Villa fan here. Great game. Celtic had some great attacks and worked well especially from the wing. Fair play to the fans and the club on a whole. Great club. I look forward to if we ever play them again 💜💙/🧡💚🤍
I’ll always buzzing to watch Villa. Exciting and powerful team. Celtic punting our top striker before this game is beyond madness. It’s hard enough with the TV money factor etc. Great Ozzy tifo btw.
@@arod9998 Most Celtic supporters haven't a clue about the IRA or Irish history in general, just like the other crowd from Govan who know nothing about the songs they are singing.
@@arod9998 CTA prior to the match! 😂😂😂 In case you hadn’t noticed, the ‘RA haven’t been active for the last 20 years! Move on and stop playing the victim living in the past.
Villa’s two second half goals were sickening. You are spot on. Both Scales & Engels had to make a foul & the mistake at the end was avoidable. It’s a real bug bear of mine with our inability to take an offensive throw in. We always go backwards & did so again in the final few minutes. We have a throw in deep in their half & we end up taking our next throw in from our defensive third. Who is coaching our set pieces & throw ins? On the game itself, I was dreading tonight but was delighted with how the boys performed. Just too many silly mistakes & a lack of options from the bench. They also made some errors but we were unable to punish them as they did with ours. I think if we had Maeda & Kyogo out there we would have taken a point. Disappointed with what must be seen as a lack of ambition in letting Kyogo & Valle go before the games were done.
I've constantly been embarrassed at the miss management by Rodgers all this season, the team picked last night and even the lateness off trying to salvage anything was completely embarrassing at least 4wks since MacGregor captained the team with any purpose and authority, Taylor, Yang, Scales, Bernardo, Palma all non starters for me. were head for a catastrophic runners up spot in league with Rodgers clueless and I was of these opinions as soon as team was announced. Gave their all, they aren't capable.
A VERY Strong Side and Play Expansive Attacking Football at Pace. They Were Excellent at Easter Road in Europe Last Season, Digne In Particular was Superb, and They Have Improved since Then. A Great Coach...And With ‘Super John McGinn’...A Side I Enjoy Watching. BUT Last Night After 5 Minutes...Thought it was Going to Be a Dortmund Repeat!!!
Loved having Celtic at Villa Park, these are the occasions that matter. For what it's worth, I thought Celtic were clearly a really good time, some really nice football at times and there wasn't a huge gulf between the teams. To come back from 2-0 showed great character. Respect. UTV!
Just after the 2nd goal, TV camera panned to Celtic supporters and there you were Paul, looking like how we all felt, kicked in the ba's. Fair review as always. Good to see the young bhoys get a bit of game time. Hopefully see more of them from now on and prove there is a gateway from our academy to 1st team player.
Be GREAT to See That Pathway Maximised. Dede Looks Like The Next to Go South...Middlesbrough This Time. He May be 5th Choice at RB...So We Definitely Develop Talent. I’m ‘Old Skool’...I LOVE to See The Academy Guys in the First Eleven...But it’s A HIGH Bar.
we've conceded around 5-7 times this season from scales doing that high press bs, hes been caught out of position doing it almost every time and we always concede from it, completely unacceptable
Congratulations guys. A really good analysis of the game. Just 1 additional thought (from a Villa perspective). The momentum changer in the first half was the injury to Matty Cash. The change with Villa’s shape unsettled Villa’s right hand side for the next 10 mins, leading to the spirted comeback from Celtic which made the contest superbly entertaining. Thanks again. Great channel. UTV.
Idah good, Hatate good, Schmeichel good, slack passing and defending cost us goals we are still a bit naive and we need to be stronger definitely need to look at a physical presence in midfield in the summer we really struggled against that Rogers tonight he bossed us about can't say I'm angry or anything though you can tell the players gave a lot to that game and coming back from 2 down was heartening stuff when it looked like another Dortmund.
@arod9998 The English occupied Ireland for 800 years. They're still there in the northeast. What you call the rebels still managed to finally liberate 26 counties from 700 years of English occupation. Who's more entitled to feel aggrieved? Not the English. Dry your eyes and get over yourself.
To get anything we needed to have our full team out and not sell our talisman player days before🥲 Alas next time. Villa are a slick outfit, constantly on the half turn.. Rogers is unbelievable.
Nice to see Scott back on the channel. Proud to be a celt this season in Europe. Hatate missed a few chances last night that you have to be clinical at that level, he had a good game though. Scales and trusty make you nervous
@richardlawes2697 clearly you taking nonsense we got 4 free kicks whole night ref was desperate to blow anytime villa hit deck u miss Tielemans blatant dive and no chance is that a pen big uefa ref let's give the millions of pound team every little help
Just look at the third villa goal, McGinn just bodies Engels. No shade on Engels but we a strongman in midfield to break up attacks. Tbf, McGinn is one of the best in the world at using his arse to good effect haha but you’re spot on, need that defensive minded 6 player.
When small teams like Dundee and Rangers can hurt us on the turnover, what do you expect against Villa. Its turning the ball over that is the major issue and how we respond to it. That happens in the opposition half.
Agree. We are struggling to recover when we are high up the park, that looks like fitness and fatigue with all the games we play, but also we need a midfielder with recovery pacr
@craigferri2162 yeah agree, but we had 4 or 5 key players and new signings to come back and Villa were at home and needed the win more. We gave a great account of ourselves but it exposed the need for more recovery pace in midfield. As good as Hatata was offensively he does leave us a man down in opponent transitions. We cant start Hate away from home at this level and we need a midfielder with more recovery in the summer.
@@ajsctech8249 Our lack of recovery has nothing to do with fitness levels during defensive transitions, but everything to do with the understanding and application of recovery lines, situational & positional awareness and overall ability to read the game. Added to the fact our mid 3 have no natural running power. This is precisely what happens when you have a manager that thinks he can get away with playing a done and dusted Calmac as a single-pivot/6 when his legs have gone, playing Engels as a box-to-box, Reo being asked to cover too many zones across practically 3 channels, and overall, continuing to run with a middle 3 that is imbalanced.
Got to remember we were 4 players down compared to our last game with a very weak bench. Our midfield despite being strong in Scotland is so weak in Europe and easy to get through putting the defence under pressure. Rodgers putting Murray on ahead of a 4 million pound defender is madness We need a winger, a striker, a left back and a right sided centre back as Ccv is injured far too often
I just read there was trouble after the game, hope you all got up the road safely. What a ride that game was. Consider this: no CCV, KT (2 stick on starters when fit), Valle (arguably same level as Taylor), Jota, Maeda or Kyogo (available all starters or at least pushing Kuhn)... no potential Ørjasæter, Slotsager or Kvistgaarden Started with squad players Yang and Scales, ended with fringe player Palma, youth player Murray and debutante/youth player Cummings .. it was remarkable we did so well and were in it so long. 2 early goals conceded, even half, finish with 2 goals. Applause well earned for Idah 2nd half was edged towards Villa but we had no bench, no LB, no ST, no wing subs, subbing fringe players for fringe players and guys that usually play in the Highland League with our unders. To make a game of it til late in the 2nd half was a minor miracle. They are selling a guy for 77m and competing at the top end of the most monied league in the world - a league where you get about 100m for ending the season 20/20- , and we, a team that get about 3m for winning a 38 game league, we made them sweat for it 👏👏👏👏👏👏 HH
Just lacked the depth tonight. Missed CCV and Maeda massively. Done well to even get ourselves back into it after that horrible start. Objective achieved of getting to the next round so move on. Unfortunately its Bayern or Madrid tho fs 🤣
Our objective hasn’t been achieved. Our objective was to qualify and avoid the big boys. Being happy to have qualified only to get humiliated in the next round sums up the severe lack of ambition and mediocrity at the club.
We played well all things considered. If we hadn't beaten young boys last week we'd have been out. Brilliant showing taking half of the points available 👏👏💚🇮🇪☘
I also noticed your fleeting appearance on the telly . They hit us early , we eventually looked a bit more like ourselves, big Adam had two cracking goals. We gave a good account of ourselves, equally, they were a couple of great Kasper saves away from putting a few past us . What about their penalty? The award and the execution. Good that we've got any easy draw for the next round. 😂😁🤣HH🍀🍀
Why all the pass backs to Kasper. We are so casual at the back at times, inviting pressure and errors. Also echo other comments on the first time starts for players that can't get a domestic runout. Would have definitely had more of a shot with a full strength team but we are where we are.
So proud of the team tonight 👏 but the drop of in quality within that group is seriously alarming yang should never put on a celtic jersey EVER again he was appalling the club have got to get cheque book out now hh ☘️ 🍀
You were on the tele Paul- overall happy with it we were unlucky bringing young players on a ucl game? No sure about that but overall happy with the full competition- whoever it is bring them on Bayern real let’s have it 6:40 no actually convinced it was a penalty- goes to down to the clear and obvious error
We have been saying this for years now I dont expect too much but hopefully the fact we had to bring young Murray on shows we need some more depth especially at this level
Engels, Idah, Jota (30m for three players). KT salary as well as big contract renewals for some other players. Would you describe this as ambitious or something else?
The Board has backed Brendan. Success or failure this is all now on Brendan which probably explains why he has often looked unusually rattled recently.
--> Excellent commentary from both of you. Bring Scott back on again. CFTV really has a good roster for analysis. --> It ended up not amounting to anything, but that wasn't a penalty. --> Madrid or Bayern? It's like asking if you want to risk 3rd degree burns or frostbite.
Not Seen Scott on Here for AN AGE!!! One of Many Great Contributors on Here. I Think He Runs His Own Business, so I Guess He’s Too Busy to Appear Regularly...And With The Fabulous Kenny Often On...What More Needs Said When We Get a Kenny Analysis Masterclass!!! :-)
We either have Bayern or Real Madrid so we gotta play 5, 4 , 1 & hope for penalties, McGregor is too slow for European football great player in Scotland but club sold its best striker and meada misses first leg at home it’s a tough draw , Hatate & Meada Kuhn could all leave in summer with no guarantees of champions league football next season the board will cash in
We either have Bayern or Real Madrid so we gotta play 5, 4 , 1 & hope for penalties, McGregor is too slow for European football great player in Scotland but club sold its best striker and meada misses first leg at home it’s a tough draw , Hatate & Meada Kuhn could all leave in summer with no guarantees of champions league football next season the board will cash in
Miss Scott brown! Last player we’ve had with any bite! Why would Rodgers last night, bring in those young boys against Villa in the champ league yet they’re deemed not good enough to play at home against ross county- this would give them 1st team experience instead of going in at the highest level and getting demoralised
I know we can all talk about the players that were missing but those players played against Dortmund and also at Ibrokes recently. Would rather discuss Brendan Rodgers deciding to start Yang instead of flooding the midfield with another player. Also bringing on Dane Murray when Nawrocki (5m) was obviously the better option. Their third goal was similar to what happened recently at Dundee having too many players forward and being caught short at the back. We never seem to learn.
Look at the negativity in the comments from most of this chat, a clueless bunch. Villa playing at home, with a far superior team, and us missing two extremely important players… Villa are allowed to and are supposed to have control of the game 😂 To hang in there like we did and perform like we did after that start is even more progress again. A couple of quality goals from us, in it to the death pretty much and Kuhn / Hatate weren’t far away from levelling it up. The team has come on leaps & bounds
Hardly Clueless...BUT Negativity on Social Media ALWAYS Abounds. We Did REALLY Well to Pull it Back to 2-2 After That Horrendous Start as Villa Can Tear Teams Apart with their Pace and Power. Celtic Played Well in Spells and Scored Two Great Goals. Maeda Would Have Made a HUGE Difference as He’d Have Nullified Cash Completely and Caused Chaos down their Right with His Pace and Work Rate. We Learn Again, The Team Improves and The Group Gets Stronger by The End of This Window...Onwards to Munich or Madrid!!! :-)
Zagreb (11) and Stuttgart (10) both out. 12 point minimum must be the target. I also think we can dismiss the nonsense that gets put in the papers next season. The OPTA "supercomputer" is built entirely out of betting slips.
No love in from this Tim. Rodgers should have hooked Murray after two minutes as he was obviously overawed by the situation he found himself in. His movement was like treakle and three times before losing the fourth goal he was nearly robbed of the ball.
I thought the players gave everything I think we need some physicality in midfield but I'll be honest we just aren't at the level required to win consistently away in europe yet and tbf playing the dross we do in Scotland doesn't help we were also without our best CB LW and ST I can't say I'm pissed off at all tbh I think you think we are better than we are tbh.
Great content guys, agree that we should have taken the foul before the 3rd goal. Yang needs to go. Midfield again being totally outplayed, sorry but Engells is certainly not CL standard hopefully he grows into the role. Villa showed the standard we need to be. Hail Hail
Did you know you were on TV at the game last night you were looking a bit fed up when the camera zoomed in on the Celtic supporters 6.17min into the game.
When I seen the line up I feared for us and that showed first 4 mins thought it was gona be a cricket score but fair play to the team for fighting back, Hatate was superb, buzzing for Idah to get the 2 goals should give him confidence,Yang just looked lost but Lasnite shows we need to sign another defender and striker because the bench is just very light which causes us to bring on the young lads. Just shows how important Daizen and CCv are to the team. Was a great game to be fair. Bring on Bayern or Madrid 😆😂☘️🤞
Rollercoaster Celtic. Need at least 3 first team capable players this window & same again at least in the summer. We've done great, but the weakness in depth is killing any momentum/potential. Build for UCLQs next season & we've a chance of getting though to the play-offs again.
The bigger picture is we should be proud that we are in the next round , the team we had played ok and did compete, yang has to go so bad, we'll done celtic
Terrible start fought back well ripped them apart for our 2 goals was top drawer we looked nervous at back and we were far to high midfield offered no protection 2nd half was crazy we just left 1 v 1s apart from reo midfield were nowhere calmac never once drove way ball engels offered nothing kasper kept us in it idah was superb held line well 1 st goal was unbelievable way he got his leg up gr8 2nd finish great campaign we hopefully have full team and new additions for next game defo need to be more solid
Villa are currently struggling with form last year's villa would have put away their chances. Celts second goal was cracking and brilliant fans. Great club...UTV
It showed last night that scales isn't cl quality, we badly missed ccv and miada for his pressing, why do we always start badly, need to get that part of the game sorted out, hattie was very unlucky with the shot late on, 🍀🇮🇪
if celtic had the same money as the english premier teams we could compete with any in the world. were still there bring on real or bayern great game for our fans hail hail
I'm still proud of the BHOYS win lose or draw you tried your best onward s and upwards well done Adam in proving your doubters wrong keep it going HH 🍀🍀💚🤍🧡🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪
I hope to see you in the Beer Halls of Munich Paul🎉. Well Rodgers got us playing some really great attacking football, but we were so open again on the counter. What do we need to do to be a more secure on counter attacks? For starters we can't start Hatate against Munich or Madrid away from home, we need a bit more Insurance in the middle. We really need a Midfield def Mid or someone with great recovery pace. It's was great to see Idah just hanging out between the Goal Frame Gary Lineker style. What a modern invention eh, get your Centre Forward to hang out between the Goal frame area. We just need more recovery discipline. See you in Munich Comrades.Btw Yang isnt even SPFL level, jesus
Why was Kyogo not sold tomorrow Not having CCV Meada and Kyogo too much Sign Onyadicha Get Jota fit Kt in the door and a striker in to replace The wee man
Our squad badly needs strengthened. We are not as good as we think we are. We’ve got the money, so let’s add quality to the team. Our defence without ccv is poor.
Yang cant help not being at the right level and is only played because we have no other option. Chocolate boy is worse. Brendans "bless him" comment from a previous interview says it all about Yang. He thinks he's a "trier." The central 3 are the biggest disappointment. Forget about tackling, those days are over. Its speed and accuracy of passing and not turning over that makes the difference. The team needs to develop with settled first picks.
It baffles me how Cummings makes his debut in a CL game. Why not blood him in at home in the league I have so many questions for BR especially around the Kyogo transfer
Saw you on tv lol hope you enjoyed the trip cant ask for anymore from celtic glad we got back into the game wee bit too much for us in the end at least we are through hail hail
Watch the Villa penalty again on the box Paul, it was the wrong call by the ref. Villa were the better team but this game could have been different had we had CCV and Maeda, we missed those two players probably more than we would have missed any other two players being out. I don't think there was the massive gulf between Celtic and Villa that some folk said there would be. I'd like to meet Villa in Europe next season and see how things go with a full strength team.
Yes, it would be interesting to have our (Villa) full strength team on the pitch too. Mings (CB) out injured, Torres (CB) out injured, Onana (DM) out injured, McGinn's first appearance back after injury and then we lost Cash during the game too. Great game though and your lads did you proud. However, I think Villa were always in control, especially in the second half and if it wasn't for Kasper Scmeichel it could have become embarrassing for you. Good luck in the play offs. I'd love to see you guys get through.
Seen you on the TV after the villa 2nd goal!!! Mixed bag being honest annoyed after 5 minutes & ecstatic at half time!!!! You think Brendan Rogers putting young Dane Murray on rather than nwracki on is a message to the board?? He done it earlier in the season he put on Ralston on for Taylor away to st mirren
All of a sudden our bench was incredibly weak compared to just a week ago….! Many not Celtic level let alone CL level! And why did the manager put Murray on instead of Nawrocki…?
Good effort without Vickers and Maeda. Our bench was weakest I've seen in years. What's the point of Bernado in CL ? He does nothing wether he starts or comes on. Yang not up to it but to be fair he's not match fit. We need need to sign a top midfielder who starts and ditch the deadwood
Twas Some Flick from Engels to Hatate to Set Up Idah’s Second. There is a TOP Player in There. Given Time and A Full Pre-Season at Celtic He’ll Develop Further. He’s Young and The Fee is The Fee. That’s The Figures Celtic Will be Paying These Days.
I thought project players were supposed to be like 1-2 million, why do we have an 11.5 million project, that can’t even do the fundamentals of the game, I also don’t think Yang would start for a Montrose team, never mind Celtic
Nobody expecting us to get anything pre game and some were fearful it wouldn't be competitive. We gave Villa a game but they have too much quality. Would have been better with Maeda and CCV. Yang would be back in Glasgow never mind on the bench.
It’s not a 500m team at all, Watkins was about 30m rogers around 16m Bailey around £30mil Ramsey is from our youth team tielemans was free McGinn cost us less than £2mil kamara was a free (don’t ask me how) konsa was around 15 if I remember correctly Martinez 25mil and digne 25mil that’s around 140mil Well played tho boys was a quality game as I said before the match to my mate who’s a Celtic season ticket holder, 1 thing with villa this season is we will always give the opposition chances to get back into the game and then struggle finishing them off. Tonight we obviously did finish it off but left it late. Schmeichal or however you spell it had a quality game, the striker took his 2 goals well and your centre half had a shocker marking Watkins ran him ragged. Safe journey back to Scotland 🏴
Villa fan. It was a fantastic experience to be there v Celtic. Both teams had weakened line ups but Villa had the superior forward line. I hope Villa give Celtic John McGinn for free when his time is up at Villa. We love him and I hope he does get the opportunity to play for his beloved Celtic.
Glad big Idah got a couple of goals kick on HH
Villa fan here. Great game. Celtic had some great attacks and worked well especially from the wing. Fair play to the fans and the club on a whole. Great club. I look forward to if we ever play them again 💜💙/🧡💚🤍
I’ll always buzzing to watch Villa. Exciting and powerful team. Celtic punting our top striker before this game is beyond madness. It’s hard enough with the TV money factor etc. Great Ozzy tifo btw.
@@imgazchillin class comment. Good luck for the rest of the season
@@arod9998 Most Celtic supporters haven't a clue about the IRA or Irish history in general, just like the other crowd from Govan who know nothing about the songs they are singing.
@@arod9998 CTA prior to the match! 😂😂😂 In case you hadn’t noticed, the ‘RA haven’t been active for the last 20 years! Move on and stop playing the victim living in the past.
@arod9998 you're a sniveling wee toad. Is that you Lee Wallace. Grass.
Villa’s two second half goals were sickening. You are spot on. Both Scales & Engels had to make a foul & the mistake at the end was avoidable. It’s a real bug bear of mine with our inability to take an offensive throw in. We always go backwards & did so again in the final few minutes. We have a throw in deep in their half & we end up taking our next throw in from our defensive third. Who is coaching our set pieces & throw ins? On the game itself, I was dreading tonight but was delighted with how the boys performed. Just too many silly mistakes & a lack of options from the bench. They also made some errors but we were unable to punish them as they did with ours. I think if we had Maeda & Kyogo out there we would have taken a point. Disappointed with what must be seen as a lack of ambition in letting Kyogo & Valle go before the games were done.
Spot on
Fair play to Celtic, you didn't give up, villa just had too much quality in the final 3rd, maybe we'll meet again.....onwards anx upwards
@@arod9998the risks are real
Yang should never play for us again. Looked like Trusty touched the ball b4 penalty
Yang just isn't even SPFL level. We just need some recovery pace in midfield as we were wide open when we go high up the park.
Surly we have a young lad that's better than Yang
I've constantly been embarrassed at the miss management by Rodgers all this season, the team picked last night and even the lateness off trying to salvage anything was completely embarrassing at least 4wks since MacGregor captained the team with any purpose and authority, Taylor, Yang, Scales, Bernardo, Palma all non starters for me. were head for a catastrophic runners up spot in league with Rodgers clueless and I was of these opinions as soon as team was announced. Gave their all, they aren't capable.
All fairness to you u gave us a run for our money played well good luck in the play of whoever you play and good luck with the rest of the season
It was a good game to watch tbh. I think had we had our main winger and main CB available we could have challenged more.
@@arod9998 what are you on about. Was there any trouble? How many arrests were made?
Your talking absolute nonsense.
Big positives tonight, good reputational game. Great to see Idah getting his goals.
Good game nothing to be embarressed by villa are a strong side
Thanks mate I wish Celtic luck next game
A VERY Strong Side and Play Expansive Attacking Football at Pace.
They Were Excellent at Easter Road in Europe Last Season, Digne In Particular was Superb, and They Have Improved since Then.
A Great Coach...And With ‘Super John McGinn’...A Side I Enjoy Watching.
BUT Last Night After 5 Minutes...Thought it was Going to Be a Dortmund Repeat!!!
Loved having Celtic at Villa Park, these are the occasions that matter. For what it's worth, I thought Celtic were clearly a really good time, some really nice football at times and there wasn't a huge gulf between the teams. To come back from 2-0 showed great character. Respect. UTV!
Post match comments are spot on. Well done with the reaction.
Just after the 2nd goal, TV camera panned to Celtic supporters and there you were Paul, looking like how we all felt, kicked in the ba's.
Fair review as always. Good to see the young bhoys get a bit of game time. Hopefully see more of them from now on and prove there is a gateway from our academy to 1st team player.
Be GREAT to See That Pathway Maximised.
Dede Looks Like The Next to Go South...Middlesbrough This Time. He May be 5th Choice at RB...So We Definitely Develop Talent. I’m ‘Old Skool’...I LOVE to See The Academy Guys in the First Eleven...But it’s A HIGH Bar.
we've conceded around 5-7 times this season from scales doing that high press bs, hes been caught out of position doing it almost every time and we always concede from it, completely unacceptable
Midfield should be doing it.
Congratulations guys. A really good analysis of the game. Just 1 additional thought (from a Villa perspective). The momentum changer in the first half was the injury to Matty Cash. The change with Villa’s shape unsettled Villa’s right hand side for the next 10 mins, leading to the spirted comeback from Celtic which made the contest superbly entertaining. Thanks again. Great channel. UTV.
Idah good, Hatate good, Schmeichel good, slack passing and defending cost us goals we are still a bit naive and we need to be stronger definitely need to look at a physical presence in midfield in the summer we really struggled against that Rogers tonight he bossed us about can't say I'm angry or anything though you can tell the players gave a lot to that game and coming back from 2 down was heartening stuff when it looked like another Dortmund.
1 difference between our midfielders and ours was there ability to receive the pass, hold and turn off the marker. We don't do that.
What a game! Well done Celtic you made a great game of it.....
@arod9998
The English occupied Ireland for 800 years. They're still there in the northeast. What you call the rebels still managed to finally liberate 26 counties from 700 years of English occupation.
Who's more entitled to feel aggrieved?
Not the English.
Dry your eyes and get over yourself.
Celtic will come again. Best of luck in the play-off. Thx for a great game. UTV! 🫶💜💙
Madness punting our top striker right before this game. Madness.
To get anything we needed to have our full team out and not sell our talisman player days before🥲
Alas next time. Villa are a slick outfit, constantly on the half turn.. Rogers is unbelievable.
Nice to see Scott back on the channel. Proud to be a celt this season in Europe. Hatate missed a few chances last night that you have to be clinical at that level, he had a good game though. Scales and trusty make you nervous
well that was a bizarre night. ...some real slack passing though...glad they got a couple of goals but it was tough
Ref was desperate to gee them free kicks was never a pen
Was a pen. Ref let you guys off many fouls. Don't talk nonsense
@richardlawes2697 clearly you taking nonsense we got 4 free kicks whole night ref was desperate to blow anytime villa hit deck u miss Tielemans blatant dive and no chance is that a pen big uefa ref let's give the millions of pound team every little help
@@rossburnside7125 Penalty all day - the big Donkey was ridiculously clumsy as always, kicks his foot prior to playing ball.
Trusty got the ball. No VAR check. And the ref gave Villa loads of fouls, that we never got. Piss poor ref.
@@leannecampbell4551 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great game! Good luck in the play offs guys!!!!
we still lack physicality, and need to beef up the midfield with a wanyama type player
Your another clueless fan
Agree, more important than another winger or even striker.
@@JohnAnderson-ss9vn agreed we need midfield physically even before another winger and striker. Decent teams just run through our midfield. Hail Hail
@gazzbhoy8950 no good teams always have a midfield enforcer tippy happy football only gets you so far look how we were bullied at ibrokes recently
@@gazzbhoy8950 Your grasp of the English language is clueless! 😂🤦🏻♀️
Yang is rank rotten. Out.
We need size and pace, been crying out for it for years. And we need a top CB who's always available for big games
Great analysis as always lads. Wasn’t to be our night, but proud of the Bhoys. Well done lads. Hail Hail. 🍀🍀
That side is screaming out for a Victor Wanyama
Spot on. Midfield poor all season
Just look at the third villa goal, McGinn just bodies Engels. No shade on Engels but we a strongman in midfield to break up attacks. Tbf, McGinn is one of the best in the world at using his arse to good effect haha but you’re spot on, need that defensive minded 6 player.
When small teams like Dundee and Rangers can hurt us on the turnover, what do you expect against Villa. Its turning the ball over that is the major issue and how we respond to it. That happens in the opposition half.
Good point the Belgium waffler has figured that out
Agree. We are struggling to recover when we are high up the park, that looks like fitness and fatigue with all the games we play, but also we need a midfielder with recovery pacr
@@ajsctech8249The Villa players looked more athletic .
@craigferri2162 yeah agree, but we had 4 or 5 key players and new signings to come back and Villa were at home and needed the win more. We gave a great account of ourselves but it exposed the need for more recovery pace in midfield. As good as Hatata was offensively he does leave us a man down in opponent transitions. We cant start Hate away from home at this level and we need a midfielder with more recovery in the summer.
@@ajsctech8249 Our lack of recovery has nothing to do with fitness levels during defensive transitions, but everything to do with the understanding and application of recovery lines, situational & positional awareness and overall ability to read the game. Added to the fact our mid 3 have no natural running power.
This is precisely what happens when you have a manager that thinks he can get away with playing a done and dusted Calmac as a single-pivot/6 when his legs have gone, playing Engels as a box-to-box, Reo being asked to cover too many zones across practically 3 channels, and overall, continuing to run with a middle 3 that is imbalanced.
Got to remember we were 4 players down compared to our last game with a very weak bench.
Our midfield despite being strong in Scotland is so weak in Europe and easy to get through putting the defence under pressure.
Rodgers putting Murray on ahead of a 4 million pound defender is madness
We need a winger, a striker, a left back and a right sided centre back as Ccv is injured far too often
I just read there was trouble after the game, hope you all got up the road safely. What a ride that game was.
Consider this: no CCV, KT (2 stick on starters when fit), Valle (arguably same level as Taylor), Jota, Maeda or Kyogo (available all starters or at least pushing Kuhn)... no potential Ørjasæter, Slotsager or Kvistgaarden
Started with squad players Yang and Scales, ended with fringe player Palma, youth player Murray and debutante/youth player Cummings
.. it was remarkable we did so well and were in it so long.
2 early goals conceded, even half, finish with 2 goals. Applause well earned for Idah
2nd half was edged towards Villa but we had no bench, no LB, no ST, no wing subs, subbing fringe players for fringe players and guys that usually play in the Highland League with our unders.
To make a game of it til late in the 2nd half was a minor miracle.
They are selling a guy for 77m and competing at the top end of the most monied league in the world - a league where you get about 100m for ending the season 20/20- , and we, a team that get about 3m for winning a 38 game league, we made them sweat for it 👏👏👏👏👏👏 HH
If only ! Maeda, ccv huge miss , proud performance, the 4th goal took some gloss off the result
A 3-2 loss wouldn't be a result
Just lacked the depth tonight. Missed CCV and Maeda massively. Done well to even get ourselves back into it after that horrible start. Objective achieved of getting to the next round so move on. Unfortunately its Bayern or Madrid tho fs 🤣
Our objective hasn’t been achieved. Our objective was to qualify and avoid the big boys. Being happy to have qualified only to get humiliated in the next round sums up the severe lack of ambition and mediocrity at the club.
@ thats a great idea, someone should have just told Rodgers to make sure he avoids the big boys
Good to see Scott back on the channel.
We played well all things considered. If we hadn't beaten young boys last week we'd have been out. Brilliant showing taking half of the points available 👏👏💚🇮🇪☘
Thanks guys - good effort without CCV & Maeda. Great experience for our knock out game.🤞🤞
Good game to watch .
I also noticed your fleeting appearance on the telly . They hit us early , we eventually looked a bit more like ourselves, big Adam had two cracking goals. We gave a good account of ourselves, equally, they were a couple of great Kasper saves away from putting a few past us . What about their penalty? The award and the execution. Good that we've got any easy draw for the next round. 😂😁🤣HH🍀🍀
Why all the pass backs to Kasper. We are so casual at the back at times, inviting pressure and errors. Also echo other comments on the first time starts for players that can't get a domestic runout. Would have definitely had more of a shot with a full strength team but we are where we are.
The captain is the worst culprit. I’ve never known a captain like ours to constantly pass sideways and backwards.
Defence shocking, some we win, some we lose, HH
Two great goals played well in parts but disappointing end. Would take Bayern over Madrid
Yea big time. Bayern are not what they once were. Defo better chance against them than Madrid. If its Madrid, I'll be dreading
So proud of the team tonight 👏 but the drop of in quality within that group is seriously alarming yang should never put on a celtic jersey EVER again he was appalling the club have got to get cheque book out now hh ☘️ 🍀
Proud ?
You were on the tele Paul- overall happy with it we were unlucky bringing young players on a ucl game? No sure about that but overall happy with the full competition- whoever it is bring them on Bayern real let’s have it 6:40 no actually convinced it was a penalty- goes to down to the clear and obvious error
I seen him
Expression on Paul’s face summed up the emotion at that time.
Over to the board now to see if there is any real ambition for progress , hmmm ?
We have been saying this for years now I dont expect too much but hopefully the fact we had to bring young Murray on shows we need some more depth especially at this level
Ambition😅
Engels, Idah, Jota (30m for three players). KT salary as well as big contract renewals for some other players.
Would you describe this as ambitious or something else?
@@dovesfan1overpaid for all of them
The Board has backed Brendan. Success or failure this is all now on Brendan which probably explains why he has often looked unusually rattled recently.
--> Excellent commentary from both of you. Bring Scott back on again. CFTV really has a good roster for analysis.
--> It ended up not amounting to anything, but that wasn't a penalty.
--> Madrid or Bayern? It's like asking if you want to risk 3rd degree burns or frostbite.
Not Seen Scott on Here for AN AGE!!!
One of Many Great Contributors on Here.
I Think He Runs His Own Business, so I Guess He’s Too Busy to Appear Regularly...And With The Fabulous Kenny Often On...What More Needs Said When We Get a Kenny Analysis Masterclass!!! :-)
I commented after Idahs contribution to the goal last week that he would kick on. Think it's vindicated now. Even though we lost, Idah played well 🍀
The big difference is physically. Scales going forward and a few times Johnston, they were just waiting to put it in the space.
playing oot the backs ok in spl .we put pressure on ourselves
We still looked like wee bhoys tho
Need a bit of physicality in midfield
Ineffective in midfield, McGregor had very little influence. Mccowan and Bernardo hardly touched the ball. Need some tackling ability.
agree
Desperately need physicality in that midfield it's very weak it's all ability and no grit we need a McGinn tbh
We either have Bayern or Real Madrid so we gotta play 5, 4 , 1 & hope for penalties, McGregor is too slow for European football great player in Scotland but club sold its best striker and meada misses first leg at home it’s a tough draw , Hatate & Meada Kuhn could all leave in summer with no guarantees of champions league football next season the board will cash in
We either have Bayern or Real Madrid so we gotta play 5, 4 , 1 & hope for penalties, McGregor is too slow for European football great player in Scotland but club sold its best striker and meada misses first leg at home it’s a tough draw , Hatate & Meada Kuhn could all leave in summer with no guarantees of champions league football next season the board will cash in
Miss Scott brown! Last player we’ve had with any bite!
Why would Rodgers last night, bring in those young boys against Villa in the champ league yet they’re deemed not good enough to play at home against ross county- this would give them 1st team experience instead of going in at the highest level and getting demoralised
Saw you in the crowd after one of villa goals
I know we can all talk about the players that were missing but those players played against Dortmund and also at Ibrokes recently. Would rather discuss Brendan Rodgers deciding to start Yang instead of flooding the midfield with another player. Also bringing on Dane Murray when Nawrocki (5m) was obviously the better option. Their third goal was similar to what happened recently at Dundee having too many players forward and being caught short at the back. We never seem to learn.
We desperately need a proper defensive midfielder, and to add some physicality in there.
For what it’s worth that was never a pen.
Look at the negativity in the comments from most of this chat, a clueless bunch. Villa playing at home, with a far superior team, and us missing two extremely important players… Villa are allowed to and are supposed to have control of the game 😂 To hang in there like we did and perform like we did after that start is even more progress again. A couple of quality goals from us, in it to the death pretty much and Kuhn / Hatate weren’t far away from levelling it up. The team has come on leaps & bounds
Hardly Clueless...BUT Negativity on Social Media ALWAYS Abounds.
We Did REALLY Well to Pull it Back to 2-2 After That Horrendous Start as Villa Can Tear Teams Apart with their Pace and Power.
Celtic Played Well in Spells and Scored Two Great Goals.
Maeda Would Have Made a HUGE Difference as He’d Have Nullified Cash Completely and Caused Chaos down their Right with His Pace and Work Rate.
We Learn Again, The Team Improves and The Group Gets Stronger by The End of This Window...Onwards to Munich or Madrid!!! :-)
Great to see big stuart
Strikers need a consistent run of games for confidence to grow then the goals will flow just watch big Adam go! 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🏴🏴🏴💚💚💚👍
Zagreb (11) and Stuttgart (10) both out. 12 point minimum must be the target. I also think we can dismiss the nonsense that gets put in the papers next season. The OPTA "supercomputer" is built entirely out of betting slips.
Bruges through on 11
@@BrianClarke-qf4vo Aye. Our target needs to be 12 tho. We are not always going to get a kind draw in the league phase.
saw you on the tele, mate
Am I the only on here pissed off with the result.Its sounds like a big love-in on the comments section.
No love in from this Tim. Rodgers should have hooked Murray after two minutes as he was obviously overawed by the situation he found himself in. His movement was like treakle and three times before losing the fourth goal he was nearly robbed of the ball.
nup...i thought the defence were poor...and some of the passing was slack
I thought the players gave everything I think we need some physicality in midfield but I'll be honest we just aren't at the level required to win consistently away in europe yet and tbf playing the dross we do in Scotland doesn't help we were also without our best CB LW and ST I can't say I'm pissed off at all tbh I think you think we are better than we are tbh.
@@122josh fair 👏
I’m with you. We were amateurish at times, absolutely nothing to be happy with tonight
Great content guys, agree that we should have taken the foul before the 3rd goal. Yang needs to go. Midfield again being totally outplayed, sorry but Engells is certainly not CL standard hopefully he grows into the role. Villa showed the standard we need to be. Hail Hail
Brillant game 🤣🇮🇪👏👏👏
Hattate was class
Did you know you were on TV at the game last night you were looking a bit fed up when the camera zoomed in on the Celtic supporters 6.17min into the game.
Sutton penalty in 2005 cup final was identical
When I seen the line up I feared for us and that showed first 4 mins thought it was gona be a cricket score but fair play to the team for fighting back, Hatate was superb, buzzing for Idah to get the 2 goals should give him confidence,Yang just looked lost but Lasnite shows we need to sign another defender and striker because the bench is just very light which causes us to bring on the young lads. Just shows how important Daizen and CCv are to the team. Was a great game to be fair. Bring on Bayern or Madrid 😆😂☘️🤞
never understand how any other result was expected, have not played since rb, usual story
Saw ya on the tv
Rollercoaster Celtic. Need at least 3 first team capable players this window & same again at least in the summer.
We've done great, but the weakness in depth is killing any momentum/potential. Build for UCLQs next season & we've a chance of getting though to the play-offs again.
The bigger picture is we should be proud that we are in the next round , the team we had played ok and did compete, yang has to go so bad, we'll done celtic
Terrible start fought back well ripped them apart for our 2 goals was top drawer we looked nervous at back and we were far to high midfield offered no protection 2nd half was crazy we just left 1 v 1s apart from reo midfield were nowhere calmac never once drove way ball engels offered nothing kasper kept us in it idah was superb held line well 1 st goal was unbelievable way he got his leg up gr8 2nd finish great campaign we hopefully have full team and new additions for next game defo need to be more solid
Villa are currently struggling with form last year's villa would have put away their chances. Celts second goal was cracking and brilliant fans. Great club...UTV
It showed last night that scales isn't cl quality, we badly missed ccv and miada for his pressing, why do we always start badly, need to get that part of the game sorted out, hattie was very unlucky with the shot late on, 🍀🇮🇪
if celtic had the same money as the english premier teams we could compete with any in the world. were still there bring on real or bayern great game for our fans hail hail
I'm still proud of the BHOYS win lose or draw you tried your best onward s and upwards well done Adam in proving your doubters wrong keep it going HH 🍀🍀💚🤍🧡🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪
I hope to see you in the Beer Halls of Munich Paul🎉. Well Rodgers got us playing some really great attacking football, but we were so open again on the counter. What do we need to do to be a more secure on counter attacks? For starters we can't start Hatate against Munich or Madrid away from home, we need a bit more Insurance in the middle. We really need a Midfield def Mid or someone with great recovery pace. It's was great to see Idah just hanging out between the Goal Frame Gary Lineker style. What a modern invention eh, get your Centre Forward to hang out between the Goal frame area. We just need more recovery discipline. See you in Munich Comrades.Btw Yang isnt even SPFL level, jesus
See you on the TV Paul, I think it was just as they went 2 up your face looked like I felt
Why was Kyogo not sold tomorrow
Not having CCV Meada and Kyogo too much
Sign Onyadicha
Get Jota fit Kt in the door and a striker in to replace The wee man
Our squad badly needs strengthened. We are not as good as we think we are. We’ve got the money, so let’s add quality to the team. Our defence without ccv is poor.
Was Johnny Kenny cup tied from Shamrock Rovers or injured ? If not I cant understand why he wasnt on the bench?
Yang cant help not being at the right level and is only played because we have no other option. Chocolate boy is worse. Brendans "bless him" comment from a previous interview says it all about Yang. He thinks he's a "trier." The central 3 are the biggest disappointment.
Forget about tackling, those days are over. Its speed and accuracy of passing and not turning over that makes the difference. The team needs to develop with settled first picks.
It baffles me how Cummings makes his debut in a CL game. Why not blood him in at home in the league I have so many questions for BR especially around the Kyogo transfer
Saw you on tv lol hope you enjoyed the trip cant ask for anymore from celtic glad we got back into the game wee bit too much for us in the end at least we are through hail hail
Yang had a ball over the top with McGinn only had to hit it straight n run be 1 on 1 with keeper n tried to cut across McGinn n lost the ball
We maybe could have done an Atalanta's type defensive game but when were attack and loose the ball there's miles of space in behind.
Watch the Villa penalty again on the box Paul, it was the wrong call by the ref.
Villa were the better team but this game could have been different had we had CCV and Maeda, we missed those two players probably more than we would have missed any other two players being out. I don't think there was the massive gulf between Celtic and Villa that some folk said there would be. I'd like to meet Villa in Europe next season and see how things go with a full strength team.
Yes, it would be interesting to have our (Villa) full strength team on the pitch too. Mings (CB) out injured, Torres (CB) out injured, Onana (DM) out injured, McGinn's first appearance back after injury and then we lost Cash during the game too. Great game though and your lads did you proud. However, I think Villa were always in control, especially in the second half and if it wasn't for Kasper Scmeichel it could have become embarrassing for you. Good luck in the play offs. I'd love to see you guys get through.
Seen you on the TV after the villa 2nd goal!!! Mixed bag being honest annoyed after 5 minutes & ecstatic at half time!!!! You think Brendan Rogers putting young Dane Murray on rather than nwracki on is a message to the board?? He done it earlier in the season he put on Ralston on for Taylor away to st mirren
All of a sudden our bench was incredibly weak compared to just a week ago….! Many not Celtic level let alone CL level!
And why did the manager put Murray on instead of Nawrocki…?
Seen both of u before game on TNT sports
Good effort without Vickers and Maeda. Our bench was weakest I've seen in years. What's the point of Bernado in CL ? He does nothing wether he starts or comes on. Yang not up to it but to be fair he's not match fit. We need need to sign a top midfielder who starts and ditch the deadwood
When ye all going to stop giving Engels an easy ride 11 million total dud
He’s one of the best in the squad by a mile, he just wasn’t worth that price tag
Twas Some Flick from Engels to Hatate to Set Up Idah’s Second.
There is a TOP Player in There.
Given Time and A Full Pre-Season at Celtic He’ll Develop Further. He’s Young and The Fee is The Fee. That’s The Figures Celtic Will be Paying These Days.
The 4th goal was Johnson's mistake not Murray.
I thought project players were supposed to be like 1-2 million, why do we have an 11.5 million project, that can’t even do the fundamentals of the game, I also don’t think Yang would start for a Montrose team, never mind Celtic
Happy to get pumped. Says it all.
Add Jota, Tierney and a striker for the play off and give it a go against RM or BM...
Just show's how the missed Maeda hes key to our play
Team
Why, why can't we pass to each other. We constantly pass to them, and they score. Is there a change needed in the leadership on the pitch?
Nobody expecting us to get anything pre game and some were fearful it wouldn't be competitive. We gave Villa a game but they have too much quality. Would have been better with Maeda and CCV. Yang would be back in Glasgow never mind on the bench.
Villa 500 million team!
It’s not a 500m team at all, Watkins was about 30m rogers around 16m Bailey around £30mil Ramsey is from our youth team tielemans was free McGinn cost us less than £2mil kamara was a free (don’t ask me how) konsa was around 15 if I remember correctly Martinez 25mil and digne 25mil that’s around 140mil
Well played tho boys was a quality game as I said before the match to my mate who’s a Celtic season ticket holder, 1 thing with villa this season is we will always give the opposition chances to get back into the game and then struggle finishing them off. Tonight we obviously did finish it off but left it late. Schmeichal or however you spell it had a quality game, the striker took his 2 goals well and your centre half had a shocker marking Watkins ran him ragged. Safe journey back to Scotland 🏴
@ look it up that’s what villas squad was .
Villa fan. It was a fantastic experience to be there v Celtic. Both teams had weakened line ups but Villa had the superior forward line. I hope Villa give Celtic John McGinn for free when his time is up at Villa. We love him and I hope he does get the opportunity to play for his beloved Celtic.
Could easily have been 8 or 9-2, lazy finishing by Villa.
Bayern please otherwise it could be 9-0 in Madrid
Sober Celtic fans?