DeWalt owner here: There are two holes on the blade wrenches that match the diameter of the fence lugs, and are spaced however far the two fence positions are supposed to be. So the procedure is square the fence in the outer position, then use the wrench to set the position of the outer lugs, and it will be the correct distance and square.
I was on the fence about this, and I was looking forward to a SkilSaw for the past few years, but now I'm definitely leaning on the DeWalt. The DeWalt stand is more much stable by far and compact, which makes a huge difference when tetrising and organizing tool in my vehicle. The knife is set better, the fence rides better, the throat plate is better, the push stick is positioned and secured in a better place... Hands down, I'm a believer now, I can't believe it. I was really set on the SkilSaw because of the worm drive and the dust port accessory. Not no more. Thank you for your video. It really helped me make up my mind.
I was two seconds away from buying a Bosch. My gut told me to go DeWalt. So in a split second decision - I went DeWalt. VERY VERY HAPPY I DID NOW!!!! It's be here in 3 days... I'm SOOO EXCITED NOW!!!!!!
I purchased the Skilsaw a few months ago after watching one of your videos unboxing the Skilsaw, easier to fold up or down and four wheel drive wheels.
Hey Mr.Mike The Tape measure is a EASY fix on the SKILL Simply take your tape measure. MARK 6' 12" 18" and 24" next to the TAPE with a FINE FELT PIN. I actually marked mine on the FACE/Tape area thru the 90* bend. Took my Heat Gun. Heated the 24 end. with a RAZOR I just lifted it carefully. TAKE HEAT gun. Slowly Peel the tape with the HEAT to soften the STICKY and peel it up to about the Last Inch. (( I am right handed had tape in Left Hand. Heat guy in Right. PEELED it back to the last INCH....)) Put heat gun down. and now with Right hand. STICK the 6" with a slight pull. to align properly. Then 12" Pulll to stick down at 12" then 18" and 24"..... ALL MY Measurements were done with fence and tape measurement CONFIRMED....... The RED marker on the slider works GREAT to draw next too. etc etc EASY FIX.
After my 25 yo Rigid died, I replaced it with this Skil. I’m strictly DIY but with a small shop. The bulk work needs to done outside. The sled was the deciding fact, since I have to roll over grass and bumps. Since then, the torque monster has been great for ripping pressure treated lumber and the cutting depth comes in handy every now and then.
The point of a contractor saw is that it needs to be portable on that fact alone. The skill is hands down the winner. When you consider all the other features, it's really a toss-up. I measured my Tape measure on the front of the saw once not off I don't know if I got lucky or if they fixed it but I don't have an issue. I also don't have an issue with my fence. I have a lot of hours on the shop. And it still works as good as the day about it. I don't have any negatives about the Dewalt, Dewalt makes great equipment. But for portability, nobody beats the skil.
I chose the SkilSaw over the Dewalt after watching this video and reading reviews for both saws. Huge plusses for the SkilSaw were: 1) Unrivaled stand. Goes cross-country and up and down stairs like no other. 2) Left-side material support. Very helpful for wide ripping. Perfectly level with the table right out of the box (and also adjustable if not perfect). 3) Available outfeed support. Great for long ripping when you don't have a helper handy. As for the criticisms in this video and some of the 1-star reviews for the SkilSaw: 1) Wow, that thing about the ruler being inaccurate would definitely be lame. Mine was DOBA (that is to say, completely accurate throughout the full range). Don't know what more to say about that. 2) Accuracy out-of-the-box: My unit was very accurate in terms of table flatness, bevel squareness, and parallelness of miter slot, fence and blade. So, for one person, I am confident I made the right choice in choosing the SkillSaw SPT-99-11 to suit my needs and preferences.
Thanks for a great comparison video. For me, the Skilsaw will work better. My shop is pretty small, so any time I can cut wood outside on the lawn, it’s one less shop cleanup for me. With that awesome stand and those big wheels, I’d have no problem rolling it out the door, even over the fairly high sill. Just turned 65, just retired and just got the shop built, after whining about not having a proper shop for 40 years, lol, so it’s time to replace all my cheap saws, (table saw, miter saw etc), with bigger, better ones. Folks like yourself who make these videos really help a bunch, with your insight. Cheers!
Very happy the video helped! FYI before RUclips I never cut wood inside a closed garage ever. Better to stand in the snow than have to clean the whole garage 🤣 Congrats on the retirement and thanks for watching!
I purchased a Skill SPT77WM circular saw, in September of 2023. That saw is a beast. Anyone using one of those better have a good grip on it before squeezing the trigger, or that thing will kick like a mule. On materials like southern yellow pine, that motor doesn't even pause at all, it just cuts through it like a hot knife through butter. If that Skill table saw is built the way my circular saw is, it should be a winner.
I have two skil saws just in case my brushless ridged or ever my corded dewalt worm drive. I just bought a bosch contracting saw. I'll get the skill if I don't like it. It's heavy and I'm a midget with a lifted f350. The saw is amazing quality
I fight the fence on my VERY old Delta saw now, and it even stops me from doing projects because of the hassle. I like the stand on the SKIL, but the deciding factor was the difference of how smooth the fence was on the DeWalt compared to the Skilsaw. I also like that outfeed support on the Skilsaw and which the Dewalt had that feature. The DeWalt fence still gets my vote and would be why I pick the DeWalt.
Well, the overriding factor for any table saw and what makes them do what they do is the fence. I like the skil stand and love that you can rip a 2x4 or 4x4 in one go I still have to give it to dewalt...it just edged out the skil with it's smooth fence and riving knife setup and accurate scale.
I agree that riving knife release is seriously cool! I’ve been contemplating which one I’d buy if I have to decide and I’m still on the fence. Wish I could combine the best features of both into one amazing saw. Thanks for watching Arthur!
I bought the skil and haven't had a chance to actually use it. The fence has a defect. I ordered a replacement fence and it also had the exact same defect. The first fence broke on the front clip where the metal hinge pin is located. The plastic is cracked on both, and on both ends after closer inspection. Does it function to lock in place? So far yes. The original one I had used super glue to repair. Quite the disappointment for a brand new saw. It would be interesting to know if yours has this same defect. A hairline crack in the plastic where the wrist/hinge pin holds the end clip. If they'd had offered just new plastic end parts, that would be all that is needed if swapped yourself. If not, a replacement fence is about $87.
As a complete beginner, and intimidated by the table saw. Why doesn't anyone use the blade guard? I just bought the Dewalt. All my power tools are on their platform, and paying more for a brand I already know made sense to me. Thanks for another nice video. Getting ready to [attempt] remodel my kitchen, buidling my own cabinets. Your videos are helping out. Thank you.
I've used my Dewalt for everything from fine woodworking to rough carpentry. I switch between driving knife to blade guard a lot so I really appreciate the easy of making the change. My favorite feature is that fence. Dead accurate and butter smooth. My only complaint is dust control. Mediocre at best for a shop saw.
I’ve got the skilsaw at home, and I frequently use a coworkers dewalt (carpenter). The dewalt is awesome, and might be slightly nicer build quality. I’d buy the skilsaw again though! The stand is absurdly good. You can do stairs with one hand! The extra left hand support from the stand is really excellent design, and makes ripping sheet goods much safer. The dust port is better on the skilsaw, and will shoot straight down into a 5 gallon bucket. A note on the fence: my skilsaw is smoother than the dewalt, cause the work one is crammed full of sawdust haha. Both move smoother with the knob. Moving the dewalt once it’s set up is annoying. I’m going to bring my skilsaw into work and see what my coworker thinks! Cheers
Great video, Mike! When I retired in 2020, I bought the DeWalt 8.25 table saw because I was intimidated by table saws then. Many projects later, I wish I would have bought a 10 inch. Pining for DeWalt to introduce a contractor table saw and I would scarf that up. However Skilsaw makes quite the impression! I’m content with what I have, but you make a strong case for upgrading for me! Take care, man!
Hello Daniel! Thank you! You bring up a good point and Ive often wondered why these top tool companies stay away from contractor sized saws. Fair bet there's less profit but it would be awesome to see more competition and choices for the consumer in that segment. Thanks as always for watching!
Just bought the Dewalt today. Was wavering between these 2 and the Bosch. After playing with all 3 i decided the stability of the Dewalt stand was the deal maker because I rip a lot of full sheets.
I have a small shop - 10 x 14 - and having the undercarraige on the Skil is a huge bonus. It moves aroung easily and even though I have a step up going into my shop the wheels on the Skil handles it with ease. I can then do the bigger jobs out on my deck.
I like your style, and the video, unlike a lot of your viewers I don't see the comparison, unless I am missing the point, the DeWalt is 10 years old, Skill is of a year ago as I am viewing your video, plenty of time for other manufactures to see what is worth using. Thank you for your time.
Hello Peter. I see your point about the age of the Dewalt but I would argue its still brings a lot to the table. it has some innovate designs which still having been duplicated like the riving knife mechanism. Its due or a refresh at least but its still a popular saw and I think its still competitive. Thanks for watching!
The Dewalt fence moved when you tapped on it and said it’s not going anywhere. You can legitimately see the gear turn to the left of the screen. (8:04) awesome video great amount of knowledge shared!
Man, that is tough! the extra height capacity of the Skil, the blade chnage and stand, outfeed accessory. The dewalt fence, plate and riving knife swap seem much better. Thank you for all of the great info!
I wish I could tell you one is better than the other but they are both great saws. At least you now know there’s no wrong answer. Good luck with the decision Shane!
@@ProjectsForAllReviews I went with the Delta 36-725T2. Your other videos were a definite help! In the end, I just need to move it around my garage, not to an actual jobsite. That being the case, the Delta seemed like the better option that was 1) locally available 2) close enough to that price range. I am looking forward to more of your videos. Keep up the great work!
Hello Mike. Just bought the Dewalt. Was leaning toward the Skillsaw as mentioned in one of my earlier comments because of its 16" wheel stand and worm drive but switched last minute. Love the DeWalt but having a problem with throat plate, havent been able to find anything and wondering if you have same. At 8:30 of your video you show the exact spot with issue. The black inserted area on the right between blade and fence is approximately 1 to 1-1/2 wide you will notice that the yellow part of the throat plate wraps around to the back of the black. The black is quite a bit lower than the yellow which almost gave me an unpleasant experience yesterday. Screw adjustments do nothing for the issue because the black inserted area is captured within the main plate. Its only a problem when you are cutting a piece that is less than the width of the black, the black becomes the support and your piece hits the yellow back edge past the blade. Why the heck is that black even there? Watched this video several times, subbed and enjoy your style. Thank you!
I have been using my Skil for 6 1/2 years. No issues. The worm drive motor is as strong today as it was when I bought it. Wouldn’t trade it for a Dewalt. Don’t get me wrong, I have many Dewalt tool. They make great tools, but when it comes to the table saw, Skil wins hands down for me.
I'm looking to buy a job site table saw. I've had my eye on the rigid table saw. A contractor friend of mine highly suggested the DeWalt table saw. I love these side by side comparison videos. I used to buy only DeWalt power tools many years ago until I found out they were bought out Black & Decker. I was afraid DeWalt would go hill in quality but have recently learned they haven't change a thing and DeWalt is still making high quality power tools. The cost is another concern. DeWalt prices are high. If the skill table saw can match the quality, power and price is cheaper than the DeWalt, I'll be buying the skill.
That Skillsaw motor and worm gear gearbox looks absolutely incredible. They built that motor and worm drive way more beautiful than it needs to be, and it's almost worth buying just because of that motor and gearbox. They even have their name cast into the side of the solid metal motor housing (not a plastic motor like 99% of brushed motors). I have to say, I am so happy that I live in a timeline where Skillsaw is a premium brand that is still commercial quality. Something you didn't mention in your Skil table saw review is that you were able to rip a 4x4 beam all the way through without flipping it over. Skil and Skillsaw have found a way to give you an extra 1/2" of cutting depth compared to the Dewalt. That's a huge factor for a person who uses 4" thick lumber. The way they positioned the motors is genius.
I agree with you the motor housing on worm drive saws is a little like art. I also have a couple hand saws sitting around, a vintage who’s model number eludes me and a newer Mag77. Love the look of both. I try not to harp on aesthetics too much in the reviews. In the end it doesn’t matter much for a tool. Thanks for watching Ritalie!
I’ve owned the Skilsaw for 5 years. My measuring scale is bang on, the fence is smooth to move and I have no wear at all compared to the video. Can’t account for the difference compared to the sample in the video. I own all DeWALT power tools aside from my table saw. I selected the Skilsaw over DeWALT when deciding to purchase because: 1. Ease and speed of setup, collapsing and moving the saw (I’ve never found it less than fully stable); 2 the Worm Drive; 3. It can rip a 4x4 beam all the way through without flipping it over - the DeWALT can’t; 4. The outfeed attachment and handle work support are super convenient - less need to set up other supports. If you have a restricted area for your workshop and need to collapse your saw after each use like I do, you’ll find the stand alone will make it worth buying the Skilsaw. I love all my DeWALT tools, but I feel my Skilsaw was hands down the best purchase for my needs.
I was leaning toward the Dewalt and now you've clouded my judgement. I love that Skilsaw stand but the fact that the Dewalt stores smaller is conflicting me. Sounds like the tape issue can be replaced easily.
Thanks for the great comparison! I appreciate the time and effort that you put into this, and thought the presentation was excellent. I just bought the DeWalt. After looking over the reviews on both Amazon and HD, I thought it would be the way to go. I loved the stand on the Skilsaw and the wheels definitely will handle rougher terrain. The Skilsaw cost less, but when I saw the DeWalt dropped $100 in price, I decided to pull the trigger. If I'm spending my money on a product, I don't want to have to "fix" something to make it function correctly, right out of the gate, so I'm happy with my choice. Only time will tell if I made the right decision.
Im a contractor who bought the skil in your video and have this to say, fence locking turnbuckle sucks constantly retighten dust chute clogs very easy saw stand foot pedal broke in first week ow motor has shit the bed. I have owned skil worm drive saws for over 40 years and they have been fantastic. I also had a dewalt 10" years ago that was a great saw , but my go to tablesaw has always been makita with rousseau set up great site saw
I own the DWE7491RS (and never used the Skilsaw). I can attest to the rock-solid stability of the Dewalt stand. I think if I was still installing wood floors and needed a lot of mobility with my table saw, where I'd be moving it daily to and from different jobsites, it looks like the Skilsaw's stand might be beneficial. Dewalt's is not very comfortable to move around. However, because I keep my table saw in the same place most of the time, and only occasionally move (mostly when cleaning), I really appreciate the stability provided by the Dewalt, and I don't think I'd like the front-to-back wobble from the Skilsaw. I can further attest to the smooth action of the Dewalt fence. I have adjusted its width and switched from fence-up to fence-down configuration hundreds of times in the three years I have owned it, and it still remains smooth and accurate. All this to say, for a woodworker needing a dedicated table saw and not needing a lot of mobility, I think I'd stick with Dewalt. But if I needed jobsite mobility, I'd at least consider the Skilsaw. Edit: I also have no need of a portable outfeed support, I use a custom-made workbench for that. But on a jobsite, I could definitely see where that outfeed support for the Skilsaw might be beneficial, depending on what you're using it for. Yet again reinforcing my initial impression that the Skilsaw might be be better for the working man needing mobile use. Second edit: thanks for your thorough review.
The skills is great with plywood and pine it struggles ripping harder woods like walnut. Made a straight edge jig and use my skil worm drive circular saw, works great.
Well personally I'm goin with the dato stack lol...DeWalt jobsite saw I've used for prolly 25 years framing houses...it's provin ok..this Skil is makein quit the splash these days..everyone seems to like it...I know space is a issue for some, but seriously get at least a contractor saw if you are guna do fine wood working..you will be that much farther ahead by doing so in so many ways...great honest review my man...
Could you put some wax on the fence rails? would that help with smoothness and maybe even wear?? If this is a stupid question I am sorry, I am just new to Table saws/wood working. I did alot in HS, but that has been many years. Since then it has just been refinishing my basement and house repairs. Really LOVE your in depth reviews. Honest about everything. and literally you check everything, even somethings I wouldnt even think to check.
saw this comparison highlighted on the Tool Show, came over to have a look. Impressed by your thorough unbiased review. I came in with the thought that the DeWalt was the best from my research, but MAN the skillsaw stand and 1 person operation has me questioning myself..... I think however the fence smoothness and accurate ruler (come on you cant fuck that up) gives it *just* to the DeWalt. Subbed!
Welcome! Thanks for letting me know I was on the Tool Show again! Love those guys! These two saws have equal parts good and bad making it super hard to pick between the two. I’m still undecided about which to recommended. I have the Bosch 4100 in the shop for this week. Thanks for watching!
After watching this video and reading through the comments, it's Skilsaw for me. I want to use it to build a large shed and need to make a lot of cuts on 4x8 sheets and 4x4 posts. Having support from the foot of the stand for panels is huge, and so is the ability to buy a rear outfeed stand. Skilsaw can cut a depth of 3 5/8ths while DeWalt can only cut 3 1/8th so it can't do posts without flipping it over. Since I plan on using a lot of rough cut wet lumber from my chainsaw and planer, Skilsaw's worm drive seems like a winner. I would have loved to see an even thicker dado on wet wood to try and see what the DeWalt's limit is
Sweet! You hit 11K subs! Grats! Great comparison, Mike. Although I'm pretty much set for power tools your reviews are always worth watching. Looking forward to the Metabo and Bosch stuff, as well as more from Skil and Flex. I think Bauer and Hercules are worth a look also. I'm not brand loyal, and it's refreshing to see the offerings from companies other than the over-covered DeWalt, Milwaukee, and Ryobi tools everyone else is doing.
Thanks Magius! Im happy with the brands we've covered up to this point but we definitely need to expand into some others. Makita is another one we haven't touched and they have a product line that rivals Milwaukee. There's so much cool stuff out there, I wish I had the time to do more than one video a week. Hopefully that'll change one of these days. Thanks for watching!
i would be interested to see one of these modern saws up against an old craftsman you see on marketplace all the time and see if the new saws are that much better
We need a video comparing replacing arbor bearings! I am replacing the bearings on my earlier generation Skillsaw SPT70WT and it requires quite a bit of disassembly!
My 10" Kobalt 10152 is 35" tall, the blade to fence length is only 28 7/8. The quick-release undercarriage/portability base is much like Skilsaw's, but the wheels are much smaller, and plastic. The base is very sturdy, however. It has a 15 amp motor, so powers through pretty much everything. When I bought it, it was on sale for $299.00 (at Lowes). The included all-purpose blade works fine for all general construction lumber, but I would buy a better blade for hardwoods. I've both ripped and cross-cut boards and plywood with no problems using that blade. The push stick thingy rests on top of the fence in a spring-loaded channel on top. Very handy. All in all a very good tool for cheap! Edit: I do NOT like the Dewalt stand-- those legs are spindly, and the back legs are, indeed, a trip hazard. Especially in a shop. No part of my stand is in the way of the table (looks like Dewalt bit it pretty bad with that handle in the way on the left of the table).
Great job Mike! I've seen a couple of your videos and you do a great job of thorough reviewing the products. I'm still on the fence (no pun intended) about which to pick but I am leaning towards the Skilsaw. Thank you for what you do and you have a new subscriber!
I am also leaning towards the Dewalt. I am in the market due to the fact My 4 year old Kolbalt table saw, the motor must had a crack in the mounting because the motor just fell down. Luckly i was not using it at the time. Just an FYI
Mike I would choose the skill saw based on the mobility factor, like you said it's easy to move around. Because essentially it looks to me like there one in the same. Both saws virtually have similar features. Like you I would replace the measuring strip and maybe look for a upgraded miter gauge any ideas ❓
Here's a couple ideas I had for the ruler and miter gauge. Affiliate links: Starett adhesive backed ruler: amzn.to/3WlhDfM. Incra V120 miter gauge: amzn.to/3YilZaq. Just a couple ideas but should get you started on your search. Thanks for watching!
Enjoy your videos....looking to purchase. Question please what is the difference between the SPT99-11 and the SPT99-12? Being older I'm seriously leaning toward the skillsaw because of the 16" wheeled stand. Thoughts on the Ridgid R4550.
Best I can tell the only difference between the SPT9911 and 12 is the 11 comes with a Skilsaw blade and the 12 has a Diablo blade included. I haven’t used that Ridgid yet but we’ll get to it eventually. Thanks for watching Dino!
Super job Mike! I have one question, the DWE7491RS use the DWE74911 stand. Do you know if you could use the DW7440RS in place of the DWE74911 stand? I assume you can buy the DWE7491 saw separately? Thank you.
Wow, such a true through and through review. I have both this skilsaw and another smaller Dewalt table saw. I want this Dewalt so bad though! I agree with everything you brought up in the comparisons. After coming from multiple higher end table saws and even my little Dewalt flex volt (daily job site use), when I first used the skilsaw it honestly felt like a junky toy. The smoothness and quality and craftsmanship just isn’t there. I do really really like the stand and how mobile it is… but ripping full sheets by myself is pretty darn sketchy as you can literally end up pushing the saw over due to the wobble. That’s kinda what did it for me. Very annoying to not be able to trust a nice straight cut knowing your saw will move out from under you… to me and probably most ppl, the rip capacity is what tips the scales. Depth of cut is nice but you can always just flip the piece over if need be so not that important for a contractor saw. But being able to rip 32+ inches is a hugeeeeee deal. Also one has to add oil to the worm drive if I’m not mistaken? In any case, the craftsmanship, thought put into the riving knife, rock solidness, and rip capacity make this an easy choice. I would only choose the skil if I needed to traverse rocky terrain up and down a mountain every single day.
You bring up some good points! I still couldn’t tell you which of these saws I would buy if had to make the choice today. I wish I could combine the best attributes of each into one saw. We’ve got tons of job saws out there to review. Maybe the perfect saws out there. Got the Bosch 4100 in the shop now. Thanks for watching!
At about 19min in, the Skilsaw seems to have borrowed A LOT from the Bosch. My old Bosch has the same rear outfeed table, a really similar throat plate, a very similar looking table, etc. of course the Bosch worm drive circ saw is pretty much identical to the Skilsaw Mag77…so, ther’s that.
I really dislike the cutout in the dewalt table. I get why they do it for portability but it just seems like it could be an issue in some circumstances
I'm in the market for a new table saw. I don't have a shop so I need to have my table saw on wheels. I wanted to see a comparison of these two saws. You nailed my friend. I wish I could snap my fingers and mesh these saws to my likings but the world doesn't work that way. I have gotten 22 years out of my Hitachi table saw and it is time to move on and up. The blade has the dreaded wiggle with no adjustments. I have tweaked it as far as I can go and I`m done. Time to get a new saw. Great job on comparing these saws.
Skil is certainly attractive, but even though easily replaced, the inaccurate fence scale really worries me. What other QC issues might be hiding? Plus the Dewalt carries a 3 year warranty but the Skil is only a year. But then the Bosch is only a year as well...
I’m kinda waiting to see if Bosch comes out with Reaxx (flesh sensing safety tech) or similar again, plus they have very interesting saws with sliding mitre options in other markets so who knows what’s coming next but I really enjoyed this review and the Dewalt is very compelling (they both are)!
I have the skilsaw table saw. It is quite good relatively speaking, however if I was to do it again I’d buy a sawstop without hesitation. Additionally I will saw the motor on a jobsite saw just isn’t in the same league as a cabinet saw that runs 220volt… I’m hard to please so I’d be going 220 sawstop despite the cost
There’s a lot of great jobsite saws but none compare to the weight, power and size of a large cabinet saw. Just the reduction in noise makes it worth the investment IMO. Thanks for watching!
Friend, make sure you check out the sawstop cause I bought one and I am very discouraged by the fence. It flops about and is nearly impossible to lock down straight. When I complained to the dealer, he says to me, it’s a worksite saw, what do you expect? Color me unimpressed, for $2100. Canadian saw? Just be careful
I was down at Lowes looking at the DeWalt, they did not have the Skil in stock, but I really liked the Metabo (Hitachi, Japan, 1910) HTP Model #C10RJSM, note that the official latest reversion is S, and this is an M. It is normally $599, with $100 off while supplies last. I like the rack and pinion, it was smoother than, or as smooth as the DeWalt, I thought it might be me, so I asked the salesman, who tested both and thought the same thing. I like the rack and pinion on the angle adjustor, slap a magnetic angle finder on it, and you can dial it in easy. I watched all your table saw reviews, yours are the best. This would be a good saw to review, it is better than the Hitachi, and although they look the same, there are many improvements. What do would recommend out of these 3?
I am contemplating getting the Dewalt. I love the larger wheel size of the Skil, but since the wheels on the Dewalt are not touching the floor when it's setup for cutting (unlike the Skil), the wheel diameter shouldn't be an issue during cutting, so couldn't I just replace the small wheels for larger ones making it easier to move around when not cutting?
It looks like you might be able to replace the OEM wheels with larger wheels but the wide angle of the back legs could severely limit the size. Based on photos and drawings only - I'm still on the "fence".
I have the Dewalt. First table saw I’ve ever owned. Bought it earlier this year. I absolutely love it. Your previous review really helped me with my decision, and also getting it set up. Keep up the great work.
I’m halfway through filming the Bosch now. Very good chance that comparison will happen Matthew. Stay tuned for the Bosch vid soon. Thanks for watching!
Only thing I didn’t notice you mention is price. I bought the Skilsaw for 2/3 the price of the Dewalt. Interestingly, I don’t have the issue with the tape, although I do have a wear spot on the rail. I’ve never trusted the tapes though and always measure using my tape measure or occasionally a rule.
Hold on. Both dewalt and skil sell for the same price ....550 on sale and 650 regular. The sawstop sells for 1,700ish and no sales on them ever...(festool parent company ownes sawstop now and they do not ever allow sales) So, you get it used?
I usually put the prices on the thumbnails of my videos and am trying to get away from talking about it unless relevant because lately price have been changing very often. Arthur is correct on the pricing here on these two. Thanks for watching!
Hi Mike, first time seeing your videos and really glad i found them; great info in each one! My company restores old houses so we put a lot of use on these job site saws; just about to retire our current Dewalt 10 inch unit. It's been a champ over the years but definitely had to replace parts from time to time. Does anyone have a sense of the Skilsaw's durability and longevity? Super interested in that unit to become our main saw.
Can you tell us , what is the foot print width, meaning what is the smallest door I can easily wheel thru. ? That info is important when taking it to changing job sites.
My Bosch 4100 seems harder to raise the blade after several years of use. I clean it out more regularly now than before, but problem seems to be getting more frequent. Any idea how to correct this?
Mostly depends on what benefits your work load and needs, however I don't own either one of these but I would choose DeWalt because it seems it is more precision built and better thought out in more things. Some of the items on the Skill just seem somewhat cheap. The stand simplicity and efficiency of the Skill is hands better. Very much a toss up though.
Honestly the stand puts me over the line on the Skilsaw, well other than the wormdrive motor. I work by myself so the fact I can get it in and out of the truck has me sold. If the DeWalt had the same stand, I would totally be screwed. Lol
Can side table extensions be mounted to either of these? In any event, I'd be taking them off of those rickety looking stands and mounting them to a more permanent stand in my shop if I get one.
The Skilsaw uses the stand frame on the left as a support which is a plus. The DeWALT doesn’t have any add on supports as far as I know. Thanks for watching!
First time I’ve seen that saw! Looks amazing and it’s 1 month to ship to Chicago on Amazon. At $1650 the channel may have to save its pennies for that one. Thanks for the head up!
Skill seems to have hired the right people in the last couple years their tools are punching way above there weight class and are heading in a good direction. If they keep the innovation in there tools moving forward they will earn a major piece of the market.
I've had the Skilsaw for a couple of years now. Bought it for projects at work during covid, which kept me employed. You never know when your woodworking skills will come in handy. The saw has tremendous power and will cut through almost anything. The saw will take a dado and Skilsaw makes a decent insert. Oddly their zero clearance insert is a piece of plastic crap. Also the cheap plastic handle that raises the blade stripped out almost immediately. I found an after market company that offers a replacement with a metal insert so we'll see. Still, having to use a vice grip to adjust the blade on a six hundred plus saw is more than a little disappointing. The rack and pinion isn't super smooth but it works well enough. I will say that the scale have proved very accurate in my experience. I can set the scale at 3 inches and the cut piece will be dead bang 3 inches. I haven't done any fairly wide rips so that may change. Dust collection is my big issue with this saw. It shoots a lot of sawdust out of the dust port as you would expect, but it also throws a hell of a lot of dust off the table back at the operator. I have to wear full face protection when I use it (I get the cheap ones at Harbor Freight). When I finish cutting, I have sawdust all over the saw, all over me, and all over the ground around it. Even with a really good vac I'm not sure I would ever use this saw in an enclosed space. I don't know it this just my machine; I would be really interested in anyone else's experience. So those are my thoughts, hope they are helpful.
I own the dewalt and use it with dado blades and a vacuum, I maximize the ripping cut up to 34.5 inches, man! I love this tool. Mine doesn't make the squeaking rail noise and stops fast.(im surprised the one in the video is actually stops slow, might be one of the first gen). I do remove the bolts for transportation in a loaded van. It's super easy. I use saw horses and plywood for outfeed and also use as a work station.
Can you please review the Kobalt 10" in 15 amp table saw w/ stand (Model TS10601)? I have never seen a review video for it, only it's less impressive and more expensive "little brother". It took has a rack and pinion fence setup and was recently on sale (after Black Friday) for just $270. I feel like I got a steal and so far my only concern is the gears for raising/lowering the blade are plastic, not metal. Interested in your thoughts and thank you for your work and content.
Been watching your Table saw difference videos. I like what I see from that SkilSaw! You say you are giving away that saw on the 16th of Sept. my Bday is the 17th and I sure could use a table saw in my shop! Been shopping for the best saw for the right price in the mean time. Have a great day and keep on showing what you got! Thanks!
My 22-year old lowest-price Craftsman just died, which I used it the last few years as my secondary beat-around benchtop saw (Kept it outside, rain or shine), and I was thinking of getting a saw for jobsites and also to built a bench around for my shop - I have a Ridgid, but the stand is almost as big as the Skilsaw, and I liked the Craftsman for being so light and movable. Now, I already wrote you that I bought the Skil (The red one, not the Skilsaw) in Greece, on your recommendation, and how impressed I was with it. Would you say the Skilsaw is a lot more powerful than the Skil? I would rather have the portability of the Skil, and pretty much everything seems the same between the two, other than the worm drive and the cart, and given the price difference, would you say that on the power they are kinda similar, or is there a big difference?
The biggest advantage the Skilsaw has over that little Skil is size. Bigger table, stand, full size dados. The Skilsaw is all metal parts also and I’m sure you’re paying for durability and longevity. I still love that Skil for the portability and quality you get for the price but it’s tough to compare the two. Thanks for watching Mak! Let me know which way you go.
Just canceled order for DeWalt after seeing so many negative reviews on their own site. A few mentioned the arbor nut coming loose! Going to cough up $100 more for the Skilsaw, due to the depth of cut and stand.
Hey Brother. great job on your videos. I love your 1st hand impression. I would expect the DeWalt to be a bit more refined. Although, I'm certain, after your video, SKIL has quickly gotten their collective sh!t together. I'm leaning towards the SKIL, but it remains to be seen whichever saw has the best price at the time of purchase. I do like those big scooter wheels on the SKIL.
DeWalt owner here: There are two holes on the blade wrenches that match the diameter of the fence lugs, and are spaced however far the two fence positions are supposed to be. So the procedure is square the fence in the outer position, then use the wrench to set the position of the outer lugs, and it will be the correct distance and square.
one thing you could address that would be beneficial is the availability of replacement parts.
I've owned the Skil for 7 years. Zero complaints.
It just came out a year ago
I was on the fence about this, and I was looking forward to a SkilSaw for the past few years, but now I'm definitely leaning on the DeWalt. The DeWalt stand is more much stable by far and compact, which makes a huge difference when tetrising and organizing tool in my vehicle. The knife is set better, the fence rides better, the throat plate is better, the push stick is positioned and secured in a better place... Hands down, I'm a believer now, I can't believe it. I was really set on the SkilSaw because of the worm drive and the dust port accessory. Not no more. Thank you for your video. It really helped me make up my mind.
Tu comentario también me ayudo a mi gracias
I was two seconds away from buying a Bosch.
My gut told me to go DeWalt.
So in a split second decision - I went DeWalt.
VERY VERY HAPPY I DID NOW!!!!
It's be here in 3 days... I'm SOOO EXCITED NOW!!!!!!
I purchased the Skilsaw a few months ago after watching one of your videos unboxing the Skilsaw, easier to fold up or down and four wheel drive wheels.
Hey Mr.Mike The Tape measure is a EASY fix on the SKILL
Simply take your tape measure. MARK 6' 12" 18" and 24" next to the TAPE with a FINE FELT PIN. I actually marked mine on the FACE/Tape area thru the 90* bend.
Took my Heat Gun. Heated the 24 end. with a RAZOR I just lifted it carefully. TAKE HEAT gun. Slowly Peel the tape with the HEAT to soften the STICKY and peel it up to about the Last Inch. (( I am right handed had tape in Left Hand. Heat guy in Right. PEELED it back to the last INCH....)) Put heat gun down. and now with Right hand. STICK the 6" with a slight pull. to align properly. Then 12" Pulll to stick down at 12" then 18" and 24".....
ALL MY Measurements were done with fence and tape measurement CONFIRMED....... The RED marker on the slider works GREAT to draw next too. etc etc
EASY FIX.
After my 25 yo Rigid died, I replaced it with this Skil. I’m strictly DIY but with a small shop. The bulk work needs to done outside. The sled was the deciding fact, since I have to roll over grass and bumps. Since then, the torque monster has been great for ripping pressure treated lumber and the cutting depth comes in handy every now and then.
The point of a contractor saw is that it needs to be portable on that fact alone. The skill is hands down the winner. When you consider all the other features, it's really a toss-up. I measured my Tape measure on the front of the saw once not off I don't know if I got lucky or if they fixed it but I don't have an issue. I also don't have an issue with my fence. I have a lot of hours on the shop.
And it still works as good as the day about it. I don't have any negatives about the Dewalt, Dewalt makes great equipment. But for portability, nobody beats the skil.
I chose the SkilSaw over the Dewalt after watching this video and reading reviews for both saws. Huge plusses for the SkilSaw were: 1) Unrivaled stand. Goes cross-country and up and down stairs like no other. 2) Left-side material support. Very helpful for wide ripping. Perfectly level with the table right out of the box (and also adjustable if not perfect). 3) Available outfeed support. Great for long ripping when you don't have a helper handy. As for the criticisms in this video and some of the 1-star reviews for the SkilSaw: 1) Wow, that thing about the ruler being inaccurate would definitely be lame. Mine was DOBA (that is to say, completely accurate throughout the full range). Don't know what more to say about that. 2) Accuracy out-of-the-box: My unit was very accurate in terms of table flatness, bevel squareness, and parallelness of miter slot, fence and blade. So, for one person, I am confident I made the right choice in choosing the SkillSaw SPT-99-11 to suit my needs and preferences.
Thanks for the insight and for watching!
Thanks for a great comparison video. For me, the Skilsaw will work better. My shop is pretty small, so any time I can cut wood outside on the lawn, it’s one less shop cleanup for me. With that awesome stand and those big wheels, I’d have no problem rolling it out the door, even over the fairly high sill. Just turned 65, just retired and just got the shop built, after whining about not having a proper shop for 40 years, lol, so it’s time to replace all my cheap saws, (table saw, miter saw etc), with bigger, better ones. Folks like yourself who make these videos really help a bunch, with your insight. Cheers!
Very happy the video helped! FYI before RUclips I never cut wood inside a closed garage ever. Better to stand in the snow than have to clean the whole garage 🤣 Congrats on the retirement and thanks for watching!
I purchased a Skill SPT77WM circular saw, in September of 2023. That saw is a beast. Anyone using one of those better have a good grip on it before squeezing the trigger, or that thing will kick like a mule. On materials like southern yellow pine, that motor doesn't even pause at all, it just cuts through it like a hot knife through butter. If that Skill table saw is built the way my circular saw is, it should be a winner.
I’d go with the Skilsaw, just because I know that in 50 years when my grandkids need a tablesaw, that worm drive powertrain will still be kicking lol.
Yep! That Skilsaw is going to stay with me for a long time if not forever. Thanks for watching Griffin!
Love my skilsaw. It's a beast.
So do I from Oxford England 🏴
Yup, the Skilsaw's been great for cutting/shaping my 4x4 landscape timbers
I have two skil saws just in case my brushless ridged or ever my corded dewalt worm drive. I just bought a bosch contracting saw. I'll get the skill if I don't like it. It's heavy and I'm a midget with a lifted f350. The saw is amazing quality
I fight the fence on my VERY old Delta saw now, and it even stops me from doing projects because of the hassle. I like the stand on the SKIL, but the deciding factor was the difference of how smooth the fence was on the DeWalt compared to the Skilsaw. I also like that outfeed support on the Skilsaw and which the Dewalt had that feature. The DeWalt fence still gets my vote and would be why I pick the DeWalt.
Well, the overriding factor for any table saw and what makes them do what they do is the fence. I like the skil stand and love that you can rip a 2x4 or 4x4 in one go I still have to give it to dewalt...it just edged out the skil with it's smooth fence and riving knife setup and accurate scale.
I agree that riving knife release is seriously cool! I’ve been contemplating which one I’d buy if I have to decide and I’m still on the fence. Wish I could combine the best features of both into one amazing saw. Thanks for watching Arthur!
I bought the skil and haven't had a chance to actually use it. The fence has a defect. I ordered a replacement fence and it also had the exact same defect. The first fence broke on the front clip where the metal hinge pin is located. The plastic is cracked on both, and on both ends after closer inspection. Does it function to lock in place? So far yes. The original one I had used super glue to repair. Quite the disappointment for a brand new saw. It would be interesting to know if yours has this same defect. A hairline crack in the plastic where the wrist/hinge pin holds the end clip. If they'd had offered just new plastic end parts, that would be all that is needed if swapped yourself. If not, a replacement fence is about $87.
As a complete beginner, and intimidated by the table saw. Why doesn't anyone use the blade guard? I just bought the Dewalt. All my power tools are on their platform, and paying more for a brand I already know made sense to me.
Thanks for another nice video. Getting ready to [attempt] remodel my kitchen, buidling my own cabinets. Your videos are helping out. Thank you.
I've used my Dewalt for everything from fine woodworking to rough carpentry. I switch between driving knife to blade guard a lot so I really appreciate the easy of making the change. My favorite feature is that fence. Dead accurate and butter smooth. My only complaint is dust control. Mediocre at best for a shop saw.
I’ve got the skilsaw at home, and I frequently use a coworkers dewalt (carpenter). The dewalt is awesome, and might be slightly nicer build quality. I’d buy the skilsaw again though! The stand is absurdly good. You can do stairs with one hand! The extra left hand support from the stand is really excellent design, and makes ripping sheet goods much safer. The dust port is better on the skilsaw, and will shoot straight down into a 5 gallon bucket. A note on the fence: my skilsaw is smoother than the dewalt, cause the work one is crammed full of sawdust haha. Both move smoother with the knob. Moving the dewalt once it’s set up is annoying. I’m going to bring my skilsaw into work and see what my coworker thinks!
Cheers
What's the update in comparing the two?
Great video, Mike! When I retired in 2020, I bought the DeWalt 8.25 table saw because I was intimidated by table saws then. Many projects later, I wish I would have bought a 10 inch. Pining for DeWalt to introduce a contractor table saw and I would scarf that up. However Skilsaw makes quite the impression! I’m content with what I have, but you make a strong case for upgrading for me! Take care, man!
Hello Daniel! Thank you! You bring up a good point and Ive often wondered why these top tool companies stay away from contractor sized saws. Fair bet there's less profit but it would be awesome to see more competition and choices for the consumer in that segment. Thanks as always for watching!
Will the Skilsaw stand accommodate the Dewalt saw. Do the mounting holes line up by any chance?
I'm pretty new to woodworking and I'm really interested in buying a table saw but all the options make it hard! Your videos help a ton, thank you!
Glad you like the vid! Thanks for watching!
Just bought the Dewalt today. Was wavering between these 2 and the Bosch. After playing with all 3 i decided the stability of the Dewalt stand was the deal maker because I rip a lot of full sheets.
I have a small shop - 10 x 14 - and having the undercarraige on the Skil is a huge bonus. It moves aroung easily and even though I have a step up going into my shop the wheels on the Skil handles it with ease. I can then do the bigger jobs out on my deck.
I like your style, and the video, unlike a lot of your viewers I don't see the comparison, unless I am missing the point, the DeWalt is 10 years old, Skill is of a year ago as I am viewing your video, plenty of time for other manufactures to see what is worth using. Thank you for your time.
Hello Peter. I see your point about the age of the Dewalt but I would argue its still brings a lot to the table. it has some innovate designs which still having been duplicated like the riving knife mechanism. Its due or a refresh at least but its still a popular saw and I think its still competitive. Thanks for watching!
The Dewalt fence moved when you tapped on it and said it’s not going anywhere. You can legitimately see the gear turn to the left of the screen. (8:04) awesome video great amount of knowledge shared!
Man, that is tough! the extra height capacity of the Skil, the blade chnage and stand, outfeed accessory. The dewalt fence, plate and riving knife swap seem much better. Thank you for all of the great info!
I wish I could tell you one is better than the other but they are both great saws. At least you now know there’s no wrong answer. Good luck with the decision Shane!
@@ProjectsForAllReviews I went with the Delta 36-725T2. Your other videos were a definite help! In the end, I just need to move it around my garage, not to an actual jobsite. That being the case, the Delta seemed like the better option that was 1) locally available 2) close enough to that price range. I am looking forward to more of your videos. Keep up the great work!
Hello Mike. Just bought the Dewalt. Was leaning toward the Skillsaw as mentioned in one of my earlier comments because of its 16" wheel stand and worm drive but switched last minute. Love the DeWalt but having a problem with throat plate, havent been able to find anything and wondering if you have same. At 8:30 of your video you show the exact spot with issue. The black inserted area on the right between blade and fence is approximately 1 to 1-1/2 wide you will notice that the yellow part of the throat plate wraps around to the back of the black. The black is quite a bit lower than the yellow which almost gave me an unpleasant experience yesterday. Screw adjustments do nothing for the issue because the black inserted area is captured within the main plate. Its only a problem when you are cutting a piece that is less than the width of the black, the black becomes the support and your piece hits the yellow back edge past the blade. Why the heck is that black even there? Watched this video several times, subbed and enjoy your style. Thank you!
I have been using my Skil for 6 1/2 years. No issues. The worm drive motor is as strong today as it was when I bought it. Wouldn’t trade it for a Dewalt. Don’t get me wrong, I have many Dewalt tool. They make great tools, but when it comes to the table saw, Skil wins hands down for me.
Thank you as I'm purchasing a table saw this week you were great help! I will be going with the 10-inch DeWalt package for $549 at HD
I'm looking to buy a job site table saw. I've had my eye on the rigid table saw. A contractor friend of mine highly suggested the DeWalt table saw. I love these side by side comparison videos. I used to buy only DeWalt power tools many years ago until I found out they were bought out Black & Decker. I was afraid DeWalt would go hill in quality but have recently learned they haven't change a thing and DeWalt is still making high quality power tools. The cost is another concern. DeWalt prices are high. If the skill table saw can match the quality, power and price is cheaper than the DeWalt, I'll be buying the skill.
That Skillsaw motor and worm gear gearbox looks absolutely incredible. They built that motor and worm drive way more beautiful than it needs to be, and it's almost worth buying just because of that motor and gearbox.
They even have their name cast into the side of the solid metal motor housing (not a plastic motor like 99% of brushed motors). I have to say, I am so happy that I live in a timeline where Skillsaw is a premium brand that is still commercial quality.
Something you didn't mention in your Skil table saw review is that you were able to rip a 4x4 beam all the way through without flipping it over. Skil and Skillsaw have found a way to give you an extra 1/2" of cutting depth compared to the Dewalt. That's a huge factor for a person who uses 4" thick lumber. The way they positioned the motors is genius.
I agree with you the motor housing on worm drive saws is a little like art. I also have a couple hand saws sitting around, a vintage who’s model number eludes me and a newer Mag77. Love the look of both.
I try not to harp on aesthetics too much in the reviews. In the end it doesn’t matter much for a tool. Thanks for watching Ritalie!
I bet the dewalt would power out on cutting a 4x4
I’ve owned the Skilsaw for 5 years. My measuring scale is bang on, the fence is smooth to move and I have no wear at all compared to the video. Can’t account for the difference compared to the sample in the video. I own all DeWALT power tools aside from my table saw. I selected the Skilsaw over DeWALT when deciding to purchase because: 1. Ease and speed of setup, collapsing and moving the saw (I’ve never found it less than fully stable); 2 the Worm Drive; 3. It can rip a 4x4 beam all the way through without flipping it over - the DeWALT can’t; 4. The outfeed attachment and handle work support are super convenient - less need to set up other supports. If you have a restricted area for your workshop and need to collapse your saw after each use like I do, you’ll find the stand alone will make it worth buying the Skilsaw. I love all my DeWALT tools, but I feel my Skilsaw was hands down the best purchase for my needs.
I was leaning toward the Dewalt and now you've clouded my judgement. I love that Skilsaw stand but the fact that the Dewalt stores smaller is conflicting me. Sounds like the tape issue can be replaced easily.
Thanks for the great comparison! I appreciate the time and effort that you put into this, and thought the presentation was excellent. I just bought the DeWalt. After looking over the reviews on both Amazon and HD, I thought it would be the way to go. I loved the stand on the Skilsaw and the wheels definitely will handle rougher terrain. The Skilsaw cost less, but when I saw the DeWalt dropped $100 in price, I decided to pull the trigger. If I'm spending my money on a product, I don't want to have to "fix" something to make it function correctly, right out of the gate, so I'm happy with my choice. Only time will tell if I made the right decision.
Thank you! Good luck with that DeWALT. The ten year old saw in the vids is still a beast. Thanks for watching!
Thanks, I'm still on the fence, but this info truly helps a lot!
Glad it was helpful!
Wow, now this is a review channel! Most in depth reviews for woodworking tools I’ve ever seen!
Im a contractor who bought the skil in your video and have this to say, fence locking turnbuckle sucks constantly retighten dust chute clogs very easy saw stand foot pedal broke in first week ow motor has shit the bed. I have owned skil worm drive saws for over 40 years and they have been fantastic. I also had a dewalt 10" years ago that was a great saw , but my go to tablesaw has always been makita with rousseau set up great site saw
Easy. The DeWalt has the superior fence and an accurate and adjustable fence is crucial when it comes to tables saws. The skilsaw is a very nice too.
I own the DWE7491RS (and never used the Skilsaw). I can attest to the rock-solid stability of the Dewalt stand. I think if I was still installing wood floors and needed a lot of mobility with my table saw, where I'd be moving it daily to and from different jobsites, it looks like the Skilsaw's stand might be beneficial. Dewalt's is not very comfortable to move around. However, because I keep my table saw in the same place most of the time, and only occasionally move (mostly when cleaning), I really appreciate the stability provided by the Dewalt, and I don't think I'd like the front-to-back wobble from the Skilsaw. I can further attest to the smooth action of the Dewalt fence. I have adjusted its width and switched from fence-up to fence-down configuration hundreds of times in the three years I have owned it, and it still remains smooth and accurate. All this to say, for a woodworker needing a dedicated table saw and not needing a lot of mobility, I think I'd stick with Dewalt. But if I needed jobsite mobility, I'd at least consider the Skilsaw.
Edit: I also have no need of a portable outfeed support, I use a custom-made workbench for that. But on a jobsite, I could definitely see where that outfeed support for the Skilsaw might be beneficial, depending on what you're using it for. Yet again reinforcing my initial impression that the Skilsaw might be be better for the working man needing mobile use.
Second edit: thanks for your thorough review.
The skills is great with plywood and pine it struggles ripping harder woods like walnut. Made a straight edge jig and use my skil worm drive circular saw, works great.
Well personally I'm goin with the dato stack lol...DeWalt jobsite saw I've used for prolly 25 years framing houses...it's provin ok..this Skil is makein quit the splash these days..everyone seems to like it...I know space is a issue for some, but seriously get at least a contractor saw if you are guna do fine wood working..you will be that much farther ahead by doing so in so many ways...great honest review my man...
Could you put some wax on the fence rails? would that help with smoothness and maybe even wear?? If this is a stupid question I am sorry, I am just new to Table saws/wood working. I did alot in HS, but that has been many years. Since then it has just been refinishing my basement and house repairs. Really LOVE your in depth reviews. Honest about everything. and literally you check everything, even somethings I wouldnt even think to check.
Or what's called a Dry Lubricant?
saw this comparison highlighted on the Tool Show, came over to have a look. Impressed by your thorough unbiased review. I came in with the thought that the DeWalt was the best from my research, but MAN the skillsaw stand and 1 person operation has me questioning myself..... I think however the fence smoothness and accurate ruler (come on you cant fuck that up) gives it *just* to the DeWalt. Subbed!
Welcome! Thanks for letting me know I was on the Tool Show again! Love those guys! These two saws have equal parts good and bad making it super hard to pick between the two. I’m still undecided about which to recommended. I have the Bosch 4100 in the shop for this week. Thanks for watching!
Great job comparing the two saw. I have always been a DeWalt fan, but the Skil looks very interesting. I’m in the market for a new table saw
If you regularly need to go up stairs or setup crossing more rugged terrain, get the Skil. Otherwise, it could be either and you would be satisfied.
I agree! Thanks for watching!
After watching this video and reading through the comments, it's Skilsaw for me. I want to use it to build a large shed and need to make a lot of cuts on 4x8 sheets and 4x4 posts. Having support from the foot of the stand for panels is huge, and so is the ability to buy a rear outfeed stand. Skilsaw can cut a depth of 3 5/8ths while DeWalt can only cut 3 1/8th so it can't do posts without flipping it over. Since I plan on using a lot of rough cut wet lumber from my chainsaw and planer, Skilsaw's worm drive seems like a winner. I would have loved to see an even thicker dado on wet wood to try and see what the DeWalt's limit is
So glad you showed that add-on for the rear outfeed table. Thank you for this amazing video! I hope you do more comparisons like this
I Would like a Dewalt on a SkillSaw stand. But already have a Kobalt with similar "gravity rise" stand that was lots cheaper on clearance.
I like the big wheels on the skilsaw. That's the selling point for me.
Do you plan on driving it? =)
Can you mount the Skilsaw on the Dewalt cart ?
Sweet! You hit 11K subs! Grats!
Great comparison, Mike.
Although I'm pretty much set for power tools your reviews are always worth watching.
Looking forward to the Metabo and Bosch stuff, as well as more from Skil and Flex. I think Bauer and Hercules are worth a look also. I'm not brand loyal, and it's refreshing to see the offerings from companies other than the over-covered DeWalt, Milwaukee, and Ryobi tools everyone else is doing.
Thanks Magius! Im happy with the brands we've covered up to this point but we definitely need to expand into some others. Makita is another one we haven't touched and they have a product line that rivals Milwaukee. There's so much cool stuff out there, I wish I had the time to do more than one video a week. Hopefully that'll change one of these days. Thanks for watching!
i would be interested to see one of these modern saws up against an old craftsman you see on marketplace all the time and see if the new saws are that much better
Sounds like a future video topic Matt!
@@ProjectsForAllReviews awesome can't wait!
Please do it!
We need a video comparing replacing arbor bearings! I am replacing the bearings on my earlier generation Skillsaw SPT70WT and it requires quite a bit of disassembly!
My 10" Kobalt 10152 is 35" tall, the blade to fence length is only 28 7/8. The quick-release undercarriage/portability base is much like Skilsaw's, but the wheels are much smaller, and plastic. The base is very sturdy, however. It has a 15 amp motor, so powers through pretty much everything. When I bought it, it was on sale for $299.00 (at Lowes). The included all-purpose blade works fine for all general construction lumber, but I would buy a better blade for hardwoods. I've both ripped and cross-cut boards and plywood with no problems using that blade. The push stick thingy rests on top of the fence in a spring-loaded channel on top. Very handy. All in all a very good tool for cheap!
Edit: I do NOT like the Dewalt stand-- those legs are spindly, and the back legs are, indeed, a trip hazard. Especially in a shop. No part of my stand is in the way of the table (looks like Dewalt bit it pretty bad with that handle in the way on the left of the table).
I’ve been eyeballing that Kobalt. Ppl keep telling me it’s a good one for the price. We’ll get one for review soon! Thanks for watching
The worm drive and the frame bar that turns into support easily makes the Skilsaw worth the extra few bucks IMHO.
It's got some nice features for sure! Thanks for watching!
Great job Mike! I've seen a couple of your videos and you do a great job of thorough reviewing the products. I'm still on the fence (no pun intended) about which to pick but I am leaning towards the Skilsaw. Thank you for what you do and you have a new subscriber!
I am also leaning towards the Dewalt. I am in the market due to the fact My 4 year old Kolbalt table saw, the motor must had a crack in the mounting because the motor just fell down. Luckly i was not using it at the time.
Just an FYI
Mike I would choose the skill saw based on the mobility factor, like you said it's easy to move around.
Because essentially it looks to me like there one in the same. Both saws virtually have similar features. Like you I would replace the measuring strip and maybe look for a upgraded miter gauge any ideas ❓
Here's a couple ideas I had for the ruler and miter gauge. Affiliate links: Starett adhesive backed ruler: amzn.to/3WlhDfM. Incra V120 miter gauge: amzn.to/3YilZaq. Just a couple ideas but should get you started on your search. Thanks for watching!
@@ProjectsForAllReviews
Very much appreciate your response Mike have a great day 👀 forward to more jam packed information videos 👍
I have the Dewalt, it’s very good I like the look of the Skill and its worm drive motor.👍
Enjoy your videos....looking to purchase. Question please what is the difference between the SPT99-11 and the SPT99-12? Being older I'm seriously leaning toward the skillsaw because of the 16" wheeled stand. Thoughts on the Ridgid R4550.
Best I can tell the only difference between the SPT9911 and 12 is the 11 comes with a Skilsaw blade and the 12 has a Diablo blade included. I haven’t used that Ridgid yet but we’ll get to it eventually. Thanks for watching Dino!
Super job Mike! I have one question, the DWE7491RS use the DWE74911 stand. Do you know if you could use the DW7440RS in place of the DWE74911 stand? I assume you can buy the DWE7491 saw separately? Thank you.
Wow, such a true through and through review. I have both this skilsaw and another smaller Dewalt table saw. I want this Dewalt so bad though! I agree with everything you brought up in the comparisons. After coming from multiple higher end table saws and even my little Dewalt flex volt (daily job site use), when I first used the skilsaw it honestly felt like a junky toy. The smoothness and quality and craftsmanship just isn’t there. I do really really like the stand and how mobile it is… but ripping full sheets by myself is pretty darn sketchy as you can literally end up pushing the saw over due to the wobble. That’s kinda what did it for me. Very annoying to not be able to trust a nice straight cut knowing your saw will move out from under you… to me and probably most ppl, the rip capacity is what tips the scales. Depth of cut is nice but you can always just flip the piece over if need be so not that important for a contractor saw. But being able to rip 32+ inches is a hugeeeeee deal. Also one has to add oil to the worm drive if I’m not mistaken? In any case, the craftsmanship, thought put into the riving knife, rock solidness, and rip capacity make this an easy choice. I would only choose the skil if I needed to traverse rocky terrain up and down a mountain every single day.
You bring up some good points! I still couldn’t tell you which of these saws I would buy if had to make the choice today. I wish I could combine the best attributes of each into one saw. We’ve got tons of job saws out there to review. Maybe the perfect saws out there. Got the Bosch 4100 in the shop now. Thanks for watching!
Absolutely, I look at my toddler sons and can only imagine what kinda of tools and tach they’ll be using when they’re my age @@ProjectsForAllReviews
At about 19min in, the Skilsaw seems to have borrowed A LOT from the Bosch. My old Bosch has the same rear outfeed table, a really similar throat plate, a very similar looking table, etc. of course the Bosch worm drive circ saw is pretty much identical to the Skilsaw Mag77…so, ther’s that.
I really dislike the cutout in the dewalt table. I get why they do it for portability but it just seems like it could be an issue in some circumstances
I love the dewalt have not regret buying it plus i recently brought the freud 8" dado blades for it 😊
I'm in the market for a new table saw. I don't have a shop so I need to have my table saw on wheels. I wanted to see a comparison of these two saws. You nailed my friend. I wish I could snap my fingers and mesh these saws to my likings but the world doesn't work that way. I have gotten 22 years out of my Hitachi table saw and it is time to move on and up. The blade has the dreaded wiggle with no adjustments. I have tweaked it as far as I can go and I`m done. Time to get a new saw. Great job on comparing these saws.
Skip saw has it all, so well made! I have said it before you did an outstanding job!
Skil is certainly attractive, but even though easily replaced, the inaccurate fence scale really worries me. What other QC issues might be hiding? Plus the Dewalt carries a 3 year warranty but the Skil is only a year. But then the Bosch is only a year as well...
I am surprised but made my choice. Getting the Skil.
On a table saw I always look for the best fence…. That said I do like the the motor on the Skill.
I'm sold on the skil , worm gear and better stand did it
I’m kinda waiting to see if Bosch comes out with Reaxx (flesh sensing safety tech) or similar again, plus they have very interesting saws with sliding mitre options in other markets so who knows what’s coming next but I really enjoyed this review and the Dewalt is very compelling (they both are)!
I have the skilsaw table saw. It is quite good relatively speaking, however if I was to do it again I’d buy a sawstop without hesitation. Additionally I will saw the motor on a jobsite saw just isn’t in the same league as a cabinet saw that runs 220volt… I’m hard to please so I’d be going 220 sawstop despite the cost
There’s a lot of great jobsite saws but none compare to the weight, power and size of a large cabinet saw. Just the reduction in noise makes it worth the investment IMO. Thanks for watching!
Friend, make sure you check out the sawstop cause I bought one and I am very discouraged by the fence. It flops about and is nearly impossible to lock down straight. When I complained to the dealer, he says to me, it’s a worksite saw, what do you expect? Color me unimpressed, for $2100. Canadian saw? Just be careful
Mike, I watched every video about job site saws you did and I picked the Dewalt! Great channel!
Awesome! Thanks for watching Brian. Glad the channel helped!!
I was down at Lowes looking at the DeWalt, they did not have the Skil in stock, but I really liked the Metabo (Hitachi, Japan, 1910) HTP Model #C10RJSM, note that the official latest reversion is S, and this is an M. It is normally $599, with $100 off while supplies last. I like the rack and pinion, it was smoother than, or as smooth as the DeWalt, I thought it might be me, so I asked the salesman, who tested both and thought the same thing. I like the rack and pinion on the angle adjustor, slap a magnetic angle finder on it, and you can dial it in easy. I watched all your table saw reviews, yours are the best. This would be a good saw to review, it is better than the Hitachi, and although they look the same, there are many improvements. What do would recommend out of these 3?
Dumb question… how often do you need to change the oil on the Skilsaw worm drive motor?
I am contemplating getting the Dewalt. I love the larger wheel size of the Skil, but since the wheels on the Dewalt are not touching the floor when it's setup for cutting (unlike the Skil), the wheel diameter shouldn't be an issue during cutting, so couldn't I just replace the small wheels for larger ones making it easier to move around when not cutting?
It looks like you might be able to replace the OEM wheels with larger wheels but the wide angle of the back legs could severely limit the size. Based on photos and drawings only - I'm still on the "fence".
I have the Dewalt. First table saw I’ve ever owned. Bought it earlier this year. I absolutely love it. Your previous review really helped me with my decision, and also getting it set up. Keep up the great work.
Glad the video helped! Thanks for watching!
I would like to see a comparison between the Bosch and Skilsaw.
I’m halfway through filming the Bosch now. Very good chance that comparison will happen Matthew. Stay tuned for the Bosch vid soon. Thanks for watching!
I had the Bosch I took it back !! It had a few issues. I have the skills now it is a nice saw
Only thing I didn’t notice you mention is price. I bought the Skilsaw for 2/3 the price of the Dewalt. Interestingly, I don’t have the issue with the tape, although I do have a wear spot on the rail. I’ve never trusted the tapes though and always measure using my tape measure or occasionally a rule.
Hold on. Both dewalt and skil sell for the same price ....550 on sale and 650 regular.
The sawstop sells for 1,700ish and no sales on them ever...(festool parent company ownes sawstop now and they do not ever allow sales)
So, you get it used?
@@arthur962 I’m in Canada. The Dewalt goes for $919 at Home Depot right now I got the Skilsaw for $620
@@regularguy9264 so sawstop was a typo?
@@arthur962 yup! Good catch. Thanks. Now corrected!
I usually put the prices on the thumbnails of my videos and am trying to get away from talking about it unless relevant because lately price have been changing very often. Arthur is correct on the pricing here on these two. Thanks for watching!
Hi Mike, first time seeing your videos and really glad i found them; great info in each one! My company restores old houses so we put a lot of use on these job site saws; just about to retire our current Dewalt 10 inch unit. It's been a champ over the years but definitely had to replace parts from time to time. Does anyone have a sense of the Skilsaw's durability and longevity? Super interested in that unit to become our main saw.
Thank you for sharing. I am a newbie at woodworking and these videos help. Thanks again. Subbed.
Can you tell us , what is the foot print width, meaning what is the smallest door I can easily wheel thru. ? That info is important when taking it to changing job sites.
Did’nt find link for the skill saw giveaway I wonder😣
My Bosch 4100 seems harder to raise the blade after several years of use. I clean it out more regularly now than before, but problem seems to be getting more frequent. Any idea how to correct this?
Mostly depends on what benefits your work load and needs, however I don't own either one of these but I would choose DeWalt because it seems it is more precision built and better thought out in more things. Some of the items on the Skill just seem somewhat cheap. The stand simplicity and efficiency of the Skill is hands better. Very much a toss up though.
Honestly the stand puts me over the line on the Skilsaw, well other than the wormdrive motor. I work by myself so the fact I can get it in and out of the truck has me sold. If the DeWalt had the same stand, I would totally be screwed. Lol
Thanks for your videos -anybody ever tell you that you sound like Ray Ramano?
Can side table extensions be mounted to either of these? In any event, I'd be taking them off of those rickety looking stands and mounting them to a more permanent stand in my shop if I get one.
The Skilsaw uses the stand frame on the left as a support which is a plus. The DeWALT doesn’t have any add on supports as far as I know. Thanks for watching!
Hey Mike,
Don't know if you can get a hold of one or not but the MAKITA - MLT100.......
First time I’ve seen that saw! Looks amazing and it’s 1 month to ship to Chicago on Amazon. At $1650 the channel may have to save its pennies for that one. Thanks for the head up!
@@ProjectsForAllReviews
Awww you mean they won't send you one for free like skilsaw... 😜🤣🤣
@@ProjectsForAllReviews
YAH I just looked at a few RUclips videos you ain't kid'n it definitely 👀amazing. 👍
@@myk1200s a guy can dream…..
Skill seems to have hired the right people in the last couple years their tools are punching way above there weight class and are heading in a good direction. If they keep the innovation in there tools moving forward they will earn a major piece of the market.
I can only assume FLEX isn’t confident enough to have their saw compared? I can’t find comparisons.
I've had the Skilsaw for a couple of years now. Bought it for projects at work during covid, which kept me employed. You never know when your woodworking skills will come in handy. The saw has tremendous power and will cut through almost anything. The saw will take a dado and Skilsaw makes a decent insert. Oddly their zero clearance insert is a piece of plastic crap. Also the cheap plastic handle that raises the blade stripped out almost immediately. I found an after market company that offers a replacement with a metal insert so we'll see. Still, having to use a vice grip to adjust the blade on a six hundred plus saw is more than a little disappointing. The rack and pinion isn't super smooth but it works well enough. I will say that the scale have proved very accurate in my experience. I can set the scale at 3 inches and the cut piece will be dead bang 3 inches. I haven't done any fairly wide rips so that may change. Dust collection is my big issue with this saw. It shoots a lot of sawdust out of the dust port as you would expect, but it also throws a hell of a lot of dust off the table back at the operator. I have to wear full face protection when I use it (I get the cheap ones at Harbor Freight). When I finish cutting, I have sawdust all over the saw, all over me, and all over the ground around it. Even with a really good vac I'm not sure I would ever use this saw in an enclosed space. I don't know it this just my machine; I would be really interested in anyone else's experience. So those are my thoughts, hope they are helpful.
I own the dewalt and use it with dado blades and a vacuum, I maximize the ripping cut up to 34.5 inches, man! I love this tool. Mine doesn't make the squeaking rail noise and stops fast.(im surprised the one in the video is actually stops slow, might be one of the first gen). I do remove the bolts for transportation in a loaded van. It's super easy. I use saw horses and plywood for outfeed and also use as a work station.
That was the first time I ever heard that fence squeak or make any noise! 😂 That DeWALTs about 8 years old or so. Thanks for watching!
Can you please review the Kobalt 10" in 15 amp table saw w/ stand (Model TS10601)?
I have never seen a review video for it, only it's less impressive and more expensive "little brother". It took has a rack and pinion fence setup and was recently on sale (after Black Friday) for just $270. I feel like I got a steal and so far my only concern is the gears for raising/lowering the blade are plastic, not metal.
Interested in your thoughts and thank you for your work and content.
Been watching your Table saw difference videos. I like what I see from that SkilSaw! You say you are giving away that saw on the 16th of Sept. my Bday is the 17th and I sure could use a table saw in my shop! Been shopping for the best saw for the right price in the mean time. Have a great day and keep on showing what you got! Thanks!
Happy belated Birthday Wendy! Thanks for watching!
Thank you so much for the Birthday wishes! Guess what i got for my Bday, a table saw! @@ProjectsForAllReviews
My 22-year old lowest-price Craftsman just died, which I used it the last few years as my secondary beat-around benchtop saw (Kept it outside, rain or shine), and I was thinking of getting a saw for jobsites and also to built a bench around for my shop - I have a Ridgid, but the stand is almost as big as the Skilsaw, and I liked the Craftsman for being so light and movable. Now, I already wrote you that I bought the Skil (The red one, not the Skilsaw) in Greece, on your recommendation, and how impressed I was with it. Would you say the Skilsaw is a lot more powerful than the Skil? I would rather have the portability of the Skil, and pretty much everything seems the same between the two, other than the worm drive and the cart, and given the price difference, would you say that on the power they are kinda similar, or is there a big difference?
The biggest advantage the Skilsaw has over that little Skil is size. Bigger table, stand, full size dados. The Skilsaw is all metal parts also and I’m sure you’re paying for durability and longevity. I still love that Skil for the portability and quality you get for the price but it’s tough to compare the two. Thanks for watching Mak! Let me know which way you go.
Just canceled order for DeWalt after seeing so many negative reviews on their own site. A few mentioned the arbor nut coming loose!
Going to cough up $100 more for the Skilsaw, due to the depth of cut and stand.
Hey Brother. great job on your videos. I love your 1st hand impression. I would expect the DeWalt to be a bit more refined. Although, I'm certain, after your video, SKIL has quickly gotten their collective sh!t together. I'm leaning towards the SKIL, but it remains to be seen whichever saw has the best price at the time of purchase. I do like those big scooter wheels on the SKIL.
I want to see a review on rigid table saw
Hey bro,
First time on your channel, and i gotta say i stayed for thebwhole video without FF it.
Very good conrenr bro thank you.
SAW the video, great work , easy to follow as always.