Onew: Heavenly and Gentle voice Jonghyun: the Powerhouse Minho: the Clear and Beautiful voice Taemin: the Timbre with a slight Vibrato every now and then Key: the Boyish voice Truly a unique combination but possibly one of the best harmonies in this world.
The fact that they all look so visibly tired and exhausted yet they produced such a flawless performance just tells you what kind of group these boys are ♡♡
Could be because they're mostly standing still for this one. Easier to keep the voice steady while breathing at the same time. With both singing and dancing going on at the same time I imagine it can be tough to keep that voice steady as they also need to maintain their breathing for the physical part so they don't get overtired. I read somewhere that when official music videos are made, the artists sing along for the lip syncing parts during production as if live, but then that version of the song gets overdubbed by an official version of the song sung prior in order to make it sound more official I guess. Something like that.
Yeah! I had the same thought! I even told myself: "omg, they sound even better live!"... I'm really hoping to see one of their lives! They really worth it!
See THIS is why I love SHINee!!!! I was thinking at first that this might be a lipsync....But of course I should have known that this was ALL LIVE!!!! Perfect vocals ugghhhh all the harmony!!! Minho's voice killed me Shinee Slayed my life once again!
one of my favorite ballads of SHINee.. i love this song because the lines are equally distributed.. and you can hear their beautiful voice individually.. and when they harmonize it's heavenly! i'm quite amazed with minho.. i know he can sing but i don't expect him to be this good!
Normally this kind of music isn't my favorite but SHINee just give this kind to music an aura that makes it sound so much better and each individual member's voice adds to the song
君だけを もっと 後には退けないほど もっと あきれるほど 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ただ愛し続けてく 問いただしても 聴こえない 人の流れと 雨に濡れ 届きそうでも 届かない ジカンはreverse oh 触れさせてよ そのheart 過去か未来で どうか 君だけを もっと 後には退けないほど もっと あきれるほど 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ココロのままにOh I love you 今 keeping love again もう一度 Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ただ愛し続けてく 泣きたいくらい 逢いたくて 夢の狭間に 泣き濡れて 伝えたくても 伝わらない ココロはreverse oh 聴かせてよ そのheart まじわれる場所まで 君だけを もっと 後には退けないほど もっと あきれるほど 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ココロのままにOh I love you 今 keeping love again もう一度 Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ただ愛し続けてく 願うなら この鼓動が 生命 刻む音 奏でるたび ひとつ ふたつ 希望になって ひとりが ふたりになって 愛は永遠に 君だけを もっと 後には退けないほど もっと あきれるほど 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ココロのままにOh I love you 今 keeping love again もう一度 Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに 意味などないさ 生きてゆくことのように ただ愛し続けてく -君だけを-
minho was the one who sang multiple hilights of this song....I always loved minho's voice and singing, and wow in this performance his singing ability was very much pronounced, love it!!!!
Today is 18/01/2018... Its been past a month that our lovely Jonghyun is gone.. And i'm still here struggling to accept all those reality..Jonghyunniee.. How i wish you could feel our feelings for missing you alot now.. I wish you could feel our love.. And to imagine we couldn't hear your voice again really breaks our heart.. We miss you alot..everything about youuu.:(
MyFp MnYul 😢😢😢 same.. everyday still crying hard for him... feel so helpless and tired but i miss him so much 😢 trying to make me busy with something to distract myself but always end up watching him and cry...if only he know how much we love him 💔
I'm still trying to convince myself that everything is gonna be alright soon but time goes on and his place in my heart never changes and i just love him more and more
I still cant let him go 3 months on. 😭💔. I cant bare it. Im still mentally struggling and in pain. Ive been so close to giving up but have never been able to. I think Jonghyunie gave me signs. 😭😭😭 I know i need to let him go but why is it so hard to? 😭😭😭💔
One of my favourite Japanese songs by SHINee and this was a great performance of it. I really like how i can hear Minho singing instead of rapping hehee He has a really nice voice. oh my goodness look at them sweat, we know you guys are working really hard, Fighting!
Minho’s “kokoro no mama ni oh I love you “ oh my......😍 Generally him speaking Japanese 😍 Key is genius when it comes to speaking Japanese his pronounciation is perfect xx
this song is my favorite because the parts are so equally distributed and you can hear each and everyone's amazing voices. This mostly goes for minho because he only gets one or two lines in korean singles, but he is actually a really good singer as you can see. because of the minimal lines, people talk crap about minho and how he doesn't match up to all the other shinee members, but that is not the case!!
I dont think anyone surpassed anyone because each memeber brings different sounds and feelings and has different qualities which make their voice so unique
This is SHINee, An amazing leader, Onew, with incredible vocals despite the fact people aren't putting him as main vocal. According to me, he is one of the main vocal. Jonghyun, that man is singing with his entire heart ♥ Minho, charismatic rapper, and actually has an angelic voice. Key, the clearest and deepest voice I ever heard. I swear his emotions are going straight to me ♥ Taemin, one of the most talented kpop maknae to me, he did amazing progres with his vocals, and he has grown so fast ♥
From all the sweat on their faces and necks, I can tell that they've been working really hard. This is one of the reasons why I'm so proud to be a Shawol. All five of the members of SHINee have amazing voices and talents. I'm so grateful to SM for putting them together into a group. Every song of SHINee's is amazing
It's really cool how everyone in SHINee have such different and unique voices from each other and yet when they sing together, the harmony is just beautiful. I hope Minho keeps improving XD One day he might be able to sing a whole song and have more lines in their songs because honestly I love his singing so much more than his rapping and he just has so much potential.
Yeah, you have a point!! I'd like to hear Minho's voice more... Even though he's not my bias (that is Key ^.^) I find his voice beautiful too... And I also reckon it's unfair he's the only one among Shinee's members not to have an important (a little longer, I mean) part to sing... btw he remains amazing
When I listen to this I feel like crying... It is such a good song! I love everthing about it!! I dont know, even if i cant understand ANYTHING AT ALL, i havent even looked the lyrics up and yet... I can feel the song, I can sense how wonderful the lyrics are, just by hearing it i can sort if understand the song. That is what SHINee does to me!!
![[LIVE] SHINee - 1000 Years, Always By Your Side 130920](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yR1h9nSrGro/mqdefault.jpg)
![[LIVE] SHINee - 1000 Years, Always By Your Side 130920](/img/tr.png)
![[MV]JYJ Get Out](/img/1.gif)
샤이니 일본 곡 중 제일 좋아하는 노래
샤이니 일본 방송 레전드 라이브 중 하나
시작부터 마음 간질간질하게 만드는 뭔가가 있네
Onew: Heavenly and Gentle voice
Jonghyun: the Powerhouse
Minho: the Clear and Beautiful voice
Taemin: the Timbre with a slight Vibrato every now and then
Key: the Boyish voice
Truly a unique combination but possibly one of the best harmonies in this world.
이 곡이 꽤 오래됐구나 도입부부터 꽂혀서 흥얼대다가 찾았음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
The fact that they all look so visibly tired and exhausted yet they produced such a flawless performance just tells you what kind of group these boys are ♡♡
やっぱりジョンヒョンの声聞いたら鳥肌立つね！！5人でSHINeeだな！！！！5HINee最高です！！
민호까지 넘나 잘 해 ㄷㄷ. 태민은 감정전달까지. 이렇게 호소력있는 음색인줄은.. 빠져든다. 종현,온유야 말해 입아프고 키도 딱딱 정확하게 꽂히고 성량 대단 흔들림이 없어. 와 음색부자, 보컬부자 인증 영상임
이 노래 진짜 오랜만에 듣는다 천년.. 이랑 양대산맥 노래
Jonghyun's voice is perfect‼️
the live sounds better than the recorded version
SHINeeメンバーそれぞれの気持ちを込めて歌ってくれているのが、すごーく感じられる。💖
ジョンヒョンとっても可愛いくて大好き😘💙
Omg Key's voice is perfect,so emotional ;(
absolutely agree
My favorite ballad song of shinee....onew's voice kills me every time I hear it. It is so beautiful.
Mine's too!! This ballad really makes me cry!
Me too😊
Me too
They singing live and it sounds like a cd, unbelievable!
Could be because they're mostly standing still for this one. Easier to keep the voice steady while breathing at the same time.
With both singing and dancing going on at the same time I imagine it can be tough to keep that voice steady as they also need to maintain their breathing for the physical part so they don't get overtired.
I read somewhere that when official music videos are made, the artists sing along for the lip syncing parts during production as if live, but then that version of the song gets overdubbed by an official version of the song sung prior in order to make it sound more official I guess. Something like that.
Yeah! I had the same thought! I even told myself: "omg, they sound even better live!"... I'm really hoping to see one of their lives! They really worth it!
この曲大好き。5人が大好き。
Who is with me again in 2021 listening to this wonderful song
2025 who is here!?
Jonghyun's voice is amazing!!
Also, Minho's high note is fantastic, too. I hope he sings sharp more.
This song never gets old ❤️
Fff vvvfvfvdvfdddddddbdfrvddvvvcddddddebbkfffbbfereevvvfd. deddffedfffddfdfdff f2f ffmbfr Dec 歐kimkkcdcvdvvdfcc dvbfddbfdddf ebb fdrffffg e oio. mkk也有經濟欸嗯欸恩恩案啊喔啊啊恩已握哦也有欸無哦案誒矮欸欸愛玉 人氣下去仍熱情欸熬 澳奧運奧案欸玵此喔欸挨喔啊欸額喔nm konkukp kpplpppkpkpppkpppppppppppppkkpkkkkkppkkkpkppppppeecbvhx ojzpi.ky
still true 7 years later
@@mmoon8159 i agree with you !
See THIS is why I love SHINee!!!! I was thinking at first that this might be a lipsync....But of course I should have known that this was ALL LIVE!!!! Perfect vocals ugghhhh all the harmony!!! Minho's voice killed me Shinee Slayed my life once again!
음식을
2018년 입덕하고 샤이니 일본앨범 들으며 무한감동 느꼈던 기억~ 서서히 조금씩밖에 못들었는데~ 올해 진짜 지난 명곡들이 한꺼번에 머릿속에서 몰아친다 진짜 멋진 그룹............
They are truly the most talented group in Korea. Always feel original and fresh and less the cheesy elements.
Jonghyun's voice omg omg omg!!!
I loooooove ONEW VOICE
one of my favorite ballads of SHINee..
i love this song because the lines are equally distributed.. and you can hear their beautiful voice individually.. and when they harmonize it's heavenly! i'm quite amazed with minho.. i know he can sing but i don't expect him to be this good!
Best song it's harmonized beautifully. SHINee are known as God of live.
the day i will never love this song or never care about SHINee will be the end of the world
아직도 이거 들으러오는 샤월들 ~?! ❤️
역시 CDNee... 처음엔 ㄹㅇ 음원틀어놓은줄ㅋㅋㅋ
Almighty Key shines especially when he sings in Japanese:)
Sweaty Onew is my favourite Onew.. Jk... All Onews are my favourite.. His voice slays me..
Normally this kind of music isn't my favorite but SHINee just give this kind to music an aura that makes it sound so much better and each individual member's voice adds to the song
와진짜이건진짜너무쩐다...진짜아름답다ㅠㅠ정말 짱ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
오랜만에 봐도 좋네용
君だけを もっと
後には退けないほど
もっと あきれるほど
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ただ愛し続けてく
問いただしても 聴こえない
人の流れと 雨に濡れ
届きそうでも 届かない
ジカンはreverse oh
触れさせてよ そのheart
過去か未来で どうか
君だけを もっと
後には退けないほど
もっと あきれるほど
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ココロのままにOh I love you
今 keeping love again もう一度
Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ただ愛し続けてく
泣きたいくらい 逢いたくて
夢の狭間に 泣き濡れて
伝えたくても 伝わらない
ココロはreverse oh
聴かせてよ そのheart
まじわれる場所まで
君だけを もっと
後には退けないほど
もっと あきれるほど
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ココロのままにOh I love you
今 keeping love again もう一度
Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ただ愛し続けてく
願うなら この鼓動が
生命 刻む音 奏でるたび
ひとつ ふたつ 希望になって
ひとりが ふたりになって
愛は永遠に
君だけを もっと
後には退けないほど
もっと あきれるほど
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ココロのままにOh I love you
今 keeping love again もう一度
Again, and keeping love again ひたすらに
意味などないさ
生きてゆくことのように
ただ愛し続けてく
-君だけを-
That Minkey moment, please
minho was the one who sang multiple hilights of this song....I always loved minho's voice and singing, and wow in this performance his singing ability was very much pronounced, love it!!!!
مع حق صوت تشوي مينهو اسطورة❤❤
minho's angelic voice
정말 먼가 심금을 울리는 호소력이 있는것같다..최고야 이그룹b
Wow, this is DBSK quality...
zackitachi1
Exactly the thoughts going across my mind
Of Course 😊
IKR!!
Today is 18/01/2018... Its been past a month that our lovely Jonghyun is gone.. And i'm still here struggling to accept all those reality..Jonghyunniee.. How i wish you could feel our feelings for missing you alot now.. I wish you could feel our love.. And to imagine we couldn't hear your voice again really breaks our heart.. We miss you alot..everything about youuu.:(
MyFp MnYul 😢😢😢 same.. everyday still crying hard for him... feel so helpless and tired but i miss him so much 😢 trying to make me busy with something to distract myself but always end up watching him and cry...if only he know how much we love him 💔
Same 😢😢😢😢
Same here:(
I'm still trying to convince myself that everything is gonna be alright soon but time goes on and his place in my heart never changes and i just love him more and more
I still cant let him go 3 months on. 😭💔. I cant bare it. Im still mentally struggling and in pain. Ive been so close to giving up but have never been able to. I think Jonghyunie gave me signs. 😭😭😭
I know i need to let him go but why is it so hard to? 😭😭😭💔
Rest in peace Jonghyun... those of us still here will keep loving you, keep and keep and keep loving you
One of the best SHINee songs ever
This is my alarm during my highschool years gosh time flies now im heading 24 😭💎
I really love Minho's sweet and deep voice. I also love SHINee's Japanese songs because Minho has many singing parts.
Yes there may be other more popular kpop groups but for me SHINee are the best ever...
Wow, their Japanese is pretty good, very stable. 日本語上手！歌詞も素敵～
♪泣きたいくらい 逢いたくて
夢のハザマに泣きぬれて
伝えたくても 伝わらない
SLAYNee is slaying this live performance.
One of my favourite Japanese songs by SHINee and this was a great performance of it. I really like how i can hear Minho singing instead of rapping hehee He has a really nice voice. oh my goodness look at them sweat, we know you guys are working really hard, Fighting!
3:01-Minho & Key- This part gets me every time. Love all of their voices on this song. Love SHINee
tak mnie też bierze
Awe, I left this comment long ago and it's still very true :-) SHINee World Fighting!
Minho’s “kokoro no mama ni oh I love you “ oh my......😍
Generally him speaking Japanese 😍
Key is genius when it comes to speaking Japanese his pronounciation is perfect xx
" The Best Boyband Ever "... That's what i think...
Great song with a little " VIEW ".. T_T
+Thal Lu that's your opinion but I think Shinee is the best boy band tbh
EXO is the best boy band??? Dafuq???
아이고 예뻐라
Who's with me in 2019
Me!! I miss them!
2020, les esperamos, se les extraña muchísimo. 💙💎💙💎💙💎💙💎💙💎😍
Feb 25 2020
LOL! March 1, 2020! ✨❤️✨❤️✨❤️✨❤️✨❤️✨⚔️✨⚔️✨⚔️✨⚔️✨⚔️✨
Me ,March 4 2020 🇻🇳♥️
3:05 made the butterflies in my tummy go wild.
Really love that part!!
진짜노래잘부른다.........역시샤이니ㅠ.ㅠ
Will always come back to this song for its adlibs and high notes.
just luv onew
this song is my favorite because the parts are so equally distributed and you can hear each and everyone's amazing voices. This mostly goes for minho because he only gets one or two lines in korean singles, but he is actually a really good singer as you can see. because of the minimal lines, people talk crap about minho and how he doesn't match up to all the other shinee members, but that is not the case!!
I miss them terribly.. I hope Onew will fully recover soon so that they will have their comeback.
Their voices make me feel like a block of butter in a hot pan.... *melts instantly*...
I'm Onew biased
They all have such distinct jaw lines it is gorgeous
MINHO... Please let us hear MORE of your BEAUTIFUL VOICE....
I dont think anyone surpassed anyone because each memeber brings different sounds and feelings and has different qualities which make their voice so unique
SHINee and Shawol is my precious things
I really love it when minho has his own line :D HAHAHA. I love you SHINee oppars. ♥ ♥ ♥
This is SHINee,
An amazing leader, Onew, with incredible vocals despite the fact people aren't putting him as main vocal. According to me, he is one of the main vocal.
Jonghyun, that man is singing with his entire heart ♥
Minho, charismatic rapper, and actually has an angelic voice.
Key, the clearest and deepest voice I ever heard. I swear his emotions are going straight to me ♥
Taemin, one of the most talented kpop maknae to me, he did amazing progres with his vocals, and he has grown so fast ♥
SHINee never fails to touch people's hearts with their amazing music
One of the best song of 5hinee
Singing live perfectly whilst melting under the lights, yup that’s my SHINee
2020 doing SHINee marathon, miss them
大好きな大好きな、歌。
In love with Key's part from 2:01 to 2:10. That dude's my bias wrecker.
From all the sweat on their faces and necks, I can tell that they've been working really hard. This is one of the reasons why I'm so proud to be a Shawol. All five of the members of SHINee have amazing voices and talents. I'm so grateful to SM for putting them together into a group. Every song of SHINee's is amazing
It's really cool how everyone in SHINee have such different and unique voices from each other and yet when they sing together, the harmony is just beautiful.
I hope Minho keeps improving XD One day he might be able to sing a whole song and have more lines in their songs because honestly I love his singing so much more than his rapping and he just has so much potential.
한마디로 뿌듯하다 ㅠㅠㅠ♥
New fan. - appreciating each one !!
これ始めベッキーが本当に嬉しそうで好きだな！
KIM KIBUM!!! SO GLAD YOU GET TO SHINE AND SHOWCASE YOUR TRUE TALENTS IN TOHEART NOW :') KEY HWAITING!!!
💕
I love their Japanese songs because the vocals are spread more easily
No matter how many groups, idol I fell in love, at the end of the day, I still comeback to them because I miss them damn hard 😭
WHY DOESN'T MINHO SING MORE AGHH HIS VOICE IS SO GENTLE AND BEAUTIFUL ;-;
Yeah, you have a point!! I'd like to hear Minho's voice more... Even though he's not my bias (that is Key ^.^) I find his voice beautiful too... And I also reckon it's unfair he's the only one among Shinee's members not to have an important (a little longer, I mean) part to sing... btw he remains amazing
Alura White 👌👌
Onew Onew Onew the moment I wake up I think about you! All day I want to hear your voice so I listen to your songs...makes me so happy! Onew Forever!
Dear Lord, this song, their expressions, the harmony, their sweat, their emotions burst me into tears.
This is the first song where Minho has 17 seconds of singing!! I really love this song! and please more singing parts for Minho ^__^
Such a heart warming music harmonized really well
THIS SONG WILL NEVER BE THE SAME AGAIN LIVE.
역시 샤이니ㅠㅠ 라이브 쬲 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
That MinKey moment was so cute💗💘💓❤, all they were cute and singing faboluos!! 🎧🎤🎶🎼🎸
I love Minho´s voice is great,and Taemin in the min 3:13 you almost doesnt see it but is voice sound so deep and nice.Love it.
shinee is wonderful
When five different voices comes into one, is ANGELIC! Forever SHINee. ^^
could be anothers new groups out there but for me SHINee is like coming back home, is a feelling i cant even describe with words, 4ever 5hinee 💎💚😇
Onew's voice effortlessly slaying. Just oh so casually ruining my life. Thanks, man. Forever appreciated.
Your comment made my day💕✨💎
They have their own unique voices. They're just so awesome :"> Minhooooo~
SHINEE is Perfect! 5 Members
When I listen to this I feel like crying... It is such a good song! I love everthing about it!! I dont know, even if i cant understand ANYTHING AT ALL, i havent even looked the lyrics up and yet... I can feel the song, I can sense how wonderful the lyrics are, just by hearing it i can sort if understand the song. That is what SHINee does to me!!
It’s been 5yrs.
The grief and pain hasn’t lessened even the slightest of a bit.
Even don't i understand this song...but SHINee voice so warm just melt my heart Minho u have beautiful voice u know
I'm so proud to be a Shawol! I really thank SM for bringing these 5 men into a group. Saranghae, SHINee, FIGHTING!
I just love how the fans scream a little when Minho and Key looked at each other. Owww, MinKey feels
this song is jus out of this world..everytime I listen it seems so fresh n new..their voice..ahh its so soothing..such a wonderful group..