I would disagree with Haqqani. Jehad was not started in 1979 when Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan but right after partition when Pakistan sent Mujahideens dressed up as "Lashkars" to capture Kashmir.
@@ModinikiLuli-m5n you mean suicide bombers? And this isn’t 1665, we should be living in an age of science and culture not War. Aim for peace like Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh tradition
Hussain Haqqani says India and Pakistan will be brought together (or atleast the relationship will be driven by) economics This is highly unlikely as they are separated by religion. Religious fanaticism (in Pakistan) will prevent them from making real progress on economic issues. Terrorism from Pakistan originates from religion more than Kashmir as they try to make the world believe. Pakistan has no will to reduce religious fanaticism as their Army is steeped in religion since the past 2 decades.
Sir , very rightly said that Economic Relations can hope for betterment . But if I correctly remember , it was started by Mr. Nawaz Sharif and what we got was Kargil plus Nawaz Sharif exiled . Next time , when both Narendra Modi and Nawaz Sharif tried to sort out , India got Pathankot Attack. The exact problem here is , people of Pakistan has to believe in Political Government and work with it rather on Military Government.
HAVING LISTENED TO Mr Haqqaani,...I tend to admire him,for his balanced,frank & fourth right views on INDO-PAK RELATIONS.He does not mince words nor circumlocute on the issue. his reasoning is acceptable,his analysis & understanding of the situation is so different from the one 'entrenched' view being circulated in PAKISTANI ESTABLISHMENT.HE points out the fact that,the average perception of the common people of PAKISTAN is highly tutored,manipulated & twisted by the powers that be, which is hell bent on calling INDIA the aggressor......well i would love to read his book, as he advices by PURCHASING IT...!!!........BUT, CONCERNED AS I AM ABOUT HIS IDEA OF RETURNING TO HIS COUNTRY OF BIRTH, I WOULD VENTURE TO SAY TO HIM ...''NOT TO GO BACK''....for certainly, he will be dead meat...!!!....there are venomous elements waiting for him to come back only to finish him off....tolerance is scarce in PAKISTAN,especially after the military junta bred the fundamentalists........
11:30 ""Victory on all fronts", was the headline in largest circulation English language newspaper of pak, Dawn, on 16th Dec 1971 - as pak forces were surrendering in Dhaka! " Haqqani. Another example, known to neighbourhood kids, was pak radio stations telling their nation in '65 that pak forces have invaded Delhi and destroyed Taj Mahal! India was listening where they could catch pak, and having a good laugh during curfew and blackout times of the war pak forced on India.
7:00 - 7:45 Haqqani forgets, the major difference is pak régimes alienated pak people from their roots, by teaching them in schools to hate India, and telling them they were not Indian, they were anything but! Neither East German régimes nor stasi did anything remotely similar to East Germany, and the only doctrine separating was communism, the only lie told was responsibility of Holocaust being on right wing and East Germany being free of it. This is minor, compared to pak régimes teaching pak children pride in heritage of invaders killing Indians and looting India. East Germany did not go into terrorism to attack West Germany and neighbourhood generally, pak did.
worth listening to literate person like him..today i was watchin videos of pakistan villages where the hindus and sikhs used to live and people over there in thise villges were like super welcoming people for those indians who visited there ...the old people were recalling the memories with the all communities.m from punjab and my grand mother used to tell us about the people in their village in lyalpurrr
It actually is. Mountbatten saw to it that it was done, for his part in dividing the nation. It is of course true that Pakistan got a disproportionately larger armed force, that's the only exception.
people of both countries have to change image of people in their minds on opposite side..as they are taught in pakistan primary school books that other communities are bad has to be changed...
Salute to this great intellectual of Pakistan. Hope Pakistani army shut down terror industries and develop good relation with India which help Pakistani economy otherwise Pakistan had no future.
You are the best we want peace between Afghanistan , India and Pakistan and Pakistan must Know they waist 70 year and fighting with your brothers Afghan and Indian people . Pakistani people week up. Time to bring change.
Greg jenko i totally agree with you they are causing issues in the world...my country is most affected by them..i was saying this for a reason that in that particular where my grandparents lived the muslims in that particular territory protected them and then as my family had a place to live here they chose to come to india and i think that was a fortunate decision you can see the environment now of pakistan in the world but still ghere are some people in muslim world who are not that radical....but yes most of them are its in their kouran
The other day (3 months back )we were having good time in the valley. ...we found courteous hotel staff aam aadmi is friendly, we had a dinner in the kashmiri residence But we could not help but notice the poverty Both local and national politicians have failed kashmiri people The speaker has rightly said "we have made aam kashmiris a foot ball "
Kashmir is a border state at receiving end of terrorism focus from a terror export factory misnamed country across border, and the terrorists or military across border couldn't care less about the people of Kashmir as proved by the shelling targeting civilians, terrorists burning schools, and ethnic cleansing of non muslims for demanding Kashmir in an islamists agenda of world conquest. That stopped tourism and film shooting on major scale that was a major source of economy. Other than that, Kashmir is pampered at expense of the poorer states of India, with completely free education, guaranteed food no matter what, and so forth. Failed? Those friendly locals, how many were involved in informing the terrorists in '90 about where a non muslim neighbour was hiding, so his head was cut off before his family? Hussain Haqqani fears visiting his nation for fear of being murdered for accusations of being non muslim!
Ambassador Hussain Haqqani is very optimistic on the relationship between India and Pakistan and quotes France and Germany relationship in 1945 and to day. hat the Ambassador forgot is that they had no problem like "Kashmir".
Radhakrishnan, France and Germany have had many territorial problems,and many major wars, in their history. The fact that they can unite in the EU after such a turbulent history shows that peace and friendship between India and Pakistan is very possible and desirable.
Pakistan seems ideologically in a different planet altogether! It stil abides by the "2 nation theory" after it failed in 1972. It is today a hub of terrorism worldwide and is ruled by proxy by Army and ISI. Which part of all these do you think can be reconciled before any serious effort can be made towards friendship. IMV, none.
Only issue of Kashmir is POK is to be absorbed to India... n Pakistan has to be broken up. This Haqqani is also a smooth talking believer in 2 nation theory !
4:01 to begin with, history of India predates rising of Himaalaya, which is far older than a few thousand years; and that makes "five thousand years of shared history" twice as wrong, especially in light of pak rejecting it's reality of being a broken off part of India and embracing the heritage of invading looting colonising and marauding non Indians! Haqqani forgets that in light of such rejection, pak is more a notion than a country, and this notion is less than seven decades old, and it's basis if in two nation theory was gone before its silver jubilee, so the only basis of pak separation from India is an intolerance that is creed of pak - hence the terrorism export adopted so naturally as national business! Racism is inherent there too, as evident in pak generals declaring intention of changing the DNA of East Bengal before sailing to massacre three million and rape half a million!
With due respect to ambassador Haqqani's erudition & experience, the issue of muslim majority has not been addressed here. Nor is it ever likely to be ! Pakistan shows all the sympathy & aids and abets the terrorism in kashmir only because it has fertile soil of muslims in majority ! This is not going to change even if both countries decide to open the borders. The issue of Kashmir can internally be sorted out with abrogation of article 370 provisions. This alone would help change the demographics of the region.Look, no part of India has any 'alienation issues' with govt when it has Hindu majority !! So, re-organising the demography of the region is single most effective route to peace whether Pakistan is on board or not !! Lifting of AFSPA should directly be linked - and it actually is linked to volatility of muslim majority - to article 370 provisions. Kashmiri people must be told in no uncertain terms that in the presence of article 370 AFSPA can never be lifted from Valley (without the danger of return of 1989 like chaos).
@1:45 Only difference is Germany was not radicalised while Pakistan is. Germany and France realised the betterment of people is way ahead. While Pakistan doesn't care for its own people....!
_IF ONLY PAKISTANI PEOPLE, NOT JUST THE GOVT OR ARMY OR ISI, COMPLETELY GIVE UP THEIR RELIGIOUS FANATICISM AND STOP LOOKING AT INDIA AS THEIR PERMANENT ENEMY NO.1, THEN THINGS CAN CHANGE_ 🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩
4:27 India was forced to go overboard by Gandhi fasting until India gave 55 crores to pak at a time when pak had attacked India and this after ethnic cleansing of non muslims from West pak via massacres forcing exodus of non muslims, reducing their numbers from over a quarter of population to barely two percent. On the other hand muslims of India did not migrate to pak en masse, but migrated depending on their level of intolerance re living with non muslims. Haqqani is being less than truthful in accusing India of not sharing.
With all due respects to Hussain Haqqani, why should india even hold any dialogue with pakistan. To us pakistan is a non entitity waiting to get broken in to multiple pieces and no india will not do it but the rogue nature of pakistani state itself will be responsibile for it. Kashmir has been culturally hindu for 5000 years named so after hindu sage Kashyap rishi. It has been islamic only for last 500 years after the barbaric invaders looted it and converted the people when hindus were weak. Now we are no longer weak and we know how to keep to ourselves what is rightfully ours. Also according the rules british made for partition of india, once the ruler signs accession thats it. After that people have no say in it and most of the kashmiris not only in indian kashmir but also the so called azad kashmir and gilgit/baltistan also want to join india as they realized pakistan is an uncivilized, barbaric and brute state. All we need to do is to wait until pakistan disintegrates to annex pakistan occupied kashmir and gilgit/baltistan with india. After that there wont be any pakistan and there wont be any kashmir problem
5:45 pak "has been in terrorism business since '79" - no, unless pak accepts Kashmir was attacked by pak military, it was terrorists sent by Jinnah as he inadvertently let slip to Mountbatten, but even before that, Jinnah commanding massacre of ten thousand in Calcutta alone in three days, by knives and not guns, most victims non muslims, was terrorism perpetrated in demand of a separate piece of India for muslims who couldn't tolerate living in a democracy with others; so terrorism was at very foundation of pak! What's more, since partition, paid régimes have gone on to take extraordinary measures to sow hatred for non muslims in pak, such as teaching false history in schools and making heroes of every possible invader and killer who marauded India and was of non Indian origin; this rooted pak firmly in terrorism as it's very basis foundation, and not merely a mixture in foundation or a convenient business for régimes zia onwards. If pak stops terrorism it has no reason to remain a separated broken off piece of Mother India.
Much has changed in six years, but not Pakistan. Just yesterday they caught a couple of radical Pakistanis in Greece. Pakistan has lost the chance to get the economic chance.
Sheikh Ejaz No it was good. At least we got away from 20 crore terrorists. They are followers of virulent inhuman wahabi Islam ,which is the biggest threat to the mankind.
This has been the narrative of India since 1948. But hum to Dushman hay mere Pakistani vaio ... chalo apne to sunlo. Dekhlo kaun suchhe the Hindustan ya Pakistan. Aab Such hazam hota hay to to ye Dushmani khatam kare nehi to chalne de ... 60 saal kam nehi hote kisi adaat ke liye.
5:33-5:57. where are those Pakistanis who accuse INDIA and Afghanistan for the terrorism in their country. your painted a target on yourself by bringing in Jihadis. How long do u think u can deal with these terrorists in your land?
AFTER THE AI 184 HIJACK, PARL ATTACK & 26.11.2008 ATTACK ON MUMBAI, THE INDIAN PEOPLE WOULD NEVER BE ABLE TO LOOK AT PAK AS A FRIEND. IF WE GET A CHANCE, _EVERY PATRIOTIC INDIAN_ WOULD WANT TO GET PAK COMPLETELY CRIPPLED. AND THEY HAVE _EARNED_ THIS BIGOTRY. NOBODY CAN BLAME INDIANS FOR HARBORING HOSTILITY AGAINST SUCH INHUMAN CRUEL FANATIC ZOMBIES. JAI HIND.🚩🇮🇳
The current situation is India should take action against Pakistan and the UN also going to suggest the same very soon....because Muslims in India are very good people...but there are certain Muslim Organizations which are recruiting Muslims in India towards terrorism. Zakka or his channel never tried to take this kind of initiative of speaking with Pak officials to understand their thoughts & stands. But all of sudden Zakka wanted to do this interview makes people of India to think in a different angle. Probably Zakka or his channel should be screened to see if they have any link with Pakistan officials...because at this point of time Pakistan can not deny any of India's allegation towards the terrorist attacks what just happened...so there could be lot of possibilities that these Media are paid by Pak to take these kind of interview and make a situation tomorrow that these Media themselves will blame India that Pak was liking to be friend of India and we should not have a war with them.....
Pakistan is not behaving as a member separated from the main family in a move to set up an independant family on the contrary Pakistan after separating from India for wrong reasons has not only been behaving as an enemy of the parent country but has actually proclaimed and proved itself as eternal enemy of India ever since it's inception, without any hope of any reconciliation and/or improvement of relations. 70 years is a long enough period of time to test and prove any relation either way. Before The pro- Pakistan narrative of Mr Hussain Hakkani, who enjoys very good standing outside Pakistan, is given any serious consideration, his own personal acceptability must be seen in the light of what Pakistan thinks about Mr Hakkani. India, the greatest democratic country in the world, has every right to guard its borders and citIzens against any foreign aggression by all means and at all times, with all its might.
He is more focused on his book rather than finding the proper solution. He often talks about his Book. He often says...India also ......India also....so on ... He gives examples European countries. There is big difference. In my opinion First thing in Pakistan has to do is to establish true democratic institution what India has. Second Army should have less power then elected democratic gov. Only then there will be congenial environment and to create the platform of Talk between India and Pak.
Hussain Saheb I want to object to your statement that jihad began in 1979. Pak ever since it was born, always had this nefarious mindset be it while gobbling balochistan which was _Kala´t_ or snatching a chunk of Kashmir which was quite lawfully handed over to India by Raja Hari Singh!! A demon has his devilish fangs by birth. It doesnt acquire' em later. Although Hussainbhai I have great respect and admiration for your honesty and courage! Just felt like correcting something that wasnt conforming with historic facts. Hari Om!
if there will be peace between both countries. Pakistanis will economically profit several times more than India but who will then need Pakistani military. that's why Pakistani military will never ever let peace between both countries happen. India is just playing the game of Pakistani military.
10:30 if Haqqani is speaking of US and USSR relationship as model, he couldn't have forgotten the use of pak terrorists by US against USSR in Afghanistan, surely? And that pak is using the same against India and generally others in the world, not just the neighbourhood?
Responding to a post about how people of Kashmir are poor due to national and local politicians failing them:- Kashmir is a border state at receiving end of terrorism focus from a terror export factory misnamed country across border, and the terrorists or military across border couldn't care less about the people of Kashmir as proved by the shelling targeting civilians, terrorists burning schools, and ethnic cleansing of non muslims for demanding Kashmir in an islamists agenda of world conquest. That stopped tourism and film shooting on major scale that was a major source of economy. Other than that, Kashmir is pampered at expense of the poorer states of India, with completely free education, guaranteed food no matter what, and so forth. Failed? Those friendly locals, how many were involved in informing the terrorists in '90 about where a non muslim neighbour was hiding, so his head was cut off before his family? Hussain Haqqani fears visiting his nation for fear of being murdered for accusations of being non muslim!
They may be intellectual but they all are hypocrites.. fact remains this only.. This Haqqani fellow starts sounding like some roadchaap jihadi.. what else do we expect from the resident of a country born out of hindu hate..and yes mr. Haqqani we will fight till our last breath for Kashmir..
Hussain Haqani, try to keep himself alive , although he is a dead personality. To activate U.S he often raise this jehadi stance. There is NO such thing visible. Making himself chootia/fool.
Partha, It would be much better, and more realistic, if both Pakistan and India could develop peace and friendship. Just think how much time, energy and money it would save both countries; also, how much we could gain from each other. We are next door neighbours; it's crazy to have so much enmity between us when our cultures are so similar in many ways.
You want dance of SUICIDE Bomber in India? It can happen in two condition Either India become Islamize or Pakistan become Hinduize. Former possibility is maximum than of Later.
India-Pakistan-Afghanistan should have a good relations and understanding. Its Pakistan's bad policy against Afghanistan and India to occupy their lands made situation worse. Now, no one want to believe on Pakistan and both of them want to finish Pakistan.--->from America
This Hakkani seems bit sensible guy but what he missed is that :: Islam is a terrorist cult started by the first terrorist of the world Mohammad who attacked Makka & Madia & himself killed thousand of innocent people. UN would have declared him a terrorist more dangerous the Osama if UN would have have existed in those days Mohammad was a product of a Arabic nomadic tribal cult of sword who used a concept called Allah (a PIMP) & used it for luring of hoors to terrorists in lieu of crime shows another aspect of Mohammad that he was a sex addict mentally sick person apart from being terrorist.
ha ha ha...your sarcasm will not change facts. He is a traitor by all means. Stop getting into politics. He was an ambassador and there are some rules to abide by even though you were fired from that position. Shouldn't be going against the very country you represented. you can go against the people of that country but the land itself. Learn to respect the land you belong to.
I would disagree with Haqqani. Jehad was not started in 1979 when Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan but right after partition when Pakistan sent Mujahideens dressed up as "Lashkars" to capture Kashmir.
Yes I agree but produce like factory after 1979.
Hindus just jealous they haven't got warriors like that
@@ModinikiLuli-m5n you mean suicide bombers? And this isn’t 1665, we should be living in an age of science and culture not War. Aim for peace like Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh tradition
educated person with knowledge of history..worth listening him....
Mr Hussain, your higher intellect and knowledge with backing of facts are worth while listening. He explains things so simply without any bias.😊👍
Hussain Haqqani says India and Pakistan will be brought together (or atleast the relationship will be driven by) economics
This is highly unlikely as they are separated by religion. Religious fanaticism (in Pakistan) will prevent them from making real progress on economic issues.
Terrorism from Pakistan originates from religion more than Kashmir as they try to make the world believe.
Pakistan has no will to reduce religious fanaticism as their Army is steeped in religion since the past 2 decades.
After a very long time, I have seen a educated Pakistani...
Sir , very rightly said that Economic Relations can hope for betterment . But if I correctly remember , it was started by Mr. Nawaz Sharif and what we got was Kargil plus Nawaz Sharif exiled . Next time , when both Narendra Modi and Nawaz Sharif tried to sort out , India got Pathankot Attack. The exact problem here is , people of Pakistan has to believe in Political Government and work with it rather on Military Government.
HAVING LISTENED TO Mr Haqqaani,...I tend to admire him,for his balanced,frank & fourth right views on INDO-PAK RELATIONS.He does not mince words nor circumlocute on the issue. his reasoning is acceptable,his analysis & understanding of the situation is so different from the one 'entrenched' view being circulated in PAKISTANI ESTABLISHMENT.HE points out the fact that,the average perception of the common people of PAKISTAN is highly tutored,manipulated & twisted by the powers that be, which is hell bent on calling INDIA the aggressor......well i would love to read his book, as he advices by PURCHASING IT...!!!........BUT, CONCERNED AS I AM ABOUT HIS IDEA OF RETURNING TO HIS COUNTRY OF BIRTH, I WOULD VENTURE TO SAY TO HIM ...''NOT TO GO BACK''....for certainly, he will be dead meat...!!!....there are venomous elements waiting for him to come back only to finish him off....tolerance is scarce in PAKISTAN,especially after the military junta bred the fundamentalists........
First time I see a pakistani speaking sensibly and the truth..
A very wise man from Pakistan who lives in USA today.
Because Pakistan administration will charge him for treason and eliminate him
11:30 ""Victory on all fronts", was the headline in largest circulation English language newspaper of pak, Dawn, on 16th Dec 1971 - as pak forces were surrendering in Dhaka! " Haqqani. Another example, known to neighbourhood kids, was pak radio stations telling their nation in '65 that pak forces have invaded Delhi and destroyed Taj Mahal! India was listening where they could catch pak, and having a good laugh during curfew and blackout times of the war pak forced on India.
Husain haqani is one of the most rational person from Pakistan to be trust upon...
Wishing more and more people like be there in Pakistan who advocates to eradicate terrorist centuries from Pakistan.
7:00 - 7:45 Haqqani forgets, the major difference is pak régimes alienated pak people from their roots, by teaching them in schools to hate India, and telling them they were not Indian, they were anything but! Neither East German régimes nor stasi did anything remotely similar to East Germany, and the only doctrine separating was communism, the only lie told was responsibility of Holocaust being on right wing and East Germany being free of it. This is minor, compared to pak régimes teaching pak children pride in heritage of invaders killing Indians and looting India. East Germany did not go into terrorism to attack West Germany and neighbourhood generally, pak did.
worth listening to literate person like him..today i was watchin videos of pakistan villages where the hindus and sikhs used to live and people over there in thise villges were like super welcoming people for those indians who visited there ...the old people were recalling the memories with the all communities.m from punjab and my grand mother used to tell us about the people in their village in lyalpurrr
Religion and Kashmir are the barrier between these two nations
@@trueravan hi randian
@@clashwithabdullah3541 Kya hua be? Apni ammi ke naam se kyo bula raha hai, jihadi pisslami madarsa-chhap jahil?
That's not a barrier it's a reality and one must not refrain from it.
yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssssss
4:19 "India didn't think of Pakistan as a member of its family ... reflected in the distribution of resources etc .. "
I think that is not true.
It actually is. Mountbatten saw to it that it was done, for his part in dividing the nation. It is of course true that Pakistan got a disproportionately larger armed force, that's the only exception.
Product of reality television...... So true so true
He is being very honest analyst ever in history of pakistan.
Zakka Jacob is an awesome excellent journalist
As a Tamilian happy to see a fellow tamilians
Tamil tigers 😈😈
The meaning of Libertarian, All balochi brothers are 100 Percent Pakistani, do not allow enemy to give you a wrong idea.
yeah just saying it wont do a thing,you need to stop killing them.
The most intelligent person in Pakistan
haqqani needs to be prime of pak
dawud khan It is useless as long as whole pakistan understands the truth.
people of both countries have to change image of people in their minds on opposite side..as they are taught in pakistan primary school books that other communities are bad has to be changed...
God bless you sir haqqani
Salute to this great intellectual of Pakistan. Hope Pakistani army shut down terror industries and develop good relation with India which help Pakistani economy otherwise Pakistan had no future.
10:05 that opportunity will come after the independence of Baluchistan
exactly
fuck u Pakistan zindabad
daniel061208 lol.. he probably attended an elite pork school. They just teach how to use a keyboard
stop making fun of porkistan
***** independent Khyber Pakthunkawa
Splendid ❤️
You are the best we want peace between Afghanistan , India and Pakistan and Pakistan must Know they waist 70 year and fighting with your brothers Afghan and Indian people . Pakistani people week up. Time to bring change.
Greg jenko i totally agree with you they are causing issues in the world...my country is most affected by them..i was saying this for a reason that in that particular where my grandparents lived the muslims in that particular territory protected them and then as my family had a place to live here they chose to come to india and i think that was a fortunate decision you can see the environment now of pakistan in the world but still ghere are some people in muslim world who are not that radical....but yes most of them are its in their kouran
The other day (3 months back )we were having good time in the valley. ...we found courteous hotel staff
aam aadmi is friendly, we had a dinner in the kashmiri residence
But we could not help but notice the poverty
Both local and national politicians have failed kashmiri people
The speaker has rightly said "we have made aam kashmiris a foot ball "
Kashmir is a border state at receiving end of terrorism focus from a terror export factory misnamed country across border, and the terrorists or military across border couldn't care less about the people of Kashmir as proved by the shelling targeting civilians, terrorists burning schools, and ethnic cleansing of non muslims for demanding Kashmir in an islamists agenda of world conquest. That stopped tourism and film shooting on major scale that was a major source of economy. Other than that, Kashmir is pampered at expense of the poorer states of India, with completely free education, guaranteed food no matter what, and so forth. Failed? Those friendly locals, how many were involved in informing the terrorists in '90 about where a non muslim neighbour was hiding, so his head was cut off before his family? Hussain Haqqani fears visiting his nation for fear of being murdered for accusations of being non muslim!
Most per capita investment has gone to Kashmir....all gets gobbled up
Both countries have to deregulate their policy... They are both dwelling in old Cold War past.
wrong thing with this man is... he always blame equally both India and Pakistan.
That's right thing.
Ambassador Hussain Haqqani is very optimistic on the relationship between India and Pakistan and quotes France and Germany relationship in 1945 and to day. hat the Ambassador forgot is that they had no problem like "Kashmir".
Radhakrishnan, France and Germany have had many territorial problems,and many major wars, in their history. The fact that they can unite in the EU after such a turbulent history shows that peace and friendship between India and Pakistan is very possible and desirable.
Senior Rocker
Pakistan seems ideologically in a different planet altogether!
It stil abides by the "2 nation theory" after it failed in 1972. It is today a hub of terrorism worldwide and is ruled by proxy by Army and ISI.
Which part of all these do you think can be reconciled before any serious effort can be made towards friendship.
IMV, none.
Only issue of Kashmir is POK is to be absorbed to India... n Pakistan has to be broken up. This Haqqani is also a smooth talking believer in 2 nation theory !
4:01 to begin with, history of India predates rising of Himaalaya, which is far older than a few thousand years; and that makes "five thousand years of shared history" twice as wrong, especially in light of pak rejecting it's reality of being a broken off part of India and embracing the heritage of invading looting colonising and marauding non Indians! Haqqani forgets that in light of such rejection, pak is more a notion than a country, and this notion is less than seven decades old, and it's basis if in two nation theory was gone before its silver jubilee, so the only basis of pak separation from India is an intolerance that is creed of pak - hence the terrorism export adopted so naturally as national business! Racism is inherent there too, as evident in pak generals declaring intention of changing the DNA of East Bengal before sailing to massacre three million and rape half a million!
We at least have people like haqqani to point out a problem plz look into ur own intolerance instead of pointing out ours
With due respect to ambassador Haqqani's erudition & experience, the issue of muslim majority has not been addressed here. Nor is it ever likely to be ! Pakistan shows all the sympathy & aids and abets the terrorism in kashmir only because it has fertile soil of muslims in majority ! This is not going to change even if both countries decide to open the borders. The issue of Kashmir can internally be sorted out with abrogation of article 370 provisions. This alone would help change the demographics of the region.Look, no part of India has any 'alienation issues' with govt when it has Hindu majority !! So, re-organising the demography of the region is single most effective route to peace whether Pakistan is on board or not !! Lifting of AFSPA should directly be linked - and it actually is linked to volatility of muslim majority - to article 370 provisions. Kashmiri people must be told in no uncertain terms that in the presence of article 370 AFSPA can never be lifted from Valley (without the danger of return of 1989 like chaos).
@1:45 Only difference is Germany was not radicalised while Pakistan is. Germany and France realised the betterment of people is way ahead. While Pakistan doesn't care for its own people....!
_IF ONLY PAKISTANI PEOPLE, NOT JUST THE GOVT OR ARMY OR ISI, COMPLETELY GIVE UP THEIR RELIGIOUS FANATICISM AND STOP LOOKING AT INDIA AS THEIR PERMANENT ENEMY NO.1, THEN THINGS CAN CHANGE_
🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩
4:27 India was forced to go overboard by Gandhi fasting until India gave 55 crores to pak at a time when pak had attacked India and this after ethnic cleansing of non muslims from West pak via massacres forcing exodus of non muslims, reducing their numbers from over a quarter of population to barely two percent. On the other hand muslims of India did not migrate to pak en masse, but migrated depending on their level of intolerance re living with non muslims. Haqqani is being less than truthful in accusing India of not sharing.
With all due respects to Hussain Haqqani, why should india even hold any dialogue with pakistan. To us pakistan is a non entitity waiting to get broken in to multiple pieces and no india will not do it but the rogue nature of pakistani state itself will be responsibile for it. Kashmir has been culturally hindu for 5000 years named so after hindu sage Kashyap rishi. It has been islamic only for last 500 years after the barbaric invaders looted it and converted the people when hindus were weak. Now we are no longer weak and we know how to keep to ourselves what is rightfully ours. Also according the rules british made for partition of india, once the ruler signs accession thats it. After that people have no say in it and most of the kashmiris not only in indian kashmir but also the so called azad kashmir and gilgit/baltistan also want to join india as they realized pakistan is an uncivilized, barbaric and brute state. All we need to do is to wait until pakistan disintegrates to annex pakistan occupied kashmir and gilgit/baltistan with india. After that there wont be any pakistan and there wont be any kashmir problem
5:45 pak "has been in terrorism business since '79" - no, unless pak accepts Kashmir was attacked by pak military, it was terrorists sent by Jinnah as he inadvertently let slip to Mountbatten, but even before that, Jinnah commanding massacre of ten thousand in Calcutta alone in three days, by knives and not guns, most victims non muslims, was terrorism perpetrated in demand of a separate piece of India for muslims who couldn't tolerate living in a democracy with others; so terrorism was at very foundation of pak! What's more, since partition, paid régimes have gone on to take extraordinary measures to sow hatred for non muslims in pak, such as teaching false history in schools and making heroes of every possible invader and killer who marauded India and was of non Indian origin; this rooted pak firmly in terrorism as it's very basis foundation, and not merely a mixture in foundation or a convenient business for régimes zia onwards. If pak stops terrorism it has no reason to remain a separated broken off piece of Mother India.
Much has changed in six years, but not Pakistan. Just yesterday they caught a couple of radical Pakistanis in Greece.
Pakistan has lost the chance to get the economic chance.
good thoughts..can't move a bit unless address their state sponsored terrorism. ..
partition. of. India. was. THE. wrong. idea.
Sheikh Ejaz No it was good. At least we got away from 20 crore terrorists. They are followers of virulent inhuman wahabi Islam ,which is the biggest threat to the mankind.
Yes , ejaj I agree with you.....
Oops..
This has been the narrative of India since 1948. But hum to Dushman hay mere Pakistani vaio ... chalo apne to sunlo. Dekhlo kaun suchhe the Hindustan ya Pakistan. Aab Such hazam hota hay to to ye Dushmani khatam kare nehi to chalne de ... 60 saal kam nehi hote kisi adaat ke liye.
Predicted Trump way before
5:33-5:57.
where are those Pakistanis who accuse INDIA and Afghanistan for the terrorism in their country. your painted a target on yourself by bringing in Jihadis. How long do u think u can deal with these terrorists in your land?
AFTER THE AI 184 HIJACK, PARL ATTACK & 26.11.2008 ATTACK ON MUMBAI, THE INDIAN PEOPLE WOULD NEVER BE ABLE TO LOOK AT PAK AS A FRIEND. IF WE GET A CHANCE, _EVERY PATRIOTIC INDIAN_ WOULD WANT TO GET PAK COMPLETELY CRIPPLED. AND THEY HAVE _EARNED_ THIS BIGOTRY. NOBODY CAN BLAME INDIANS FOR HARBORING HOSTILITY AGAINST SUCH INHUMAN CRUEL FANATIC ZOMBIES.
JAI HIND.🚩🇮🇳
Only key is Pakistan if India has to develop more and nore
NOW INDIA HAS DONE PARTIALLY WHAT PAK IS TO DO. ADVISE THEM PROPERLY.
The current situation is India should take action against Pakistan and the UN also going to suggest the same very soon....because Muslims in India are very good people...but there are certain Muslim Organizations which are recruiting Muslims in India towards terrorism. Zakka or his channel never tried to take this kind of initiative of speaking with Pak officials to understand their thoughts & stands. But all of sudden Zakka wanted to do this interview makes people of India to think in a different angle. Probably Zakka or his channel should be screened to see if they have any link with Pakistan officials...because at this point of time Pakistan can not deny any of India's allegation towards the terrorist attacks what just happened...so there could be lot of possibilities that these Media are paid by Pak to take these kind of interview and make a situation tomorrow that these Media themselves will blame India that Pak was liking to be friend of India and we should not have a war with them.....
Pakistan is not behaving as a member separated from the main family in a move to set up an independant family on the contrary Pakistan after separating from India for wrong reasons has not only been behaving as an enemy of the parent country but has actually proclaimed and proved itself as eternal enemy of India ever since it's inception, without any hope of any reconciliation and/or improvement of relations. 70 years is a long enough period of time to test and prove any relation either way. Before The pro- Pakistan narrative of Mr Hussain Hakkani, who enjoys very good standing outside Pakistan, is given any serious consideration, his own personal acceptability must be seen in the light of what Pakistan thinks about Mr Hakkani. India, the greatest democratic country in the world, has every right to guard its borders and citIzens against any foreign aggression by all means and at all times, with all its might.
He is more focused on his book rather than finding the proper solution. He often talks about his Book. He often says...India also ......India also....so on ... He gives examples European countries. There is big difference. In my opinion First thing in Pakistan has to do is to establish true democratic institution what India has. Second Army should have less power then elected democratic gov. Only then there will be congenial environment and to create the platform of Talk between India and Pak.
Hussain Saheb I want to object to your statement that jihad began in 1979. Pak ever since it was born, always had this nefarious mindset be it while gobbling balochistan which was _Kala´t_ or snatching a chunk of Kashmir which was quite lawfully handed over to India by Raja Hari Singh!! A demon has his devilish fangs by birth. It doesnt acquire' em later.
Although Hussainbhai I have great respect and admiration for your honesty and courage! Just felt like correcting something that wasnt conforming with historic facts. Hari Om!
if there will be peace between both countries. Pakistanis will economically profit several times more than India but who will then need Pakistani military. that's why Pakistani military will never ever let peace between both countries happen. India is just playing the game of Pakistani military.
HH is the best person 👍
Haqqani also be get Indian nationallity
Burney sander _ Hussain Haqqani _ Jamat-e-Islami in Karachi.
10:30 if Haqqani is speaking of US and USSR relationship as model, he couldn't have forgotten the use of pak terrorists by US against USSR in Afghanistan, surely? And that pak is using the same against India and generally others in the world, not just the neighbourhood?
Responding to a post about how people of Kashmir are poor due to national and local politicians failing them:-
Kashmir is a border state at receiving end of terrorism focus from a terror export factory misnamed country across border, and the terrorists or military across border couldn't care less about the people of Kashmir as proved by the shelling targeting civilians, terrorists burning schools, and ethnic cleansing of non muslims for demanding Kashmir in an islamists agenda of world conquest. That stopped tourism and film shooting on major scale that was a major source of economy. Other than that, Kashmir is pampered at expense of the poorer states of India, with completely free education, guaranteed food no matter what, and so forth. Failed? Those friendly locals, how many were involved in informing the terrorists in '90 about where a non muslim neighbour was hiding, so his head was cut off before his family? Hussain Haqqani fears visiting his nation for fear of being murdered for accusations of being non muslim!
He dnt talk about how Pakistan is using militancy to pursue unrest in Kashmir
French are different from Pakistan. They have sense Pakistan does not.
well said sir Ji going to Pakistan conditions?
They may be intellectual but they all are hypocrites.. fact remains this only.. This Haqqani fellow starts sounding like some roadchaap jihadi.. what else do we expect from the resident of a country born out of hindu hate..and yes mr. Haqqani we will fight till our last breath for Kashmir..
i mean protected the whole village from muslims
independent Indian kashmir is the key to peace
Hussain Haqani, try to keep himself alive , although he is a dead personality. To activate U.S he often raise this jehadi stance. There is NO such thing visible. Making himself chootia/fool.
the traitor always do this like hussain haqani
Gandhi g ko Indians jotty py nae likhty bs dandda pakrra k note py rakha hova ha...
Why cant India and Pakistan merge togather
Are ypu crazy!!
Partha, It would be much better, and more realistic, if both Pakistan and India could develop peace and friendship. Just think how much time, energy and money it would save both countries; also, how much we could gain from each other. We are next door neighbours; it's crazy to have so much enmity between us when our cultures are so similar in many ways.
Barb, see my reply to Partha. I hope you agree with me.
Partha Sahu You have to be MAD to think like that!
You want dance of SUICIDE Bomber in India? It can happen in two condition Either India become Islamize or Pakistan become Hinduize. Former possibility is maximum than of Later.
Main problem is Islam..
India-Pakistan-Afghanistan should have a good relations and understanding. Its Pakistan's bad policy against Afghanistan and India to occupy their lands made situation worse. Now, no one want to believe on Pakistan and both of them want to finish Pakistan.--->from America
ak bat samajh nhi ati ki eitanay paray likhay responsible parson Pakistan ky bahar rahatay h qu??????? kya uonko ak1% dimag nhi same Pakistani
HOsain aqni is pakistani trump
Lakhlalanat duno kutunbpa
This video appears to be an Indian propoganda video
too hard for madrasa jahisl to digest allah u akbar go boom
Pakistanio, NEVER trust Husain Haqqani, he can say and do anything for his personal benefits. He is a traitor and should be punished.
traitor at his best
by "traitor" do u mean one who doesn't share ur demented vision of GHAZWA E HIND....
I guess after 7 years you should take your words back 🔙
He is gadaar, he should be kicked off from pakistan !
This Hakkani seems bit sensible guy but what he missed is that ::
Islam is a terrorist cult started by the first terrorist of the world Mohammad who attacked Makka & Madia & himself killed thousand of innocent people. UN would have declared him a terrorist more dangerous the Osama if UN would have have existed in those days
Mohammad was a product of a Arabic nomadic tribal cult of sword who used a concept called Allah (a PIMP) & used it for luring of hoors to terrorists in lieu of crime shows another aspect of Mohammad that he was a sex addict mentally sick person apart from being terrorist.
He is the perfect Traitor a country can have.
ha ha ha...your sarcasm will not change facts. He is a traitor by all means. Stop getting into politics. He was an ambassador and there are some rules to abide by even though you were fired from that position. Shouldn't be going against the very country you represented. you can go against the people of that country but the land itself. Learn to respect the land you belong to.
Traitor
HH is the best person 👍
HOsain aqni is pakistani trump
US ESTEBLISH NOT SAPORT TRUMP
THE SAME
PAK ESTAB NOT SAPORT TRUMP HAQANI