Im glad she’s embracing her voice’s new range and not forcing the belts. She’s highlighting her lower register and her head voice, the registers that are easier for her, and just letting the belts be what they are without forcing it too much. I love it!! Mariah doesn’t need to prove anything belting wise. Her musicality exceeds far beyond just belting.
As a dedicated lamb, I no longer expect much from her in terms of live vocals. All I need is an album ❤ She needs to lower her songs now or change the set list. Her voice ain't doing it anymore for this type of high key songs. Hope she'll do something about the music arrangement. I'm fine with lipping the hard parts but she can't even properly sing the easy parts now. Don't come for me for saying this coz God knows how much of a lamb I am ✨
@@pietrofattorello In this state, definitely not. But if she's in a booth after a good rest then she can deliver great vocals for sure. Singing is much more tiring when you're in a live setting since there's too much adrenaline and tension. Imagine singing against loud speakers plus cheering crowd. But I still believe that she can slay in the studio.
Her speaking voice is so different now too. It’s so much deeper than what we’re used to and it even has more air to it if that makes sense. So her nodules have gotten worse. To me this performance wasn’t as bad as I thought, nor was it great. But I did love it since it’s Mariah a living legend. She’s the only one from the vocal trinity performing as of right now.
definitely not outstanding vocals, but this compilation shows some decent moments that definitely make me think she can bounce back to where she was in 2019-20
What I like about this "2023 era" (Paris and LNF) is that she can use her chest voice in the middle range, without switching to falsetto, while she can use her falsetto intentionally whenever she wants to (it shows that she's improved since Christmas, when she couldn't access falsetto at all)
Her whistles this era are so strong 😍 she needs to release glottic tension to be able to recover her notes past the B4 because her throat is so closed,
Yessss. She's so compressed while also pushing so hard. Idk if it's the only way to get the notes out with her hardened nodules or what, but even the notes that are good aren't *that* pleasing to the ear bc of this.
Love it, thx for vid. Mariah need more concert. Her voice gain better and batter like vegaw resindency, sweet sweet fantasy, asian tour 2018 even caution world tour
@@shadowcArey the delusional part of the lambily will take the best 10 seconds and say you have to focus on positive things and if u say the 900 seconds were bad then you're a hater
This sculptural, haute couture dress from Schiaparelli looks even better than the version from the runway show. The proportions are better as is the use of gold instead of white. 2:12 I need this amplified, reworked remix. It is fire!
As a lamb I would like to address some of these issues. This is most definitely NOT the worst she’s sounded, am I disappointed she lipped that vision of love line for the first time I think ever in her career if I’m not mistaken, yes . But she has nothing to prove , unfortunately with nodules you have no idea your voice day to day condition. She is 100% capable of still singing but like I said depends on the day and also her confidence which can affect the voice in a tremendous way!!. Love you Mariah, I will always look up to you no matter what shape you’re voice is in .
I'm starting to wonder if she was infected by cov!d, because the major problem here is her breath control/support. If that was the case, then that must be the long covd effect. At this point I only wish her well and recover as soon as possible. Despite all that, her whistle sounds so beautiful. Just like during the Emancipation era. The impromptu before the OSD is so good.
Guys I'm starting to hate the lambs fr fr! Imagine someone who's been struggling with her voice and confidence for so long and her so called fans are the ones who are shitting on her! It's insane
@@SeanMichael1992 and they have to audacity to call us delusional for supporting our fav's because we know she struggles so ofc REAL fans would feel proud of her for doing her best.. being a fan means to stand by your fav on both their highs or lows, and if you had problems with her go meet her yourselves and tell her "I don't like your voice anymore" and then do the annoying over analyzing of every semi tone, or OR sing yourself and TRY to fill a concert venue like she does🙄
@@maryamtara2934 People are allowed to be critical of what is an objectively bad performance. Being a fan doesn’t mean you need to be delusional or blindly supportive.
@@maryamtara2934 If your loved ones sense something is wrong with you, a loved one will of course tell you that, something is probably wrong with you instead of covering it up with lies/good words that aren't true
I don’t think alot of the more critical lambs are coming from a bad place they love her just the same. Mariah is still capable of sounding great when she actually wants to and I think that’s why lambs are tired & upset at this point. They want the best for her and this isn’t it.
Great video, she cleraly has vocal damage and fatigue. Hopefully she is okay and she will take the time for her voice so she can recover in the futur ❤
hate to sound like other lambs but this is was so disappointing i really wish she would get some help. her voice is so disconnected and inaccessible in every register
I was very confused when everyone on her Instagram was talking about how amazing her performance was, she slayed, yes queen, the best ever, etc , how could everyone be so delusional ._."
Exactly! And there will be no improvement in the live vocal performances if these #DelusionalLambs continue to blow smoke & kiss a**! One of the most important responsibilities that friends & families have is holding those we love accountable... one of the worst things you can do is tell those that you care most about what they want to hear.
Imagine calling yourself a fan and not being able to support your fav when she improved over the Christmas show, her tones lows and whistles were great and YOU are the delusional one to think that Mariah would ✨magically✨ be 90s Mariah again... respectfully keep your negativity to yourself, OR send a fan mail to Mariah with your very enticing critique
i don't think it's the worst thing ever but i'm just confused with her breath control... what happened between 2020-2022 i feel like she never struggled this much with it
@@abrahamjavalera5158 heavy drinking doesn't affect your breath support also Mariah also didnt heavily drink (Yalls perception of heavy drinking is off af)
So sick & tired of hearing people blaming her age for her vocal decline. Yes, it's true that age is partly to do with it and of course no one is ever going to sound exactly like they did after 30 years of non-stop singing but the main issue here is the nodules, she's had them since birth, and because her songs require top effort, her vocal chords have literally gone through the wringer, what we are seeing is pure wear and tear in addition to swollen & inflamed nodules that really need to be looked at and treated otherwise they'll just grow bigger and she'll risk further damage. I think she still has all the techniques and skills there, but the nodules are preventing her from accessing her top registers as fluidly as she use to, so some of that agility has been lost. I know she is fearful of surgery but sometimes you have to weigh it against the pros and cons, do you carry on singing with nodules until you lose your voice completely or do you choose treatment and risk losing your whistle register? A good vocal specialist would be sincerly careful to avoid such possibilities. She would be out for a couple of months or a year maybe recovering, and might have to retrain her voice but it could turn out to be the best decision she's ever made.
While i don't think this was her worst, and i don't think this was fully reflective of her current abilities, i do wish she'd just take a hiatus, remove the nodules, and work with a vocal coach. Isn't she curious about what could be if she removed them? Or at least, i wish she'd lower the key of every song waaay more. Regardless, there were some great moments here! And the live parts of VOL were soooo good, idk why she lipped any of it?
Good it’s awful. I mean the absolute pits of her performing career. I just cannot understand how she is not so embarrassed by how bad her voice is that she doesn’t sort it out.
I hope it's just a moment, only a night with she having these issues with her voice. The previous performance in France was better but was few days prior. She might not get the necessary rest her vocal chords need. No doubt that her voice is wonderful as always.
Seeing a lot of fake lambs in the comments and they should know they are the problem within the lambily; the type of lamb that Mariah will never be good enough for. She has nothing to prove to us. We're supposed to support her because if you have nothing nice to say don't say anything at all; what a lot of you are doing is harmful by sharing a toxic mentality within the lambily that Mariah needs to sound like 1995 every time. You think you're doing good for her, but you're no different than the haters that are always tearing her down. Mariah performed amazingly, stop living in the past. Love and support the legendary woman, make her feel validated and enough.
You’re acting like Mariah is some poor child that needs to be uplifted lmao. She is a professional who is being paid millions. Being a fan doesn’t mean you need to blindly love every single thing someone does.
She did all her best she could. Even though these difficulties sounds better than many singers nowadays. But being honest, she needs to heal, get voice therapy and go back with loaded battery's. And the lambs STOP BEING TOXIC ❤❤
People getting disappointed like MC is stopping their paychecks or something. She doesn't owe anyone anything. Let her be and just don't come to her videos if you don't like her anymore.
I think she should now adapt to the changes in her voice. It’s a darker, heavy, thicker and warmer kind of tone. She should also change the arrangement and the key of her songs based on the status and condition of her voice. Not necessary to showcase those belts and higher registers. She has nothing to prove but to accept that her voice is not what it was decades ago.
I KNEW IT THAT 0:38 was a B4. She lowkey ate that one tho she just sounds a lil bit inaudible 😭 also the 0:24 was just a G4 (maybe G#4 it sounded sharp 😭) and 0:33 is on key G4.
I think im the lambiest lamb of the world ( kidding haha ) but seriously I think we should reach her so as to tell she needs to remove those fucking nodules. We need our queen
It’s sad that she struggles in every frase, lambs we need to say the truth to Mariah, she needs more than rest, she need to check his voice with a specialist, saying with love because I ❤ her, so I’m saying the truth.
This little pieces show she can still hit notes but just so oddly inconsistent, her breath control has not been the same either, also she hasn’t been able to transition as smoothly either. Overall not horrible but definitely inconsistent,
Mariah for 15 years was singing in a high pitch constantly so naturally her voice strained. Mariah is a songbird she does not have the power soul voice of someone like Houston. I think she did a great job and she smiles which a lot of artists fail to do so.
0:54 the amount of live whistles just from one sweet day 😭 she was goin off
first time since release she did those whistles 😭
Im glad she’s embracing her voice’s new range and not forcing the belts. She’s highlighting her lower register and her head voice, the registers that are easier for her, and just letting the belts be what they are without forcing it too much. I love it!! Mariah doesn’t need to prove anything belting wise. Her musicality exceeds far beyond just belting.
As a dedicated lamb, I no longer expect much from her in terms of live vocals. All I need is an album ❤
She needs to lower her songs now or change the set list. Her voice ain't doing it anymore for this type of high key songs. Hope she'll do something about the music arrangement. I'm fine with lipping the hard parts but she can't even properly sing the easy parts now.
Don't come for me for saying this coz God knows how much of a lamb I am ✨
I have to agree with you. I love her. But I don’t like seeing her struggle or hand the mic off to the audience
she can't record an album with this vocal state:/
@@pietrofattorello In this state, definitely not. But if she's in a booth after a good rest then she can deliver great vocals for sure.
Singing is much more tiring when you're in a live setting since there's too much adrenaline and tension. Imagine singing against loud speakers plus cheering crowd. But I still believe that she can slay in the studio.
@@pietrofattorelloshe's definitely been recording though, that's probably part of the reason her voice got like this in the first place
0:16 live whistles 😭 it’s so beautiful
Her speaking voice is so different now too. It’s so much deeper than what we’re used to and it even has more air to it if that makes sense. So her nodules have gotten worse. To me this performance wasn’t as bad as I thought, nor was it great. But I did love it since it’s Mariah a living legend. She’s the only one from the vocal trinity performing as of right now.
What is everyone talking about she freaking slayed omg? I’m living for the 100% live vocals
definitely not outstanding vocals, but this compilation shows some decent moments that definitely make me think she can bounce back to where she was in 2019-20
yass
Can u sing
What I like about this "2023 era" (Paris and LNF) is that she can use her chest voice in the middle range, without switching to falsetto, while she can use her falsetto intentionally whenever she wants to (it shows that she's improved since Christmas, when she couldn't access falsetto at all)
thank you for posting this, people only focus on the negatives when she did so many nice moments
Her whistles this era are so strong 😍 she needs to release glottic tension to be able to recover her notes past the B4 because her throat is so closed,
Yessss. She's so compressed while also pushing so hard. Idk if it's the only way to get the notes out with her hardened nodules or what, but even the notes that are good aren't *that* pleasing to the ear bc of this.
Love it, thx for vid. Mariah need more concert. Her voice gain better and batter like vegaw resindency, sweet sweet fantasy, asian tour 2018 even caution world tour
Not even close to that era
damn these Mariah vocal showcase videos keep getting shorter and shorter
because this year she has only sung a maximum of 5-6 songs
It was a 20 minute performance tho
@@shadowcArey the delusional part of the lambily will take the best 10 seconds and say you have to focus on positive things and if u say the 900 seconds were bad then you're a hater
This sculptural, haute couture dress from Schiaparelli looks even better than the version from the runway show. The proportions are better as is the use of gold instead of white. 2:12 I need this amplified, reworked remix. It is fire!
As a lamb I would like to address some of these issues. This is most definitely NOT the worst she’s sounded, am I disappointed she lipped that vision of love line for the first time I think ever in her career if I’m not mistaken, yes . But she has nothing to prove , unfortunately with nodules you have no idea your voice day to day condition. She is 100% capable of still singing but like I said depends on the day and also her confidence which can affect the voice in a tremendous way!!. Love you Mariah, I will always look up to you no matter what shape you’re voice is in .
Living for the lows 😍Omg that D3 is one of her best
I'm starting to wonder if she was infected by cov!d, because the major problem here is her breath control/support. If that was the case, then that must be the long covd effect.
At this point I only wish her well and recover as soon as possible.
Despite all that, her whistle sounds so beautiful. Just like during the Emancipation era. The impromptu before the OSD is so good.
I doubt that she has a covid since she never go out during the pandemic 😭. It may just be her nodules and also nervousness and corset idk.
She needs to seek vocal therapy
The nerves are a major problem
theres moments of potential but i hope she works with a vocal coach sometime soon 🙏
Guys I'm starting to hate the lambs fr fr! Imagine someone who's been struggling with her voice and confidence for so long and her so called fans are the ones who are shitting on her! It's insane
Yup, had to unfollow a few lamb channels. No wonder she’s always talking about who her “REAL” fans are. It’s disgusting actually.
@@SeanMichael1992 and they have to audacity to call us delusional for supporting our fav's because we know she struggles so ofc REAL fans would feel proud of her for doing her best.. being a fan means to stand by your fav on both their highs or lows, and if you had problems with her go meet her yourselves and tell her "I don't like your voice anymore" and then do the annoying over analyzing of every semi tone, or OR sing yourself and TRY to fill a concert venue like she does🙄
@@maryamtara2934 People are allowed to be critical of what is an objectively bad performance. Being a fan doesn’t mean you need to be delusional or blindly supportive.
@@maryamtara2934 If your loved ones sense something is wrong with you, a loved one will of course tell you that, something is probably wrong with you instead of covering it up with lies/good words that aren't true
I don’t think alot of the more critical lambs are coming from a bad place they love her just the same. Mariah is still capable of sounding great when she actually wants to and I think that’s why lambs are tired & upset at this point. They want the best for her and this isn’t it.
Great video, she cleraly has vocal damage and fatigue.
Hopefully she is okay and she will take the time for her voice so she can recover in the futur ❤
0:39 I think she phrased B4’s and a C5 here
Just be honest, This is not Mariah Carey the Vocal goddess we all know. She needs a vocal doctor for sure
hate to sound like other lambs but this is was so disappointing i really wish she would get some help. her voice is so disconnected and inaccessible in every register
I was very confused when everyone on her Instagram was talking about how amazing her performance was, she slayed, yes queen, the best ever, etc , how could everyone be so delusional ._."
I feel you. #delusionallambily This performance was a train wreck. But people have issues with the truth.
Exactly! And there will be no improvement in the live vocal performances if these #DelusionalLambs continue to blow smoke & kiss a**! One of the most important responsibilities that friends & families have is holding those we love accountable... one of the worst things you can do is tell those that you care most about what they want to hear.
Imagine calling yourself a fan and not being able to support your fav when she improved over the Christmas show, her tones lows and whistles were great and YOU are the delusional one to think that Mariah would ✨magically✨ be 90s Mariah again... respectfully keep your negativity to yourself, OR send a fan mail to Mariah with your very enticing critique
It’s more so about being supportive but she has bounced back so this don’t even matter anymore
i don't think it's the worst thing ever but i'm just confused with her breath control... what happened between 2020-2022 i feel like she never struggled this much with it
Agreed! Might she be drinking heavily again🤔
@@abrahamjavalera5158 heavy drinking doesn't affect your breath support also Mariah also didnt heavily drink (Yalls perception of heavy drinking is off af)
@@JordonLee2003 fr
@@JordonLee2003 yeah i agree
@@abrahamjavalera5158 drinking does not affect your voice that dramatically she’s over working herself in the studio.
i lowkey am loving this dark tone of hers nowadays! hopefully her voice can recover soon tho!
If you compare these vocals even too caution world tour where she was performing back to back her voice was much better
Sad to see her lip VOL 😭 ugh as a lamb that really signifies a moment I’d never thought would come. She has confidence tho which I am happy about
she said lemme bless y’all with some rare gems (Till the end of time/Camouflage intro interlude) and (Emotions remix and AYNAF remix)
So sick & tired of hearing people blaming her age for her vocal decline. Yes, it's true that age is partly to do with it and of course no one is ever going to sound exactly like they did after 30 years of non-stop singing but the main issue here is the nodules, she's had them since birth, and because her songs require top effort, her vocal chords have literally gone through the wringer, what we are seeing is pure wear and tear in addition to swollen & inflamed nodules that really need to be looked at and treated otherwise they'll just grow bigger and she'll risk further damage. I think she still has all the techniques and skills there, but the nodules are preventing her from accessing her top registers as fluidly as she use to, so some of that agility has been lost. I know she is fearful of surgery but sometimes you have to weigh it against the pros and cons, do you carry on singing with nodules until you lose your voice completely or do you choose treatment and risk losing your whistle register? A good vocal specialist would be sincerly careful to avoid such possibilities. She would be out for a couple of months or a year maybe recovering, and might have to retrain her voice but it could turn out to be the best decision she's ever made.
it's hard because her whistle notes is like her main thing though.
I love her headvoice in Fantasy!!!🤩
While i don't think this was her worst, and i don't think this was fully reflective of her current abilities, i do wish she'd just take a hiatus, remove the nodules, and work with a vocal coach. Isn't she curious about what could be if she removed them? Or at least, i wish she'd lower the key of every song waaay more. Regardless, there were some great moments here!
And the live parts of VOL were soooo good, idk why she lipped any of it?
I'm sorry but seeing her lip VOL HURTS MEEEE!!! That song was sacred!!
Good it’s awful. I mean the absolute pits of her performing career. I just cannot understand how she is not so embarrassed by how bad her voice is that she doesn’t sort it out.
Agree, as a loyal fan myself for years, this is embarassing indeed. This is not Mariah
y'all are so extra. she's paid her dues
I agree with you because I'm a concerned lamb. Something has to be done either with the voice or the music arrangement.
@@ilovetati91 it doesn't mean she should become Milli Vanilli
I feel like her voice is rested, but damn nodules is going to be bigger and bigger.
She said " just need moment" jjust gave it
She looks like she’s lost weight and seems a lot more confident on stage
I hope it's just a moment, only a night with she having these issues with her voice. The previous performance in France was better but was few days prior. She might not get the necessary rest her vocal chords need. No doubt that her voice is wonderful as always.
Vision of Lipped 😢
ok her lows and runs are so much like 2022, which is decent, but her belts are barely there.
Seeing a lot of fake lambs in the comments and they should know they are the problem within the lambily; the type of lamb that Mariah will never be good enough for. She has nothing to prove to us. We're supposed to support her because if you have nothing nice to say don't say anything at all; what a lot of you are doing is harmful by sharing a toxic mentality within the lambily that Mariah needs to sound like 1995 every time. You think you're doing good for her, but you're no different than the haters that are always tearing her down. Mariah performed amazingly, stop living in the past. Love and support the legendary woman, make her feel validated and enough.
You’re acting like Mariah is some poor child that needs to be uplifted lmao. She is a professional who is being paid millions. Being a fan doesn’t mean you need to blindly love every single thing someone does.
we are not gonna kiss her butt lol
@@xenetaulia okay?? no one said you had to 💀
@@mar-ui2sr seems like it’s a non spoken thing in this fandom 😂
She did all her best she could. Even though these difficulties sounds better than many singers nowadays. But being honest, she needs to heal, get voice therapy and go back with loaded battery's. And the lambs STOP BEING TOXIC ❤❤
she sounds better than nobody at this point
@@SPexHoS2137 for a "lamb" you sure sound like a hater. 🤣
@@mar-ui2sr whom does she sound better than?
People getting disappointed like MC is stopping their paychecks or something. She doesn't owe anyone anything. Let her be and just don't come to her videos if you don't like her anymore.
If you pay for a concert, do you still think she doesn't owe you a decent performance?
I think she should now adapt to the changes in her voice. It’s a darker, heavy, thicker and warmer kind of tone. She should also change the arrangement and the key of her songs based on the status and condition of her voice. Not necessary to showcase those belts and higher registers. She has nothing to prove but to accept that her voice is not what it was decades ago.
Why are people acting like she didn't have a warm, "thick" tone and timbre throughout her debut and emotions?!...
0:24 is a Bb4/B4 0:33 is an G#4 (or a flat A4?) 0:38 are B4's which she ate up
I KNEW IT THAT 0:38 was a B4. She lowkey ate that one tho she just sounds a lil bit inaudible 😭 also the 0:24 was just a G4 (maybe G#4 it sounded sharp 😭) and 0:33 is on key G4.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 sorry i didn't mean to gag you I just felt in my spirit some of them were B4's
I think im the lambiest lamb of the world ( kidding haha ) but seriously I think we should reach her so as to tell she needs to remove those fucking nodules. We need our queen
Definitely not. I'm not gonna tell her to get surgery that could potentially put her voice and/or life on the line.
I never thought I’d see her struggle to hit/sustain a b4. Also what happened to the resonance. There’s like barely any
…where have you been for the past 10 years?
She’s had these problems for like, awhile….
@@mesmereized she sustained tons of b4s 2015-2020…and her resonance those years were crazy
@@mariahmyers9737 she also struggled with a lot of B4’s during those years. She’s been on and off vocally since 2014
People stop exaggerating how bad the performance is. While this performance wasn't something to brag about it wasn't bad either
It’s sad that she struggles in every frase, lambs we need to say the truth to Mariah, she needs more than rest, she need to check his voice with a specialist, saying with love because I ❤ her, so I’m saying the truth.
Rip her chest voice.
This little pieces show she can still hit notes but just so oddly inconsistent, her breath control has not been the same either, also she hasn’t been able to transition as smoothly either.
Overall not horrible but definitely inconsistent,
Mariah for 15 years was singing in a high pitch constantly so naturally her voice strained. Mariah is a songbird she does not have the power soul voice of someone like Houston. I think she did a great job and she smiles which a lot of artists fail to do so.
not only 15 years dahhling. she literally did it her whole career. Which is 33 years. She’s even still doing it rn.
1:51 slaying WHAT- 💀
HV or headvoice
@The Elusive Mimi nah i just thought that was whistle lol or smn like that but now that i think about it, i see it
What a mess tbh
Here we go, the same type of miserable people who pushed Whitney till the dead and the same ones who will come after trolling like Beloved fans.
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 why can't the fans criticize their own idols?
@@tonybs03 thank you
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 please don't act like you didn't hear her lip part of VOL for the first time
the way u hate on every Mariah video is crazy tbh get a life
The eb5 vol is lipped
do you think im not aware?
@@DaydreamCarey1234 Well usually a highlight is supposed to highlight live vocals
@@StevenSenjaya Depends, mostly what i do is all live except if its a new prerecord and it sounded great.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 alright good for you appreciating her
what happen queen?😭
Christina was wayyyy better
All of 1:39 was not live
Only the "I had a vision of love" Eb5 part.
lows and hv tho
yasss
Honestly, Xtina destroyed her that night...
That wasn't a competition and Xtina doesn't have anything to compare with Mariah, Grow up!
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 THANK YOU