Both Dune movies are worthless trash, the plot never advances, the acting ranges from okay to Adam Sandler in Grown Ups, all characters are cartoonishly one dimensional, not a single song is memorable, there are two tones in this movie: Washed off sand and black and white and the final battle is rushed into 30 seconds at the end. I LOVE slow burn movies that take their time, the problem with Dune is that NOTHING happens. In between Dune 1 & 2 there has been almost 6 hours of film and Chani ends with the dialogue “you know this is just the beginning, right?” AFTER 6 HOURS THIS IS JUST BEGINNING????? This movie is trash and I perfectly understand why Dune will be forgotten in sci-fi. And yes, I know Dune inspired Star Wars, but there is a reason Star Wars will never be forgotten anytime soon and Dune will disappear 2 years after the third movie
This guy is the epitome of a dude who only likes Action. I bet ya, he loves all the Fast and Furious movies. He can't say otherwise, because all his reasons for 'cutting down to two hours' is simply; theres not enough action. Your opinion is noted, but rename the title to: I think Part Two of Dune is Beautiful and Boring.
Buddy, if you think your comment was anything other than one dimensionality and narrow mindedness personified, the very best of luck to you. But my reply stands. Just because everyone is fellating this movie, doesn't mean those that aren't are somehow stunted or stupid. Thinking that way sure leads to it, though.
Dune from 1984 by Lynch has a lot of effects that hold up and are more amusing than the new films. The 4k versions they sell currently look very good, they have re-released it in cinemas too.
lol no the movie could not have been cut down to two hours. you guys forget that this is a book and and the fact that this material even came out this coherent was a monumental achievement. most of the scenes exist to make sure that the themes are clear cut as well as the romance that makes the basis of the story. while i can see why someone might find this boring especially the first half but to say an entire hour could have been cut is insanity. respect your opinion though.
Dune 1984, and its extended editions are far better than the remakes. Dune 1984 has multiple tv versions, streaming versions too so its interesting to see what each one included. In some countries they are selling official releases of fan edits too. Probably due to them re-adding back bonus scenes. The extended edition explains more but the Theatrical edition is the best one, its great as is and easy enough to follow. Some of the new physical media versions they sell currently include bonus scenes. They have an Ultimate Edition selling but its pricey.
@@Solid_Gravy visual accuracy and general accuracy are too different things, bud. David Lynch's film is generally more accurate. Denis' is (sometimes) visually accurate
@@Solid_Gravy oh, and I wouldn't disparage Lynch's Dune if I were you. Without it, DV would've had only the miniseries to plagiarise (look at the art design, costumes and actor blocking, for example, tell me I'm wrong)
Plagerise, buddy its an adaptation, its going to pull from what came from before. And I want to say I don't think Lynch's Dune is bad by any means, in fact I like it a ton for the Lynch things in it, heart plugs, Baron's middle school acne and even the fucking pugs. But what DV really has which unfortunately Lynch didn't isn't just budget and good vfx, it's character accuracy. Paul is Paul to a T in Denis version and that matters more than mise en scene in my books.@@humbleopulence
You are better off with Fast and the Furious part 647 or maybe Transformers part 47... Dune 1 and 2 are for people that have an attention span that is longer than 20 seconds tiktok clips
If you thought the movie was boring you you must have an attention problem. At the end of the movie I wanted more and I’m eager to see what happens next. It was so good I’m going to start reading the books
Dune remake 1 and 2 are boring, woke Hollywood checklist trash. Very safe, very boring, poor telling of the story, miscast in every way. The action is boring, the sets, designs everything. Lynch's Dune from 1984 became a classic because it was inspired and entertaining. The only reason theses remakes occurred was due to the Dune 1984 becoming a hit with younger generations. It surpassed the books too.
It's his right to state his opinion. I'd rather people state their honest thoughts than just parroting everything on the internet just to appease people. And as a disclaimer, I loved the movie.
To be honest even with the people who found the first one boring I could tell that they just had a short attention span and aren’t satisfied unless there are explosions every 5 seconds. Haven’t seen this one yet but most reviews I’ve seen say there is a good amount of action compared to the first one so… maybe grow a longer attention span?
The 1984 film covers only the first book, not the "whole Dune story". Seriously, people in this video talking out of their asses with no clue about the subject.
I loved the movie even though it had flaws. Your take on it is just incredibly stupid. Here is what you could of legitimately talked about: 1: The way the worm riding was depicted was very inconsistent. When shown with entire families and supplies on a worm. How did they get on, how do they get off? The movie did a terrible job to make that believable. 2: The Emperor's soldiers in the books are supposed to be an elite army. In the movie they are just standing there with swords like idiots and get easily crushed. That was poorly shown. 3. How Paul was brought back from the dead after drinking the worm blood was incredibly eye rolling and felt too Disney. That pulled me from the emersion of the movie.
The worst review I've ever seen. IMO. You're entitled to an opinion, but if you're going to review a film at least try to make it relevant and accurate. This was appalling.
Seems like an unpopular opinion, but I agree. Second film seemed to drag even though there was a lot happening. I nearly fell asleep at one point, and considered leaving early - I’ve read the books so already know the rough story. The CGI is gorgeous and the movie is visibly striking. But the problem is that the entire thing seems to be shot like a trailer. It’s way too consistently “cinematic,” and if everything is that way, it just leads to fatigue. Cool movie, idk if it’s for me.
@@andyquelch5754 I am honestly asking, because I am trying to understand, how will you watch this movie in the future? Will you sit down and watch all 5 hours at once to see the full story? Or just jump back and forth between the the first and second movie to see just the parts you like? Do people just watch at home with their phones out and look up at the good parts. I am just trying to understand modern viewing habits. Maybe I need to change the way I watch things.
@@todddonaldson7974 I'm happy to watch them together or independently. Just as I have the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Dune is to big to be trapped within the confines of one movie. It would becomes disjointed and illogical. I think they got this just about right. I really don't understand what the issue is?🤔
@@andyquelch5754 overall, I just don't like splitting up movies just for a cash grab like the Hobbit. The Feyd scene in the fighting arena was awesome to look at, but did it really establish Feyd as a good fighter? He took out a few drugged men, and a starved looking man. (I know he is the fight coordinator IRL and a bad ass in real life, but he did not look that way in the movie) Is that really enough to justify a fight with someone trained in the wierding way, a mentat, and a kwisatz haderach who can see the future. So they added other Bene G scenes to pump him up.
i think you're the one thats boring my friend.
Yeah. dune 2 is the best documentary ever made. Period.
Documentaries will never be the same.
Both Dune movies are worthless trash, the plot never advances, the acting ranges from okay to Adam Sandler in Grown Ups, all characters are cartoonishly one dimensional, not a single song is memorable, there are two tones in this movie: Washed off sand and black and white and the final battle is rushed into 30 seconds at the end.
I LOVE slow burn movies that take their time, the problem with Dune is that NOTHING happens. In between Dune 1 & 2 there has been almost 6 hours of film and Chani ends with the dialogue “you know this is just the beginning, right?” AFTER 6 HOURS THIS IS JUST BEGINNING?????
This movie is trash and I perfectly understand why Dune will be forgotten in sci-fi.
And yes, I know Dune inspired Star Wars, but there is a reason Star Wars will never be forgotten anytime soon and Dune will disappear 2 years after the third movie
i'm sorry that you have a tiktok brain
This guy is the epitome of a dude who only likes Action. I bet ya, he loves all the Fast and Furious movies.
He can't say otherwise, because all his reasons for 'cutting down to two hours' is simply; theres not enough action. Your opinion is noted, but rename the title to: I think Part Two of Dune is Beautiful and Boring.
With all due respect, your attention span is severely detrimental.
How to make sure your channel doesn't grow, right there
How to make sure you never grow as a person, right here.
I get that you're attempting some kind of witty retort, I suggest you delete to hide your failure.
This video might become his most watched video in a week thought
Buddy, if you think your comment was anything other than one dimensionality and narrow mindedness personified, the very best of luck to you. But my reply stands.
Just because everyone is fellating this movie, doesn't mean those that aren't are somehow stunted or stupid.
Thinking that way sure leads to it, though.
@@humbleopulence tldr, and won't. stfu
Dune from 1984 by Lynch has a lot of effects that hold up and are more amusing than the new films. The 4k versions they sell currently look very good, they have re-released it in cinemas too.
TikTok has fried this dudes brain
lol no the movie could not have been cut down to two hours. you guys forget that this is a book and and the fact that this material even came out this coherent was a monumental achievement. most of the scenes exist to make sure that the themes are clear cut as well as the romance that makes the basis of the story. while i can see why someone might find this boring especially the first half but to say an entire hour could have been cut is insanity. respect your opinion though.
You can’t tell me dune 1 isn’t boring.
Dune 1984, and its extended editions are far better than the remakes. Dune 1984 has multiple tv versions, streaming versions too so its interesting to see what each one included. In some countries they are selling official releases of fan edits too. Probably due to them re-adding back bonus scenes. The extended edition explains more but the Theatrical edition is the best one, its great as is and easy enough to follow. Some of the new physical media versions they sell currently include bonus scenes. They have an Ultimate Edition selling but its pricey.
Wow. Way to suddenly and unexpectedly make sure that nobody ever takes you seriously. Ever.
ah tiktok brain
Different strokes for different folks.
I found it phenomenal. Wasn't bored for even a millisecond.
Damn social media has ruined the attention span of people
They going crazy in the comment section 😂😂😂. I’ll be watching thanks guys!!
True cinema isnt for everyone man,Movies like- Dune series, Oppenheimer gives you the feeling of true cinematography...
Yes but not much else;)
@@humbleopulenceexactly.
Lynch's Dune being accurate to the source material hahaha
Much more than this one and that by a Roman mile
My man, the ornithopter is a block of cheese and with it raining at the end of the '84 version, Ima say Denis' more faithful.
@@humbleopulence
@@Solid_Gravy visual accuracy and general accuracy are too different things, bud. David Lynch's film is generally more accurate. Denis' is (sometimes) visually accurate
@@Solid_Gravy oh, and I wouldn't disparage Lynch's Dune if I were you. Without it, DV would've had only the miniseries to plagiarise (look at the art design, costumes and actor blocking, for example, tell me I'm wrong)
Plagerise, buddy its an adaptation, its going to pull from what came from before. And I want to say I don't think Lynch's Dune is bad by any means, in fact I like it a ton for the Lynch things in it, heart plugs, Baron's middle school acne and even the fucking pugs. But what DV really has which unfortunately Lynch didn't isn't just budget and good vfx, it's character accuracy. Paul is Paul to a T in Denis version and that matters more than mise en scene in my books.@@humbleopulence
Bro has BvS posters up there and complains about "so much exposition"
You are better off with Fast and the Furious part 647 or maybe Transformers part 47...
Dune 1 and 2 are for people that have an attention span that is longer than 20 seconds tiktok clips
Guys just cuz most of them liked the movie, everyone can't. Let the man have his opinions
You keep trying to use words. I don't think they mean what you think they mean.
I mean if you have a poor attention span this movie isn't for you. Maybe just watch RUclips shorts or something
If you thought the movie was boring you you must have an attention problem. At the end of the movie I wanted more and I’m eager to see what happens next. It was so good I’m going to start reading the books
Number of likes equals next movie runtime
Dune remake 1 and 2 are boring, woke Hollywood checklist trash. Very safe, very boring, poor telling of the story, miscast in every way. The action is boring, the sets, designs everything. Lynch's Dune from 1984 became a classic because it was inspired and entertaining. The only reason theses remakes occurred was due to the Dune 1984 becoming a hit with younger generations. It surpassed the books too.
Boringg???
bro i havent even read Dune to know that Part one was going at a crazy fast pace like so much happens so fast and people call it boring?
thanks god we have "dont recommend" and "block channel" feature on youtube
Batman vs Superman poster behind thats all i needed to know
This right here
Then go back and watch Sesame Street. Leave the grown-up films to the grown-ups.
It's his right to state his opinion. I'd rather people state their honest thoughts than just parroting everything on the internet just to appease people. And as a disclaimer, I loved the movie.
Bro is just tryna be different 😂 tik tok brain
I’m glad your opinion dosnt dictate what’s accepted
To be honest even with the people who found the first one boring I could tell that they just had a short attention span and aren’t satisfied unless there are explosions every 5 seconds. Haven’t seen this one yet but most reviews I’ve seen say there is a good amount of action compared to the first one so… maybe grow a longer attention span?
The 1984 film covers only the first book, not the "whole Dune story". Seriously, people in this video talking out of their asses with no clue about the subject.
bad take
I loved the movie even though it had flaws. Your take on it is just incredibly stupid.
Here is what you could of legitimately talked about:
1: The way the worm riding was depicted was very inconsistent. When shown with entire families and supplies on a worm. How did they get on, how do they get off? The movie did a terrible job to make that believable.
2: The Emperor's soldiers in the books are supposed to be an elite army. In the movie they are just standing there with swords like idiots and get easily crushed. That was poorly shown.
3. How Paul was brought back from the dead after drinking the worm blood was incredibly eye rolling and felt too Disney. That pulled me from the emersion of the movie.
First grown man with tiktok generation attention span
I did fall asleep during the first one, but this second movie was much bettwr
The worst review I've ever seen. IMO. You're entitled to an opinion, but if you're going to review a film at least try to make it relevant and accurate. This was appalling.
the ratio is crazy lol
boring? dude it was amazing
Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
tiktok brain
bro is literally marvel brained
what on earth is this dude tapping about
the end sucks!
Thank you for saying this. People so starved for good movies that a decent one like this gets hailed like it's Lawrence of Arabia or Citizen Kane.
Denis Villeneuve wishes this was Lawrence of Arabia. Lawrence of Arabia is a TRUE masterpiece, both in terms of storytelling and visuals.
Oop. Found dude's alt account...
Seems like an unpopular opinion, but I agree. Second film seemed to drag even though there was a lot happening. I nearly fell asleep at one point, and considered leaving early - I’ve read the books so already know the rough story.
The CGI is gorgeous and the movie is visibly striking. But the problem is that the entire thing seems to be shot like a trailer. It’s way too consistently “cinematic,” and if everything is that way, it just leads to fatigue.
Cool movie, idk if it’s for me.
Yup,no said it before too. It's a 6 hour trailer to a 12 hour movie.
It was a total BS
Nah 👎🏻
I agree!!!
This movie was way boring!! No one wants to admit it; but you!
Thanks!!!
It sucked for me. I wouldn’t recommend it.
They took the liberty to change/add/cut whatever they liked. They could have made Dune 1 and 2 into one movie. The pace would have been better.
no
Good grief 😔
@@andyquelch5754 I am honestly asking, because I am trying to understand, how will you watch this movie in the future? Will you sit down and watch all 5 hours at once to see the full story? Or just jump back and forth between the the first and second movie to see just the parts you like? Do people just watch at home with their phones out and look up at the good parts. I am just trying to understand modern viewing habits. Maybe I need to change the way I watch things.
@@todddonaldson7974 I'm happy to watch them together or independently. Just as I have the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Dune is to big to be trapped within the confines of one movie. It would becomes disjointed and illogical. I think they got this just about right. I really don't understand what the issue is?🤔
@@andyquelch5754 overall, I just don't like splitting up movies just for a cash grab like the Hobbit. The Feyd scene in the fighting arena was awesome to look at, but did it really establish Feyd as a good fighter? He took out a few drugged men, and a starved looking man. (I know he is the fight coordinator IRL and a bad ass in real life, but he did not look that way in the movie) Is that really enough to justify a fight with someone trained in the wierding way, a mentat, and a kwisatz haderach who can see the future. So they added other Bene G scenes to pump him up.
he’s either farming for engagement or mentally disabled. and no, “i respect your opinion” does not apply to this scenario. i’m right, he’s wrong.