In a lot of ways, yes, but there are still a lot of ways they didn't either, like Rosie, she shouldn't actually be alive, in the main books she was never even conceived let alone born. And there is no such thing as Magnussen in the original, there was a Charles Augustus Milverton but not a Magnussen. The list goes on, so they haven't done EXACTLY as Conan Doyle did.
I'm quite oriented when it comes to ACD, so I know about Mary, Agra, CAM, Sholto etc. Of course they do not copy ACD word by word. This comment was specifically targeted to what Mark said about Mary in the video.
@@rainejefferies889 The only thing I want them to keep is Holmes' singleness so that Watson and he can have their adventures without the hassle of a girlfriend or wife. I also do not really like the idea of a baby, but I have a theory about Rosie. The only work of Doyle (that I know, of course) that there is the presence of a child is in the story 'The yellow face'. In the story, there is a black girl named Lucy, whom Holmes' client adopts after discovering that she is the daughter of his wife, the fruit of an earlier marriage. Was it a parallel with Rosie? What made me think of it was when, in a conversation with Mrs. Hudson, shortly after Mary's death, Sherlock tells her landlady that when he became too arrogant with an affair she would tell him the word "Norbury" . In the original Doyle, that phrase is at the end of the "yellow face" tale, and Holmes had told Watson. Does Rosie have to do with this tale in particular? Just a Theory.
I swear, if they kill Mycroft i will grill the writers piles and serve them as jumbo hot dogs to their crew members. let our goldfish lord live please and thank you
Mycroft has to survive!!! He has to. Please Mark, Please Stephen! Some part of me would be dying. And not a small one. Can you really risk me lying on my couch, broken, torn apart. Nobody would find me in days. And then they will start to ask questions. And then Sherlock has to investigate to find my murderers. And he WILL find you. So please. Just don't kill Mycroft in the first plays and it will be better for everyone - Trust me.
I think that he's hinting that they won't follow the books in that case..unfortunately they didn't..I'm literally shaking right now.. I just loved her character so much it's so sad.. I never thought the death of a fictional character would make me feel this way😛
Calvero 221 can't decide if I would like seeing her pulling a 'sherlock'.. on one hand I really love Mary because she is a badass and I love the actress that plays her because I think she's done an amazing job but on the other hand I don't think it would feel right.. it would be kind of unoriginal since Sherlock has already done it.. That being said although its a long shot I do think there is a way that she may have faked her death. The fact the neither Sherlock or Mary noticed that the secretary was carrying a gun is very unusual..so I was thinking that maybe they did noticed and that's why Sherlock wouldn't stop pissing her off. The secretary shoots, Mary takes the bullet and Mary presumably dies. Now that she is 'dead' she is free from her past. Of course that theory falls apart if you watch the rest of the episode (that video wouldn't have been sent to Sherlock for one thing) but that's all I've got.
Okay, but then: sherlock vs. mary gunshot wound okay, i am in no way a gunshot wounds expert, but considering that we have already seen a chest gunshot injury in this show it’s only fair to at least compare them. both sherlock and mary are hit in the same area, so we could expect the same flow of events, right? well, we don’t have it here. sherlock’s wound is tight and barely bleeding and as mp molly says:" It's not like it is in the movies, There's not a great big spurt of blood en you go flying backwards." yet, in mary's case it's exactly what happens. next, when sherlock got shot he had exactly 3 seconds of consciousness led by shock, mary though was able to talk for a whole minute before passing. i am not saying it doesn’t happen, perhaps it does, but considering the previous evidence and conclusions, it is like “in the movies”. also, vivian’s reaction is pretty weird. while she was ready to kill, her goal was sherlock, and when the other person gets in the way she doesn’t look surprised nor shocked. she is calm, she says “surprise” and she is….. smiling?? again, i am not gonna draw any conclusions, i am merely comparing two similar experiences, and i just wanna say that in bbc sherlock absolutely nothing is what it seems ;)
Oh God, please don't kill off Mycroft if there's a season five. Almost every other show has killed off my favourite character and I don't want this to be another one of those shows where it causes tears.
Oh how I would love to sit down with him over a drink and just pick his brain, he would be one of those well read people that would be fun to have a conversation with.
I know. Johnlock is one of the biggest fan theories there is, and yet, not one question about them? Really? I think it's absolutely telling that Mark made sure not to pick a question like that so he wouldn't have to lie about it.
I want Jimcroft. Mycroft scoops up Jim after he fakes his death and realizes caring is an advantage. Hence proving he really is the smart one. Mycroft calls him James when they’re alone and James introduce Irene to Molly ( hell I wrote a fan fiction on AO3 about that. The Introduction by magnetic_field) LOL
this just makes me so happy bc series 4 is the first time I'll actually be watching Sherlock and having to wait and predict everything, it's so fun and annoying at the same time! Love the creators, actors, and the show 💟
+JennyM1998 when sexuality stops being a main plot point. In the real world, I agree with you. However, in the fictional world, a lot of plot points hinge on romance. As a result, sexuality automatically comes into play. All characters are assumed to be straight so the writers have to make it a point to "announce" that a character is gay or bisexual.
Well... he said no to the most things, exept for Mary`s and Mycroft`s death. Given that Mary is indeed dead now, I feel very bad about Mycroft (he is my favourite character)...
I love Mark Gatiss and he's such a brilliant actor and screenwriter. I have now watched Sherlock for the 8th time and it doesn't cease to excite me like a little kid every. single. time. and mind you I get very easily very bored of things, Sherlock is just that good, every single line is genious and exciting. I didn't know he played Mycroft (I hadn't put a name to the face of Mycroft's actor, so although I knew the names of the producers, I had no idea they were the same person), all the more cool when I found out, and his performance is just SO good.
Besides if as an actor Mark had to do a kissing scene with another actor he has had a crush on forever he would blush like a schoolboy and that would be so over the top. There are not enough older love pairings gay or straight in media and it would be so groundbreaking. Blushing is a big turn on to lots of people.
If Sherlock can't remember his other sibling, why would Mycroft tell him, "I'm not given to outbursts of brotherly affection, you know what happened to the other one,"?
well, he is passed the torch to john is already a signal in special episode, I hope we are not gonna go that route, please give sherlock break, he is already went through so much.
Уважаемый мистер Гэтисс, а правда, что Шерлок носил галстук и был похож на айтишника, а потом оставил его у Молли в комнате рядом с лабораторией? И стал носить шарф, чтобы быть больше похожим на Детектива? Или кого-то ещё?
Red beard!!!!! Explain please! When Sherlock gets shot he goes to red beard... ( in his mind palace )but in season 4 he clams not to remember red beard. Why?
No. You left the most interesting one out Mystrade. Such a pairing would be groundbreaking as an older love pairing gay or straight is very rare in the media. You side stepped that subject very well. What gives ?
Mark, please don't kill Mycroft. Please.
I think he enjoys playing him way too much to do that. I hope I won't be proven wrong though.
more Mycroft
Mary Souza PLEASE
"Do you have a mind palace? I have a mind hut." lmao 😂😂😂
I have a mind cardboard box fort in a warehouse.
@@newchannel7523 I have a mind flat
"Doesn't mean we'll do what Doyle did." Well I see.
monikavec and they did exactly as Doyle did
In a lot of ways, yes, but there are still a lot of ways they didn't either, like Rosie, she shouldn't actually be alive, in the main books she was never even conceived let alone born.
And there is no such thing as Magnussen in the original, there was a Charles Augustus Milverton but not a Magnussen.
The list goes on, so they haven't done EXACTLY as Conan Doyle did.
I'm quite oriented when it comes to ACD, so I know about Mary, Agra, CAM, Sholto etc. Of course they do not copy ACD word by word. This comment was specifically targeted to what Mark said about Mary in the video.
mwahahaha (jawnlock)
@@rainejefferies889 The only thing I want them to keep is Holmes' singleness so that Watson and he can have their adventures without the hassle of a girlfriend or wife. I also do not really like the idea of a baby, but I have a theory about Rosie. The only work of Doyle (that I know, of course) that there is the presence of a child is in the story 'The yellow face'. In the story, there is a black girl named Lucy, whom Holmes' client adopts after discovering that she is the daughter of his wife, the fruit of an earlier marriage. Was it a parallel with Rosie? What made me think of it was when, in a conversation with Mrs. Hudson, shortly after Mary's death, Sherlock tells her landlady that when he became too arrogant with an affair she would tell him the word "Norbury" . In the original Doyle, that phrase is at the end of the "yellow face" tale, and Holmes had told Watson. Does Rosie have to do with this tale in particular? Just a Theory.
DONT GIVE MARK IDEAS TO KILL MYCROFT FOR FUCKS SAKE
he is so damn cute, god I love him so much
My crush on Mycroft morphed into a "Good Lord, I'm in love with a fictional character" scenario very quickly.
Darn it how can he be so hot and cute at the same time XD
He could literally stand in front of me and do nothing I'd thank him and pay with my leg and a kidney.
+21 Cascrofts same bro, same. I'm in love with Mycroft.
same! very beautifully said!
I swear, if they kill Mycroft i will grill the writers piles and serve them as jumbo hot dogs to their crew members. let our goldfish lord live please and thank you
Megan Suka If they kill mycroft, you'll kill mycroft?
Mycroft has to survive!!!
He has to. Please Mark, Please Stephen! Some part of me would be dying. And not a small one. Can you really risk me lying on my couch, broken, torn apart. Nobody would find me in days. And then they will start to ask questions. And then Sherlock has to investigate to find my murderers. And he WILL find you. So please. Just don't kill Mycroft in the first plays and it will be better for everyone - Trust me.
Goldfish lord lol
leonie Grosse he did :)
That's so disgusting and I am here for it
It's just so obvious how much Mark is enjoying this. :)
everyone saying Mark's cute and sweet, but man, we all know he's a freaking sex god
Nah Martin is the sex god
But Mark is cute
@@rielletambaoan_ LMAO WHAT-
0:35 he just lies to our faces! when I first watched this I knew something was off
he was just saying that it could happen but the series is not always following the books. Nevertheless i am very shocked about her death too right now
I think that he's hinting that they won't follow the books in that case..unfortunately they didn't..I'm literally shaking right now.. I just loved her character so much it's so sad.. I never thought the death of a fictional character would make me feel this way😛
I am not totally convinced she is dead. Mostly convinced, but not totally. It wouldn't be the first time someone faked their death ;)
Calvero 221 can't decide if I would like seeing her pulling a 'sherlock'.. on one hand I really love Mary because she is a badass and I love the actress that plays her because I think she's done an amazing job but on the other hand I don't think it would feel right.. it would be kind of unoriginal since Sherlock has already done it.. That being said although its a long shot I do think there is a way that she may have faked her death. The fact the neither Sherlock or Mary noticed that the secretary was carrying a gun is very unusual..so I was thinking that maybe they did noticed and that's why Sherlock wouldn't stop pissing her off. The secretary shoots, Mary takes the bullet and Mary presumably dies. Now that she is 'dead' she is free from her past. Of course that theory falls apart if you watch the rest of the episode (that video wouldn't have been sent to Sherlock for one thing) but that's all I've got.
Okay, but then: sherlock vs. mary gunshot wound
okay, i am in no way a gunshot wounds expert, but considering that we have already seen a chest gunshot injury in this show it’s only fair to at least compare them.
both sherlock and mary are hit in the same area, so we could expect the same flow of events, right? well, we don’t have it here. sherlock’s wound is tight and barely bleeding and as mp molly says:" It's not like it is in the movies, There's not a great big spurt of blood en you go flying backwards."
yet, in mary's case it's exactly what happens.
next, when sherlock got shot he had exactly 3 seconds of consciousness led by shock, mary though was able to talk for a whole minute before passing. i am not saying it doesn’t happen, perhaps it does, but considering the previous evidence and conclusions, it is like “in the movies”.
also, vivian’s reaction is pretty weird. while she was ready to kill, her goal was sherlock, and when the other person gets in the way she doesn’t look surprised nor shocked. she is calm, she says “surprise” and she is….. smiling??
again, i am not gonna draw any conclusions, i am merely comparing two similar experiences, and i just wanna say that in bbc sherlock absolutely nothing is what it seems ;)
If Mycroft dies I will cry for days
Marky Downing too
Yeah me too
For years
1:32 I love how he hesitates to answer this xD please don't leave us hangin' man!!
he got some bad ideas for the next season, im sure
Letícia Assef Bad bad ideas
Oh God, please don't kill off Mycroft if there's a season five. Almost every other show has killed off my favourite character and I don't want this to be another one of those shows where it causes tears.
I really like this guy, I want to see him in more things!! Also like the "mind hut".
Thank you!
I'll have to check it out, because he's awesome.
2:43 most british sounding thing i've heard all week
Elise Sweeney You're welcome 😆
Mark is so sweet.
Compassion Mycroft.... outbursts of brotherly compassion!!! :-P
i just love mark gatiss . sweet man
Anyone else just can't stop seeing him as mycroft it's driving me crazy
Even I can’t stop.. I want but cant
His voice is so soothing and brilliant
Oh how I would love to sit down with him over a drink and just pick his brain, he would be one of those well read people that would be fun to have a conversation with.
Goodness, I love him. Protect this man at all costs.
“The next christmas special...” “ooh ambitious” This bastard right here.
Wow i cannot unsee this guy as Mycroft
4 years later... And I'm amazed that the first one Was so accurate
"The next christmas special...*ooh, ambitious*" UM OKAY SORRY FOR YOUR FANDOM HAVING HOPE BAHAHAHAH
IF he lied about mary's death he also lied for john and Sherlock being JUST bestfriend
THEY ARE IN LOVE
JOHNLOCK FOR S4
I know. Johnlock is one of the biggest fan theories there is, and yet, not one question about them? Really? I think it's absolutely telling that Mark made sure not to pick a question like that so he wouldn't have to lie about it.
He didn't lie though
How did he lie? He didn't say anything
Nah Sherlolly happened
@@billybellebooks1853 When did Sherloly happen? Are you referring to that fake 'I love you'?
I want Jimcroft. Mycroft scoops up Jim after he fakes his death and realizes caring is an advantage. Hence proving he really is the smart one.
Mycroft calls him James when they’re alone and James introduce Irene to Molly ( hell I wrote a fan fiction on AO3 about that. The Introduction by magnetic_field) LOL
this just makes me so happy bc series 4 is the first time I'll actually be watching Sherlock and having to wait and predict everything, it's so fun and annoying at the same time! Love the creators, actors, and the show 💟
"We're living in the plot of the man in the high castle" that's some dose of reality thrown at our faces
When he said "Oooh! Ambitious!" after reading "The next Christmas Special..." HAHAHAHA 😂😂😂
I know why Sherlock has Moriarty chained up in his mind. it is to keep him from damaging his mind and sanity.
I can't believe that this is 3 years old
WE NEED SEASON 5 PLEASE
Tons of respect for this guy, he really created something quite special.
NOW ROSAMUND HAS 2 DADS, yassss
July Julzz *she has a heterosexual father and a heterosexual godfather
of course, two heterosexuals...
*bangs head against table*
when. will. people. stop. giving. a. damn. about. sexuality.
Leo585 just wanted to remind everyone is all 😜
+JennyM1998 when sexuality stops being a main plot point. In the real world, I agree with you. However, in the fictional world, a lot of plot points hinge on romance. As a result, sexuality automatically comes into play. All characters are assumed to be straight so the writers have to make it a point to "announce" that a character is gay or bisexual.
This was brilliant! Mark Gatiss is brilliant!
"..because we live in a dystopian future.." D'X true
Well... he said no to the most things, exept for Mary`s and Mycroft`s death. Given that Mary is indeed dead now, I feel very bad about Mycroft (he is my favourite character)...
I love Mark Gatiss and he's such a brilliant actor and screenwriter. I have now watched Sherlock for the 8th time and it doesn't cease to excite me like a little kid every. single. time. and mind you I get very easily very bored of things, Sherlock is just that good, every single line is genious and exciting. I didn't know he played Mycroft (I hadn't put a name to the face of Mycroft's actor, so although I knew the names of the producers, I had no idea they were the same person), all the more cool when I found out, and his performance is just SO good.
I like Mycroft pretty please don't kill him.
@ 2:41 "I've got a mind hut" xD me too, Mark
What exactly does he say in answer to the theory concerning Moriarty in S's mindpalace?
In other words, whoever asked that question totally ships it.
MARY DIED.
Nikky Mansnoozie spoiler (I already know tho)
I just LOVE this show...I hope more will be shown in the future. PLEASE
Some sort of game is starting
William It's not a game anymore!
The game is now
Hey, look it's me!
Mycroft Holmes Hey I've seen you on another video! and I'm subbed
Fucking Gatiss is awwsome
1:41 thank god that I watched this after season 4 😂
Eu gosto muito do Mark: inteligente, engraçado... Meus parabéns por tudo
I love that the second question references that kids show Sherlock Holmes in the 22nd Century
the best theories were left behind, wonder why that could be... ;)
Honestly what certain fan writers have done with Sebastian Moran is more interesting a character than anything on the show so far.
dad please
I like Mark's accent goes from rather posh BBC voice and then back up north to Durham
I love him so much omg
Mark is so cute XD I love him
am I the only one that thinks Mycroft is actually the secret villian in Sherlock? Huge Plot Twist?
Nope. I mean, yes there are shit loads of scenes where Mike cared a lot and showed concern to Sher and John but I agree with you all the way
@@rielletambaoan_ so you think the same?
@@tickedoffnow yep
I love the face swap
I googled the face swap thing.....I am disturbed 😂
I love mark
Mi Piace vedere Mark Gatiss, è lo sfondo di Londra, con la sua serie o stagione Sherlock Holmes.
keep the conversation going. At least theres hope.
tfw fan theories are more making sense than your season finale
Besides if as an actor Mark had to do a kissing scene with another actor he has had a crush on forever he would blush like a schoolboy and that would be so over the top. There are not enough older love pairings gay or straight in media and it would be so groundbreaking.
Blushing is a big turn on to lots of people.
he is so talented
I hope Mycroft doesn't die.
oh yeaaaaah, I love Mark! :D
If Sherlock can't remember his other sibling, why would Mycroft tell him, "I'm not given to outbursts of brotherly affection, you know what happened to the other one,"?
Mycroft never told this to Sherlock. When Mycroft says this, Sherlock is not even there.
@@hettyherz he said it on his last wow, to lady Smallwood, not sherlock
WHY DIDNT THEY MENTION JOHNLOCK
AGRA Description of the place includes the truth, the wife dies in childbirth or around that time
Well if he were to even read one quarter of all the theories and headcanons this fandom has come up with he'd sit there for ages-
well, he is passed the torch to john is already a signal in special episode, I hope we are not gonna go that route, please give sherlock break, he is already went through so much.
마이크로프트 ㅠㅠ 죽지 마요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
mind hut.....hahhahahaha
OMG I LOVE THIS!!!!!!!!!!!
This man is awesome!!!!
Nooooo we needed Sebastian Moran 🥺
oh, so it IS "Gaitiss"!!
Anna Baumann Gay Tiss ^-^
Уважаемый мистер Гэтисс, а правда, что Шерлок носил галстук и был похож на айтишника, а потом оставил его у Молли в комнате рядом с лабораторией? И стал носить шарф, чтобы быть больше похожим на Детектива? Или кого-то ещё?
I’m desperately in love with you :))
It’s brotherly compassion, not affection...
UH! ambitious!
Huh, I've been mispronouncing his name for a while.
_I've got a mind hut._
ALL HAIL THE MIND HUT
i love mycroft.
wait so Mycroft is the co-creater
MinorAccident yeah
Red beard!!!!! Explain please! When Sherlock gets shot he goes to red beard... ( in his mind palace )but in season 4 he clams not to remember red beard. Why?
He never claims he doesn't remember redbeard the dog. He doesn't remember that redbeard was actually a human being.
TheLightPurple thank you
its a sister.
MIND HUT
Good writer more than moff 😐
1:00 Didn't read the book or horribly dumb? The latter seems unlikely given his body of work, so..
if he answered the mucroft one there wouldve been 0 suspense
No. You left the most interesting one out Mystrade. Such a pairing would be groundbreaking as an older love pairing gay or straight is very rare in the media.
You side stepped that subject very well. What gives ?
There was nothing about Johnlock.. disappointment 😆
I loved Sherlock until you took liberties with logic and plausibility too far in the final episode. I'll never watch a 5th series.