624
      @Dav624 Месяц назад +2

      @@yobrodontshoot1130 that's why I put "?" At the end of each question and not a "." Because I'm not implying anything I'm just asking strange how u didn't see that isn't it?

  • @ChaseddiHondo
    @ChaseddiHondo 8 дней назад

    Screwable tangs should be a crime by itself, but a tang THAT SHORT?? I'm convinced whoever the hell designed this knife only has experience as far as using a bread knife

  • @dwightchaos9449
    @dwightchaos9449 Месяц назад +4

    After Rambo 2, I think just about every 11 yr old country boy had one of these. Compass on the back, fishing line, hooks, sinkers, inside the handle!!!
    We weee ready to survive at least a couple years with that alone!!! 🤣🤣

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад

      Thats not an M9 bayonet. Thats a cheap movie knockoff. I remember those, but it's not this knife.

    • @chuckschillingvideos
      @chuckschillingvideos Месяц назад

      @@ShellShock11C Some of those absurd fantasy survival knives actually went for quite a bit of money. If memory serves the Gerber example was particularly sought after.

    • @lanceroberthough1275
      @lanceroberthough1275 Месяц назад

      That Rambo knife has nothing to do with this knife. You don't know what you're talking about.

    • @ShellShock11C
      @ShellShock11C Месяц назад

      @@lanceroberthough1275 I agree, but they just look similar and he may be miss remembering.

    • @dwightchaos9449
      @dwightchaos9449 24 дня назад

      @@lanceroberthough1275 relax Francis. I know it’s not the same exact fukin knife. Go learn something or go outside. Trying to be a smarty pants on the internet make you look weak and needing a self esteem boost. Just so ya know. I didn’t think I had to explain that part as it was just a joking memory of a somewhat similar knife.
      Why so serious?

  • @pocketsand4404
    @pocketsand4404 Месяц назад

    Never had experience with this knife, but the Glock 81 field knife and AK bayonet have both been solid for me. Good working man's knives that are inexpensive.

  • @RachDarastrix2
    @RachDarastrix2 2 месяца назад +3

    Almost 2 pounds? Am I just really strong?

  • @blaznskais2048
    @blaznskais2048 Месяц назад

    Gotta love that military logic

  • @user-xm9zi2qv1p
    @user-xm9zi2qv1p 2 месяца назад +3

    Ese.cuchillo es solo basura.....el que lo diseñó no tenía ni idea de un cuchillo

  • @johnwayne3085
    @johnwayne3085 Месяц назад

    Im a retired Army Infantryman Our unit armorers brought our bayonets to Iraq in 05 but they sucked so much I never saw them in any arm's room in any unit until i retired.

  • @Don69420
    @Don69420 2 месяца назад +3

    Prybar without a tang. Its laughable really

  • @vrnsmth
    @vrnsmth Месяц назад +1

    broke mine in BCT in 2011. Drill sergeants laughed and said "theres always one" but I didn't know it was so universally hated because we basically stopped using them after BCT. In fact, I was never issued one again.

  • @HB013b
    @HB013b Месяц назад

    I can recommend 6H3 which is the old soviet bayonet. I've used it for everything from cutting fences to chopping firewood and it has never let me down.

  • @bobbressi5414
    @bobbressi5414 26 дней назад

    When Lockheed Martin developed the F-22 raptor the designers went to both pilots and ground crew and asked them what sort of changes they could implement to make it better than previous generation aircraft. They used a great deal of that input to make a better fighter that was easier to work on and by all accounts the ground crews that work on them love them and the pilots appreciate the cockpit layout. It seems to me if you're going to make something you should get some feedback from the end user before sticking them with something they hate.

  • @timothynaquin8899
    @timothynaquin8899 Месяц назад

    In the Marines I was issued the M7 which came before the M9 but with some better bayonet. But before I left the Marine Corps that bayonet fighting knife they issued us was gorgeous

  • @ashadowawhisper
    @ashadowawhisper Месяц назад +1

    When I went to Iraq, the good ol Marine Corps issued me an Mk.7 bayonet. Never once saw an Mk.9. But that was the beginning days of GWOT. We also were issued woodland plate carriers.

  • @craigthescott5074
    @craigthescott5074 26 дней назад +1

    I own one of these I didn’t know it didn’t have a full tang. I gave my son in the USMC a Dawson fighting knife which is very well made.

  • @crusader3108
    @crusader3108 22 дня назад +1

    You know we are an advanced civilisation when we cant even make a functional knife for military purposes.

  • @bornonthebattlefront4883
    @bornonthebattlefront4883 Месяц назад +1

    The M9 is like the perfect example of how to make something that looks like a knife physically
    But functions nothing like a knife
    It’s also made of 420
    Which, while very tough
    Can’t hold an edge for longer then 50 cuts on abrasives
    Steels like Nitro V or AUS 8 are only slightly less tough, equally (if not better) stainless, and can actually get over that 100 cut mark before dulling
    That and with a TERRIBLE ergonomic design
    It’s just the knife no one wants, even if you aren’t a knife guy, you won’t like this knife
    It “looks cool” but that’s it

  • @bizudamarasengan
    @bizudamarasengan 5 дней назад +1

    Oh that's why I hated it in game. It always felt like something was wrong with that knife.

  • @RagingEggs
    @RagingEggs Месяц назад +1

    "Very small tang"
    That tang is non existent.

  • @natp8387
    @natp8387 Месяц назад

    As my father (who was ex military though not in the US, an antiques dealer and a wilderness guide) would say: 'Bayonets are for stabbing and to counter barrel climb, anything else you're wasting your time.'

  • @elijahrobinson2362
    @elijahrobinson2362 Месяц назад

    You KNOW someone got the contract and the people who chose it got kickbacks.

  • @bradeng367
    @bradeng367 26 дней назад

    Ive rarely met anyone who hates the m9, there are many iteratioms and the later ones are quite nice. Ive got a cheap knockoff myself and quite enjoy it. Im not a service member, but as an avid outdoorsman its a near perfect survival knife and is incredibly versitile. My only complaint is that mine is lacking some power in the wire cutter designed to cut barbed wire fencing, but i dont necessarily plan to do a lot of barbed wire cuttinf anyways, so a very minor hangup. I got mine for around $30 on amazon, compared to nearly 200-300 for a legitimate m9 sabre, so the downside is easily outweighed by the nearly 90% discount i bought it for

  • @wingzero7X
    @wingzero7X Месяц назад

    Imagine how scary the military would be if they let them “build their class” as it were, personal knives, guns, etc

  • @wolf17238
    @wolf17238 Месяц назад

    K-Bar - "If ain't broke, don't fix it"

  • @CubeFrog
    @CubeFrog 9 дней назад

    That "tang" is a freakin' tragedy, jfc

  • @Heurigijdbd
    @Heurigijdbd 21 день назад

    thick enough to be a pry bar but the second you use it as a pry bar it’ll snap at the tang

  • @OssianEMills
    @OssianEMills Месяц назад

    Had one issued at CIF, every time I PCS’d, but never used it. Leatherman or Gerber usually got the job done.
    The only time we used it was in BCT.

  • @ShellShock11C
    @ShellShock11C Месяц назад

    Ex Infantry Army grunt here. We were issued these when we deployed to Iraq and I was one of the last generations to go through the bayonet assault course in Fort Benning. And yeah, it's not a great bayonet. I'll never understand whey they just didnt make it ful tang, instead of the pointless over complicated screw tang. That and the handle is circular, which sucks. The only good side to this bayo is the blade is INSANELY strong. I got drunk one night and quite literally stabbed a stone wall full force, and I'm a big dude. No damage at all other than scrathing.

  • @bigdaddy7119
    @bigdaddy7119 Месяц назад

    The M9 was ok, and the blade thickness had NOTHING to do with it’s cutting ability. That was due to the type of steel it was made of, and 99% of soldiers not knowing how to properly sharpen a knife. I could literally shave with mine.
    That being said, my daily carry/use knife and/or tool as a Medic, since we didn’t carry out M9’s unless we were deployed or in the field) was my Spyderco semi-serrated knife and my Gerber multi-tool. I also purchased my own Ka-Bar, for “other” purposes.

  • @imdoobie80
    @imdoobie80 Месяц назад

    It was good for opening our MRE'S, but that was it. Almost everyone in my platoon kept a second knife and a multi tool.

  • @garbagebeans6939
    @garbagebeans6939 Месяц назад +1

    We made this knife thicker so it could be used as a pry bar, and we also gave it a tiny ass tang so it could break at the first instance of being used as a pry bar

  • @Daniel-lw1po
    @Daniel-lw1po 14 дней назад

    I'm not a soldier, but I am a tradesmen, knives make bad prybars, use a pipe, two by four, stick literally so many things u can find around you work better

  • @bobholly3843
    @bobholly3843 Месяц назад

    Sounds exactly how something "Government Issued" would be built.

  • @ManInTheWoods76
    @ManInTheWoods76 Месяц назад

    Switching knives is faster than reassembling

  • @BagelmanSupreme
    @BagelmanSupreme Месяц назад

    “Hey look we made this knife to work as a pry bar! Don’t try pry anything open tho you’ll snap it in half” awesome work guys!

  • @kylechesney2740
    @kylechesney2740 Месяц назад

    Not being MOLLE compatible is the least of this bayonet concerns, but MOLLE didn't exist when the bayonet/sheath was introduced in 1986

  • @goodwinter6017
    @goodwinter6017 Месяц назад +1

    That tang!?!? Yeah, whom ever made the knife, has absolutely no idea how to make a knife.
    This is probably the actual problem with it!

  • @Herowebcomics
    @Herowebcomics Час назад

    No wonder they hated it!
    They wanted people to use it as a pry bar?!
    It's a KNIFE!
    Just give them a pry bar!

  • @PsychoC4rnivore
    @PsychoC4rnivore Месяц назад

    Remember guys: “military grade” means the thing that barely passes requirements for the cheapest cost

  • @SkyfireHero
    @SkyfireHero 2 дня назад

    Meanwhile the KA-BAR and Fairbairn Sykes dagger continue to exist and be damn fine knives