Not a chance that attack of the clones is worse than any of the sequels at all. Childish jokes can be made sometimes but they done get in the way of things like in the phantom menace, which has some childish stuff front and center. The love story is very good in my opinion. Anakin is completely in character by being confident AND awkward with Padme. He’s confident because he has been told he is extremely important since he met qui gon, and he’s awkward in his dialogue because he lived as a slave and a member of a borderline cult without proper socialization for a child, not to mention, PEOPLE TALK DIFFERENT IN THE STAR WARS UNIVERSE!! The dialogue is intentionally not supposed to remind us of exactly how we talk. It also makes sense that Padme gives the mixed signals that she does, as Anakin’s honesty, confidence, and good looks attract her, but she knows it’s important to follow her duty as a senator. The sequels have more plot holes than what seems like any movie ever and butcher iconic characters while lazily forcing in new ones that have no depth and constantly make decisions that make no sense.
Very good in-depth analysis and rankings. It will interesting to see your analysis of The Rise of Skywalker and where that movie ranks on your Star Wars lists.
Ngl the colosseum scene in SW 2 reminds me of a typical mockbuster movie by The Asylum Btw did you realize that the only difference between the two lists pre top 3 was that the Num 9 on Caleb's list was elevated to Num 7 on the other, but aside from that the same order completely
Not a chance that attack of the clones is worse than any of the sequels at all. Childish jokes can be made sometimes but they done get in the way of things like in the phantom menace, which has some childish stuff front and center. The love story is very good in my opinion. Anakin is completely in character by being confident AND awkward with Padme. He’s confident because he has been told he is extremely important since he met qui gon, and he’s awkward in his dialogue because he lived as a slave and a member of a borderline cult without proper socialization for a child, not to mention, PEOPLE TALK DIFFERENT IN THE STAR WARS UNIVERSE!! The dialogue is intentionally not supposed to remind us of exactly how we talk. It also makes sense that Padme gives the mixed signals that she does, as Anakin’s honesty, confidence, and good looks attract her, but she knows it’s important to follow her duty as a senator. The sequels have more plot holes than what seems like any movie ever and butcher iconic characters while lazily forcing in new ones that have no depth and constantly make decisions that make no sense.
Bro you get it man I couldn’t have said it better. Honestly AOTC is my favourite prequel with ROTS a close second.
Very good in-depth analysis and rankings. It will interesting to see your analysis of The Rise of Skywalker and where that movie ranks on your Star Wars lists.
did they just say that they hope Hayden isn't in 9
Ngl the colosseum scene in SW 2 reminds me of a typical mockbuster movie by The Asylum
Btw did you realize that the only difference between the two lists pre top 3 was that the Num 9 on Caleb's list was elevated to Num 7 on the other, but aside from that the same order completely
10 rogue one 5/10
9 episodio 2 6-/10
8 episodio 7 6/10
7 episodio 9 6+/10
6 episodio 5 7/10
5 episodio 4 8/10
4 episodio 8 8+/10
3 episodio 1 8'5/10
2 episodio 3 9'5/10
1 episodio 6 10/10