종현이 저때 수술하고 힘든상태에서 부른거여서 그런지 부르는게 많이 힘들어보인다.. 그래도 열심히 부르는모습 보니까 너무예쁘다 종현아 아프지 말고 밥잘챙겨먹고 라디오 때문에 잠도 잘 못자니까 너무 무리하지마 얼마 전에 서가대 퇴근길에도 엄청 피곤해보이던데.. 항상 열심히 해줘서 고마워 종현이 뿐만이 아니라 다른 멤버들도 항상 스케줄 챙기랴 가수다 보니까 몸이랑 외모랑 헤어 관리하랴 바쁠텐데 다들 항상 팬들 생각해서 열심히 해서 늘 예쁜모습 보게 해줘서 너무 고마워 앞으로도 힘내자 샤이니 화이팅
This is a perfect example showcasing their unique voices. Minho's deep voice/low key is critical to their harmonization. I wish people would stop comparing which voice is better. They shine bright together because of their unique vocals/individuality.
Sorry, Taemin's...voice is a weak feathery thing that undermines the song every time he has a solo line. And no, it's not hateful or rude to say it. Hes a professional; criticism comes with the territory. What iI dont get is why they dont electronically overdub or something when he sings, as they do in his solo concerts. As for why Taemin was the first solo act out of SHINee...I can only speculate. Certainly not for the power or beauty of his voice, which is heavily enhanced for him in his " solo" concerts. It's also not rude to compare voices. That's part of what people who listen to music naturally do.
@@firstsensibility9455 lol Are you the Shawol police? No, I don't think I will "get the fuck out of here." I'll comment wherever I want, thanks. I consider myself a Jonghyun-era Shawol. I don't care what you consider me, weirdo.
Yeahhh, but we won't hear his voices again Shinee will not be the same like before without jonghyun 😭😭 They lost the lead vocalist that has sweet voices 😢😢😢
These guys are just awe-inspiring. From gorgeous slow ballads like this to hot, up-beat dance numbers, they rule it all and are totally convincing. Jonghyun's voice...Heaven on Earth. I'm impressed that Minho pulled off that mid-ballad rap, making it fit the vibe of the song with complete control. Jonghyun-era SHINee is the best boy-band ever.
It's 2022. SHINee is still my favourite kpop group and Jonghyun is still my bias and my favourite vocalist. You did well Jonghyun ❤️ There are many groups and vocalists out there in the industry but SHINee is rare still no one can replace or duplicate SHINee and Jonghyun ❤️
i love how the fact that they are all singers now. I mean yes, they still had their roles as the dancing machine and rapper and all but before, taemin barely even have any solo parts and other than rapping, minho didn't really have any singing line. I'm so proud of what they have turned out to be~ they deserve all the shine for all their hardwork.
....... Onew!!!! From start to finish he nailed every single note!!!! Songs like this r made for Onew. Omg don't get me started on Bling Bling and Taemin!!!!! Bling Bling is an angel and with that voice of his it just sends me to heaven. Ugh on my bias lee taemin! Just flawless!!!! Minho with that deep voice!!!!! Ugh and last but not least almighty key!!! His blonde hair with that middle parting..... Throughout the whole thing I had chills. So glad I'm a Shawol!!!!!!
I rmbr Jjong returned from his mini hiatus for the last of the WSS promos looking like a god with platinum hair for the first time. We were so relieved he was ok and so happy to see him back with SHINee, where he belongs. 😢 Come back, baby💔
First performance of jonghyun after the accident, he still wasnt fully heal yet that's he didnt sound that good but he did his best! And this was their goodbye stage, the boys looked freaking tired. Ahh watching their ballads performance always make me wanna ;~~~~;
@@Gargi__mazumder he had small car accident back in april 2013 and hurt his nose. Thus why he couldnt join 'why so serious' promotions with the rest. This stage was his comeback after resting
Jonghyun Oppa, I don't know why I suddenly thought of you tonight and I thought this song. It's been five months since you left up and I'm still crying again. My mind kept saying that you're gone, I won't be able to hear anything new from you again, that all I can do now is reminisce and watch your old videos, and listen to your old songs. But you know what oppa? My heart is still screaming that you're just around. I still feel like that you're still here, that we can still see you. I just hope that wherever you are right now, you're not suffering anymore. We miss you oppa...
It makes me so sad that they cut out Taemin's high note in this because for me it's the highlight of the entire song. I mean, Jinki's voice is beautiful and gives me the shivers as always. The boys are as always beautiful af. But Taemin's part? It just holds so much freaking raw emotion and makes me wanna cry. Nevertheless, they seemed really tired in this performance and Jonghyun couldn't reach his note like he would be able to normally so I'm glad they didn't push themselves unnecessarily. SHINee hwaiting!
@@Lexusirizarry he did nose surgery because of his car accident.. So he was kinda struggling while singing... He's back without taking proper rest at that time
Time is passing by so fast... I still cant believe how much Taemin has grown... I still see him as that cute little boy from Hello.... He's all grown up now and is so mature looking now it's amazing how fast time has passed
One of my favourite ballads, but I constantly forget about it until something weird af reminds me of it. But it's a special treat when it comes back to me!
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] SHINee - Don`t Let Me Go, 샤이니 - 투명 우산 Show Music core 20161022](/img/1.gif)
종현아 꼭 오늘같은 날처럼 너무 너가 보고싶은 날들이 있는데. 보고싶다고 괜히 징징대고 싶다
종현이 저때 수술하고 힘든상태에서 부른거여서 그런지 부르는게 많이 힘들어보인다.. 그래도 열심히 부르는모습 보니까 너무예쁘다 종현아 아프지 말고 밥잘챙겨먹고 라디오 때문에 잠도 잘 못자니까 너무 무리하지마 얼마 전에 서가대 퇴근길에도 엄청 피곤해보이던데.. 항상 열심히 해줘서 고마워 종현이 뿐만이 아니라 다른 멤버들도 항상 스케줄 챙기랴 가수다 보니까 몸이랑 외모랑 헤어 관리하랴 바쁠텐데 다들 항상 팬들 생각해서 열심히 해서 늘 예쁜모습 보게 해줘서 너무 고마워 앞으로도 힘내자 샤이니 화이팅
His angelic voice fades away our pain and worries❤️
This is a perfect example showcasing their unique voices. Minho's deep voice/low key is critical to their harmonization. I wish people would stop comparing which voice is better. They shine bright together because of their unique vocals/individuality.
Completely agree with you.
Sorry, Taemin's...voice is a weak feathery thing that undermines the song every time he has a solo line. And no, it's not hateful or rude to say it. Hes a professional; criticism comes with the territory. What iI dont get is why they dont electronically overdub or something when he sings, as they do in his solo concerts.
As for why Taemin was the first solo act out of SHINee...I can only speculate. Certainly not for the power or beauty of his voice, which is heavily enhanced for him in his " solo" concerts.
It's also not rude to compare voices. That's part of what people who listen to music naturally do.
@@morningsminion3242 u are not a shawol so get the fuck out of here
@@firstsensibility9455 lol Are you the Shawol police? No, I don't think I will "get the fuck out of here." I'll comment wherever I want, thanks. I consider myself a Jonghyun-era Shawol. I don't care what you consider me, weirdo.
@@morningsminion3242 nah people who hate on one of the members are not shawols
I swear Onew is always so fricken stable, he like needs a solo ASAP pls
I swear that said I swear onew is so fried chicken 😂😂
널 보는게 고통스러워서 일부러 너희 영상을 안봤어 아직 너의 모습을 눈물없이 볼수 없지만 잘있을리라 믿어 얼마의 시간이 지나야 다시 널보며 미소지을 수 있을까
"수고했어요 정말 고생했어요
그댄 나의 자랑이죠"
2:29 jonghyun's voice oh god
gets me everytime
Yeahhh, but we won't hear his voices again
Shinee will not be the same like before without jonghyun 😭😭
They lost the lead vocalist that has sweet voices 😢😢😢
😢😢😢
julie .
Is really beautiful .
그래도 너야만해
하루끝에 쉴 곳 너야..
너무 그리워 잊을 수 없어
다시 돌아와..
종현이는 자신의 아품보다 다른사람의 아품을 더먼저 생각하고 자신이상처받는것보다 다른사람이 상처받는걸 더먼저걱정하던 맘이여리고 이쁜 사람이여서
먼저 하늘에 별이된거 같아..
그래도 보고싶다
These guys are just awe-inspiring. From gorgeous slow ballads like this to hot, up-beat dance numbers, they rule it all and are totally convincing. Jonghyun's voice...Heaven on Earth. I'm impressed that Minho pulled off that mid-ballad rap, making it fit the vibe of the song with complete control. Jonghyun-era SHINee is the best boy-band ever.
I really like here Minho's cold rap❤️❤️
2021.....discoovered the gem called shinee not regretting any second of it
Onew killed that song. He is so good live.
딱 샤이니스러운 발라드 같음..ㅠㅠ 이번 발라드들이 엘범에 많이 실렸으면 하는 바람..❤️ 개좋다ㅠㅠ 태민이 노래하는디 울컥하네ㅠㅠ
미안해 .난 아직 널 떠나 보내지 못하겠어.. 넌 내 하루 끝에 기대어 쉴 곳인데 다시 돌아와 제발...
화음이 진짜 완벽하고.. 라이브 라는 게 놀라울 정도로 음정 박자 정확하고ㅜㅜ
이노래는 너가 떠난 후 내 마음같아서 듣기가 너무힘들다 미안해 편히쉬어 종현아 사랑해
나도 떠날수가 없는데... 어떻게 해야 좋을까... 종현아,
SHINee's voices individually are so unique and distinct from each other but together, it's just heavenly.
Jonghyun's voice is beautiful. I feel so bad that we won't be able to listen to it again. Rest in peace.
오늘도 그리워서 눈물이 나네요...멤버 태민이가감수성 깊어지는건 좋은데 눈물이 많아졌다고 틀기만 해도 바로 눈물 흘린다고 라디오에서 한말 왜이리 안타까운지ㅜㅜ1년이 되어 가네요😢 지인중에 그런분 계시면 짧은 대화라도 해주시면 말해도 괜찮은 지인에게 말할수 있는 용기가 생길수 있어요...
It's 2022. SHINee is still my favourite kpop group and Jonghyun is still my bias and my favourite vocalist. You did well Jonghyun ❤️ There are many groups and vocalists out there in the industry but SHINee is rare still no one can replace or duplicate SHINee and Jonghyun ❤️
샤이니 멤버들이 보고싶다, ㅠㅠ종현아,, ㅠㅠ
lee jinki. you r the reason why i became a hardcore kpop fan for 8 years...
Now 12 years^^
The beauty of this is that if you search this song with "MR Removed" and listen to that video it sounds exactly the same *-* Proud Shawol here~
종현오빠 너무 보고싶어
i love how the fact that they are all singers now. I mean yes, they still had their roles as the dancing machine and rapper and all but before, taemin barely even have any solo parts and other than rapping, minho didn't really have any singing line. I'm so proud of what they have turned out to be~ they deserve all the shine for all their hardwork.
I swear no other kpop males groups can sing ballad songs this well live!!!
.......
Onew!!!! From start to finish he nailed every single note!!!! Songs like this r made for Onew. Omg don't get me started on Bling Bling and Taemin!!!!! Bling Bling is an angel and with that voice of his it just sends me to heaven. Ugh on my bias lee taemin! Just flawless!!!! Minho with that deep voice!!!!! Ugh and last but not least almighty key!!! His blonde hair with that middle parting..... Throughout the whole thing I had chills. So glad I'm a Shawol!!!!!!
I'm glad too😊😊😊😊
one of onew's best hairstyle and outfit :)
하루 끝에 기대어 좀 쉬면서 맘대로도 살아보지..
Thanks Changmin who wrote this song!
창민이가 가사를 감성적으로 잘 쓰는구나를 알수있었지. 샤이니표 발라드 넘 좋다잉 🌾
다섯명이 샤이니가 되서 다행이야 다섯명이 모두 다 빛나고 있어
Onew, you're the death of me...
종현아 너무 고마워요
JONGHYUN THE VOICE 😍
화음 실화니......♡ 보고싶다
샤이니는 언제나 5명이야 보고싶어
After all those sleepless nights Jonghyun left. Rest in peace, my love.
SHINee's ballad songs never fails. And I miss Jonghyun.
Perfect Vocal, Perfect harmonization, Perfect Visual.
태민이 후렴을 이끌어가다니.. 정말 실력 많이 늘었구나
Onew and Minho just stole my heart during this performance. But I remember really falling in love with SHINee after this performance..
Oh man minhos low voice is to die for
maria sninee jonvhyun
+mariaNoemi Martinezsnineejonghyun♡♡♡♡♥♥♥♡♡♡♡♥♥♡:-):-):-):-):-):-):-):-)
종현아😢잘가렴~아직은 널 보낼 준비가 안되었지만 그래도 너의 선택을 존중하께 편히 그리고 이제부턴 쭉 행복하기~
😭😭😭😭😭 RIP JONGHYUN
WE LOVE YOU
Leticia Dias 😢🌹
Wow shinee slayed it ! They are not singer, they are CD player !
Onew is freaking handsome in this video
샤이니 오빠 사랑해요
How can you not fall in love with these guys?
I damn near shed a tear 😢 Their voices are just perfection and Jonghyun😍 I can't handle him.
Same 😭I couldn't handle him either, that's why he was my bias in SHINee 😭
아 이때가.. 내 기억이 맞다면, 이때 활동내내 아파서 무대에 없었던 종현이가 막주에 등장해서 이거 불렀던 거 같다. 나은지 얼마 안되서 되게마르고 목소리에 힘이 없었음
너무 그리워 잊을 수 없어 다시 돌아와
YAL BETTA HIT THOSE NOTES!!! I see you Jonghyun
onew's voice is just one of a kind
This song will never sound the same again.........
I rmbr Jjong returned from his mini hiatus for the last of the WSS promos looking like a god with platinum hair for the first time. We were so relieved he was ok and so happy to see him back with SHINee, where he belongs. 😢 Come back, baby💔
와쏘씨때 활동하나도 못하고 막방되서야 종현이 왔는데 은발에 떠나지못해 불러줘서 기절했잖아 화질이 좋아서 오늘같다
goosebumps! Onew and Jonghyun have perfect vocal control it showed in this performance. Overall they all did fantastic!
remember when we made parodies of Taemin for getting parts in Hello. Look at him go here. such a talented babe. All of them are.
holy shit yeah we all laughed at our cute baby who couldn't really sing XD taemin's progress is really amazing
hahhahahahah I loved the parodies xD I died like every time
This song was hard enough to listen to when it first came out, now it's even harder...
First performance of jonghyun after the accident, he still wasnt fully heal yet that's he didnt sound that good but he did his best! And this was their goodbye stage, the boys looked freaking tired. Ahh watching their ballads performance always make me wanna ;~~~~;
What accident?
@@Gargi__mazumder he had small car accident back in april 2013 and hurt his nose. Thus why he couldnt join 'why so serious' promotions with the rest. This stage was his comeback after resting
Jonghyun Oppa,
I don't know why I suddenly thought of you tonight and I thought this song. It's been five months since you left up and I'm still crying again. My mind kept saying that you're gone, I won't be able to hear anything new from you again, that all I can do now is reminisce and watch your old videos, and listen to your old songs. But you know what oppa? My heart is still screaming that you're just around. I still feel like that you're still here, that we can still see you.
I just hope that wherever you are right now, you're not suffering anymore. We miss you oppa...
'떠나지 못해' 너무 좋아ㅠㅠ 개인적으로 이 노래가 샤이니의 화음을 제일 잘보여주는 것 같아서 자꾸 듣게 되는것 같다ㅠ 좋아좋아♥♥
It still hurts to listen to SHINee since Jonghyun left us. :( miss you forever jonghyun
It makes me so sad that they cut out Taemin's high note in this because for me it's the highlight of the entire song.
I mean, Jinki's voice is beautiful and gives me the shivers as always. The boys are as always beautiful af.
But Taemin's part? It just holds so much freaking raw emotion and makes me wanna cry.
Nevertheless, they seemed really tired in this performance and Jonghyun couldn't reach his note like he would be able to normally so I'm glad they didn't push themselves unnecessarily.
SHINee hwaiting!
余光晖 Omg SAME I WANTED TO HEAR THE HIGH NOTE
very_ship_ them Arghhh, exactly the same, I was super disappointed... 😫 This high note is everything...
Was he sick then
@@Lexusirizarry he did nose surgery because of his car accident.. So he was kinda struggling while singing... He's back without taking proper rest at that time
I miss you jong.... these sleepless nights...
It will be a sleepless night for me. RIP Jonghyun...
5HINEE IN STAGE IS PERFECT.
너무 그리워 잊을 수 없어
SHINEE's vocals and harmony are amazing. Love them!
Ah. I just died of excitement and maybe seeing Jonghyun performing with his AMAZING voice and lovely face again
i miss jjong's beautiful voice & their harmonies while singing together.... :'(
The sweetest voices around.
Onew's voice complete my day~~~
i will be having a sleepless night because our Jonghyun passed away. im crying
I knew there was a reason I stanned SHINee in general and Onew in particular. This was absolutely beautiful.
Listening on headphones, they sounded so amazing for real! I know they are great live but I'm still blown away.
i say this everytime but i love their live performances
Taemin's voice is so beautiful.
종현오빠가 부룬 oh 하루끝에 기대어쉴곳이너야난 이부분 너무 좋아요 잊지않을게요 종현오빠 보고싶어요❤
Minho is perfect from head to toe. Even singing and dancing. Saranghe oppa. 😘
Time is passing by so fast... I still cant believe how much Taemin has grown... I still see him as that cute little boy from Hello.... He's all grown up now and is so mature looking now it's amazing how fast time has passed
이 노래를 라이브로 들을 수 있어서 기쁘다!
Best appreciated with headphones on. Their vocals are so good, blends so well but i can still distinguish each of their voices
Coming back in 2020 hits hard. I no longer listen to kpop but I will always love you SHINee
Same. Only i never left:)
잘했어요 정말!
Binge watching SHINee perfs at 3AM coz I miss them. Their voices are 💎💎💎💎💎
SHINee is the best live.
Minho looking like a perfect prince. Onew's voice.....love.
보고싶다 종현아
One of my favourite ballads, but I constantly forget about it until something weird af reminds me of it. But it's a special treat when it comes back to me!
너무 그리워 잊을 수 없어 😭❤️
I never knew a hum could be so beautiful Onew
Listening to this made me realize how much they were missing out on giving Minho lines to sing... like he has such a beautiful voice
너무이쁘네 ㅎㅎㅎ 영상으로 라도 볼 수 있어서 너무 좋네...💕 항상 응원해!!
honestly after all the news, i can finally see the pain that jonghyun was trying to showcase, yet we all turned a blind eye to him. #RipKimJonghyun
Minho's voice in the this song. I mean, his VOICE. Gives you goose bumps.
I have to say, I loved Minho's rap in this! It was so soothing and man, he gave me the creeps! I love him, even though SM barely gives him any parts!!
As attractive as dancing SHINee, its really really nice to see them just stand there and sing so beautifully!
In the chorus, with headphones, you can hear Minho's deep voice harmonizing and it just sounds so nice! I love his voice so much
Shinee always have the best live vocals 💖 I miss jonghyun.. I miss them.. pls comeback soon 🥺🥺
onew y jong!