This video is different. Mostly others make you feel sad and depressed. Not this one. This one makes you feel anger. Frustration. Grief. And sadness. All the emotions Arthur felt as he neared his demise. This is the true masterpiece and you should be extremely proud of yourself
i will never forget this game. i wish i could erase my memory and play it like the first time again. no other game has made me so emotional, rockstar you did a great job with this beautiful game.
I’m in the epilogue now, I was late to getting this game lol This is the most beautiful game I’ve ever played. Amazing story. The end was truly heartbreaking
@@clinte2864 epilogue? Lol you have a Looooong way to go, I would recommend you don't rush it though and instead try to enjoy every moment, this game is a masterpiece.
@@clinte2864 I'd wouldn't replay too many times though lol, it gets to the point that you know the cutscenes and then it's nowhere near as good as the first time.
@@illfindyou115 true the game makes you interested but I starting disliking him mainly in chapter 2 At the horseshoe overlook I think it was called well I haven't played Ina while but the first camp well basically second near valentine town but then he just got worse and even killed Arthur
I have a. Comment with thousands of likes about how this game made me cry. I have never self Identified my self with any gaming character other than Arthur. This game was a cinematic masterpiece
He's a real soldier, he never gave up even if he knew that some point he was gonna die of Tuberculosis, he kept on fighting until the end and he died fighting. He really deserves those flowers on his grave. I would really put some on his grave if I could.
Quitting, giving up-it aint no way to Live. I have a sort-of Britherhood with Arthur in more ways than one-Diabetes as a child, Losing my vision in my 20's [[not completely Blind-I could drive till maybe five yearts ago, even ride a Motorcycle, but there were limitations when I could drive]] I'm 55. Stroke and Renal Failure in my 30's and a Kidney/Pancreas Transplant that's lasted several years beyond it's Expiration Date. As Arthur said-we're just Ghosts. Never give up.
I don't think I'll ever let this game go, every part of it will be etched in my memory for eternity. Thank you Rockstar for making one of my worst years a whole lot better when you released this beautiful game! And thank you Sezo and all other tribute makers for these videos!
@@daltoncampbell8401 Emotional Games like RDR 1&2 and the TLOUS (The Last Of Us) series don't come around too often! You feel really impacted after playing games like these.
Remember boys *"revenge is an idiot's game"* *"redemption is one of em..."* *"we're more ghosts than people"* *"be loyal to what matters"* *"I insist."* *"we ain't both gonna make it"* *"John made it...."*
One thing Arthur Morgan taught me was that, no matter how long you stay by someone’s side, do everything for them, stick by them through tough times, they will always choose someone new....
“I’m not seeking forgiveness, I don’t want your forgiveness, just let me atone for what I have done” Arthur Morgan Not really what he said to the downes family but close enough
What makes this video game so damn amazing is the anger it makes you feel, and the reflection that comes after. Arthur was a bad man, he got his karma beating that guy to death and getting TB. He deserved it. As the game goes on he starts to change and you're along for the journey, making those choices with him. You start to get angry, thinking how unfair it is that Arthur Morgan, such a good man, has to die of an illness. Then after the nun scene it makes you start reflecting on how his evolution has progressed. At the time Arthur deserved it. Karma. An eye for an eye. It's completely fair. TB killed him in the end, but also saved him at the same time. He became a good man. "You can't change what's already done, you can only move on."
Dude I’m disappointed how much this video has been viewed and liked it’s a MASTERPIECE! It’s captures Arthur’s Character Development in the best ways to the meaning of life and death through time not many of us get to have
Arthur is a legend I hate the fact that he died like that, they should keep him alive and just went missing in rdr1 so they could bring him back in rdr3 whenever it comes
@@samuelbm4843 doesn't John die tho in rdr1. also I don't see there being a rdr3 cuz rdr1 takes place in 1911 and in that time that's when the western cowboy ages are dying so there wouldn't be a time line for it
Even being an outlaw,He is the only one I would dream to become one day..All of his ideals,loyalty and kindness is everything a man can dream to possess one day.Like a father to us,he really set an idea.. And he also says "those folks,i know we've ruined your life and I suffer for it everyday." Broke my heart💔
Arthur wasn’t just some normal man, He was a outlaw he was a friend he was a man who’d die for his gang he fought and lived his life like a legend and shall be remembered
That’s why I enjoyed that the later game choices gave you a ton of honor, so you can play the game as a true outlaw doing terrible things but the way the story and characters were written perfectly the game gave you the chance to get the honorable ending
Finished the game as Arthur last night and have been watching tribute videos throughout the day, this is the best one, fantastic! RIP Arthur Morgan, the best video game character of ALL TIME!
These videos always make me think, Arthur says he’s not a good person but even good people do bad things and even all the things he has done, he IS the best protagonist to ever live.
I have had this game for a while. Every time I replay and get to the end, I am left speechless. Arthur's death has been the death that I can never have anything to say during. Out of all the deaths I personally experienced in games, Authur's has been the hardest to get past. I almost cry during it every time. I have replayed this game almost 5 times fully completing the story. I will always love Arthur as a character.
0:13 has been my xbox background since 2018. The absolute greatest game I have ever played. Arthur morgan didn't feel like another game character. He was so alive, he felt so real and he taught us so much. rockstar murdered rdr2 bc I honestly wasn't expecting much, and well... I got this, im here tearing up thinking back to my first playthrough. I have never cared for a game more in my life. Out of hundreds and hundreds of games that I've played. This has been at the #1 perch since 2018. Nothing I've played has even come close to this. I thank rockstar games for developing this masterpiece of art.
My God, this was masterfully put together! And I think the more I play this game, the more I understand why GTA VI is taking this long. For one, the longer it takes to make, the better. And for another, Red Dead Redemption 2 is such a masterpiece, we’re still trying to wrap our minds around what we’ve been playing this last 2 1/2 years. Rockstar be like “Gratitude instead of attitude for making y’all wait. We been giving y’all time to get the last one straight.”
Wow arthur really is a legend and when i reached the saddest scene i felt so sad but i was still proud and happy bc i could start a new game and be arthur and start the story all over again and arthur REALLY isn't only a criminal he's good and bad no matter his personality is. He had to do what ducted slayed and the whole gang really wanted money to get out even arthur but he didn't want that to happen he just had to listen to dutch and thanks rockstar games to create such a beautiful game and R.I.P arthur at the end. thanks to all your great memories and you where being mostly good arthur :).
Arthur was a bad man “WAS” he was the most honest gang member out of all he taught us all a lesson “you’ll have a good life if you make the right choices and give all you have -Arthur Morgan
it's the amazing fact that u don't realize it but rockstar made a character that makes us go through the stages of grief for a week after i first played and every time i play i go through the stages it's amazing how a video game can represent this
It's insane to see how Arthur's fate was exactly like the man he killed so heartlessly. Wish Micah got the same fate of pain and torment to death or even worse, feels like he just got an easy death
Best Arthur tribute I’ve ever seen on RUclips props to you for making this honestly took me through 4 years of multiple play through a in 5 minutes… amazing ❤️
Arthur as a protagonist shows that no one can be perfect and doing the right thing isn’t easy but when you do the wrong thing you get the chance of redemption and the chance to change your past mistakes
I found myself being able to relate to both Arthur and John. Losing Family and living the only life you know. As as a Veteran, we all wrestle with the Giant inside. We lose everything. Ourselves. Our loved ones. But we remain what we are. Warrior class. Soldiers. Cowboys from Hell. We’re difficult to live with. We are hard to handle. But we are good people inside. We live our lives according to our own code and ethos. Many do not understand. And they don’t need to. But they sleep well knowing that we exist. Till we don’t.
I remember before rd2 came out and I was angry it wasn't John cause i loved the first one so much but after playing through and getting to know Arthur and be apart of his life and struggles, it changed me. He has taught me so much and he really did his best to be a better man in the end. This game will forever be in my heart and so will Arthur. Awesome work on this, beautiful song choice and amazing editing
The thing I love about Arthur Morgan is that he doesn't make it obvious he is badass. Also how he show's his weaknesses, his loyalty and his beliefs. I can't express how much his death affected me. Yeah, he's just some character from a game but god damn did the do a good job and making him feel real
Arthur was a soldier loyal to his friends and in the end he did everything he could to make sure the ones he loved could try to make their lives better. And made sure the ones that could hurt his loved ones were taken care of.
2:35 This part is so great in my opinion. This shows how the roles changed in the end. Instead of beating a sick man, Arthur is the one who is sick. But the way you ilustrate this in this tribute is amazing. Thank you for that video, you did a great job
Same. He made me learn,that it's never too late to do what is right. Do what is right. Realize that people can be controlling. Arthur is a good man. Like you guys can be.
Arthur taught me that no matter what you do, you can always do the right thing in the end.
But even if You choose Redemption... Your actions will have consecuences.
Revenge is a fools game.
Indeed great advice guys
@@HarambetheWhite that’s what lead to Johns death😔
fr
This video is different. Mostly others make you feel sad and depressed. Not this one. This one makes you feel anger. Frustration. Grief. And sadness. All the emotions Arthur felt as he neared his demise. This is the true masterpiece and you should be extremely proud of yourself
Thank you! ❤️
Damn you Micah!!!!!!!!
@@xenon5656 damn you rat micah bell
Couldnt have Said it better!
@@sezo758 you should be proud, what a video you made. Really is impressive and makes me realize how beautiful this game and story truly is.
If I ever find a grave with the name Arthur Morgan I bring him flowers everyday
Same Arthur is most loved game character ever
@@phantom-so9fj course I am, you can even ask your damn Machine "goodle"
Yep, same here
@@Unblasphemy Arthur I love you❤️
Their is a grave we're rains falls and eagle flies camp is you go up Hill also Charles baried him and grimshaw
He’ll go down in history as the best protagonist of all time
Facts
@GGMAN that's if they ever make RDR3
@GGMAN and if they make a rdr3 they should just make a story mode and no online mode for it and an rdr1 remaster would be cool
@GGMAN don't worry boy, watchin from heaven, progress is comin your way. Great prediction kid! It'll take couple years
I am already boah, ask your Google yourself
"You can't change what's already done... You can only move on"
-Arthur Morgan
i will never forget this game. i wish i could erase my memory and play it like the first time again. no other game has made me so emotional, rockstar you did a great job with this beautiful game.
I’m in the epilogue now, I was late to getting this game lol
This is the most beautiful game I’ve ever played. Amazing story. The end was truly heartbreaking
@@clinte2864 epilogue? Lol you have a Looooong way to go, I would recommend you don't rush it though and instead try to enjoy every moment, this game is a masterpiece.
@@JTedits I finished the epilogue yesterday! Blown away. Now to explore and hunt
I’m gonna restart the whole game again. Too good to put away
@@clinte2864 I'd wouldn't replay too many times though lol, it gets to the point that you know the cutscenes and then it's nowhere near as good as the first time.
@@JTedits oh I’m sure, it’s the feeling I missed a lot of details in the heat of the moment my first time through
The single greatest protagonist in gaming history
And the game containes the worst antagonist. micha
@@aishamareecaseybrignell4472 ye he's a twat but still an interesting/engaging character
@@illfindyou115 true the game makes you interested but I starting disliking him mainly in chapter 2 At the horseshoe overlook I think it was called well I haven't played Ina while but the first camp well basically second near valentine town but then he just got worse and even killed Arthur
@@aishamareecaseybrignell4472Micah is the best antagonist
I have a. Comment with thousands of likes about how this game made me cry. I have never self Identified my self with any gaming character other than Arthur. This game was a cinematic masterpiece
He's a real soldier, he never gave up even if he knew that some point he was gonna die of Tuberculosis, he kept on fighting until the end and he died fighting. He really deserves those flowers on his grave. I would really put some on his grave if I could.
Quitting, giving up-it aint no way to Live. I have a sort-of Britherhood with Arthur in more ways than one-Diabetes as a child, Losing my vision in my 20's [[not completely Blind-I could drive till maybe five yearts ago, even ride a Motorcycle, but there were limitations when I could drive]] I'm 55. Stroke and Renal Failure in my 30's and a Kidney/Pancreas Transplant that's lasted several years beyond it's Expiration Date. As Arthur said-we're just Ghosts. Never give up.
@@mindofmadness5593 God Bless you
You are a soldier
Man, if there was a mock grave somewhere I would absolutely roadtrip and lay some flowers there.
I don't think I'll ever let this game go, every part of it will be etched in my memory for eternity. Thank you Rockstar for making one of my worst years a whole lot better when you released this beautiful game! And thank you Sezo and all other tribute makers for these videos!
I know right... this game will be something I tell my grandkids about
@@daltoncampbell8401 Emotional Games like RDR 1&2 and the TLOUS (The Last Of Us) series don't come around too often! You feel really impacted after playing games like these.
It’s the only game I’ve never uninstalled on the PS and prob never will lol
Remember boys
*"revenge is an idiot's game"*
*"redemption is one of em..."*
*"we're more ghosts than people"*
*"be loyal to what matters"*
*"I insist."*
*"we ain't both gonna make it"*
*"John made it...."*
OUTLAWS, NOT IDIOTS!
Who said the second one ?
@@artorius4809 arthur said revenge is a fools game
"I gave you all I had"
"When the time comes, run and don't look back"
One thing Arthur Morgan taught me was that, no matter how long you stay by someone’s side, do everything for them, stick by them through tough times, they will always choose someone new....
“I’m not seeking forgiveness, I don’t want your forgiveness, just let me atone for what I have done” Arthur Morgan
Not really what he said to the downes family but close enough
2:25 best part of the edit
I love that part
How?
What makes this video game so damn amazing is the anger it makes you feel, and the reflection that comes after. Arthur was a bad man, he got his karma beating that guy to death and getting TB. He deserved it. As the game goes on he starts to change and you're along for the journey, making those choices with him. You start to get angry, thinking how unfair it is that Arthur Morgan, such a good man, has to die of an illness. Then after the nun scene it makes you start reflecting on how his evolution has progressed. At the time Arthur deserved it. Karma. An eye for an eye. It's completely fair. TB killed him in the end, but also saved him at the same time. He became a good man. "You can't change what's already done, you can only move on."
Dude I’m disappointed how much this video has been viewed and liked it’s a MASTERPIECE! It’s captures Arthur’s Character Development in the best ways to the meaning of life and death through time not many of us get to have
The end makes me sad seeing Arthur with the sun shining on him
Arthur is a legend I hate the fact that he died like that, they should keep him alive and just went missing in rdr1 so they could bring him back in rdr3 whenever it comes
Right jhon get captured and aruther the bad@$$ comes in a saves him
Hopefully rdr3 will be will be leading up to the blackwater incident and you will be able to play as him once again
the law didnt get him, enemy gangs didnt get him, bounty hunters didnt get him, he is a true badass
@@samuelbm4843 doesn't John die tho in rdr1. also I don't see there being a rdr3 cuz rdr1 takes place in 1911 and in that time that's when the western cowboy ages are dying so there wouldn't be a time line for it
@@cadenward9309 b4 rdr2
This is one of the best tributes out there, it deserves more views!
“Run, Run and don’t look back.”
“Your my brother!”
“I know, I know.”
😢😢😢
All them god damn years...
-Arthur Morgan
Even being an outlaw,He is the only one I would dream to become one day..All of his ideals,loyalty and kindness is everything a man can dream to possess one day.Like a father to us,he really set an idea..
And he also says "those folks,i know we've ruined your life and I suffer for it everyday."
Broke my heart💔
Arthur wasn’t just some normal man, He was a outlaw he was a friend he was a man who’d die for his gang he fought and lived his life like a legend and shall be remembered
Did anyone else have there perspective on the world change after playing this....like anyone can change
No just me...
You know, I’m pretty sure Arthur taught me one thing: Everyone can be redeemed, no matter how messed up, sick, or twisted they are.
Even with low honor he was still the most honorable person in the game
That’s why I enjoyed that the later game choices gave you a ton of honor, so you can play the game as a true outlaw doing terrible things but the way the story and characters were written perfectly the game gave you the chance to get the honorable ending
@@Godfather9814 thats a pretty nice idea, this game is like 3 tarentinomovies combined to an epic westernlore
Lies again? Marine Soldier
You just make me look like such a badass.
"Yur alraht boah"
Dude when you died it made me cry
I found your grave
You're not Arthur Morgan though so stop
@@warriorchiefmussolini706 awwww a sensitive boi ☺
Pretty boah? U kidding me, prETty boAh?
me, trying to watch a sad video:
Arthurs hat: I am a three musketeer
Finished the game as Arthur last night and have been watching tribute videos throughout the day, this is the best one, fantastic! RIP Arthur Morgan, the best video game character of ALL TIME!
"It's just a game"
Me: I would like to present how you are dead wrong.
I'll never ever forget Arthur Morgan.....what a game. What a awesome character he was.
Arthur taught me that even if something bad happens always be strong and power on.
These videos always make me think, Arthur says he’s not a good person but even good people do bad things and even all the things he has done, he IS the best protagonist to ever live.
3:10 to 3:21
the best scene ive ever seen.
GOOD JOB. the end of the video make me sad wow congratulation you made me cry boah.
OUTTA THE DAMN WAY
Actually, no the best part is from 0:00 to 3:56
@@kingtavish cool.
Arthur learned me One thing friends and family over everything
Never thought I'd ball my eyes out for a game, Arthur taught me well.
3:47 Arthur's eyes in this last shot get me everytime... bravo, Sezo! You're incredibly underrated!
I’ve played this game 50 times over and I still cry every time when it’s Arthur’s time to go 🥺
Finaly someone who played the game in style and doesnt look like the wolveman with some clothes made out of squirells
This is what the end credits should've been. This tribute right here.
Arthur Morgan feels like a real person
If we were normal people in 1899 we would think Arthur was always a terrible person
I cried and got happy at the same time and watching this after completing the game hit even harder.
"You don't get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you."
- Arthur
I have had this game for a while. Every time I replay and get to the end, I am left speechless. Arthur's death has been the death that I can never have anything to say during. Out of all the deaths I personally experienced in games, Authur's has been the hardest to get past. I almost cry during it every time. I have replayed this game almost 5 times fully completing the story. I will always love Arthur as a character.
Arthur Morgan is such a beautiful complex character and you showed his journey in the game amazingly. Its one of the best edits I've seen so far
Brought me to tears. Well done this is an amazing edit! I'll never forget about Arthur, best protagonist ever written
0:13 has been my xbox background since 2018. The absolute greatest game I have ever played. Arthur morgan didn't feel like another game character. He was so alive, he felt so real and he taught us so much. rockstar murdered rdr2 bc I honestly wasn't expecting much, and well... I got this, im here tearing up thinking back to my first playthrough. I have never cared for a game more in my life. Out of hundreds and hundreds of games that I've played. This has been at the #1 perch since 2018. Nothing I've played has even come close to this. I thank rockstar games for developing this masterpiece of art.
this has to be one of if not THE saddest video game deaths
Fantastic tribute to best damn character in any media. Arthur my BOAH you were the best.
Idk anyone else that hasn’t at least shed a tear when Arthur died in the end
Arthur Morgan, who found Redemption through blood and death, at first others then his own.
*Red Dead Redemption*
Cheers to the best game protagonist the world has ever seen to this date. May it remain that way.
"Run, and don't look back..."
My God, this was masterfully put together! And I think the more I play this game, the more I understand why GTA VI is taking this long. For one, the longer it takes to make, the better. And for another, Red Dead Redemption 2 is such a masterpiece, we’re still trying to wrap our minds around what we’ve been playing this last 2 1/2 years.
Rockstar be like “Gratitude instead of attitude for making y’all wait. We been giving y’all time to get the last one straight.”
Author Morgan the greatest man in rdr II
Wow arthur really is a legend and when i reached the saddest scene i felt so sad but i was still proud and happy bc i could start a new game and be arthur and start the story all over again and arthur REALLY isn't only a criminal he's good and bad no matter his personality is. He had to do what ducted slayed and the whole gang really wanted money to get out even arthur but he didn't want that to happen he just had to listen to dutch and thanks rockstar games to create such a beautiful game and R.I.P arthur at the end. thanks to all your great memories and you where being mostly good arthur :).
dutch* sayed*
Arthur was a bad man “WAS” he was the most honest gang member out of all he taught us all a lesson “you’ll have a good life if you make the right choices and give all you have -Arthur Morgan
it's the amazing fact that u don't realize it but rockstar made a character that makes us go through the stages of grief for a week after i first played and every time i play i go through the stages it's amazing how a video game can represent this
It's insane to see how Arthur's fate was exactly like the man he killed so heartlessly. Wish Micah got the same fate of pain and torment to death or even worse, feels like he just got an easy death
Best Arthur tribute I’ve ever seen on RUclips props to you for making this honestly took me through 4 years of multiple play through a in 5 minutes… amazing ❤️
Still to this day, Red dead redemption two is still the best game in my opinion!
Arthur as a protagonist shows that no one can be perfect and doing the right thing isn’t easy but when you do the wrong thing you get the chance of redemption and the chance to change your past mistakes
Looking through this comment section makes me realize I’m not the only godamn cowboy left
Arthur never wanted the outlaw life but there was no leaving it and he redeemed himself in the end although everything he’s gone through
I can't see my Arthur without his legendary bear hat or massive beard
I've seen a bunch of Arthur Morgan motivational videos. But out of all, this is the best.
my third round playing I can't get enough of this master piece
We're thieves in a world that don't want us no more I miss you Arthur Morgan
I found myself being able to relate to both Arthur and John.
Losing Family and living the only life you know.
As as a Veteran, we all wrestle with the Giant inside.
We lose everything. Ourselves. Our loved ones.
But we remain what we are. Warrior class.
Soldiers. Cowboys from Hell.
We’re difficult to live with.
We are hard to handle.
But we are good people inside.
We live our lives according to our own code and ethos.
Many do not understand.
And they don’t need to.
But they sleep well knowing that we exist.
Till we don’t.
Very good video man! Give me chills...
Thanks! The whole story gave me chills and I loved it. ^^
This is a masterpiece you deserve 100 million subs for the editing
Rockstar told an amazing story here.
Arthur's death broke my heart.
This should have been the trailer for the game. I love this game its not just a game its a true work of art
I'm about to finish this game for the third time. this is the best game I've ever played easily
My favorite game his death changed my way of seeing people
The single best edit for Arthur Morgan that I've ever seen on youtube and I've seen quite a bit of 'em. Good job.
I love you, Arthur, although you were a character from the game world, but you taught me a lot of lessons😞🥀🖤
I dont think I'll ever find a character that had such a big effect on me the way arthur the best protaganest in gaming history
Arthur taught us much. You can always do the right thing and more.
THIS THIS RIGHT HERE this deserves more recognition brother
This is so sad and heartbreaking 😪😔😪
Not just that though it makes you annoyed and really angry about all of it. RIP Arthur Morgan ❤
Arthur taught me to keep fighting no matter what stands in your way
I remember before rd2 came out and I was angry it wasn't John cause i loved the first one so much but after playing through and getting to know Arthur and be apart of his life and struggles, it changed me. He has taught me so much and he really did his best to be a better man in the end. This game will forever be in my heart and so will Arthur. Awesome work on this, beautiful song choice and amazing editing
subbed! btw R.I.P Arthur Morgan
DUDE I PRETTY SURE THAT GAVE ME THE CHILLS! THIS WAS SO GOOD!
He's the best man I ever met and he never even existed.:(
This is SOO good and I can’t stop watching it and crying 😭 I absolutely love Arthur Morgan
The thing I love about Arthur Morgan is that he doesn't make it obvious he is badass. Also how he show's his weaknesses, his loyalty and his beliefs. I can't express how much his death affected me. Yeah, he's just some character from a game but god damn did the do a good job and making him feel real
and he's not only a legend, he's a god because he was mostly good :).
Arthur was a soldier loyal to his friends and in the end he did everything he could to make sure the ones he loved could try to make their lives better. And made sure the ones that could hurt his loved ones were taken care of.
Arthur is the best video game character ever
If “ you either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain” it would be Arthur
I guess? But it would be more of the polar opposite
I wanna cry now because how good this video is
Respect to the hero
I watched every edit of red dead redemption 2. I played the game 4 times. But now i can't love it anymore and it's breaking me
Arthur is the best game protagonist in gaming history and deserves yo go down in the gaming hall of fame
Hands down the best game ever this is why I love the western time
This is one of the best tribute for Arthur I ever 👍
I just want to say this is incredible thank you 🌹🌹🌹❤❤❤
You're welcome. Thank you for watching! :)
arthur deserved so much better. he was such a good soul.
2:35 This part is so great in my opinion. This shows how the roles changed in the end. Instead of beating a sick man, Arthur is the one who is sick. But the way you ilustrate this in this tribute is amazing. Thank you for that video, you did a great job
That is the best part
Same. He made me learn,that it's never too late to do what is right. Do what is right. Realize that people can be controlling. Arthur is a good man. Like you guys can be.